throbber
Page 1 of 32
`
`Meeeee ole aem gee el
`der Stoel involved plenty of thought, some
`roadblocks, and a chance encounter
`
`1 Van der Stoel
`ter and Miriam
`eee RET)
`Crear Pf ete
`
`LY
`
`$4.00 PM40064683
`
`NUHN15000022732
`NUHN15000022732
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 1 of 32
`
`

`

`Page 2 of 32
`
`For more information, please contact your local authorized DeLaval dealeror visit delaval.ca
`
`Cal Kwantes, DeLaval Sales
`Support Western Canada
`250-503-6002
`
`J&D Farmers Dairy Service Ltd.
`Enderby, BC
`1-888-811-0231
`
`Agrai-Dairy Mart
`Lethbridge, AB
`403-327-1414
`
`Island Dairy Services Ltd.
`Duncan, BC
`250-748-2188
`
`Agrai-Dairy Mart
`Lacombe, AB
`403-786-9999
`
`Agrai-Dairy Mart
`Nisku, AB
`780-955-3737
`
`Tristar Dairy Center Ltd.
`Grunthal, MB
`204-434-6801
`
`DeLaval Dairy Service
`Saskatoon, SK
`306-955-5474
`
`J&D Farmers Dairy Service Ltd.
`Abbotsford, BC
`604-853-2372
`
`Follow
`ate
`
`facebook.com/
`Sratenner
`
`pee ae
`pores
`VW a@DelavalCanada
`
`Bina
`uae
`BiomeWean)
`
`£: DeLaval
`
`NUHN15000022733
`NUHN15000022733
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 2 of 32
`
`

`

`FARMER
`
`published by:
`
`WESTERN CANADA'S
`DAIRY BUSINESS MAGAZINE
`1-877-358-7773
`519-473-0010 © fax 519-473-2256
`ontariofarmer.editorial@sunmedia.ca
`
`x540221
`
`PUBLISHER/
`EDITOR-IN-CHIEF, Paul Mahon
`ADVERTISING INFORMATION,
`1-877-358-7773
`NATIONAL SALES DIRECTOR,
`Kevin Lord
`ph 519-656-9521
`fax 519-656-9522
`DISTRICT SALES CONSULTANT,
`Melanie Shipway 780-986-2271 x700241
`fax 780-986-6397
`
`SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION,
`Circulation
`1-877-358-7773
`MAILING ADDRESS,
`Ontario Farmer, Box 7400
`London, ON N5Y 4X3
`COURIER ADDRESS,
`1147 Gainsborough Rd.,
`London, ON N6H 5L5
`
`Reproduction,in whole orin part, of the
`editorial or advertising contentis forbidden
`without the written consentof the publisher.
`PUBLICATIONS MAIL AGREEMENT NO.
`40064683
`RETURN UNDELIVERABLE CANADIAN
`ADDRESSES TO: CIRCULATION DEPT.
`PO BOX 7400 LONDON ON NSY 4x3.
`ISSN 1192-800X
`
`[P] POSTMEDIA
`
`The land defines the system
`Labour andsoil factors affect how this Australian operation is set up
`
`Show Class
`He's only 26, but more than a few thousand cowsand heifers
`have already passed beneath Kyle Henderson's clippers
`
`Becoming information managers
`
`Do early lactation cows need B-vitamins supplements?
`
`A long road
`The career path for Pieter and Miriam Van der Stoel involved plenty
`of thought, some roadblocks, and a chance encounter
`
`John Deere’s new 8000self-
`propelled forage harvester
`Deere adds three new 8000seriesself-propelled forage harvesters
`
`Strategies for reducing high-quality forages
`
`Self-propelled
`Manure crawler concept has saved lagoons around the world
`
`Concerns about electromagnetics
`A Saskatchewan couple with electromagnetic field
`sensitivity blames “dirty electricity”
`
`Space and time for transition cows
`
`OCTOBER 2015 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER 3
`
`CONTRIBUTING WRITERS
`
`SUZANNE
`ATKINSON
`
`CUMMING
`
`i
`
`SHARON
`GROSE
`
`ef
`BRIAN
`VAN DOORMAAL
`
`&,
`
`fi,
`ROBERT
`WESTRA
`
`!
`
`PETER
`vITTI
`
`NUHN15000022734
`NUHN15000022734
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 3 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 3 of 32
`
`

