Comparison of Districts Within the First Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`ME
`701
`809
`598
`
`7.4
`-17.2
`3
`0.0
`234
`136
`
`MA
`3,112
`3,184
`4,448
`
`-7.2
`-15.8
`13
`26.4
`239
`185
`
`NH
`938
`654
`4,006
`
`-30.8
`14.1
`3
`5.5
`313
`243
`
`RI
`683
`714
`976
`
`-7.2
`-9.8
`3
`0.0
`228
`164
`
`PR
`2,022
`2,232
`3,501
`
`0.7
`-41.9
`7
`26.3
`289
`100
`
`68
`
`31
`
`50
`
`52
`
`132
`
`29
`199
`224
`270
`15
`
`23
`342
`239
`245
`12
`
`20
`1,335
`279
`218
`14
`
`12
`325
`228
`238
`4
`
`56
`500
`290
`319
`9
`
`23.0
`14.7
`13.8
`21.8
`13.2
` 9.4 10.0 11.5 11.4 18.7
`
`-
`
`19
`5.2
`
`1.3
`
`57.1
`
`30.4
`
`34.5
`
`576
`16.8
`
`1.6
`
`74.2
`
`46.5
`
`-
`
`1,498
`39.9
`
`1.2
`
`47.6
`
`35.4
`
`-
`
`102
`14.4
`
`1.5
`
`42.8
`
`47.7
`
`-
`
`308
`21.9
`
`1.8
`
`54.6
`
`33.7
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 1 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Comparison of Districts Within the Second Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`CT
`2,302
`2,594
`2,686
`
`-10.2
`-16.3
`8
`15.9
`288
`217
`
`NY,S
`NY,E
`NY,N
`8,458 13,298
`2,010
`8,949 13,848
`2,306
`2,534 12,232 18,672
`
`-16.0
`-8.7
`5
`12.0
`402
`306
`
`0.2
`-3.9
`15
`38.6
`564
`495
`
`-4.1
`6.2
`28
`51.2
`475
`410
`
`NY,W
`2,413
`3,243
`3,966
`
`-39.3
`-16.1
`4
`0.0
`603
`417
`
`VT
`492
`526
`511
`
`-4.5
`-11.5
`2
`0.0
`246
`124
`
`39
`
`66
`
`48
`
`35
`
`86
`
`71
`
`32
`336
`291
`324
`12
`
`31
`507
`348
`461
`14
`
`21
`815
`550
`597
`10
`
`30
`667
`558
`495
`17
`
`101
`992
`445
`811
`11
`
`51
`256
`220
`263
`12
`
`13.1
`19.6
` 8.9 11.4
`
`28.3
` 6.5
`
`13.8
`19.6
` 5.7 15.1
`
`14.1
` 6.6
`
` 40.3 48.7 52.5 44.4
`
`158
`8.2
`
`265
`14.4
`
`2,018
`22.8
`
`3,617
`26.3
`
`-
`
`478
`15.2
`
`1.6
`
`75.1
`
`42.9
`
`1.1
`
`1.4
`
`1.6
`
`1.1
`
`33.8
`
`124.0
`
`68.6
`
`109.3
`
`18.2
`
`30.7
`
`48.3
`
`48.3
`
`-
`
`43
`15.5
`
`1.2
`
`37.6
`
`40.4
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 2 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Comparison of Districts Within the Third Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`NJ
`DE
`1,921 14,268
`2,250 10,041
`2,246 64,852
`
`PA,E
`6,498
`6,992
`9,429
`
`-13.3
`-23.8
`22
`41.9
`295
`268
`
`PA,M PA,W
`2,741
`3,707
`2,905
`3,594
`3,826
`3,887
`
`-11.8
`-8.7
`6
`10.9
`457
`351
`
`0.7
`14.4
`10
`0.0
`371
`298
`
`VI
`285
`471
`1,430
`
`-48.7
`-15.9
`2
`0.0
`143
`93
`
`-49.3
`8.6
`17
`57.0
`839
`783
`
`44
`
`18
`
`85
`
`64
`
`49
`
`12
`3,815
`659
`591
`7
`
`9
`429
`280
`318
`7
`
`21
`638
`430
`484
`27
`
`9
`389
`340
`359
`19
`
`2
`715
`-
`236
`10
`
`-5.1
`2.9
`4
`0.0
`480
`455
`
`21
`
`4
`562
`873
`563
`20
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`15.2
` 8.1
`
`12.5
` 7.6
`
`22.8
`20.4
` 6.7 11.8
`
`19.7
` 6.8
`
`20.0
` 6.2
`
` 36.0 50.2 24.3 42.9 42.9
`
`278
`13.6
`
`23,459
`37.1
`
`2,046
`25.2
`
`1.2
`
`1.1
`
`45.2
`
`130.6
`
`39.1
`
`45.1
`
`1.2
`
`53.3
`
`44.2
`
`261
`10.1
`
`1.3
`
`48.9
`
`34.6
`
`-
`
`179
`36.8
`
`121
`4.8
`
`1.6
`
`1.8
`
`52.1
`
`111.8
`
`42.0
`
`46.3
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 3 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Comparison of Districts Within the Fourth Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`MD
`4,110
`4,846
`5,570
`
`-3.7
`-13.5
`10
`12.0
`411
`343
`
`NC,E
`2,528
`2,960
`3,382
`
`-12.3
`-5.5
`4
`0.0
`632
`393
`
`NC,M NC,W
`1,573
`1,868
`1,809
`2,236
`1,512
`1,612
`
`-13.1
`-15.4
`4
`0.0
`393
`237
`
`-10.9
`-15.6
`5
`0.0
`374
`227
`
`SC
`5,362
`4,496
`7,082
`
`6.6
`14.1
`10
`0.0
`536
`431
`
`VA,E
`4,145
`4,463
`3,754
`
`-7.6
`-13.2
`11
`22.8
`377
`271
`
`VA,W WV,N WV,S
`1,389
`1,183
`1,072
`1,673
`1,380
`1,279
`1,451
`984
`2,275
`
`-21.3
`-14.7
`4
`10.0
`347
`274
`
`-6.9
`-10.6
`3
`0.0
`394
`215
`
`-17.6
`-90.3
`5
`0.0
`214
`121
`
`53
`
`164
`
`90
`
`94
`
`67
`
`68
`
`46
`
`122
`
`71
`
`15
`557
`379
`485
`12
`
`76
`846
`562
`740
`42
`
`67
`378
`319
`452
`21
`
`52
`322
`339
`447
`12
`
`39
`708
`439
`450
`11
`
`38
`341
`354
`406
`19
`
`28
`363
`288
`418
`25
`
`57
`328
`345
`460
`14
`
`23
`455
`207
`256
`10
`
`13.5
`9.3
`15.4
`19.0
` 9.4 11.6 10.8 10.2
`
`16.3
` 9.7
`
`8.4
`12.4
`13.1
`8.6
` 6.9 13.1 11.7 10.1
`
` 43.3
`
`954
`22.1
`
`1.4
`
`58.4
`
`38.4
`
`-
`
`398
`18.6
`
`1.4
`
`43.8
`
`35.0
`
`-
`
`31.1 35.0 18.1 32.4
`
`72
`7.5
`
`1.3
`
`41.3
`
`35.0
`
`51
`5.1
`
`1.3
`
`27.8
`
`36.7
`
`588
`10.0
`
`1.6
`
`51.6
`
`44.0
`
`254
`9.9
`
`1.2
`
`65.1
`
`47.9
`
`56
`5.4
`
`1.2
`
`36.8
`
`34.3
`
`-
`
`37
`7.6
`
`1.7
`
`67.0
`
`49.9
`
`-
`
`1,104
`57.5
`
`1.2
`
`38.6
`
`5.8
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 4 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Comparison of Districts Within the Fifth Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`LA,E
`3,089
`7,095
`20,784
`
`LA,M LA,W MS,N
`989
`4,900
`823
`1,136
`3,605
`916
`1,303
`4,993
`828
`
`TX,N
`MS,S
`7,386
`1,866
`2,026 13,080
`2,056
`6,836
`
`TX,W
`TX,S
`TX,E
`4,407 14,753 12,792
`3,862 15,779 11,469
`6,136 14,657 10,933
`
`15.2
`-73.8
`12
`5.1
`257
`223
`
`29
`
`5
`1,732
`264
`591
`7
`
`-3.0
`-9.9
`3
`0.0
`330
`282
`
`28
`
`20
`434
`307
`379
`31
`
`52.9
`133.2
`7
`10.1
`700
`643
`
`-7.4
`-11.8
`3
`7.9
`274
`208
`
`-8.7
`-18.7
`6
`0.0
`311
`227
`
`45
`
`55
`
`66
`
`-9.8
`2.5
`12
`0.0
`616
`452
`
`128
`
`12
`713
`808
`515
`12
`
`12
`276
`277
`305
`19
`
`18
`343
`309
`338
`28
`
`36
`570
`576
`1,090
`18
`
`3.2
`-9.7
`8
`0.0
`551
`382
`
`168
`
`1
`767
`693
`483
`16
`
`-8.5
`4.3
`19
`5.9
`776
`314
`
`373
`
`90
`771
`592
`830
`23
`
`-1.3
`10.2
`13
`12.0
`984
`357
`
`525
`
`102
`841
`845
`882
`27
`
`12.6
`22.3
` 69.3 16.1
`
`9.8
`11.7
`11.4
`12.6
` 8.0 11.3 12.0 65.0
`
`14.7
` 8.8
`
`5.0
` 8.9
`
`6.0
` 8.4
`
` 31.7 36.9 31.9
`
`-
`
`29.8 25.1 24.5 29.4 28.3
`
`16,324
`80.6
`
`1.3
`
`49.5
`
`45.7
`
`61
`5.7
`
`1.2
`
`31.7
`
`34.5
`
`489
`10.7
`
`1.3
`
`36.3
`
`29.8
`
`27
`4.4
`
`1.6
`
`29.4
`
`24.5
`
`84
`5.5
`
`1.2
`
`35.4
`
`35.7
`
`812
`17.5
`
`1.3
`
`51.9
`
`46.3
`
`258
`8.2
`
`2.1
`
`46.4
`
`41.9
`
`332
`6.2
`
`1.1
`
`41.6
`
`32.1
`
`240
`5.8
`
`1.1
`
`52.1
`
`47.4
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 5 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Comparison of Districts Within the Sixth Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`TN,M TN,W
`1,744
`1,889
`1,724
`1,965
`1,986
`2,775
`
`KY,E
`1,706
`1,910
`2,114
`
`-7.6
`-25.6
`5.5
`0.0
`310
`180
`
`KY,W
`1,623
`1,862
`1,885
`
`-9.2
`-11.9
`4.5
`0.0
`361
`263
`
`MI,E
`3,991
`4,331
`5,111
`
`-3.7
`-26.1
`15
`19.5
`266
`201
`
`OH,S
`MI,W OH,N
`6,491
`1,819
`3,969
`3,302
`1,991
`4,545
`1,331
`6,940 21,234
`
`-13.1
`-11.6
`4
`5.5
`455
`358
`
`-15.0
`-8.1
`11
`33.1
`361
`219
`
`-30.1
`95.5
`8
`1.4
`811
`724
`
`TN,E
`1,798
`2,032
`2,122
`
`-0.2
`-14.3
`5
`12.0
`360
`196
`
`7.9
`-50.1
`4
`0.0
`436
`276
`
`0.9
`-7.2
`5
`0.0
`378
`215
`
`99
`
`64
`555
`354
`393
`27
`
`92
`
`75
`
`44
`
`65
`
`88
`
`65
`
`145
`
`117
`
`38
`384
`295
`347
`15
`
`23
`419
`340
`414
`10
`
`21
`341
`260
`289
`10
`
`32
`333
`406
`498
`17
`
`54
`631
`327
`413
`12
`
`23
`2,654
`650
`413
`29
`
`18
`424
`413
`406
`10
`
`43
`497
`449
`431
`20
`
`15.6
`11.9
` 12.0 11.0
`
`18.0
` 9.5
`
`8.3
` 7.8
`
`14.7
`22.7
`16.1
`13.0
`12.1
` 9.8 12.0 12.6 11.2 10.5
`
`-
`
`52.4 46.8 45.3 36.2 48.0 33.0 36.6 24.3
`
`366
`28.3
`
`1.5
`
`47.8
`
`25.9
`
`158
`11.7
`
`1.4
`
`47.9
`
`43.3
`
`433
`11.6
`
`1.3
`
`77.5
`
`54.4
`
`50
`4.5
`
`2,354
`41.4
`
`3,383
`16.8
`
`1.3
`
`49.0
`
`50.0
`
`1.5
`
`51.1
`
`41.8
`
`1.2
`
`58.3
`
`60.3
`
`91
`8.2
`
`1.6
`
`41.2
`
`36.5
`
`87
`6.8
`
`1.3
`
`65.2
`
`53.2
`
`181
`12.4
`
`1.4
`
`51.9
`
`53.8
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 6 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Comparison of Districts Within the Seventh Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`IL,N
`8,122
`8,773
`12,044
`
`-11.7
`-27.7
`22
`12.0
`369
`332
`
`IL,C
`1,673
`1,922
`2,066
`
`-12.3
`-17.4
`4
`0.0
`418
`311
`
`IL,S
`2,819
`1,790
`3,409
`
`40.6
`56.0
`4
`0.0
`705
`611
`
`IN,S
`IN,N
`4,115
`2,263
`4,099
`2,726
`2,426 11,835
`
`WI,E WI,W
`1,974
`1,021
`2,113
`1,233
`2,233
`1,227
`
`-7.6
`-12.6
`5
`12.0
`453
`373
`
`-24.7
`-25.7
`5
`0.0
`823
`733
`
`-14.5
`-16.7
`5
`12.0
`395
`301
`
`-16.3
`-7.9
`2
`0.0
`511
`392
`
`25
`
`54
`
`59
`
`61
`
`86
`
`66
`
`77
`
`13
`547
`366
`399
`8
`
`54
`517
`317
`481
`27
`
`35
`852
`529
`448
`22
`
`19
`485
`397
`545
`20
`
`4
`2,367
`689
`820
`15
`
`28
`447
`354
`423
`6
`
`42
`614
`457
`617
`19
`
`16.5
`14.7
`14.5
`17.5
`22.9
` 7.2 11.4 11.0 12.5 10.1
`
`9.4
`15.2
` 9.8 10.4
`
` 48.9 39.2 39.7 39.4 39.9 47.7 24.1
`
`2,126
`21.7
`
`1.4
`
`103.4
`
`70.8
`
`168
`10.6
`
`1.1
`
`27.6
`
`39.9
`
`241
`8.0
`
`1.2
`
`44.7
`
`30.9
`
`154
`8.1
`
`4,714
`42.3
`
`1.2
`
`38.1
`
`39.5
`
`1.4
`
`36.5
`
`29.1
`
`96
`6.0
`
`1.4
`
`31.2
`
`25.6
`
`125
`13.3
`
`1.2
`
`27.1
`
`28.3
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 7 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Comparison of Districts Within the Eighth Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`MN MO,E MO,W
`8,943
`3,112
`2,977
`4,101
`3,623
`3,381
`8,048
`3,094
`2,923
`
`NE
`1,531
`1,489
`1,383
`
`AR,W
`1,101
`1,159
`1,140
`
`-14.7
`-12.0
`3
`7.6
`367
`280
`
`IA,N
`979
`1,032
`676
`
`-5.2
`-16.8
`2
`0.0
`490
`207
`
`IA,S
`1,159
`1,198
`900
`
`-4.8
`-11.5
`3
`0.0
`386
`176
`
`146.8
`64.0
`7
`11.5
`1,278
`1,170
`
`-16.5
`-32.1
`8
`0.0
`389
`207
`
`70
`
`162
`
`138
`
`34
`
`123
`
`17
`380
`315
`386
`12
`
`121
`338
`410
`516
`67
`
`73
`300
`367
`399
`46
`
`73
`1,150
`391
`586
`11
`
`59
`387
`369
`453
`22
`
`ND
`752
`741
`954
`
`-8.7
`-14.4
`2
`0.0
`376
`102
`
`197
`
`78
`477
`411
`371
`26
`
`SD
`1,320
`1,374
`1,104
`
`-1.1
`-3.6
`3
`8.9
`440
`122
`
`188
`
`130
`368
`433
`458
`43
`
`-6.5
`-7.9
`6
`0.0
`496
`321
`
`114
`
`61
`487
`473
`564
`22
`
`1.5
`0.1
`3
`0.0
`510
`267
`
`179
`
`64
`461
`483
`496
`17
`
`AR,E
`2,463
`2,464
`3,034
`
`-4.6
`0.7
`5
`0.0
`493
`364
`
`103
`
`26
`607
`440
`493
`19
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`10.4
`26.3
` 12.4 11.6
`
`11.3
`10.9
` 8.0 11.0
`
`15.1
`15.1
` 7.4 10.8
`
`20.0
` 7.3
`
`11.5
`16.5
`12.6
` 5.1 12.9 11.6
`
` 34.5
`
`73
`4.2
`
`1.4
`
`43.2
`
`52.2
`
`-
`
`23
`3.2
`
`1.3
`
`48.2
`
`46.9
`
`-
`
`16
`4.5
`
`1.2
`
`42.8
`
`31.5
`
`-
`
` 39.6 34.3 27.3 31.5
`
`28
`6.0
`
`1.3
`
`39.2
`
`16.2
`
`275
`3.6
`
`1.3
`
`58.6
`
`47.2
`
`108
`6.6
`
`1.2
`
`31.0
`
`26.6
`
`118
`8.8
`
`1.5
`
`49.8
`
`32.5
`
`37
`6.2
`
`1.3
`
`35.8
`
`18.8
`
`-
`
`54
`18.3
`
`1.7
`
`36.9
`
`29.8
`
`-
`
`62
`14.6
`
`1.2
`
`42.5
`
`27.0
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 8 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`OR WA,E WA,W
`2,895
`1,905
`3,131
`3,014
`1,936
`3,493
`3,481
`1,270
`2,928
`
`Comparison of Districts Within the Ninth Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`AK
`552
`543
`807
`
`-7.4
`-5.6
`3
`0.0
`184
`134
`
`CA,N
`AZ
`9,837
`9,748
`9,079 11,511
`6,258 12,453
`
`CA,C
`CA,E
`4,581 15,114
`4,671 16,545
`7,828 13,198
`
`-0.9
`-16.8
`13
`0.0
`750
`240
`
`-11.0
`15.3
`14
`42.5
`703
`626
`
`-8.2
`-16.1
`6
`20.0
`764
`650
`
`-14.1
`-8.7
`28
`83.8
`540
`480
`
`CA,S
`7,348
`7,870
`5,936
`
`-11.0
`-6.8
`13
`54.7
`565
`158
`
`HI
`782
`886
`882
`
`-19.1
`-28.3
`4
`0.0
`196
`133
`
`ID
`939
`971
`1,117
`
`-7.3
`-5.2
`2
`10.4
`470
`259
`
`Filings
`
`49
`
`388
`
`33
`
`67
`
`35
`
`282
`
`36
`
`143
`
`1
`269
`202
`181
`9
`
`122
`481
`491
`698
`10
`
`44
`890
`699
`822
`9
`
`47
`1,305
`674
`779
`14
`
`25
`471
`563
`591
`10
`
`125
`457
`503
`605
`10
`
`27
`221
`193
`222
`9
`
`68
`559
`448
`486
`21
`
`MT
`1,279
`1,276
`1,085
`
`-2.0
`9.2
`3
`0.0
`426
`201
`
`129
`
`96
`362
`402
`425
`56
`
`NV
`3,222
`3,775
`4,505
`
`-12.2
`-33.2
`7
`17.4
`460
`374
`
`-10.3
`-5.6
`6
`6.1
`483
`314
`
`52
`
`96
`
`35
`644
`424
`539
`12
`
`73
`580
`422
`502
`9
`
`GU
`95
`116
`367
`
`-22.1
`-37.5
`1
`0.0
`95
`26
`
`NMI
`56
`51
`104
`
`-17.6
`-9.7
`1
`0.0
`56
`27
`
`-9.5
`-17.1
`7
`30.0
`447
`380
`
`33
`
`30
`
`23
`
`34
`418
`401
`499
`14
`
`39
`367
`-
`116
`10
`
`6
`104
`-
`51
`10
`
`-5.4
`2.6
`4
`8.9
`476
`235
`
`82
`
`159
`318
`253
`484
`14
`
`18.4
` 12.3
`
`28.4
`16.8
`4.2
` 9.2 10.1 10.4
`
`20.2
` 4.8
`
`7.8
` 7.7
`
`9.0
`11.1
`12.6
` 9.9 12.8 11.6
`
`18.1
`20.4
` 8.6 13.1
`
`16.8
` 8.9
`
`15.3
`14.8
` 7.9 10.0
`
`10.0
` 8.8
`
`35.3
`
`-
`
`-
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`Other
`
`-
`
`37.4 34.7
`
`-
`
`23.5 46.9
`
`62
`13.6
`
`1.2
`
`68.9
`
`32.4
`
`149
`5.1
`
`1.1
`
`44.4
`
`35.0
`
`971
`8.6
`
`1,008
`17.3
`
`1.4
`
`68.0
`
`48.0
`
`1.4
`
`70.9
`
`49.4
`
`911
`9.2
`
`1.4
`
`62.9
`
`57.3
`
`535
`23.2
`
`1.2
`
`61.3
`
`46.2
`
`-
`
`58
`11.6
`
`1.3
`
`54.0
`
`46.5
`
`-
`
`21.2 51.4 44.3
`
`95
`13.7
`
`1.1
`
`55.9
`
`36.0
`
`77
`11.3
`
`1.2
`
`40.5
`
`30.2
`
`606
`17.7
`
`1.2
`
`49.6
`
`34.2
`
`272
`10.6
`
`1.4
`
`33.9
`
`17.9
`
`-
`
`52
`7.0
`
`1.3
`
`60.2
`
`36.3
`
`141
`6.2
`
`227
`77.5
`
`17
`30.9
`
`1.3
`
`1.3
`
`1.2
`
`56.4
`
`351.4
`
`216.0
`
`34.3
`
`77.7
`
`67.1
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 9 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Comparison of Districts Within the Tenth Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`CO
`3,923
`4,107
`3,724
`
`-8.9
`4.0
`7
`10.8
`560
`475
`
`KS
`1,802
`2,250
`1,592
`
`-11.8
`-17.5
`6
`17.5
`300
`206
`
`NM
`3,905
`4,010
`3,237
`
`8.4
`-30.2
`7
`24.0
`558
`159
`
`OK,N
`1,294
`1,388
`1,295
`
`-15.4
`11.7
`3.5
`12.0
`370
`168
`
`OK,E OK,W
`673
`1,816
`708
`1,886
`954
`1,749
`
`-27.7
`1.5
`1.5
`0.0
`449
`263
`
`-8.1
`-7.3
`6
`0.0
`303
`188
`
`UT
`2,121
`2,242
`2,632
`
`-12.1
`-15.9
`5
`2.9
`424
`210
`
`WY
`694
`574
`901
`
`14.5
`-3.3
`3
`1.0
`231
`98
`
`61
`
`55
`
`291
`
`160
`
`161
`
`84
`
`154
`
`81
`
`25
`532
`580
`587
`18
`
`40
`265
`275
`375
`14
`
`108
`462
`396
`573
`14
`
`42
`370
`417
`397
`20
`
`24
`636
`502
`472
`63
`
`31
`292
`296
`314
`21
`
`60
`526
`433
`448
`8
`
`52
`300
`227
`191
`11
`
`16.5
` 8.7
`
`6.9
`10.6
`12.7
`11.5
`8.9
`4.9
`16.6
` 8.3 11.0 13.3 14.6 10.2 12.2 13.0
`
` 34.6 26.0
`
`187
`6.2
`
`1.4
`
`34.9
`
`34.8
`
`109
`11.0
`
`1.3
`
`44.4
`
`40.1
`
`-
`
`132
`10.4
`
`1.0
`
`62.8
`
`30.4
`
`-
`
`73
`10.4
`
`1.3
`
`51.4
`
`33.7
`
`-
`
` 24.5 70.0
`
`27
`5.2
`
`1.1
`
`44.0
`
`26.0
`
`61
`6.0
`
`1.3
`
`43.5
`
`29.7
`
`233
`15.0
`
`1.2
`
`46.0
`
`32.2
`
`-
`
`21
`6.8
`
`1.1
`
`35.2
`
`21.2
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 10 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`

`

`Comparison of Districts Within the Eleventh Circuit — 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2022
`
`Overall
`Caseload
`Statistics
`
`Actions
`per
`Judgeship
`
`Median
`Time
`(Months)
`
`Other
`
`Filings
`
`Filings
`Terminations
`Pending
`Over
`Percent Change
`Last Year
`in Total Filings
`Current Year
`Over 2017
`Number of Judgeships
`Vacant Judgeship Months ¹
`Total
`Civil
`Criminal
`Felony
`Supervised
`Release
`Hearings
`Pending Cases
`Weighted Filings ¹
`Terminations
`Trials Completed
`Criminal
`From
`Felony
`Filing to
`Disposition
`Civil ¹
`From Filing to Trial ¹
`(Civil Only)
`Number (and %)
`of Civil Cases
`Over 3 Years Old ¹
`Average Number
`of Felony Defendants
`Filed per Case
`Avg. Present for
`Jury Selection
`Percent Not Selected
`or Challenged
`
`Jurors
`
`GA,N
`7,085
`7,234
`9,140
`
`1.6
`7.8
`11
`17.6
`644
`564
`
`GA,M
`1,664
`1,866
`1,712
`
`-10.3
`-14.4
`4
`0.0
`416
`303
`
`GA,S
`1,383
`1,681
`1,525
`
`-16.1
`-5.7
`3
`0.0
`461
`311
`
`-7.2
`-13.2
`18
`24.0
`594
`476
`
`-6.0
`-7.7
`15
`0.0
`653
`555
`
`69
`
`29
`546
`570
`708
`14
`
`FL,S
`FL,M
`FL,N
`AL,S
`9,799 10,689
`1,091 57,118
`1,199 42,468 10,614 11,657
`980 260,113
`8,194
`5,977
`
`AL,N
`2,322
`2,632
`2,746
`
`-15.1
`-18.3
`8
`0.0
`290
`213
`
`AL,M
`1,118
`1,221
`1,639
`
`-14.5
`-8.8
`3
`0.0
`373
`276
`
`-46.5
`-1.7
`-3.1 2,155.8
`3
`4
`0.0
`0.0
`364 14,280
`177 14,190
`
`49
`
`84
`
`96
`
`58
`
`29
`343
`274
`329
`21
`
`13
`546
`361
`407
`19
`
`32
`91
`327 65,028
`332
`9,451
`400 10,617
`38
`34
`
`86
`
`62
`
`99
`
`105
`
`31
`332
`593
`648
`30
`
`19
`831
`570
`658
`21
`
`15
`428
`386
`467
`14
`
`45
`508
`425
`560
`17
`
`11.8
`10.2
` 11.5 13.0
`
`13.7
`10.6
` 9.8 20.9
`
`11.0
` 6.6
`
`8.6
` 3.6
`
`13.0
` 5.0
`
`14.5
` 8.3
`
`12.7
` 9.9
`
` 40.8
`
`352
`16.8
`
`1.2
`
`30.6
`
`28.3
`
`-
`
`164
`13.8
`
`1.4
`
`42.2
`
`27.3
`
`-
`
`23.8 29.9 25.0 39.1
`
`32
`5.7
`
`1.4
`
`45.0
`
`34.5
`
`788
`0.3
`
`1.3
`
`34.8
`
`18.9
`
`455
`7.1
`
`1.3
`
`38.6
`
`29.1
`
`133
`3.4
`
`2,335
`30.6
`
`1.3
`
`39.8
`
`14.2
`
`1.3
`
`41.2
`
`31.9
`
`-
`
`79
`7.8
`
`1.8
`
`9.2
`
`40.0
`
`-
`
`99
`10.8
`
`1.5
`
`65.4
`
`45.4
`
`NOTE: Criminal data in this profile count defendants rather than cases and therefore will not match previously published numbers.
`¹ See "Explanation of Selected Terms."
`
`Ex.1023 / IPR2022-01137 / Page 11 of 11
`Apple Inc. v. Aire Technology Limited
`
`