throbber
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`MARSHALL DIVISION
`
`
`
`BISHOP DISPLAY TECH LLC
`Plaintiff,
`
`
`v.
`
`SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.;
`SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS AMERICA,
`INC.; and SAMSUNG DISPLAY CO., LTD.,
`A KOREAN COMPANY
`Defendant.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Civil Action No. 2:21-cv-00139
`
`Jury Trial Requested
`
`
`
`PLAINTIFF’S DISCLOSURE OF
`ASSERTED CLAIMS AND INFRINGEMENT CONTENTIONS
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-1 and 3-2, Plaintiff Bishop Display Tech LLC (“Plaintiff” or “Bishop
`
`Display”) submits its disclosure of asserted claims and infringement contentions to Defendants
`
`Samsung Display Co., Ltd. (“SDC”), Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (“SEC”), and Samsung
`
`Electronics America, Inc. (“SEA”) (collectively, “Defendants” or “Samsung”).
`
`The following asserted claims and contentions are based upon Bishop Display’s good
`
`faith evaluation of information known to Bishop Display at this time based on publicly available
`
`information and documents, including reverse-engineering of select products. Bishop Display
`
`reserves its right to supplement and/or amend these Asserted Claims and Infringement
`
`Contentions in view of information and/or documents that may be obtained during discovery,
`
`further investigation, the Court’s claim construction ruling, applicable case law and authorities,
`
`and/or any other reasons permitted under the Court’s order, the Patent Rules, and the Federal
`
`Rules of Civil Procedure. See Eolas Techs. Inc. v. Amazon.com, Inc., No. 6:15-CV-01038, 2016
`
`WL 7666160, at *2 (E.D. Tex. Dec. 5, 2016) (“[G]iven Plaintiff’s assertion that Defendants have
`
`1
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 1
`
`

`

`not produced all documents and code reflecting their server architectures, it is unreasonable to
`
`expect Plaintiff to draft ICs in great detail . . . . [C]ontentions should become more detailed with
`
`the conclusion of fact discovery and claim construction.”).
`
`I. P.R. 3-1 Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions
`
`(a) Each claim of each patent in suit that is allegedly infringed by each opposing
`party;
`
`By making, using, testing, offering for sale, selling, and/or importing any of the Accused
`
`Instrumentalities identified herein, Defendants, either by themselves (individually and/or in
`
`concert) and/or via an agent directly and/or indirectly infringe U.S. Patent No. 6,819,377 (the
`
`“’377 patent”), U.S. Patent No. 6,822,706 (the “’706 patent”), U.S. Patent No. 7,583,347 (the
`
`“’347 patent”), U.S. Patent No. 7,995,047 (the “’047 patent”), U.S. Patent No. 8,093,830 (the
`
`“’830 patent”), and U.S. Patent No. 8,016,449 (the “’449 patent”) (collectively, the “patents-in-
`
`suit”). Based on information presently available, Plaintiff contends that the Defendants infringe
`
`the claims identified in Exhibits H-M, including the following claims of the patents-in-suit:
`
`1. Claim 1 of the ’377 patent;
`
`2. Claim 1 of the ’706 patent;
`
`3. Claim 1 of the ’347 patent;
`
`4. Claim 1 of the ’047 patent;
`
`5. Claim 1 of the ’830 patent; and
`
`6. Claims 1, 2, 3, and 4 of the ’449 patent.
`
`(b) Separately for each asserted claim, each accused apparatus, product, device,
`process, method, act, or other instrumentality (“Accused Instrumentality”) of
`each opposing party of which the party is aware. This identification shall be as
`specific as possible. Each product, device, and apparatus must be identified by
`name or model number, if known. Each method or process must be identified by
`name, if known, or by any product, device, or apparatus which, when used,
`allegedly results in the practice of the claimed method or process;
`
`2
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 2
`
`

`

`
`The Accused Instrumentalities of which Bishop Display is aware are identified below.
`
`Plaintiff reserves the right, in response to discovery or as otherwise permitted, to supplement its
`
`identification of Accused Instrumentalities.
`
`1. The ’377 Accused Instrumentalities
`
`Based on publicly-available information and reverse-engineering of select products, each
`
`of the ’377 Accused Instrumentalities include any Samsung LCD structure (excluding OLED)
`
`and any of Samsungs’s TVs, monitors, or laptops comprising a Samsung or third party LCD
`
`structure identified that are in Appendix 1, and all other reasonably similar products. Each of the
`
`’377 Accused Instrumentalities result in Samsung’s direct and/or indirect infringement of the
`
`asserted claims of the ’377 patent. Appendix 1 is not intended to be an exhaustive list, and
`
`Plaintiff reserves the right, in response to discovery or as otherwise permitted, to supplement
`
`Appendix 1 to include additional Accused Instrumentalities. All Instrumentalities in Appendix 1
`
`made after the expiration date of the ’377 patent are not Accused Instrumentalities.
`
`2. The ’706 Accused Instrumentalities
`
`Based on publicly-available information and reverse-engineering of select products, each
`
`of the ’706 Accused Instrumentalities include any Samsung LCD structure (excluding OLED)
`
`and any of Samsungs’s TVs, monitors, or laptops comprising a Samsung or third party LCD
`
`structure that are in Appendix 1, and all other reasonably similar products. Each of the ’706
`
`Accused Instrumentalities result in Samsung’s direct and/or indirect infringement of the asserted
`
`claims of the ’706 patent. Appendix 1 is not intended to be an exhaustive list, and Plaintiff
`
`reserves the right, in response to discovery or as otherwise permitted, to supplement Appendix 1
`
`to include additional Accused Instrumentalities. All Instrumentalities in Appendix 1 made after
`
`the expiration date of the ’706 patent are not Accused Instrumentalities.
`
`3
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 3
`
`

`

`3. The ’347 Accused Instrumentalities
`
`Based on publicly-available information and reverse-engineering of select products, each
`
`of the ’347 Accused Instrumentalities include any Samsung active matrix LCD (excluding TN
`
`and OLED) and any of Samsungs’s TVs, monitors, or laptops comprising a Samsung or third
`
`party active matrix LCD that are in Appendix 1, and all other reasonably similar products. Each
`
`of the ’347 Accused Instrumentalities result in Samsung’s direct and/or indirect infringement of
`
`the asserted claims of the ’347 patent. Appendix 1 is not intended to be an exhaustive list, and
`
`Plaintiff reserves the right, in response to discovery or as otherwise permitted, to supplement
`
`Appendix 1 to include additional Accused Instrumentalities.
`
`4. The ’047 Accused Instrumentalities
`
`Based on publicly-available information and reverse-engineering of select products, each
`
`of the ’047 Accused Instrumentalities include any Samsung power supply comprising two or
`
`more output terminals and any of Samsungs’s TVs, monitors, or laptops comprising a Samsung
`
`or third party power supply comprising two or more output terminals that are in Appendix 1, and
`
`all other reasonably similar products. Each of the ’047 Accused Instrumentalities result in
`
`Samsung’s direct and/or indirect infringement of the asserted claims of the ’047 patent.
`
`Appendix 1 is not intended to be an exhaustive list, and Plaintiff reserves the right, in response to
`
`discovery or as otherwise permitted, to supplement Appendix 1 to include additional Accused
`
`Instrumentalities.
`
`Based on currently available information, Bishop Display has not confirmed infringement
`
`by UN32N5300 of the ’047 patent. Bishop Display does not currently accuse the UN32N5300 of
`
`infringing the ’047 patent. Accordingly, that product, as well as any others of Samsung’s
`
`products determined through discovery to have a similarly non-infringing structure, are not
`
`4
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 4
`
`

`

`accused of infringing this patent. Plaintiff reserves the right, in response to discovery as
`
`otherwise permitted, to supplement or otherwise amend the identified Accused Instrumentalities
`
`with respect to this patent.
`
`5. The ’830 Accused Instrumentalities
`
`Based on publicly-available information and reverse-engineering of select products, each
`
`of the ’830 Accused Instrumentalities include any Samsung semiconductor light source driver
`
`and any of Samsungs’s TVs, monitors, or laptops comprising a Samsung or third party
`
`semiconductor light source driver that are in Appendix 1, and all other reasonably similar
`
`products. Each of the ’830 Accused Instrumentalities result in Samsung’s direct and/or indirect
`
`infringement of the asserted claims of the ’830 patent. Appendix 1 is not intended to be an
`
`exhaustive list, and Plaintiff reserves the right, in response to discovery or as otherwise
`
`permitted, to supplement Appendix 1 to include additional Accused Instrumentalities.
`
`6. The ’449 Accused Instrumentalities
`
`Based on publicly-available information and reverse-engineering of select products, each
`
`of the ’449 Accused Instrumentalities include any Samsung device comprising a light source
`
`section that includes at least one light source which emits a laser beam and any of Samsungs’s
`
`products that includes a Samsung or third party device comprising a light source section that
`
`includes at least one light source which emits a laser beam, and all other reasonably similar
`
`products. Each of the ’449 Accused Instrumentalities result in Samsung’s direct and/or indirect
`
`infringement of the asserted claims of the ’449 patent. Based on publicly available information,
`
`the ’449 Accused Instrumentalities include at least:
`
`
`
`
`
`5
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 5
`
`

`

`• The LSP7T series, including at least model no. SP-LSP7TFAXZA.; and
`
`• The LSP9T series, including at least model no. SP-LSP9TFAXZA.
`
`This is not intended to be an exhaustive list, and Plaintiff reserves the right, in response to
`
`discovery or as otherwise permitted, to supplement this list to include additional ‘449 Accused
`
`Instrumentalities.
`
`Plaintiff expressly reserves the right to seek leave of Court to augment and supplement
`
`these disclosures after discovery from Defendants, or as permitted by the Court, the Patent Rules,
`
`or the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Plaintiff expects that this disclosure may be subject to
`
`amendment or supplementation to identify and accuse additional products developed or made
`
`available after the date on which these contentions are served, or of which Plaintiff was not
`
`aware at the time that these contentions were prepared. Plaintiff reserves the right to seek leave
`
`of Court to augment and supplement this disclosure after discovery from Defendants, or as
`
`permitted by the Court, the Patent Rules, or the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
`
`(c) A chart identifying specifically where each element of each asserted claim is
`found within each Accused Instrumentality, including for each element that such
`party contends is governed by 35 U.S.C. § 112(6), the identity of the structure(s),
`act(s), or materials(s) in the Accused Instrumentality that performs the claimed
`functions;
`
`Based on publicly available information and Plaintiff’s reverse engineering efforts, each
`
`of the respective Accused Instrumentalities infringe the asserted claims of the patents-in-suit in
`
`the same or substantially similar manner. Moreover, discovery has yet to begin and the infringing
`
`aspects of the Accused Instrumentalities are non-public. As such, Plaintiff reserves the right to
`
`amend its list of Accused Instrumentalities. See MOSAID Techs. Inc. v. Micron Tech., Inc. No.
`
`2:06-CV-302 (DF), 2008 WL 11344767, at *2 (E.D. Tex. Jan. 29, 2008) (holding that “the
`
`6
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 6
`
`

`

`cumulative authority in this district” is that when “there is a lack of public information” a
`
`plaintiff need not “perform reverse engineering on every accused product[] to satisfy P.R.3-1.”).
`
`The attached claim charts are, therefore, representative of the manner and theory of
`
`infringement pertaining to the Accused Instrumentalities for each of the patents-in-suit. See
`
`Eolas Techs., 2016 WL 7666160, at *3 (“[T]his Court has consistently found that multiple
`
`instrumentalities can apply to the same chart where separate charts would be identical for each
`
`instrumentality.”); see also Rapid Completions LLC v. Baker Hughes Inc., 6:15-CV-724, 2016
`
`WL 3407688, at *7 (E.D. Tex. June 21, 2016) (“[A] plaintiff may provide an exemplar chart,
`
`which encompasses multiple products, if that chart would be representative of each of those
`
`products.”). The accused features and functionalities of the Accused Instrumentalities are non-
`
`public and instead based on Plaintiff’s reverse-engineering efforts and publicly available
`
`information. As such, Plaintiff reserves the right to amend or supplement its infringement charts
`
`and the list of Accused Instrumentalities after receiving discovery in this matter.
`
`1. The elements of the asserted claims of the ’377 patent are found within the Accused
`
`Instrumentalities as identified in the charts contained with Exhibits H1-H10.1
`
`2. The elements of the asserted claims of the ’706 patent are found within the Accused
`
`Instrumentalities as identified in the charts contained with Exhibits I1-I10.
`
`3. The elements of the asserted claims of the ’347 patent are found within the Accused
`
`Instrumentalities as identified in the charts contained with Exhibits J1-J8.
`
`
`1 Reference to the Accused Product or Representative Product in each of the attached claim
`charts for the patents-in-suit is intended to put Defendants on notice as to the infringement
`theories for all of the Accused Instrumentalities based on information currently known to
`Plaintiff.
`
`7
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 7
`
`

`

`4. The elements of the asserted claims of the ’047 patent are found within the Accused
`
`Instrumentalities as identified in the charts contained with Exhibits K1-K4.
`
`5. The elements of the asserted claims of the ’830 patent are found within the Accused
`
`Instrumentalities as identified in the charts contained with Exhibits L1-L5.
`
`6. The elements of the asserted claims of the ’449 patent are found within the Accused
`
`Instrumentalities as identified in the charts contained with Exhibit M1.
`
`The charts are based on publicly available information and reverse-engineering information
`
`currently accessible to Plaintiff, and no discovery has occurred to date. Specifically, Plaintiff
`
`believes that evidence of infringement will be found in Samsung’s documents, specifications,
`
`schematics, and other proprietary information, which has not yet been produced or disclosed.
`
`Plaintiff reserves the right to seek leave of Court to augment and supplement this disclosure after
`
`discovery from Samsung, or as permitted by the Court, the Patent Rules, or the Federal Rules of
`
`Civil Procedure. See Eolas Techs., 2016 WL 7666160, at *2 (“[G]iven Plaintiff’s assertion that
`
`Defendant’s have not produced all documents and code reflecting their server architectures, it is
`
`unreasonable to expect Plaintiff to draft ICs in great detail . . . . [C]ontentions should become
`
`more detailed with the conclusion of fact discovery and claim construction.”).
`
`(d) Whether each element of each asserted claim is claimed to be literally present or
`present under the doctrine of equivalents in the Accused Instrumentality;
`
`As the Court has not construed any claim term, it is not yet clear whether Plaintiff will
`
`rely on the doctrine of equivalents. Accordingly, Plaintiff reserves the right to amend its
`
`infringement contentions as necessary. Based on its current understanding of the claim language
`
`and publicly available information pertaining to the Accused Instrumentalities, and without
`
`notice of any claim construction or non-infringement position from Defendants, Plaintiff asserts
`
`that Defendants literally infringe each element of the asserted claims. However, any claim
`
`8
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 8
`
`

`

`element not literally present in or performed by the Accused Instrumentalities is satisfied under
`
`the doctrine of equivalents because any difference between such claim element and the accused
`
`element is insubstantial. In other words, the accused element performs substantially the same
`
`function, in substantially the same way, to achieve substantially the same result.
`
`(e) For any patent that claims priority to an earlier application, the priority date to
`which each asserted claim allegedly is entitled;
`
`Each of the patents-in-suit is entitled to a priority date no later than the filing date of the
`
`earliest application to which it claims priority. To date, Plaintiff believes the patents-in-suit have
`
`the following priority dates. Plaintiff reserves the right to amend its list of priority dates as
`
`additional information becomes available, such as in response to discovery from third parties.
`
`- The asserted claims of the ’377 patent are entitled to a priority date at least as early as
`
`May 23, 1997.
`
`- The asserted claims of the ’706 patent are entitled to a priority date at least as early as
`
`May 23, 1997.
`
`- The asserted claims of the ’347 patent are entitled to a priority date at least as early as
`
`July 31, 2000.
`
`- The asserted claims of the ’047 patent are entitled to a priority date at least as early as
`
`December 13, 2006.
`
`- The asserted claims of the ’830 patent are entitled to a priority date at least as early as
`
`July 3, 2008.
`
`- The asserted claims of the ’449 patent are entitled to a priority date at least as early as
`
`March 20, 2008.
`
`(f) If a party claiming patent infringement wishes to preserve the right to reply, for
`any purpose, on the assertion that its own apparatus, product, device, process,
`method, act, or other instrumentality practices the claimed invention, the party
`
`9
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 9
`
`

`

`must identify, separately for each asserted claim, each such apparatus, product,
`device, process, method, act, or other instrumentality that incorporates or
`reflects that particular claim.
`
`Plaintiff is not aware of any apparatus, product, device, process, method, act, or other
`
`instrumentality of its own that practices the claimed inventions.
`
`II.
`
`P.R. 3-2 Document Production Accompanying Disclosure
`
`(a)
`
`Plaintiff is not presently aware of any non-privileged documents sufficient to
`
`evidence discussion with, disclosure to, or other manner of providing to a third party, or sale of
`
`or offer to sell, the claimed inventions prior to the date of application for the patents-in-suit.
`
`(b)
`
`Plaintiff is not presently aware of any non-privileged documents that evidence
`
`conception, reduction to practice, design, and development of each claimed invention that were
`
`created on or before the above referenced dates for each of the patents-in-suit. Plaintiff notes that
`
`documents responsive to P.R. 3-2(b) may be in the possession of the inventors and/or original
`
`assignees of the patents-in-suit. In the event that discovery leads to documents that evidence
`
`conception, reduction to practice, design, and development of any claimed invention that were
`
`created on or before the date of application for the patents-in-suit, Plaintiff reserves the right to
`
`claim such date.
`
`(c)
`
`Copies of the file histories for the patents-in-suit are produced herewith and bear
`
`production numbers as follows:
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`-
`
`’377 patent: BDT_SAM003119 to BDT_SAM003262.
`
`’706 patent: BDT_SAM003271 to BDT_SAM003405.
`
`’347 patent: BDT_SAM006485 to BDT_SAM006746.
`
`’047 patent: BDT_SAM006765 to BDT_SAM006934.
`
`’830 patent: BDT_SAM007174 to BDT_SAM007345.
`
`10
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 10
`
`

`

`-
`
`’449 patent: BDT_SAM006954 to BDT_SAM007154.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`/s/ John Murphy
`Patrick J. Conroy
`Texas Bar No. 24012448
`Justin Kimble
`Texas Bar No. 24036909
`T. William Kennedy Jr.
`Texas Bar No. 24055771
`Jon Rastegar
`Texas Bar No. 24064043
`Ryan Griffin
`Texas Bar No. 24053687
`John Murphy
`Texas Bar No. 24056024
`Nelson Bumgardner Conroy PC
`2727 North Harwood Street
`Suite 250
`Dallas, TX 75201
`Tel: (817) 377-9111
`pat@nelbum.com
`justin@nelbum.com
`bill@nelbum.com
`jon@nelbum.com
`ryan@nelbum.com
`murphy@nelbum.com
`
`Attorneys for Plaintiff
`BISHOP DISPLAY TECH LLC
`
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`
`Dated: September 29, 2021
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`The undersigned hereby certifies that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document
`
`was served on Defendants through its respective counsel via e-mail on September 29, 2021.
`
`/s/ John Murphy
`
`
`
`
`
`11
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 11
`
`

`

`APPENDIX 1
`TVs
`
`Series
`TU6950
`AU8000
`AU8000
`AU8000
`AU8000
`AU8000
`AU8000
`TU9010
`TU9000
`QN85A
`QN85A
`QN85A
`QN85A
`QN90A
`QN90A
`QN90A
`QN90A
`QN90A
`QN800A
`QN800A
`QN800A
`QN900A
`QN900A
`QN900A
`LST9T
`LST9T
`Q70A
`Q70A
`Q70A
`Q70A
`Q80A
`Q80A
`Q80A
`Q80A
`Q80A
`Q80T
`LS05T
`LS03A
`
`Model
`UN82TU6950FXZA
`UN43AU8000FXZA
`UN50AU8000FXZA
`UN55AU8000FXZA
`UN65AU8000FXZA
`UN75AU8000FXZA
`UN85AU8000FXZA
`UN86TU9010FXZA
`UN86TU9000FXZA
`QN55QN85AAFXZA
`QN65QN85AAFXZA
`QN75QN85AAFXZA
`QN85QN85AAFXZA
`QN50QN90AAFXZA
`QN55QN90AAFXZA
`QN65QN90AAFXZA
`QN75QN90AAFXZA
`QN85QN90AAFXZA
`QN65QN800AFXZA
`QN75QN800AFXZA
`QN85QN800AFXZA
`QN65QN900AFXZA
`QN75QN900AFXZA
`QN85QN900AFXZA
`QN65LST9TAFXZA
`QN75LST9TAFXZA
`QN55Q70AAFXZA
`QN65Q70AAFXZA
`QN75Q70AAFXZA
`QN85Q70AAFXZA
`QN50Q80AAFXZA
`QN55Q80AAFXZA
`QN65Q80AAFXZA
`QN75Q80AAFXZA
`QN85Q80AAFXZA
`QN50Q80TAFXZA
`QN43LS05TAFXZA
`QN43LS03AAFXZA
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 12
`
`

`

`QN75Q800TAFXZA
`
`QN50LS03AAFXZA
`QN55LS03AAFXZA
`QN65LS03AAFXZA
`QN75LS03AAFXZA
`QN32Q60AAFXZA
`QN43Q60AAFXZA
`QN50Q60AAFXZA
`QN55Q60AAFXZA
`QN60Q60AAFXZA
`QN65Q60AAFXZA
`QN70Q60AAVXZA
`QN75Q60AAFXZA
`QN85Q60AAFXZA
`QN32LS03TBFXZA
`QN43LS01TAFXZA
`QN43LS03TAFXZA
`QN43Q60TAFXZA
`QN49Q80TAFXZA
`QN50LS03TAFXZA
`QN50Q60TAFXZA
`QN82Q60TAFXZA
`QN55LS01TAFXZA
`QN55LS03TAFXZA
`QN55LST7TAFXZA
`QN55Q60TAFXZA
`QN55Q70TAFXZA
`QN82Q70TAFXZA
`QN65Q80TAFXZA
`QN55Q80TAFXZA
`QN55Q90TAFXZA
`QN58Q60TAFXZA
`QN65LS03TAFXZA
`QN65LST7TAFXZA
`QN65Q60TAFXZA
`QN65Q70TAFXZA
`QN65Q800TAFXZA
`QN65Q80TAFXZA
`QN65Q900TSFXZA
`QN65Q90TAFXZA
`QN75LS03TAFXZA
`QN75LST7TAFXZA
`QN75Q60TAFXZA
`QN75Q70TAFXZA
`
`LS03A
`LS03A
`LS03A
`LS03A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`Q60A
`LS03T
`LS01T
`LS03T
`Q60T
`Q80T
`LS03T
`Q60T
`Q60T
`LS01T
`LS03T
`LST7T
`Q60T
`Q70T
`Q70T
`Q80T
`Q80T
`Q90T
`Q60T
`LS03T
`LST7T
`Q60T
`Q70T
`Q800
`Q80T
`Q900TS
`Q90T
`LS03T
`LST7T
`Q60T
`Q70T
`Q800
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 13
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 13
`
`

`

`QN32Q50RAFXZA
`
`QN75Q80TAFXZA
`QN75Q900TSFXZA
`QN82Q800TAFXZA
`QN75Q90TAFXZA
`QN82Q800TAFXZA
`QN85Q60TAFXZA
`QN85Q70TAFXZA
`QN85Q80TAFXZA
`QN85Q900RAFXZA
`QN85Q900TSFXZA
`QN85Q90TAFXZA
`QN85Q950TSFXZA
`UN43TU7000FXZA
`UN43TU8000FXZA
`UN50TU7000FXZA
`UN50TU8000FXZA
`UN55TU7000FXZA
`UN60TU7000FXZA
`UN65TU7000FXZA
`UN70TU7000BXZA
`UN75TU7000FXZA
`UN82TU7000FXZA
`UN43TU8000FXZA
`UN50TU8000FXZA
`UN55TU8000FXZA
`UN65TU8000FXZA
`UN75TU8000FXZA
`UN85TU8000FXZA
`UN55TU8300FXZA
`UN65TU8300FXZA
`UN55TU850DFXZA
`UN58TU7000FXZA
`UN65RU9000FXZA
`UN65TU7000FXZA
`UN65TU8000FXZA
`UN65TU8300FXZA
`UN65TU850DFXZA
`UN70TU7000FXZA
`UN75RU9000FXZA
`UN75TU7000FXZA
`UN75TU8000FXZA
`UN82RU9000FXZA
`UN85TU8000FXZA
`
`Q80T
`Q900TS
`Q800T
`Q90T
`Q800
`Q60T
`Q70T
`Q80T
`Q900
`Q900TS
`Q90T
`Q950
`TU7000
`TU8000
`TU7000
`TU8000
`TU7000
`TU7000
`TU7000
`TU7000
`TU7000
`TU7000
`TU8000
`TU8000
`TU8000
`TU8000
`TU8000
`TU8000
`TU8300
`TU8300
`TU850D
`TU7000
`RU9000
`TU7000
`TU8000
`TU8300
`TU850D
`TU7000
`RU9000
`TU7000
`TU8000
`RU9000
`TU8000
`Q50R
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 14
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 14
`
`

`

`a7D
`
`QN43LS03RAFXZA
`QN43Q60RAFXZA
`QN43Q6DRAFXZA
`QN49LS03RAFXZA
`QN49Q60RAFXZA
`QN49Q6DRAFXZA
`QN49Q70RAFXZA
`QN49Q7DRAFXZA
`QN55LS01RAFXZA
`QN55LS01RAFXZA
`QN55LS03RAFXZA
`QN55Q60RAFXZA
`QN55Q6DRAFXZA
`QN55Q70RAFXZA
`QN55Q7DRAFXZA
`QN55Q80RAFXZA
`QN55Q80RAFXZA
`QN55Q900RBFXZA
`QN65LS03RAFXZA
`QN65Q60RAFXZA
`QN65Q60RAFXZA
`QN65Q6DRAFXZA
`QN65Q6DRAFXZA
`QN65Q70RAFXZA
`QN65Q70RAFXZA
`QN65Q7DRAFXZA
`QN65Q7DRAFXZA
`QN65Q80RAFXZA
`QN65Q80RAFXZA
`QN65Q80RAFXZA
`QN65Q900RBFXZA
`QN65Q90RAFXZA
`QN65Q90RAFXZA
`QN75Q60RAFXZA
`QN75Q6DRAFXZA
`QN75Q70RAFXZA
`QN75Q7DRAFXZA
`QN75Q7DRAFXZA
`QN75Q80RAFXZA
`QN75Q80RAFXZA
`QN75Q900RBFXZA
`QN75Q90RAFXZA
`QN75Q90RAFXZA
`QN82Q60RAFXZA
`
`LS03R
`Q60R
`Q6DR
`LS03R
`Q60R
`Q6DR
`Q70R
`Q7D
`LS01R
`LS01R
`LS03R
`Q60R
`Q6DR
`Q70R
`Q7D
`Q80R
`Q80R
`Q900
`LS03R
`Q60R
`Q60R
`Q6DR
`Q6DR
`Q70R
`Q70R
`Q7D
`Q7D
`Q80R
`Q80R
`Q80R
`Q900
`Q90R
`Q90R
`Q60R
`Q6DR
`Q70R
`Q7D
`Q7D
`Q80R
`Q80R
`Q900
`Q90R
`Q90R
`Q60R
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 15
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 15
`
`

`

`a7D
`
`QN82Q6DRAFXZA
`Q6D
`asSSS*~ONEOEDRAPKZA
`Q70R
`QN82Q70RAFXZA
`Q7D
`QN82Q7DRAFXZA
`Q80R
`QN82Q80RAFXZA
`Q900
`QN82Q900RBFXZA
`Q90R
`QN82Q90RAFXZA
`Q90R
`QN82Q90RAFXZA
`Q70R
`QN85Q70RAFXZA
`Q900
`QN98Q900RBFXZA
`Q900
`QN98Q900RBFXZA
`RU7100
`UN43RU7100FXZA
`RU7100
`UN43RU7100FXZA
`RU8000
`UN49RU8000FXZA
`RU800D
`UN49RU800DFXZA
`RU7100
`UN50RU7100FXZA
`RU7100
`UN50RU7100FXZA
`RU7100
`UN50RU7100FXZA
`RU7100
`UN50RU7100FXZA
`RU710D
`UN50RU710DFXZA
`RU710D
`UN50RU710DFXZA
`RU710D
`UN50RU710DFXZA
`RU710D
`UN50RU710DFXZA
`RU7100
`UN55RU7100FXZA
`RU710D
`UN55RU710DFXZA
`RU7200
`UN55RU7200FXZA
`RU7200
`UN55RU7200FXZA
`RU7300
`UN55RU7300FXZA
`RU7300
`UN55RU7300FXZA
`RU730D
`UN55RU730DFXZA
`RU730D
`UN55RU730DFXZA
`RU740D
`UN55RU740DFXZA
`RU8000
`UN55RU8000FXZA
`RU800D
`UN55RU800DFXZA
`RU7100
`UN58RU7100FXZA
`RU7100
`UN58RU7100FXZA
`RU710D
`UN58RU710DFXZA
`RU710D
`UN58RU710DFXZA
`RU7100
`UN65RU7100FXZA
`RU7100
`UN65RU7100FXZA
`RU710D
`UN65RU710DFXZA
`RU710D
`UN65RU710DFXZA
`RU7200
`UN65RU7200FXZA
`RU7200
`UN65RU7200FXZA
`RU7300
`UN65RU7300FXZA
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 16
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 16
`
`

`

`sr
`
`UN65RU7300FXZA
`UN65RU730DFXZA
`UN65RU730DFXZA
`UN65RU740DFXZA
`UN65RU8000FXZA
`UN65RU8000FXZA
`UN65RU800DFXZA
`UN65RU800DFXZA
`UN75RU7100FXZA
`UN75RU7100FXZA
`UN75RU7100FXZA
`UN75RU710DFXZA
`UN75RU710DFXZA
`UN75RU710DFXZA
`UN75RU8000FXZA
`UN75RU800DFXZA
`UN82RU8000FXZA
`UN82RU800DFXZA
`QN49Q65FNFXZA
`QN49Q6FNAFXZA
`QN55Q65FNFXZA
`QN55Q6FNAFXZA
`QN55Q6FNAFXZA
`QN55Q75FNFXZA
`QN55Q75FNFXZA
`QN55Q7CNAFXZA
`QN55Q7CNAFXZA
`QN55Q7FNAFXZA
`QN55Q7FNAFXZA
`QN55Q7FNAFXZA
`QN55Q8FNBFXZA
`QN55Q8FNBFXZA
`QN55Q8FNBFXZA
`QN65Q65FNFXZA
`QN65Q65FNFXZA
`QN65Q6FNAFXZA
`QN65Q6FNAFXZA
`QN65Q75FNFXZA
`QN65Q75FNFXZA
`QN65Q7CNAFXZA
`QN65Q7FNAFXZA
`QN65Q7FNAFXZA
`QN65Q8FNBFXZA
`QN65Q8FNBFXZA
`
`RU7300
`RU730D
`RU730D
`RU740D
`RU8000
`RU8000
`RU800D
`RU800D
`RU7100
`RU7100
`RU7100
`RU710D
`RU710D
`RU710D
`RU8000
`RU800D
`RU8000
`RU800D
`Q65FN
`Q6F
`asF
`Q65FN
`Q6F
`asF
`Q6F
`sr
`Q75FN
`Q75FN
`Q7CN
`Q7CN
`Q7FN
`Q7FN
`Q7FN
`Q8FN
`Q8FN
`Q8FN
`Q65FN
`Q65FN
`Q6F
`asF
`Q6F
`Q75FN
`Q75FN
`Q7CN
`Q7FN
`Q7FN
`Q8FN
`Q8FN
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 17
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 17
`
`

`

`asF
`
`QN65Q8FNBFXZA
`QN65Q8FNBFXZA
`QN65Q9FNAFXZA
`QN65Q9FNAFXZA
`QN65Q9FNAFXZA
`QN65Q9FNAFXZA
`QN65Q9FNAFXZA
`QN75Q65FNFXZA
`QN75Q65FNFXZA
`QN75Q65FNFXZA
`QN75Q6FNAFXZA
`QN75Q6FNAFXZA
`QN75Q6FNAFXZA
`QN75Q75FNFXZA
`QN75Q7FNAFXZA
`QN75Q7FNAFXZA
`QN75Q8FNBFXZA
`QN75Q8FNBFXZA
`QN75Q8FNBFXZA
`QN75Q9FNAFXZA
`QN75Q9FNAFXZA
`QN82Q65FNBXZA
`QN82Q65FNFXZA
`QN82Q6FNAFXZA
`QN82Q8FNBFXZA
`QN85Q900RAFXZA
`UN32N5300AFXZA
`UN40NU7100FXZA
`UN40NU710DFXZA
`UN40NU7200FXZA
`UN43LS03NAFXZA
`UN43LS03NAFXZA
`UN43N5300AFXZA
`UN43NU6900BXZA
`UN43NU6900BXZA
`UN43NU6950FXZA
`UN43NU7100FXZA
`UN43NU7100FXZA
`UN49NU8000FXZA
`UN49NU8000FXZA
`UN49NU8000FXZA
`UN50NU6900FXZA
`UN50NU6900FXZA
`UN50NU6900FXZA
`
`Q8FN
`Q8FN
`Q9FN
`Q9FN
`Q9FN
`Q9FN
`Q9FN
`Q65FN
`Q65FN
`Q65FN
`Q6F
`sr
`Q6F
`OsF
`Q6F
`sr
`Q75FN
`Q7FN
`Q7FN
`Q8FN
`Q8FN
`Q8FN
`Q9FN
`Q9FN
`Q65FN
`Q65FN
`Q6F
`Q8FN
`Q900
`N5300
`NU7100
`NU710D
`NU7200
`LS003
`LS004
`N5300
`NU6900
`NU6901
`NU6950
`NU7100
`NU7101
`NU8000
`NU8001
`NU8002
`NU6900
`NU6901
`NU6902
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 18
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 18
`
`

`

`UN55NU8500FXZA
`
`UN50NU6950FXZA
`UN50NU6950FXZA
`UN50NU7100FXZA
`UN50NU7100FXZA
`UN50NU7100FXZA
`UN50NU7100FXZA
`UN50NU7100FXZA
`UN50NU710DFXZA
`UN50NU710DFXZA
`UN50NU710DFXZA
`UN50NU710DFXZA
`UN50NU710DFXZA
`UN50NU7200FXZA
`UN50NU7200FXZA
`UN50NU7200FXZA
`UN55LS03NAFXZA
`UN55NU6900FXZA
`UN55NU6900FXZA
`UN55NU6950FXZA
`UN55NU7100FXZA
`UN55NU7100FXZA
`UN55NU7100FXZA
`UN55NU7100FXZA
`UN55NU7100FXZA
`UN55NU710DFXZA
`UN55NU710DFXZA
`UN55NU710DFXZA
`UN55NU710DFXZA
`UN55NU710DFXZA
`UN55NU7200FXZA
`UN55NU7200FXZA
`UN55NU7200FXZA
`UN55NU7300FXZA
`UN55NU7300FXZA
`UN55NU7300FXZA
`UN55NU7300FXZA
`UN55NU8000FXZA
`UN55NU8000FXZA
`UN55NU8000FXZA
`UN55NU8000FXZA
`UN55NU8000FXZA
`UN55NU8500FXZA
`UN55NU8500FXZA
`
`NU6950
`NU6951
`NU7100
`NU7101
`NU7102
`NU7103
`NU7104
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU7200
`NU7201
`NU7202
`LS03N
`NU6900
`NU6901
`NU6950
`NU7100
`NU7101
`NU7102
`NU7103
`NU7104
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU7200
`NU7201
`NU7202
`NU7300
`NU7301
`NU7302
`NU7303
`NU8000
`NU8001
`NU8002
`NU8003
`NU8004
`NU8500
`NU8501
`NU8502
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 19
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 19
`
`

`

`UN75NU6900FXZA
`
`UN55NU8500FXZA
`UN58NU6080FXZA
`UN58NU6080FXZA
`UN58NU7100FXZA
`UN58NU7100FXZA
`UN58NU710DFXZA
`UN58NU710DFXZA
`UN65LS03NAFXZA
`UN65NU6070FXZA
`UN65NU6070FXZA
`UN65NU6080FXZA
`UN65NU6080FXZA
`UN65NU6900FXZA
`UN65NU6900FXZA
`UN65NU6950FXZA
`UN65NU7100FXZA
`UN65NU7100FXZA
`UN65NU7100FXZA
`UN65NU710DFXZA
`UN65NU710DFXZA
`UN65NU710DFXZA
`UN65NU7200FXZA
`UN65NU7200FXZA
`UN65NU7200FXZA
`UN65NU7300FXZA
`UN65NU7300FXZA
`UN65NU8000FXZA
`UN65NU8000FXZA
`UN65NU8000FXZA
`UN65NU8000FXZA
`UN65NU8000FXZA
`UN65NU8000FXZA
`UN65NU8000FXZA
`UN65NU8500FXZA
`UN65NU8500FXZA
`UN65NU8500FXZA
`UN65NU8500FXZA
`UN70NU6900FXZA
`UN70NU6900FXZA
`UN75NU6080FXZA
`UN75NU6080FXZA
`UN75NU6080FXZA
`UN75NU6900FXZA
`
`NU8503
`NU6080
`NU6081
`NU7100
`NU7101
`NU710D
`NU710D
`LS03N
`NU6070
`NU6071
`NU6080
`NU6081
`NU6900
`NU6901
`NU6950
`NU7100
`NU7101
`NU7102
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU7200
`NU7201
`NU7202
`NU7300
`NU7301
`NU8000
`NU8001
`NU8002
`NU8003
`NU8004
`NU8005
`NU8006
`NU8500
`NU8501
`NU8502
`NU8503
`NU6900
`NU6901
`NU6080
`NU6081
`NU6082
`NU6900
`NU6901
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 20
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 20
`
`

`

`O3F
`
`UN75NU6950FXZA
`UN75NU6950FXZA
`UN75NU7100FXZA
`UN75NU7100FXZA
`UN75NU7100FXZA
`UN75NU7100FXZA
`UN75NU710DEXZA
`UN75NU710DEXZA
`UN75NU710DEXZA
`UN75NU710DFXZA
`UN75NU7200FXZA
`UN75NU7200FXZA
`UN75NU7200FXZA
`UN75NU7200FXZA
`UN75NU8000FXZA
`UN75NU8000FXZA
`UN75NU8000FXZA
`UN75NU8000FXZA
`UN75NU8000FXZA
`UN75NU8000FXZA
`UN82NU8000FXZA
`QN55Q7CAMFXZA
`QN55Q7FAMFXZA
`QN55Q7FAMFXZA
`QN55Q8CAMFXZA
`QN55Q8CAMFXZA
`QN65Q7CAMFXZA
`QN65Q7CAMFXZA
`QN65Q7CAMFXZA
`QN65Q7FAMFXZA
`QN65Q7FAMFXZA
`QN65Q7FAMFXZA
`QN65Q7FAMFXZA
`QN65Q7FAMFXZA
`QN65Q8CAMFXZA
`QN65Q8CAMFXZA
`QN65Q9FAMFXZA
`QN65Q9FAMFXZA
`QN65Q9FAMFXZA
`QN75Q7FAMFXZA
`QN75Q8CAMFXZA
`QN75Q9FAMFXZA
`UN32M4500BFXZA
`UN32M5300AFXZA
`
`NU6950
`NU6951
`NU7100
`NU7101
`NU7102
`NU7103
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU710D
`NU7200
`NU7201
`NU7202
`NU7203
`NU8000
`NU8001
`NU8002
`NU8003
`NU8004
`NU8005
`NU8000
`Q7C
`a7c
`Q7F
`a7F
`Q7F
`a7F
`Q8C
`aac
`Q8C
`aac
`Q7C
`arc
`Q7C
`arc
`Q7C
`arc
`Q7F
`O7F
`Q7F
`a7F
`Q7F
`a7F
`Q7F
`a7F
`Q7F
`a7F
`Q8C
`aac
`Q8C
`aac
`Q9F
`aSF
`Q9F
`O3F
`Q9F
`a3F
`Q7F
`a7F
`Q8C
`aac
`Q9F
`M4500
`M5300
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 21
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 21
`
`

`

`UN49MU7000FXZA
`
`UN32M5300AFXZA
`UN32M5300AFXZA
`UN32M5300AFXZA
`UN32M530DAFXZA
`UN32M530DAFXZA
`UN32M530DAFXZA
`UN32M530DAFXZA
`UN40M5300AFXZA
`UN40M5300AFXZA
`UN40M5300AFXZA
`UN40M530DAFXZA
`UN40M530DAFXZA
`UN40M530DAFXZA
`UN40M530DAFXZA
`UN40MU6290FXZA
`UN40MU6290FXZA
`UN40MU6300FXZA
`UN40MU6300FXZA
`UN40MU7000FXZA
`UN40MU700DFXZA
`UN43LS003AFXZA
`UN43M5300AFXZA
`UN43M5300AFXZA
`UN43M5300AFXZA
`UN43M530DAFXZA
`UN43M530DAFXZA
`UN43MU6290FXZA
`UN43MU6290FXZA
`UN43MU6290FXZA
`UN43MU6300FXZA
`UN43MU6300FXZA
`UN43MU6300FXZA
`UN43MU6300FXZA
`UN43MU6300FXZA
`UN49J5000AFXZA
`UN49J5000AFXZA
`UN49J5000AFXZA
`UN49M5300AFXZA
`UN49M5300AFXZA
`UN49M530DAFXZA
`UN49MU6290FXZA
`UN49MU6290FXZA
`UN49MU6500FXZA
`
`M5301
`M5302
`M5303
`M5300
`M5301
`M5302
`M5303
`M5300
`M5301
`M5302
`M5300
`M5301
`M5302
`M5303
`MU6290
`MU6291
`MU6300
`MU6301
`MU7000
`MU7000
`LS003
`M5300
`M5301
`M5302
`M5300
`M5301
`MU6290
`MU6291
`MU6292
`MU6300
`MU6301
`MU6302
`MU6303
`MU6304
`J5000
`J5001
`J5002
`M5300
`M5301
`M5300
`MU6290
`MU6291
`MU6500
`MU7000
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 22
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 22
`
`

`

`UN55MU6290FXZA
`
`UN49MU700DFXZA
`UN49MU7500FXZA
`UN49MU750DFXZA
`UN49MU8000FXZA
`UN49MU8000FXZA
`UN50M5300AFXZA
`UN50M5300AFXZA
`UN50M5300AFXZA
`UN50M530DAFXZA
`UN50M530DAFXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6070FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN50MU6300FXZA
`UN55LS003AFXZA
`UN55MU6071FXZA
`UN55MU6071FXZA
`UN55MU6071FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`UN55MU6290FXZA
`
`MU7000
`MU7500
`MU7500D
`MU8000
`MU8001
`M5300
`M5301
`M5302
`M5300
`M5301
`MU6070
`MU6071
`MU6072
`MU6073
`MU6074
`MU6075
`MU6076
`MU6077
`MU6078
`MU6079
`MU6080
`MU6300
`MU6301
`MU6302
`MU6303
`MU6304
`MU6305
`MU6306
`MU6307
`MU6308
`MU6309
`LS003
`MU6071
`MU6072
`MU6073
`MU6290
`MU6291
`MU6292
`MU6293
`MU6294
`MU6295
`MU6296
`MU6297
`MU6298
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 23
`
`SAMSUNG, EXH. 1040, P. 23
`
`

`

`UN65MU6290FXZA
`
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6300FXZA
`UN55MU6490FXZA
`UN55MU6490FXZA
`UN55MU6490FXZA
`UN55MU6500FXZA
`UN55MU6500FXZA
`UN55MU6500FXZA
`UN55MU6500FXZA
`UN55MU6500FXZA
`UN55MU7000FXZA
`UN55MU7000FXZA
`UN55MU700DFXZA
`UN55MU7500FXZA
`UN55MU750DFXZA
`UN55MU8000FXZA
`UN55MU8000FXZA
`UN55MU8000FXZA
`UN55MU80

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket