IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`WACO DIVISION
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Civil Action No. 21-cv-411
`
`Jury Trial Demanded
`
`MEMORYWEB, LLC,
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`
`v.
`
`SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD. (A
`KOREAN COMPANY) and SAMSUNG
`ELECTRONICS AMERICA, INC.,
`
`Defendants.
`
`
`
`
`SAMSUNG’S PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS
`
`I.
`
`INTRODUCTION
`
`Pursuant to the Standing Order Governing Proceedings – Patent Cases (“OGP”) (Dkt. 24)
`
`paragraph 4 and the Agreed Scheduling Order (Dkt. 35), Defendants Samsung Electronics Co.,
`
`Ltd. and Samsung Electronics America, Inc. (collectively, “Defendants” or “Samsung”) hereby
`
`provide their Preliminary Invalidity Contentions with respect to the claims identified by Plaintiff
`
`MemoryWeb, LLC (“Plaintiff” or “MemoryWeb”) in its First Supplemental Initial Infringement
`
`Contentions (“Infringement Contentions”) served on November 24, 2021, in the above-captioned
`
`case. Plaintiff asserts the following claims (the “Asserted Claims”):
`
`• Claims 1-15 of U.S. Patent No. 10,423,658 (“the ’658 patent”)
`
`• Claims 1-10, 12-15, and 17-19 of U.S. Patent No. 10,621,228 (“the ’228 patent”)
`
`• Claims 1-34 of U.S. Patent No. 11,163,823 (“the ’823 patent”)1
`
`1 The ’658 patent, the ’228 patent, and the ’823 patent are collectively referred to herein as
`the “Asserted Patents” or the “Patents-in-Suit.”
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`1/172
`
`

`

`Pursuant to OGP ¶ 4, Samsung hereby provides its invalidity disclosures and related
`
`documents pertaining only to the asserted claims as identified by Plaintiff in its Infringement
`
`Contentions. With respect to each asserted claim and based on its investigation to date, Samsung
`
`hereby: (1) submits a chart setting forth where in the prior art references each element of the
`
`asserted claims are found; (2) identifies any limitations Samsung contends are indefinite or lack
`
`written description under 35 U.S.C. § 112; and (3) identifies the claims Samsung contends are
`
`directed to ineligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. § 101. Samsung further relies on and
`
`incorporates all prior art references cited in and/or on the cover of the Asserted Patents and their
`
`respective prosecution histories, including for supporting the obviousness of any asserted claim.
`
`Samsung further relies on and incorporates by reference, as if originally set forth herein, all
`
`invalidity positions (but not necessarily claim construction positions), and all associated prior art
`
`and claim charts, disclosed to Plaintiff by present or former defendants in any lawsuits or other
`
`proceedings or by potential or actual licensees to any of the asserted claims, including
`
`MemoryWeb, LLC v. Apple, Inc., No. 3:21-cv-9839 (N.D. Cal.); MemoryWeb, LLC v. Apple,
`
`Inc., No. 6:21-cv-531 (W.D. Tex.); MyHeritage (USA), Inc. et al. v. MemoryWeb, LLC, No.
`
`1:21-cv-2666 (N.D. Ill.); IPR2021-01413; IPR2022-00031; IPR2022-00033; IPR2022-00221;
`
`and IPR2022-00222. Samsung hereby discloses and identifies as if originally set forth herein, all
`
`prior art references listed and/or asserted in the above as invalidating prior art against each of the
`
`asserted claims.
`
`In addition, based on its investigation to date Samsung hereby produces the documents
`
`currently in its possession, custody, or control required to accompany these Invalidity
`
`Contentions pursuant to OGP ¶ 4.
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`2/172
`
`

`

`II.
`
`RESERVATIONS OF RIGHTS
`
`Samsung hereby provides disclosures and related documents pertaining only to the
`
`asserted claims identified by Plaintiff in its Infringement Contentions. Samsung reserves the
`
`right to modify, amend, or supplement these Invalidity Contentions to show the invalidity of any
`
`additional claims that the Court may allow Plaintiff to later assert. The OGP contemplates that
`
`these Invalidity Contentions be prepared and served in response to Plaintiff’s Infringement
`
`Contentions. But Plaintiff’s Infringement Contentions are insufficient in that they lack proper
`
`and complete disclosure as to how Samsung allegedly infringes the asserted claims. As such,
`
`Samsung reserves the right to modify, amend, and/or supplement these Invalidity Contentions
`
`should the Court permit Plaintiff to correct, clarify, amend, and/or supplement its Infringement
`
`Contentions.
`
`Samsung’s Invalidity Contentions and selection of documents accompanying them are
`
`based on information currently available to Samsung and subject to further revision. For
`
`example, Plaintiff (or its counsel) may be in possession of prior art that has not been disclosed to
`
`Samsung. As another example, because discovery (except venue, jurisdictional, and claim
`
`construction discovery) has not yet begun pursuant to the Court’s OGP, Samsung reserves the
`
`right to amend or supplement the information provided herein, including identifying and relying
`
`on additional references.
`
`To the extent that these Invalidity Contentions reflect or otherwise embody particular
`
`constructions of terms or phrases in the asserted claims, Samsung is not proposing any such
`
`constructions as proper constructions of those terms or phrases. Various positions put forth in
`
`these Invalidity Contentions are predicated on Plaintiff’s incorrect and overbroad interpretation
`
`of its claims as evidenced by its Infringement Contentions provided to Samsung. These
`
`Invalidity Contentions are not intended to, and do not necessarily, reflect Samsung’s
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`3/172
`
`

`

`interpretation of the true and proper scope of the asserted claims. Samsung reserves the right to
`
`adopt claim construction positions that differ from or even conflict with positions put forth in
`
`this document. Also, Samsung objects to any attempt to infer any claim constructions from any
`
`identification of potential prior art. In those instances where Samsung asserts that the asserted
`
`claims are invalid under 35 U.S.C. § 112 (e.g., no written description, not enabled, and/or
`
`indefinite), Samsung has applied the prior art in accordance with its assumption that Plaintiff
`
`contends such asserted claims (1) are definite, (2) have written description support, and (3) are
`
`enabled, as evidenced by Plaintiff’s Infringement Contentions. As such, Samsung’s Invalidity
`
`Contentions do not represent its agreement or view as to the meaning, definiteness, written
`
`description support for, or enablement of any asserted claim. These Invalidity Contentions and
`
`accompanying documents are not intended to reflect Samsung’s claim construction contentions,
`
`which will be disclosed in accordance with the OGP.
`
`Samsung’s contentions may change depending on the Court’s construction of the asserted
`
`claims, any findings as to the priority date of the asserted claims, and/or positions that Plaintiff or
`
`its experts may take concerning claim construction, infringement, and/or invalidity issues. Prior
`
`art not included in this disclosure, whether known or unknown to Samsung, may become
`
`relevant. In particular, Samsung is currently unaware of the extent, if any, to which Plaintiff will
`
`contend that limitations of the asserted claims are not disclosed in the prior art identified by
`
`Samsung, or will contend that any of the identified references do not qualify as prior art. To the
`
`extent that such an issue arises, Samsung reserves the right to identify other references that, inter
`
`alia, would have made the addition of the allegedly missing limitation to the disclosed device or
`
`method obvious.
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`4/172
`
`

`

`The identification of any patent or patent publication shall be deemed to include any
`
`counterpart patent or application filed, published, or issued anywhere in the world. The citation
`
`to any specifications published by standard-setting organizations shall be deemed to include any
`
`product that implements such specifications and that would qualify as prior art under 35 U.S.C. §
`
`102, e.g., under Sections 102(a), 102(b), or 102(g)(2).
`
`Samsung’s claim charts cite to particular teachings and disclosures of the prior art as
`
`applied to features of the asserted claims. Persons having ordinary skill in the art, however, may
`
`view an item of prior art in the context of other publications, literature, products, and
`
`understanding. As such, the cited portions are only exemplary, and Samsung reserves the right
`
`to rely on uncited portions of the prior art references and on other publications and expert
`
`testimony as aids in understanding and interpreting the cited portions, as providing context
`
`thereto, and as additional evidence that the prior art discloses a claim limitation. Samsung
`
`further reserves the right to rely on uncited portions of the prior art references, other
`
`publications, and testimony to establish bases for combinations of certain cited references that
`
`render the asserted claims obvious. Further, for any combination, Samsung reserves the right to
`
`rely additionally on information generally known to those skilled in the art or common sense.
`
`The references discussed in the claim charts may disclose the elements of the asserted
`
`claims explicitly or inherently, or they may be relied upon to show the state of the art in the
`
`relevant time frame. The suggested obviousness combinations are provided in the alternative to
`
`Samsung’s anticipation contentions and are not to be construed to suggest that any reference
`
`included in the combinations is not by itself anticipatory.
`
`Samsung reserves the right to challenge patentability of the asserted claims under 35
`
`U.S.C. § 102(f) in the event Samsung obtains evidence that the named inventors of the Patents-
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`5/172
`
`

`

`in-Suit did not invent the subject matter claimed in the Patents-in-Suit. Should Samsung obtain
`
`such evidence, it will provide the name of the person(s) from whom and the circumstances under
`
`which the invention or any part of it was derived. Samsung further reserves the right to assert
`
`that the Patents-in-Suit are unenforceable due to inequitable conduct.
`
`III.
`
`IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART
`
`Subject to Samsung’s reservation of rights, Samsung identifies each item of prior art that
`
`at least evidences the obviousness of one or more of the asserted claims. In its Infringement
`
`Contentions, Plaintiff provided a priority date earlier than the filing date of the asserted patent.
`
`Without admitting the priority of that early priority date, for the purposes of these Invalidity
`
`Contentions, Samsung uses February 28, 2014 as the priority date for the ’658 and ’228 patents
`
`and both June 9, 2011 and February 28, 2014 as the priority date for the ’823 patent,2 and also
`
`includes items that qualify as prior art using a priority date of December 12, 2016 (the filing date
`
`of the ’658 patent), September 20, 2019 (the filing date of the ’228 patent), and/or August 8,
`
`2019 (the filing date of the ’823 patent), as appropriate.
`
`In the following sections, Table 1 identifies each prior art patent by its number, first
`
`named inventor, filing or priority date, and date of issuance. Table 2 identifies each non-patent
`
`prior art publication by, where possible, its title, date of publication, and author and/or publisher.
`
`Table 3 identifies each prior art system currently known to Samsung by, where possible, its name
`
`and date of sale, use, or knowledge. Samsung hereby discloses and identifies as if originally set
`
`forth herein, all prior art references listed and/or asserted in the above as invalidating prior art
`
`against each of the asserted claims. Samsung reserves the right to identify additional non-patent
`
`2 Samsung contends that the ’823 patent is not entitled to a priority date of June 9, 2011, as
`the alleged inventions claimed in the ’823 patent are not supported by the disclosure of the parent
`application(s) filed on June 9, 2011, or otherwise before February 28, 2014.
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`6/172
`
`

`

`and non-publication prior art systems that were sold, offered for sale, used, etc. prior to the
`
`priority date to the extent any such systems become known during discovery of Plaintiff and
`
`third parties.
`
`Table 1: Prior Art Patents and Applications
`
`Inventor
`
`Patent
`
`US 5,666,578
`US 6,437,797
`US 6,714,215
`US 6,883,146
`US 7,372,976
`US 7,403,642
`US 7,415,662
`US 7,479,949
`US 7,480,669
`US 7,518,650
`US 7,519,200
`US 7,555,725
`US 7,620,496
`
`US 7,663,671
`US 7,706,577
`US 7,797,019
`US 7,840,892
`US 7,890,889
`US 7,978,207
`US 8,013,874
`US 8,099,679
`US 8,116,598
`US 8,122,024
`
`US 8,150,844
`US 8,169,505
`US 8,189,880
`US 8,340,695
`US 8,531,478
`US 8,649,572
`US 8,732,149
`US 8,750,574
`
`Filing
`Date/Priority
`Date
`Yoshiro Oikawa et al. 8/2/1996
`2/18/1998
`Yoshinori Ota
`5/19/2000
`Flora et al.
`12/20/2000
`Prabhu et al.
`8/22/2006
`Rhoads et al.
`4/21/2005
`Zhang et al.
`7/17/2002
`Rothmuller et al.
`4/11/2008
`Jobs et al.
`12/5/2005
`Lo et al.
`5/16/2005
`Takashi Miyamoto
`10/7/2005
`Gokturk et al.
`8/8/2005
`Abramson et al.
`7/12/2005
`Jens Eilstrup
`Rasmussen
`Gallagher et al.
`Casillas et al.
`Michael Friedmann
`Pyhalammi et al.
`Artman et al.
`Herf et al.
`Reid et al.
`Yee et al.
`Filley et al.
`Piotr Konrad
`Tysowski
`Redstone et al.
`Tsutomu Hoshi
`Wen et al.
`Song et al.
`Lee et al.
`Gokturk et al.
`Iida et al.
`Ganong et al.
`
`11/22/2005
`1/26/2006
`3/29/2006
`8/29/2003
`9/27/2004
`6/13/2007
`11/9/2005
`2/14/2008
`1/27/2010
`12/12/2008
`
`8/18/2010
`9/18/2008
`5/29/2007
`7/2/2010
`3/19/2009
`2/27/2009
`6/3/2011
`12/30/2008
`
`Published/Issue
`Date
`
`Short Name
`
`9/9/1997
`8/20/2002
`3/30/2004
`4/19/2005
`5/13/2008
`7/22/2008
`8/19/2008
`1/20/2009
`1/20/2009
`4/14/2009
`4/14/2009
`6/30/2009
`11/17/2009
`
`2/16/2010
`4/27/2010
`9/14/2010
`11/23/2010
`2/15/2011
`7/12/2011
`9/6/2011
`1/17/2012
`2/14/2012
`2/21/2012
`
`4/3/2012
`5/1/2012
`5/29/2012
`12/25/2012
`9/10/2013
`2/11/2014
`5/20/2014
`6/10/2014
`
`Oikawa
`Ota
`Flora
`Prabhu
`Rhoads
`Zhang
`Rothmuller
`Jobs
`Lo
`Miyamoto
`Gokturk-200
`Abramson
`Rasmussen
`
`Gallagher-671
`Casillas-577
`Friedmann-019
`Pyhalammi
`Artman
`Herf
`Reid
`Yee-679
`Filley et al.
`Tysowski-024
`
`Redstone
`Hoshi
`Wen
`Song-695
`Lee-478
`Gokturk-572
`Iida
`Ganong-574
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`7/172
`
`

`

`Patent
`
`Inventor
`
`US 9,047,847
`
`Hochmuth et al.
`
`US 9,639,740
`
`Ganong et al.
`
`US 9,665,597
`US 10,599,712
`
`US Pub. No.
`2002/0075322
`US Pub. No.
`2004/0004663
`US Pub. No.
`2005/0116954
`US Pub. No.
`2005/0246324
`US Pub. No.
`2006/0080342
`US Pub. No.
`2006/0165380
`US Pub. No.
`2006/0253771
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0139546
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0198495
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0256026
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0271297
`US Pub. No.
`2007/027943
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0282908
`US Pub. No.
`2008/0080743
`US Pub. No.
`2008/0098316
`US Pub. No.
`2008/0133697
`US Pub. No.
`2008/0177723
`
`Filing
`Date/Priority
`Date
`2/5/2013
`8/7/2014
`11/12/2013
`12/30/2008
`3/22/2007
`6/25/2019
`11/25/2016
`12/20/20000
`
`7/2/2002
`
`12/1/2003
`
`4/30/2004
`
`10/5/2005
`
`6/22/2005
`
`4/15/2006
`
`Published/Issue
`Date
`
`Short Name
`
`6/2/2015
`
`6/2/2015
`
`5/30/2017
`3/24/2020
`
`Hochmuth
`
`Ganong-740
`
`Haitani et al.
`Friedmann-712
`
`6/20/2002
`
`Rosenzweig
`
`1/8/2004
`
`6/2/2005
`
`Kahn
`
`Ripps et al.
`
`11/3/2005
`
`Paala Smaa
`
`4/13/2006
`
`7/27/2006
`
`11/9/2006
`
`Takaki
`
`Tanaka
`
`Baschy
`
`11/14/2006
`
`6/21/2007
`
`Baiping
`
`1/25/2007
`
`7/7/2006
`
`5/19/2006
`
`5/29/2007
`
`8/23/2007
`
`Buron
`
`11/1/2007
`
`Klassen
`
`11/22/2007
`
`Jaffe
`
`12/6/2007
`
`Takakura
`
`Haitani et al.
`Michael Jonathan
`Friedmann
`Rosenzweig et al.
`
`Kahn et al.
`
`Ripps et al.
`
`Paala Smaa et al.
`
`Goro Takaki
`
`Tanaka et al.
`
`Leo Baschy
`
`Baiping et al.
`
`Buron et al.
`
`Klassen et al.
`
`Jaffe et al.
`
`Takakura et al.
`
`Van der Meulen et al. 6/5/2006
`
`12/6/2007
`
`Meulen
`
`Schneiderman et al.
`
`9/29/2006
`
`4/3/2008
`
`Schneiderman
`
`Kelly Patrick Declan
`
`1/17/2007
`
`4/24/2008
`
`Declan
`
`Stewart et al.
`
`Abe et al.
`
`3/22/2007
`
`10/24/2007
`
`6/5/2008
`
`Stewart
`
`7/24/2008
`
`Abe
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`8/172
`
`

`

`Patent
`
`Inventor
`
`US Pub. No.
`2008/0307343
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0019031
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0028393
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0049408
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0113350
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0160972
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0161962
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0210793
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0284551
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0030578
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0036818
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0115407
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0149212
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0153386
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0172551
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0293224
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0058087
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0122153
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0150340
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0159885
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0163971
`
`Robert et al.
`
`Krovitz et al.
`
`Kim et al.
`
`Naaman et al.
`
`Hibino et al.
`
`Wang et al.
`
`Gallagher et al.
`
`Yee et al.
`
`Craig Stanton
`
`Siddique et al.
`
`Valencia-Campo et
`al.
`Kim et al.
`
`Fukuya et al.
`
`Piotr Konrad
`Tysowski
`Gilley et al.
`
`Kenichi Moriwaki
`
`Ito et al.
`
`Okamura et al.
`
`Gotoh et al.
`
`Song et al.
`
`Wagner et al.
`
`Filing
`Date/Priority
`Date
`6/9/2007
`
`7/10/2007
`
`2/4/2008
`
`8/13/2007
`
`10/26/2007
`
`7/17/2008
`
`12/20/2007
`
`2/14/2008
`
`5/13/2008
`
`3/23/2009
`
`8/4/2009
`
`3/18/2009
`
`11/12/2009
`
`12/12/2008
`
`9/25/2009
`
`6/29/2010
`11/26/2008
`8/31/2010
`0/4/2009
`10/20/2010
`11/26/2009
`10/20/2010
`12/22/2009
`7/2/2010
`12/30/2009
`3/27/2010
`1/6/2010
`
`Published/Issue
`Date
`
`Short Name
`
`12/11/2008
`
`Robert
`
`1/15/2009
`
`Krovitz
`
`1/29/2009
`
`Kim-393
`
`2/19/2009
`
`Naaman
`
`4/30/2009
`
`Hibino
`
`6/25/2009
`
`Wang
`
`6/25/2009
`
`Gallagher-962
`
`8/20/2009
`
`Yee - 793
`
`11/19/2009
`
`Stanton-551
`
`2/4/2010
`
`Siddique
`
`2/11/2010
`
`Valencia-Campo
`
`5/6/2010
`
`Kim-407
`
`6/17/2010
`
`Fukuya
`
`6/17/2010
`
`Tysowski-386
`
`7/8/2010
`
`Gilley
`
`11/18/2010
`
`Moriwaki
`
`3/10/2011
`
`Ito
`
`3/26/2011
`
`Okamura
`
`6/23/2011
`
`Gotoh
`
`6/30/2011
`
`Song-885
`
`7/7/2011
`
`Wagner
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`9/172
`
`

`

`Patent
`
`Inventor
`
`Filing
`Date/Priority
`Date
`9/29/2010
`3/25/2010
`6/1/2011
`6/8/2010
`5/18/2011
`9/7/2010
`2/21/2011
`
`6/9/2011
`
`11/29/2012
`
`Hanson et al.
`
`Yamamoto et al.
`
`Phang et al.
`
`Lou et al.
`
`Desmond et al.
`
`Han et al.
`
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0234613
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0302529
`US Pub. No.
`2012/0059818
`US Pub. No.
`2012/0213497
`US Pub. No.
`2012/031711
`US Pub. No.
`2013/0141467
`US Pub. No.
`2014/0040774
`US Pub. No.
`2014/0071160
`US Pub. No.
`2014/0108405
`US Pub. No.
`2014/0225925
`US Pub. No.
`2014/0282099
`US Pub. No.
`2015/0066941
`US Pub. No.
`2016/0292494
`US RE 42,289
`
`WO 2006/026567
`A2
`JP 2006-323621
`JP 2008-165701
`JP 2008-217695
`EP 1987683 B1
`EP 2572264 B1
`US 7,916,976
`US 7,945,852
`US 7,978,936
`US 8,160,400
`US 8,543,917
`US 8,595,638
`
`Charytoniuk et al.
`
`8/1/2012
`
`Sugiura et al.
`
`Rathnavelu et al.
`
`Hayashi et al.
`
`Bronder et al.
`
`U-Me Holdings LLC.
`Derek P. Martin
`Ganong et al.
`
`Robert Vicent
`
`Hugh Svendsen
`
`Kazuya Tanizawa
`Takashi Huga
`Yushi Hassegawa
`Weber et al.
`Tuomas Vaittinew
`Roland H. Kedikian
`Orest J. Pilskalns
`Casillas et al.
`Snavely et al.
`Ketola et al.
`Belitz et al.
`
`8/16/2013
`9/7/2012
`10/16/2012
`
`1/16/2014
`2/14/2013
`5/10/2013
`3/14/2013
`10/2/2013
`8/30/2013
`11/12/2014
`12/30/2008
`5/23/2008
`1/31/1996
`8/31/2004
`
`
`5/19/2005
`1/5/2007
`3/7/2007
`2/24/2006
`5/16/2010
`2/8/2007
`8/18/2006
`1/26/2006
`7/25/2006
`12/11/2009
`8/28/2008
`
`Published/Issue
`Date
`
`Short Name
`
`9/29/2011
`
`Hanson-613
`
`12/8/2011
`
`Yamamoto
`
`3/8/2012
`
`Phang
`
`8/23/2012
`
`Lou
`
`12/13/2012
`
`Desmond
`
`6/6/2013
`
`2/6/2014
`
`Han
`
`Charytoniuk
`
`3/13/2014
`
`Sugiura
`
`4/17/2014
`
`Rathnavelu
`
`8/14/2014
`
`Hayashi
`
`9/18/2014
`
`Bronder
`
`3/5/2015
`
`Martin
`
`10/6/2016
`
`Ganong-494
`
`4/12/2011
`
`Vicent
`
`3/9/2006
`
`Svendsen
`
`11/30/2006
`7/17/2008
`9/18/2008
`2/22/2007
`2/10/2011
`3/29/2011
`3/17/2011
`7/12/2011
`4/17/2012
`9/24/2013
`11/26/2013
`
`Tanizawa
`Huga
`Hassegawa
`Weber
`Vaittinew
`Kedikian
`Pilskalns-852
`Casillas-936
`Snavely-400
`Ketola
`Belitz-638
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`10/172
`
`

`

`Patent
`
`Inventor
`
`US 8,606,493
`US 8,966,398
`US 9,104,695
`US 9,185,299
`
`Gold et al.
`Wright et al.
`Cervelli et al.
`Irimoto et al.
`
`US 9,465,890
`
`Donald Jay Wilson
`
`Filing
`Date/Priority
`Date
`8/31/2009
`12/2/2009
`7/21/2010
`4/16/2013
`3/13/2014
`8/9/2010
`8/10/2009
`12/3/2007
`11/1/2004
`
`4/15/2006
`
`8/4/2006
`
`7/25/2006
`
`2/12/2007
`
`2/12/2007
`
`4/20/2006
`
`8/23/2007
`
`1/2/2008
`
`8/14/2009
`
`3/19/2009
`
`3/26/2010
`4/22/2005
`9/25/2009
`
`1/15/2011
`1/15/2010
`2/27/2012
`2/27/2011
`8/28/2008
`
`Published/Issue
`Date
`
`Short Name
`
`12/10/2013
`2/24/2015
`8/11/2015
`11/10/2015
`
`Gold
`Wright
`Cervelli
`Irimoto
`
`10/11/2016
`
`Wilson
`
`4/4/2017
`5/4/2006
`
`Beletski
`Torres et al.
`
`11/9/2006
`
`Baschy
`
`2/8/2007
`
`Kim-391
`
`5/17/2007
`
`Snavely-338
`
`8/23/2007
`
`Frank-951
`
`9/20/2007
`
`Frank-968
`
`11/8/2007
`
`3/27/2008
`
`Thota
`
`Butler
`
`7/17/2008
`
`Pilskalns-288
`
`12/3/2009
`
`Matraszek
`
`9/23/2010
`
`Lee-819
`
`10/7/2010
`
`Arrouye
`
`3/31/2011
`
`Hanson-811
`
`12/15/2011
`
`Sakaguchi
`
`8/30/2012
`
`Hunter
`
`3/4/2010
`
`1/9/2009
`
`
`Belitz
`
`Go
`
`US 9,612,126
`US Pub. No.
`2006/0095397
`US Pub. No.
`2006/0253771
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0030391
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0110338
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0198951
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0219968
`US Pub. No.
`2007/0258642
`US Pub. No.
`2008/0077597
`US Pub. No.
`2008/0172288
`US Pub. No.
`2009/0297065
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0238191
`US Pub. No.
`2010/025717
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0074811
`US Pub. No.
`2011/0305437
`US Pub. No.
`2012/0221687
`US Pub. No.
`2010/0058212
`KR20090002656A Go Chang-Seok et al. 7/2/2007
`
`Beletski et al.
`Torres et al.
`
`Leo Baschy
`
`Kim et al.
`
`Snavely et al.
`
`John R. Frank
`
`John R. Frank
`
`Cdlszgndrasekhar
`Thota
`Lance Butler
`
`Pilskalns et al.
`
`Matraszek et al.
`
`Lee et al.
`
`Arrouye et al.
`
`Hanson et al.
`
`Sakaguchi et al.
`
`Hunter et al.
`
`Belitz et al.
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`11/172
`
`

`

`Patent
`
`Inventor
`
`KR20090041750A Park Seong-ha
`
`KR20090050420A Park Ki-Soo et al.
`KR20100050221A Kim Hyeong-Mi et
`al.
`KR20110068587A Jeong Dong-Seok et
`al.
`
`Table 2: Non-Patent Prior Art Publications
`
`Filing
`Date/Priority
`Date
`10/24/2007
`
`11/15/2007
`11/5/2008
`
`12/16/2009
`
`
`
`Published/Issue
`Date
`
`Short Name
`
`4/29/2009
`
`5/20/2009
`5/13/2010
`
`Park-750
`
`Park-420
`Kim-221
`
`6/22/2011
`
`Jeong
`
`Author or
`Publisher
`Hyunmo Kang
`
`Erik Sjödin
`
`HTC Corporation
`
`Greg Johnson
`
`Kathleen Wiegner
`
`Business Wire
`
`Computergram
`International
`
`Oracle
`
`Reference Title
`
`Managing and Exploring Personal
`Media Using Semantic Regions: A
`Spatial Interface Supporting User-
`Defined Mental Models
`Photographs with Embedded
`Spatial Metadata
`HTC Hero User Manual
`
`Kodak System Puts on Audio CD
`(Los Angeles Times)
`Illustra Charts Its Own Path --
`Positions hybrid relational
`database to handle multimedia
`(Dow Jones)
`Illustra introduces two new
`DataBlade modules; `Database for
`Cyberspace’ announces new Web
`DataBlade, as well as OMF
`DataBladeargeted for
`entertainment industry (Dow
`Jones)
`Illustra-Virage Searcher Looks Up
`Pictures Without Needing
`Keywords
`Oracle interMedia User’s Guide
`and Reference
`Release 8.1.7 Part No A85336-01
`
`Publication
`/ Use Date
`2003
`
`Short Name
`
`Kang 2003
`
`10-31-2006
`
`Sjödin
`
`2009
`
`HTC Hero
`
`7/31/1992
`
`10/24/1994
`
`
`12/6/1994
`
`
`Johnson
`
`Wiegner
`
`Businesswire 1261944
`
`4/28/1995
`
`Computergram
`
`9/2000
`
`Oracle interMedia
`2000
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`12/172
`
`

`

`Author or
`Publisher
`Oracle
`
`Reference Title
`
`Oracle Spatial Users Guide and
`Reference
`Release 8.1.7 Part No A85337-01
`Mark Monmonier Webcams, Interactive Index Maps,
`and
`Our Brave New World’s
`Brave New Globe
`Oracle® interMedia
`User's Guide
`10g Release 2 (10.2)
`B14302-01
`Building Flickr Applications
`with PHP
`Space-Time Travel Blogging
`Using a Mobile Phone
`
`Oracle
`
`Rob Kunkle and
`Andrew Morton
`Will Bamford, Paul
`Coulton and Reuben
`Edwards
`Benjamin B
`Bederson
`
`Jon Byous
`
`Davide Carboni,
`Stefano Sanna and
`Pietro Zanarini
`Davide Carboni,
`Valentina Marotto
`and Pietro Zanarini
`
`Sara Chizari
`
`Saman H. Cooray
`
`Lei Zhang, Longbin
`Chen, Mingjing Li,
`Hongjiang Zhang
`Mark Milian
`
`Publication
`/ Use Date
`9/2000
`
`Short Name
`
`Oracle Spatial
`
`Fall 2000
`
`Monmonier
`
`6/2005
`
`Oracle interMedia
`2005
`
`2006
`
`Kunkle
`
`June 2007
`
`Bamford
`
`2001
`
`Bederson – Quantum
`Treemaps
`
`8/1/2001
`
`
`Byous
`
`Sept. 2006
`
`Carboni GeoPix
`
`Int. J. Web
`Engineering
`and
`Technology,
`Vol 6, No.,
`2011
`Sept. 2010
`
`Carboni, Visualisation
`
`Chizari
`
`9/2008
`
`Cooray
`
`11/2003
`
`Zhang
`
`Quantum Treemaps and
`Bubblemaps for a Zoomable Image
`Browser
`View with a Zoom – Browse and
`Zoom Digital Images in One
`Application (Source Java Sun)
`GeoPix: Image Retrieval on the
`Geo Web, from Camera Click to
`Mouse Click
`Visualisation of geo-tagged
`pictures in the web
`
`Using Google Earth To Visualise
`Photographs Captured with
`Advanced Data
`Enhancing Person Annotation
`For Personal Photo Management
`Using Content And Context based
`Technologies
`Automated Annotation of Human
`Faces in Family Albums
`
`Digital Photos can reveal your
`location raise privacy fears
`
`10/15/2010 Milian
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`13/172
`
`

`

`Author or
`Publisher
`Marian Dörk,
`Sheelagh
`Capendale,
`Christopher Collins,
`and Carey
`Williamson
`David Wilkinson
`Malcolm Hall
`Feng Jing, Lei
`Zhang, Wei-Ying
`Ma
`Hyunmo Kang, Ben
`Shneiderman
`
`Jack Kustanowitz
`and Ben
`Shneiderman
`
`Quang Minh
`Nguyen et al.
`
`Shu-Wai Chow
`Daniel Isenberg
`
`Chang Sau Sheong
`
`Steven Sande,
`Michael Grothaus,
`Erica Sadum
`Ansgar Scherp,
`Srikanth Agaram
`and Ramesh Jain
`Ben Shneiderman,
`et al.
`
`Steve Holzner
`Kyoung-Sook Kim,
`Koji Zettsu, Yutaka
`Kidawara
`
`Howard F.
`Greisdorf and Brian
`C. O’Connor
`
`Reference Title
`
`VisGets: Coordinated
`Visualizations for Web-based
`Information
`Exploration and Discovery
`
`Publication
`/ Use Date
` Nov/Dec
`2008
`
`Short Name
`
`Dörk
`
`Flickr Mashups
`Contextual Mobile Adaptation
`VirtualTour: An Online Travel
`Assistant Based on High Quality
`Images
`Visualization Methods for Personal
`Photo Collections: Browsing and
`Searching in the PhotoFinder
`Motivating Annotation for
`Personal Digital Photo Libraries:
`Lowering Barriers While Raising
`Incentives
`Tagnsearch: Searching and
`navigating geo-referenced
`collections of photographs
`PHP Web 2.0 Mashups Projects
`Pixamo--- Inc, AG, or OOO? (N9-
`806-123)
`Ruby on Rails Web Mashups
`Projects
`Touching Your Digital Photos -
`Taking Your Ipad to The Max
`
`2007
`5/2008
`October
`2006
`
`2000
`
`2005
`
`Wilkinson
`Hall
`Jing
`
`Kang 2000
`
`Kustanowitz
`
`9-2008
`
`Nguyen
`
`2007
`2/9/2006
`
`2008
`
`2010
`
`Chow
`Isenberg
`
`Ruby
`
`Sande
`
`Event-centric Media Management
`
`1/28/2008
`
`Scherp
`
`A Photo History of SIGCHI:
`Evolution of Design from Personal
`to Public
`Sams Teach Yourself Flickr
`StickViz: A New Visualization
`Tool for Phenomenon-based k-
`Neighbors Searches in
`Geosocial Networking Services
`Image Collections Chauvet-Pont-
`d’Arc to Flickr - Structure of
`Image Collections
`
`May-June
`2002
`
`2010
`2010 12th
`Int’l Asia-
`Pacific Web
`Conference
`2008
`
`Shneiderman 2002
`
`Holzner
`Kim - StickViz
`
`Greisdorf
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`14/172
`
`

`

`Author or
`Publisher
`Bongwon Suh.
`
`Scaine.Net
`
`Carlo Torniai, Steve
`Battle, Steven
`Cayzer
`
`Kentaro Toyama,
`Ron Logan, Asta
`Roseway and P.
`Anadan
`Windson Viana,
`Jose Bringel Filho,
`Jerome Gensel,
`Marlene Villanova
`Oliver, Herve
`Martin
`Nan Zang
`
`Aleks Aris, Jim
`Gemmell, Roger
`Lueder
`Andreas
`Girgensohn, John
`Adcock, Lynn
`Wilcox
`Khalid Latif,
`Khabib Mustofa, A.
`Min Tjoa
`
`Charles Freedman
`Shane Ahern, Mor
`Naaman, Rahul
`Nair, Jeannie Yang
`
`Vyron Antoniou
`
`Avrithis, Kalatidis,
`Tolias
`
`Saikat Basu
`
`Reference Title
`
`Image Management Using Pattern
`Recognition Sys
`Tagging JPG photos using EXIF
`properties
`Sharing, Discovering and
`Browsing Geotagged Pictures on
`the Web – Digital Media Systems
`Laboratory
`Geographic Location Tags on
`Digital Images
`
`Publication
`/ Use Date
`2005
`
`Short Name
`
`Suh 2005
`
`1/14/2010
`
`Scaine
`
`5/15/2007
`
`Torniai
`
`11/2003
`
`Toyama
`
`PhotoMap: automatic
`spatiotemporal annotation for
`mobile photos
`
`1/27/2009
`
`Viana
`
`Mashups for the Web-Active End
`User
`Exploiting Location and Time
`for Photo Search and Storytelling
`in MyLifeBits
`Leveraging Face Recognition
`Technology
`to Find and Organize Photos
`
`An Approach for a Personal
`Information Management
`System for Photos for a Lifetime
`by Exploiting Semantics
`Yahoo! Maps Mashups
`World Explorer: Visualizing
`Aggregate Data from
`Unstructured Text in Geo-
`Referenced Collections
`User Generated Spatial Content:
`An Analysis of the Phenomenon
`and its Challenges for Mapping
`Agencies
`Retrieving Landmark and Non-
`Landmark Images from
`Community Photo Collections
`How to Geotag Your Flickr Photo
`& Explore Them by Location
`
`12/2008
`
`9/2004
`
`Zang
`
`Aris
`
`10/2004
`
`Girgensohn 2004
`
`9/4/2006
`
`Latif
`
`2007
`June 2007
`
`Freedman
`Ahern
`
`February,
`2011
`
`October
`2010
`
`Antoniou
`
`Avrithis
`
`6/9/2010
`
`Basu 2010
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`15/172
`
`

`

`Reference Title
`
`Author or
`Publisher
`Saikat Basu
`View Photos Taken Around the
`World
`Yi-Fam Chen et al. GeoTracker: Geospatial and
`Temporal RSS Navigation
`Michael Christel,
`Interactive Maps for a Digital
`Andreas
`Video Library
`Olligschlaeger
`Andreas
`Girgensohn, Frank
`Shipman, Thea
`Turner, Lynn
`Wilcox
`David Crandall et al. Mapping the World ’s Photos
`Madirakshi Das,
`Event-based Location Matching
`Jens Farmer,
`for Consumer Image Collections
`Andrew Gallagher,
`Alexander Loui
`Apple., Inc.
`
`Flexible Access to Photo Libraries
`via Time, Place, Tags, and Visual
`Features
`
`Publication
`/ Use Date
`3/28/2012
`
`Short Name
`
`Basu 2012
`
`May 2007
`
`Chen
`
`June 7-11,
`1999
`
`Christel
`
`June 2010
`
`Girgensohn 2010
`
`April 2009
`July 2008
`
`Crandall
`Das
`
`Various
`
`2009
`Various
`
`2009
`2009
`July 2010
`
`n/a
`
`Exploring Aperture
`n/a
`
`A3UM
`Engst
`Kisilevich
`
`2008
`
`Lacerda
`
`n/a
`
`2/2014
`
`6/23/2008
`9/22/2009
`
`1/13/2009
`9/22/2009
`
`Larson
`
`Lefebvre
`
`Lowensohn 2008
`Lowensohn 2009
`
`MacWorld
`McCracken
`
`June 2004
`
`Naaman 2004
`
`Various Packaging and Marketing
`Materials for Aperture 3
`Aperture 3: Exploring Aperture
`Various Packaging and Marketing
`Materials for iLife
`Aperture 3 User Manual
`iPhoto 09 Visual Quickstart Guide
`Event-based analysis of people’s
`activities and behavior using Flickr
`and Panoramio geotagged photo
`collections
`PhotoGeo: a self-organizing
`system for personal photo
`collections
`Geographic Information Retrieval
`and Spacial Browsing
`How To See Where You Took
`Your Photos At On Your Phone
`Newbie’s Guide to Flickr
`Picasa 3.5 brings facial recognition
`to the desktop
`Macworld Expo Best of Show
`Picasa Gets Face Recognition,
`Built-in Google Maps
`Automatic Organization for Digital
`Photographs with Geographic
`Coordinates
`
`Apple, Inc.
`Apple., Inc.
`
`Apple, Inc.
`Adam Engst
`Slava Kisilevich et
`al.
`
`Yuri Lacerda et al.
`
`Ray R. Larson
`
`Rob Lefebvre
`
`Josh Lowensohn
`Josh Lowensohn
`
`Macworld Staff
`Harry McCracken
`
`Mor Naaman, Yee
`Jiun Song, Andreas
`Paepcke, Hector
`Garcia-Molina
`Fong
`Gabay, Chareyron
`
`Google Picasa 3.5
`Picturing the World
`
`11/2/2009
`06/21/2010
`
`Fong
`Gabay
`
`MemoryWeb Ex. 2014
`Samsung v. MemoryWeb – IPR2022-00221
`16/172
`
`

`

`David Pogue, J.D.
`Biersdorfer
`Quack, Leibe, Gool World-scale Mining of Objects and
`Events from Community Photo
`Collections
`Creation of Personal Space with
`HyWebMap
`
`Hanke
`Hao
`
`Pogue
`
`Quack
`
`2009
`
`7/2008
`
`6/2001
`
`Saleh
`
`Author or
`Publisher
`Ai Gomi, Takayuki
`Itoh
`
`John Hanke
`Qiang Hao et al.
`
`Imad Saleh, Fabrice
`Papy, Nasserddine
`Bouhai
`Maria Dolores
`Salmeron Perez et
`al.
`Diomidis Spinellis
`
`Khalid
`
`The Picasa 3
`ReadMe
`The Picasa 3
`ReadMe
`Jefferson Graham
`
`Tobias Verhoog
`
`Flickr
`
`
`Ellis Hamburger
`
`Reference Title
`
`Publication
`/ Use Date
`March 2011 Gomi
`
`Short Name
`
`A Personal Photograph Browser
`for Life Log Analysis
`based on Location, Time, and
`Person
`A picture’s worth a thousand clicks 5/30/2007
`Generating Location Overviews
`October
`with Images and Tags by Mining
`2009
`User-Generated Travelogues
`iPhoto 09 The missing Manual
`
`Media Database with web interface
`for a local history