`
`IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`MARSHALL DIVISION
`
`JAPAN DISPLAY INC. and PANASONIC
`LIQUID CRYSTAL DISPLAY CO., LTD.,
`
`
`Plaintiffs,
`
`v.
`
`
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS CO.
`LTD.,
`
`
`Defendant.
`JAPAN DISPLAY INC.,
`
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`v.
`
`
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS CO.
`LTD.,
`
`
`Defendant.
`JAPAN DISPLAY INC.,
`
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`v.
`
`
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS CO.
`LTD.,
`
`
`Defendant.
`
`
`
`
`CIVIL ACTION NO. 2:20-cv-00283-JRG
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`
`
`
`CIVIL ACTION NO. 2:20-cv-00284-JRG
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`
`
`
`CIVIL ACTION NO. 2:20-cv-00285-JRG
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`
`
`
`
`DEFENDANT’S PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS
`
`Pursuant to Patent Local Rules (“P.R.”) 3-3 and 3-4 and the Court’s Docket Control
`
`Order (Dkt. No. 30) (“Court’s Order”), Defendant Tianma Microelectronics Co. Ltd.
`
`(“Defendant” or “Tianma Microelectronics”), hereby makes the following initial Invalidity
`
`Contentions and provides accompanying document production.
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`I.
`
`
`
`Introduction
`
`Plaintiffs Japan Display Inc. and Panasonic Liquid Crystal Display Co., Ltd.
`
`(collectively, “Plaintiffs”) have asserted the following patents in Civil Action Nos. 2:20-cv-
`
`00283-JRG (E.D. Tex.) (“the 283 Action”), 2:20-cv-00284-JRG (E.D. Tex.) (“the 284 Action”),
`
`and 2:20-cv-00285-JRG (E.D. Tex.) (“the 285 Action”): U.S. Patent Nos. 8,218,119 (“the ’119
`
`patent”), 10,139,687 (“the ’687 patent”), 9,715,132 (“the ’132 patent”), 9,793,299 (“the ’299
`
`patent”), 10,018,859 (“the ’859 patent”), 8,218,118 (“the ’118 patent”), 10,423,034 (“the ’034
`
`patent”), 10,330,989 (“the ’989 patent”), 7,936,429 (“the ’429 patent”), 9,310,654 (“the ’654
`
`patent”), 8,830,409 (“the ’409 patent”), 9,817,288 (“the ’288 patent”), 7,636,142 (“the ’142
`
`patent”), 7,385,665 (“the ’665 patent”), and 9,939,698 (“the ’698 patent”) (collectively, the
`
`“Patents-in-Suit”). See Plaintiffs’ Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions
`
`(“Infringement Contentions”), served on January 6, 2021, with amended Appendices 2 and 5
`
`served on January 12, 2021.
`
`
`
`Defendant’s investigation is ongoing. Defendant serves these disclosures based on
`
`information currently available to Defendant at this early stage of these actions. Defendant
`
`reserves the right to modify and supplement these disclosures in response to any amendment by
`
`Plaintiffs to their Infringement Contentions or as Defendant discovers additional information in
`
`the course of discovery.
`
`
`
`This Court has not yet construed any of the terms in the Patents-in-Suit in these actions.
`
`Defendant’s Invalidity Contentions are based on Defendant’s present understanding of the
`
`asserted claims and the apparent construction of the claims used by Plaintiffs in their
`
`Infringement Contentions. Defendant reserves the right to modify or supplement these
`
`contentions in response to the Court’s construction of the claim terms at issue. Defendant’s
`
`Invalidity Contentions, including the attached invalidity claim charts, may reflect alternative
`
`-2-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`positions dependent upon claim construction and scope. These Invalidity Contentions are not an
`
`admission by Defendant that the accused products, including any current or past versions of
`
`these products, are covered by or infringe the asserted claims. Furthermore, by including prior art
`
`that anticipates or renders obvious claims based on Plaintiff’s apparent claim construction,
`
`Defendant does not thereby adopt Plaintiffs’ apparent claim construction. These Invalidity
`
`Contentions do not represent an agreement with Plaintiffs’ views as to the meaning, definiteness,
`
`written description support for, or enablement of any asserted claim.
`
`
`
`Prior art not included in this disclosure may become relevant. Defendant is currently
`
`unaware of the extent, if any, to which Plaintiffs may contend that certain limitations of the
`
`asserted claims are not disclosed in the prior art identified by Defendant. Defendant reserves the
`
`right to identify other relevant prior art with respect to such allegedly missing limitation(s).
`
`
`
`Defendant’s exhibits attached hereto cite to particular portions, teachings, and disclosures
`
`of the prior art as applied to features of the asserted claims. Persons skilled in the art, however,
`
`may view an item of prior art in the context of other publications, literature, products, and
`
`understanding. The cited portions of prior art identified herein are exemplary only. Defendant
`
`will rely on the entirety of the prior art references listed herein, including uncited portions of
`
`those prior art references, as well as additional information including products, documents,
`
`materials, and expert testimony.
`
`
`
`The references cited herein disclose the elements of the asserted claims explicitly or
`
`inherently, and they also demonstrate the state of the art in the relevant time frame. The
`
`suggested obviousness combinations are provided in the alternative to Defendant’s anticipation
`
`contentions and are not to be construed to suggest that any reference included in the
`
`combinations is not by itself anticipatory. Further, the combinations listed herein are exemplary
`
`-3-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`and not exhaustive. There are many possible invalidating combinations of the references listed
`
`herein and it is not practical, at this early stage, to identify and list all potentially relevant
`
`combinations without the benefit of further factual investigation and prior to the claim
`
`construction proceedings.
`
`
`
`In addition to the prior art identified below and in the accompanying invalidity claim
`
`charts, Defendant hereby incorporates by reference any additional prior art and invalidity
`
`contentions that have been or will be disclosed in any other action related to any of the Patents-
`
`in-Suit. Defendant’s incorporation by reference also includes all inter partes review proceedings
`
`at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office related to any of the Patents-in-Suit.
`
`II.
`
`
`
`P.R. 3-3(a): Identification of Prior Art
`
`Defendant identifies the following prior art that anticipates one or more asserted claims
`
`of the Patents-in-Suit and/or renders one or more claims obvious. Defendant also incorporates by
`
`reference each and every prior art reference of record in the prosecution of the Patents-in-Suit
`
`and patents or patent applications related to the Patents-in-Suit, as well as the prior art referred to
`
`in the specifications of the Patents-in-Suit.
`
`
`
`In these contentions, Defendant identifies each item of prior art, including: (1) each
`
`patent, constituting prior art under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. §§ 102(a), (b), and/or (e)/ AIA 35 U.S.C.
`
`§§ 102(a)(1) and/or (a)(2), by its patent number, country of origin, and date of issue; (2) each
`
`non-patent publication, , constituting prior art under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. §§ 102(a) and/or (b)/
`
`AIA 35 U.S.C. §§ 102(a)(1) and/or (a)(2), by its title, date of publication, and, where feasible,
`
`author and publisher; (3) pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(a) and/or (b)/AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) prior
`
`art by the item offered for sale or publicly used or known, the date the offer or use took place or
`
`the information became known, and the identity of the person or entity which made the use or
`
`which made and received the offer, or the person or entity which made the information known or
`
`-4-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`to whom it was made known; (4) pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(f) prior art by the name of the
`
`person(s) from whom and the circumstances under which the invention or any part of it was
`
`derived; and (5) pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(g) prior art by the identities of the person(s) or entities
`
`involved in and the circumstances surrounding the making of the invention before the patent
`
`applicant(s), based on currently available information.
`
`
`
`Defendant’s identification of patents and publications as prior art herein and in the
`
`attached claim charts includes the publications themselves as well as the use of the products and
`
`systems described therein. Defendant’s investigation continues, but information available to date
`
`indicates that such products and systems were (1) known or used in the country before the
`
`alleged invention(s) of the claimed subject matter of the asserted claims, (2) were in public use
`
`and/or on sale in this country more than one year before the filing date of the patent, and/or (3)
`
`were invented by another who did not abandon, suppress, or conceal, before the alleged
`
`invention(s) of the claimed subject matter of the asserted claim. Upon information and belief,
`
`these prior art products and systems and their associated references anticipate and/or render
`
`obvious each of the asserted claims.
`
`
`
`Defendant further intends to rely on inventor admissions concerning the scope of the
`
`prior art relevant to the Patents-in-Suit found in, inter alia: the patent prosecution histories for
`
`the Patents-in-Suit and related patents, patent applications, and/or re-examinations; any
`
`deposition testimony of the named inventors on the Patents-in-Suit; and the papers and any
`
`evidence submitted by Plaintiffs in these actions.
`
`A.
`
`Prior Art Patents
`
`
`
`Defendant identifies the following prior art patents as anticipating or rendering
`
`obvious, either alone or in combination with one or more other prior art references, one or
`
`more asserted claims of the Patents-in-Suit under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. §§ 102(a), (b), and/or (e)/
`
`-5-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`AIA 35 U.S.C. §§ 102(a)(1) and/or (a)(2), and/or 35 U.S.C. § 103:
`
`
`
`Country
`
`CN
`
`CN
`
`JP
`
`JP
`
`JP
`
`JP
`
`JP
`
`JPH
`
`JPH
`
`JPH
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`Patent/
`Application No.
`2789801Y
`
`Filing/Publication/
`Issue Date
`06/21/2006
`
`Inventor(s)
`
`Li (“Li-’801”)
`
`100507693C
`
`10/15/2002
`
`Nakayoshi et al. (“Nakayoshi-’693”)
`
`2002215059A
`
`12/19/2000
`
`Hasegawa (“Hasegawa-’059”)
`
`2002357807A
`
`12-13-2002
`
`Maeda (“Maeda-’807”)
`
`2003075860A
`
`03-12-2003
`
`Nakazato (“Nakazato-’860”)
`
`2005062472A
`
`3/10/2005
`
`Furukawa (“Furukawa-’472”)
`
`2007293155A
`
`11/08/2007
`
`Segawa et al. (“Segawa-’155”)
`
`06186553A
`
`09105918A
`
`11119252A
`
`5185601
`
`5,285,301
`
`5781261
`
`5859683
`
`5,995,189
`
`6097467
`
`6111625
`
`6124917
`
`6188458
`
`6208399
`
`6219115
`
`07/08/1994
`
`Hayakawa et al. (“Hayakawa-’553”)
`
`10/12/1995
`
`Yanagawa et al. (Yanagawa-’918”)
`
`04/30/1999
`
`Ando et al. (“Ando-’252”)
`
`02/09/1993
`
`Takeda et al. (“Takeda-’601”)
`
`03/16/1992
`
`Shirahashi et al. (“Shirahashi-’301”)
`
`07/14/1998
`
`Ohta et al. (“Ohta-’261”)
`
`01/12/1999
`
`Tagusa et al. (“Tagusa-’683”)
`
`12/16/1999
`
`Zhang (“Zhang-’189”)
`
`08/01/2000
`
`Fujimaki (“Fujimaki-’467”)
`
`08/29/2000
`
`Ohta et al. (“Ohta-’625”)
`
`09/26/2000
`
`Fujioka et al. (“Fujioka-’917”)
`
`02/13/2001
`
`Tagusa et al. (“Tagusa-’458”)
`
`03/27/2001
`
`Ohta et al. (“Ohta-’399”)
`
`04/17/2001
`
`Nakayoshi et al. (”Nakayoshi-’115”)
`
`-6-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`Country
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`
`
`Patent/
`Application No.
`6222595
`
`Filing/Publication/
`Issue Date
`04/24/2001
`
`Inventor(s)
`
`Zhang et al. (“Zhang-’595”)
`
`6233034
`
`6266118
`
`6281953
`
`6292237
`
`6297867
`
`6335770
`
`6341003
`
`05/15/2001
`
`Lee et al. (“Lee-’034”)
`
`07/24/2001
`
`Lee et al. (“Lee-’118”)
`
`08/28/2001
`
`Lee et al. (“Lee-’953”)
`
`09/18/2001
`
`Hebiguchi (“Hebiguchi-’237”)
`
`10/02/2001
`
`Miyahara et al. (“Miyahara-’867”)
`
`01/01/2001
`
`Komatsu (“Komatsu-’770”)
`
`01/22/2002
`
`Ashizawa et al. (“Ashizawa-’003”)
`
`6,346,932
`
`11/14/1997
`
`Maeda (“Maeda-’932”)
`
`6356330
`
`6392622
`
`6404475
`
`6411360
`
`6445435
`
`6449026
`
`6462800
`
`6466290
`
`6469765
`
`6532053
`
`6549260
`
`6577368
`
`6583845
`
`3/12/2002
`
`Ando et al. (“Ando-’330”)
`
`05/21/2002
`
`Ozawa (“Ozawa-’622”)
`
`06/11/2002
`
`Nakayoshi et al. (”Nakayoshi-’475”)
`
`6/25/2002
`
`Matsuyama (“Matsuyama-’360”)
`
`09/03/2002
`
`Seo et al. (“Seo-’435”)
`
`09/10/2002
`
`Min et al. (“Min-’026”)
`
`10/08/2002
`
`Kim et al. (“Kim-’800”)
`
`10/15/2002
`
`Kim et al. (“Kim-’290”)
`
`10/22/2002
`
`Matsuyama et al. (“Matsuyama-’765”)
`
`03/11/2003
`
`Ohta et al. (“Ohta-’053”)
`
`04/15/2003
`
`Shibahara (“Shibahara-’260”)
`
`06/10/2003
`
`Yuh et al. (“Yuh-’368”)
`
`06/24/2003
`
`Chung et al. (“Chung-’845”)
`
`-7-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`Country
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`
`
`Patent/
`Application No.
`6650389
`
`Filing/Publication/
`Issue Date
`11/18/2003
`
`Inventor(s)
`
`Sakamoto (“Sakamoto-’389”)
`
`6771342
`
`6798486
`
`6833897
`
`6897931
`
`7148944
`
`7173281
`
`7282091
`
`7327411
`
`7495648
`
`7551256
`
`7675592
`
`7742140
`
`7839476
`
`8053171
`
`8652766
`
`8830429
`
`8908116
`
`9285636
`
`08/03/2004
`
`Hirakata et al. (“Hirakata-’342”)
`
`09/28/2004
`
`Yanagawa et al. (“Yanagawa-’486”)
`
`04/19/2002
`
`Lee et al. (“Lee-’897”)
`
`11/26/2003
`
`Lee et al. (“Lee-’931”)
`
`12/12/2006
`
`Kinoshita et al. (“Kinoshita-’944”)
`
`02/06/2007
`
`Hirakata et al. (“Hirakata-’281”)
`
`10/16/2007
`
`Hashimoto (“Hashimoto-’091”)
`
`02/05/2008
`
`Yoon et al. (“Yoon-’411”)
`
`02/24/2009
`
`Kang et al. (“Kang-’648”)
`
`06/23/2009
`
`Seo (“Seo-’256”)
`
`03/09/2010
`
`Ochiai et al. (“Ochiai-’592”)
`
`06/22/2010
`
`Lee et al. (“Lee-’140”)
`
`05/23/2007
`
`Iwato et al. (“Iwato-’476”)
`
`11/8/2011
`
`Maekawa et al. (“Maekawa-’171”)
`
`10/03/2011
`
`Ishigaki et al. (“Ishigaki-’766”)
`
`09/09/2010
`
`Ishigaki et al. (“Ishigaki-’429”)
`
`10/20/2011
`
`Fujiyoshi et al. (“Fujiyoshi-’116”)
`
`05/27/2009
`
`Kunimatsu et al. (“Kunimatsu-’636”)
`
`20010009447A1
`
`07/26/2001
`
`Ohta et al. (“Ohta-’447”)
`
`20010030717A1
`
`10/18/2001
`
`Kaneko et al. (“Kaneko-’717”)
`
`20010046027A1
`
`11/29/2001
`
`Tai et al. (“Tai-’027”)
`
`-8-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`Country
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`Patent/
`Application No.
`20040036833A1
`
`Filing/Publication/
`Issue Date
`02/26/2004
`
`Inventor(s)
`
`Monzen (“Monzen-’833”)
`
`20040145695A1
`
`07/29/2004
`
`Kurahashi et al. (“Kurahashi-’695”)
`
`20040239641A1
`
`12/2/2004
`
`Takahata et al. (“Takahata-’641”)
`
`20050046779A1
`
`03/03/2005
`
`Sumi et al. (“Sumi-’779”)
`
`20050259210A1
`
`11/24/2005
`
`Lee et al. (“Lee-’210”)
`
`20050099402A1
`
`5/12/2005
`
`Nakanishi et al. (“Nakanishi-’402”)
`
`20050105034A1
`
`05/19/2005
`
`Ono et al. (“Ono-’034”)
`
`20050158665A1
`
`7/21/2005
`
`Maekawa et al. (“Maekawa-’665”)
`
`US
`
`20060103412A1
`
`05/18/2006
`
`Kimura et al. (“Kimura-412”)
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`US
`
`20060170854A1
`
`01/27/2006
`
`Han et al. (“Han-’854”)
`
`20070040816A1
`
`2/22/2007
`
`Toyomaki (“Toyomaki-’816”)
`
`20070171319A1
`
`07/26/2007
`
`Fujita et al. (“Fujita-’319”)
`
`20070200992A1
`
`09/15/2006
`
`Kim et al. (“Kim-’992”)
`
`20080007666A1
`
`01/10/2008
`
`Takeda et al. (“Takeda-’666”)
`
`20080007679A1
`
`01/10/2008
`
`Ochiai et al. (“Ochiai-’679”)
`
`20150116623A1
`
`10/30/2014
`
`Tomioka et al. (“Tomioka-’623”)
`
`20150138476A1
`
`11/17/2014
`
`Hyodo et al. (“Hyodo-’476”)
`
`
`
`
`
`B.
`
`Prior Art Public Use/Sales/Offers for Sale
`
`Defendant believes that there may be sales, offers for sale, and public uses of products
`
`that qualify as prior art under AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(a) or pre-AIA, 35 U.S.C. § 102(b)/AIA
`
`35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) against one or more of the Patent-in-Suits. The below-identified prior art
`
`-9-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`products include products Defendant is currently aware of following a diligent and reasonable
`
`investigation at this stage of discovery and/or based on public available information. These
`
`products include a number of products sold by Plaintiffs or their predecessor entities, and a
`
`number of prior art products that JDI accused of infringement in its Infringement Contentions.
`
`Details regarding such offers for sale and public uses may be within the possession of third
`
`parties, including but not limited to entities associated with JDI, Panasonic, Toshiba, Hitachi, and
`
`Sony, their successors-in-interest, and their respective customers from whom Defendant has not
`
`yet received discovery. As discovery progresses, Defendant intends and reserves the right to
`
`promptly supplement and/or amend the lists below to include additional prior art products that
`
`anticipate and/or render the asserted claims obvious.
`
`1.
`
`US8218118B2
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to September 5, 1999 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`NL128102AC28-01
`NL6448AC33-18J
`
`
`2.
`
`NL10276AC28-02
`NL10276AC28-02F
`
`NL128102AC28-01A NL6448AC33-29
`NL6448AC33-24
`NL10276AC28-02E
`
`US7385665B2
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to October 26, 2005 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`NL128102AC28-01
`NL6448AC33-27
`NL6448AC33-18J
`NL10276AC24-05
`NL6448AC33-18
`NL6448CC33-30
`NL10276AC28-01A
`NL10276AC28-02
`NL10276AC28-02F
`NL10276AC28-01F
`NL6448AC20-02
`
`NL8060BC31-20
`NL8060AC26-02
`NL10276AC30-04R
`NL8060BC26-12
`NL6448AC63-01
`NL8060BC31-09
`NL10276AC30-09
`NL8060BC31-13B
`NL12876AC39-01
`NL6448CC33-30W
`NL128102AC31-02A NL10276BC12-02
`NL10276BC30-04D
`NL6448BC33-50
`NL128102AC31-02
`NL6448BC26-03
`NL160120AC27-01
`NL3224AC35-10
`NL128102AC28-01F NL8060BC26-19Y
`NL6448BC33-46
`NL10276BC20-05Y
`
`NL2432HC22-22A
`NL256204AC15-02
`NL10276BC16-01
`NL6448BC33-59
`NL128102BC29-01
`NL204153BC21-02
`NL204153BM21-01
`NL8060BC31-27
`NL8060BC31-28D
`TM128160CKFWG
`NL10276BC30-24D
`
`-10-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`NL10276BC30-10
`NL128102BC23-03
`NL6448AC33-13
`NL6448BC33-54
`NL8060BC31-18A
`NL6448AC33-15
`NL8060BC31-17E
`NL128102AC28-07
`NL128102AC23-02
`NL8060BC26-23Y
`NL10276AC30-03L
`NL10276BC26-08
`NL128102BC28-09
`NL10276AC30-07
`NL10276AC20-02
`NL10276BC20-07Y
`NL3224CR24-03
`NL10276AC28-01L
`NL128102AC31-01E NL10276BC20-06Y
`NL10276AC28-02A
`NL2432DR22-02B
`NL6448BC33-53
`NL6448AC33-18A
`NL3224CR24-04A
`NL6448BC20-09Y
`NL10276BC28-11A
`NL3224CR24-05A
`NL8060BC31-17D
`NL10276AC28-02L
`NL6448BC33-46D
`NL256204AM15-01
`NL10276BC28-05D
`NL3224BC35-20
`NL6448BC20-12Y
`NL6448BC33-31D
`NL2432DR22-11B
`NL2432HC22-22B
`NL128102AC28-04
`NL6448BC26-01
`NL10276BC24-13
`TM48064BDA
`NL10276BC20-04
`NL4823HC37-03
`NL6448AC30-09
`NL128102BM29-05
`NL128102AC23-03
`NL10276BC30-18
`NL10276AC28-05R
`NL12876BC26-21
`NL10276BC20-08
`NL10276AC30-04L
`NL12876BC26-22F
`NL10276BC30-17
`NL128102AC31-02E NL10276AC30-04W
`NL2432HC22-20
`NL128102BC29-01C NL10276BC12-01
`NL2432HC22-YYB
`NL128102BM29-05A NL10276BC28-11F
`NL3224BC35-21
`NL160120AM27-06
`NL10276BC28-24C
`NL3224ER24-03
`NL160120AM27-06A NL10276BC28-27E
`NL6448AC33-31D
`NL160120BC27-02
`NL10276BC30-04F
`NL6448BC33-27
`NL160120BC27-10
`NL10276BC30-21A
`TMT062AMAGDD
`TMT035CF01
`TMT035DMAFWD
`NL6448BC33-50E
`NL204153BM21-05
`NL1216ER26-02
`LTM12C505N
`NL128102AC28-01A NL8060BC26-15
`LTM12C318S
`NL6448AC33-24
`LTM12C289
`LTM10C272S
`NL6448AC33-29
`NL6448BC33-24
`LTD141EA0D
`NL10276AC28-02E
`NL10276AC30-01A
`LTM035A776G
`NL160120AC27-01A NL10276AC30-03A
`LTM09C362S
`NL10276AC28-01
`NL128102AC23-02A LTM10C321K
`NL3224AC35-01
`NL6448AC33-27G
`LTM14C550S
`NL10276BC24-04
`NL10276AC28-05D
`LTM15C503F
`NL3224AC35-06
`NL10276AC30-04E
`LTM15C551S
`NL128102AC20-07
`NL6448BC33-29
`LTD170LL1SG
`NL10276AC24-02
`EDTCA28QA0
`LTM12C505D
`NL6448AC20-06
`NL8060BC26-17
`LTM12C505X
`NL6448BC33-31
`NL128102AC28-01E ACX506AKM
`NL8060BC31-02
`NL6448AC33-11
`LTH15C503-A
`NL6448AC30-12
`LTM06C381
`ACX507AKM
`NL6448BC20-08
`ACX302AK
`EDT70WZQM02G
`NL8060AC26-11
`LTM06C310
`LTD121LA3S
`NL8060BC31-01
`LTM07C382
`LTD121LA4S
`
`-11-
`
`NL160120BM27-03
`NL6448BC33-59D
`NL6448BC20-14
`NL3224BC35-22
`NL10276BC30-15
`NL8060BC31-32
`NL6448BC20-18D
`NL8060BC26-27
`NL128102BC29-01B
`NL204153BM21-01A
`NL256204AM15-01A
`NL160120BM27-03A
`NL2432HC22-30B
`NL8060BC31-27D
`NL160120AC27-05
`NL6448BC63-01
`NL8060BC21-02N
`NL8060BC31-12
`NL8060BC31-17-BIS
`NL8060BC31-17-CIS
`TMT035AMAGDD
`TMT102DMAGSD
`TMT053AMAGDD
`TMT070ANAGDU
`LTA170C07RF
`LTD121EA4Z
`LTD141EACV
`ACX503AKN
`TX54D11VC0CAB
`LTD121EC5S
`LTD121ECAK
`LTD121KC5S
`LTD121KM2M
`LTD141EC7D
`TR-LM7WR3PS
`LTA090B230F
`LTD141LM1SG-1
`LTD104XA1F
`LTD121EA43G
`LTA070B343A
`LTD121EA4A
`LTD121EX9D
`ACX399CMP-7
`LTM015A312
`LTD121C32S
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`NL10276AC30-03
`NL10276BC26-01
`NL10276AC28-01E
`NL8060AC26-04
`NL10276BC26-03
`NL10276AC30-04
`NL8060BC31-17
`NL6448AC30-06
`NL6448AC32-01
`NL6448BC20-08E
`NL160120BC27-09
`NL6448AC30-10
`LTM10C025
`NL10276AC24-01
`NL6448AC33-10
`NL6448CC20-04
`NL10276AC20-03
`LTM10C209A
`NL8060BC26-13
`NL8060BC26-14
`NL8060BC26-11
`NL10276BC26-02
`NL10276BC24-05
`NL160120AC26-01
`NL6448CC33-25
`NL128102AC31-01
`NL128102AC31-01B
`NL10276AC30-01
`NL10276BC26-09
`NL10276BC28-08B
`NL10276BC28-11
`NL128102AC23-01
`TM12232ACC6
`
`
`3.
`
`LTM12C268E
`LTM12C278E
`TFD58W30MM
`LTM12C263
`LTM12C283S
`LTM13C420S
`LTM14C421
`LTM15C425S
`ACX306AK
`LTM10C386
`LTM15C429
`TFD58W40-F
`ACX705AKM
`LTM10C210
`LTM12C285
`ACX301AKM
`LTM084P363
`LTM08C351
`LTM15C441
`EDTCB29QB0
`LTM035A776
`LTM035A776C
`LTM08C355S
`LTM12C283D
`LTM15C166
`LTM15C423S
`LTM15C428S
`ACX306BKM
`ACX709AKM
`ACX709AKN
`LTM04C395K
`TM12864LCAWG
`
`
`US9793299B2
`
`
`
`LTD141LM0S
`ACX318ELN
`LTM018A02A
`ACX502BMU-7
`LTD154LX0S (Z)
`LTA170C070F
`LTA058B302A
`LTD121C31S
`LTD121GA0S
`LTD121KA0S
`LTD141ECEF
`LTM024D030x
`LTM12C324C
`LTM15C458C
`LTM15C458S
`LTM15C458T
`EDTCB18QEF
`LTD104C11S
`LTD121C30S
`LTD121C30T
`LTD154EX0S
`LTD141LM1SG-181
`LTD154LZ1SG (Z)
`ACX306BKU
`LTM09C362J
`LTM12C300
`LTM12C505W
`LTA140C06HF
`LTM024D250
`LTM022A05D
`ACX506AKU
`LTA065A041F
`
`
`LTD121C33S
`LTD121EC5V
`LTD121EX1Z
`LTA230A172F
`LTM018A073P
`LTA070B381A
`LTD133EX2A
`LTD133EX2S
`LTM09C362Z
`LTD154EZ0HG
`LTM022A230
`LCX059AKB
`LTA058B304A
`LTA065A043F
`LTA070B349A
`LTD104C11U
`LTD111EXDA
`LTD121EXFV
`LTD121EXGS
`LTD121KA0Q
`LTD121LC0S
`LTM08C351S
`LTM024D161
`LTD121EXEQ
`LTD121EXFA
`LTD121EXPS
`LTD133KX2S
`LTD141LM3S
`LTM020A52A
`LTA065B626A
`NL128102AC23-01A
`LTM15C1625
`
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to December 26, 2005 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`NL128102AC28-01
`NL6448AC33-27
`NL6448AC33-18J
`NL10276AC24-05
`NL6448AC33-18
`
`NL8060AC26-02
`NL8060BC26-12
`NL8060BC31-09
`NL8060BC31-13B
`NL6448CC33-30W
`
`NL8060BC31-20
`NL10276AC30-04R
`NL6448AC63-01
`NL10276AC30-09
`NL12876AC39-01
`
`NL2432HC22-22A
`NL256204AC15-02
`NL10276BC16-01
`NL6448BC33-59
`NL128102BC29-01
`
`-12-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`NL128102AC31-02A NL10276BC12-02
`NL6448CC33-30
`NL10276BC30-04D
`NL6448BC33-50
`NL10276AC28-01A
`NL128102AC31-02
`NL6448BC26-03
`NL10276AC28-02
`NL160120AC27-01
`NL3224AC35-10
`NL10276AC28-02F
`NL128102AC28-01F NL8060BC26-19Y
`NL10276AC28-01F
`NL6448BC33-46
`NL10276BC20-05Y
`NL6448AC20-02
`NL128102BC23-03
`NL10276BC30-10
`NL6448AC33-13
`NL8060BC31-18A
`NL6448BC33-54
`NL6448AC33-15
`NL128102AC28-07
`NL8060BC31-17E
`NL128102AC23-02
`NL10276AC30-03L
`NL8060BC26-23Y
`NL10276BC26-08
`NL10276AC30-07
`NL128102BC28-09
`NL10276AC20-02
`NL3224CR24-03
`NL10276BC20-07Y
`NL10276AC28-01L
`NL128102AC31-01E NL10276BC20-06Y
`NL10276AC28-02A
`NL2432DR22-02B
`NL6448BC33-53
`NL6448AC33-18A
`NL3224CR24-04A
`NL6448BC20-09Y
`NL10276BC28-11A
`NL3224CR24-05A
`NL8060BC31-17D
`NL10276AC28-02L
`NL6448BC33-46D
`NL256204AM15-01
`NL10276BC28-05D
`NL3224BC35-20
`NL6448BC20-12Y
`NL6448BC33-31D
`NL2432DR22-11B
`NL2432HC22-22B
`NL128102AC28-04
`NL6448BC26-01
`NL10276BC24-13
`TM48064BDA
`NL10276BC20-04
`NL4823HC37-03
`NL6448AC30-09
`NL128102BM29-05
`NL2432HC22-32B
`NL10276BC30-18
`NL10276AC28-05R
`NL128102AC23-03
`NL10276BC20-08
`NL10276AC30-04L
`NL12876BC26-21
`NL10276BC30-17
`NL128102AC31-02E NL10276AC30-04W
`NL12876BC26-22F
`NL128102BC29-01C NL10276BC12-01
`NL2432HC22-20
`NL128102BM29-05A NL10276BC28-11F
`NL2432HC22-YYB
`NL160120AM27-06
`NL10276BC28-24C
`NL3224BC35-21
`NL160120AM27-06A NL10276BC28-27E
`NL3224ER24-03
`NL160120BC27-02
`NL10276BC30-04F
`NL6448AC33-31D
`NL160120BC27-10
`NL10276BC30-21A
`NL6448BC33-27
`TMT035CF01
`TMT035DMAFWD
`TMT062AMAGDD
`NL204153BM21-05
`NL1216ER26-02
`NL6448BC33-50E
`NL128102AC28-01A NL8060BC26-15
`LTM12C505N
`NL6448AC33-24
`LTM12C289
`LTM12C318S
`NL6448AC33-29
`NL6448BC33-24
`LTM10C272S
`NL10276AC28-02E
`NL10276AC30-01A
`LTD141EA0D
`NL160120AC27-01A NL10276AC30-03A
`LTM035A776G
`NL10276AC28-01
`NL128102AC23-02A LTM09C362S
`NL3224AC35-01
`NL6448AC33-27G
`LTM10C321K
`NL10276BC24-04
`NL10276AC28-05D
`LTM14C550S
`NL3224AC35-06
`NL10276AC30-04E
`LTM15C503F
`NL128102AC20-07
`NL6448BC33-29
`LTM15C551S
`NL10276AC24-02
`EDTCA28QA0
`LTD170LL1SG
`NL6448AC20-06
`NL8060BC26-17
`LTM12C505D
`
`-13-
`
`NL204153BC21-02
`NL204153BM21-01
`NL8060BC31-27
`NL8060BC31-28D
`TM128160CKFWG
`NL10276BC30-24D
`NL160120BM27-03
`NL6448BC33-59D
`NL6448BC20-14
`NL3224BC35-22
`NL10276BC30-15
`NL8060BC31-32
`NL6448BC20-18D
`NL8060BC26-27
`NL128102BC29-01B
`NL204153BM21-01A
`NL256204AM15-01A
`NL160120BM27-03A
`NL2432HC22-30B
`NL8060BC31-27D
`NL160120AC27-05
`NL6448BC20-20
`NL6448BC63-01
`NL8060BC21-02N
`NL8060BC31-12
`NL8060BC31-17-BIS
`NL8060BC31-17-CIS
`TMT035AMAGDD
`TMT102DMAGSD
`TMT053AMAGDD
`TMT070ANAGDU
`LTA170C07RF
`LTD121EA4Z
`LTD141EACV
`ACX503AKN
`TX54D11VC0CAB
`LTD121EC5S
`LTD121ECAK
`LTD121KC5S
`LTD121KM2M
`LTD141EC7D
`TR-LM7WR3PS
`LTA090B230F
`LTD141LM1SG-1
`LTD104XA1F
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`NL128102AC28-01E
`NL6448BC33-31
`NL6448AC33-11
`NL8060BC31-02
`LTM06C381
`NL6448AC30-12
`ACX302AK
`NL6448BC20-08
`LTM06C310
`NL8060AC26-11
`LTM07C382
`NL8060BC31-01
`LTM12C268E
`NL10276AC30-03
`LTM12C278E
`NL10276BC26-01
`TFD58W30MM
`NL10276AC28-01E
`LTM12C263
`NL8060AC26-04
`LTM12C283S
`NL10276BC26-03
`LTM13C420S
`NL10276AC30-04
`LTM14C421
`NL8060BC31-17
`LTM15C425S
`NL6448AC30-06
`ACX306AK
`NL6448AC32-01
`LTM10C386
`NL6448BC20-08E
`LTM15C429
`NL160120BC27-09
`TFD58W40-F
`NL6448AC30-10
`ACX705AKM
`LTM10C025
`LTM10C210
`NL10276AC24-01
`LTM12C285
`NL6448AC33-10
`ACX301AKM
`NL6448CC20-04
`LTM084P363
`NL10276AC20-03
`LTM08C351
`LTM10C209A
`LTM15C441
`NL8060BC26-13
`EDTCB29QB0
`NL8060BC26-14
`LTM035A776
`NL8060BC26-11
`LTM035A776C
`NL10276BC26-02
`LTM08C355S
`NL10276BC24-05
`LTM12C283D
`NL160120AC26-01
`LTM15C166
`NL6448CC33-25
`LTM15C423S
`NL128102AC31-01
`LTM15C428S
`NL128102AC31-01B
`ACX306BKM
`NL10276AC30-01
`ACX709AKM
`NL10276BC26-09
`ACX709AKN
`NL10276BC28-08B
`LTM04C395K
`NL10276BC28-11
`LTM15C1625
`NL128102AC23-01
`NL128102AC23-01A LTA065A041F
`
`
`4.
`
`US8830409B2
`
`
`
`LTM12C505X
`ACX506AKM
`LTH15C503-A
`ACX507AKM
`EDT70WZQM02G
`LTD121LA3S
`LTD121LA4S
`LTD141LM0S
`ACX318ELN
`LTM018A02A
`ACX502BMU-7
`LTD154LX0S (Z)
`LTA170C070F
`LTA058B302A
`LTD121C31S
`LTD121GA0S
`LTD121KA0S
`LTD141ECEF
`LTM024D030x
`LTM12C324C
`LTM15C458C
`LTM15C458S
`LTM15C458T
`EDTCB18QEF
`LTD104C11S
`LTD121C30S
`LTD121C30T
`LTD154EX0S
`LTD141LM1SG-181
`LTD154LZ1SG (Z)
`ACX306BKU
`LTM09C362J
`LTM12C300
`LTM12C505W
`LTA140C06HF
`LTM024D250
`LTM022A05D
`ACX506AKU
`TM12864LCAWG
`
`LTD121EA43G
`LTA070B343A
`LTD121EA4A
`LTD121EX9D
`ACX399CMP-7
`LTM015A312
`LTD121C32S
`LTD121C33S
`LTD121EC5V
`LTD121EX1Z
`LTA230A172F
`LTM018A073P
`LTA070B381A
`LTD133EX2A
`LTD133EX2S
`LTM09C362Z
`LTD154EZ0HG
`LTM022A230
`LCX059AKB
`LTA058B304A
`LTA065A043F
`LTA070B349A
`LTD104C11U
`LTD111EXDA
`LTD121EXFV
`LTD121EXGS
`LTD121KA0Q
`LTD121LC0S
`LTM08C351S
`LTM024D161
`LTD121EXEQ
`LTD121EXFA
`LTD121EXPS
`LTD133KX2S
`LTD141LM3S
`LTM020A52A
`LTA065B626A
`TM12232ACC6
`
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to December 26, 2006 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`-14-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`NL160120BM27-03A
`NL10276BC16-01
`NL160120AC27-01
`NL128102AC28-01
`NL160120AC27-05
`NL128102AC28-01F NL128102BC29-01
`NL6448AC33-18J
`NL128102BM29-05
`NL128102AC28-07
`NL204153BC21-02
`NL10276AC28-02
`NL128102BM29-05A
`NL128102AC31-01E NL204153BM21-01
`NL10276AC28-02F
`NL10276BC20-08
`NL8060BC31-20
`NL160120BM27-03
`NL10276AC28-02A
`LTA320C141F
`NL12876AC39-01
`NL8060BC26-27
`NL10276AC28-02L
`TX54D11VC0CAB
`NL6448BC33-53
`NL128102BC29-01B
`NL128102AC28-04
`NL128102AC31-02A NL256204AM15-01
`NL204153BM21-01A NL10276BC20-11
`NL128102AC31-02
`NL4823HC37-03
`NL256204AM15-01A
`
`
`
`5.
`
`US7636142B2
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to January 30, 2007 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`LTA320C141F
`
`
`6.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US10423034B2
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to February 19, 2008 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`LTA320C141F
`
`
`7.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US9310654B2
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to March 4, 2008 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`LTA320C141F
`
`
`8.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US9817288B2
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to December 9, 2013 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`TL050VYXP02
`TL045JDXP01
`TL045JYXP02
`TL049JDXP01
`LTA320C141F
`LT070ME0500B
`
`TL050JDXP01
`TL050VDXP01
`TL055VDXP01
`TL055VYXP02
`ACX454BLN-7
`LPM084A082A
`
`TL057VDXP01
`TL047JDXP01
`TL047JYXP01-00
`TL050JYXP01-00
`TFTMD089030
`LPM089A001A
`
`TL050JYXP02-00
`TL049JDXP02
`TL060JDXP01
`TL060JDXP01-00
`LPM063Y425A
`LH280WV1
`
`-15-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`TFTMD070021
`LH300WV1
`
`
`9.
`
`LT070ME05000
`LH220Q13-SD01
`
`LPM070W425B
`
`
`LH263H01-VD01
`
`
`US9939698B2
`
`
`
`Defendant believes that each of the below products was offered for sale, sold, and/or used
`
`prior to December 9, 2013 by its respective manufacturer and/or its customers.
`
`TL050VYXP02
`TL045JDXP01
`TL045JYXP02
`TL049JDXP01
`LTA320C141F
`LT070ME0500B
`TFTMD070021
`LH300WV1
`
`
`
`TL050JDXP01
`TL050VDXP01
`TL055VDXP01
`TL055VYXP02
`ACX454BLN-7
`LPM084A082A
`LT070ME05000
`LH220Q13-SD01
`
`TL057VDXP01
`TL047JDXP01
`TL047JYXP01-00
`TL050JYXP01-00
`TFTMD089030
`LPM089A001A
`LPM070W425B
`
`
`TL050JYXP02-00
`TL049JDXP02
`TL060JDXP01
`TL060JDXP01-00
`LPM063Y425A
`LH280WV1
`LH263H01-VD01
`
`
`For the public uses identified herein, Defendant is investigating the identities of the
`
`individuals who knew about and/or were involved in the making, first public use, offer for sale
`
`and/or sale of these products and systems. Defendant is also investigating the exact date that
`
`these products and systems were first made, first publicly used, offered for sale and/or sold. In
`
`addition, Defendant is currently investigating the dates of conception and reduction to practice of
`
`these products and systems and when these products and systems were first known or used by
`
`others. In the course of its investigation, Defendant may identify additional prior art documents
`
`describing these products and systems that may also anticipate and/or render obvious as
`
`invalidating printed publications. Any citation to one or more of prior art references, or other
`
`prior art references regarding these products and systems should be construed to constitute not
`
`only a citation to the prior art reference itself, but also a reference to the associated products and
`
`systems.
`
`C.
`
`Prior art under Pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(f)
`
`
`
`Plaintiffs may have in its possession, custody, or control information related to or
`
`-16-
`
`
`
`JDI/PLD - EX. 2012
`TIANMA MICROELECTRONICS
`CO. LTD. v. JDI/PLD
`IPR2021-01060
`
`

`

`
`
`pertaining to prior art under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(f) but has yet to produce that information
`
`in discovery. Defendant will supplement these Invalidity Contentions if and when Plaintiffs
`
`produce such information and Defendant has had the opportunity to obtain and analyze that
`
`information. Defendant contends that the Patents-in-Suit are invalid under p