throbber
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`WACO DIVISION
`
`SCRAMOGE TECHNOLOGY LTD.,
`
`v.
`
`APPLE INC.,
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`Defendant.
`









`
`Civil Action No. 6:21-cv-01071-ADA
`
`DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
`
`APPLE INC.’S PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 1
`
`

`

`I.
`
`INTRODUCTION
`
`Defendant Apple Inc. (“Apple”) hereby makes the following Preliminary disclosure of
`
`Invalidity Contentions (“Preliminary Invalidity Contentions”) to Plaintiff Scramoge
`
`Technology Ltd. (“Scramoge”).
`
`These contentions address only the claims of U.S. Patent Nos. 9,490,652 (“the ’652
`
`Patent”), 7,825,537 (“the ’537 Patent”), and 10,193,392 (“the ’392 Patent”) (collectively, the
`
`“Asserted Patents”) asserted in Plaintiff’s Preliminary Disclosure of Asserted Claims and
`
`Infringement Contentions to Defendant Apple Inc. (“Infringement Contentions”) served on
`
`January 28, 2022.
`
`Scramoge has asserted the following claims (collectively, the “asserted claims”) against
`
`Apple:
`
` The ’652 Patent: Claim 1.
`
` The ’537 Patent: Claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 and 22.
`
` The ’392 Patent: Claims 1, 2, 4, 6, 7, and 8.
`
`With respect to each asserted claim and based on its investigation to date, Apple hereby:
`
`(a) identifies each item of prior art that anticipates and/or renders obvious each asserted claim;
`
`(b) specifies whether each such item of prior art anticipates each asserted claim and/or renders
`
`it obvious, and, if it renders it obvious, explains why the prior art renders the asserted claim
`
`obvious and identifies any combinations of prior art showing obviousness; (c) submits a chart
`
`identifying where specifically in each item of prior art each limitation of each asserted claim is
`
`found; (d) identifies the grounds of invalidity based on 35 U.S.C. § 112; and (e) identifies the
`
`claims that are directed to patent-ineligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
`
`In addition, pursuant to the Standing Order Governing Patent Proceedings, and based on
`
`- 1 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 2
`
`

`

`its investigation to date, Apple has produced or is producing documents concurrently with these
`
`Preliminary Invalidity Contentions.
`
`II.
`
`RESERVATIONS
`
`
`
`Apple reserves the right to amend these Preliminary Invalidity Contentions. The
`
`information and documents that Apple produces are based on information available to date and
`
`are subject to further revision. Apple expressly reserves the right to amend these disclosures
`
`and the accompanying document production should Scramoge provide any additional
`
`information that it failed to provide in its Infringement Contentions.
`
`Further, because discovery (including discovery from third parties) has not yet begun,
`
`Apple reserves the right to revise, amend, and/or supplement the information provided herein,
`
`including identifying and relying on additional references, should Apple’s further search and
`
`analysis yield additional information or references, consistent with the Standing Order
`
`Governing Patent Cases and the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Apple reserves the right to
`
`rely on additional prior art; further analysis of prior art; application of prior art to new or
`
`different claims; depositions and discovery from prior art sources and authors; analysis of prior
`
`art products; combinations of references; expert opinion and/or testimony; evidence supporting
`
`invalidity of any asserted claim; and any additional relevant information that may result from
`
`its further investigation and discovery. Additionally, Apple reserves the right to rely on
`
`additional information, testimony, and/or analysis concerning operation of prior art systems.
`
`Moreover, Apple reserves the right to revise its ultimate contentions concerning the invalidity
`
`of the asserted claims, which may change depending upon the Court’s construction of the
`
`asserted claims, any findings as to the priority or invention date of the asserted claims, and/or
`
`positions that Scramoge or its expert witness(es) may take concerning claim construction,
`
`infringement, and/or invalidity issues.
`
`- 2 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 3
`
`

`

`Prior art not included in this disclosure, whether known or unknown to Apple, may
`
`become relevant. In particular, Apple is currently unaware of the extent, if any, to which
`
`Scramoge will contend that limitations of the asserted claims are not disclosed in the prior art
`
`identified by Apple, or will contend that any of the identified references do not qualify as prior
`
`art. The identification of any patent or patent publication shall be deemed to include any
`
`counterpart patent or application filed, published, or issued anywhere in the world.
`
`The information and documents that Apple produces are based on Apple’s present
`
`understanding of Scramoge’s infringement theories as advanced by Scramoge in its
`
`Infringement Contentions. Scramoge’s Infringement Contentions are deficient in numerous
`
`respects. For example, Scramoge has failed to specifically identify where each element of each
`
`Asserted Claim is found within each accused instrumentality, and does not identify a specific
`
`mapping from components of the accused instrumentalities to the elements of the asserted
`
`claims. Scramoge has also failed to present any contentions for infringement under the
`
`doctrine of equivalents. Scramoge has not provided detailed infringement contentions that
`
`identify each specific claim limitation allegedly infringed under the doctrine of equivalents and
`
`its alleged equivalent element in the accused instrumentalities, or the basis for purported
`
`insubstantial differences between each such limitation and its alleged equivalent. If Scramoge
`
`attempts or is permitted to cure such deficiencies, doing so may lead to further grounds for
`
`invalidity, and thus Apple specifically reserves the right to modify, amend, or supplement its
`
`contentions. Apple has provided notice to Scramoge regarding the deficiencies in its
`
`Infringement Contentions. It has failed to cure the deficiencies and has not undertaken
`
`reasonable efforts to prepare preliminary contentions to put Apple on notice of its theories of
`
`infringement. Thus, it no longer has the opportunity to amend as of right under the Court’s
`
`- 3 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 4
`
`

`

`Order Governing Proceedings in Patent Cases (“OGP”) 3.5, unless “the amendment is based on
`
`material identified after those preliminary contentions were served.” OGP 3.5 at 8 n.7.
`
`However, if it is granted leave to amend its contentions, or other additional information
`
`regarding Scramoge’s infringement theories becomes available, Apple anticipates that it will
`
`provide corresponding invalidity contentions which establish that, under Scramoge’s
`
`interpretation of the claim scope as set forth in its Infringement Contentions, the asserted
`
`patents read on the prior art.
`
`Further, Scramoge has not produced prior art known to it, including regarding any
`
`known prior art products. As discovery in this action provides Apple with additional
`
`information, Apple may serve subpoenas on third parties believed to have knowledge,
`
`documentation, and/or corroborating evidence relating to invalidity and/or prior art. It is
`
`therefore likely that Apple will discover additional prior art pertinent to the invalidity of the
`
`asserted claims and Apple reserves the right to supplement these contentions after becoming
`
`aware of additional prior art or information. Apple further reserves the right to introduce and
`
`use such supplemental materials at trial.
`
`Apple’s claim charts in Exhibits A-C cite particular teachings and disclosures of the
`
`prior art as applied to features of the asserted claims. However, persons having ordinary skill
`
`in the art may view an item of prior art generally in the context of other publications, literature,
`
`products, and understanding. Accordingly, the cited portions are only exemplary, and Apple
`
`reserves the right to rely on uncited portions of the prior art references and on other
`
`publications and expert testimony as aids in understanding and interpreting the cited portions,
`
`as providing context thereto, and as additional evidence that a claim limitation is known or
`
`disclosed. Citations to figures are inclusive of all discussion of those figures. Apple further
`
`- 4 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 5
`
`

`

`reserves the right to rely on uncited portions of the prior art references, other publications,
`
`documents explicitly or implicitly incorporated by reference, and testimony, to establish bases
`
`for combinations of certain cited references that render the asserted claims obvious. Further,
`
`for any combination, Apple reserves the right to rely additionally on information generally
`
`known to those skilled in the art and/or common sense.
`
`The references discussed herein and in the claim charts in Exhibits A-C, or elsewhere
`
`identified, may disclose the elements of the asserted claims explicitly and/or inherently, and/or
`
`they may be relied upon to show the state of the art in the relevant timeframe. The exemplary
`
`obviousness combinations are provided in the alternative to Apple’s anticipation contentions
`
`and are not to be construed to suggest that any reference included in the combinations is not
`
`itself anticipatory.
`
`Apple further reserves the right to assert that the asserted claims are invalid under 35
`
`U.S.C. § 102(f) in the event that discovery reveals that the named inventor of the asserted
`
`patents did not invent (either alone or in conjunction with others) the subject matter recited in
`
`the asserted claims. If Apple asserts invalidity under Section 102(f), Apple will provide the
`
`name of the person(s) from whom, and the circumstances under which, the invention or any
`
`part of it was derived.
`
`Apple further intends to rely on inventor admissions concerning the scope of the
`
`asserted claims or of the prior art relevant to the asserted claims found in, inter alia: the patent
`
`prosecution history and/or reexamination history for the asserted patents and related patents
`
`and/or patent applications; any deposition testimony of a named inventor of the asserted
`
`patents; and the papers filed and any evidence submitted by Scramoge in conjunction with this
`
`litigation. Apple reserves the right to contend that the asserted claims are invalid for failure to
`
`- 5 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 6
`
`

