,9BB >E72
`;U[YVK\JPUN
`DPUNSL&5HYYPLY
`86?4
`
`:RUD\ ?XPQH\ 1@F# 2% 4QJ# :74A
`Lead Technologist, Agilent Technologies
`cehWoVhkcd[o;W]_b[dj+Yec
`
`.## <]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 1 of 10
`
`

`

`C>bei[#ed#j^[#^[[bi#e\#D@@@vi#d[m#5-/+.3[#ijWdZWhZ{X[jj[h#
`
`ademd#Wi#HeX_b[#R_H<S OH#{#\ebbemi#j^[#h[ifedi[#\hec#j^[#
`
`O^_hZ*B[d[hWj_ed#KWhjd[hi^_f#Khe‘[Yj#%0BKK&#_d#j^[#\ehc#e\#_ji#
`
`Ged]*O[hc#@lebkj_ed#%GO@&#fhe‘[Yj+#R[#\[Wjkh[Z#R_H<S OH#
`
`_d#Diik[#O^h[[#e\#Agilent Measurement Journal#WdZ#_d#j^_i#
`
`Whj_Yb[#m[#[nfbeh[#m^Wj#GO@#W_ci#je#Xh_d]#je#j^[#m_h[b[ii#
`
`[Yeioij[c+#<\j[h#Yedi_Z[h_d]#j^[#XheWZ[h#Wif[Yji#e\#GO@)#m[#
`
`jWa[#W#Ybei[h#beea#Wj#j^[#kfb_da)#m^_Y^#ki[i#W#d[m#ceZkbWj_ed#
`
`\ehcWj#YWbb[Z#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#\h[gk[dYo*Z_l_i_ed#ckbj_fb[#WYY[ii#
`
`%N>*A?H<&+#O^[i[#Wh[#_dj[h[ij_d]#j_c[i#X[YWki[#_j#_i#hWh[#j^Wj#
`
`j^[#Yecckd_YWj_edi#_dZkijho#hebbi#ekj#W#d[m#ceZkbWj_ed#\ehcWj+
`
`Ahec#Xej^#W#j[Y^d_YWb#WdZ#fhWYj_YWb#fe_dj#e\#l_[m)#j^[h[#_i#ckY^#
`
`je#kdZ[hijWdZ)#[nWc_d[#WdZ#[lWbkWj[#_d#j^[#YWfWX_b_j_[i#WdZ#
`
`X[d[!#ji#j^Wj#N>*A?H<#Xh_d]i#je#GO@+#N>*A?H<#_i#W#^oXh_Z#
`
`ceZkbWj_ed#iY^[c[#j^Wj#YecX_d[i#j^[#bem#f[Wa*je*Wl[hW][#
`
`hWj_e#%K<M&#e\#jhWZ_j_edWb#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#\ehcWji#ikY^#Wi#BNH#
`
`m_j^#j^[#ckbj_fWj^#h[i_ijWdY[#WdZ#_d*Y^Wdd[b#\h[gk[dYo#
`
`iY^[Zkb_d]#"#[n_X_b_jo#e\#ehj^e]edWb#\h[gk[dYo*Z_l_i_ed#
`
`ckbj_fb[n_d]#%JA?H&+
`
`4JYVU‘TZ NHSVYL2 >E7 OPZ[VY‘ HUK JVU[L_[
`
`O^_i#Ze[i#dej#c[Wd#j^[#[dZ#e\#0BKKvi#_dj[h[ij#_d#BNH#WdZ#
`
`R*>?H<+#MWj^[h)#j^[#_dl[ijc[dj#_d#j^[i[#j[Y^debe]_[i#{#WdZ#
`
`j^[_h#h[cW_d_d]#kdjWff[Z#fej[dj_Wb#{#c[Wdi#j^Wj#GO@#_i#dej#j^[#
`
`edbo#\ehcWj#X[_d]#Z[l[bef[Z#_d#0BKK#M[b[Wi[#5+#Aeh#[nWcfb[)#
`
`j^[#@?B@#@lebkj_ed#fhe‘[Yj#m_bb#X[#fki^_d]#BNH#je#d[m[h#b[l[bi#
`
`WdZ#j^[#CNK<(#fhe‘[Yj#{#j^[#hkdd[h*kf#je#JA?H#\eh#GO@#
`
`{#m_bb#Yedj_dk[#je#[lebl[#j^[#kdZ[hbo_d]#R*>?H<)#CN?K<#
`
`WdZ#CNPK<#j[Y^debe]_[i+#Aeh#Wd#el[hl_[m#e\#^em#j^[i[#\ehcWji#
`
`_dj[h*h[bWj[)#fb[Wi[#i[[#wR^Wj#I[nj#\eh#HeX_b[#O[b[f^edo:x#
`
`_d#Diik[#O^h[[#e\#Agilent Measurement Journal+
`
`=o#ki_d]#JA?H)#GO@#_i#Wb_]d_d]#m_j^#i_c_bWh#Z[Y_i_edi#cWZ[#Xo#
`
`0BKK/#\eh#PbjhW*HeX_b[#=heWZXWdZ#%PH=&#WdZ#Xo#D@@@#5-/+.3#
`
`\eh#R_H<S+#Aeh#Wd#el[hl_[m#e\#JA?H#j[Y^debe]o)#fb[Wi[#i[[#
`
`wPdZ[hijWdZ_d]#j^[#Pi[#e\#JA?H#_d#D@@@#5-/+.3#%R_H<S&x#_d#
`
`Diik[#Ome#e\#Agilent Measurement Journal+#<bj^ek]^#j^[#Whj_Yb[#
`
`[nfbW_di#j^[#XWi_Yi#e\#JA?H#m_j^#h[\[h[dY[#je#R_H<S)#j^[#
`
`][d[hWb#fh_dY_fb[i#Wffbo#je#GO@#WdZ#PH=#Wi#m[bb+
`
`R_j^_d#j^[#\ehcWb#0BKK#if[Y_!#YWj_edi)#j^[#GO@#[lebl[Z#M<I#_i#
`
`ifb_j#_dje#jme#fWhji7#j^[#@lebl[Z#PHON#O[hh[ijh_Wb#MWZ_e#<YY[ii#
`
`%@*POM<&#Z[iYh_X_d]#j^[#ceX_b[#fWhj8#WdZ#j^[#@lebl[Z#PHON#
`
`O[hh[ijh_Wb#MWZ_e#<YY[ii#I[jmeha#%@*POM<I&#\eh#j^[#XWi[#
`
`ijWj_ed+#Aeh#i_cfb_Y_jo)#j^_i#Whj_Yb[#h[\[hi#je#j^[#d[m#W_h#_dj[h\WY[#
`
`Xo#_ji#fhe‘[Yj#dWc[)#GO@+#O^_i#_i#X[Yec_d]#Yecced#kiW][#‘kij#Wi#
`
`^Wff[d[Z#m_j^#Wdej^[h#fhe‘[Yj#dWc[)#PHON)#m^_Y^#^Wi#X[[d#
`
`iodedoceki#m_j^#R*>?H<#i_dY[#.666+#Dd#WZZ_j_ed#je#Z[l[bef_d]#
`
`GO@)#0BKK#_i#Wbie#meha_d]#ed#W#Yecfb[c[djWho#fhe‘[Yj#ademd#
`
`Wi#Noij[c#<hY^_j[Yjkh[#@lebkj_ed#%N<@&)#m^_Y^#Z[!#d[i#j^[#ifb_j#
`
`GO@vi#ijkZo#f^Wi[#X[]Wd#_d#bWj[#/--1+#O^[#el[hWbb#]eWb#mWi#je#
`
`X[jm[[d#GO@#WdZ#W#d[m#@lebl[Z#KWYa[j#>eh[#%@K>&)#m^_Y^#_i#W#
`
`i[b[Yj#j[Y^debe]o#j^Wj#mekbZ#a[[f#0BKKvi#Pd_l[hiWb#HeX_b[#
`
`"#Wjj[h#fWYa[j*edbo#Yeh[#d[jmeha#j^Wj#W_ci#je#Z[b_l[h#j^[#^_]^[h#
`
`O[b[Yecckd_YWj_edi#Noij[c#%PHON&#Wj#j^[#\eh[\hedj#e\#ceX_b[#
`
`j^hek]^fkj)#bem[h#Yeij#WdZ#bem[h#bWj[dYo#fhec_i[Z#Xo#GO@+#O^[#
`
`m_h[b[ii#m[bb#_dje#j^[#d[nj#Z[YWZ[+#F[o#fhe‘[Yj#eX‘[Yj_l[i#m[h[#
`
`@K>#_i#Wbie#Z[i_]d[Z#je#fhel_Z[#i[Wcb[ii#_dj[hmeha_d]#m_j^#
`
`i[j#_d#j^[#\ebbem_d]#Wh[Wi7#f[Wa#ZWjW#j^hek]^fkj8#if[YjhWb#
`
`[n_ij_d]#0BKK#WdZ#ded*0BKK#WYY[ii#j[Y^debe]_[i+
`
`[\!#Y_[dYo8#"#[n_Xb[#Y^Wdd[b#XWdZm_Zj^i8#bWj[dYo8#Z[l_Y[#
`
`Yecfb[n_jo8#WdZ#el[hWbb#ioij[c#Yeij+#O^[#cW_d#Z[Y_i_ed#mWi#
`
`m^[j^[h#je#fkhik[#j^[#eX‘[Yj_l[i#Xo#Yedj_dk_d]#je#[lebl[#j^[#
`
`[n_ij_d]#R*>?H<#W_h#_dj[h\WY[#%m^_Y^#_dYehfehWj[i#CNK<’&#eh#
`
`WZefj#W#d[m#W_h#_dj[h\WY[#XWi[Z#ed#JA?H+#<j#j^[#YedYbki_ed#
`
`e\#j^[#ijkZo#f^Wi[)#0BKK#Z[Y_Z[Z#j^Wj#j^[#fhe‘[Yj#eX‘[Yj_l[i#
`
`YekbZ#dej#X[#[dj_h[bo#c[j#Xo#[lebl_d]#CNK<+#<i#W#h[ikbj)#j^[#GO@#
`
`[lebl[Z#hWZ_e#WYY[ii#d[jmeha#%M<I&#_i#XWi[Z#ed#W#Yecfb[j[bo#
`
`d[m#JA?H#W_h#_dj[h\WY[+
`
`#:DB4 !OPNO&ZWLLK WHJRL[ HJJLZZ" YLMLYZ JVSSLJ[P]LS‘ [V OPNO&ZWLLK KV^USPUR WHJRL[
`HJJLZZ !:D6B4" HUK OPNO&ZWLLK \WSPUR WHJRL[ HJJLZZ !:DFB4"% [OL SH[[LY ILPUN
`MVYTHSS‘ RUV^U HZ [OL 7UOHUJLK 6LKPJH[LK 5OHUULS !7&65:"’
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`<]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb#
`
`#/
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 2 of 10
`
`

`

`>E7 VIQLJ[P]LZ HUK [PTPUN
`
`O^[#i_Z[XWh#LTE at a glance#%fW][#/2&#Z[iYh_X[i#j^[#cW‘eh#
`
`eX‘[Yj_l[i#e\#j^[#GO@#fhe‘[Yj#WdZ#iec[#e\#j^[#a[o#ioij[c#
`
`Wjjh_Xkj[i+#A_]kh[#.#i^emi#Wd#el[hWbb#j_c[b_d[#\eh#j^[#GO@#
`
`fhe‘[Yj+#>ecfWh[Z#je#PHON)#j^[#el[hWbb#j_c[iYWb[#_i#i^ehj[h)#
`
`Zk[#bWh][bo#je#W#ckY^#iceej^[h#ijWdZWhZ_pWj_ed#fheY[ii+#O^[#
`
`Z[l[befc[dj#e\#GO@#m_bb#Wle_Z#j^[#5---*fbki#Y^Wd][#h[gk[iji#
`
`kbj_cWj[bo#Wffb_[Z#el[h#W#\ekh*o[Wh#f[h_eZ#je#j^[#w\hep[dx#PHON#
`
`M[b[Wi[#66#if[Y_!#YWj_edi+#O^[#_dijWX_b_jo#WdZ#ikXi[gk[dj#Z[bWoi
`
`#_d#j^[#PHON#ijWdZWhZ#b[Z#je#Yecc[hY_Wb#Z[fbeoc[dj#e\#W#
`
`fhefh_[jWho#ioij[c#_d#EWfWd#X[\eh[#j^[#mehbZm_Z[#ijWdZWhZ#mWi#
`
`WlW_bWXb[+#Dj#_i#[nf[Yj[Z#j^Wj#j^[#ikhfh_i[i#WdZ#Z[bWoi#e\#PHON#
`
`m_bb#X[#Wl[hj[Z#m_j^#GO@)#c[Wd_d]#_ji#_djheZkYj_ed#i^ekbZ#X[#
`
`ceh[#fh[Z_YjWXb[#WdZ#X[jj[h#WXb[#je#Wle_Z#W#fhefh_[jWho#bWkdY^+#
`
`O^[#ZWj[i#_d#A_]kh[#.#Wh[#WYademb[Z][Z#Wi#W]]h[ii_l[#WdZ#cWo#
`
`ib_f8#^em[l[h)#fhe]h[ii#_i#ieb_Z#WdZ)#Wi#PHON#fhel[Z)#jho_d]#je#
`
`hki^#j^[#fheY[ii#YWd#X[#Yekdj[hfheZkYj_l[+
`
`A86?2 EOL JOVPJL VM
`UL_[&NLULYH[PVU ^PYLSLZZ
`
`R_j^#GO@#‘e_d_d]#PH=#WdZ#R_H<S#_d#Y^eei_d]#JA?H#Wi#j^[#
`
`kdZ[hbo_d]#ceZkbWj_ed#j[Y^debe]o)#_j#YekbZ#X[#Wh]k[Z#j^Wj#
`
`j^[h[#_i#dem#b_jjb[#je#Y^eei[#X[jm[[d#j^[i[#Y[bbkbWh#ioij[ci+#
`
`J\#j^[#!#l[#cW‘eh#d[m#Y[bbkbWh#ioij[ci)#edbo#CNK<(#WdZ#@?B@#
`
`@lebkj_ed#Ze#dej#ki[#JA?H)#W#Z_\\[h[dY[#Yb[Whbo#Zh_l[d#Xo#j^[#
`
`JA?H#^Wi#X[[d#WhekdZ#i_dY[#j^[#c_Z#.63-i#WdZ#_i#dem#ki[Z#_d#
`
`W#dkcX[h#e\#ded*Y[bbkbWh#m_h[b[ii#ioij[ci#ikY^#Wi#?_]_jWb#Q_Z[e#
`
`=heWZYWij#%?Q=&)#?_]_jWb#<kZ_e#=heWZYWij#%?<=&)#<iocc[jh_Y#
`
`?_]_jWb#NkXiYh_X[h#G_d[#%<?NG&#WdZ#iec[#e\#j^[#5-/+..#\Wc_bo#e\#
`
`R_*A_#ijWdZWhZi+#Dd#YedjhWij)#_j#^Wi#jWa[d#bed][h#\eh#JA?H#je#X[#
`
`WZefj[Z#_dje#Y[bbkbWh#ijWdZWhZi7#Dj#mWi#Xh_["#o#[lWbkWj[Z#_d#j^[#
`
`bWj[#.65-i#Zkh_d]#j^[#[Whbo#ijW][i#e\#BNH#WdZ#W]W_d#W#Z[YWZ[#
`
`bWj[h#Wi#W#YWdZ_ZWj[#j[Y^debe]o#\eh#PHON#Xkj#mWi#dej#WZefj[Z#
`
`_d#[_j^[h#YWi[+#O^[#fh_cWho#_iik[#mWi#j^[#fheY[ii_d]#fem[h#
`
`d[[Z[Z#je#f[h\ehc#j^[#\Wij#Aekh_[h#jhWdi\ehc#%AAO&#ef[hWj_edi#
`
`Wj#j^[#^[Whj#e\#JA?H+#Dd#j^[#v5-i#WdZ#v6-i)#ik_jWXb[#fheY[iiehi#
`
`m[h[#jee#[nf[di_l[#WdZ#fem[h*^kd]ho#\eh#ceX_b[#Wffb_YWj_edi+
`
`N_dY[#j^[d)#Heeh[vi#GWm#^Wi#Yec[#je#j^[#h[iYk[#\eh#!#hij#
`
`R_H<S#j^[d#PH=#WdZ#dem#GO@+
`
`4ZZLZZPUN [OL HK]HU[HNLZ VM A86?
`
`O^[#fh_cWho#WZlWdjW][#e\#JA?H#_i#_ji#h[i_ijWdY[#je#j^[#ZWcW]_d]#
`
`[\\[Yji#e\#ckbj_fWj^#Z[bWo#ifh[WZ#%\WZ_d]&#_d#j^[#hWZ_e#Y^Wdd[b+#
`
`R_j^ekj#ckbj_fWj^#fhej[Yj_ed)#j^[#iocXebi#_d#j^[#h[Y[_l[Z#i_]dWb#
`
`YWd#el[hbWf#_d#j_c[)#b[WZ_d]#je#_dj[h*iocXeb#_dj[h\[h[dY[#%DND&+#
`
`Dd#JA?H#ioij[ci#Z[i_]d[Z#\eh#ki[#_d#ckbj_fWj^#[dl_hedc[dji)#
`
`DND#YWd#X[#Wle_Z[Z#Xo#_di[hj_d]#W#]kWhZ#f[h_eZ)#ademd#Wi#j^[#
`
`YoYb_Y#fh[!#n#%>K&)#X[jm[[d#[WY^#jhWdic_jj[Z#ZWjW#iocXeb+#O^[#
`
`>K#_i#W#Yefo#e\#j^[#[dZ#e\#j^[#iocXeb#_di[hj[Z#Wj#j^[#X[]_dd_d]+#
`
`=o#iWcfb_d]#j^[#h[Y[_l[Z#i_]dWb#Wj#j^[#efj_ckc#j_c[)#j^[#
`
`h[Y[_l[h#YWd#Wle_Z#Wbb#DND#YWki[Z#Xo#Z[bWo#ifh[WZ#kf#je#j^[#
`
`fhWYj_YWb#d[[Z#\eh#XWYamWhZi#YecfWj_X_b_jo#m_j^#j^[_h#h[if[Yj_l[#
`
`b[d]j^#e\#j^[#>K+
`
`_dijWbb[Z#XWi[i+
`
`+))-
`
`+)).
`
`+))/
`
`+))0
`
`+))1
`
`+)*)
`
`?HO$. @WXG\ SKDVH
`
`?HO$/ CRUN SKDVH
`
`AHVW VSHFV
`
`5VYL
`ZWLJZ
`KYHM[LK
`
`8PYZ[
`[LZ[
`ZWLJZ
`
`8PYZ[ F7
`JLY[PMPJH[PVU3
`
`8PYZ[
`JVTTLYJPHS
`YLSLHZL
`
`5LJXUH (% 9A4 WLPLQJ
`
`0## <]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 3 of 10
`
`

`

`O^[#>K#_i#Y^ei[d#je#X[#ib_]^jbo#bed][h#j^Wd#j^[#bed][ij#[nf[Yj[Z#
`
`JA?Hvi#ej^[h#cW_d#WZlWdjW][#el[h#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#ioij[ci#_i#j^[#
`
`Z[bWo#ifh[WZ#_d#j^[#hWZ_e#Y^Wdd[b+#Aeh#j^[#Y[bbkbWh#GO@#ioij[c)#
`
`[Wi[#m_j^#m^_Y^#_j#YWd#WZWfj#je#\h[gk[dYo#WdZ#f^Wi[#Z_ijehj_edi#_d#
`
`j^[#ijWdZWhZ#>K#b[d]j^#^Wi#X[[d#i[j#Wj#1+36#€i)#[dWXb_d]#j^[#
`
`j^[#h[Y[_l[Z#i_]dWb)#m^[j^[h#YWki[Z#Xo#jhWdic_jj[h#_cfW_hc[dji#eh#
`
`ioij[c#je#Yef[#m_j^#fWj^#Z[bWo#lWh_Wj_edi#kf#je#WXekj#.+1#ac+#
`
`hWZ_e*Y^Wdd[b#_cf[h\[Yj_edi+#OhWdic_jj[Z#WdZ#h[Y[_l[Z#i_]dWbi#
`
`Iej[#j^Wj#j^_i#!#]kh[#h[fh[i[dji#j^[#Z_\\[h[dY[#_d#fWj^#b[d]j^#
`
`Wh[#h[fh[i[dj[Z#_d#j^[#\h[gk[dYo#ZecW_d#Xo#ikXYWhh_[h#f^Wi[#
`
`Zk[#je#h["#[Yj_edi)#dej#j^[#i_p[#e\#j^[#Y[bb+’#Ddi[hj_d]#W#>K#
`
`WdZ#Wcfb_jkZ[+#=o#i[[Z_d]#j^[#jhWdic_jj[Z#i_]dWb#WYheii#j^[#
`
`X[jm[[d#[l[ho#iocXeb#h[ZkY[i#j^[#ZWjW#^WdZb_d]#YWfWY_jo#e\#
`
`\h[gk[dYo#ZecW_d#m_j^#cWdo#h[\[h[dY[#i_]dWbi#%MN)#ademd#_d#
`
`j^[#ioij[c#Xo#j^[#hWj_e#e\#j^[#>K#je#j^[#iocXeb#b[d]j^+#Aeh#GO@)#
`
`ej^[h#ioij[ci#Wi#f_beji&#e\#fh[Z[j[hc_d[Z#Wcfb_jkZ[#WdZ#f^Wi[)#
`
`j^[#iocXeb#b[d]j^#_i#33+4#€i)#m^_Y^#]_l[i#W#icWbb#Xkj#i_]d_!#YWdj#
`
`j^[#h[Y[_l[h#YWd#[Wi_bo#Yehh[Yj#\eh#\h[gk[dYo*Z[f[dZ[dj#i_]dWb#
`
`i[l[d#f[hY[dj#beii#e\#YWfWY_jo#m^[d#ki_d]#j^[#ijWdZWhZ#>K+
`
`Z_ijehj_edi#fh_eh#je#Z[ceZkbWj_ed+#O^_i#Yehh[Yj_ed#_i#fWhj_YkbWhbo#
`
`O^[#_Z[Wb#iocXeb#b[d]j^#_d#JA?H#ioij[ci#_i#Z[!#d[Z#Xo#j^[#
`
`.3L<H)#31L<H&#j^Wj#Wh[#ikiY[fj_Xb[#je#[hhed[eki#iocXeb#
`
`h[Y_fheYWb#e\#j^[#ikXYWhh_[h#ifWY_d]#WdZ#_i#Y^ei[d#je#X[#bed]#
`
`Z[ceZkbWj_ed#YWki[Z#Xo#[l[d#icWbb#[hhehi#_d#f^Wi[#
`
`d[Y[iiWho#m^[d#ki_d]#^_]^[h*ehZ[h#ceZkbWj_ed#\ehcWji#%[+]+)#
`
`YecfWh[Z#je#j^[#[nf[Yj[Z#Z[bWo#ifh[WZ+#GO@#^Wi#Y^ei[d#
`
`WdZ#Wcfb_jkZ[+#
`
`.2#aCp#ikXYWhh_[h#ifWY_d])#]_l_d]#33+4#€i#\eh#j^[#iocXeb#b[d]j^+#
`
`Dd#W#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#ioij[c)#j^[#iocXeb#b[d]j^#_i#Ybei[bo#h[bWj[Z#
`
`O^_i#WX_b_jo#je#[Wi_bo#cWd_fkbWj[#f^Wi[#WdZ#\h[gk[dYo#Wbie#b[dZi#
`
`je#j^[#eYYkf_[Z#XWdZm_Zj^+#Aeh#[nWcfb[)#BNH#^Wi#/--#aCp#
`
`_ji[b\#je#j^[#fheY[ii_d]#h[gk_h[Z#\eh#ckbj_fb[*_dfkj,ckbj_fb[*
`
`Y^Wdd[b#ifWY_d]#WdZ#W#/4-+500#aifi#iocXeb#hWj[)#]_l_d]#W#
`
`ekjfkj#%HDHJ&#Wdj[ddW#j[Y^d_gk[i#ikY^#Wi#ifWj_Wb#ckbj_fb[n_d]#
`
`0+36#€i#iocXeb#b[d]j^#j^Wj#_i#.5#j_c[i#i^ehj[h#j^Wd#j^Wj#e\#GO@+#
`
`WdZ#X[Wc\ehc_d]+#O^[#h[gk_h[Z#cWd_fkbWj_edi#e\#i_]dWb#f^Wi[#
`
`Dd#YedjhWij)#R*>?H<#^Wi#2#HCp#Y^Wdd[b#ifWY_d]#WdZ#W#
`
`WdZ#Wcfb_jkZ[#Wh[#ckY^#[Wi_[h#je#_cfb[c[dj#_d#JA?H#ioij[ci#
`
`0+51#Hifi#iocXeb#hWj[)#fheZkY_d]#W#-+/3#€i#iocXeb#b[d]j^#
`
`j^Wd#_d#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#ioij[ci)#m^_Y^#h[fh[i[dj#i_]dWbi#_d#j^[#
`
`{#/23#j_c[i#i^ehj[h#j^Wd#GO@+#Dj#mekbZ#X[#_cfhWYj_YWb#je#_di[hj#
`
`j_c[#ZecW_d+
`
`W#1+36#€i#>K#X[jm[[d#ikY^#i^ehj#iocXebi#X[YWki[#YWfWY_jo#
`
`mekbZ#Zhef#Xo#ceh[#j^Wd#^Wb\#m_j^#BNH#WdZ#Xo#W#\WYjeh#e\#
`
`Oe#ikccWh_p[#j^[#WZlWdjW][i)#JA?H#ioij[ci#jhWdic_j#ckbj_fb[#
`
`/-#m_j^#R*>?H<+#Noij[ci#j^Wj#ki[#i^ehj#iocXeb#b[d]j^i#
`
`bem*hWj[#ikXYWhh_[hi#{#h[i_ijWdj#je#ckbj_fWj^#{#j^Wj#YecX_d[#
`
`YecfWh[Z#je#j^[#Z[bWo#ifh[WZ#ckij#h[bo#ed#h[Y[_l[h*i_Z[#
`
`Xo#j^[#^kdZh[Zi#WdZ#j^ekiWdZi#je#fhel_Z[#W#jhkbo#iYWbWXb[#
`
`Y^Wdd[b#[gkWb_p[hi#je#h[Yel[h#j^[#eh_]_dWb#i_]dWb+#
`
`ioij[c#XWdZm_Zj^#WdZ#WiieY_Wj[Z#ZWjW#hWj[i+#Dd#WZZ_j_ed)#
`
`j^[#\h[gk[dYo*ZecW_d#h[fh[i[djWj_ed#e\#i_]dWbi#i_cfb_!#[i#
`
`O^[#b_da#X[jm[[d#Y^Wdd[b#XWdZm_Zj^#WdZ#iocXeb#b[d]j^#fkji#
`
`j^[#Yehh[Yj_ed#e\#i_]dWb#[hhehi#_d#j^[#h[Y[_l[h#WdZ#h[ZkY[i#j^[#
`
`i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#ioij[ci#Wj#W#Z_iWZlWdjW][#l[hiki#JA?H#m^[d#
`
`Yecfb[n_jo#e\#HDHJ#_cfb[c[djWj_ed+#=o#YedjhWij)#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#
`
`j^[#Y^Wdd[b#XWdZm_Zj^i#][j#m_Z[h+#>edi_Z[h#W#hWZ_e#Y^Wdd[b#
`
`ioij[ci#Ze#dej#iYWb[#m[bb#m_j^#XWdZm_Zj^#WdZ#Wh[#_cfhWYj_YWb#
`
`m_j^#.#€i#e\#Z[bWo#ifh[WZ7#<#2#HCp#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#i_]dWb#mekbZ#
`
`Wj#ckY^#WXel[#2#HCp#_\#fWj^#Z[bWo#Z_\\[h[dY[i#Wh[#bed]+
`
`[nf[h_[dY[#Wffhen_cWj[bo#!#l[#iocXebi#e\#DND#WdZ#W#/-#HCp#
`
`i_]dWb#mekbZ#[nf[h_[dY[#Wffhen_cWj[bo#/-#iocXebi#e\#DND+#O^[#
`
`Wcekdj#e\#DND#Z[j[hc_d[i#^em#^WhZ#j^[#[gkWb_p[h#^Wi#je#meha#
`
`WdZ#j^[h[#[n_iji#W#fhWYj_YWb#kff[h#b_c_j#e\#WXekj#2#HCp#X[oedZ#
`
`m^_Y^#[gkWb_p[h#Yeiji#h_i[#WdZ#f[h\ehcWdY[#Zhefi#e\\+
`
`@WY^#.2#aCp#ikXYWhh_[h#_d#GO@#_i#YWfWXb[#e\#jhWdic_jj_d]#.2#aifi)#
`
`]_l_d]#GO@#W#hWm#iocXeb#hWj[#e\#.5#Hifi#Wj#_ji#/-#HCp#ioij[c#
`
`XWdZm_Zj^#%./--#ikXYWhh_[hi)#.5#HCp&+#Pi_d]#31L<H#{#j^[#
`
`ceij#Yecfb[n#e\#j^[#GO@#ceZkbWj_ed#\ehcWji#{#_d#m^_Y^#ed[#
`
`iocXeb#h[fh[i[dji#i_n#X_ji)#j^[#hWm#YWfWY_jo#_i#.-5#HXfi+#
`
`Iej[#j^Wj#WYjkWb#f[Wa#hWj[i#Wi#Z[iYh_X[Z#_d#j^[#GO@#i_Z[XWh#Wh[#
`
`Z[h_l[Z#Xo#ikXjhWYj_d]#YeZ_d]#WdZ#Yedjheb#el[h^[WZi#WdZ#WZZ_d]#
`
`]W_di#\hec#\[Wjkh[i#ikY^#Wi#ifWj_Wb#ckbj_fb[n_d]+
`
`#>VUNLY 5B SLUN[OZ HYL H]HPSHISL MVY \ZL PU SHYNLY JLSSZ HUK MVY ZWLJPHSPZ[ T\S[P&JLSS
`IYVHKJHZ[ HWWSPJH[PVUZ’ EOPZ WYV]PKLZ WYV[LJ[PVU MVY \W [V *) RT KLSH‘ ZWYLHK I\[
`^P[O H WYVWVY[PVUHS YLK\J[PVU PU [OL HJOPL]HISL KH[H YH[LZ’
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`<]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb#
`
`#1
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 4 of 10
`
`

`

`7_HTPUPUN [OL KPZHK]HU[HNLZ VM A86?
`
`;U[YVK\JPUN D5&86?4
`
`JA?H#^Wi#jme#X_]#Z_iWZlWdjW][i#m^[d#YecfWh[Z#je#i_d]b[*
`
`O^[#kdZ[i_hWXb[#^_]^#K<M#e\#JA?H#b[Z#0BKK#je#Y^eei[#W#
`
`YWhh_[h#ioij[ci+#A_hij)#Wi#j^[#dkcX[h#e\#ikXYWhh_[hi#_dYh[Wi[i)#
`
`Z_\\[h[dj#ceZkbWj_ed#\ehcWj#\eh#j^[#GO@#kfb_da+#O^_i#Z_\\[h[dY[#
`
`j^[#Yecfei_j[#j_c[*ZecW_d#i_]dWb#ijWhji#je#beea#b_a[#BWkii_Wd#
`
`Yedjh_Xkj[Z#je#j^[#_dWX_b_jo#e\#OO<)#j^[#Feh[Wd#ijWdZWhZi#XeZo)#
`
`de_i[)#m^_Y^#^Wi#W#^_]^#f[Wa*je*Wl[hW][#hWj_e#%K<M&#j^Wj#YWd#
`
`je#f[hikWZ[#0BKK#%_d#/--3&#je#c[h][#GO@#WdZ#R_H<S+#Kkh[#
`
`YWki[#fheXb[ci#\eh#Wcfb_!#[hi+#<bbem_d]#j^[#f[Wai#je#Z_ijehj#
`
`JA?H#_i#ki[Z#_d#j^[#R_H<S#kfb_da#Xkj#GO@#Yedj_dk[Z#je#ki[#
`
`_i#kdWYY[fjWXb[#X[YWki[#j^_i#YWki[i#if[YjhWb#h[]hemj^#_d#j^[#
`
`N>*A?H<)#W#d[m#^oXh_Z#ceZkbWj_ed#iY^[c[#j^Wj#Yb[l[hbo#Yec*
`
`WZ‘WY[dj#Y^Wdd[bi+#HeZ_\o_d]#Wd#Wcfb_!#[h#je#Wle_Z#Z_ijehj_ed#
`
`X_d[i#j^[#bem#K<M#e\#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#ioij[ci#m_j^#j^[#ckbj_fWj^#
`
`e\j[d#h[gk_h[i#_dYh[Wi[i#_d#Yeij)#i_p[#WdZ#fem[h#Yedikcfj_ed+#
`
`h[i_ijWdY[#WdZ#"#[n_Xb[#ikXYWhh_[h#\h[gk[dYo#WbbeYWj_ed#e\\[h[Z#
`
`O^[h[#[n_ij#j[Y^d_gk[i#je#b_c_j#j^[#f[Wai#%[+]+)#Yb_ff_d]#WdZ#jed[#
`
`Xo#JA?H+
`
`h[i[hlWj_ed’&#Xkj#Wbb#^Wl[#b_c_ji#WdZ#YWd#Yedikc[#i_]d_!#YWdj#
`
`fheY[ii_d]#fem[h#m^_b[#Z[]hWZ_d]#_d*Y^Wdd[b#i_]dWb#gkWb_jo+
`
`R^[d#W#d[m#YedY[fj#_d#ceZkbWj_ed#Yec[i#Wbed]#%[+]+)#JA?H#
`
`eh#>?H<&)#_j#YWd#jWa[#W#bed]#j_c[#X[\eh[#j^[#b_j[hWjkh[#ijWhji#je#
`
`O^[#ej^[h#cW_d#Z_iWZlWdjW][#e\#JA?H#ioij[ci#_i#YWki[Z#Xo#
`
`cWa[#i[di[+#T[j)#W\j[h#[l[hoed[#w][ji#_j)x#m[#e\j[d#beea#XWYa#
`
`j_]^j#ifWY_d]#e\#ikXYWhh_[hi+#Oe#c_d_c_p[#j^[#beij#[\!#Y_[dYo#
`
`Wj#m^Wj#fh[l_ekibo#i[[c[Z#je#X[#_cf[d[jhWXb[#[nfbWdWj_edi#
`
`YWki[Z#Xo#_di[hj_d]#j^[#>K)#_j#_i#Z[i_hWXb[#je#^Wl[#l[ho#bed]#
`
`WdZ#medZ[h#m^Wj#j^[#\kii#mWi#WXekj$#Ne#_j#cWo#X[#m_j^#
`
`iocXebi)#m^_Y^#c[Wdi#Ybei[bo#ifWY[Z#ikXYWhh_[hi8#^em[l[h)#
`
`N>*A?H<+#O^[#M[b[Wi[#5#0BKK#if[Y_!#YWj_edi#Ze#b_jjb[#je#
`
`WfWhj#\hec#_dYh[Wi_d]#j^[#h[gk_h[Z#fheY[ii_d])#Ybei[#ikXYWhh_[hi#
`
`[nfbW_d#j^[#YedY[fj+#Aeh#W#\ehcWb#Z[!#d_j_ed#e\#N>*A?H<)#
`
`ijWhj#je#bei[#j^[_h#ehj^e]edWb_jo#%_dZ[f[dZ[dY[#\hec#[WY^#ej^[h&#
`
`W#ijkZ[dj#e\#i_]dWb#fheY[ii_d]#d[[Z#beea#de#\khj^[h#j^Wd#
`
`Zk[#je#\h[gk[dYo#[hhehi+#O^h[[#a[o#fheXb[ci#WiieY_Wj[Z#m_j^#
`
`ON#03+/..)#m^_Y^#]_l[i#j^[#cWj^[cWj_YWb#Z[iYh_fj_ed#e\#j^[#
`
`Ybei[#ikXYWhh_[hi#YWki[#beij#f[h\ehcWdY[+#A_hij)#Wdo#\h[gk[dYo#
`
`j_c[*ZecW_d#h[fh[i[djWj_ed#e\#Wd#N>*A?H<#iocXeb+/#Aeh#j^[#
`
`[hheh#_d#j^[#h[Y[_l[h#m_bb#YWki[#[d[h]o#\hec#ed[#ikXYWhh_[hvi#
`
`cW‘eh_jo#e\#ki#m^e#!#dZ#j^[#\ehcWb#cWj^[cWj_YWb#WffheWY^#^WhZ#
`
`iocXeb#je#_dj[h\[h[#m_j^#j^[#d[nj+#N[YedZ)#f^Wi[#de_i[#_d#j^[#
`
`je#\ebbem)#m[#m_bb#fh[i[dj#^[h[#W#]hWf^_YWb#YecfWh_ied#e\#j^[#
`
`h[Y[_l[Z#i_]dWb#YWki[i#i_c_bWh#DND#_d#j^[#ikXYWhh_[hi#Xkj#ed#Xej^#
`
`Z_\\[h[dY[i#X[jm[[d#JA?H#WdZ#N>*A?H<+
`
`i_Z[i+#O^_hZ)#?effb[h#i^_\j#YWd#YWki[#^WleY+#Dj#_i#[Wio#je#h[cel[#
`
`W#!#n[Z#?effb[h#i^_\j#Xkj#Yedi_Z[h#j^[#YWi[#m^[d#ckbj_fWj^#_i#
`
`_dlebl[Z#WdZ#i_]dWbi#Wh[#Whh_l_d]#Wj#j^[#h[Y[_l[h#\hec#Xej^#\hedj#
`
`5VTWHYPUN A86? HUK D5&86?4
`
`WdZ#XWYa7#O^[#h[Y[_l[Z#i_]dWbi#Wh[#i^_\j[Z#Xej^#^_]^[h#WdZ#
`
`bem[h#_d#\h[gk[dYo#WdZ#_j#jWa[i#Yedi_Z[hWXb[#fheY[ii_d]#fem[h#
`
`je#h[Yel[h#j^[#eh_]_dWb#i_]dWb+#Oe#XWbWdY[#j^[#Z[i_h[#\eh#bed]#
`
`iocXebi#m_j^#j^[#fheXb[ci#YWki[Z#Xo#Ybei[#ikXYWhh_[h#
`
`ifWY_d])#GO@#^Wi#WZefj[Z#.2#aCp#ifWY_d])#m_j^#W#dWhhem[h#
`
`4+2#aCp#Y^ei[d#\eh#ki[#m_j^#GO@vi#iebkj_ed#\eh#ceX_b[#OQ)#j^[#
`
`[lebl[Z#Hkbj_c[Z_W#=heWZYWij#Hkbj_YWij#N[hl_Y[#%[H=HN&+.
`
`A_]kh[#/#i^emi#^em#W#i[h_[i#e\#LKNF#iocXebi#Wh[#cWff[Z#_dje#
`
`j_c[#WdZ#\h[gk[dYo#Xo#j^[#jme#Z_\\[h[dj#ceZkbWj_ed#iY^[c[i+#
`
`MWj^[h#j^Wd#ki_d]#JA?H)#m[#m_bb#dem#i^_\j#je#j^[#j[hc#JA?H<)#
`
`m^_Y^#ijWdZi#\eh#ehj^e]edWb#\h[gk[dYo*Z_l_i_ed#ckbj_fb[#WYY[ii+#
`
`JA?H<#_i#i_cfbo#Wd#[bWXehWj_ed#e\#JA?H#ki[Z#Xo#GO@#WdZ#
`
`ej^[h#ioij[ci#j^Wj#_dYh[Wi[i#ioij[c#"#[n_X_b_jo#Xo#ckbj_fb[n_d]#
`
`ckbj_fb[#ki[hi#edje#j^[#iWc[#ikXYWhh_[hi+#O^_i#YWd#X[d[!#j#j^[#
`
`[\!#Y_[dj#jhkda_d]#e\#cWdo#bem*hWj[#ki[hi#edje#W#i^Wh[Z#Y^Wdd[b#
`
`Wi#m[bb#Wi#[dWXb[#f[h*ki[h#\h[gk[dYo#^eff_d]#je#c_j_]Wj[#j^[#
`
`[\\[Yji#e\#dWhhemXWdZ#\WZ_d]+#Aeh#YbWh_jo)#j^[#[nWcfb[#^[h[#
`
`ki[i#edbo#\ekh#%I&#ikXYWhh_[hi#el[h#jme#iocXeb#f[h_eZi#m_j^#j^[#
`
`fWobeWZ#ZWjW#h[fh[i[dj[Z#Xo#LKNF#ceZkbWj_ed+#M[Wb#GO@#i_]dWbi#
`
`Wh[#WbbeYWj[Z#_d#kd_ji#e\#./#WZ‘WY[dj#ikXYWhh_[hi#%.5-#aCp&#YWbb[Z#
`
`h[iekhY[#XbeYai#j^Wj#bWij#\eh#-+2#ci#WdZ#kikWbbo#YedjW_d#i[l[d#
`
`iocXebi#m^ei[#ceZkbWj_ed#YWd#X[#LKNF)#.3L<H#eh#31L<H+
`
`#EVUL YLZLY]H[PVU PZ HU HK]HUJLK MVYT VM JSPWWPUN PU ^OPJO [OL [PTL&KVTHPU ZPNUHS PZ
`ZOHWLK Z\JO [OH[ [OL LYYVY LULYN‘ MHSSZ VU ZWLJPe J% YLZLY]LK PU&JOHUULS MYLX\LUJPLZ%
`LUZ\YPUN SLZZ KPZ[VY[PVU PU [OL ^HU[LK WHY[ VM [OL ZPNUHS’
`
`2## <]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 5 of 10
`
`

`

`$(# (
`
`C
`
`(# (
`
`(# (
`
`$(# $(
`
`$(# (
`
`(# $(
`
`(# (
`
`$(# $(
`
`$(# (
`
`(# $(
`
`;
`
`$(# $(
`
`(# $(
`
`CBD= TVK\SH[PUN
`KH[H Z‘TIVSZ
`
`DLX\LUJL VM CBD= KH[H Z‘TIVSZ [V IL [YHUZTP[[LK
`
`G
`
`MJ
`
`5B
`
`G
`
`MJ
`
`5B
`
`.) R:a
`
`8YLX\LUJ‘
`
`@2$53:0
`6H[H Z‘TIVSZ VJJ\W‘ @ _ *- R:a MVY
`*(@ D5&86?4 Z‘TIVS WLYPVKZ
`
`*- R:a
`
`8YLX\LUJ‘
`
`<53:0
`6H[H Z‘TIVSZ VJJ\W‘ *- R:a MVY
`VUL A86?4 Z‘TIVS WLYPVK
`
`5LJXUH )% 2RPSDULVRQ RI KRZ <53:0 DQG @2$53:0 WUDQVPLW D VHTXHQFH RI >=@8 GDWD V\PEROV
`
`O^[#GO@#Zemdb_da#ki[i#jhWZ_j_edWb#JA?H<#c[j^eZi#WdZ#Z_\\[hi#
`
`Z_\\[h[dY[#X[jm[[d#j^[#jme#iY^[c[i#_i#j^Wj#JA?H<#jhWdic_ji#
`
`\hec#ej^[h#ioij[ci#ikY^#Wi#PH=#WdZ#R_H<S#edbo#_d#Z[jW_bi#
`
`j^[#\ekh#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXebi#_d#fWhWbb[b)#ed[#f[h#ikXYWhh_[h)#m^_b[#
`
`e\#j^[#JA?H#dkc[hebe]o#%j^Wj#_i#ikXYWhh_[h#ifWY_d])#iocXeb#
`
`N>*A?H<#jhWdic_ji#j^[#\ekh#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXebi#_d#i[h_[i#Wj#\ekh#
`
`b[d]j^)#XWdZm_Zj^)#[jY+&+#Jd#j^[#b[\j#i_Z[#e\#A_]kh[#/)#I#WZ‘WY[dj#
`
`j_c[i#j^[#hWj[)#m_j^#[WY^#ZWjW#iocXeb#eYYkfo_d]#I#n#.2#aCp#XWdZ*
`
`.2#aCp#ikXYWhh_[hi#{#Wbh[WZo#fei_j_ed[Z#Wj#j^[#Z[i_h[Z#fbWY[#
`
`m_Zj^+#Q_ikWbbo)#j^[#JA?H<#i_]dWb#_i#Yb[Whbo#ckbj_*YWhh_[h#WdZ#j^[#
`
`_d#j^[#Y^Wdd[b#XWdZm_Zj^#{#Wh[#[WY^#ceZkbWj[Z#\eh#j^[#
`
`N>*A?H<#i_]dWb#beeai#ceh[#b_a[#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h)#m^_Y^#[nfbW_di#
`
`JA?H<#iocXeb#f[h_eZ#e\#33+4#€i#Xo#ed[#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXeb+#
`
`j^[#wN>x#_d#_ji#dWc[+#Iej[#j^Wj#JA?H<#WdZ#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#
`
`Dd#j^_i#i_cfb[#\ekh*ikXYWhh_[h#[nWcfb[)#\ekh#iocXebi#Wh[#jWa[d#
`
`b[d]j^i#Wh[#j^[#iWc[#Wj#33+4#€i8#^em[l[h)#j^[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#
`
`_d#fWhWbb[b+#O^[i[#Wh[#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXebi#ie#edbo#j^[#f^Wi[#e\#
`
`YedjW_di#I#wikX*iocXebix#j^Wj#h[fh[i[dj#j^[#ceZkbWj_d]#ZWjW+
`
`[WY^#ikXYWhh_[h#_i#ceZkbWj[Z#WdZ#j^[#ikXYWhh_[h#fem[h#h[cW_di#
`
`YedijWdj#X[jm[[d#iocXebi+#<\j[h#ed[#JA?H<#iocXeb#f[h_eZ#
`
`Dj#_i#j^[#fWhWbb[b#jhWdic_ii_ed#e\#ckbj_fb[#iocXebi#j^Wj#Yh[Wj[i#
`
`^Wi#[bWfi[Z)#j^[#>K#_i#_di[hj[Z#WdZ#j^[#d[nj#\ekh#iocXebi#Wh[#
`
`j^[#kdZ[i_hWXb[#^_]^#K<M#e\#JA?H<+#=o#jhWdic_jj_d]#j^[#I#ZWjW#
`
`jhWdic_jj[Z#_d#fWhWbb[b+#Aeh#l_ikWb#YbWh_jo)#j^[#>K#_i#i^emd#Wi#W#
`
`iocXebi#_d#i[h_[i#Wj#I#j_c[i#j^[#hWj[)#j^[#N>*A?H<#eYYkf_[Z#
`
`]Wf8#^em[l[h)#_j#_i#WYjkWbbo#!#bb[Z#m_j^#W#Yefo#e\#j^[#[dZ#e\#j^[#
`
`XWdZm_Zj^#_i#j^[#iWc[#Wi#ckbj_*YWhh_[h#JA?H<#Xkj#{#YhkY_Wbbo#
`
`d[nj#iocXeb)#c[Wd_d]#j^[#jhWdic_ii_ed#fem[h#_i#Yedj_dkeki#Xkj#
`
`{#j^[#K<M#_i#j^[#iWc[#Wi#j^Wj#ki[Z#\eh#j^[#eh_]_dWb#ZWjW#
`
`^Wi#W#f^Wi[#Z_iYedj_dk_jo#Wj#j^[#iocXeb#XekdZWho+#Oe#Yh[Wj[#j^[#
`
`iocXebi+#O^_i#i^ekbZ#cWa[#^[kh_ij_Y#i[di[#m_j^ekj#Z[bl_d]#
`
`jhWdic_jj[Z#i_]dWb)#Wd#_dl[hi[#AAO#_i#f[h\ehc[Z#ed#[WY^#ikXYWhh_[h#
`
`_dje#j^[#cWj^[cWj_Yi7#<ZZ_d]#je][j^[h#cWdo#dWhhemXWdZ#
`
`je#Yh[Wj[#I#j_c[*ZecW_d#i_]dWbi#j^Wj#Wh[#l[Yjeh#ikcc[Z#je#
`
`LKNF#mWl[\ehci#_d#JA?H<#m_bb#WbmWoi#Yh[Wj[#^_]^[h#f[Wai#
`
`Yh[Wj[#j^[#!#dWb#j_c[*ZecW_d#mWl[\ehc#ki[Z#\eh#jhWdic_ii_ed+
`
`j^Wd#mekbZ#X[#i[[d#_d#j^[#m_Z[h*XWdZm_Zj^#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#
`
`N>*A?H<#i_]dWb#][d[hWj_ed#X[]_di#m_j^#W#if[Y_Wb#fh[YeZ_d]#
`
`_dYh[Wi[i)#j^[#K<M#e\#JA?H<#m_j^#hWdZec#ceZkbWj_d]#ZWjW#
`
`fheY[ii#Xkj#j^[d#Yedj_dk[i#Wi#m_j^#JA?H<+#=[\eh[#ekjb_d_d]#
`
`WffheWY^[i#BWkii_Wd#de_i[#ijWj_ij_Yi#Xkj)#h[]WhZb[ii#e\#j^[#
`
`j^[#][d[hWj_ed#fheY[ii#_j#_i#^[bf\kb#je#\_hij#Z[iYh_X[#j^[#[dZ#
`
`lWbk[#e\#I)#j^[#N>*A?H<#K<M#h[cW_di#j^[#iWc[#Wi#j^Wj#ki[Z#
`
`h[ikbj#Wi#i^emd#ed#j^[#h_]^j#i_Z[#e\#A_]kh[#/+#O^[#ceij#eXl_eki#
`
`\eh#j^[#eh_]_dWb#ZWjW#iocXebi+
`
`LKNF#mWl[\ehc#e\#N>*A?H<+#<i#j^[#dkcX[h#e\#ikXYWhh_[hi#I#
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`<]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb#
`
`#3
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 6 of 10
`
`

`

`CWl_d]#i[[d#m^Wj#N>*A?H<#beeai#b_a[)#m[#m_bb#dem#[nfbW_d#j^[#
`
`ikXYWhh_[hi+#O^_i#i^ekbZ#cWa[#_djk_j_l[#i[di[7#R^[d#Wd#_dYh[Wi_d]#
`
`fh[YeZ_d]#fheY[ii#j^Wj#Xh_d]i#_j#WXekj+#A_]kh[#0#i^emi#j^[#!#hij#
`
`dkcX[h#e\#ZWjW#iocXebi#_i#jhWdic_jj[Z#Zkh_d]#ed[#N>*A?H<#
`
`ij[fi)#m^_Y^#Yh[Wj[#W#j_c[*ZecW_d#mWl[\ehc#e\#j^[#LKNF#ZWjW#
`
`f[h_eZ)#j^[#j_c[*ZecW_d#mWl[\ehc#Y^Wd][i#\Wij[h)#][d[hWj_d]#
`
`ikX*iocXebi+#Pi_d]#j^[#\ekh#Yebeh*YeZ[Z#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXebi#
`
`W#^_]^[h#XWdZm_Zj^#WdZ#^[dY[#h[gk_h_d]#ceh[#?AO#X_di#je#\kbbo#
`
`\hec#A_]kh[#/)#j^[#fheY[ii#Yh[Wj[i#ed[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#_d#j^[#
`
`h[fh[i[dj#j^[#i_]dWb#_d#j^[#\h[gk[dYo#ZecW_d+
`
`j_c[#ZecW_d#Xo#Yecfkj_d]#j^[#jhW‘[Yjeho#jhWY[Z#Xo#cel_d]#\hec#
`
`ed[#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXeb#je#j^[#d[nj+#O^_i#_i#Zed[#Wj#I#j_c[i#j^[#
`
`Iej[#\hec#A_]kh[#1#j^Wj#j^[h[#_i#de#bed][h#W#Z_h[Yj#h[bWj_edi^_f#
`
`hWj[#e\#j^[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#ikY^#j^Wj#ed[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#
`
`X[jm[[d#j^[#Wcfb_jkZ[#WdZ#f^Wi[#e\#j^[#_dZ_l_ZkWb#?AO#X_di#
`
`YedjW_di#I#Yedi[Ykj_l[#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXebi+#Aeh#i_cfb_Y_jo)#
`
`WdZ#j^[#eh_]_dWb#LKNF#ZWjW#iocXebi+#O^_i#_i#gk_j[#Z_\\[h[dj#\hec#
`
`m[#m_bb#dej#Z_iYkii#j_c[*ZecW_d#!#bj[h_d]#e\#j^[#ZWjW#iocXeb#
`
`j^[#JA?H<#[nWcfb[#_d#m^_Y^#ZWjW#iocXebi#Z_h[Yjbo#ceZkbWj[#
`
`jhWdi_j_edi#[l[d#j^ek]^#ikY^#!#bj[h_d]#m_bb#X[#fh[i[dj#_d#Wdo#h[Wb#
`
`j^[#ikXYWhh_[hi+
`
`_cfb[c[djWj_ed+
`
`O^[#d[nj#ijW][#_i#je#i^_\j#j^[#XWi[XWdZ#?AO#h[fh[i[djWj_ed#e\#
`
`CWl_d]#Yh[Wj[Z#Wd#DL#h[fh[i[djWj_ed#_d#j^[#j_c[#ZecW_d#e\#ed[#
`
`j^[#j_c[*ZecW_d#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#je#j^[#Z[i_h[Z#fWhj#e\#j^[#
`
`N>*A?H<#iocXeb)#j^[#d[nj#ijW][#_i#je#h[fh[i[dj#_j#_d#j^[#
`
`el[hWbb#Y^Wdd[b#XWdZm_Zj^+#=[YWki[#j^[#i_]dWb#_i#dem#h[fh[*
`
`\h[gk[dYo#ZecW_d#ki_d]#W#Z_iYh[j[#Aekh_[h#jhWdi\ehc#%?AO8#
`
`i[dj[Z#Wi#W#?AO)#\h[gk[dYo#i^_\j_d]#_i#W#l[ho#i_cfb[#fheY[ii#
`
`A_]kh[#1&+#O^[#?AO#iWcfb_d]#\h[gk[dYo#_i#Y^ei[d#ikY^#j^Wj#
`
`WY^_[l[Z#Xo#Yefo_d]#j^[#I#X_di#_dje#W#bWh][h#?AO#ifWY[#j^Wj#YWd#
`
`j^[#j_c[*ZecW_d#mWl[\ehc#e\#ed[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#_i#\kbbo#
`
`X[#kf#je#j^[#i_p[#e\#j^[#ioij[c#Y^Wdd[b#XWdZm_Zj^#{#e\#m^_Y^#
`
`h[fh[i[dj[Z#Xo#I#?AO#X_di#ifWY[Z#.2#aCp#WfWhj)#m_j^#[WY^#X_d#
`
`j^[h[#Wh[#i_n#je#Y^eei[#\hec#_d#GO@)#ifWdd_d]#.+1#HCp#je#
`
`h[fh[i[dj_d]#ed[#ikXYWhh_[h#m_j^#Wcfb_jkZ[#WdZ#f^Wi[#^[bZ#
`
`/-#HCp+#O^[#[b[]WdY[#e\#j^[#?AO#b[ji#ki#fei_j_ed#j^[#i_]dWb#
`
`YedijWdj#\eh#33+4#€i+#O^[h[#_i#WbmWoi#W#ed[*je*ed[#Yehh[bWj_ed#
`
`Wdom^[h[#_d#j^[#Y^Wdd[b#XWdZm_Zj^)#j^ki#[n[Ykj_d]#j^[#
`
`X[jm[[d#j^[#dkcX[h#e\#ZWjW#iocXebi#je#X[#jhWdic_jj[Z#Zkh_d]#
`
`\h[gk[dYo*Z_l_i_ed#ckbj_fb[#WYY[ii#%A?H<&#[ii[dj_Wb#\eh#
`
`ed[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#f[h_eZ#WdZ#j^[#dkcX[h#e\#?AO#X_di#
`
`[\!#Y_[djbo#i^Wh_d]#j^[#kfb_da#X[jm[[d#ckbj_fb[#ki[hi+#’O^_i#
`
`Yh[Wj[Z#{#WdZ#j^_i#_d#jkhd#X[Yec[i#j^[#dkcX[h#e\#eYYkf_[Z#
`
`[nfbW_di#j^[#eh_]_d#e\#j^[#bWjj[h#fehj_ed#e\#wN>*A?H<+x
`
`G!;"
`
`G!C"
`
`$(# (
`
`C
`
`(# (
`
`;
`
`$*
`
`&*
`
`$(# $(
`
`(# $(
`
`$*
`
`&*
`
`AUL D5&86?4
`Z‘TIVS WLYPVK
`
`AUL D5&86?4
`Z‘TIVS WLYPVK
`
`5LJXUH *% 2UHDWLQJ WKH
`WLPH$GRPDLQ ZDYHIRUP
`RI DQ @2$53:0 V\PERO
`
`5LJXUH +% 1DVHEDQG DQG
`VKLIWHG IUHTXHQF\ GRPDLQ
`UHSUHVHQWDWLRQV RI DQ
`@2$53:0 V\PERO
`
`8YLX\LUJ‘
`
`8YLX\LUJ‘
`
`#4S[OV\NO ,9BB KPK JVUZPKLY H KPZ[YPI\[LK MVYT VM Z\IJHYYPLY HSSVJH[PVU MVY [OL
`\WSPUR [OH[ ^V\SK OH]L HSSL]PH[LK Z\ZJLW[PIPSP[‘ [V UHYYV^IHUK MHKPUN% P[ PUZ[LHK
`VW[LK MVY [OL HKQHJLU[ HSSVJH[PVU KLZJYPILK OLYL JVTIPULK ^P[O [OL WVZZPIPSP[‘ VM
`MYLX\LUJ‘ OVWWPUN H[ [OL ZSV[ !)’- TZ" SL]LS’
`
`4## <]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 7 of 10
`
`

`

`Oe#YedYbkZ[#N>*A?H<#i_]dWb#][d[hWj_ed)#j^[#fheY[ii#\ebbemi#
`
`R^[d#WdWbop[Z#ed[#ikXYWhh_[h#Wj#W#j_c[)#JA?H<#h[i[cXb[i#j^[#
`
`j^[#iWc[#ij[fi#Wi#\eh#JA?H<+#K[h\ehc_d]#Wd#_dl[hi[#AAO#
`
`eh_]_dWb#ZWjW#iocXebi+#<j#\kbb#XWdZm_Zj^)#^em[l[h)#j^[#i_]dWb#
`
`Yedl[hji#j^[#\h[gk[dYo*i^_\j[Z#i_]dWb#je#j^[#j_c[#ZecW_d#WdZ#
`
`beeai#b_a[#BWkii_Wd#de_i[#_d#j[hci#e\#_ji#K<M#ijWj_ij_Yi#WdZ#j^[#
`
`_di[hj_d]#j^[#>K#fhel_Z[i#JA?H<vi#\kdZWc[djWb#heXkijd[ii#
`
`Yedij[bbWj_ed+#O^[#effei_j[#_i#jhk[#\eh#N>*A?H<+#Dji#h[bWj_edi^_f#
`
`W]W_dij#ckbj_fWj^+
`
`je#j^[#eh_]_dWb#ZWjW#iocXebi#_i#[l_Z[dj#m^[d#WdWbop_d]#j^[#[dj_h[#
`
`i_]dWb#XWdZm_Zj^#m^[h[kfed#j^[#Yedij[bbWj_ed#%WdZ#^[dY[#bem#
`
`D\#m[#dem#h[jkhd#je#A_]kh[#/vi#h[fh[i[djWj_ed#e\#JA?H<#
`
`K<M&#e\#j^[#eh_]_dWb#ZWjW#iocXebi#YWd#X[#eXi[hl[Z#hejWj_d]#Wj#
`
`WdZ#N>*A?H<)#m[#YWd#Yedi_Z[h#^em#[WY^#i_]dWb#mekbZ#beea#
`
`I#j_c[i#j^[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#hWj[#%_]deh_d]#j^[#i[l[d#f[hY[dj#
`
`Z[f[dZ_d]#ed#j^[#WdWboi_i#XWdZm_Zj^+#OWXb[#.#ikccWh_p[i#j^[#
`
`hWj[#h[ZkYj_ed#Zk[#je#WZZ_d]#j^[#>K&+#R^[d#WdWbop[Z#Wj#j^[#
`
`Z_\\[h[dY[i#X[jm[[d#j^[#ceZkbWj_ed#\ehcWji+
`
`ikXYWhh_[h#XWdZm_Zj^)#j^[#N>*A?H<#K<M#WdZ#Yedij[bbWj_ed#
`
`Wh[#c[Wd_d]b[ii#X[YWki[#j^[i[#Wh[#I#j_c[i#dWhhem[h#j^Wd#j^[#
`
`_d\ehcWj_ed#XWdZm_Zj^#e\#j^[#ZWjW#iocXebi+
`
`ADEOH (% 0QDO\VLV RI <53:0 DQG @2$53:0 DW GLIIHUHQW EDQGZLGWKV
`
`<53:0
`
`@2$53:0
`
` :RGXODWLRQ
`
`IRUPDW#
`
` 0QDO\VLV #
` EDQGZLGWK#
`
`#
`
`.2#aCp#
`#
`
` =HDN$WR$DYHUDJH
` SRZHU UDWLR#
`
`NWc[#Wi##
`ZWjW#iocXeb#
`
`#
`
`N_]dWb#=R#
`%I#n#.2#aCp&#
`
`C_]^#K<M##
`%BWkii_Wd&#
`
` <EVHUYDEOH#
`
`7> #
` FRQVWHOODWLRQ#
`
`NWc[#Wi###
`ZWjW#iocXeb#Wj##
`33+4#€i#hWj[#
`
`Iej#c[Wd_d]\kb#
`%BWkii_Wd&#
`#
`
`9A4 DW D JODQFH
`
`;RYHPEHU )’’+ 9A4&@04
`6LJK$OHYHO UHTXLUHPHQWV
`q# M[ZkY[Z#Yeij#f[h#X_j
`
`.2#aCp#
`#
`
`Iej#c[Wd_d]\kb#
`%9#ZWjW#iocXeb&#
`
`Iej#c[Wd_d]\kb#
`%9#ZWjW#iocXeb&##
`#
`
`N_]dWb#=R
`%I#n#.2#aCp&
`
`NWc[#Wi#
`ZWjW#iocXeb
`
`NWc[#Wi#
`ZWjW#iocXeb#Wj##
`I#n#33+4#€i#hWj[
`
`5OH[LEOH FKDQQHO EDQGZLGWKV
`=WdZm_Zj^#HCp#
`<YY[ii#ceZ[
`
`#
`
`#
`
`.+1#
`
`0#
`
`A??#WdZ#O??
`
`A??#WdZ#O??
`
`q# Heh[#bem[h*Yeij#i[hl_Y[i#m_j^#X[jj[h#ki[h#[nf[h_[dY[
`
`q# Ab[n_Xb[#ki[#e\#d[m#WdZ#[n_ij_d]#\h[gk[dYo#XWdZi
`
`q# N_cfb_!#[Z#bem[h*Yeij#d[jmeha#m_j^#ef[d#_dj[h\WY[i
`
`q# M[ZkY[Z#j[hc_dWb#Yecfb[n_jo#WdZ#h[WiedWXb[#fem[h#
`
`# Yedikcfj_ed
`
`#
`
`#
`
`#
`
`#
`
`2#
`
`.-#
`
`.2#
`
`/-#
`
`A??#WdZ#O??
`
`A??#WdZ#O??
`
`A??#WdZ#O??
`
`A??#WdZ#O??
`
`@SHHG
`3RZQOLQN SHDN GDWD UDWHV !-+>0:"
`
`EOL *’. ?:a HUK ,’+ ?:a E66 IHUK^PK[OZ OH]L YLJLU[S‘ ILLU KLSL[LK%
`HUK [OL ZP_ YLTHPUPUN IHUK^PK[OZ HWWS‘ [V IV[O 866 HUK E66’
`
`<dj[ddW#Yed!#]khWj_ed#
`
`NDNJ#
`
`/n/#HDHJ#
`
`1n1#HDHJ
`
`K[Wa#ZWjW#hWj[#%HXfi&#
`
`.--#
`
`.4/+5#
`
`0/3+1
`
`:RELOLW\
`Jfj_c_p[Z7#-#je#.2#ac,^
`
`BSOLQN SHDN GDWD UDWHV !VLQJOH DQWHQQD"
`
`HeZkbWj_ed#Z[fj^#
`
`LKNF#
`
`.3L<H#
`
`31L<H
`
`K[Wa#ZWjW#hWj[#%HXfi&#
`
`2-#
`
`24+3#
`
`53+1
`
`C_]^#f[h\ehcWdY[7#.2#je#./-#ac,^
`
`AkdYj_edWb7#./-#je#02-#ac,^
`
`PdZ[h#Yedi_Z[hWj_ed7#02-#je#2--#ac,^
`
`@HUYLFHV
`KWYa[j*im_jY^[Z#le_Y[#WdZ#ZWjW+#Ie#Y_hYk_j*im_jY^[Z#
`
`i[hl_Y[i#ikffehj[Z+
`
`@SHFWUDO 4I_ FLHQF\
`0*1n#M[b*3#CN?K<#%Zemdb_da&
`
`9DWHQF\
`DZb[#je#WYj_l[#9#.--#ci
`
`/*0n#M[b*3#CNPK<#%kfb_da&
`
`NcWbb#fWYa[ji#9#2#ci
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`<]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb#
`
`#5#
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 8 of 10
`
`

`

`5LJXUH ,% 0QDO\VLV RI D (->0: @2$53:0 VLJQDO
`
`?\S[PWH[O YLZPZ[HUJL ^P[O
`ZOVY[ KH[H Z‘TIVSZ3
`
`<j#j^_i#fe_dj#_j#_i#h[WiedWXb[#je#Wia)#wCem#YWd#N>*A?H<#ij_bb#X[#
`
`h[i_ijWdj#je#ckbj_fWj^#m^[d#j^[#ZWjW#iocXebi#Wh[#ij_bb#i^ehj:x#
`
`Dj#cWo#i[[c#Yekdj[h_djk_j_l[#j^Wj#I#j_c[*_dlWh_Wdj#?AO#X_di#YWd#
`
`\kbbo#h[fh[i[dj#W#j_c[*lWho_d]#i_]dWb+#Cem[l[h)#j^[#?AO#fh_dY_fb[#
`
`_i#i_cfbo#_bbkijhWj[Z#Xo#Yedi_Z[h_d]#j^[#ikc#e\#jme#!#n[Z#i_d[#
`
`mWl[i#Wj#Z_\\[h[dj#\h[gk[dY_[i7#O^[#h[ikbj#_i#W#ded*i_dkie_ZWb#
`
`j_c[*lWho_d]#i_]dWb#{#\kbbo#h[fh[i[dj[Z#Xo#jme#!#n[Z#
`
`Dd#JA?H<)#j^[#ceZkbWj_d]#ZWjW#iocXebi#Wh[#YedijWdj#el[h#j^[#
`
`33+4#€i#JA?H<#iocXeb#f[h_eZ#Xkj#Wd#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#_i#dej#
`
`i_d[#mWl[i+
`
`YedijWdj#el[h#j_c[#i_dY[#_j#YedjW_di#I#ikX*iocXebi#e\#ckY^#
`
`i^ehj[h#ZkhWj_ed+#O^[#ckbj_fWj^#h[i_ijWdY[#e\#j^[#JA?H<#Z[*
`
`ceZkbWj_ed#fheY[ii#i[[ci#je#h[bo#ed#j^[#bed]#ZWjW#iocXebi#j^Wj#
`
`cWf#Z_h[Yjbo#edje#j^[#ikXYWhh_[hi+#AehjkdWj[bo)#_j#_i#j^[#YedijWdj#
`
`dWjkh[#e\#[WY^#ikXYWhh_[h#{#dej#j^[#ZWjW#iocXebi#{#j^Wj#
`
`fhel_Z[i#j^[#h[i_ijWdY[#je#Z[bWo#ifh[WZ+#<i#i^emd#[Whb_[h)#j^[#
`
`?AO#e\#j^[#j_c[*lWho_d]#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#][d[hWj[Z#W#i[j#e\#
`
`?AO#X_di#YedijWdj#_d#j_c[#Zkh_d]#j^[#N>*A?H<#iocXeb#f[h_eZ#
`
`[l[d#j^ek]^#j^[#ceZkbWj_d]#ZWjW#iocXebi#lWh_[Z#el[h#j^[#iWc[#
`
`f[h_eZ+#Dj#_i#_d^[h[dj#je#j^[#?AO#fheY[ii#j^Wj#j^[#j_c[*lWho_d]#
`
`N>*A?H<#iocXeb#{#cWZ[#e\#I#i[h_Wb#ZWjW#iocXebi#{#_i#h[fh[*
`
`i[dj[Z#_d#j^[#\h[gk[dYo#ZecW_d#Xo#I#j_c[*_dlWh_Wdj#ikXYWhh_[hi+#
`
`O^ki)#[l[d#N>*A?H<#m_j^#_ji#i^ehj#ZWjW#iocXebi#X[d[!#ji#\hec#
`
`ckbj_fWj^#fhej[Yj_ed+
`
`7_HTPUPUN H YLHS D5&86?4 ZPNUHS
`
`A_]kh[#2#i^emi#iec[#e\#j^[#c[Wikh[c[dji#j^Wj#YWd#X[#cWZ[#ed#
`
`W#jof_YWb#N>*A?H<#i_]dWb+#O^[#Yedij[bbWj_ed#_d#jhWY[#<#%jef#b[\j&#
`
`i^emi#j^_i#_i#W#.3L<H#i_]dWb+#O^[#kd_jo#Y_hYb[#h[fh[i[dji#j^[#
`
`MN#%[l[ho#i[l[dj^#iocXeb&)#m^_Y^#Ze#dej#ki[#N>*A?H<#Xkj#Wh[#
`
`f^Wi[#ceZkbWj[Z#ki_d]#Wd#ehj^e]edWb#UWZe\\*>^k#i[gk[dY[+0#
`
`OhWY[#=#%bem[h#b[\j&#i^emi#j^[#i_]dWb#fem[h#l[hiki#\h[gk[dYo+#
`
`O^[#\h[gk[dYo#iYWb[#_i#_d#.2#aCp#ikXYWhh_[hi#dkcX[h[Z#\hec#
`
`z3--#je#266)#m^_Y^#h[fh[i[dji#W#XWdZm_Zj^#e\#.5#HCp+#Ahec#
`
`j^_i#m[#YWd#YedYbkZ[#j^_i#ckij#X[#W#/-#HCp#Y^Wdd[b#WdZ#j^[#
`
`WbbeYWj[Z#i_]dWb#XWdZm_Zj^#_i#2#HCp#jemWhZi#j^[#bem[h#[dZ+#
`
`O^[#Xhemd#Zeji#h[fh[i[dj#j^[#_dijWdjWd[eki#ikXYWhh_[h#Wcfb_*
`
`jkZ[#WdZ#j^[#m^_j[#Zeji#j^[#Wl[hW][#el[h#.-#ci+#Dd#j^[#Y[dj[h#
`
`e\#j^[#jhWY[)#j^[#if_a[#h[fh[i[dji#j^[#GJ#b[WaW][#%DL#e\\i[j&#e\#
`
`6## <]_b[dj#H[Wikh[c[dj#EekhdWb
`
`ZZZ%DJLOHQW%FRP&JR&MRXUQDO
`
`Ex. 1016 – TCT Mobile (US) Inc.
`TCT Mobile (US) Inc. v. Sisvel S.P.A., IPR2021-00678
`Page 9 of 10
`
`

`

`j^[#i_]dWb8#j^[#bWh][#_cW][#je#j^[#h_]^j#_i#Wd#JA?H#Whj_\WYj#Z[*
`
`5VUJS\ZPVU
`
`Dd#[ii[dY[)#N>*A?H<#c[Wdi#wYh[Wj[#W#i_d]b[*YWhh_[h#mWl[\ehc#
`
`WdZ#i^_\j#_j#je#j^[#Z[i_h[Z#fWhj#e\#j^[#\h[gk[dYo#ZecW_d+x#<\j[h#
`
`W#YWh[\kb#Yedi_Z[hWj_ed#e\#j^[#Y^WhWYj[h_ij_Yi#e\#JA?H<#WdZ#
`
`j^[#d[m#N>*A?H<)#m[#YWd#YedYbkZ[#j^Wj#N>*A?H<#fhel_Z[i#
`
`j^[#WZlWdjW][i#e\#JA?H<#{#[if[Y_Wbbo#heXkij#h[i_ijWdY[#
`
`je#ckbj_fWj^#{#m_j^ekj#j^[#fheXb[c#e\#^_]^#K<M+#O^[#ki[#e\#
`
`N>*A?H<#_d#GO@)#^em[l[h)#_i#h[ijh_Yj[Z#je#j^[#kfb_da#X[YWki[#
`
`j^[#_dYh[Wi[Z#j_c[*ZecW_d#fheY[ii_d]#mekbZ#X[#W#Yedi_Z[hWXb[#
`
`XkhZ[d#ed#j^[#XWi[#ijWj_ed)#m^_Y^#^Wi#je#cWdW][#j^[#ZodWc_Yi#
`
`e\#ckbj_*ki[h#jhWdic_ii_ed+
`
`Dj#m_bb#X[#_dj[h[ij_d]#je#i[[#_\#GO@#{#j^[#bWj[ij#e\#j^[#j^h[[#d[m#
`
`JA?H<#Y[bbkbWh#ijWdZWhZi#{#^Wi#_dZ[[Z#_Z[dj_!#[Z#W#ikf[h_eh#
`
`iebkj_ed#\eh#j^[#kfb_da#eh#m^[j^[h#j^[#fkh[#JA?H<#ki[Z#_d#
`
`R_H<S#eh#j^[#JA?H<,>?H<#YecX_dWj_ed#ki[Z#_d#PH=#fhel[#
`
`je#X[#‘kij#Wi#ikYY[ii\kb#m^[d#Wbb#j^[#\WYjehi#Wh[#jWa[d#_dje#
`
`WYYekdj+#OeZWo)#j^[#[nf[hji#Z_iW]h[[#ie#m[#m_bb#^Wl[#je#mW_j#
`
`ed#j^[#kbj_cWj[#WhX_j[h)#j_c[)#X[\eh[#m[#!#dZ#ekj#\eh#ikh[+
`
`?HIHUHQFHV
`
`.+#0BKK#ON#03+/-.#l5+-+-#i[Yj_ed#1+/+.#
`
`/+#0BKK#ON#03+/..#l5+-+-#ikXYbWki[#2+3
`
`0+#0BKK#ON#03+/..#l5+-+-#ikXYbWki[#2+2
`
`wR_H<S)x#wHeX_b[#R_H<Sx#WdZ#wR_H<S#Aehkcx#Wh[#
`jhWZ[cWhai#e\#j^[#R_H<S#Aehkc+#
`
`b_X[hWj[bo#Yh[Wj[Z#ki_d]#-+2#Z=#DL#]W_d#_cXWbWdY[#_d#j^[#i_]dWb+#
`
`=ej^#j^[#GJ#b[WaW][#WdZ#j^[#fem[h#_d#ded*WbbeYWj[Z#ikXYWhh_[hi#
`
`m_bb#X[#b_c_j[Z#Xo#j^[#0BKK#if[Y_!#YWj_edi+
`
`OhWY[#>#%jef#c_ZZb[&#i^emi#W#ikccWho#e\#j^[#c[Wikh[Z#
`
`_cfW_hc[dji#_dYbkZ_d]#j^[#[hheh#l[Yjeh#cW]d_jkZ[#%@QH&)#
`
`\h[gk[dYo#[hheh#WdZ#DL#e\\i[j+#Iej[#j^[#ZWjW#@QH#Wj#.+.2#f[hY[dj#
`
`_i#ckY^#^_]^[h#j^Wd#j^[#MN#@QH#Wj#-+..1#f[hY[dj+#O^_i#_i#Zk[#
`
`je#W#(-+.#Z=#Xeeij#_d#j^[#ZWjW#fem[h#Wi#h[fehj[Z#_d#jhWY[#@)#
`
`m^_Y^#mWi#_]deh[Z#%\eh#_bbkijhWj_ed&#Xo#j^[#h[Y[_l[h#je#Yh[Wj[#
`
`ZWjW*if[Y_!#Y#@QH+#<bie#dej[#j^[#MN#fem[h#Xeeij#_i#h[fehj[Z#
`
`Wi#(.#Z=)#m^_Y^#YWd#Wbie#X[#eXi[hl[Z#_d#j^[#DL#Yedij[bbWj_ed#
`
`X[YWki[#j^[#kd_jo#Y_hYb[#Ze[i#dej#fWii#j^hek]^#[_]^j#e\#j^[#
`
`.3L<H#fe_dji+#OhWY[#?#%bem[h#c_ZZb[&#i^emi#j^[#Z_ijh_Xkj_ed#
`
`e\#@QH#Xo#ikXYWhh_[h+#O^[#Wl[hW][#WdZ#f[Wa#e\#j^[#WbbeYWj[Z#
`
`i_]dWb#@QH#_i#_d#b_d[#m_j^#j^[#dkcX[hi#_d#jhWY[#>+#O^[#@QH#
`
`\eh#j^[#ded*WbbeYWj[Z#ikXYWhh_[hi#h[WZi#ckY^#^_]^[h#Wbj^ek]^#
`
`j^[#mWo#j^_i#_d*Y^Wdd[b#_cfW_hc[dj#m_bb#X[#if[Y_!#[Z#m_bb#X[#Wi#
`
`W#fem[h#hWj_e#X[jm[[d#j^[#mWdj[Z#i_]dWb#WdZ#j^[#kdmWdj[Z#
`
`i_]dWb+#O^[#hWj_e#\eh#j^_i#i_]dWb#_i#WhekdZ#0-#Z=#Wi#YWd#X[#i[[d#_d#
`
`jhWY[#=+#O^[#Xbk[#Zeji#_d#jhWY[#?#Wbie#i^em#j^[#@QH#e\#j^[#MN)#
`
`m^_Y^#_i#l[ho#bem+
`
`OhWY[#@#%je