`

`
`
`[ INTERNATIONAL
`The land defines
`the system
`
`Labour and soil factors affect
`how this Australian operation is
`set up BY IAN CUMMING
`
`GLENORE GROVE, QUEENSLAND,
`AUSTRALIA - There are only about 20
`farmsin Australia with milking robots,
`from several companies, but dairyman
`Steven Duncanis happy with the three
`Lely units he installed two and a half
`years ago.
`With the booming mining sectorelse-
`where in the country, and youngtal-
`ented people making over $200,000 a
`year,“I couldn't find good labour,” to
`help milk his 180 cows, hesaid.
`He did note that with commodity
`prices crashing, labourwill probably
`come available as long as that situation
`lasts.
`While the robots themselves cost the
`
`same as what a Canadian producer
`would pay, Duncan has them covered
`not by an expensivebarn specially
`designedfor cowflow, but a small, simple
`tin roof with no sides anywhere.
`With the dealer many miles away,a
`local mechanically inclined person has
`become educated on maintenance, but
`it also means they have to carry a higher
`than normal inventory ofparts,said
`Duncan.
`
`Thusfar things have hummed along
`trouble-free with the robots averaging
`2,000 to 2,200kilos per robotper day,
`he said.
`
`Sitting on someof the mostfertile land
`in the country,in this market gardening
`area,the blackrichalluvial soil goes
`4 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER OCTOBER 2015
`
`down for 60 feet and “will turn to mudif
`
`it’s irrigated orit rains,” said Duncan.
`That doesn't makeit ideal for pasturing.
`Twoother roofs have been con-
`
`structedin the past year, giving this
`dairy farm a different appearance from
`the usual one roof overa parlourin this
`country.
`~ Oneroofis over the feed manger,
`where a TMR is fed, and the otheris over
`a compost bedding pack which wasonly
`built last year, said Duncan.
`All areas are connected directly with
`the robots.
`“The bankers were easier to educate
`
`on investing in robots, than the concept
`of cattle housing,” said Duncan. The sim-
`ple housing,with the roofed compost
`pack and covered manger, “made it a
`winner,” as to making the whole system
`work.
`The 160 acres he owns, with the
`majority ofit irrigated, grows enough
`forage for his cows and young stock, but
`he buysin the grain and protein,said
`Duncan.His total feed costs in the TMR,
`whichis fed twice per day, are $7.80 per
`cow perday,he said.
`He averages about36 litres per cow in
`the winter and 32 litres per cow in the
`hot summer. His lowerfat price at just
`under 60 cents perlitre to Parmalat,“is
`break even in the current environment,”
`said Duncan.
`
`Both winter and summerforageis
`
`
`
`Steven Duncan: “The bankers were
`
`easier to educate on investing in robots,
`than the conceptofcattle housing.”
`
`grown, mainly a rye grass/alfalfa mixture
`for the winter and sod seeded sorghum
`for the summer. “We get aboutsix cuts
`per year on the rye and four cuts on the
`sorghum forage,” he said.
`Averaging about one tonneofdry
`matter per acre per cut, the 10 harvests
`per year, “means youtravel around that
`field a lot,” he said. The haylage is
`packed into bunks.
`Hefertilizes about 20 poundsof urea
`per acre after every cut.
`Buying the waterforirrigating “is dirt
`cheap"at $9 per megalitre, he said. @
`
`
`NUHN15000022735
`NUHN15000022735
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 4 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 4 of 32
`
`

`

`
`
` Zoetis” isa registered trademark of Zoetis, used underlicenseby Zoetis Canadainc
`
`CALF JADP O1A.0315 E
`
`NUHN15000022736
`NUHN15000022736
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 5 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 5 of 32
`
`

`

`
`
`[ PROFILE
`
`Show Class
`
`He’s only 26, but more than a few thousand cows and heifers have
`already passed beneath Kyle Henderson’s clippers sysuzanne Atkinson
`
`for the show-ring,classification and the sales ring,
`
`IT’S BEEN ALONG HAUL to the top.
`And even nowthat he’s arrived, few
`people actually know Kyle Henderson.
`“It's taken me years to get here,” the
`26-year-old admits. “Well, four or five.”
`“| busted myballs.”
`He's amongthe bestin the world, say
`those who have watched this Millbrook
`
`man workhis way to the top.
`Thefitter who has piloted threediffer-
`ent cows to World Dairy Expo champi-
`onships, Henderson chuckles that
`thoughhis workis well-known; he him-
`self isn't.
`
`“The people who know me,” he says,
`“know me. The rest?” He just shrugs.
`WhenOntario Dairy Farmer caught up
`with Hendersonin Lindsay, the hard
`work was done. His string of 10 show
`animals wasrelaxing,filling with beet
`pulp and water on a deep straw-bedded
`pack in their digs headinginto the
`Ontario Summer Show. Numerous
`
`youngerfitters were buzzing about,
`helping out with the manure watch,
`sharing in a beverage.
`This year’s judge of the World Dairy
`Expo youthfitting competition?
`He was kicking back, betweenstints of
`watering and feeding his owncattle,jok-
`ing with the other showjocks.
`At 26 Henderson has made a name
`
`for himself in the world offitting cattle
`
`You have tobe “willing to put your
`’
`career ahead of everything else,”if you
`:
`Kyle Henderson: You have to be “willing to putyour career ahead of
`want to reach the pinnaclein thisgig;
`everything else,” ifyou want to reach the pinnaclein this gig; “evenif :
`“even if your dad says ‘Go out and cut
`yourdadsays ‘Go out andcut thatfield of hay.”
`+
`
`|=a RRR ERE TRE CR Ree oO eee 2 that field of hay.”
`|f
`6 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER OCTOBER2015
`
`}
`
`
`
`NUHN15000022737
`NUHN15000022737
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page6 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 6 of 32
`
`

`

`Having Hendersononthe job, adds
`this year from Albert Cormier’sfinal
`Did he go?
`sale,
`Coughlin “is probably good for a couple
`Ohyeah.
`“| made sure | was available for that, he
`of placings.”
`“You've got to.”
`says, crediting Cormier with “being a
`He gets the hard part right too, says
`“I'm not a tractor guy.I'm a cow guy.”
`hugeinfluencein my life.”
`It was here in the summer show's clip-
`Katie Coyne-DeBruin.
`“Whenhe is done clipping an animal,
`ping competition that Henderson didn't
`Hesays he learnedalot “justlistening
`to him.”
`everyhair is in place. The topline hair is
`gethis start.
`straight up and down.Lots offitters
`He competedfourtimes and finished
`Hendersongets the easy stuff right,
`says Coughlin. He is always prepared.
`have a curlin it orit’s going forward, but
`second every year.
`His clippers are well-maintained and “he
`Kyle has just the right touchto getit in
`It wasn't necessarily a failure because,
`the direction it needs to be. The hair on
`more determined than ever, Henderson
`knows exactly what every blade can do.”
`kept plugging away; a trait he’s known
`for to this day.
`“It doesn't matter how good youare
`in 4-H,” Henderson says.“It's the pas-
`sion that you bring,” and how hard you
`work.
`
`Income over
`feed cost
`increases
`when
`balancing for
`amino acids
`
`It takes clipping hundreds and thou-
`sands of cows every year. He estimates
`he'll clip 3,000 head in a show season,
`and spends the off-season clipping for
`sales and classification.
`“He never stops learning,” says Gerald
`Coughlin, co-chair of the Ontario Sum-
`mer Show committee.
`“He's a good kid. He works hard, and
`he's dedicated,” adds Coughlin, explain-
`ing that the hard work has paid off for
`Properly balancing your herd’s
`the Millbrook, Ontario man.
`amino acids allows reduced
`“He's got to be as goodas there is
`a)cepaciaMch] mae dele iat f
`supports milk production, and
`really.”
`decreases nitrogen excretion.
`MilkSource herd manager Jamie Endvik
`says Henderson cansee the potential in
`every cow and knowshowtobringit
`out.
`
`AjiPro®-L use when balancing the
`amino acid levels is a Best Practice. 9
`
`
`
`+ 793-850-9795 * AHISales@ajiusa.com « WWW.AjiPro-L.com
`
`Clipping, he says,is extremely impor-
`tantin the heifer classes; it can “make or
`break,” the animal's showing.In the milk-
`ing classes, a good clipperlike Hender-
`son can “bring out the character.”
`Henderson's WDE resume includes
`
`last year's red and white champion,
`Strans-Jen D Tequila REd, the Brown
`Swiss Old Mill JP Grace in 2010, and
`Blondin Redman Seisme, getting his
`start 10 years ago whenhis father asked
`the Phoenixesif they wouldlike some
`help, again at the Ontario summershow.
`He just completed his 10th year helping
`them and hastravelled throughout
`Ontario and New York; heading to WDE
`
`AjiPro-Lis:
`
`v The most heavily researchedrumen
`protectedlysine; scientifically proven
`by universities and research institutes
`
`Highly bypassable (80% rumen bypass)
`
`& Highly digestible
`(62.5% intestinal digestibility)
`
`& Highly bioavailable (50%)
`
`& Stable in TMRs and premixes
`
`AJINOMOTO.
`AJINOMOTO HEARTLAND,INC.
`[ine
`ents
`
`8430 W Bryn Mawr #650 » Chicago, IL, USA 60631-3421
`
`Rumen Protected Lysine
`
`
`
`OCTOBER 2015 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER 7
`
`NUHN15000022738
`NUHN15000022738
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 7 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 7 of 32
`
`

`

`
`
`PROFILE
`
`
`the heifer’s belly is also blendedin to
`the sides, cut appropriately for the
`
`
`heifer (long if she needs depth, shortif
`she doesn't) and is blown out and ring
`ready. The rest of the animal is clipped
`
`with nolines or marks.”
`
`
`She toopraises his dedication.
`“Kyle will clip all day and into the eve-
`
`ning if that’s whatit takes to getit
`
`right.”
`
`Andshesays, he “does his workwith-
`
`outa lot oftalking or fanfare - he just
`
`does whathe is asked to do and doesn't
`
`
`make a big deal ofit. This is rare in his
`the off season clipping whole herds,
`superintendentsays his credentials do
`line of work.”
`
`mostly between Toronto and the Que-
`the talking.
`Coughlin too admires his get-to-work
`bec border.
`“The reason youre not getting much
`attitude.
`
`outof him is because he wouldn't want
`“That's mylife.” He says he followed
`“He's very quiet; very studious,” he
`the usual route. He worked at home
`
`to talk about himself! He has prepared
`says, adding that Henderson's mentor,
`numerous champions in Ontario, Wis-
`Mike Phoenix, was as good as anyone
`
`consin, European shows and more. He
`ever to prepare an animal for the show
`hasfit the MilkSource string at World
`ring.
`Dairy Expo and the Royalwith huge
`Henderson “just pays attention...and
`amountsof success,including several
`he's notafraid to try different things,”
`champions and premier breeder and
`adds Coughlin, who has included Hen-
`exhibitor banners.”
`dersonin his judging line-up for the
`“Kyle also hasclipped at someof the
`summershow overthe past three years.
`mostprestigioussales in the world,” she
`“He's respected everywhere.”
`notes.
`It’s all of that that Katie Coyne-
`DeBruin expects Hendersonto bring
`when he becomesthe first Canadian to
`judge the World Dairy Expo's youthfit-
`ting competition this month.
`“When we select a judge for ourfitting
`contest, we want them toreally under-
`stand fitting - howto clip, how to blow
`up the topline, how to properly use the
`equipment- Kyle fit this first criteria
`easily,”
`she told Ontario Dairy Farmer,
`describing Hendersonas“simply one of
`the best fitters that thereis.”
`“He's gotten some ofthe best cowsin
`the world clipped for shows and you'd
`never knowit. He is the first Canadian
`fitter to judge the contest and | am
`thrilled for him. He doesthe job heis
`supposedto do, he doesit quietly,
`respectfully and very well.”
`While Hendersonisn’t big on brag-
`ging, Coyne-DeBruin, WDE's youth
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`“playing with calves,” going to shows
`and helping people ontheir farms,
`learning from others, teaching himself,
`wil while completing high school, then
`graduating from Kemptville College.
`And he's now atthe point where “I
`don’t haveto call anyone.If can doit, |
`do.”
`He's clipping 250 days a year and
`making a goodliving.
`“You can't spend three hours ona
`calf” he says. “If you can't get a calf
`done in 45 minutes you're wasting time;
`you're too nit-picky.”
`At World Dairy Expo Hendersonwill
`be doing more thanjust judging the end
`product.
`“Kyle will watch the youth for 60 min-
`utes, make notes and place the topten.
`After the youth are done,hewill give
`them individual pointers on how to
`improve,” says Coyne-DeBruin.
`The youth have one hourto clip and
`prepare their animals, and Henderson
`will be watching how well they know and
`handle their equipmentincluding
`“knowledge of which clippers to use
`where on the body,finished product
`and overall appearance of animal.”
`“Weare looking forward to having
`him as our judge as he workswell with
`young people, knowshis fitting andis a
`great young man.” ®
`
`As his career has propelled him onto
`the international circuit, Henderson
`hasn't abandonedhis central Ontario
`clients. He has beena part of the Web-
`bview team for about eight years, says
`an enthusiastic Christina WebbPettey.
`“He always shows up on time and
`doeshis best. He takes pride in making
`every cow look her best,” adds Webb,
`whosayshis talent is almost instinctive.
`“He makes every cow looknatural; like
`that’s how she was supposedto look.”
`With Henderson ontheclippers,
`Webbviewhas enjoyedlots of success
`bringing home Honorable Mention ban-
`ners from the Quinte Exhibition, exhib-
`iting the grand championJersey two
`years ago and grand championin Bel-
`leville three years ago.
`“We've had tonsof success with him.”
`
`Henderson spends 90% to 95 per
`cent ofhis time on the road, mostly
`doing showsin the summertime, then in
`
`8 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER OCTOBER 2015
`
`NUHN15000022739
`NUHN15000022739
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 8 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 8 of 32
`
`

`

`Page 9 of 32
`
`Vétoquinol Club is a rewards program and our way
`of thanking you for sharing our passion in animal health.
`Vétoquinol Club lets you:
`* earn points on Vétoquinol product purchases;
`« redeem yourpoints for amazing rewards;
`« get members only accessto special offers and events.
`
`}
`
`ra
`=
`*
`J
`Join the Vétoquinol Club
`We rarely have the chance to thank you.
`
`SIGN UP TODAY AND REAP THE BENEFITS
`
`BECAUSE YOU ARE
`ALWAYS ON THE JOB
`
`club
`
`REWARD YOURSELF
`
`Vera
`
`%
`
`\
`
`www.vetoquinol.ca
`
`Vetoquinol
`hy, a Sig of(Revi/
`
`NUHN15000022740
`NUHN15000022740
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazookav. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 9 of 32
`
`

`

`Seven-year-old Aleah takes a momentto posewith her
`
`EL.
`
`parents Brian and Amber Craswell during Crasdale
`Farm's open house during PEI Old Home Week.
`
`:
`
`
`
`Crasdale Farms has gone from being one of the oldest, to one of the
`most technically advanced dairy barns on the Island. But they also
`kept the ring.sy sHaron Grose
`
`
`
`
`animals and that had them traveling
`barn until, according to Brian, the
`CRASDALE FARM went from being
`
`oneofthe oldest dairy facilities on barn outlived its usefulness. Their set-|across North America showingcattle.
`
`
`Prince Edward Island, to being one of|up was labour-intense enough, and You may have seen themin the show
`
`the most technically advanced dairy
`then an employee of 30 years decided
`ring at Royal Winter Fair or World
`barns in Canada, to move west to work in the oil fields.|Dairy Expo in Madison., Wisconsin.
`
`Brian and AmberCraswell used to They decidedit was time fora change.|Changesin the marketplace caused
`
`
`milk 62 cowsin a tail-to-tail tie-stall
`Historically their focus was show
`the couple to re-examine their goals
`
`
`
`NUHN15000022741
`NUHN15000022741
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 10 of 32
`
`10 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER OCTOBER 2015
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 10 of 32
`
`

`

`PROFILE
`
`“Show cows
`and everyday
`
`cows are
`
`getting closer
`together
`because they
`should be”
`
`and they now focus on genetics and
`milk.
`The Craswells have had the oppor-
`tunity to tour quite a few different
`dairy barns as they travelled across
`North America with their auction
`
`business. They were drawn to VMS
`system because they felt the cows
`appeared morerelaxed and comfort-
`able. Cow comfort was a priority when
`it came time to design and build their
`
`||LNAAUAANAAAA Lifestyles Realty
`ROYAL LEPAGE__5820 Atwy 2A Lacombe
`LN AN AANAAA
`
`new barn. They opted for a DeLaval
`IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SELL OR
`
`TIE
`BUY, TALK TO ANDRIES WHOIS WELL CONNECTEDIN THE INDUSTRY!
`www.centralalbertafarms.com ¢ email: asteegstra @ royallepage.ca
`
`
`
`OCTOBER 2015 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER 11
`
`NUHN15000022742
`NUHN15000022742
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 11 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 11 of 32
`
`

`

`PROFILE
`
`
`
`Page 12 of 32
`
`Brian and Amberrecently hosted an open hose
`at Crasdale Farms during Old Home Weekin PEI.
`oieClineeee reheateelili te
`toured their new barn.It was a great opportunity
`to showcase their barn and educate consumers on
`
`modern dairy practices.
`
`NUHN15000022743
`NUHN15000022743
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 12 of 32
`
`

`

`PROFILE
`
`farmers thinking about robotic milking
`cows into the herd. They brought the
`Robotic milking system, automatic
`systems, Brian and Ambersaiditis
`whole herd in all at once and within six
`feed system and Herd Navigator.
`important to plan ahead andinclude
`“The amount ofinformation about
`weeks cowswere visiting the robot3.1
`as many experts possible in the deci-
`each individual cows we have is amaz-
`times on average. Thingsgot a little
`sion process. “Get advice from your
`complicated when Brian added 23
`ing and makes yourealize howlittle we
`vet, feed manager, dairy specialist and
`knew about our cows before!” said
`cows onaFriday afternoon and then
`Amber.
`anyoneelse you have confidencein”
`left for a few weeks with his auctioneer
`“We are farmers that became more
`and ask a lot of questions, said Amber.
`business. The original herd learned
`“Sometimes as dairy farmers, we don’t
`traffic patterns but then new cows
`managers, we're not doing as much
`were introduced and the old cows
`information-share enough. While we
`labour,” said Brian, “with the tie stall
`are a large group, we operate individu-
`becameannoyed with the cows that
`system we were more hands-on but
`ally, but we should remember, thereis
`didn’t know what to do.
`the day passes quickly and not much
`strength in numbers.”
`“If | had to do it again | would milk
`time was spent with each cow. The
`100 cowsinstead of 60 and would
`Whendesigning and building a new
`auctioneerbusinesshas us traveling
`dairy facility is important to set your
`put them all in at once.”
`across Canada,but staying in touch is
`budget and timeline. “Get everything
`Whenasked if robots can milk show
`no problem because we can log in to
`99.9% final on paper and then don't
`cows, Brian was quick to reply that
`our system from anywhere.”
`make many changes while building
`robots can milk any cows. The chal-
`Craswell feel their new system allows
`because that tends to kill your bud-
`cows to make their own decisions on
`lenge is having the time to put the
`get,” said Amber.
`show cows on special feed for show-
`feeding, milking and rest,allowing
`“It's a major project and change. The
`ing. “Show cows and everyday cows
`managers moreflexibility to manage
`unexpectedwill happen, you just need
`are getting closer together because
`their time moreefficiently.
`to stay calm and milk on!” added
`The transition from tie stall to
`they should be,” said Brian.
`Amber. ©
`Whenasked aboutoffering advice to
`robotic wentwell until they put other
`
`
`
`WORLD LEADER IN THE DESIGN
`AND MANUFACTURING OF AUTOMATED HERD FEEDER SYSTEMS AND ROBOTIC FEEDING
`
`
`
`
`
`\i
`
`‘
`
`AGRISOLUTIONS
`
`TMR AUTOMATED SILAGE
`Pyees
`MIXER FEEDER
`
`eT rAt ess
`
`Manitoba
`Saskatchewan
`Alberta
`1-204-488-5078
`1-306-933-3366
`1-403-224-3454
`
`
`OCTOBER 2015 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER 13
`
`NUHN15000022744
`NUHN15000022744
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 13 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 13 of 32
`
`

`

`NUTRITION|PeterVitti
`
`
`
`eteTe
`
`
`
`‘Doearly lactation
`-vitamins
`‘Cows need B
`supplements?
`
`
`
`WHEN | BALANCE a lactating dairy
`TMR,| first use available forages as a
`base, then add energy-enriched feeds
`such asgrains and fats, then add pro-
`tein sources, add in macro-, trace min-
`erals and fat-soluble vitamins. | might
`finish these diets off with a small
`amountof pro-biotics and other spe-
`cialty feed ingredients.
`Myfinal dairy diet should contain
`enoughessential nutrients in the right
`proportions to meet the essential
`
`nutrient requirements of dairy cows
`that produce large volumesof milk
`and milkfat as well as maintain healthy
`body condition. Oddly enough,|
`largely ignore formulating B-vitamins
`such as choline (B4), niacin (B3), bio-
`tin (B8), and thiamine (B1) into lacta-
`tion diets.
`That’ because the National
`
`Research Council (2001) from which|
`draw informationfor lactating cow
`nutrient requirements, dictates:
`
`““B-Vitamins requirements of lactat-
`ing dairy cows can be met through
`synthesis by ruminal microorganisms
`and escapeof dietary sources from
`the rumen.” Furthermore, it has been
`my experience that aside from the
`occasionally polio case in bulls
`(caused by a B12 deficiency), actual
`B-vitamin are rare in lactating dairy
`cows.
`
`Someuniversity dairy nutritionists
`do not agree with the NRC's B-vita-
`
`|
`14 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER OCTOBER 2015
`
`Thewriter is an independent dairy consultant basedin Winnipeg
`
`]
`
`
`
`NUHN15000022745
`NUHN15000022745
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 14 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 14 of 32
`
`

`

`OCTOBER 2015 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER 15
`OTOTOTS)
`
`min assessment. They believe that the
`genetic pedigree of today's high pro-
`ducing dairy cowcalls for routine sup-
`plementation, because the modern
`cow’s requirementfor B-vitamins
`exceeds what amounts that rumen
`microbes can normally supply. Hereis
`a brief overview of such positive
`B-vitamin unversity research:
`* PennState fed 6 gramsof supple-
`mental niacin to lactating dairy cows
`fed a typical lactation diets consisting
`of; either corn silage, or corn silage
`and hay, or pasture. The researchers
`found that cows producingat least 35
`kg of milk produced about 2.5 kg
`more milk with supplemental niacin.
`* University of Maryland study, the
`researchers infused choline directly
`into the small intestine of lactating
`dairy cows and successfully exhibited
`a 1.9 kg per head perday increasein
`milk production. The general con-
`science amongstudiesis that a cho-
`line supplement needs to be
`“protected” to bypass the rumen to
`provide any benefit to the animal.
`¢ University of Florida fed mature
`dairy cows O or 20 mg; 16 days pre-
`calving and O or 30 mgofbiotin; 70
`days post-calving. The researchers
`not only found that milk production
`increased about 1.0 kg per head per
`day onthe biotin treatments, but
`these cows had less non-esterified
`fatty acids (NEFA)built upin theirliv-
`ers, whichis a leading causeoffatal
`fatty liver syndromein high perform-
`ing dairy cattle.
`* Ohio State attributed 20 mg of
`supplemental biotin added to the
`transition-early lactation diets
`resulted in 2.9 kg more milk produced
`by biotin-supplemented cows com-
`Tom Uestore Lae)
`pared to an un-supplemented control
`CeleReleRPLLia
`group. The control cows averaged
`about 37 kg of milk/day versus about
`40 kg of milk in the biotin-cows.
`Dr. Randy Shaver from University
`of Wisconsin (2000) feed 150-300
`mg per head per day of rumen unpro-
`
`tected thiamine (B1) to lactating
`dairy cowsfed low fiber/high NFC
`diets. The results showed a nominal
`increasein dry matter intake, milk
`production and milk components.
`The biological mechanism for these
`documented positive B-vitamin
`responsesis largely unknown. How-
`ever, many ruminantscientists believe
`that many B-vitamins such asniacin,
`biotin and thiamine act as the “on”
`
`switch of enzymes in the numerous
`intermediary energy-yielding steps,
`which are required to transform
`dietary nutrients into a metabolite
`form that the cows’ tissues can use for
`body maintenance andfor perfor-
`mance such as good milk production.
`Choline, which is not part of any par-
`ticular enzyme system, like these
`other B-vitaminsalso plays an active
`role in carbohydrate and fat
`
`a
`WALL DAY, EVERY DAY.
`RELEAEMeee mat sete Rolmiele
`industry-leading advancements in automated
`milking and feeding equipment — for today and
`for generations. The Lely team partners with
`you to offer automatedrobotic milking, feeding
`and barn product solutions for cow comfort,
`backed by 24-hour local support. Your milking
`operation runs at peak efficiency — maximizing
`profitability with minimal manual labor and a
`host of technical information. Turn to Lely to
`improve your financial and social well-being —
`all day, every day. Contact your local Lely dealers
`ie) Mie)Medoa
`
`wwwilely.com 1-888-245-4684
`
`innovators in agriculture
`
`——
`
`NUHN15000022746
`NUHN15000022746
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 15 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 15 of 32
`
`

`

`associated with ketosis in early lactat-
`ing dairy cows.
`Since these B-vitaminsare signifi-
`cantly involved in the bio-chemical
`reactions that drive efficient carbohy-
`drate and fat metabolism,it is likely
`that they help drive the biochemical
`reactions that produce more energy
`(glucose) is ultimately available to the
`early lactation cow and thushelp pre-
`vent dangerousketosis.
`A common recommendation is to
`add each of these B-vitamins to a
`
`transition cow diet, which is fed three
`weeks before calving and three weeks
`into early lactation; 6-12 grams of
`niacin per head, or 60 gramsof cho-
`line (in a rumen-protected form), and
`biotin added at 20 mgperhead, daily.
`The respective cost per head per day
`also as follows: niacin @ 8.5-17 cents,
`rumen-protected choline @ 60 cents,
`and biotin @ 3 cents.Lastly, | recom-
`mended adding thiamine @ no more
`
`than 10 cents per head per day to
`help stimulate appetite and dry mat-
`ter intake. One should realize that
`
`there is no substantial proof that add-
`ing any of these B-vitamins together
`yields a cumulative response.
`Nor is there any proof that the gen-
`eral lactating cow population needs
`added B-vitaminsto their overall
`
`dairy diet. Rather, the existing
`research and my own experiencetells
`me that the best areasin the dairy
`barn for B-vitamin supplementation
`is: (1) early lactation cowsin negative
`energy balance, (2) Ist calf lactating
`heifers to stimulate feed intake and
`(3) cowssuffering from significant
`digestive upsets. Otherwise, | formu-
`late a well-balanced nutritious dairy
`diet that ultimately promotes good
`rumen function, in which the “rumen
`bugs” should producesufficient
`B-vitamins for healthy and productive
`dairy cows. ©
`
`NUTRITION
`
`metabolism.
`
`For example, although interdepen-
`dent of one another, these particular
`B-vitamins are strongly advocated by
`the same researchers to be involved in
`
`the regulation of NEFA (non-esteri-
`fied fatty acids) metabolism in the
`liver of early lactation dairy cows.
`Whetherweare feeding health or
`metabolically challenged dairy cows,
`dietary carbohydrates (containing
`glucose) are oftenin short supply for
`early milk production, The dairy cow
`must then burn her own body fat to
`produce immediate energy or non-
`esterified fatty acids (NEFAs), which
`are later transformed back into
`
`energy-rich glucose or provide fatty
`acids for butterfat. However, when
`too many NEFAsare producedfor
`glucose transformation, a good por-
`tion of these NEFAs end up as poison-
`ous ketones.It is these circulating
`ketone bodies that lead to toxicity
`
`Bba
`
`HARVESTORE'
`
`1-204-488-5078
`
`AGRISOLUTIONS
`
`livestock Systems
`
`Alberta
`1-403-224-3454
`
`Saskatchewan
`1-306-933-3366
`
`Manitoba
`
`16 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER OCTOBER 2015
`
`NUHN15000022747
`NUHN15000022747
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 16 of 32
`
`
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 16 of 32
`
`

`

`he is more thanthat. | It is the certainty to get a fast and effective management of manure contained in your
`
`It is not Only TP
`Doing the Job...
`
`offering unbeatable products.
`
`st
`
`lagoon orin your concretepit.
`
`The Articulated Agi-Pompestands out withits propeller givinga constant agitation up to 21500 US gpm in loading
`modeas wellas in agitation mode. Equipped with an articulatedhousing, the agitation nozzle combined with the 40°
`vertical rotation of the housing allows to significantly reduce main storage honaaaation time. GEA neverstops
`Articulated Agi-Pompe with the articulatedhousing|
`sail
`
`
`gino
`
`ie
`
`A.G. Penner Farm Services Ltd.
`Blumenort, MB — 204.326.3781
`
`Kneller’s Sales & Services Ltd.
`Leduc, AB — 780.986.5600
`
`Pacific Dairy Centre Ltd.
`Abbotsford, BC — 604.852.9020
`
`D. H. & P. Supplies & EquipmentLtd.
`Blackfalds, AB — 403.782.6473
`
`Lethbridge Dairy Mart Ltd.
`Lethbridge, AB — 403.329.6234
`
`PennerFarm Services, BrandonDiv,
`Brandon, MB — 204.728.7563
`
`Dairyland Agro SupplyLtd.
`Emerald Park, SK — 306.721.6844
`Saskatoon, SK — 306.242.5850
`
`Mountain View Electric Ltd.
`Enderby, BC — 250.838.6455
`
`engineering for a better world
`
`
`
`OCTOBER 2015 WESTERN DAIRY FARMER 17
`
`NUHN15000022748
`NUHN15000022748
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 17 of 32
`
`Exhibit 2074
`Bazooka v. Nuhn - IPR2024-00098
`Page 17 of 32
`
`

`

`
`
`PROFILE
`
`< ern
`
`The career path for Pieter and Miriam
`Van der Stoelinvolved plenty of
`thought, some roadblocks, and a chance
`encounter sy sHaron Grose
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`his day. He's the first to admit that
`“milking was never really my hobby.”
`Whenhis father was readyto retired
`
`Pieter lacked funding to take over the
`farm. So he started looking aroundfor
`
`more economicaloptions. Pieter and his
`
`wife Miriam decided to take a working
`holiday to Canada and tour somefarms.
`introduced to automatic milkers in the
`ROBOTIC MILKERS SPARKEDPieter
`They st

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket