`
`Third Generation
`Partnership Project
`
`3GPP
`
`Working Procedures
`
`30 September 2020
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 1 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`2
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Foreword
`
`These Working Procedures of the Third Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) are effective from 30
`September 2020.
`
`An electronic version of these Partnership Project Working Procedures is available from the following
`address:
`
`http://www.3gpp.org
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 2 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`3
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Contents
`
`Foreword............................................................................................................................................................. 2
`
`SECTION A:
`
`GENERAL ........................................................................................................................... 7
`
`Article 1: Description ..................................................................................................................................... 7
`
`Article 2: Purpose ........................................................................................................................................... 7
`
`Article 3: Scope and objectives ...................................................................................................................... 7
`
`SECTION B: PARTICIPATION .................................................................................................................... 8
`
`Article 4: Categories ...................................................................................................................................... 8
`
`Article 5: Partnership ..................................................................................................................................... 9
`
`Article 6: Organizational Partnership ............................................................................................................. 9
`
`Article 7: Market Representation Partnership ................................................................................................ 9
`
`Article 8:
`
`Individual Membership ................................................................................................................ 10
`
`Article 9: Termination of Individual Membership ....................................................................................... 10
`
`Article 10:
`
`Observers and Guests .............................................................................................................. 10
`
`SECTION C: STRUCTURE ......................................................................................................................... 11
`
`Article 11:
`
`Structure of 3GPP ................................................................................................................... 11
`
`SECTION D:
`
`PARTNERS’ COLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITIES ........................................................ 11
`
`Article 12:
`
`Organizational Partners’ Collective Responsibilities ............................................................. 11
`
`Article 13:
`
`Collective responsibilities of all Partners ............................................................................... 11
`
`SECTION E: PROJECT CO-ORDINATION GROUP (PCG) ..................................................................... 12
`
`Article 14:
`
`PCG tasks ................................................................................................................................ 12
`
`Article 15:
`
`PCG participation ................................................................................................................... 13
`
`Article 16:
`
`PCG appointment of Chairman and Vice Chairman ............................................................... 13
`
`Article 17:
`
`PCG Chairman and Vice Chairman Responsibilities ............................................................. 13
`
`Article 18:
`
`PCG meetings ......................................................................................................................... 14
`
`Article 19:
`
`PCG decision making ............................................................................................................. 14
`
`SECTION F: TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION GROUPS........................................................................... 14
`
`Article 20:
`
`TSG tasks ................................................................................................................................ 14
`
`Article 21:
`
`TSG participation .................................................................................................................... 15
`
`TSG and WG election of Chairman and Vice Chairman ........................................................ 15
`Article 22:
`22.1
`TSG elections ................................................................................................................................................... 15
`22.2
`WG elections ................................................................................................................................................... 17
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 3 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`4
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Article 23:
`
`TSG and WG Chairman and Vice Chairman responsibilities................................................. 18
`
`Article 24:
`
`TSG and WG Chairman and Vice Chairmen dismissal .......................................................... 18
`
`Article 25:
`
`TSG and WG decision making ............................................................................................... 18
`
`Article 26:
`
`TSG and WG voting during a meeting ................................................................................... 19
`
`Article 27:
`
`TSG or WG voting by correspondence ................................................................................... 19
`
`Article 28:
`
`TSG or WG voting for the election of TSG or WG Chairman and Vice Chairman ............... 20
`
`Article 29:
`
`TSG or WG appeal process .................................................................................................... 20
`
`Article 30:
`
`TSG and WG meetings ........................................................................................................... 21
`
`Article 30A: TSG and WG participation ..................................................................................................... 21
`
`Article 31:
`
`TSG and WG meeting invitation ............................................................................................ 21
`
`Article 32:
`
`TSG and WG meeting agenda ................................................................................................ 21
`
`Article 33:
`
`TSG and WG meeting registration ......................................................................................... 21
`
`Article 34:
`
`TSG and WG meeting document and file naming .................................................................. 22
`
`TSG and WG Voting Membership List .................................................................................. 22
`Article 35:
`35.1
`Voting list ........................................................................................................................................................ 22
`35.2
`On creation of new TSG or WG ...................................................................................................................... 23
`35.3
`Established TSGs and WGs ............................................................................................................................. 23
`35.4
`Removal from and reinstatement to voting list ................................................................................................ 23
`35.5
`Meetings other than ordinary meetings ............................................................................................................ 24
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 4 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`5
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Article 36:
`
`TSG Sub Working Groups ...................................................................................................... 24
`
`SECTION G:
`
`WORK PROGRAMME AND TECHNICAL CO-ORDINATION .................................. 24
`
`Article 37:
`
`Work Programme .................................................................................................................... 24
`
`Article 38:
`
`Work Items ............................................................................................................................. 24
`
`Article 39:
`
`Work Item creation ................................................................................................................. 25
`
`Article 40:
`
`Work Item adoption by PCG .................................................................................................. 25
`
`Article 41:
`
`Work Item stopping ................................................................................................................ 25
`
`Article 42:
`
`Technical co-ordination .......................................................................................................... 26
`
`SECTION H:
`
`DELIVERABLES.............................................................................................................. 26
`
`Article 43:
`
`Deliverable types .................................................................................................................... 26
`
`Article 44:
`
`Approval process .................................................................................................................... 26
`
`Article 45:
`
`Drafting rules .......................................................................................................................... 26
`
`Article 46:
`
`Copyright and ownership ........................................................................................................ 27
`
`Article 47:
`
`Conversion by Organizational Partners .................................................................................. 27
`
`SECTION I: REPORTING .......................................................................................................................... 27
`
`Article 48:
`
`Chairman’s reporting obligations ........................................................................................... 27
`
`Article 49:
`
`Changes to structure and officials ........................................................................................... 27
`
`Article 50:
`
`Calendar of meetings .............................................................................................................. 27
`
`SECTION J: EXTERNAL RELATIONS .................................................................................................... 28
`
`Article 51:
`
`Relationship with the ITU ....................................................................................................... 28
`
`Article 52:
`
`Relations with other groups .................................................................................................... 29
`
`SECTION K:
`
`MISCELLANEOUS .......................................................................................................... 29
`
`Article 53:
`
`Resources ................................................................................................................................ 29
`
`Article 54:
`
`Support Team .......................................................................................................................... 29
`
`Article 55:
`
`Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Policy ............................................................................... 29
`
`Article 56:
`
`Working language ................................................................................................................... 30
`
`Article 57:
`
`Duration .................................................................................................................................. 30
`
`Article 58:
`
`Review of activities ................................................................................................................ 30
`
`Article 59:
`
`Dissolution, winding up .......................................................................................................... 30
`
`Article 59A: Exhaustion of appeal procedures ............................................................................................ 30
`
`Article 60:
`
`Amendments to 3GPP Working Procedures ........................................................................... 31
`
`Annex A: Definitions .................................................................................................................................... 32
`
`Annex B: Abbreviations ............................................................................................................................... 34
`
`Annex C:
`
`Individual member application form ............................................................................................ 35
`
`Annex D:
`
`(Void) ........................................................................................................................................... 37
`
`Annex E: Guidance for MRP applicants ...................................................................................................... 38
`E.1
`Introduction...................................................................................................................................................... 38
`E.2
`Guidance .......................................................................................................................................................... 38
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 5 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`6
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Annex F: Guidance on meeting organization .............................................................................................. 39
`F.1
`Meeting classification ...................................................................................................................................... 39
`F.2
`Ordinary meetings ........................................................................................................................................... 39
`F.3
`Ad hoc meetings .............................................................................................................................................. 39
`F.4
`Attendance register .......................................................................................................................................... 40
`F.4.1
`Face to face meetings ................................................................................................................................. 40
`F.4.2
`Electronic meetings .................................................................................................................................... 40
`
`Annex G: Working agreements .................................................................................................................... 41
`
`Annex H: Calculation of quorum in TSGs and WGs ................................................................................... 43
`
`Annex I:
`
`Special procedures for exceptional situations restricting travel ................................................... 44
`
`Article 28:
`
`TSG or WG voting for the election of TSG or WG Chairman and Vice Chairman ............... 44
`
`Change history ............................................................................................................................. 47
`
`Annex J:
`
`
`
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 6 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`7
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`SECTION A: GENERAL
`
`Article 1: Description
`
`The Partnership Project is not a legal entity but is a collaborative activity between the following recognized
`Standards Development Organizations:
`
`ARIB
`
`(Japan)
`
`CCSA
`
`(China)
`
`ETSI
`
`(Europe)
`
`ATIS
`
`(US)
`
`TTA
`
`(Korea)
`
`TTC
`
`(Japan)
`
`TSDSI
`
`(India)
`
`The Partnership Project is entitled the “THIRD GENERATION PARTNERSHIP PROJECT” and may be known by
`the acronym “3GPP”.
`
`top
`
`Article 2: Purpose
`
`The purpose of 3GPP is to prepare, approve and maintain globally applicable Technical Specifications and
`Technical Reports for
`
`- a 3rd Generation Mobile System based on the evolved GSM core network, and the Universal
`Terrestrial Radio Access (UTRA),
`
`-
`
`further development of radio technologies such as LTE, coupled with evolution of core network
`elements such as the Evolved Packet Core (EPC),
`
`-
`
`continuing evolution of the 2nd generation GSM/EDGE Radio Access Network (GERAN),
`
`to be transposed by the Organizational Partners into appropriate deliverables (e.g., standards).
`
`top
`
`Article 3: Scope and objectives
`
`The 3rd Generation Mobile System and its capabilities shall be developed in a phased approach. Initially,
`3GPP shall prepare, approve and maintain the necessary set of Technical Specifications and Technical
`Reports for a 3rd Generation Mobile System including:
`
`• UTRAN (including UTRA; in Frequency Division Duplex (FDD) and Time Division Duplex (TDD) modes);
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 7 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`8
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`• 3GPP Core Network (Third Generation networking capabilities evolved from GSM. These capabilities
`include mobility management, global roaming, and utilisation of relevant Internet Protocols);
`
`• Terminals for access to the above (including specifications for a UIM); and
`
`• System and service aspects.
`
`3GPP shall prepare, approve and maintain the necessary set of Technical Specifications and Technical
`Reports for:
`
`- the Global System for Mobile communication (GSM) including GSM evolved radio access technologies
`(e.g., General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) and Enhanced Data rates for GSM Evolution (EDGE)).
`
`3GPP shall consider the long term evolution.
`
`The Technical Specifications and Technical Reports shall be developed in view of global roaming and
`circulation of terminals.
`
`The set of 3GPP Technical Specifications and Technical Reports for the 3GPP core network and the
`specifications for the GSM core network should be common to the greatest extent possible and should not
`be unnecessarily different.
`
`Options in the form of a regulatory requirement particular to one or more regions / nations shall be
`included in 3GPP specifications. TSGs should not debate the inclusion or rejection of such options.
`
`The results of the 3GPP work shall form the basis of member contributions to the ITU in accordance with
`existing procedures.
`
`3GPP shall take account of emerging ITU recommendations on interworking between IMT-2000 family
`members.
`
`In the framework of agreed relationships, the 3GPP Technical Specifications and Technical Reports will form
`the basis of standards, or parts of standards, of the Organizational Partners.
`
`SECTION B: PARTICIPATION
`
`Article 4: Categories
`
`Participation in 3GPP shall be classified into one of the following categories:
`
`• Partners;
`
`• Individual Members;
`
`• ITU Representatives;
`
`• Observers;
`
`• Guests.
`
`top
`
`top
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 8 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`9
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Article 5: Partnership
`
`Partners in 3GPP shall be classified into one of the following two categories:
`
`• Organizational Partners;
`
`• Market Representation Partners.
`
`top
`
`Article 6: Organizational Partnership
`
`Organizational Partnership is open to any Standards Organization, irrespective of its geographical location,
`which has:
`
`• a national, regional or other officially recognized status and the capability and authority to define,
`publish and set standards within the 3GPP scope, in that nation or region;
`
`• an Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Policy which is compatible with those of the Organizational
`Partners;
`
`• committed itself to all or part of the 3GPP scope;
`
`• signed the Partnership Project Agreement.
`
`Standards Organizations may apply to become an Organizational Partner by writing to any of the existing
`Organizational Partners.
`
`top
`
`Article 7: Market Representation Partnership
`
`The Organizational Partners may invite Market Representation Partners to take part in 3GPP.
`
`An invitation for Market Representation Partnership is open to any organization, irrespective of its
`geographical location, which:
`
`• has the ability to offer market advice to 3GPP and to bring into 3GPP a consensus view of market
`requirements (e.g., services, features and functionality) falling within the 3GPP scope;
`
`• does not have the capability and authority to define, publish and set standards within the 3GPP scope,
`nationally or regionally;
`
`• has committed itself to all or part of the 3GPP scope;
`
`• has signed the Partnership Project Agreement.
`
`Organizations may apply to become Market Representation Partners by writing to any of the existing
`Partners. Further guidance for MRP applicants can be found in annex E.
`
`top
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 9 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`10
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Article 8: Individual Membership
`
`Membership in an Organizational Partner is a pre-requisite for Individual Membership of 3GPP. All entities
`registered as members of an Organizational Partner and eligible for participation in the technical work of
`that Organizational Partner, can become Individual Members of 3GPP if they are committed to support
`3GPP and:
`
`• to contribute technically or otherwise to one or more of the Technical Specification Groups within the
`3GPP scope;
`
`• to use the 3GPP results to the extent feasible.
`
`An Individual Member has the right to participate in the work of 3GPP by attending meetings of the
`Technical Specification Groups and subtending groups.
`
`Applications for Individual Membership of a Technical Specification Group shall be made in writing to the
`relevant Organizational Partner using the form given at annex C. Applications may also be made on-line
`using the template available at http://www.3gpp.org.
`
`Individual Members act in 3GPP in their own right and carry the full responsibility for their contributions.
`
`top
`
`Article 9: Termination of Individual Membership
`
`Individual Membership of 3GPP may be terminated by dissolution, abolition, resignation or expulsion from
`the related Organizational Partner.
`
`top
`
`Article 10: Observers and Guests
`
`The status of Observer may be granted by the Organizational Partners to an entity which has the
`qualifications to become a future Partner.
`
`An Observer may send a single representative to an Organizational Partners or PCG meeting. An Observer
`may also have representatives at TSG meetings. Representatives of Observers may receive documents and
`contribute documents for information, but shall not submit documents that propose changes to the
`specifications, reports, work item descriptions, work plan, or any other document under the control of the
`TSG. Observers shall not take part in decision making or hold any leadership positions.
`
`Additional participation rights of an Observer shall be decided by the Organizational Partners on a case-by-
`case basis.
`
`The status of Guest may be granted for a limited period, by the Organizational Partners to an entity which
`has the qualifications to become a future Individual Member. The limited period shall be decided by the
`Organizational Partners on a case-by-case basis.
`
`A Guest may have representatives at TSG and subtending group meetings. Representatives may receive
`documents but shall not take part in decision making, participate in discussions, contribute documents, or
`hold any leadership positions.
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 10 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`11
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`top
`
`SECTION C: STRUCTURE
`
`Article 11: Structure of 3GPP
`
`3GPP shall consist of a Project Co-ordination Group (PCG) and Technical Specification Groups (TSGs). The
`Technical Specification Groups may establish Working Groups if required.
`
`The Organizational Partners may decide to call a meeting of the full 3GPP membership if required.
`
`top
`
`SECTION D: PARTNERS’ COLLECTIVE
`RESPONSIBILITIES
`
`Article 12: Organizational Partners’ Collective
`Responsibilities
`
`The Organizational Partners shall determine the general policy and strategy of 3GPP.
`
`In addition the Organizational Partners shall perform the following tasks:
`
`• approval and maintenance of the 3GPP scope;
`
`• maintenance the Partnership Project Description;
`
`• taking decisions on the creation or cessation of Technical Specification Groups, and approving their
`scope and terms of reference;
`
`• approval of Organizational Partner funding requirements;
`
`• allocation of human and financial resources provided by the Organizational Partners to the Project Co-
`ordination Group;
`
`• acting as a body of appeal on procedural matters referred to them;
`
`• conduct compliance training at least annually for elected leadership, relevant Support Team personnel
`and interested parties on best practices to follow to
`
`• avoid issues with respect to antitrust/competition laws and regulations;
`
`• fulfil his or her leadership or support role with impartiality and in the interests of 3GPP.
`
`top
`
`Article 13: Collective responsibilities of all Partners
`
`Organizational Partners and Market Representation Partners shall perform the following tasks:
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 11 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`12
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`• maintenance of the Partnership Project Agreement;
`
`• approval of applications for 3GPP partnership;
`
`• taking decisions relating to the dissolution of 3GPP.
`
`SECTION E: PROJECT CO-ORDINATION GROUP (PCG)
`
`top
`
`Article 14: PCG tasks
`
`The PCG shall perform the following tasks:
`
`• appointment of PCG Chairman and Vice Chairmen;
`
`• allocation of human and financial resources provided by Organizational Partners to TSGs;
`
`• allocation of voluntary human and financial resources provided by Market Representation Partners and
`Individual Members;
`
`• management of the 3GPP Support Team;
`
`• handling of appeals from Individual Members on procedural matters referred to them;
`
`• propose and approve modifications to the Partnership Project Working Procedures;
`
`• handling of appeals from Individual Members on technical matters referred to them;
`
`• determination of the overall time frame and manage overall work progress;
`
`• final adoption of new and stopped work items proposed by the TSGs within the agreed 3GPP scope and
`objectives;
`
`• when a work item is outside the scope of the 3GPP, and where a common global solution is desired,
`recommend how to achieve a global solution;
`
`• appointment or dismissal of TSG Chairmen and Vice Chairmen, as proposed by TSGs based on election
`results. (The proposed candidate shall be appointed unless there are extraordinary reasons that prevent
`such an appointment, e.g., severe company or geographical imbalance within 3GPP. In such cases the
`TSG shall be requested to elect an alternative candidate. The decision not to appoint a candidate shall
`be made by consensus.);
`
`• authorizing requests from the TSGs for approval to liaise with external organizations, and maintain a list
`of approved requests;
`
`• maintenance of the register of Individual Members eligible to participate in 3GPP;
`
`• maintenance of the register of IPR declarations relevant to 3GPP, received by the Organizational
`Partners.
`
`The PCG may decide to call a meeting of the full 3GPP membership if required.
`
`top
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 12 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`13
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`Article 15: PCG participation
`
`The following shall have a right to participate in the PCG:
`
`• Typically, a maximum of five representatives of each Organizational Partner (not counting the Chairman
`and Vice-Chairmen);
`
`• A maximum of three representatives of each Market Representation Partner. (MRPs are however urged
`to limit their participation to one representative wherever possible.);
`
`• The Chairmen and Vice Chairmen of the TSGs as ex-officio members;
`
`• A maximum of three ITU representatives;
`
`• One representative of each Observer.
`
`Article 16: PCG appointment of Chairman and Vice
`Chairman
`
`The PCG shall appoint their Chairman and Vice Chairmen from amongst the Organizational Partner
`representatives.
`
`The Chairman and Vice Chairmen shall be appointed for a one year term of office.
`
`The Chairman and Vice Chairmen shall normally serve one term of office. If no other candidates are
`available, the Chairman or Vice Chairmen may be appointed for a further term.
`
`Successive Chairmen and Vice Chairmen should not be from the same Organizational Partner, the same
`region or from the same group of companies, unless no other candidate is available.
`
`top
`
`top
`
`Article 17: PCG Chairman and Vice Chairman
`Responsibilities
`
`The PCG Chairman is responsible for the overall management of the co-ordination work within 3GPP.
`
`The Chairman has the overall responsibility to ensure that the Partnership Project Agreement, Partnership
`Project Description and Partnership Project Working Procedures are followed.
`
`The Chairman may nominate officials to assist in the work.
`
`The Chairman may be assisted by the Support Team.
`
`The Chairman may delegate tasks to the Vice Chairmen.
`
`In performing their leadership role, the Chairman and Vice Chairmen shall maintain impartiality and act in
`the interests of 3GPP.
`
`At the commencement of each meeting of the PCG, the group shall be reminded that:
`
`
`
`(i) compliance with all applicable antitrust and competition laws is required; and
`
`IPR2021-00908 Honeywell Exh. 1027 - Page 13 of 48
`(Honeywell International, Inc., et al. v. 3G Licensing S.A.)
`
`
`
`14
`Third Generation Partnership Project Working Procedures, 15 May 2020
`
`(ii) the leadership will conduct the meeting with impartiality and in the interests of 3GPP.
`
`top
`
`Article 18: PCG meetings
`
`A meeting of the PCG shall be held at least twice per year.
`
`At least thirty days before the due date, a calling notice, draft agenda and supporting documents shall be
`issued.
`
`top
`
`Article 19: PCG decision making
`
`In any meeting of the PCG, the quorum required for decision making shall be 50% of the total number of
`Organizational Partners. Proxies shall not be permitted.
`
`The PCG shall endeavour to reach consensus on all issues. The views and opinions of the Market
`Representation Partners and the Chairmen and Vice Chairmen of the TSGs shall be taken into account
`during the consensus building process. If consensus cannot be achieved, the Chairman can decide to take a
`vote. The vote may exceptionally be performed by a secret ballot if decided by the PCG.
`
`Each Organizational Partner shall have one vote. A proposal shall be deemed to be approved if 71% of the
`votes cast are in favour. Abstentions or failure to submit a vote shall not be included in determining the
`number of votes cast.
`
`top
`
`SECTION F: TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION GROUPS
`
`Article 20:
`
`TSG tasks
`
`The TSGs shall prepare, approve and maintain the 3GPP Technical Specifications and Technical Reports
`taking into account the market requirements provided by Market Representation Partners.
`
`The TSGs shall also perform the following tasks:
`
`• Propose to the PCG for appointment TSG Chairman and Vice Chairmen based on election results;
`
`• Creation of TS