`
`WDTX"Implausible Schedule" & Cursory Markman Order Highlighted | Patents Post-Grant
`
`ÿ
`
`ÿÿÿ
`
`ROPES GRAY
`
`ra
`
`JA
`
`
`Inside Views & NewsPertaining to the Nation's Busiest Patent Court
`
`
`./ÿ12344ÿ5267389ÿ39ÿ:;97ÿ<=ÿ<><?
`
`WDTX “Implausible Schedule” & Cursory Markman Order
`Highlighted
`
`By Scott McKeown on June 2, 2021
`
`https:/Awww.patentspostgrant.com/wdtx-implausible-schedule-conclusory-analysis-highlighted/
`
`$$ ) ***+ $ $ $# $+
`
`1/3
`
` -
`
`Micron Ex. 1038,p. 1
`Micron v. Vervain
`IPR2021-01550
`
`Micron Ex. 1038, p. 1
`Micron v. Vervain
`IPR2021-01550
`
`
`
`
`
`ÿ
`
`ÿÿÿ
`
`./0ÿ2030456ÿ789:48;:ÿ<=4ÿ:/0ÿ>09:04?ÿ789:48;:ÿ=<ÿ.0@59ÿA>7.BCÿ89ÿ5ÿ/=:D03ÿ=<ÿE5:0?:ÿ68:8F5:8=?GÿH8?;0ÿIJKLMÿ:/0ÿ;590ÿ6=53ÿ/59ÿ8?;405903
`9=N0ÿOJJPMÿQ8:/ÿ5ÿ98?F60ÿ<030456ÿRS3F0ÿAT=?GÿU65?ÿU6D48F/:Cÿ?=QÿE409838?Fÿ=V04ÿIJPÿ=<ÿ:/0ÿ?5:8=?W9ÿE5:0?:ÿ68:8F5:8=?ÿ3=;X0:GÿÿZ?0ÿ=<
`:/0ÿE48N54[ÿ5::45;:8=?9ÿ=<ÿ:/0ÿ>7.Bÿ89ÿ8:9ÿ30<5S6:ÿ9;/03S60MÿQ/8;/ÿ\S3F0ÿU6D48F/:ÿ/59ÿ/8F/68F/:03ÿ9/=S63ÿD05:ÿ:/0ÿ].U^W9ÿ;=NE0:8?F
`:4856ÿ:8N8?FGÿÿ_=?90`S0?:6[Mÿ:/0ÿabcdÿfbghijdkÿhlÿmnopbqÿrjcsitdjhubikÿrtujbvcÿ5:ÿ:/0ÿ].U^ÿ8?V=6V0ÿ>7.Bÿ;5909Gÿÿ./5:ÿ89Mÿ:/0ÿ].U^
`/59ÿ9/=Q?ÿ30<040?;0ÿ:=ÿ:/0ÿ9E003ÿ5?3ÿ8?V09:N0?:ÿ=<ÿ:/0ÿ>7.BÿQ/0?ÿ30:04N8?8?Fÿ8<ÿ8:ÿ9/=S63ÿ0@04;890ÿ389;40:8=?ÿ:=ÿ30?[ÿ5?ÿUwUÿ:4856
`E0:8:8=?G
`$$ ) ***+ $ $ $# $+
` -
`
`Micron Ex. 1038, p. 2
`Micron v. Vervain
`IPR2021-01550
`
`
`
`./0ÿ234350678ÿ093ÿ:;<.ÿ9=>ÿ?3@/5ÿ0Aÿ6AABÿCA23ÿ46A>367ÿ=0ÿ093ÿ=40/=6ÿD5E3>0C350ÿ093ÿFA/20ÿD>ÿC=BD5@ÿD5ÿ4=>3>Gÿÿ<>ÿ093ÿFA/20ÿD>>/3>
`ÿ
`
`ÿÿÿ
`
`I=0350ÿJ34D>DA5>ÿ=0ÿ=ÿ?23=B534BÿI=438ÿ093ÿ63E36ÿAKÿ=5=67>D>ÿ=5JÿE=6/3ÿ0Aÿ093ÿI/?6D4ÿD>ÿ5ALÿ?3D5@ÿM/3>0DA53Jÿ?7ÿ093ÿ=@3547Gÿ
`N3=5L9D638ÿA0932>ÿ=23ÿ=>>320D5@ÿ09=0ÿ093ÿJ3K=/60ÿ>493J/63ÿD>ÿD5423=>D5@67ÿDCI6=/>D?63ÿLD09ÿ/IL=2JÿAKÿOPÿ02D=6>ÿ?3D5@ÿ>493J/63JÿKA2ÿ=
`@DE35ÿJ=03G
`<>ÿ093ÿQR;SÿJA4B30ÿ4A50D5/3>ÿ0Aÿ3TI=5J8ÿD0>ÿ6DCD03Jÿ?=5JLDJ09ÿC=7ÿ?3ÿD0>ÿ/5JAD5@G
`U34350678ÿD5ÿV:UOPOPWPXOYPÿZ[\]\^8ÿ093ÿ:;<.ÿ@=E3ÿ6D0063ÿL3D@90ÿ0Aÿ=ÿQR;SÿN=2BC=5ÿ_2J32ÿ5A0D5@ÿ09=0ÿ`093ÿ;3T=>ÿ4A/20ÿD>>/3Jÿ=ÿKDE3W
`I=@3ÿ_2J32ÿ6D>0D5@ÿ4A5>02/40DA5>ÿKA2ÿXaÿ032C>ÿD5ÿ093ÿKA/2ÿ=>>3203JÿI=0350>ÿD5ÿ093ÿ;3T=>ÿ4=>38ÿ?/0ÿ5A0ÿI2AEDJD5@ÿ3TI6=5=0DA5>ÿKA2ÿ09A>3
`4A5>02/40DA5>Gbÿ;93ÿJ34D>DA5ÿ4A502=>0>ÿ093ÿN=2BC=5ÿ_2J32ÿAKÿ093ÿcdefdgÿ4=>3ÿD0>36K8ÿL9D49ÿD546/J3Jÿ=ÿ`J30=D63J8ÿhiÿI=@3bÿ=5=67>D>ÿ0A
`093ÿK=2ÿCA23ÿ4/2>A278ÿKDE3WI=@3ÿA2J32ÿ9323GÿÿjA0=?678ÿcdefdgÿL=>ÿKD63JÿLD09ÿ093ÿQR;SÿD5ÿOPXYGÿÿ<44A2JD5@678ÿ?7ÿ4ACI=2D5@ÿ093ÿOPXYÿ=5J
`OPOPÿQR;SÿN=2BC=5ÿ_2J32>8ÿ093ÿ=@3547ÿD>ÿ9D@96D@90D5@ÿ=ÿ>33CD5@67ÿ@2ALD5@ÿ?=5JLDJ09ÿ=5JÿC=5IAL32ÿI2A?63CG
`<>ÿI=20ÿAKÿ09D>ÿ>=C3ÿJD>I/038ÿ=ÿC=5J=C/>ÿI30D0DA5ÿ9=>ÿ?335ÿ6AJ@3JÿLD09ÿ093ÿk3J32=6ÿFD24/D0ÿ4A503>0D5@ÿE35/3GÿV5ÿD0>ÿ?2D3K8ÿZ[\]\^ÿ093
`J3K35J=50ÿ3TI6=D5>ÿ09=0l
`opÿ]\r\psÿt\u]vwÿs[\ÿxuryÿz{|{v{ypÿy}ÿs[\ÿx\vs\]pÿz{vs]{rsÿy}ÿ~\uv
`[uvÿv\\pÿupÿu|uupr[\ÿy}ÿp\ÿus\psÿ}{{pvÿÿ~[usÿry]sÿuv
`uvv{p\ÿyptÿÿus\psÿruv\vÿ{pÿÿÿ\{pÿyp\ÿs[\
`p\]ÿuyyp\ÿsyÿuysÿÿus\psÿruv\vÿ{pÿwÿupÿ
`ruv\vÿ{pÿuÿy}ÿs[\ÿ\{pÿ[up\ÿtÿuÿv{p\ÿ\ÿÿ{|\p
`s[usÿ\yp\ps{uÿ{pr]\uv\ÿ{pÿruv\vwÿ{sÿ{vÿ{uv{\ÿs[usÿs[\
`{vs]{rsÿry]sÿ{ÿ\ÿu\ÿsyÿu[\]\ÿsyÿ{svÿ\}usÿvr[\\ÿ{pÿu
`Z3CI9=>D>ÿ=JJ3J^
`<>ÿ02D=6>ÿ>493J/63>ÿ=23ÿD53ED0=?67ÿI/>93JÿA/08ÿ=5Jÿ53Lÿ>/D0>ÿ4A50D5/3ÿ0AÿID63ÿ/IÿD5ÿQR;S8ÿD0ÿC=7ÿ?3ÿ09=0ÿcdefdgmnÿ0DC3ÿ9=>ÿ=623=J7
`I=>>3JÿKA2ÿ09D>ÿI=20D4/6=2ÿJD>02D40G
`
`us\psÿruv\vFAI72D@90ÿÿOPOX8ÿUAI3>ÿÿ 2=7ÿ¡¡:Gÿ<66ÿUD@90>ÿU3>32E3JG
`
`$$ ) ***+ $ $ $# $+
`
`- -
`
`Micron Ex. 1038, p. 3
`Micron v. Vervain
`IPR2021-01550
`
`