Apple, Inc. v. CPC Patent Technologies Pty Ltd.
`IPR2022-00601, -00602
`
`Patent Owner’s Slides – Not Evidence
`
`Hearing – June 29, 2023
`
`© Copyright 2020 by K&L Gates LLP. All rights reserved.
`
`CPC EXHIBIT 2016
`Apple Inc. v. CPC Patent Technologies PTY Ltd.
`IPR2022-00602
`
`Page 1 of 21
`
`

`

`Apple’s Single Challenge Ground
`
`Patent Owner Slide 2
`
`Page 2 of 21
`
`

`

`Mathiassen
`
`on
`relies
`“Claim 1’s mapping
`Mathiassen’s
`20
`control
`portable
`embodiment of Mathiassen, where the
`‘controlled item’
`is Mathiassen’s car
`door
`locks
`in the
`‘central
`locking
`system.’” Petition at 11.
`
`Patent Owner Slide 3
`
`Page 3 of 21
`
`

`

`K&L GATES
`
`“Duration”
`“Duration”
`
`Page 4 of 21
`
`Patent OwnerSlide 4
`Patent Owner Slide 4
`
`Page 4 of 21
`
`

`

`Mathiassen ≠ “Duration”
`
`Petition at 3
`
`Patent Owner Slide 5
`
`Page 5 of 21
`
`

`

`Apple's Proposed Combination
`
`Patent Owner Slide 6
`
`Page 6 of 21
`
`

`

`Mathiassen Alone is Simpler
`
`POR at 19, citing Ex. 2013, ¶ 51
`
`Patent Owner Slide 7
`
`Page 7 of 21
`
`

`

`No Rationale to Modify Mathiassen
`
`“Because Hon ’043 already discloses a reliable means
`for transporting liquid from a liquid supply to a heating
`element, Whittemore’s
`‘known
`technique’
`of
`transporting liquid via the capillary action of a porous
`wick is not applicable to the known device of Hon
`’043. Accordingly, we do not find that one of ordinary
`skill in the art would have been motivated to use the
`technique of Whittemore to improve Hon ’043.” Sur-
`Reply at 5-6, citing R.J. Reynolds Vapor Co. v. Fontem
`Holdings 1 B.V., IPR2016-01692, Paper No. 45, 26
`(PTAB March 2, 2018) (emphasis added).
`
`Patent Owner Slide 8
`
`Page 8 of 21
`
`

`

`Dr. Sears’ Push Button Opinion
`
`“A POSITA would have understood two separate
`input operations to add complexity and slow
`down the input process for a user, and thus a
`POSITA would not have found including a push
`button in Mathiassen to be a simpler solution.”
`Ex. 1090, ¶ 8.
`
`Patent Owner Slide 9
`
`Page 9 of 21
`
`

`

`Push Button = Viable
`
`“Ziegler’s security system grants access
`to the user while sending out a silent
`alarm.” Ex. 1003, ¶ 153
`
`See Sur-Reply at 9-10
`
`Patent Owner Slide 10
`
`Page 10 of 21
`
`

`

`Mathiassen = Separate Hardware
`
`Sur-Reply at 12, citing E. 2015 at 36:18-37:14
`
`“Movement analyzing means, in the form of a
`hardware or a software movement analyzing
`program module analyzes the obtained series of
`fingerprint representations to obtain a measure
`of
`the omni-directional
`finger movements
`across the sensor in two dimensions.” Ex.
`1004, ¶ [0192] (emphasis added).
`
`Patent Owner Slide 11
`
`Page 11 of 21
`
`

`

`Combination “Evidence”
`
`Sur-Reply at 15, citing Ex. 2015 at 61:12-20
`
`Patent Owner Slide 12
`
`Page 12 of 21
`
`

`

`Anderson # Duration
`Anderson ≠ Duration
`
`op United States Patent
`Andere
`
`om Pateet Ne
`oeDate of Patent:
`
`«US 6,509,847 BI
`Jan, 21, 2008
`
`US 6.500.547 Tt
`
`5
`7
`imilarly, in an
`
`Die tered mgeme crake mney Me etka oe cretpeemteeell eewe whey eT" chin ert the ers gee elt
`et cere otek eotering Ge reweme, aml cory rf Ge mune
`Tb chee ceeweey memes bee veeenyie. the meee crn
`exemplary embodiment, digitizer pad 120 may include an
`othe Sel Bowe et be Rewernate© (heal parten
`optical scanner or thermal sensor for collecting an image of
`bs
`eree
`PR, Ne ey erty 6 eee O88Rewung + eeeeee Denly
`G12 wel ot leant ee bey O14 tein + ee ereetnw
`element Ge g. 6 Bree senmetive meter, o& } Memctemng oF
`oe etertne be pepkeeretetes of Ge cutee of Oe
`Pernt corwetene The ome e capet 6 premere mone wale
`coy tk”
`Ce
`m OAc
`preeebeON cond apy) Areeeeulpremere cas wenyeerel,
`
`the user's fingerprint as the pressure access code is entered
`
`(BNE 1) Ae ey are cctereel, Ge preeeee apptcteee ae
`weed Py ihe eek eters cf Vetere @ preeeee
`
`RT oO 08 eteaheetothsetagys will te eralremnal bry te K&L GATES
`
`merwwreeee Of he Rey O08 fy he were Rage ta fe oe
`ee ee
`Reged 0 Ge cory emoiing Ge terme hed qerdide we
`tere ey ee meeget ley end premeets 4 te tems ted
`Seeeel premare que Oe mee My he owt be otis oe
`wn”
`Bee oatheteeneng the eye meeremy il Ge
`arma
`ee
`(e227 A be
`ime
`ee
`Sime”
`Be the pees ervreten, whee snplewweted 08 nthe
`Peee
`et Ge ahemeti beeing ete’ core ceedI
`Reem rym senpreed fo pertahte eens TED
`duran beretg ¢ ome cemrime Th2 wmenewesl te 6 feemem
`corte od oe teeming Patereteie wah oneetme VIZ
`ontearnt he some eters wmthl et tent variate
`preetected ws at tm eReteely teckied Gen Oe yee od
`end pemes Hy Oe rmperes6 teenage Demy ening
`> preweere cengeitecs oe eetemeaty Then, ie aeewee cout
`ee bbeteen! hee cece crane camreel by che me reey Oe
`eel be creed om erie of deren preerere appl
`wered hy ted partes
`<item of varyeng eee Aermaety, oe deowe oe 1G
`Q Does Anderson say anything about a
`OD te ee erie tty eee ek peel apie
`Keke em te PR Be eel be appereet ee
`led ot the et Rat ee eed of the premeetarenmtem
`Nee 6 pees el Chem aeperenre maytitete ow
`ates Vinee Ge meen ink weed he commend ane ree
`AY OS Melee’ PyebweetensMetetlengeynmome ar 4 wale
`durational component about tap that's used for
`4 aimemenang dee! tend bey prewensegytnsieemthee oy
`
`serery ofppytaten Sank ite pet hore cmpbered
`
`eed oeDetwere ten! emegyeeierte
`Reyer co benped watered mcnes conten Pow etme oe
`A been cle bee eg, Meee cok) ce 6 eeey
`ern we FHC) Oe rewind pol he preneee ervemmens may by
`eelied Oy et etemeted wiker eee (ATM) OD
`were beg. Ge cowbealy ul « Lewentte cong) mee te ete
`fingerprint capture?
`prevent Bard potas coe Be AIM be chomp, combing
`© ed Oe ee ee hey,
`wal comeing Oe
`ew eleel Ge eee, ee
`o> eet
`socom ec. Ferten, by wedge «code bey cet ot Morne
`eon senter (FIN) & @ i conrad ATM O88
`
`rele 6 chereenteane!slypRemesera peeemeed preyeenly
`A
`If that's the only place where fingerprint
`peeHeh CoteemA oeadwmeteatNmenllamyeretere thew
`catered the 6 beyhenand ot beypel pay be creer ate 6
`Rage tgmetotaal totparhemang Peutotg orl Mekong
`Pern pemeeenl coemnting fe erm of hay teal ateet
`
`peere epeetows be ene Oe De pret memeete lated WemtiemThen o typed APM GORD wer centele
`ety fhe Cee od te heeheeaRieetersJOD od
`capture is mentioned,
`I don’t believe it mentions
`ee
`TI2 ee an Be Chnipin, premewnn 2BE vyeties ceement
`
`et he pewetomete, whee snptemecdot os ate
`ter 202, ct 2046, detepe che 208, wad tent tee 200
`aer ry
`Se oe AEM GD trey ohn: ets eequenet hw mee
`otheet Cees degree pod LIDCTHA 0) eee ened eeerlnee Pow
`anything about the durational component there.
`teSUD eekgCeskmere mah oetageeta card he
`one,
`ewe FIO 8 on ites benting
`GAZ be meeering + eageetenly emnted AIM card 6
`yee a eee whako crempnwed of 6 meteite ym
`Seppe! 814 + Geptey 818, & rier O18 be primey
`SD hawngberend 942 cmphryung + owree control ta
`Sur-Reply at 21, citing Ex. 2015 at 46:9-14
`Cee Ce, ent chete bwdetetg eee ent
`SEO be mavens Wed ie premmtirretanm, «erent cram
`weer Apne caebows O20 4 O22
`Ak EG cme meee verieremm ot free ow premeare ayyteel
`ber ae ctartarycowteatanmet, ALM GHD eeey tee prowated
`seeg 6°70" eee pepeniwte keteend 12 be te
`eens, cares coemred ak ENG may he etdued os heal
`wR + heh fetes be cry ot Oe Ger) eet
`tonestnns emmates (FEN) An terwe an ID Bee met
`tert te (adeeme cerry of avers cones ® marnteme
`
`Oe Reeeeedof Hee preset eweFit comterme. ot cet eeenee ny comentm 8meperee Dgreme pml M26eeented
`We he ATM me oe te Oe canily meme by ie ee
`erenpleny ceteris, ceree comet ek 914 way
`tee 6 fone mney reaieee (ree teen) aetalde bow
`
`Abermeely the end cenrine ey coongree 6 teh ee
`metre comerbey Gee teen meer) heyhey O10 thet mcapatite
`
`ee 10 mney Snelpegaetme! & ihe Bove agyted
`A ermeng eens) Saeteee ot peewee apple oe
`ed
`hagiey 010%) Oe ome
`ek 0046 cet copty + ewe peers ee epee
`
`petmeen PelerOly, vere cretind Minh etl bean 6g Wa tehere Oat Be weifnad1 ihe promi aente eee
`of eng Herne ie fee dong he OT ee eel oe
`
`Dr. Sears
`
`—c
`
`
`Page 13 of 21
`Patent Owner Slide 13
`Patent Owner Slide 13
`
`Page 13 of 21
`
`

`

`Anderson ≠ Biometric Signal Series
`
`POR at 28, citing Ex. 2013, ¶ 69
`
`Sur-Reply at 20, citing Ex. 2012 at 58:3-10
`
`Patent Owner Slide 14
`
`Page 14 of 21
`
`

`

`“Under Which Conditions”
`
`Patent Owner Slide 15
`
`Page 15 of 21
`
`

`

`“Under Which Conditions”
`
`Patent Owner Slide 16
`
`Page 16 of 21
`
`

`

`Mathiassen ≠ “Which Conditions”
`
`Sur-Reply at 22, citing Ex. 2015 at 66:1-67:9
`
`Patent Owner Slide 17
`17
`
`Page 17 of 21
`
`

`

`“Populating the Database”
`
`Patent Owner Slide 18
`
`Page 18 of 21
`
`

`

`Claimed Enrollment Steps
`
`Patent Owner Slide 19
`
`Page 19 of 21
`
`

`

`‘705 Patent - Figure 8
`‘705 Patent - Figure 8
`
`“FIG. 8 shows a process 800 for
`implementing various enrollment
`procedures.” Col. 12, Lines 54-55.
`
`Col. 13, Lines 4-6 (emphasis added).
`
`“It is noted that the step 802, as well as the
`steps 805, 807 and 809 involve sequences of
`finger presses on the biometric sensor 121.”
`
`Page 20 of 21
`
`Patent OwnerSlide 20
`Patent Owner Slide 20
`
`Page 20 of 21
`
`

`

`Mathiassen ≠ “Populating”
`
`Patent Owner Slide 21
`
`Page 21 of 21
`
`