throbber
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`WACO DIVISION
`
`BILLJCO, LLC,
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`Case No. 6:21-cv-528-ADA
`
`v.
`
`APPLE INC.
`
`Defendant.
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`DEFENDANT APPLE, INC.’S
`FINAL INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`Exhibit 2021
`
`

`

` Davies + Berger + Aalto + Kolmel
`
` Davies + Berger + Aalto + Ribaudo
`
` Davies + Berger + Aalto+ Himmelstein
`
` Davies + Berger + Aalto + Haberman
`
`It would have been obvious to combine Davies with one or more of the references identified
`
`above, and a person of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to combine Davies with
`
`one or more of the references identified above for the exemplary reasons provided in section
`
`III.B.1.
`
`d.
`
`’804 Patent
`
`1.
`
`Exemplary Combinations Based on Himmelstein (Appendix 804-Himmelstein)
`
`Exemplary combinations based on Himmelstein (Chart 804-Himmlstein) include the
`
`following:
`
` Himmelstein + Knowledge in the Art
`
` Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Johnson + Myr + Wrappe
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`183
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wilkes + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Wilkes + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Wilkes + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Vincent + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Johnson + Wrappe
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`184
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + 802.11 + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + 802.11
`
`185
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Wu + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Wu + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
`186
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Gast + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wu + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wu + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wu + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Gast + Wu + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Vincent + Wrappe
`
`187
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + GSM + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wu + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wu + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wu + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Wu + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast + 802.11
`
`188
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + GSM + Gast + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wu
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`189
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wu + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wu + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wu + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Wu + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + Gast + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + Wu
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`190
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + CyberGuide + GSM + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Davies
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wu
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`191
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Davies + Wu + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wu + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wu + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Wu + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + Gast + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + Wu
`
`192
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Davies + GSM + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Davies + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Vincent
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`193
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Parctab + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wu + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wu + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wu + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Wu + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast + Vincent
`
`194
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Gast + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + GSM + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`195
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Parctab + Davies + CyberGuide
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Myr + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Johnson + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Vincent + Wrappe
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`196
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wu + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wu + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wu + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Wu + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast + 802.11
`
`197
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Gast + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + GSM + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + Myr
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`198
`
`

`

` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Davies + CyberGuide
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Myr
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Wrappe
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Johnson
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Wilkes
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Vincent
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + 802.11
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Wu
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Gast
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + GSM
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + CyberGuide
`
` Himmelstein + Sanchez + Parctab + Davies
`
`It would have been obvious to combine Himmelstein with one or more of the references
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`199
`
`

`

`identified above, and a person of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to combine
`
`Himmelstein with one or more of the references identified above for the exemplary reasons
`
`provided in section III.B.1.
`
`2.
`
`Exemplary Combinations Based on Myr (Appendix 804-Myr)
`
`Exemplary combinations based on Myr (Chart 804-Myr) include the following:
`
` Myr + Knowledge in the Art
`
` Myr + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Johnson
`
` Myr + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Johnson + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wilkes + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + Wilkes + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Wilkes + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Vincent
`
` Myr + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Vincent + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`200
`
`

`

` Myr + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + Vincent + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Vincent + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Vincent + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Vincent + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + 802.11
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + 802.11 + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Wu
`
` Myr + Wu + Himmelstein
`
`201
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wu + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wu + Johnson
`
` Myr + Wu + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Wu + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Wu + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wu + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + Wu + Vincent
`
` Myr + Wu + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wu + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + Wu + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Wu + 802.11
`
` Myr + Wu + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Wu + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Wu + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + Wu + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Wu + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Myr + Gast
`
` Myr + Gast + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Gast + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
`202
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Gast + Johnson
`
` Myr + Gast + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Gast + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Gast + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Gast + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + Gast + Vincent
`
` Myr + Gast + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Gast + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + Gast + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Gast + 802.11
`
` Myr + Gast + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Gast + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Gast + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + Gast + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Gast + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Myr + Gast + Wu
`
` Myr + Gast + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Gast + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Gast + Wu + Johnson
`
` Myr + Gast + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Gast + Wu + Vincent
`
`203
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Gast + Wu + 802.11
`
` Myr + GSM
`
` Myr + GSM + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + Johnson
`
` Myr + GSM + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + GSM + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Myr + GSM + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + GSM + Vincent
`
` Myr + GSM + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + GSM + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + GSM + 802.11
`
` Myr + GSM + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + GSM + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + GSM + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + GSM + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Myr + GSM + Wu
`
`204
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + GSM + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + GSM + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + Wu + Johnson
`
` Myr + GSM + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Myr + GSM + Wu + Vincent
`
` Myr + GSM + Wu + 802.11
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast + Johnson
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast + Vincent
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast + 802.11
`
` Myr + GSM + Gast + Wu
`
` Myr + CyberGuide
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`205
`
`

`

` Myr + CyberGuide + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wu
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wu + Johnson
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wu + Vincent
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Wu + 802.11
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast + Wrappe
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`206
`
`

`

` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast + Johnson
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast + Vincent
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast + 802.11
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + Gast + Wu
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + Johnson
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + Vincent
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + 802.11
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + Wu
`
` Myr + CyberGuide + GSM + Gast
`
` Myr + Davies
`
` Myr + Davies + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Davies + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Davies + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + Wilkes
`
`207
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Davies + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + Vincent
`
` Myr + Davies + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Davies + 802.11
`
` Myr + Davies + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Davies + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Davies + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Myr + Davies + Wu
`
` Myr + Davies + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Davies + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + Wu + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Davies + Wu + Vincent
`
` Myr + Davies + Wu + 802.11
`
` Myr + Davies + Gast
`
` Myr + Davies + Gast + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Davies + Gast + Wrappe
`
`208
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Davies + Gast + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Davies + Gast + Vincent
`
` Myr + Davies + Gast + 802.11
`
` Myr + Davies + Gast + Wu
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + Vincent
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + 802.11
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + Wu
`
` Myr + Davies + GSM + Gast
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + Wu
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`209
`
`

`

` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Myr + Davies + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Myr + Parctab
`
` Myr + Parctab + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + Vincent
`
` Myr + Parctab + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + 802.11
`
` Myr + Parctab + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + 802.11 + Vincent
`
`210
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Parctab + Wu
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wu + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wu + Vincent
`
` Myr + Parctab + Wu + 802.11
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast + Vincent
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast + 802.11
`
` Myr + Parctab + Gast + Wu
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM + Vincent
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM + 802.11
`
`211
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Parctab + GSM + Wu
`
` Myr + Parctab + GSM + Gast
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + Wu
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Myr + Parctab + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + Johnson
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + Vincent
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + 802.11
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + Wu
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + Gast
`
` Myr + Parctab + Davies + GSM
`
`212
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Parctab + Davies + CyberGuide
`
` Myr + Sanchez
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Himmelstein + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Johnson + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wilkes + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Vincent + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + 802.11
`
` Myr + Sanchez + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + 802.11 + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wu
`
`213
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Sanchez + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wu + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wu + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wu + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Wu + 802.11
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast + 802.11
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Gast + Wu
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + 802.11
`
` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + Wu
`
`214
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Sanchez + GSM + Gast
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + 802.11
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Wu
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + Gast
`
` Myr + Sanchez + CyberGuide + GSM
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + 802.11
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + Wu
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + Gast
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + GSM
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Davies + CyberGuide
`
`215
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Himmelstein
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Wrappe
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Johnson
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Wilkes
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Vincent
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + 802.11
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Wu
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Gast
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + GSM
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + CyberGuide
`
` Myr + Sanchez + Parctab + Davies
`
`It would have been obvious to combine Myr with one or more of the references identified
`
`above, and a person of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to combine Myr with
`
`one or more of the references identified above for the exemplary reasons provided in section
`
`III.B.1.
`
`3.
`
`Exemplary Combinations Based on Wrappe (Appendix 804-Wrappe)
`
`Exemplary combinations based on Wrappe (Chart 804-Wrappe) include the following:
`
` Wrappe + Knowledge in the Art
`
` Wrappe + Knowledge in the Art
`
` Wrappe + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Myr
`
`216
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Wrappe + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Johnson + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Johnson + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Wilkes + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wilkes + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Wilkes + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Wilkes + Johnson + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Johnson + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Wilkes + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Vincent + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + 802.11
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
`217
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Wrappe + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Johnson + Myr
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Wilkes + Myr
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Vincent + Myr
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + 802.11 + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Wu
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Johnson + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Wilkes + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Wilkes + Johnson
`
`218
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Wrappe + Wu + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Vincent + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Wu + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Wu + 802.11
`
` Wrappe + Wu + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Wu + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Wu + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Wu + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Wu + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + Gast
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Johnson + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wilkes + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Vincent + Myr
`
`219
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Wrappe + Gast + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Gast + 802.11
`
` Wrappe + Gast + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Gast + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Gast + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Gast + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Gast + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wu
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wu + Myr
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wu + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wu + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + Gast + Wu + 802.11
`
` Wrappe + GSM
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Myr
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Himmelstein + Myr
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Johnson + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Johnson + Myr
`
`220
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Wrappe + GSM + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wilkes + Myr
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wilkes + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Vincent + Myr
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Vincent + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Vincent + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + GSM + 802.11
`
` Wrappe + GSM + 802.11 + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + GSM + 802.11 + Myr
`
` Wrappe + GSM + 802.11 + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + GSM + 802.11 + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + GSM + 802.11 + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wu
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wu + Himmelstein
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wu + Myr
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wu + Johnson
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wu + Wilkes
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wu + Vincent
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Wu + 802.11
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Gast
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Gast + Himmelstein
`
`221
`
`EAST\189796847.1
`
`

`

` Wrappe + GSM + Gast + Myr
`
` Wrappe + GSM + Gast + Johnson
`
` Wr

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket