Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
`v.
`StratosAudio, Inc.
`
`IPR2021-00721
`
`U.S. Patent No. 8,166,081
`
`Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox P.L.L.C.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstratives
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`1
`
`VWGoA EX1020
`VWGoA v. Stratos Audio
`IPR2021-00721
`
`

`

`Agenda
`
`I. Overview of the ’081 Patent
`
`II. Overview of the Challenged Claims
`
`III. Instituted Grounds
`
`IV.Undisputed Issues
`
`V. Disputed Issues
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`2
`
`

`

`IPR2021-00721
`’081 Patent
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`3
`
`

`

`Introduction to the ’081 Patent
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, 3:6-12.
`
`Display
`
`Speaker
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, 3:27-40.
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, FIG. 3 (annotated).
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 3-7; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶26-29.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`4
`
`

`

`Instituted Grounds
`
`IPR2021-00721 (’081 Patent)
`References
`Mackintosh (EX1004) – Anticipation
`Mackintosh (EX1004) – Obviousness
`DeWeese (EX1005) – Anticipation
`DeWeese (EX1005) – Obviousness
`
`Ground 1
`Ground 2
`Ground 3
`Ground 4
`
`Claim(s)
`9-11 and 23
`9-11 and 23
`9-11 and 23
`9-11 and 23
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 3; ’081 DI., Paper 16, 10, 50.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`5
`
`

`

`’081 Patent – Independent Claim 9
`
`IPR2021-00721 (’081 Patent) – Claim 9
`
`9[a]
`
`9[preamble] A system for combining multiple media comprising:
`a first receiver module configured to receive at least a first media content and data
`enabling the identification of a specific instance of the first media content from
`a first broadcast medium;
`a second receiver module configured to receive at least a second media content
`and uniquely identifying data specific to at least the second media content,
`the second media content received discretely from the first media content;
`an output system configured to present concurrently the first media content and the
`second media content on an output of the first receiver module or the second
`receiver module;
`an input module configured to receive at least a response input responsive to the
`second media content; and
`a transmitting module configured to transmit a response message having at least the
`uniquely identifying data specific to the second media content to a computer server.
`
`9[b]
`
`9[c]
`
`9[d]
`
`9[e]
`
`9[f]
`
`’ 081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-47; ’081 Patent, EX1001, 35:22-41.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`6
`
`

`

`Overview of Mackintosh
`
`Mackintosh,
`EX1004, 2:38-56.
`
`Mackintosh,
`EX1004, 9:60-10:1.
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 5 (annotated).
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-21; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶55-66.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`7
`
`

`

`Overview of Mackintosh
`
`PLAYER
`
`DISPLAY
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 8 (annotated).
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-21; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶55-66;
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 13-15; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶36-41.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`8
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 12 (annotated).
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses the Elements of Claim 9
`
`Element from Claim 9
`
`“First Receiver Module”
`
`Mackintosh’s Mapping to the Elements of Claim 9
`Mackintosh’s Disclosure
`User terminal 212 and/or computer system 702 (referred to as Mackintosh’s “computer”).
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 21-25; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-74.
`(Broadcast module 404. ’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 14-15; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶40-41)
`Broadcast material / audio data. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 21-25; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-74.
`
`“First Media Content”
`“Data Enabling the Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`“Second Receiver Module”
`
`“Second Media Content” / “Uniquely identifying
`Data”
`“Second Media Content Received Discretely
`From the First Media Content”
`“Output System Configured to Present
`Concurrently the First Media Content and the
`Second Media Content”
`“Input Module” to receive a response input
`“Transmitting module” transmitting a “response
`message ” to a “computer server”
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-47; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶55-102.
`
`Program data / cut code. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 21-25; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-74.
`
`Communication Interface 724. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 25-32; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶75-86.
`(Get-data module 414. ’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 14-15; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶40-41)
`
`Supplemental materials / URL or Link. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 25-32; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶75-86.
`
`Receipt of broadcasts and supplemental materials discretely from different servers. ’081
`Pet., Paper 1, 33-35; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶87-90.
`Speakers & display of player 510. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 36-38; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶91-92.
`(Display 410 & speaker 412 of player & peripheral devices 422. ’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 15-17;
`Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶45-46)
`Virtual buttons or selectors. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 38-41; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶93-95.
`Communication Interface 724 facilitates communications with web servers to access
`webpages. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 42-47; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶96-102.
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`9
`
`

`

`Overview of DeWeese
`
`DOCSIS
`Modem
`
`DeWeese,
`EX1005, ¶55.
`
`DeWeese,
`EX1005, ¶58.
`
`DeWeese,
`EX1005, ¶59.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 53-56, 59-64; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶117-25, 125-31.
`Not Evidence
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, FIG. 1A.
`
`10
`
`

`

`Overview of DeWeese
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶97.
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, FIG. 9 (annotated).
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 66-68; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶136-39.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`11
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses the Elements of Claim 9
`
`DeWeese’s Mapping to the Elements of Claim 9
`Element from Claim 9
`DeWeese’s Disclosure
`
`“First Receiver Module”
`
`Set-top box 26. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 57-59; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶122-24.
`
`“First Media Content”
`“Data Enabling the Identification of a Specific Instance of
`the First Media Content”
`
`Television programming. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 57-59; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶122-24.
`
`Program Guide Data. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 57-59; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶122-24.
`
`“Second Receiver Module”
`
`DOCSIS Modem. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 59-64; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶125-31.
`
`“Second Media Content” / “Uniquely identifying Data”
`
`“Second Media Content Received Discretely From the
`First Media Content”
`“Output System Configured to Present Concurrently the
`First Media Content and the Second Media Content”
`
`“Input Module” to receive a response input
`
`“Transmitting module” transmitting a “response message ”
`to a “computer server”
`
`Real-time communications and chat requests. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 59-64; Williams Decl.,
`EX1003, ¶¶125-31.
`IP traffic interleaves packets with distinct headers. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 64-65; Williams
`Decl., EX1003, ¶¶132-35.
`Displaying TV programming and chat messages on a display screen 200. ’081 Pet.,
`Paper 1, 66-68; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶136-39.
`User interface 32 which may include a wireless keyboard 34. ’081 Pet., Paper 1, 68-70;
`Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶140-42.
`DOCSIS modem that facilitates two-way communications with a server. ’081 Pet.,
`Paper 1, 70-75; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶143-50.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 53-75; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶117-53.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`12
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues
`
`IPR2021-00721 (’081 Patent)
`
`Mackintosh discloses a first receiver module – 9[a]
`
`Mackintosh discloses receiving first and second media content – 9[a] and 9[b]
`
`Mackintosh discloses uniquely identifying data specific to the second media content – 9[b]
`
`Mackintosh discloses receiving second media content discretely from the first media content – 9[c]
`
`Mackintosh discloses an input module configured to receive a response input responsive to the second media content – 9[e]
`
`Mackintosh discloses a transmitting module configured to transmit a response message having the uniquely identifying data specific to the second media
`content to a computer server – 9[f]
`
`DeWeese discloses a first receiver module – 9[a]
`
`DeWeese discloses receiving first and second media content – 9[a] and 9[b]
`
`DeWeese discloses uniquely identifying data specific to the second media content – 9[b]
`
`DeWeese discloses an input module configured to receive a response input responsive to the second media content – 9[e]
`
`DeWeese discloses a transmitting module configured to transmit a response message having the uniquely identifying data specific to the second media
`content to a computer server – 9[f]
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-47, 53-75; ’081 POR, Paper 27, i-ii.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`13
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues
`
`IPR2021-00721 (’081 Patent)
`Mackintosh discloses a computer storage device configured to store at least one of the first and second
`media content - Claim 11
`Mackintosh discloses the response message including data that enables identification of a responder -
`Claim 23
`DeWeese discloses a computer storage device configured to store at least one of the first and second
`media content - Claim 11
`DeWeese discloses the response message including data that enables identification of a responder -
`Claim 23
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-47, 53-75; ’081 POR, Paper 27, i-ii.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`14
`
`

`

`Mackintosh
`Undisputed Issues
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`15
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues - Mackintosh Discloses a “First Receiver Module”
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[a] - a first
`receiver module
`configured to
`receive at least a
`first media content
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`User terminal 212
`and/or computer
`system 702
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 21-25; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-74.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`16
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 5 (annotated).
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues - Mackintosh Discloses Receiving First Media Content
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[a] - a first receiver
`module configured
`to receive at least a
`first media content
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Broadcast material
`/ audio data
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 21-32; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-86.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 8:40-49, 9:48-56.
`
`17
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues - Mackintosh Discloses Receiving Second Media Content
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[b] - a second
`receiver module
`configured to
`receive at least a
`second media
`content
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Supplemental
`materials
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-32; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶55-86.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 3:15-23, 5:50-58.
`
`18
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues – Mackintosh Discloses Uniquely Identifying the Second Media
`Content
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`URL or link
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`9[b] - a second receiver
`module configured to
`receive at least a
`second media content
`and uniquely
`identifying data
`specific to at least the
`second media content
`
`Mackintosh,
`EX1004, 23:63-24:4.
`
`Mackintosh,
`EX1004, 23:26-44.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 25-32; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶75-86.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`19
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues - Mackintosh Discloses Second Media Content Received Discretely
`from First Media Content
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`9[c] - the second
`media content
`received discretely
`from the first media
`content;
`
`Receipt of broadcasts
`& supplemental
`materials discretely
`from different servers
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004,
`9:48-50.
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004,
`10:37-40.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 33-35; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶87-90.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 5 (annotated).
`
`20
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues – Mackintosh Discloses an Input Module
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[e] - an input
`module configured
`to receive at least a
`response input
`responsive to the
`second media
`content
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Virtual buttons or
`selectors
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 38-41; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶93-95.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 12:35-46, 13:45-56.
`
`21
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues – Mackintosh Discloses a Transmitting Module
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`9[f] - a transmitting
`module configured to
`transmit a response
`message having at
`least the uniquely
`identifying data
`specific to the second
`media content to a
`computer server.
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Communication
`Interface 724
`facilitates
`communications
`(using a URL or link)
`with web servers to
`access webpages
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 38-47; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶93-102.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`22
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 24:55-61, 23:63-24:4.
`
`

`

`DeWeese
`Undisputed Issues
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`23
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues - DeWeese Discloses a “First Receiver Module”
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[a] - a first
`receiver module
`configured to
`receive at least a
`first media content
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`Set-Top Box 26
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 57-59; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶122-24.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, FIG. 1A.
`
`24
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues - DeWeese Discloses Receiving First Media Content
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[a] - a first receiver
`module configured
`to receive at least a
`first media content
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`Television
`programming
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶55.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 57-59; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶122-24.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`25
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues - DeWeese Discloses Receiving Second Media Content
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[b] - a second
`receiver module
`configured to
`receive at least a
`second media
`content
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`Real-time
`communications &
`chat requests
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 59-64; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶125-31.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`26
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶58.
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues – DeWeese’s Discloses Uniquely Identifying the Second Media
`Content
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`9[b] - a second
`receiver module
`configured to receive
`at least a second
`media content and
`uniquely identifying
`data specific to at
`least the second
`media content
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`Real-Time
`communications &
`chat requests are
`uniquely identified via
`a “unique user
`identification code”
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶76.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 59-64; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶125-31.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`27
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues – DeWeese Discloses an Input Module
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`9[e] - an input module
`configured to receive
`at least a response
`input responsive to
`the second media
`content; and
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`User interface 32
`which may receive
`input through
`wireless keyboard
`34
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 68-70; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶140-42.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶¶67, 94.
`
`28
`
`

`

`Undisputed Issues – DeWeese Discloses a Transmitting Module
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`9[f] - a transmitting
`module configured to
`transmit a response
`message having at
`least the uniquely
`identifying data
`specific to the second
`media content to a
`computer server.
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`DOCSIS modem
`that facilitates two-
`way
`communications
`(using a “unique
`user identification
`code”) with a
`server
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶59.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 70-75; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶143-50.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶76.
`
`29
`
`

`

`Disputed Issues
`
`I. Patent Owner’s Attempts to Read Additional Limitations Into Claim 9
`
`II. Claim Construction for “First Receiver Module” and “Second Receiver Module”
`
`III. Mackintosh Anticipates the Challenged Claims
`A. Mackintosh Discloses the Claimed “Second Receiver Module”
`B. Mackintosh Discloses the Claimed “Output System”
`C. Mackintosh Discloses the Claimed “Data Enabling the Identification of a Specific Instance of the
`First Media Content”
`D. Mackintosh Discloses Claim 10
`
`IV. DeWeese Anticipates the Challenged Claims
`A. DeWeese Discloses the Claimed “Data Enabling the Identification of a Specific Instance of the First
`Media Content”
`B. DeWeese Discloses the Claimed “Second Receiver Module”
`C. DeWeese Discloses the Claimed “Output System”
`D. DeWeese Discloses the Claimed “Second Media Content Received Discretely From the First Media
`Content”
`E. DeWeese Discloses Claim 10
`’081 POR, Paper 27, i-ii; ’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, i.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`30
`
`

`

`Claim Construction
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`31
`
`

`

`Patent Owner’s Attempts to Improperly Rewrite the Claims
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`a first receiver module configured to
`receive at least a first media content and
`data enabling the identification of a
`specific instance of the first media
`content from a first broadcast medium;
`
`a second receiver module configured to
`receive at least a second media content and
`uniquely identifying data specific to at least
`the second media content,
`
`an output system configured to present
`concurrently the first media content and the
`second media content on an output of the
`first receiver module or the second
`receiver module;
`
`9[a]
`
`9[b]
`
`9[d]
`
`1. Patent Owner improperly imports a limitation that the first
`and second receiver modules are “separate and
`distinct,” but provides no explanation for what this
`means.
`
`2. Patent Owner improperly interprets the claimed “output
`system” to require two “separate and distinct” receiver
`modules each having its own output, at least one of
`which being capable of concurrently presenting the first
`and second media content. This interpretation ignores
`the “or” recited in claim element 9[d], which indicates that
`an output system on a single device satisfies the claim.
`
`3. Patent Owner improperly interprets the “data enabling
`the identification of a specific instance of first media
`content” to additionally require distinguishing between
`multiple instances of the first media content as well as
`the data being dynamically determined at the time of
`broadcast.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 3-12; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶11-14.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`32
`
`

`

`Claim Construction for “First Receiver Module” & “Second Receiver
`Module”
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`9[a] - a first receiver module configured
`to receive at least a first media content …
`9[b] - a second receiver module
`configured to receive at least a second
`media content …
`
`’081 POR, Paper 27, 12-15; ’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 5-12;
`Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶15-35.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`33
`
`POR, Paper 27, 12.
`
`

`

`Claim Construction for “First Receiver Module” & “Second Receiver
`Module”
`
`DI, Paper 16, 43.
`
`DI, Paper 16, 44.
`
`’081 POR, Paper 27, 12-15; ’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 5-7;
`Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶15-35.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`34
`
`

`

`Claim Construction for “First Receiver Module” & “Second Receiver
`Module”
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, 6:47-50.
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, 7:2-8.
`
`Moon Depo. Tr., EX1015, 95:16-18.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 6-10; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶19-29.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`35
`
`

`

`Claim Construction for “First Receiver Module” & “Second Receiver
`Module”
`
`The ’081 Patent Discloses a Single Device
`Receiving Both First & Second Media Content
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, 4:50-63.
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, FIG. 4A.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 6-10; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶19-29.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`36
`
`

`

`Claim Construction for “First Receiver Module” & “Second Receiver
`Module”
`
`Claims 1 & 12 recite a “plurality of user devices.”
`Claim 9 recites “modules,” which is broader than
`“user devices.” Had Patent Owner intended to
`limit claim 9 to require multiple devices, it could
`have done so using the same language.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 6-10; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶19-29.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`37
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001, 34:19-49.
`
`

`

`Claim Construction for “First Receiver Module” & “Second Receiver
`Module”
`
`The ’081 patent discloses embodiments with a
`single device having multiple receiver modules that
`output received signals on the same output system
`
`The “output system” recited in claim element 9[d]
`does not support Patent Owner’s claim construction
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`9[d] - an output system configured to
`present concurrently the first media
`content and the second media content on
`an output of the first receiver module or
`the second receiver module;
`’081 Patent, EX1001, 35:32-35.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 11-12; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶30-35.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`38
`
`’081 Patent, EX1001,
`FIG. 3.
`
`

`

`Mackintosh
`Disputed Issues
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`39
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Communication
`Interface 724
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[b] - a second
`receiver module
`configured to
`receive at least a
`second media
`content and
`uniquely identifying
`data specific to at
`least the second
`media content
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 25-32; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶75-86.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`40
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 13.
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Communication
`Interface 724
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[b] - a second
`receiver module
`configured to
`receive at least a
`second media
`content and
`uniquely identifying
`data specific to at
`least the second
`media content
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 25-32; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶75-86.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`41
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 24:55-25:4.
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`Patent Owner’s Arguments
`
`POR, Paper 27, 26.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 13-15; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶36-41.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`POR, Paper 27, 27.
`
`42
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`The Board correctly noted that a single element
`in the art may disclose multiple claimed functions
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 13-15.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`DI, Paper 16, 44.
`
`43
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`Mackintosh Discloses a Second Receiver Module
`Even Under Patent Owner’s Interpretation
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 9
`
`9[a] - a first receiver
`module configured to
`receive at least a first
`media content …
`9[b] - a second receiver
`module configured to
`receive at least a second
`media content …
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Broadcast
`module 404
`
`Get-data
`module 414
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 14-15; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶40-41.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`44
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 8.
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 14-15; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶40-41.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`45
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 20:3-22.
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses the “Output System”
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Speakers &
`display of player
`510
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[d] - an output
`system configured
`to present
`concurrently the first
`media content and
`the second media
`content on an
`output of the first
`receiver module or
`the second receiver
`module
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 36-38; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶91-92.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 21:56-67, 22:55-60.
`
`46
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses the “Output System”
`
`Patent Owner’s Arguments
`
`POR, Paper 27, 30.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 15-17; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶45-46.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`POR, Paper 27, 31-32.
`
`47
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses the “Output System”
`
`Mackintosh discloses a single device including two outputs (speakers & display) that
`present two pieces of media content (broadcast material (first media content) &
`supplemental materials (second media content))
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 15-17; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶45-46.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`48
`
`Petition, Paper 1, 37.
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses the “Output System”
`
`Additionally, Mackintosh discloses multiple devices, each
`with its own output system (display & speakers) capable
`of concurrently presenting two pieces of media content
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Display 410 &
`speaker 412 of
`player & peripheral
`devices 422
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[d] - an output
`system configured
`to present
`concurrently the first
`media content and
`the second media
`content on an
`output of the first
`receiver module or
`the second receiver
`module
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, FIG. 8.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 15-17; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶45-46.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`49
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses the “Output System”
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 20:8-13
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 20:24-30.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 15-17; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶45-46.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`50
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses “Data Enabling Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`Mackintosh’s
`Disclosure
`
`Program data / cut
`code
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[a] - a first receiver
`module configured
`to receive at least a
`first media content
`and data enabling
`the identification
`of a specific
`instance of the
`first media content
`from a first
`broadcast medium;
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-25; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-74.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 8:40-49, 9:7-17.
`
`51
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses “Data Enabling Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`Patent Owner’s Arguments
`
`POR, Paper 27, 34-35.
`
`POR, Paper 27, 33-34.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-25; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-74.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`52
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses “Data Enabling Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`Mackintosh’s cut code “uniquely identif[ies] a segment”
`and “each song … comprises a distinct segment”
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-25; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶67-74.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`53
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 21:10-25.
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses “Data Enabling Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`Identifying a single instance of a
`song is sufficient
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 17-19; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶47-53.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Moon Depo. Tr., EX1015, 133:4-9, 131:18-25.
`
`54
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses Claim 10
`
`Mackintosh’s “tuner knob or button” and/or other
`controls disclose the “output selection module”
`
`’081 Patent – Claim 10
`The system of claim 9 further comprising
`an output selection module configured
`to limit the output of the first and second
`media content based on a criterion.
`
`Mackintosh, EX1004, 12:47-54.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 47-49; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶103-06.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`55
`
`

`

`Mackintosh Discloses All Elements of Clams 9 and 10
`
`IPR2021-00720 (’081 Patent) – Claims 9 and 10
`
`9[pre]
`
`A system for combining multiple media comprising:
`
`9[a]
`
`9[b]
`
`a first receiver module configured to receive at least a first media content and data enabling the
`identification of a specific instance of the first media content from a first broadcast medium;
`a second receiver module configured to receive at least a second media content and uniquely identifying
`data specific to at least the second media content,
`the second media content received discretely from the first media content;
`an output system configured to present concurrently the first media content and the second media content
`on an output of the first receiver module or the second receiver module;
`an input module configured to receive at least a response input responsive to the second media content;
`and
`a transmitting module configured to transmit a response message having at least the uniquely identifying
`data specific to the second media content to a computer server.
`10. The system of claim 9 further comprising an output selection module configured to limit the output of the first and
`second media content based on a criterion.
`
`9[c]
`
`9[d]
`
`9[e]
`
`9[f]
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15-49; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶55-106.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`56
`
`

`

`DeWeese
`Disputed Issues
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`57
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses “Data Enabling Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`Program Guide
`Data
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[a] - a first receiver
`module configured
`to receive at least a
`first media content
`and data enabling
`the identification
`of a specific
`instance of the
`first media content
`from a first
`broadcast medium;
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 15, 57-59; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶ 122-24.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶¶53, 55.
`
`58
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses “Data Enabling Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`Patent Owner’s Arguments
`
`POR, Paper 27, 39.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 21-23; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶59-63.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`59
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses “Data Enabling Identification of a Specific
`Instance of the First Media Content”
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶53.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 22
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 21-23; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶59-63.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`60
`
`Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶63.
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`DOCSIS Modem
`
`DOCSIS
`Modem
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[b] - a second
`receiver module
`configured to
`receive at least a
`second media
`content and
`uniquely identifying
`data specific to at
`least the second
`media content,
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 59-64; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶125-31.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, FIG. 1A (annotated).
`
`61
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`Patent Owner’s Arguments
`
`POR, Paper 27, 39-40.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`62
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses a “Second Receiver Module”
`
`(1) DOCSIS modem receives real-time
`communications (“second media content”)
`from chat equipment 22
`
`(2) DOCSIS modem does not need to be
`separate/distinct from first receiver module
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶58.
`
`DI, Paper 16, 43.
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 59-64; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶125-31.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶59.
`
`63
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses the “Output System”
`
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`
`Displaying TV
`programming & chat
`messages on
`display screen 200
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[d] - an output
`system configured
`to present
`concurrently the first
`media content and
`the second media
`content on an
`output of the first
`receiver module or
`the second receiver
`module;
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 66-68; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶136-39.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`64
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶93.
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses the “Output System”
`
`Patent Owner’s Arguments
`
`POR, Paper 27, 43.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 25-27; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶69-71.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`65
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses the “Output System”
`
`Patent Owner ignores the “or” recited in claim
`9[d], which indicates that an output system on a
`single device satisfies the claim
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶97.
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, FIG. 9 (annotated).
`
`’081 Pet., Paper 1, 66-68; Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶¶136-39.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`66
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses “Second Media Content Received Discretely
`From the First Media Content”
`DeWeese’s
`Disclosure
`Set-top box 26
`receives television
`programming
`separately from two-
`way (real-time)
`communications
`
`’081 Patent –
`Claim 9
`9[c] - the second
`media content
`received
`discretely from
`the first media
`content
`
`Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶134.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 27-28; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶72-76.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`67
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶55.
`
`DeWeese, EX1005, ¶59.
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses “Second Media Content Received Discretely
`From the First Media Content”
`
`Patent Owner’s Arguments
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 27-28; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶72-76.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`68
`
`POR, Paper 27, 45-46.
`
`

`

`DeWeese Discloses “Second Media Content Received Discretely
`From the First Media Content”
`
`Smith, EX1008, Page 3.
`
`Smith, EX1008, Page 3.
`
`Williams Decl., EX1003, ¶133.
`
`’081 Pet. Reply, Paper 31, 27-28; Williams Reply Decl., EX1016, ¶¶72-76.
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibit
`Not Evidence
`
`Smith,