Name:
`
`Curriculum Vitae May 2021
`Craig Bishop
`
`Contact Tel No.:
`
`+44 (0)7984 564949 (mobile)
`
`Email:
`
`craig@bishopcom.co.uk
`
`Current job title:
`
`Independent Consulting Engineer, CEO
`
`Address:
`
`32 Nightingale Road, Faversham, Kent, ME13 8RF
`
`Key Skills and Experience
`
`31 years Telecoms, Radio and Broadcast experience
`24 years experience in 2G/3G/4G telecoms standardisation and mobile handset development
`Extensive knowledge of 3GPP and ETSI specifications and procedures including ETSI role from
`regulatory perspective (harmonised standards, mandates, spectrum, etc)
`Sound understanding of 3GPP systems, including Radio Access Interfaces and Networks, Access
`Stratum protocols, Core Networks, Non-Access Stratum protocols, and IMS
`Depositions, reports, and declarations as expert witness in cases on 3GPP technologies and on
`3GPP & ETSI practices and procedures.
`Intellectual property analysis including prior art search and evaluation of patent essentiality
`Application of data analytics and machine learning techniques to standards and IP data
`Programming in Java, Python, C, Octave (Matlab)
`
`Career History
`
`Bishop Communications Ltd.
`
`01/13
`
`Independent Telecommuncations Standards and Intellectual Property
`Consultant
`Full ETSI member
`
`Activities have included:
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Provision of expertise for EC funded ETSI Specialist Task Force (STF489) to produce
`implementation guidelines for Total Conversation for emergency services. Project delivered on
`time / budget and well received. Ouput published March 2016 as ETSI TR 103 201.
`
`Provision of expertise for ETSI Specialist Task Force (STF555) assessing the impact on existing
`standards of communications involving IoT devices in all types of emergency situations. Project
`delivered on time / budget and well received. Ouput published July 2019 as ETSI TR 103 582.
`
`Provision of expert support for IPR litigation from standards landscape analysis / background
`technical reports to expert testimony reports / declarations and depositions.
`
`Intellectual property analysis assessing strengths and weaknesses of patents and patent
`portfolios, conducting searches for prior art, evaluating patent essentiality, and acquring relevant
`documentation.
`
`Provision of standards consultancy services for Samsung Electronics in ETSI including
`membership of the ETSI Board until November 2014
`
`Technologies covered in patent related work include: 3GPP GSM, UMTS, LTE radio interface
`technologies (Phy, MAC, RLC, RRC), 3GPP access and core networks (GPRS/UMTS & EPC NAS),
`IMS. Organisations covered include 3GPP & ETSI.
`
`Clients served during last 8 years include: Addy Hart LLP, Alston & Bird LLP, Banner Witcoff LLP, DLA
`Piper LLP, European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI), Fish & Richardson P.C., Gibson
`Dunn LLP, Haynes and Boone LLP, Hillebrand-CE GmbH (work for third party clients as Consulting
`Engineer for Hillebrand-CE), Kilpatrick Townsend & Stockton, Kirkland & Ellis LLP, KL Gates LLP
`Morgan, Lewis & Bokius LLP, MckoolSmith LLP, PV Law LLP, Paul Hastings LLP, Perkins Coie LLP,
`
`Ex.1006
`APPLE INC. / Page 1 of 5
`
`

`

`Powell Gilbert LLP, Sidley Austin LLP, Samsung Electronics Research & Development Institute UK
`(SRUK), Taylor Wessing LLP, Williams & Connolly LLP, WilmerHale LLP.
`
`Expert testimony through deposition:
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd. vs. T-Mobile US, Inc., et al., Case Nos. 2:16-cv-0052-JRG-RSP,
`2:16-cv-0055-JRG-RSP, 2:16-cv-0056-JRG-RSP, and 2:16-cv-0057-JRG-RSP (E.D. Tex.). On
`behalf of T-Mobile US Inc.
`
`T-Mobile US, Inc., et al. v. Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd., IPR Nos. IPR2017-00696 and
`IPR2017-00697 (PTAB). On behalf of T-Mobile US Inc.
`
`LG Electronics, Inc., v. Koninklijke KPN N.V., IPR Nos. Case IPR2018-00558 (PTAB). On behalf
`of LG Electronics, Inc.
`
`Expert testimony in court:
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Between IPCom GmbH and Vodafone, et al., Claim No. HP-2018-000030 Claim No. HP-2018-
`000031, High Court of Justice, Business & Property Courts of England and Wales, Intellectual
`Property List (ChD), Patents Court. Retained by Vodafone.
`
`Between (1) Mitsubishi Electric Corporation (2) Sisvel International SA and Oneplus Mobiletech
`UK Limited, Oppo Mobile UK Ltd, Xiaomi Technology UK Limited, et al., Claim No. HP-2019-
`000014, High Court of Justice, Business & Property Courts of England and Wales, Intellectual
`Property List (ChD), Patents Court. Retained by Oneplus, Oppo, and Xiaomi (trial held remotely
`due to COVID-19 restrictions)
`
`A list of reports and declarations submitted but not deposed for can be provided upon request.
`
`Samsung Electronics Research Institute (SERI)
`
`Director Standards and Industry Affairs
`Mission and Tasks as for previous role plus:
`
`12/96
`
`01/13
`
`03/11
`
`01/13
`
`-
`
`Proactive member of ETSI Board following election as Board member in November 2011
`
`- Worked with Samsung internal and external legal counsel in response to EC investigation into
`Samsung suspected abuse of Standards Essential Patents.
`
`-
`Deposed by Apple as fact witness in ITC investigation 337-TA-794.
`09/05 - 03/11
`Head of Advanced Technologies Standards & Regulation
`Mission: To help position Samsung and SERI at the forefront of mobile telecommunication
`developments through participation in and leadership of mobile communications standards and
`European regulatory affairs
`
`Key tasks:
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Developed standards and research strategy and coordinated activites with head office, acting as
`official Samsung contact for the European Telecommunications Standars Institute.
`
`Programme managed standardisation and regulation projects covering 3GPP (RAN2, CT1, SA2,
`SA1, SA, RAN, CT), OMA, and mobile Broadcast strategies and technologies (DVB Forum),
`European Framework projects (FP7), Spectrum Management (CEPT, ETSI EM, TFES, BRAN
`and European Regulatory affairs (Digital Europe, relations with European Commission
`). -
`Grew department from 3 to 12 persons to cater for these activities.
`
`)
`
`Participated and actively contributed to 3GPP SA1 (11/08 11/11), SA2 (10/05 08/11) , SA and
`ETSI TC SCP groups on issues including IMS / CS Interworking (VCC / SRVCC, VoLTE, T-ADS,
`ICS), Local IP Access & Selected IP Traffic Offload (LIPA-SIPTO), MOSAP, M2M/MTC,
`Embedded / 4FF UICC.
`
`Drafted and filed communication technology related patents related to 3GPP SA2 and CT1
`technologies
`18 filed, mainly IMS and 3GPP NAS related
`
`Supported Samsung IP team with analysis of Samsung and 3rd party communication technology
`related patents and claim charts including GSM/GPRS, UTRAN, NAS, and IMS patents
`
`Ex.1006
`APPLE INC. / Page 2 of 5
`
`

`

`-
`
`Chaired SERI Patent Committee from 2007-2009 - SERI achieved patent targets for first time in
`2007 and did so in every year following
`
`Standards consultant part time
`(Whilst studying fulltime for MSC)
`
`09/04 09/05
`
`During this time, I conducted a review of the wireless communication technolgies and the associated
`standards space, with a particular emphasis on 802.16a, as well as 3G and 802.11 evolutions. I was
`also involved in analysis of 3rd party patents and claim charts on request from Samsung IP team.
`
`06/03 09/04
`Technology Manager System Engineering group
`Mission: To establish a System Engineering group within SERI to support development
`mode GSM/UMTS radio modem platform.
`
`Key Tasks:
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Defined and implemented System Engineering group strategy including recruitment and line
`management of the group which grew from 3 to 10 engineers during this period.
`
`dual mode 2G/3G radio modem platform(s)
`Developed detailed system requirements for
`including production of background documentation describing system wide behaviour
`
`Defined system test programme for platform, including example test cases using off the shelf test
`equipment. This project outsourced (under my supervision) to a third party company for
`completion.
`
`Provided continued support to development engineers in terms of understanding specification and
`system requirements, particularly with respect to Access Stratum and Non Access Stratum
`specifications and protocols.
`
`Instigated and managed studies investigating optimised system architecture for future Samsung
`mobile platforms.
`Analysed Samsung and 3rd party 3GPP technology related patents and claim charts on request by
`Samsung IP team and reported on their value and standards essentiality.
`
`Technology Manager Standards & System Group
`Mission: To pro
`standardisation activities.
`
`Key Tasks:
`
`04/02
`
`06/03
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Devised and implemented revised strategy to improve the focus of activities and provide improved
`support for software developers from a system perspective.
`
`Attended 3GPP TSG SA plenary and occasional SA WG1 meetings - acted as rapporteur for
`3GPP Evolution technical report 3GPP TR 21.902.
`
`Analysed 3rd party GSM/GPRS technology related patents and claim charts on request by
`Samsung IP team and reported on their value and standards essentiality.
`
`Line managed 3 engineers, ensuring that the group provided expert support for SERI SW and HW
`developers in terms of standards interpretation and system requirements, particularly with respect
`to the Radio Access Network.
`
`04/00 04/02
`Project Manager
`Mission: To establish and manage development of a dual mode GSM/UMTS modem platform.
`
`Key tasks:
`
`-
`
`Defined and managed work relating to core technology development for
`
`handsets.
`
`Ex.1006
`APPLE INC. / Page 3 of 5
`
`

`

`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Determined major technical architecture and parameters for the platform producing high level
`system requirements specification and project development plan.
`
`As a technical authority on UMTS, supported the project in terms of requirements specification
`and interpretation (L1, MAC/RLC, RRC, and NAS specifications), and contributed towards the
`training of UMTS project team members.
`
`Acting in a consultative capacity, interfaced with other departments in Samsung and with external
`customers/suppliers on issues relating to 2G and 3G technologies
`
`Responsible for the overall planning, work allocation and co-ordination of engineers for the
`project, as well as being involved in recruitment during this period the number of engineers
`working on the project increased from 10 to over 40.
`
`Instigated, defined and managed a feasibility study involving HW and SW engineers, as essential
`preparation for the development of a dual mode GSM/UMTS radio modem platform.
`
`12/96 04/00
`Senior/Principal Standards Engineer
`Mission: To support Samsung standards and development activities in ETSI and 3GPP.
`
`Key Tasks:
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Gathered and disseminated information throughout Samsung concerning latest specifications and
`trends in telecommunications, providing advice to Senior Management on future strategies for
`telecommunications development.
`
`Acted as sole Samsung representative in ETSI TC SMG2 from December 1996 and during the
`selection phase for the UMTS Radio Acces Technology providing training for Samsung engineers
`on elaborated technologies
`
`Participated in 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 (UTRA Physical Layer), and RAN WG2 (L2/3) contributing
`specifically in areas related to FEC, Common Packet Channel, and Transmit Diversity
`
`In 3GPP TSG T WG2 I initiated and acted as rapporteur for the UE capabilities work item. I also
`acted as liaison officer between TSG T WG2, TSG RAN WG1 and TSG SA WG1 (Service
`Aspects) on issues of common interest
`
`Acted as main spokesperson for and advisor on Samsung strategic activities in, 3GPP TSG RAN
`on until April 2000
`
`Acted in a consultative capacity advising the company on technical, commercial and regulatory
`issues relating to 3rd generation telecommunications development and implementation.
`
`Developed and promoted programme to co-ordinate standards activities throughout Samsung.
`Samsung Global Standards Strategy Group established in September 1998.
`
`Attended ETSI TCs, SMG1, SMG4, SMG5, SMG7, SMG9 and SMG11 as required by Samsung
`to keep abreast of developments prior to establishment of 3GPP
`
`Radiocommunications Agency
`
`06/93 -11/96
`
`HPTO Spectrum Engineer
`-
`Responsible for the management of spectrum for use by PMR and Wireless LAN technologies.
`
`-
`
`Defined and instigated development of an improved assignment methodology for Private Mobile
`Radio (PMR) channels, promoting increased quality and spectrum efficiency.
`
`- Managed research projects involving the assessment and selection of bids from external
`companies, submitted under competitive tender.
`
`-
`
`Represented the Agency in the National and International fora associated with the use of Land
`Mobile Radio, acting as rapporteur for PMR voice and data standards in ETSI Sub-Technical-
`Committee RES02, and as chairman of a sub-working group under ITU WP8A drafting the
`recommendation for use of the radio spectrum by Radio LANs.
`
`Ex.1006
`APPLE INC. / Page 4 of 5
`
`

`

`-
`
`-
`
`Involved in CEPT Spectrum Engineering Project Teams, dealing with spectrum for Narrow band
`PMR technology and co-ordination between that technology and T-DAB transmissions in Band III.
`
`Dispensed technical advice both within the Agency and to external customers, on national and
`international PMR standards, assessing requests for additional frequencies, and providing
`technical justification for assignments and wider spectrum policy
`
`BBC Radio
`
`Radio Operations Engineer
`
`11/89 05/93
`
`- Worked on projects requiring the design, development, maintenance and testing of equipment for
`use within the broadcasting chain.
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Responsible for acceptance testing of new studios for Radio 5, and in particular redesign of
`outside source circuits for the main sports continuity studio.
`
`Involved in acceptance testing for NICAM transmission routers. Designed and implemented
`modifications to synchronise transmission feeds, resulting in seamless switching between routers.
`
`Education
`1. MSC in Computer Science from the University of Kent
`
`Awarded (with distinction): 07/2006
`
`Dissertation title: Roles Variables and Program Analysis Received prize for outstanding
`achievement
`
`2. B.Eng. (Hons) in Electronic Engineering from the Polytechnic of Central London
`
`Awarded: 07/1989
`
`3.
`
`In house and external technical and management training including: Learning Tree courses on
`System Analysis and Design, User Requirements, UML, and Project Management.
`
`4. On-line courses from: Cousera, Udemy, and Zenva courses covering Machine Learning, Python,
`Data Science, and Natural Language Processing
`
`Ex.1006
`APPLE INC. / Page 5 of 5
`
`