`

`name the correct inventor(s), and/or to contend that Scramoge lacks standing to bring this
`
`litigation with respect to such patents.
`
`Furthermore, nothing stated herein shall be treated as an admission or suggestion that
`
`Apple agrees with Scramoge regarding either the scope of any asserted claim or the claim
`
`constructions Scramoge advances in its Infringement Contentions or anywhere else. To the
`
`extent that Apple’s Preliminary Invalidity Contentions reflect constructions of claim limitations
`
`consistent with or suggested by Scramoge’s Infringement Contentions, no inference is intended
`
`nor should any be drawn that Apple agrees with Scramoge’s claim constructions. Nor shall
`
`anything in these Preliminary Invalidity Contentions be treated as an admission that Apple’s
`
`accused products meet any limitation of any asserted claim. Apple denies that it infringes any
`
`claim of the asserted patents. To the extent that any prior art reference identified by Apple
`
`contains a claim element that is the same as or similar to an element in an accused product,
`
`based on a claim construction inferred from Scramoge’s Infringement Contentions, inclusion of
`
`that reference in Apple’s Preliminary Invalidity Contentions shall not be deemed a waiver by
`
`Apple of any claim construction or noninfringement position. Apple expressly reserves the
`
`right to contest any claim construction asserted by Scramoge and expressly reserves all
`
`noninfringement arguments.
`
`Depending on the Court’s construction of the asserted claims of the asserted patents,
`
`and/or positions that Scramoge or its expert witness(es) may take concerning claim
`
`interpretation, infringement, and/or invalidity issues, the charted prior art references in Exhibits
`
`A-C, or otherwise identified herein, may be of greater or lesser relevance, and different
`
`combinations of these references may be implicated. Given this uncertainty, the charts may
`
`reflect alternative applications of the prior art against the asserted claims. Nothing stated
`
`- 6 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 7
`
`

`

`herein shall be construed as an admission or a waiver of any particular construction of any
`
`claim term.
`
`Apple understands that Scramoge proposes to rely on the following priority dates for
`
`the Asserted Claims of the Patents based on their priority applications:
`
` The ’652 Patent: July 24, 2013.
`
` The ’537 Patent: November 14, 2008.
`
` The ’392 Patent: January 8, 2014.
`
`Though Apple’s investigation is ongoing, at least the Asserted Claims of the ’652 Patent
`
`should not be entitled to their earliest claimed priority date, e.g., July 24, 2013. Instead,
`
`Applicant should be afforded an effective priority date no earlier than January 7, 2014, which is
`
`the first date that Applicant's application included support for the claims issued in the ’652
`
`Patent. As an example, Korean application 10-2013-0087400 fails to disclose all elements of
`
`the Asserted Claim of the ’652 Patent.
`
`Further, the Asserted Claims of the ’392 Patent should not be entitled to their earliest
`
`claimed priority date, e.g., January 8, 2014. Instead, Applicant should be afforded an effective
`
`priority date no earlier than January 7, 2015, which is the first date that Applicant's application
`
`included support for the claims issued in the ’392 Patent. As an example, Korean applications
`
`10-2014-0002327 and 10-2014-0009243 fail to disclose all elements of the Asserted Claims of
`
`the ’392 Patent.
`
`Apple reserves the right to challenge any other alleged date of conception earlier than
`
`the filing date of the asserted patents. Apple further reserves the right to seek discovery
`
`regarding any alleged conception and reduction to practice dates, as appropriate, and to
`
`demonstrate earlier invention by other parties under 35 U.S.C. § 102(g), public use and/or the
`
`- 7 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 8
`
`

`

`on-sale bar under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b), and/or applicants’ failure to comply with 35 U.S.C. §
`
`112.
`
`In addition to these Preliminary Invalidity Contentions and the prior art identified
`
`herein, Apple hereby relies on and incorporates by reference in their entirety and expressly
`
`reserves the right to rely upon invalidity expert reports, including all invalidity positions,
`
`invalidity charts and all prior art cited therein, as well as invalidity contentions presented by
`
`any present or former defendant in any of Scramoge’s or its predecessors’ lawsuits or by
`
`potential or actual licensees to the asserted patents, including any reexamination or other post-
`
`grant review, involving the asserted patents or any patents that claim priority to, claim priority
`
`from, or are the basis for a claim of priority in the asserted patents (collectively, “related
`
`patents”). In particular, Apple incorporates by reference any invalidity contentions, invalidity
`
`charts, and invalidity positions in:
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd., v. Google LLC, WDTX 6:21-cv-01138-ADA, Scramoge
`
`Technology Ltd., v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al, WDTX 6:21-cv-00902, Scramoge
`
`Technology Ltd. v. Mophie Inc., CDCA 2:21-cv-08004-DOC-ADS, Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`
`v. Belkin International, Inc., CDCA 2:21-08035-DOC-ADS, Scramoge Technology Ltd. v.
`
`Anker Innovations Ltd. et al, CDCA 5:21-cv-01712-DOC-ADS, Fantasia Trading LLC d/b/a
`
`Ankerdirect v. Scramoge Technology Limited, IPR2022-00499, Apple Inc. v. Scramoge
`
`Technology Limited, PTAB-IPR2022-00529, Apple Inc. v. Scramoge Technology Limited,
`
`PTAB-IPR2022-00532.
`
`Nothing in Apple’s disclosures should be regarded as necessarily reflecting the proper
`
`interpretation of the claims or an interpretation of the claims Apple agrees with or proposes.
`
`Nothing herein should be construed as an admission that Apple agrees with Scramoge’s express
`
`- 8 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 9
`
`

`

`or implied claim constructions or that Scramoge has proposed any discernible constructions for
`
`claims and/or claim terms in its Infringement Contentions. Apple disputes Scramoge’s apparent
`
`claim interpretations and will propose alternative constructions to those proposed by Scramoge
`
`in its Infringement Contentions at the appropriate time. Nothing herein should be interpreted as
`
`reflecting Apple’s proposed claim construction positions. Apple expressly reserves the right to
`
`propose alternative constructions to those that have been or may be advocated by Scramoge.
`
`III.
`
`PRIOR ART DISCLOSURES
`
`In addition to the references cited on the face of the asserted patents and related patents,
`
`the admitted prior art references in the specifications of the asserted patents and related patents,
`
`the prosecution histories of the asserted patents and related patents, the references cited in any
`
`reexaminations, reissue proceedings, or other post-grant proceedings in the U.S. Patent Office
`
`of the asserted patents and related patents, and the references cited in any invalidity contentions
`
`or expert reports submitted in any action or proceedings involving the asserted patents or
`
`related patents, Apple below identifies the following prior art that anticipates each asserted
`
`claim or renders it obvious. Apple has set forth in detail in the accompanying claim charts the
`
`particular claims that are anticipated under 35 U.S.C. § 102 and/or rendered obvious under 35
`
`U.S.C. § 103 by the particular reference.
`
`A.
`
`Prior Art Patents
`
`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`CA2794703 A1 (Zhu)
`CA2794703 C (Zhu)
`CN101540554A (Zhao et al)
`CN102738869(A) (Zhang)
`CN103078365 B (Xia et al)
`CN103151812 B (Zhang)
`
`Canada
`Canada
`China
`China
`China
`China
`
`11/13/2012
`11/13/2012
`5/12/2009
`7/3/2012
`12/26/2012
`1/29/2013
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`1/16/2013
`12/20/2016
`9/23/2009
`10/17/2012
`12/23/2015
`3/4/2015
`
`- 9 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 10
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`CN103211376 A (Zhang)
`CN202405842 U (Ye)
`CN203326734U (Wei et al)
`JP2002101578 (Abe Hideaki)
`JP2002320347 (Ishiguro et al)
`JP2002354711 (Okuno et al)
`JP2006230032 (Daiho)
`JP2007336788A (Hoshino
`Masaru)
`JP2008125198
`JP2008206327 (Onishi et al)
`JP20100233364
`JP2010074894
`JP2010098861 A (Shoichi
`Toya)
`JP2011035964A (Aoki)
`JP2013106490
`JP2014007924 A (Norihiko
`Shirogane)
`JP3178882U
`JP3179782 U
`JP3427663B2 (Susumu et al)
`JP3692541 B2 (Nagai et al)
`JPH10-228337 (Shinozaki
`Kunio et al)
`KR100819753B1 (Jung)
`KR101162221 (Jung)
`KR101197078 (Chung)
`KR101393852 B1
`KR10-2012999 B1
`KR10-20130087400
`KR1554605 B1 (Kim et al)
`KR20030045545 (Lee)
`KR20070014804 (Min)
`
`3/26/2013
`12/19/2011
`6/21/2013
`9/26/2000
`4/18/2001
`5/22/2001
`2/15/2005
`6/19/2006
`
`11/9/2006
`2/21/2007
`3/27/2009
`9/16/2008
`10/16/2008
`
`7/30/2009
`11/16/2011
`6/27/2012
`
`7/24/2012
`9/7/2012
`3/12/1997
`2/3/1998
`2/17/1997
`
`9/12/2007
`12/29/2010
`5/9/2011
`4/6/2012
`6/27/2013
`7/24/2013
`5/6/2013
`12/4/2001
`7/29/2005
`
`China
`China
`China
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`Japan
`
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`
`- 10 -
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`7/24/2013
`8/29/2012
`12/4/2013
`4/5/2002
`10/31/2002
`12/6/2002
`8/31/2006
`12/27/2007
`
`5/29/2008
`9/4/2008
`10/14/2010
`4/2/2010
`4/30/2010
`
`2/17/2011
`5/30/2013
`1/16/2014
`
`9/12/2012
`10/24/2012
`7/22/2003
`9/7/2005
`8/25/1998
`
`4/8/2008
`7/5/2012
`11/7/2012
`5/2/2014
`8/14/2019
`7/9/2014
`9/22/2015
`6/11/2003
`2/1/2007
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 11
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`KR20090055630 (Kasai)
`KR20130067338 (Song)
`
`Republic of Korea
`Republic of Korea
`
`Republic of Korea
`United States
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`KR20130130191A (Bae)
`US Provisional Application
`61/019411 (Baarman et al)
`US10014721 (Singh et al)
`US10065510 (Murayama et al)
`US10090884 (Ettes et al)
`US10199877 B2 (Van Den
`Brink et al)
`United States
`US10250083 (Taylor et al)
`United States
`US10326309 (Lee et al)
`United States
`US10355525 (Singh et al)
`United States
`US10493853 B2 (Widmer et al)
`United States
`US10523276 B2 (Stone et al)
`US10693299 B2 (Petersen et al) United States
`US11063635 (Kozakai et al)
`United States
`US20010015697 (Wuidart)
`United States
`US20040070994 A1 (Takagi)
`United States
`US20040130915 (Baarman)
`United States
`US20040130916 (Baarman)
`United States
`US20040218406 (Jang et al)
`United States
`US20070182367 A1 (Partovi)
`United States
`US20070182368 A1 (Yang)
`United States
`US20070212596 A1 (Nebrigic)
`United States
`US20070279002 (Partovi)
`United States
`US20080197711 A1 (Kato et al) United States
`US20080211455 A1 (Park et al) United States
`US2008049372 (Loke)
`United States
`US2008061733A1 (Toya)
`United States
`US2008079392 (Baarman et al)
`United States
`US20090001941 (Hsu)
`United States
`
`10/12/2007
`12/13/2011
`Published:
`06/24/2013
`3/19/2012
`1/7/2008
`
`01/09/2015
`12/1/2015
`6/10/2015
`6/21/2017
`
`3/14/2013
`5/14/2012
`06/29/2018
`2/3/2017
`4/18/2012
`5/11/2018
`8/20/2019
`1/26/2001
`9/16/2003
`10/20/2003
`10/20/2003
`5/1/2003
`1/30/2007
`1/30/2006
`3/21/2007
`6/1/2007
`2/12/2008
`5/22/2008
`8/23/2007
`8/10/2007
`9/14/2007
`6/29/2007
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`6/2/2009
`6/24/2013
`
`12/2/2012
`
`07/03/2018
`9/4/2018
`10/2/2018
`2/5/2019
`
`4/2/2019
`6/18/2019
`07/16/2019
`12/3/2019
`12/31/2019
`6/23/2020
`7/13/2021
`8/23/2001
`4/15/2004
`7/8/2004
`7/8/2004
`11/4/2004
`8/9/2007
`8/9/2007
`9/13/2007
`12/6/2007
`8/21/2008
`9/4/2008
`2/28/2009
`3/13/2008
`4/3/2008
`1/1/2009
`
`- 11 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 12
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`4/16/2009
`9/17/2009
`4/16/2009
`7/9/2009
`3/4/2010
`
`5/6/2010
`6/24/2010
`9/9/2010
`3/18/2010
`8/18/2011
`9/8/2011
`10/6/2011
`10/27/2011
`
`10/27/2011
`2/16/2012
`4/12/2012
`5/24/2012
`6/21/2012
`
`5/7/2008
`9/11/2008
`5/7/2008
`6/7/2009
`11/13/2009
`
`10/31/2008
`5/13/2008
`3/2/2010
`6/11/2008
`2/15/2010
`12/13/2010
`1/7/2011
`8/27/2010
`
`4/27/2010
`10/25/2011
`10/12/2010
`11/17/2011
`12/16/2011
`
`11/16/2010
`
`8/9/2012
`
`11/4/2011
`2/6/2012
`4/19/2011
`5/27/2011
`
`12/15/2011
`7/28/2011
`
`8/23/2012
`9/13/2012
`10/25/2012
`11/29/2012
`
`12/27/2012
`1/31/2013
`
`7/27/2012
`
`1/31/2013
`
`8/6/2012
`3/12/2012
`
`2/7/2013
`2/14/2013
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`US20090096413 A1 (Partovi)
`US20090231885 (Won)
`US2009096413 (Partovi et al)
`US2009174263 (Baarman et al)
`US20100052615 A1
`(Loncarevic)
`US20100110741 A1 (Lin et al)
`US20100156343 A1 (Jung)
`US20100225173A1 (Aoyama)
`US2010066304 A1 (Oshimi)
`US20110199045 A1 (Hui et al)
`US20110215757 A1 (Tsai)
`US20110241603 A1 (Chang)
`US20110260681 A1 (Guccione
`et al)
`US20110260681 A1 (Guccione) United States
`US20120039102 A1 (Shinoda)
`United States
`US20120088555 A1 (Hu)
`United States
`US20120127765 (Maruyama)
`United States
`US20120153717 (Obayashi et
`United States
`al)
`US20120201054 A1 (Kitamura
`et al)
`US20120212178 A1 (Kim)
`US20120229034 A1 (Yu et al)
`US20120268064 (Ostrom et al)
`US20120299553 (Menegoli et
`al)
`US20120326515 (Murai)
`US20130026981 A1 (Van der
`Lee)
`US20130026984 A1
`(Yamamoto et al)
`US20130033118 (Karalis)
`US20130039099 (Wu)
`
`United States
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`United States
`United States
`
`United States
`
`United States
`United States
`
`- 12 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 13
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`United States
`US20130063983 A1 (Sumi)
`US20130077360 A1 (Low er al) United States
`US20130082536 A1 (Taylor et
`United States
`al)
`United States
`US20130162201 A1 (Yeh)
`United States
`US20130175981 (Yeh)
`United States
`US20130241304 (Bae)
`United States
`US20130278207 (Yoo)
`United States
`US20140009109 A1 (Lee)
`United States
`US20140009120 (Kim)
`United States
`US20140097790 (Yeh)
`United States
`US20140132206 (Zhu)
`United States
`US20140152250 A1 (Vijayan)
`US20140167690 A1 (Ting et al) United States
`US20140168019 (Hirobe et al)
`United States
`US20140368164 (Jung)
`United States
`US20150008748 A1 (Deboy et
`United States
`al)
`US20150357863 A1 (Sadakata
`et al)
`US20210152025 A1 (Nagatsuka
`et al)
`US20210234412 A1 (Walley et
`al)
`US3537192 (Churchill)
`US3942535 (Schulman)
`US3942535 (Schulman)
`US5598326 (Liu et al)
`US5600225 (Goto)
`US5702431 (Wang)
`US5703573 (Fujimoto et al)
`US5991170 (Nagai et al
`US6067243 (Suzuki)
`US6227204 (Baumann)
`
`United States
`
`United States
`
`United States
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`- 13 -
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`3/14/2013
`3/28/2013
`4/4/2013
`
`6/27/2013
`7/11/2013
`9/19/2013
`10/24/2013
`1/9/2014
`1/9/2014
`4/10/2014
`5/15/2014
`6/5/2014
`6/19/2014
`7/19/2014
`12/18/2014
`1/8/2015
`
`9/6/2012
`9/24/2012
`3/21/2012
`
`12/27/2011
`1/6/2012
`3/14/2013
`4/18/2013
`7/8/2013
`7/8/2013
`10/10/2012
`11/12/2012
`11/25/2013
`1/28/2014
`10/17/2012
`12/21/2012
`1/16/2013
`
`8/20/2015
`
`12/10/2015
`
`1/27/2021
`
`5/20/2021
`
`4/14/2021
`
`7/29/2021
`
`1/11/1968
`7/26/1974
`7/24/1976
`1/25/1996
`6/20/1995
`9/17/1996
`1/11/1996
`2/3/1998
`3/18/1999
`0/14/1991
`
`11/3/1970
`03/09//1976
`3/9/1976
`1/28/1997
`2/4/1997
`12/30/1997
`12/30/1997
`11/23/1999
`5/23/2000
`5/8/2001
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 14
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`US6512437 (Jin et al)
`US6772011 (Dolgin)
`US6825620 (Kuennen et al)
`US7167384 (Yasumura)
`US7173467 (Liu)
`US7193868 (Yasumura)
`US7211986 (Flowerdew et al)
`US7633263 (Toya)
`US7791311 (Sagoo)
`US7825543 (Karalis)
`US7948208 (Partovi)
`US7952322 (Partovi et al)
`US8004236 B2 (Chen et al)
`US8008888 (Oyobe et al)
`US8035255 B2 (Kurs et al)
`US8060011 (Jin)
`US8076801 (Karalis et al)
`US8090550 B2 (Azancot et al)
`US8097983 (Karalis et al)
`US8102147 (Jung)
`US8111041 (Onishi et al)
`US8116681 (Baarman)
`US8129864 B2 (Baarman et al)
`US8140168 (Olson)
`US8159182 B2 (Kato et al)
`US8160654 (Onishi et al)
`US8169185 B2 (Partovi et al)
`US8188619 (Azancot et al)
`US8228025 A (Ho et al)
`US8248024 (Yuan)
`US8294418 (Hui)
`US8314513 (Aoyama)
`US8338990 (Baarman et al)
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`- 14 -
`
`7/3/1998
`8/20/2002
`9/18/2002
`8/13/2004
`3/31/2005
`3/6/2006
`7/1/2004
`8/10/2007
`10/24/2006
`3/26/2008
`6/1/2007
`1/30/2007
`12/26/2008
`9/25/2008
`11/6/2009
`2/20/2008
`5/14/2009
`9/21/2009
`5/8/2009
`7/2/2008
`2/15/2008
`10/1/2009
`1/7/2009
`4/30/2004
`5/28/2008
`1/14/2008
`5/7/2008
`7/2/2009
`11/9/2007
`8/15/2008
`2/3/2012
`3/2/2010
`3/12/2009
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`1/28/2003
`8/3/2004
`11/30/2004
`1/23/2007
`2/6/2007
`3/20/2007
`5/1/2007
`12/15/2009
`9/7/2010
`11/2/2010
`5/24/2011
`5/31/2011
`8/23/2011
`8/30/2011
`10/11/2011
`11/15/2011
`12/13/2011
`1/3/2012
`1/17/2012
`1/24/2012
`2/7/2012
`2/14/2012
`5/6/2012
`3/20/2012
`4/17/2012
`4/17/2012
`5/1/2012
`5/29/2012
`7/24/2012
`8/21/2012
`10/23/2012
`11/20/2012
`12/25/2012
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 15
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`US8362651 (Hamam et al)
`US8427012 (Azancot et al)
`US8427101 (Saunamaki)
`US8446045 (Smith et al)
`US8461723 (Kojima)
`US8477519 (Nakamura)
`US8482158 (Kurs et al)
`US8487481 B2 (Cook et al)
`US8519667 (Tsai)
`US8629651 (Guccione)
`US8674551 (Low et al)
`US8710701 (Cook et al)
`US8729734 (Cook)
`US8729735 (Urano)
`US8791601 (Furukawa)
`US8804375 (Manabe)
`US8829725 (Urano)
`US8855554 (Cook et al)
`US8928275 B2 (Elo)
`US8942624 (Singh et al)
`US8946939 B2 (Drennen)
`US9013895 (Baarman)
`US9018900 (Yamamoto)
`US9035600 (Park et al)
`US9083204 (Azancot et al)
`US9123467 (Wu et al)
`US9178445 (Hara)
`US9203475 B2 (Kim et al)
`US9225391 (Bae)
`US9231412 B2 (Lisi et al)
`US9246409 (Wu)
`US9287039 (Lee)
`US9305700 B2 (Lisuwandi)
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`- 15 -
`
`10/1/2009
`4/27/2012
`11/18/2009
`8/20/2009
`12/9/2009
`7/6/2011
`12/28/2009
`6/21/2012
`5/11/2011
`4/27/2010
`11/24/2010
`12/17/2012
`2/29/2008
`11/11/2010
`3/24/2011
`11/29/2011
`3/18/2011
`3/4/2009
`6/18/2010
`03/30/2012
`6/17/2012
`7/27/2011
`6/27/2012
`12/14/2011
`1/10/2014
`1/23/2013
`9/17/2013
`12/21/2012
`3/14/2013
`12/20/2011
`10/23/2012
`7/8/2013
`4/12/2013
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`1/29/2013
`4/23/2013
`4/23/2013
`5/21/2013
`6/11/2013
`7/2/2013
`7/9/2013
`7/16/2013
`8/27/2013
`1/14/2014
`3/18/2014
`4/29/2014
`5/20/2014
`5/20/2014
`7/29/2014
`8/12/2014
`9/9/2014
`10/7/2014
`1/6/2015
`01/27/2015
`2/3/2015
`4/21/2015
`4/28/2015
`5/19/2015
`7/14/2015
`9/1/2015
`11/3/2015
`12/1/2015
`12/29/2015
`1/5/2016
`1/26/2016
`3/15/2016
`4/5/2016
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 16
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`
`3/20/2014
`8/6/2012
`9/21/2012
`6/7/2013
`5/23/2013
`6/7/2013
`4/12/2013
`1/7/2014
`4/23/2012
`11/18/2013
`1/27/2014
`4/7/2011
`4/18/2013
`6/20/2014
`8/19/2014
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`4/19/2016
`7/5/2016
`8/23/2016
`8/30/2016
`10/4/2016
`10/4/2016
`10/18/2016
`11/8/2016
`11/22/2016
`11/29/2016
`1/3/2017
`2/7/2017
`2/14/2017
`5/23/2017
`5/23/2017
`
`United States
`
`12/2/2015
`
`10/10/2017
`
`US9318915 (Miller et al)
`US9384885 B2 (Karalis)
`US9425864 (Staring)
`US9431169 B2 (Huang et al)
`US9461479 (Chae et al)
`US9461714 (Cook)
`US9473210 (Komiyama)
`US9490652 (Kim)
`US9502925 (Kim et al)
`US9509168 B2 (Ye et al)
`US9537345 (Wang)
`US9561730 (Widmer et al)
`US9570936 (Yoo)
`US9660479 (Jung)
`US9660514 (Hideki Sadakata
`US)
`US9787104 B2 (Murayama et
`al)
`US9843219 (Ye)
`US9843226 B2 (Lee et al)
`US9859956 (Kissin)
`US9876535 B2 (Keeling et al)
`US9882434 (Kohara et al)
`US9948141 (Hosotani)
`US9960640 (Mach et al)
`WO2006011769A1 (Lee)
`
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`United States
`World Intellectual
`Property
`Organization
`World Intellectual
`Property
`Organization
`World Intellectual
`Property
`Organization
`WO2008114268A2 (Azancot et World Intellectual
`
`WO2007069293 A1 (Oshimi)
`
`WO2008017818A1 (Pollard)
`
`11/4/2016
`12/29/2014
`3/14/2013
`2/21/2013
`2/28/2013
`4/8/2015
`6/2/2014
`7/29/2005
`
`12/12/2017
`12/12/2017
`1/2/2018
`1/23/2018
`1/30/2018
`4/17/2018
`5/1/2018
`2/2/2006
`
`12/12/2005
`
`6/21/2007
`
`8/3/2007
`
`2/14/2008
`
`3/23/2008
`
`9/25/2008
`
`- 16 -
`
`Scramoge Technology Ltd.
`Ex. 2009 - Page 17
`
`

`

`Patent or Publication Number Country of Origin
`
`Filing Date
`
`al)
`
`Date of Issue or
`Publication
`
`Property
`Organization
`

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket