throbber
From:
`Sent:
`To:
`Subject:
`
`Hi Gavin,
`
`asam.yn.lin@foxconn.com
`Tuesday, April 8, 2014 6:32 PM
`gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com; snwangpilot@earthlink.net
`回信:Fw: IMPORTANT!! Pilot / FoxConn samples updates- follow up 4/4
`
` We never have a product need to pass so much UL standard, This means there's no one standard is suitable for this kind of product.
` I still can provide some information for you.
`
`UL 1642: for the Lithium-ion Cells within the battery
`JS battery cell is already pass.
`UL 2054: For the battery itself
`Battery vendor told us this is based on UL1642 and add EMI,EMC test. It takes one month and 25000 USD dollars.
`Since our product will have the FCC, including the EMI, EMC test. Get this UL test in just another cost.
`UL 60950: for the battery and PC/USB-type charging function as an ITE battery/power supply.
`It seems the PC peripheral product and should connect to the AC source. JS is not IT product and not connect to the AC
`source.
`JS is not this kind of product and uER's power bank with USB output do not need this one to ship to US.
`
`Since it is being used for other functions, one or more of the following may be needed (assuming it is DC output only, and
`does not have 120VAC outputs)
`UL 1310: power supply class 2 (essentially max 100 watt charging power to other device)
`JS only uses the 15V/1A or 12V/1.5A adapter, and the charging max power is 18W. We don't know which one exceed the
`100W charging power.
`UL 1236: Engine Starter Battery charger (UL 1839 is for the jumper cables, not the actual charger/jump starter)
`We still under survey this one. But it may not apply to the Li-battery charger. Lots of the characteristic is totally different.
`UL1839 is the same, because we add the safety module into the cable. It's already totoally different to the tranditional one.
`
` If Lowes still have any concern, please ask them to list the detail test standard and item list. We are willing to follow.
` Per Calvin's experience, if there's new product and need UL to fix a standard, then it takes couple months.
`
` Thanks!
`
`Best Regards,
`--------------------------------------------------
`林逸寧/ Asam Lin
`+86-755-28129588 Ext:38586
`+86-13715044550(560-42-724550) <------------------I'm here
`short call: (511)42-208526
`mail: asam.yn.lin@foxconn.com
`attachment password: 123
`辦公地點: 深圳龍華鎮東環二路富士康科技集團
`B2 棟 6 樓北一門
`--------------------------------------------------
`
`本電子郵件及附件所載信息均為保密信息,受合同保護或依法不得洩漏。其內容僅供指定收件人按限定範圍或特殊目的使
`用。未經授權者收到此信息均無權閱讀、 使用、 複製、洩漏或散佈。若您因為誤傳而收到本郵件或者非本郵件之指定收件
`人,請即刻回覆郵件或致電 Super Notes 郵件客服熱線 560-104,並永久刪除此郵件及其附件和銷毀所有複印件。謝謝您的合
`作!
`This e-mail message together with any attachments thereto (if any) is confidential, protected under an enforceable non-disclosure
`1
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`agreement, intended only for the use of the named recipient(s) above and may contain information that is privileged, belonging to
`professional work products or exempt from disclosure under applicable laws.Any unauthorized review, use, copying, disclosure, or
`distribution of any information contained in or attached to this transmission is STRICTLY PROHIBITED and may be against the
`laws. If you have received this message in error, or are not the named recipient(s), please immediately notify the sender by e-mail or
`telephone at Super Notes support hotline 560-104 and delete this e-mail message and any attached documentation from your
`computer. Receipt by anyone other than the intended recipient(s) is not a waiver of any attorney-client or work product privilege.
`Thank you!
`
`— 回信者 asam.yn.lin@mail.foxconn.com 於 2014/4/9 上午 08:16:25 —
`gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.comTo:
`snwangpilot@earthlink.net,asam.yn.lin@mail.foxconn.com
`Cc:
`主
`旨:
`
`Fw: IMPORTANT!! Pilot / FoxConn samples updates-
`follow up 4/4
`
`2014/4/8 上午 09:24:06
`
`The below just was sent to me by Daniel. I am sure he will try and argue, but we need to understand if the UL
`they are looking at is really someting we need to consider.
`
`See below
`
`Confidentiality Notice: This message and any attachments may contain confidential and proprietary information and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended
`recipient, you must not review, transmit, print, copy, use or disseminate this e-mail or any attachments. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender
`by return e-mail and delete this message and any attachments.
`----- Forwarded Message -----
`From: "Lyalls, Robert - Robert D" <Robert.D.Lyalls@Lowes.com>
`To: Gavin McCalla <gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com>
`Sent: Monday, April 7, 2014 4:28 PM
`Subject: FW: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates- follow up 4/4
`
`FYI….I am hoping to feel good enough to discuss this tomorrow.
`
`From: Niland, Jay - Jay
`Sent: Monday, April 07, 2014 5:27 PM
`To: Chan, Horace - Horace; Chan, Edwin - Edwin; Lyalls, Robert - Robert D
`Cc: Rao, Bill - Bill H; Fang, Jade - Jade X; Yeung, Tony - Tony X; Lo, Anita - Anita P; Lau, Dixon - Dixon; Lo, Jimmy - Jimmy H;
`Wong, David - David Y; Smiley, Michael - Michael A; Matthews, Gloria - Gloria
`Subject: RE: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates- follow up 4/4
`
`Good Day All,
`
`Our Intertek representative responded back regarding potential listing requirements for the InstaBoost. Their suggestions are as
`follows:
`
`UL 1642: for the Lithium-ion Cells within the battery
`UL 2054: For the battery itself
`UL 60950: for the battery and PC/USB-type charging function as an ITE battery/power supply.
`
`Since it is being used for other functions, one or more of the following may be needed (assuming it is DC output only, and does not
`have 120VAC outputs)
`UL 1310: power supply class 2 (essentially max 100 watt charging power to other device)
`UL 1236: Engine Starter Battery charger (UL 1839 is for the jumper cables, not the actual charger/jump starter)
`
`Note that it is anticipated by Lowe’s that this entire unit will be listed and as I understand it, it is the responsibility of the manufacturer
`(Foxconn) to submit the product to a certified listing agency.
`
`2
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`
`
`Jay Niland
`Sr. Electrical Engineer
`Lowe’s Quality Assurance
`120 Talbert Road, Suite "A"
`Mooresville, NC 28117
`704-360-3065
`
`
`
`
`
`From: Chan, Horace - Horace
`Sent: Monday, April 07, 2014 5:02 AM
`To: Chan, Edwin - Edwin; Niland, Jay - Jay; Lyalls, Robert - Robert D
`Cc: Rao, Bill - Bill H; Fang, Jade - Jade X; Yeung, Tony - Tony X; Lo, Anita - Anita P; Lau, Dixon - Dixon; Lo, Jimmy - Jimmy H;
`Wong, David - David Y; Smiley, Michael - Michael A; Matthews, Gloria - Gloria
`Subject: RE: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates- follow up 4/4
`
`
`Hi Edwin,
`
`
`Per my previous communication with US QA, we need the attachment checklist completed by the vendor/factory and verified by
`LGS-QA and all technical issues (as reported by Jay) got fixed. This is part of Tony’s note point 8 (APQP) in the email chain below
`before they can move to production.
`
`
`Why Pilot told Foxconn this product does not require UL listing? How about the status of the battery packs certified to UL2054 Safety
`Std for Li Ion Battery packs? I think that you’re doing the right things to get confirmation from Jay and Daniel about the product
`requirement and product testing issue.
`
`
`Regards,
`Horace
`
`
`From: Chan, Edwin - Edwin
`Sent: Monday, April 07, 2014 4:42 PM
`To: Niland, Jay - Jay; Lyalls, Robert - Robert D
`Cc: Chan, Horace - Horace; Rao, Bill - Bill H; Fang, Jade - Jade X; Yeung, Tony - Tony X; Lo, Anita - Anita P; Lau, Dixon - Dixon;
`Lo, Jimmy - Jimmy H; Wong, David - David Y; Smiley, Michael - Michael A
`Subject: FW: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates- follow up 4/4
`
`
`Hi Jay and Daniel,
`
`
`Further to the visit report from Tony, today we have a phone discussion with Foxconn team and learn the following…..
`
`
`· They are preparing 3 golden samples and planning to ship them out by Tuesday 4/8 for your testing.
`· If the test runs well for those 3 samples, Lowe’s US will provide “Green light” to start mass production.
`· This golden sample will have the latest software design but your recommendation on 3/31 test update such as thermal
`shutdown/protective circuit will not be implemented
`· Mass production timeline – as they will ship samples tomorrow, they expect to hear from Lowe’s in one week. Assuming
`the test result is positive, they target to start their mass production by week of April 22. (Note: During our discussion today,
`we have reminded Foxconn that things like product test, transit and packaging design and artwork must be completed and
`approved before shipment)
`· Pilot (Gavin) told Foxconn this product does not require UL listing
`
`
`
`As we realized that you had a meeting with Pilot (Gavin) last week, can you please confirm us the above comments from Foxconn are
`valid? Or if you have an agreed specification with Pilot, please kindly share with us.
`
`
`Finally, in order to make sure we are on the same page at this critical moment, we propose to have a conference call with you to
`review the status. Please advise if you are available to talk on April 7 9pm US/April 8 9am HK or April 8 10:30am US/April 9
`10:30pm HK?
`
`
`Thanks,
`
`3
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`Edwin
`
`
`
`
`From: Yeung, Tony - Tony X
`Sent: Monday, April 07, 2014 1:12 AM
`To: hzlh-ccc-qe01@foxconn.com
`Cc: Chan, Horace - Horace; Lau, Dixon - Dixon; Lo, Jimmy - Jimmy H; Fang, Jade - Jade X; Rao, Bill - Bill H;
`snwangpilot@earthlink.net; Chan, Edwin - Edwin; lily.ll.bao@foxconn.com; ian.chang@uer.com.tw;
`gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com; Niland, Jay - Jay; Wong, David - David Y; asam.yn.lin@foxconn.com;
`mandy.j.jiang@foxconn.com; hzlh-ccc-epm01@foxconn.com; gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com; Lyalls, Robert - Robert D; Smiley,
`Michael - Michael A; roy.cc.yen@foxconn.com
`Subject: RE: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates- follow up 4/4
`
`
`All,
`Below highlighted in blue are the updates during 4/4 visit.
`
`
`1),Lowe’s brand Logo is not clearly seen on 3/19 sample, compared the photo taken last time which is provided to IMM for check on
`2/28,
`it should be obvious different, factory should further check and investigate it.
`
`
`Tony: Lowe’s brand Logo is improved as per action mentioned at previous Email, refer to below photo:
`
`
`
` 4/4 new sample photo provided by Foxconn QA
`
`
`2),Push button of some units still were not recessed because of some wrong old push button used on product.
`
`
`
`Pushbutton not recessed New parts Old parts
`
`
`Tony: 50 Samples used old material is reworked, old material is purged, checking requirement for “push button
`not recessed” is
`required to write on factory’s inspection instruction.
`
`
`3), Safety device on cable – the heat sink that has been added to dissipate the heat.
` However no any thermal pad or thermal grease applied between sink and MOSFETS.
`4), Safety device on cable – were to adjust the pass through wires on the positive conductor,
`
`4
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

` factory should pay attention to soldering joint quality.
`
`
`
`5),After final product test which discharged and under 9v output shutdown at factory,
`the unit can’t be directly activated by pressing pushbutton switch unless end user charged it again by adapter.
`Factory test engineer called it as “product locked”, vendor should determine if they will unlock the unit after final test.
`Tony: The similar problem as below Jay mentioned on 3/31 IB test report, Factory will update the software to
`fix these problem,
`Due new PCBA with new software was not available on 4/4 in factory, no verification done.
`
`
`
`
`
`6), Factory shall submit the pilot run report with root cause analysis and corrective action owner, due date for each defectives for
`review,
`cosmetic defect such as gap issue, USB Connector not seated well, edge painting dye..should be included.
`Tony:
`For USB Connector not seated well, edge painting dye’s action is taken,
`For 10A over discharge protection NG, factory will discuss new specification with >12A shut off.
`output Voltage is supposed to change to 9 to 12.6v.
`For LED fail during drop test, action 2 to increase supporting Pin on top cover to fix the PCBA is determined
`and made on new top cover,
`action 1 is cancelled, because factory informed they has checked the test height criteria with Jay to lower it to
`1mm.
`factory shall verify the effectiveness by drop test as new top cover available.
`
`
`1.Per one side solder change
` to two sides solder.—3/28
`2.Top cover increase the pin
` to fix the PCBA—3/24
`
`
`7),For test plan, As per reviewed, factory shall further review and determine PCBA level, Safety cable module, battery test plan,
`Current factory have no fixture/equipment or plan to perform this level test even if no IQC sampling test for these parts.
`Factory shall make plan to monitor these supplier’s product quality, Shall submit complete test plan before next pilot run, end of
`march, Zenglin/Asam Lin
`Tony: Reviewed the test plan for end product, a few test item still need to final determine and confirm,
`factory shall finalize the all test plan and submit with English rev ASAP!
`
`8),APQP(advanced product quality planning) from QMS requirement, this pilot run showed it is not well planning and implemented,
`factory shall establish their APQP process, FMEA Control plan, MSA, SPC(CPK) shall be ready and well implemented for jump
`starter product.
`Tony: factory set up control plan, MSA, CPK, FMEA, in addition, however,
`Current FMEA is not specific for problem identification and analysis and problem prevention, it shall be
`updated.
`factory also shall establish their APQP procedure and DFMEA.
`
`5
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`
`
`Thanks&Best Regard!
`Tony Yeung
`
`
`Sr. Production Engineer
`LG Sourcing Inc.
`(a wholly owned subsidiary of Lowe’s Companies. Inc.)
`Mobile:+86-13430980585
`Website:www.lowes.com
`
`
`From: hzlh-ccc-qe01@foxconn.com [mailto:hzlh-ccc-qe01@foxconn.com]
`Sent: Friday, March 21, 2014 4:24 PM
`To: Yeung, Tony - Tony X
`Cc: Chan, Horace - Horace; Lau, Dixon - Dixon; Lo, Jimmy - Jimmy H; Fang, Jade - Jade X; Rao, Bill - Bill H;
`snwangpilot@earthlink.net; Chan, Edwin - Edwin; hzlh-ccc-qe01@foxconn.com; lily.ll.bao@foxconn.com; ian.chang@uer.com.tw;
`gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com; Niland, Jay - Jay; Wong, David - David Y; asam.yn.lin@foxconn.com;
`mandy.j.jiang@foxconn.com; hzlh-ccc-epm01@foxconn.com; gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com; Lyalls, Robert - Robert D; Smiley,
`Michael - Michael A; roy.cc.yen@foxconn.com
`Subject: 轉呈:轉呈:RE: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates
`
`
`Hi Tony,
` Please kindly find the attached for findings action plan.
`Please let me know if there is any further information ,
`thank you !
`
`Best regards
`------------------------------------------------------------------------
`Lin Zeng 曾林
`FOXCONN-SHZBG-CCC-MEBU-DQE
`Tel:86+755+28129588+60154
`Mobile:86+13590191481
`E-mail:hzlh-ccc-qe01@mail.foxconn.com
`Address: 深圳龍華鎮東環二路富士康科技集團 B2 棟 6 樓
`
`------------------------------------------------------------------------
`Tony.X.Yeung@lowes.com To: asam.yn.lin@mail.foxconn.com,hzlh-ccc-jiangjuan@mail.foxconn.com,hzlh-ccc-
`epm01@mail.foxconn.com,gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com,Robert.D.Lyalls@lowes.com,Michael.A.Smiley@lowes.com
`Horace.Chan@lowes.com,dixon.lau@lowes.com,jimmy.lo@lowes.com,Jade.X.Fang@lowes.com,Bill.H.Rao@lowes.com,snwangpilot@earthlink
`Cc:
`ccc-qe01@mail.foxconn.com,hzlh-ccc-
`bao.ll@mail.foxconn.com,ian.chang@uer.com.tw,gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com,Jay.T.Niland@lowes.com,thomas.tan@uer.com.tw,coco.chu@uer.com.tw,david.wong@lowes.com
`
`
`
`2014/3/20 上午 08:31:08
`
`主
`旨:
`
`RE: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates
`
`Hi Asam/Mandy/Zenglin:
`Below is a detail sample check status except some problem David mentioned, pls take an action to improve for all quality problem
`reported.
`
`
`1),Lowe’s brand Logo is not clearly seen on 3/19 sample, compared the photo taken last time which is provided to IMM for check on
`2/28,
`it should be obvious different, factory should further check and investigate it.
`
`6
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
` 3/19 sample 2/28 sample checked by IMM
`
`
`2),Push button of some units still were not recessed because of some wrong old push button used on product.
`
`Pushbutton not recessed New parts Old parts
`
`
`3), Safety device on cable – the heat sink that has been added to dissipate the heat.
`· However no any thermal pad or thermal grease applied between sink and MOSFETS.
`
`
`
`
`4), Safety device on cable – were to adjust the pass through wires on the positive conductor,
` factory should pay attention to soldering joint quality.
`
`7
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`5),After final product test which discharged and under 9v output shutdown at factory,
`the unit can’t be directly activated by pressing pushbutton switch unless end user charged it again by adapter.
`Factory test engineer called it as “product locked”, vendor should determine if they will unlock the unit after final test.
`
`6), Factory shall submit the pilot run report with root cause analysis and corrective action owner, due date for each defectives for
`review,
`cosmetic defect such as gap issue, USB Connector not seated well, edge painting dye..should be included.
`
`7),For test plan, As per reviewed, factory shall further review and determine PCBA level, Safety cable module, battery test plan,
`Current factory have no fixture/equipment or plan to perform this level test even if no IQC sampling test for these parts.
`Factory shall make plan to monitor these supplier’s product quality, Shall submit complete test plan before next pilot run, end of
`march, Zenglin/Asam Lin
`
`8),APQP(advanced product quality planning) from QMS requirement, this pilot run showed it is not well planning and implemented,
`factory shall establish their APQP process, FMEA Control plan, MSA, SPC(CPK) shall be ready and well implemented for jump
`starter product.
`
`Others function or feature is checked by take a sample to test or inspection:
`a),Replace regular screws with one way screws so that the unit cannot be unscrewed or unsnapped open.

`Changed screw from cross screw to inner hexagon screw

`b),Light should have 2 cycles – solid beam and SOS flash.
`Short press-Activated/deactivated USB and 12 Auxiliary DC output, Indicator off/on
`Long press- Solid beam
`Then Long press- SOS flash
`Then Long press-Shut down all
`
`c),Indicator lights (blue) should remain on and decrease as battery status changes.
` Used a unit(not full charge) to discharge, the blue indicator light start from 2 blue light to 1 blue light then
`all off
`d),Indicator lights should remain on and flash/flash as unit is charged.
` Used the adapter to charge, Indicator lights remain on and flash. 12 DC changer was not checked due to no
`proper connector to connect.
`e),12V-10Amp output confirm 9V shutdown and 10amp override control
` 12V-10Amp output 9V shutdown and 10.5amp override control by fixture test
`
`Thanks&Best Regard!
`Tony Yeung
`
`Sr. Production Engineer
`LG Sourcing Inc.
`(a wholly owned subsidiary of Lowe’s Companies. Inc.)
`Mobile:+86-13430980585
`Website:www.lowes.com
`
`From: Wong, David - David Y
`Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2014 7:29 PM
`To: asam.yn.lin@foxconn.com; mandy.j.jiang@foxconn.com; hzlh-ccc-epm01@foxconn.com; gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com;
`
`8
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`Lyalls, Robert - Robert D; Smiley, Michael - Michael A
`Cc: Chan, Horace - Horace; Lau, Dixon - Dixon; Lo, Jimmy - Jimmy H; Fang, Jade - Jade X; Rao, Bill - Bill H;
`snwangpilot@earthlink.net; Chan, Edwin - Edwin; Yeung, Tony - Tony X; hzlh-ccc-qe01@foxconn.com; lily.ll.bao@foxconn.com;
`ian.chang@uer.com.tw; gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com; Niland, Jay - Jay; thomas.tan@uer.com.tw; coco.chu@uer.com.tw
`Subject: RE: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates
`
`Hi Asam/Mandy/Lynn,
`We were glad to visit FoxConn today as we witnessed surprises. We went through them in details already so please work on them and
`update us with improvement plan asap.
`
`Today’s findings from agenda set from last week:

`Lab testing (abnormal)
`
`o David (3/19): LGS only see testers but no test data or testing were performed on any jump starter samples.

`Application testing (with a van)
`
`o David (3/19): Did not happen as car was out. WHY?

`LGS QA/PE will review detail test, test fixture, test criteria
`
`o David (3/19) LGS Production Engineer Tony Yeung will update more on this.

`Pilot run
`
`o David (3/19) Yes we saw it but wrong part were used without realize until we find out on the line. No data were record.
`o David (3/19) Fail of drop test. LED not working after 5th drop.
`
`l
`Others questions:
`Which UL standard?
`
`To Daniel and Gavin:
`When 50 pcs samples are ready on 3/20. Can the 20pcs directly ship directly to Jay @ Lowe’s QA to begin testing ASAP? The rest
`will goes to Gavin? Please confirm.
`
`Thank you and Best Regards,
`David Wong
`LGS Hong Kong Limited.
`Tel: +852 3423 6305
`
`From: Wong, David - David Y
`Sent: Tuesday, March 18, 2014 2:39 PM
`To: asam.yn.lin@foxconn.com; 'mandy.j.jiang@foxconn.com'
`Cc: Chan, Horace - Horace; Lau, Dixon - Dixon; Lo, Jimmy - Jimmy H; Fang, Jade - Jade X; Rao, Bill - Bill H;
`snwangpilot@earthlink.net; Chan, Edwin - Edwin; Yeung, Tony - Tony X; hzlh-ccc-qe01@foxconn.com; lily.ll.bao@foxconn.com;
`Smiley, Michael - Michael A; hzlh-ccc-epm01@foxconn.com; ian.chang@uer.com.tw; gavin.mccalla@innovxgroup.com; Niland, Jay
`- Jay; thomas.tan@uer.com.tw; coco.chu@uer.com.tw; Lyalls, Robert - Robert D
`Subject: RE: Pilot / FoxConn samples updates
`
`Hi Asam:
`Good to talk to you and understood our expectation.
`
`Our agenda for tomorrow:

`Lab testing (abnormal)

`Application testing (with a van)

`LGS QA/PE will review detail test, test fixture, test criteria

`Pilot run
`
`Please arrange van to pick us from tmorrow 3/18, 9:45am at Longhua 清湖 MTR Station.
`9
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

`

`Our contact numbers for your driver:

`Dixon: 13602258199

`David: 13602251180
`
`Thank you and Best Regards,
`David Wong
`LGS Hong Kong Limited.
`Tel: +852 3423 6305
`
`mail from ip-->10.151.88.92
`mail from pc-->LH-MEPC039
`Version: Super Notes 1.5.1.6B
`
`mail from ip-->10.151.134.98
`mail from pc-->LH-MEPC050
`Version: Super Notes 1.6.4.5B
`(See attached file: 0319 Findings Action Plan.pdf)
`NOTICE: All information in and attached to the e-mails below may be proprietary, confidential, privileged and
`otherwise protected from improper or erroneous disclosure. If you are not the sender's intended recipient, you
`are not authorized to intercept, read, print, retain, copy, forward, or disseminate this message. If you have
`erroneously received this communication, please notify the sender immediately by phone (704-758-1000) or by
`e-mail and destroy all copies of this message electronic, paper, or otherwise.
`
`By transmitting documents via this email: Users, Customers, Suppliers and Vendors collectively
`acknowledge and agree the transmittal of information via email is voluntary, is offered as a convenience,
`and is not a secured method of communication; Not to transmit any payment information E.G. credit
`card, debit card, checking account, wire transfer information, passwords, or sensitive and personal
`information E.G. Driver's license, DOB, social security, or any other information the user wishes to
`remain confidential; To transmit only non-confidential information such as plans, pictures and drawings
`and to assume all risk and liability for and indemnify Lowe's from any claims, losses or damages that
`may arise from the transmittal of documents or including non-confidential information in the body of an
`email transmittal. Thank you.
`
`mail from ip-->10.151.88.92
`mail from pc-->LH-MEPC039
`Version: Super Notes 1.6.4.5B
`
`10
`
`Pilot, Inc., Ex. 2004
`The NOCO Company, Inc. v. Pilot, Inc.
`IPR2023-00167
`
`

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket