`
`
`
`
`
`
`EX1008
`Chart Cross-Comparing the Limitations of Challenged Claims 1 and 19
`of U.S. Patent No. 8,649,971
`
`Challenged Claim 1
`[Claim 1, 1-PRE] A navigation device
`comprising:
`
`[1a] a setting unit configured to set
`waypoints and a destination;
`
`[1b] a route searching unit configured
`to search for a whole route leading to
`the destination via the waypoints set by
`said setting unit;
`
`[1c] a route guidance unit configured to
`carry out route guidance according to
`the whole route which is searched for
`by said route searching unit;
`
`[1d] an output unit configured to output
`a message showing that a vehicle has
`deviated from a route leading to a first
`next waypoint toward which the
`vehicle has been heading when said
`route guidance unit determines that the
`vehicle has deviated from the route to a
`predetermined distance or more and is
`traveling along a route after said first
`next waypoint; and
`
`[1e] an input unit configured to input a
`command indicating whether or not to
`travel via said first next waypoint in
`response to the message outputted by
`said output unit.
`
`Challenged Claim 19
`[Claim 19, 19-PRE] A navigation
`method performed by utilizing a
`navigation apparatus, comprising:
`[19a] setting, by utilizing a setting unit
`of the navigation apparatus, waypoints
`and a destination;
`[19b] searching, by utilizing a route
`searching unit of the navigation
`apparatus, for a whole route leading to
`the destination via the waypoints set by
`said setting step;
`[19c] carrying out, by utilizing a route
`guidance unit of the navigation
`apparatus, route guidance according to
`the whole route which is searched for by
`said route searching step;
`[19d] outputting, by utilizing an output
`unit of the navigation apparatus, a
`message showing that a vehicle has
`deviated from a route leading to a first
`next waypoint toward which the vehicle
`has been heading when, by said route
`guidance step, it is determined that the
`vehicle has deviated from the route to a
`predetermined distance or more and is
`traveling along a route after said first
`next waypoint; and
`[19e] inputting, by utilizing an input
`unit of the navigation apparatus, a
`command indicating whether or not to
`travel via said first next waypoint in
`response to the outputted message.
`
`Page 1 of 1
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1008, Page 1 of 1
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`