`
`____________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`____________________
`
`SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.
`Petitioner
`
`v.
`
`SCRAMOGE TECHNOLOGY LTD.
`Patent Owner
`_________________________
`
`
`U.S. Patent No. 10,461,426
`
`_________________________
`
`DECLARATION OF R. JACOB BAKER, PH.D., P.E.
`IN SUPPORT OF PETITON FOR INTER PARTES REVIEW OF
`U.S. PATENT NO. 10,461,426
`
`Page 1 of 187
`
`SAMSUNG EXHIBIT 1002
`
`
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`
`TABLE OF CONTENTS
`I.
`INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................... 1
`BACKGROUND AND QUALIFICATIONS ................................................ 1
`II.
`III. MATERIALS REVIEWED ........................................................................... 5
`IV. PERSON OF ORDINARY SKILL IN THE ART ......................................... 7
`V.
`TECHNICAL BACKGROUND .................................................................... 8
`A. Wireless Charging ................................................................................ 8
`B.
`Flexible Printed Circuit Boards ............................................................ 9
`VI. OVERVIEW OF THE ’426 PATENT ......................................................... 12
`VII. CLAIM CONSTRUCTION ......................................................................... 14
`VIII. OVERVIEW OF THE PRIOR ART ............................................................ 15
`A. Kim ..................................................................................................... 15
`B.
`Shostak ............................................................................................... 20
`C.
`Kim ’681 ............................................................................................. 25
`D. An ....................................................................................................... 29
`IX. THE PRIOR ART DISCLOSES OR SUGGESTS ALL OF THE
`FEATURES OF CLAIMS 1-12, 17-29, 34-45, 50-52 ................................. 33
`A. Kim discloses the Features of Claims 1-5, 9-16, and 50 .................... 33
`1.
`Claim 1 ..................................................................................... 33
`a)
`1[pre]: A wireless antenna comprising: ......................... 33
`b)
`1[a]: a wireless communication antenna
`comprising a first wireless communication coil and
`a second wireless communication coil; and .................. 35
`1[b]: a wireless charging antenna comprising a
`wireless charging coil, ................................................... 37
`1[c]: wherein the wireless charging coil is disposed
`inside the first wireless communication coil, and
`the second wireless communication coil is
`disposed inside the wireless charging coil, .................... 39
`
`d)
`
`c)
`
`i
`
`
`Page 2 of 187
`
`
`
`f)
`
`g)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`1[d]: wherein the wireless communication antenna
`further comprises a coil connection member
`traversing the wireless charging coil so as to
`interconnect the first wireless communication coil
`and the second wireless communication coil, ............... 40
`1[e]: wherein a number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a number
`of windings of the first wireless communication
`coil, and .......................................................................... 42
`1[f]: wherein a width of a winding of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a width of
`a winding of the first communication coil. .................... 44
`Claim 2 ..................................................................................... 47
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different shapes. ............................................................. 47
`Claim 3 ..................................................................................... 48
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 2,
`wherein a shape of the first wireless
`communication coil is a polygonal loop pattern,
`and wherein a shape of the second wireless
`communication coil is a circular loop pattern. .............. 48
`Claim 4 ..................................................................................... 49
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different curvatures. ....................................................... 49
`Claim 5 ..................................................................................... 50
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the wireless charging coil and the second
`wireless communication coil have corresponding
`curvatures. ...................................................................... 50
`Claim 9 ..................................................................................... 51
`
`e)
`
`2.
`
`3.
`
`4.
`
`5.
`
`6.
`
`ii
`
`
`Page 3 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`7.
`
`b)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the coil connection member is insulated
`from the wireless charging coil. .................................... 51
`Claim 10 ................................................................................... 52
`a)
`10[a]: The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil are
`connected to each other in series, and ........................... 52
`10[b]: wherein the first wireless communication
`coil and the second wireless communication coil
`are wound so as to have a same rotational direction
`of current. ....................................................................... 54
`Claim 11 ................................................................................... 56
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the wireless communication antenna and
`the wireless charging antenna are formed on a
`flexible printed circuit board. ........................................ 56
`Claim 12 ................................................................................... 58
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 11,
`wherein the flexible printed circuit board further
`comprises a connector connected to the wireless
`communication antenna and to the wireless
`charging antenna. ........................................................... 58
`10. Claim 50 ................................................................................... 61
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein each of the windings of the first
`communication coil has a width that is greater than
`the width of the winding of the second wireless
`communication coil. ...................................................... 61
`Kim in Combination with Shostak Discloses or Suggests the
`Features of Claims 6, 17-22, 25-29, 34-39, 42-45, 51, and 52 .......... 63
`1.
`Claim 6 ..................................................................................... 63
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is one. .............................. 63
`
`8.
`
`9.
`
`B.
`
`iii
`
`
`Page 4 of 187
`
`
`
`2.
`
`3.
`
`4.
`
`5.
`
`c)
`
`d)
`
`e)
`
`f)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`Claim 17 ................................................................................... 69
`a)
`17[pre]: A wireless antenna comprising: ....................... 69
`b)
`17[a]: a wireless communication antenna
`comprising a first wireless communication coil and
`a second wireless communication coil; and .................. 69
`17[b]: a wireless charging antenna comprising a
`wireless charging coil, ................................................... 69
`17[c]: wherein the wireless charging coil is
`disposed inside the first wireless communication
`coil, and the second wireless communication coil
`is disposed inside the wireless charging coil, ................ 69
`17[d]: wherein a number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a number
`of windings of the first wireless communication
`coil, ................................................................................ 69
`17[e]: wherein a minimum distance between the
`second wireless communication coil and the
`wireless charging coil is greater than a minimum
`distance between the first wireless communication
`coil and the wireless charging coil, and ......................... 70
`17[f]: wherein a width of a winding of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a width of
`a winding of the first communication coil. .................... 78
`Claim 18 ................................................................................... 78
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different shapes. ............................................................. 78
`Claim 19 ................................................................................... 79
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 18,
`wherein a shape of the first wireless
`communication coil is a polygonal loop pattern,
`and wherein a shape of the second wireless
`communication coil is a circular loop pattern. .............. 79
`Claim 20 ................................................................................... 79
`
`g)
`
`iv
`
`
`Page 5 of 187
`
`
`
`7.
`
`8.
`
`9.
`
`a)
`
`6.
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different curvatures. ....................................................... 79
`Claim 21 ................................................................................... 79
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the wireless charging coil and the second
`wireless communication coil have corresponding
`curvatures. ...................................................................... 79
`Claim 22 ................................................................................... 79
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is one. .............................. 79
`Claim 25 ................................................................................... 80
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the wireless communication antenna
`further comprises a coil connection member
`traversing the wireless charging coil so as to
`interconnect the first wireless communication coil
`and the second wireless communication coil. ............... 80
`Claim 26 ................................................................................... 80
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 25,
`wherein the coil connection member is insulated
`from the wireless charging coil. .................................... 80
`10. Claim 27 ................................................................................... 80
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil are
`connected to each other in series, and ........................... 80
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil are wound
`in a same rotational direction of current. ....................... 80
`11. Claim 28 ................................................................................... 81
`
`b)
`
`v
`
`
`Page 6 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`c)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the wireless communication antenna and
`the wireless charging antenna are formed on a
`flexible printed circuit board. ........................................ 81
`12. Claim 29 ................................................................................... 81
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 28,
`wherein the flexible printed circuit board further
`comprises a connector connected to both the
`wireless communication antenna and the wireless
`charging antenna. ........................................................... 81
`13. Claim 34 ................................................................................... 81
`a)
`34[pre]: A wireless antenna comprising: ....................... 81
`b)
`34[a]: a wireless communication antenna
`comprising a first wireless communication coil
`having a polygonal loop pattern and a second
`wireless communication coil having a circular loop
`pattern; and .................................................................... 81
`34[b]: a wireless charging antenna comprising a
`wireless charging coil having a circular loop
`pattern, ........................................................................... 82
`34[c]: wherein the wireless charging coil is
`disposed inside the first wireless communication
`coil, and the second wireless communication coil
`is disposed inside the wireless charging coil, ................ 82
`34[d]: wherein the wireless communication
`antenna further comprises a coil connection
`member traversing the wireless charging coil so as
`to interconnect the first wireless communication
`coil and the second wireless communication coil, ........ 83
`34[e]: wherein a minimum distance between the
`second wireless communication coil and the
`wireless charging coil is greater than a minimum
`distance between the first wireless communication
`coil and the wireless charging coil, and ......................... 83
`
`d)
`
`e)
`
`f)
`
`vi
`
`
`Page 7 of 187
`
`
`
`g)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`34[f]: wherein a width of a winding of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a width of
`a winding of the first communication coil. .................... 83
`14. Claim 35 ................................................................................... 83
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different curvatures. ....................................................... 83
`15. Claim 36 ................................................................................... 84
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein the wireless charging coil and the second
`wireless communication coil have corresponding
`curvatures. ...................................................................... 84
`16. Claim 37 ................................................................................... 84
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein a number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is different from a number of
`windings of the second wireless communication
`coil. ................................................................................ 84
`17. Claim 38 ................................................................................... 86
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein a number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is one. .............................. 86
`18. Claim 39 ................................................................................... 86
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein a number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a number
`of windings of the wireless charging coil. ..................... 86
`19. Claim 42 ................................................................................... 87
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein the coil connection member is insulated
`from the wireless charging coil. .................................... 87
`20. Claim 43 ................................................................................... 87
`
`vii
`
`
`Page 8 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`b)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil are
`connected to each other in series, and ........................... 87
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil are wound
`so as to have a same rotational direction of current. ..... 87
`21. Claim 44 ................................................................................... 87
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein the wireless communication antenna and
`the wireless charging antenna are formed on a
`flexible printed circuit board. ........................................ 87
`22. Claim 45 ................................................................................... 88
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 44,
`wherein the flexible printed circuit board further
`comprises a connector connected to both the
`wireless communication antenna and the wireless
`charging antenna. ........................................................... 88
`23. Claim 51 ................................................................................... 88
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein each of the windings of the first
`communication coil has a width that is greater than
`the width of the winding of the second wireless
`communication coil. ...................................................... 88
`24. Claim 52 ................................................................................... 88
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 34,
`wherein each of the windings of the first
`communication coil has a width that is greater than
`the width of the winding of the second wireless
`communication coil. ...................................................... 88
`Kim in Combination with Kim ’681 Discloses or Suggests the
`Features of Claims 7 and 8 ................................................................. 89
`1.
`Claim 7 ..................................................................................... 89
`
`C.
`
`viii
`
`
`Page 9 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`2.
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein a number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the first wireless communication coil. ....... 89
`Claim 8 ................................................................................... 101
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 7,
`wherein the number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the second wireless communication
`coil. .............................................................................. 101
`D. Kim in Combination with An Discloses or Suggests the
`Features of Claims 12, 29, and 45 .................................................... 103
`1.
`Claim 12 ................................................................................. 103
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 11,
`wherein the flexible printed circuit board further
`comprises a connector connected to the wireless
`communication antenna and to the wireless
`charging antenna. ......................................................... 103
`Claim 29 ................................................................................. 109
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 28,
`wherein the flexible printed circuit board further
`comprises a connector connected to both the
`wireless communication antenna and the wireless
`charging antenna. ......................................................... 109
`Claim 45 ................................................................................. 109
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 44,
`wherein the flexible printed circuit board further
`comprises a connector connected to both the
`wireless communication antenna and the wireless
`charging antenna. ......................................................... 109
`Kim in Combination with Shostak and Kim ’681 Discloses or
`Suggests the Features of Claims 23, 24, 40, and 41 ......................... 109
`1.
`Claim 23 ................................................................................. 110
`
`E.
`
`2.
`
`3.
`
`ix
`
`
`Page 10 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`2.
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein a number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the first wireless communication coil. ..... 110
`Claim 24 ................................................................................. 110
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 23,
`wherein the number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the second wireless communication
`coil. .............................................................................. 110
`Claim 40 ................................................................................. 110
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 39,
`wherein the number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than a number of windings
`of the first wireless communication coil. .................... 110
`Claim 41 ................................................................................. 111
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 40,
`wherein the number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the second wireless communication
`coil. .............................................................................. 111
`Shostak in Combination with Kim Discloses or Suggests the
`Features of Claims 1-12, 17-29, 34-45, and 50-52 .......................... 111
`1.
`Claim 1 ................................................................................... 111
`a)
`1[pre]: A wireless antenna comprising: ....................... 111
`b)
`1[a]: a wireless communication antenna
`comprising a first wireless communication coil and
`a second wireless communication coil; and ................ 113
`1[b]: a wireless charging antenna comprising a
`wireless charging coil, ................................................. 114
`1[c]: wherein the wireless charging coil is disposed
`inside the first wireless communication coil, and
`the second wireless communication coil is
`disposed inside the wireless charging coil, .................. 115
`
`d)
`
`3.
`
`4.
`
`F.
`
`c)
`
`x
`
`
`Page 11 of 187
`
`
`
`f)
`
`g)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`1[d]: wherein the wireless communication antenna
`further comprises a coil connection member
`traversing the wireless charging coil so as to
`interconnect the first wireless communication coil
`and the second wireless communication coil, ............. 116
`1[e]: wherein a number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a number
`of windings of the first wireless communication
`coil, and ........................................................................ 118
`1[f]: wherein a width of a winding of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a width of
`a winding of the first communication coil. .................. 119
`Claim 2 ................................................................................... 127
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different shapes. ........................................................... 127
`Claim 3 ................................................................................... 129
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 2,
`wherein a shape of the first wireless
`communication coil is a polygonal loop pattern,
`and wherein a shape of the second wireless
`communication coil is a circular loop pattern. ............ 129
`Claim 4 ................................................................................... 130
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different curvatures. ..................................................... 130
`Claim 5 ................................................................................... 131
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the wireless charging coil and the second
`wireless communication coil have corresponding
`curvatures. .................................................................... 131
`Claim 6 ................................................................................... 132
`
`e)
`
`2.
`
`3.
`
`4.
`
`5.
`
`6.
`
`xi
`
`
`Page 12 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`7.
`
`8.
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is one. ............................ 132
`Claim 7 ................................................................................... 133
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein a number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the first wireless communication coil. ..... 133
`Claim 8 ................................................................................... 134
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 7,
`wherein the number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the second wireless communication
`coil. .............................................................................. 134
`Claim 9 ................................................................................... 135
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the coil connection member is insulated
`from the wireless charging coil. .................................. 135
`10. Claim 10 ................................................................................. 138
`a)
`10[a]: The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil are
`connected to each other in series, and ......................... 138
`10[b]: wherein the first wireless communication
`coil and the second wireless communication coil
`are wound so as to have a same rotational direction
`of current. ..................................................................... 139
`11. Claim 11 ................................................................................. 140
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 1,
`wherein the wireless communication antenna and
`the wireless charging antenna are formed on a
`flexible printed circuit board. ...................................... 140
`12. Claim 12 ................................................................................. 144
`
`b)
`
`9.
`
`xii
`
`
`Page 13 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`c)
`
`d)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 11,
`wherein the flexible printed circuit board further
`comprises a connector connected to the wireless
`communication antenna and to the wireless
`charging antenna. ......................................................... 144
`13. Claim 17 ................................................................................. 146
`a)
`17[pre]: A wireless antenna comprising: ..................... 146
`b)
`17[a]: a wireless communication antenna
`comprising a first wireless communication coil and
`a second wireless communication coil; and ................ 146
`17[b]: a wireless charging antenna comprising a
`wireless charging coil, ................................................. 146
`17[c]: wherein the wireless charging coil is
`disposed inside the first wireless communication
`coil, and the second wireless communication coil
`is disposed inside the wireless charging coil, .............. 147
`17[d]: wherein a number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a number
`of windings of the first wireless communication
`coil, .............................................................................. 147
`17[e]: wherein a minimum distance between the
`second wireless communication coil and the
`wireless charging coil is greater than a minimum
`distance between the first wireless communication
`coil and the wireless charging coil, and ....................... 147
`17[f]: wherein a width of a winding of the second
`wireless communication coil is less than a width of
`a winding of the first communication coil. .................. 147
`14. Claim 18 ................................................................................. 148
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different shapes. ........................................................... 148
`15. Claim 19 ................................................................................. 148
`
`e)
`
`f)
`
`g)
`
`xiii
`
`
`Page 14 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 18,
`wherein a shape of the first wireless
`communication coil is a polygonal loop pattern,
`and wherein a shape of the second wireless
`communication coil is a circular loop pattern. ............ 148
`16. Claim 20 ................................................................................. 148
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil have
`different curvatures. ..................................................... 148
`17. Claim 21 ................................................................................. 148
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the wireless charging coil and the second
`wireless communication coil have corresponding
`curvatures. .................................................................... 148
`18. Claim 22 ................................................................................. 149
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the number of windings of the second
`wireless communication coil is one. ............................ 149
`19. Claim 23 ................................................................................. 149
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein a number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the first wireless communication coil. ..... 149
`20. Claim 24 ................................................................................. 150
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 23,
`wherein the number of windings of the wireless
`charging coil is greater than the number of
`windings of the second wireless communication
`coil. .............................................................................. 150
`21. Claim 25 ................................................................................. 151
`
`xiv
`
`
`Page 15 of 187
`
`
`
`a)
`
`Declaration of R. Jacob Baker, Ph.D., P.E.
`Patent No. 10,461,426
`The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the wireless communication antenna
`further comprises a coil connection member
`traversing the wireless charging coil so as to
`interconnect the first wireless communication coil
`and the second wireless communication coil. ............. 151
`22. Claim 26 ................................................................................. 151
`a)
`The wireless antenna according to claim 25,
`wherein the coil connection member is insulated
`from the wireless charging coil. .................................. 151
`23. Claim 27 ................................................................................. 151
`a)
`27[a]: The wireless antenna according to claim 17,
`wherein the first wireless communication coil and
`the second wireless communication coil are
`connected to each other in series, and ......................... 151
`27[b]: wherein the first wireless communication
`coil and the second wireless communication coil
`are wound in a same rotational direction of current. ... 151
`24. Claim 28 ................................................................................. 152