`
`David Hilliard Williams
`203-423-9015; dwilliams@LBSGlobe.com; www.E911-LBS.com
`
`
`Expertise
` Location-Based Services (LBS)
` GPS Systems; Network-Based Location
`Determination Systems
` Wireless 911 (E911); NG911 Technology,
`Processes, Operations, and Funding
` Internet of Things (IoT); Edge Computing;
`Real-Time Location Systems (RTLS)
` Non-Cellular/Indoor/Sensor-based Location
`Systems, including: RFID, Wi-Fi/WPS,
`BLE/Bluetooth, Beacon-based RTLS; NFC/
`DSRC; RF Fingerprint systems; Wearable
`systems; Hybrids/Combinations
` Expert Witness Litigation Support,
`Patent/Intellectual Property Services
` GPS/Cellphone Criminal and Civil Matter
`Forensics, using CDRs, RTT, PCMD,
`NELOS, EVDO, Geotab, Paraben,
`CellHawk, and Cellebrite
` Accident/Incident Reconstruction
` Internet of Things (IoT) Ecosystem (Sensors,
`Identification, Verification, Authentication,
`Interfaces, Edge, Network, Cloud, Data
`Network Management, Data Management,
`Analytics, Network Topologies, Integration)
` Location & IoT Data Privacy and Security;
`Location Sharing Policies, Systems/Methods;
`Device/User ID, Verification, Authentication
` Sensor Design; Sensor System Architecture
`and Interface Design; Sensor Arrays
` Wireless Communications Standards, e.g.
`Bluetooth/BLE, Zigbee, Wi-Fi, WPAN, etc.
` Microcontroller Design, Sensor Controls
`Design, IoT Design/Systems Integration
` Channel, Bandwidth Management; Network
`Design; Path Loss Management
` Location Data Aggregation, Anonymizing
` LIDAR/Radar Data Sourcing; Crowdsourcing
` Indoor Positioning & App Ecosystem Design
` Artificial Intelligence (AI), Machine Learning,
`Virtual/Augmented Reality in Mobile Apps
` Short/Longer-range Positioning Technologies
` LBS and IoT Enterprise/Consumer Product &
`Technical Strategy, Design and Buy/Build
` Mobile Devices/Systems Power Management
`
` Internet of Things (IoT), Cellular IoT (LTE-M,
`NB-IoT), LAN/PAN (WiFi, BLE), LPWAN
`(Sigfox, LoRaWAN, Mesh (Zigbee, RFID),
`Consumer/Industrial/Commercial/Govt. IoT
` Home, Office, and Industrial Automation
`System Design and Integration; Control System
`Design, including Remote Management,
`Monitoring, and Control; User Interface Design
`(visible, audible, tactile, virtual, augmented,
`context-sensitive, GUI-based, directional,
`wearables, implants, holographic, others)
` Health, Wearables Monitoring & Tracking
` Safety and Security, Surveillance Systems,
`Home Energy Management Systems
` Smart Card/Wallet/Purse, Contactless
`Payment Systems (e.g. Google Pay); SEs.
` Mobile Resource Management (MRM)
`Tracking and Management; Vehicle, Drone,
`Fleet/ELD/AOBRD, Worker/Driver, and
`Freight/Trailer & Asset Tracking/Mgmt.
` Telematics; ITS, Vehicle/Engine/ECM,
`PGN/SPN Tracking/Monitoring, V2V, V2I,
`V2N, Vehicle Communications Networks and
`Operating and Analytics Ecosystems including
`SAE standards (J1939, CAN, etc.)
` Connected Cars/Autonomous Vehicles (AV)
` Navigation Systems; PNDs; Geofencing; Route
`Optimization; Infotainment Apps/Interfaces
` Location-Based/Dependent Advertising, Search
` Map Data, Digital Mapping, Media/Advertising
`Interfacing/Management, GIS, & IoT IT
` Mobile Social/Business Networking;
` Location/Context-Centric Enterprise Process
`Reengineering, Integration, & Interoperability
` SMART location, Home, Wearables; SMART
`Buildings, Cities; All forms of location-related
`alerts, notifications, alarms; Barcodes, QR Codes
` Context/Presence-Based LBS and IoT; AI-
`based context determination and utilization
` M2M, Smart Grid/Energy Systems
` Engineering, Network, and IT Process Design
`and Organizational Capabilities Assessment
` LBS Big Data and Cloud Computing
` AI, MV, VR/AR Context/Location Integration
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 1
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 1 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Professional Summary
`
`David Hilliard Williams is an internationally-known expert in the wireless/mobile location
`and Internet of Things (IoT) fields and President and Founder of E911-LBS Consulting and
`E911-LBS Forensics Engineering, LLC. He specializes in wireless and IoT-based product and
`technology development and implementation, as well as Intellectual Property (IP)/patent and
`forensics litigation services involving technologies such as Global Positioning Satellite (GPS)
`systems; Network-based location determination technologies such as TDOA, ECID, and
`AFLT; Wireless 911 (E911) and Next Generation 911; Real-Time Location Systems (RTLS)
`including Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) systems, Wi-Fi-based positioning systems
`(WPS), BLE/Beacon-based location systems, Bluetooth, Near Field Communications (NFC),
`and alternative RTLS (Ultrasound, Infrared); Wearable Tags/Sensor tracking systems;
`Zigbee/Mesh networks; Pattern Matching; and various hybrids and combinations, as well as a
`broad array of IoT sensors and other systems, network (wireline and wireless, all generations),
`user interface, and technology enablers for management, monitoring, tracking, and control
`purposes, including in remote control/distributed ecosystems and associated use cases.
`
`Mr. Williams is expert in the full range of business and consumer location-based services
`(LBS) and IoT applications enabled by these technologies, including safety, security, and
`intruder detection/monitoring, energy management, vehicle/fleet tracking/management,
`telematics and vehicle/engine/component/driver monitoring and analytics, local search,
`navigation systems, presence/context-aware apps, mobile resource management, asset and
`freight management, wearable tags/sensors, financial/mobile wallet, mobile hospitality/POS
`systems, supply chain management, family tracking, mobile social and business networking,
`proximity-based entertainment and leisure, gaming, and intelligent transportation systems.
`
`Mr. Williams has extensive expertise in all aspects of LBS and IoT delivery across the mobile
`and IoT ecosystems including enabling sensors, network communications, location
`determination technologies, geofencing design, map data, location data/database management,
`geospatial platform/Geographical Information Systems, GPS and other chipsets, data
`management, control system design, remote management/utilization of such control systems,
`and device, infrastructure and integration provider integration and management. Mr. Williams
`has developed and implemented industry-leading product and technology solutions for
`numerous LBS and IoT applications and markets and provides consulting and research
`services to some of the leading carriers and enterprises in the U.S., Asia, and Europe. His
`client list includes Apple, AT&T, BJ’s Wholesale Club, Draft Kings, Ecobee, Ericsson,
`FedEx, GE, Geotab, Green Mountain Grill, Google, Heil, the Houston Police Department,
`HP/Aruba, the L.A. County District Attorney’s Office (both prosecution and public defender),
`Lyft, Macropoint, Motorola, Nextel, NAVTEQ, Overhead Door, Peschke, Prova, Qualcomm,
`Samsung, Snap, Sprint, Target, Toyota, Twilio, Verizon Wireless, VIVINT, Volkswagen,
`Zillow, and ZIM.
`
`Mr. Williams has successfully served as an expert for plaintiffs, prosecutors and defendants in
`patent, ITC, and criminal litigation (including assisting State Public Defender entities
`including California, Florida, Maryland, New York, and Tennessee), as well as both sides of
`civil trade secrets, product liability, fraud, and other litigation. He has been deposed 35 times
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 2
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 2 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`and has testified 11 times, including successfully in The Eastern District Court of Texas
`(winning both infringement and invalidity matters), and in winning in ITC Court. In total he
`has provided expertise in matters involving over 225 patents and over 50 criminal and
`civil matters. His credentials in wireless/mobile/IT technologies and associated applications,
`infrastructure, systems, and enablers are established to the 1980s. Mr. Williams has testified
`in a variety of district and state courts, ITC, and international (Canada, Trinidad & Tobago).
`
`Mr. Williams is expert in smart location technology issues in the Internet of Things (IoT),
`telematics, and connected/driverless car fields, particularly in their utilization of sensor,
`location and context information through the practical envisioning and design of:
`consumer/enterprise use matters and associated application and user interface design; sensor
`design and deployment strategies; process (re)engineering; IT integration; data aggregation,
`segmentation, analysis, and management; scalability; and security and privacy issues,
`requirements, collaboration structures, and ongoing management. He is expert on Big Data,
`data mining/analytics, and emerging Artificial Intelligence issues associated with location,
`context and IoT data, as well as its potential usage in the criminal forensics field.
`
`
`With nearly forty (40) years in location, networking/communications, control, and
`information technology solutions design, selection, implementation and ongoing management,
`Mr. Williams has extensive experience in the activities and issues needed to get applications
`to market, including planning and design at the application, system, interface/integration,
`network, IT, operational and customer facing levels. He has been published and quoted by
`leading magazines and newspapers about mobile services, including The New York Times,
`CBS News.com, The Columbus (Ohio) Dispatch, The Boston Globe, Computerworld,
`Directions Mag, Mission Critical Communications, Popular Mechanics, and RFID Journal.
`Mr. Williams has authored five books on wireless location, including The Definitive Guide to
`IoT Sensors (In Development), The Definitive Guide to GPS, RFID, Wi-Fi, and Other
`Wireless Location-Based Services (two versions, third in development), The Definitive Guide
`to Wireless E911, and (co-authored) The Definitive Guide to Mobile Positioning and Location
`Management. Mr. Williams has authored dozens of research reports, and tracks and analyzes
`leading companies in the LBS, IoT, and public safety industries particularly with respect to
`their product and technology strategies, competitive capabilities and implementation issues.
`He is expert on all public policy and technology issues related to emergency services/public
`safety, location data privacy and security, and LBS and IoT privacy protection policies,
`systems, and support infrastructure. He opines on location privacy issues in various forums.
`He is the sole or named inventor on nine (9) patents involving mobile location and context,
`sensors, IoT, and various other technologies and associated methods, with 10 pending.
`
`Employment History
`
`E911-LBS Consulting; E911-LBS Forensics Engineering (2015+)
`From:
`2002
`To:
`Present
`
`
`Position: President and Founder
`
`
`Provides services across the entire wireless value chain, particularly
`with respect to technology and business strategic planning and product
`design, development, implementation, and ongoing management and
`operations, plus specialized services such IP/Patent litigation associated
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 3
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 3 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`with Location Based Services and applications, GPS, E911, IoT,
`RTLS, RFID, Wi-Fi, NFC, BLE/Bluetooth, beacons, & other location
`technologies and associated ecosystems. Projects include:
`
`
`• Provided expert witness, technical consulting, and research
`analysis services with respect to location-based services-related
`intellectual property/patent protection, licensing, and litigation
`(details in separate litigation support section).
`
`• Provide forensics expertise in examination of mobile location-
`related events and associated data for civil and criminal matters
`(both prosecutor/plaintiff and defense entities).
`
`
`
`
`
`• Developed, implemented, managed, and marketed a portfolio of
`LBS applications and broader offers for leading North
`American wireless carrier. Responsible for all dimensions of
`product lifecycle and associated budgets. Work included the
`development and launch of several LBS applications including
`mobile social networking, family tracking, local search, 411 w/
`location, and mobile worker, fleet, and asset management.
`Location technologies utilized include GPS, Wi-Fi positioning,
`RFID, Bluetooth, Cell ID (CID), ECID, and TDOA. Worked
`extensively with network engineering to troubleshoot/refine
`new location-determination infrastructure to address/improve
`location accuracy, privacy and security issues.
`
`• Conducted geofencing accuracy compliance analysis for ride-
`sharing company auditing their driver airport compliance
`record. Involved extensive use of JSON/GeoJSON records.
`
`• Conducted comprehensive technical and intellectual property
`analysis of Real-Time Location Systems (e.g. RFID, Wi-Fi
`Positioning, Bluetooth, Infrared/Ultrasound, Others) market for
`European client looking to assert location-related patents.
`
`• Provided technical guidance for mobile payments/wallet startup
`utilizing RFID, NFC and other technologies as key location
`enablers. Identified key issues and redeveloped successful
`patent application after initial USPTO rejection.
`
`• Conducted technical and intellectual property analysis for Fleet
`Management/Telematics operator and service provider
`assessing potential infringement candidates.
`
`• Conducted market research and developed market research on
`Telematics industry, both overall as well as tailored for specific
`auto manufacturers.
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 4
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 4 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`
`• Conducted analysis of location aggregation market for client
`interested in acquisition in that industry space.
`
`• Ghost-wrote comprehensive study on Traffic data collection,
`processing, and reporting technologies, markets, and associated
`companies on behalf of ABI Research.
`
`• Provided E911 consulting expertise in support of new spectrum
`regulatory approval and technical implementation issues for
`startup carrier.
`
`• Managed the design, collection, and analysis of E911
`infrastructure deployment of western region of major wireless
`carrier. Data collected focused on technical issues associated
`with TDOA (Time Difference of Arrival) technology
`implementation, and collection and reporting of location
`accuracy data for FCC reporting purposes.
`
`• Developed the site map and primary content for the NAVTEQ
`(now HERE) Network for Developers (N4D) LBS web
`ecosystem – http://developer.navteq.com. Responsible for
`designing and managing the site map and overall content,
`identifying key contributors and materials, and utilizing a
`variety of fragmented information to develop broad and deep
`technical, digital media and business content to assist various
`expertise levels of application developers and business
`management to become intimately familiar with map data, GIS
`platforms, and LBS applications and underlying technologies
`and to provide the information and guidance to successfully
`develop and launch their LBS applications.
`
`• Managed the development of the Nextel (now Sprint/T-Mobile)
`Location-Based Services strategy. Efforts included market and
`technical analysis of likely LBS offerings and integrating those
`findings with Nextel’s broader wireless voice and data
`strategies. Work included prioritizing applications based on
`focus group findings, business matter attractiveness, ease of
`implementation, impact on network infrastructure, and
`synchronization and integration with GPS terminal and E911
`mandate rollout plans. Managed network engineering and
`consulting team to design network modifications to best support
`the additional demands of LBS applications and underlying
`bandwidth-consuming digital media content. Product strategy
`including researching and incorporating context-aware/presence
`concepts into product/device and network engineering plans.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 5
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 5 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`• Developed navigation platform strategy for major international
`auto manufacturer. Assessed direction and technology
`requirements of in-car and portable navigation device (PND)
`technologies; developed strategy for in-car navigation platform.
`
`• Developed numerous LBS company research reports using
`proprietary multi-point “report card” addressing numerous
`business and technology strategy dimensions and issues.
`
`• Authored multiple books on wireless location, including The
`Definitive Guide to IoT Sensors and IoT Use Cases (In
`Development), The Definitive Guide to GPS, RFID, Wi-Fi, and
`Other Wireless Location-Based Services (2005/2009 versions,
`new version in development), The Definitive Guide to Wireless
`E911, and (co-authored) The Definitive Guide to Mobile
`Positioning and Location Management.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`• Advised numerous small companies and startups such as
`i360Hygiene, LOCAID, Finder Technologies, Orion GPS, and
`XYVerify on LBS-related issues to enhance value propositions
`on business, product and technology dimensions to enhance
`attractiveness to potential investors/acquisition candidates.
`
`
`AT&T Mobility
`2009
`
`2010
`Position: Senior Product Manager – Enterprise LBS
`
`Led the development, implementation, and marketing of numerous
`enterprise location-based services across all sales, marketing and
`operational channels. Work included responsibility for all dimensions
`of product lifecycle and associated budgets. Products managed
`included telematics, fleet/vehicle management, asset/freight
`management, and mobile resource management GPS/LBS apps on a
`variety of platforms such as Telenav. Played key role in design of
`company-wide location services product and implementation roadmap.
`
`AT&T Mobility
`2007
`
`2009
`Position: Consumer LBS Product Realization Manager (Consultant)
`
`Responsible for the design, development, implementation, and ongoing
`lifecycle management of several high-profile Consumer LBS
`applications and associated operational support. Overall application
`design and implementation responsibilities included AT&T
`FamilyMap, Loopt Mobile Social Networking, 411 with location,
`Slifter Local Search, and CaddyHawk Game systems. Work included
`design, troubleshooting, and implementation of AT&T location-related
`network, application, user interface, digital media and content delivery,
`and privacy infrastructure and associated issues such as accuracy and
`
`From:
`To:
`
`
`
`From:
`To:
`
`
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 6
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 6 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`
`From:
`To:
`
`
`
`
`
`From:
`To:
`
`
`
`From:
`To:
`
`
`
`From:
`To:
`
`
`
`privacy (efforts resulted in patent co-invention).
`
`
`
`Accenture
`1993
`
`2002
`Position: Associate Partner - Communications & High-Technology Strategy;
`Information & Technology Strategy practices
`Responsible for development of wireless location practice. Led
`development of business, technology, and product strategies for
`numerous communications and technology-centric companies looking
`to enter new markets. Specialized in new product design, development,
`and implementation, as well as network infrastructure design need to
`support next generation, high bandwidth-consuming digital media
`content and associated infrastructure. Efforts included assisting AT&T
`(re)enter local service, (then) Bell Atlantic launch long distance
`services, (then) GTE design and implement Intelligent Network and
`High Value Network services, Nextel (later part of Sprint, and now T-
`Mobile) develop their location-based services product strategy and
`enabling network and IT architectures, and Omnipoint (later part of T-
`Mobile) network integration strategy, as well as leading the design and
`implementation of voice and data communications networks and
`associated data management capabilities in numerous industries
`including communications, computer, transportation, hospitality/retail,
`energy, agriculture, and banking/financial services. Worked with
`utilities such as Ameren, Georgia Power, and Duke Energy to identify
`strategic opportunities utilizing technology and communications in
`utility-associated infrastructure and other capabilities.
`
`
`Booz Allen & Hamilton
`1991
`
`1993
`Position: Senior Associate – Information Technology Practice
`
`Provided and led consulting services for communications industry
`and other Information Technology-intensive companies in
`developing technology strategies for addressing new marketing
`opportunities and internal operational issues.
`
`Deloitte Consulting (Originally Touche Ross)
`1987
`
`1991
`Position: Senior Manager
`Provided consulting services for technology-intensive companies in
`developing business and product strategies for addressing new
`marketing opportunities and internal operational issues.
`
`
`Hughes Aircraft Company
`1983
`
`1985
`Position: Electrical Engineer – Radar Development
`
`Microcomputer and digital system design engineer on the F-15
`fighter radar system as part of analog to digital platform conversion
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 7
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 7 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`and associated tracking and control systems design. System involved
`designing multi-microprocessor-based system to interface to/with
`wide array of on-board, ground control, and other in-flight
`communications/control sensors/sensor arrays and systems.
`
`Litigation Support Experience
`
`Baker Botts
`Date:
`2023
`
`Matter:
`Tile
`
`Project
`Providing expert consulting, support, analysis, and declarations for
`
`
`IPR matter for patent involving systems and methods for finding
`
`
`lost or stolen property. Deposition.
`
`
`
`Buchanan
`Date:
`2023
`
`Matter:
`
`Project:
`Providing expert consulting, support, and declarations for 6
`
`
`patents/4 groups involving indoor/outdoor location, signal
`
`
`strengths, rf fingerprinting and grid point analysis; use of network
`
`
`calibration data in location determination; and incorporating path
`
`
`loss with calibration, fingerprinting, and location determination/
`
`
`
`Jenner & Block LLP
`Date:
`2023
`
`Matter:
`Uber
`
`Project:
`Providing expert consulting, support, and declarations for matter
`
`
`involving Taxi/ride sharing systems and methods.
`
`
`
`Vorys
`Date:
`2022-2023
`
`Matter:
`BJ’s Wholesale Club
`
`Project:
`Providing expert consulting, support, and declarations for matters
`
`
`involving location-related in-store ordering, fulfillment, and
`
`
`customer service aspects of e-commerce and m-commerce services.
`
`
`Deposition.
`
`
`
`Wilson Sonsini
`Date:
`2023
`
`Matter:
`Rocateq
`
`Project
`Provided expert consulting, support, and declaration work
`
`
`involving connected shopping cart technology and applications IP.
`
`
`
`Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner, LLP
`Date:
`2023
`
`Matter:
`
`Project:
`Providing expert consulting, support, and declarations for IPR
`
`
`matters directions, video, wearables/spatial orientation detection.
`
`
`
`Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton LLP
`Date:
`2022-2023
`
`Matter:
`Apple
`
`Project:
`Provide expert consulting, support, and reports for IPRs, invalidity
`
`
`and non-infringement proceedings involving eight (8) patents
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 8
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 8 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`2022-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`2022-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`2022-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2022-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2021-2022
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`2021-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`2021-2022
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2022
`
`involving sharing of location information between multiple devices
`for a variety of use cases. Six IPRs instituted and in process.
`Depositions (2 covering 6 IPRs).
`
`Venable LLP
`Verizon Wireless dba Cellco Partnership
`Provide expert consulting, support, and declaration for IPR matters
`involving georeferencing and specialty messaging techniques.
`
`Hall Griffin
`Ben’s Asphalt
`Provided technical expertise in assessing technical aspects of
`telematics breach-of-contract lawsuit. Successfully settled.
`
`Wolf, Greenfield & Sacks, P.C.
`Snap
`Providing expert consulting, support, and report for IPR matter
`involving social-based location, mapping, matching, and display
`technologies. Deposition.
`
`Dreifuss Bonacci & Parker
`Pacific Controls Inc.
`Providing expert consulting, report, and testimony in regards to
`contractual dispute between Telematics Service Provider and
`equipment manufacturer. Deposition and Testimony (SDNY).
`
`Greenberg Trauig
`HP Enterprises, Aruba
`Providing expert consulting, report, and testimony in support of
`non-infringement and invalidity analysis in EDTX matter involving
`beacons/beaconing technologies, methods, and associated systems.
`Depositions (2).
`
`Keker, Van Nest & Peters LLP
`Google, Ecobee, and VIVINT (v. Ecofactor) (WDTX)
`Provided/ing expert consulting, report, and testimony in support of
`invalidity analysis involving HVAC remote monitoring and control
`and associated sensors, systems, and communications capabilities.
`Deposition and Testimony; VIVINT trial pending.
`
`Baker Botts
`Lyft (multiple matters)
`Providing expert consulting, support, and report for matters
`involving location-related applications technologies including GPS,
`Bluetooth, Wi-Fi positioning, RFID, and road sensors/readers.
`
`Winston & Strawn LLP
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 9
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 9 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2020-2021
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`
`2021
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2021
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2020-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`2020-2021
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`
`2020-2022
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2020
`
`ZIM Integrated Shipping
`Provided expert consulting in EDTX invalidity and non-
`infringement case involving method and apparatus for shipping
`information patents.
`
`Lowe Graham Jones
`Green Mountain Grill (IoT Connected Grill) (ITC Court)
`Provided expert consulting, report, and testimony in ITC case
`involving Internet of Things (IoT), remote monitoring and control,
`cloud services, and various short-range communications
`technologies. Involves non-infringement, DI, Invalidity, and
`Inventorship. Deposition and Testimony.
`
`Munger, Tolles & Olson LLP
`Provided expert consulting and support for EDTX matter involving
`invalidity/non-infringement of smart cards and payment systems
`and associated capabilities such as Secure Elements.
`
`Jackson Walker L.L.P.
`Prova
`Provide expert consulting, support, and report for IPR involving
`buyer verification/tracking and inventory management/tracking
`utilizing RFID technology.
`
`Latham & Watkins LLP
`Overhead Door (OHD-Garage Door Manufacturer) (ITC Court)
`Provided expert consulting, report, and testimony in ITC case
`involving Internet of Things (IoT), remote monitoring and control,
`and various short-range communications technologies. Deposition
`and Testimony in ITC court. Support in Customs and Enforcement.
`
`Ropes & Gray LLP
`Target
`Providing expert consulting, support, and report for IPRs for
`several patents involving short-range communications technologies
`and associated identification and location determination methods
`and techniques including Bluetooth, RFID, and Wi-Fi. Depositions
`seven (7) involving nine (9) patents.
`
`Baker Botts
`Draft Kings
`Providing expert consulting, support, and report for IPRs for
`several patents involving validating gaming customers location in
`appropriate online gaming jurisdictions/geofencing. Depositions (2)
`
`Baker Botts
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 10
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 10 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`2020-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2019-2023
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`2018-2020
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`2019-2020
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`2019-2020
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`2016-2021
`Matters:
`Projects:
`
`
`
`
`2013,
`2019/2020
`Projects:
`
`Lyft
`Provided expert consulting, support, and report for IPRs involving
`Intelligent Transportation systems, geofences, and location
`technologies including GPS, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi positioning, RFID,
`and road sensors/readers. Deposition.
`
`Finnegan & Henderson
`Google (3)
`Providing expert consulting, support, and report for IPRs involving
`user experience sharing, software registration, and device/user
`tracking involving a variety of location technologies.
`
`Lynch Thompson LLP
`Heil
`Providing technical/engineering expertise in trade secrets matter
`involving Internet of Things, RFID, Telematics, Vehicle Sensors, &
`Big Data for waste vehicle manufacturer. Deposition.
`
`Lawgivers (Trinidad and Tobago)
`A&V Oil and Gas
`Provided expert support, report, and testimony in arbitration matter
`involving government of T&T. Focused on (in)accuracies of GPS-
`based vehicle tracking system relative to a variety of key events.
`Testimony at trial.
`
`Perkins Coie
`Zillow
`Provided expert support, report, and deposition for non-
`Infringement matter for major real estate services firm and
`associated subsidiaries involving a wide array of location
`determination technologies on smartphones.
`
`Baker Botts
`Lyft
`Provided expert support, report, and deposition is support of Claim
`Construction brief associated with non-infringement matter.
`
`Sterne Kessler Goldstein Fox
`Google (Multiple matters); Google (Nest, Multiple matters)
`Providing expert support, reports, and deposition for several IPRs
`of location/context-related patents on behalf of leading Internet
`services company utilizing a wide variety of communications and
`location technologies.
`
`XYVerify (3)
`Patent Re-Submission and Approval; Patent Application Creation
`(Re)wrote patent applications for LBS/financial verification system
`
`Curriculum Vitae of David Hilliard Williams
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Page 11
`
`Hyundai Exhibit 1004, Page 11 of 17
`Hyundai Motor Company v. Mel Navip LLC
`IPR2024-00173
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`2013-2023
`Matters:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`2019
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`2017-2018
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`
`
`
`2017-2018
`Matter:
`Project:
`
`using multiple location determination methods including RFID,
`Bluetooth, WPS, and GPS. Efforts enabled patents to be approved
`after initial rejection by USPTO.
`
`Civil and Criminal Forensics
`Various
`Provided/Providing cellphone, vehicle/telematics, specialty device,
`and computer-based location forensics expertise in over 50 criminal
`and civil matters involving numerous location determination
`technologies and associated applications and systems. Criminal
`matters include homicide, attempted murder, assault (multiple
`types), arson (building and land), armed robbery, breaking and
`entering, assault (various types), and property crime. Civil matters
`include trade secrets, product liability, accident liability, fraud,
`contract disputes, and employment matters.
`
`Applications/Platforms for criminal and civil forensics analysis
`include cellular records, 911 records, Facebook/Instagram/
`Messenger/social media apps, Google/search, Google tracking apps
`(e.g. Timeline, others), vehicle tracking systems, specialty GPS
`(e.g. GPS ankle bracelets, specialty devices) surveillance and safety
`systems, smart home systems, aviation, vehicle infotainment