!"#$%& ’$($%’ )($%"$ ("& $*(&%+(*, -..#/%
`000000000000
`
`1%.-*% $2% )($%"$ $*#(3 ("& ())%(3 1-(*&
`000000000000
`
`’(+’!"4 %3%/$*-"#/’ /-5 3$&56 ’(+’!"4 %3%/$*-"#/’
`(+%*#/(6 #"/56 ("& ())3%6 #"/56
`)78989:;7<6
`
`=5
`
`"%-"-&% ’+(*$)2-"% 33/6
`)>87;8 -?;7<5
`000000000000
`
`/>@7 #)*ABACDBBCEE
`)>87;8 F6BGH6FIG
`000000000000
`
`PATENT OWNER’S SUR-REPLY
`
`EXHIBIT 1073
`Samsung et al. v. Neonode
`IPR2021-00144
`
`1
`
`

`

`TABLE OF CONTENTS
`
`#5
`
`##5
`
`’%/-"&(*J /-"’#&%*($#-"’ ’$*-"43J ’!))-*$ ( .#"&#"4
`-. "-"-1K#-!’"%’’5 55555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 C
`
`)%$#$#-"%* .(#3’ $- ’2-L (/$#K($#-" 1J M43#&#"4 N
`(L(JO P(33 /3(#+’Q5 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 R
`
`(5
`
`$S7 )T>9; +7>;9;U (;V $S7 #;8<9;@9W *7W:<V /:;X9<Y $S>8
`M4T9V9;U N (?>ZO #@ &9@89;W8 .<:Y ( &<>UD(;VD&<:[5 55555555555555555555 I
`
`C5
`
`A5
`
`\5
`
`$S7 )T>9; +7>;9;U /:;X9<Y@ M4T9V9;UO (;V M&<>UU9;UO (<7
`&9@89;W85 55555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 I
`
`$S7 ([[T9W>;8 &9@WT>9Y7V M&<>UD>;VD&<:[5O 5555555555555555555555555555 G
`
`)78989:;7<]@ ):@989:; $S>8 (;Z +:=7Y7;8 /:;@898^87@
`M4T9V9;UO #@ !;@^_@8>;89>87V (;V /:;8<><Z $: $S7 #;8<9;@9W
`*7W:<V5 5555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 CA
`
`15
`
`)78989:;7<]@ (<U^Y7;8 $S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ -[7<>89:; #@ ":8 &<>UD
`(;VD&<:[ #@ #;W:<<7W85 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 CH
`
`###5
`
`)%$#$#-"%*]’ 4*-!"&’ .(#3 $- &#’/3-’% -* *%"&%*
`-1K#-!’ ML2%*%#" $2% *%)*%’%"$($#-" -. $2% .!"/$#-"
`#’ "-$ *%3-/($%& -* &!)3#/($%&O P(33 /3(#+’Q5 555555555555555555 A\
`
`(5
`
`15
`
`/5
`
`)78989:;7<]@ 17T>87V /T>9Y $S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI &9@WT:@7@ ":
`&^[T9W>89:; -< *7T:W>89:; /:;8<>V9W8@ 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ %‘[<7@@
`&9@WT:@^<75 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 A\
`
`)78989:;7< .>9T@ $: )<7@7;8 (;Z )<:[7< +:89=>89:; $: +:V9XZ
`29<>Z>Y>D\BI ’: (@ ":8 $: &^[T9W>87 -< *7T:W>87 $S7 #W:;5 555555555 AH
`
`)78989:;7<@ .>9T $: )<:=9V7 (;Z +:89=>89:; $: +:V9XZ 29<>Z>Y>D
`\BI #; K97? -X *7;5 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 AF
`
`#K5
`
`K5
`
`K#5
`
`)%$#$#-"%*]’ /3(#+ R (*4!+%"$’ (*% !"$#+%3J5 55555555555555555 AG
`
`)%$#$#-"%* .(#3’ $- ’2-L &#’/3-’!*% -. /3(#+ CH5 5555555555555 \B
`
`#+)*-)%*3J #"/-*)-*($%& )-*$#-"’ -. &*5 1%&%*’-"]’
`*%)3J &%/3(*($#-" ’2-!3& 1% &#’*%4(*&%&5 55555555555555555555555 \C
`
`K##5 /-"/3!’#-" 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 \C
`
`9
`
`2
`
`

`

`TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
`
`Page(s)
`
`COURT DECISIONS
`
`Omega Eng’g, Inc. v. Raytek Corp.6
`\\E .5\V C\CE P.7V5 /9<5 ABB\Q 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 G
`
`Uship Intellectual Props., LLC v. United States6
`ICE .5\V C\CC P.7V5 /9<5 ABC\Q 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 G
`
`Wasica Fin. GmbH v. Cont’l Auto. Sys., Inc.6
`FH\ .5\V CAIA P.7V5 /9<5 ABCIQ 5555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 AI
`
`ADM INISTRATIVE DECISIONS
`
`Dish Network L.L.C. v. Sound View Innovations LLC6
`#)*ABABDBCAIR6 )>[7< EB P)$(1 .7_5 F6 ABAAQ 5555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 AI
`
`Ericsson Inc. v. Intellectual Ventures II LLC6
`#)*ABCEDBBGCG6 )>[7< \I P)$(16 &7W5 I6 ABCHQ 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 C\
`
`Merial Limited v. Virbac6
`#)*ABCEDBCAIG6 )>[7< C\ Pa>;5 AA6 ABCHQ 55555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 C\
`
`OTHER AUTHORITIES
`
`.ED5 *5 %VID5 b FBCPVQPAQ 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 E
`
`.ED5 *5 %VID5 b FB\P\Q 55555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 E
`
`99
`
`3
`
`

`

`EXHIBIT LIST
`
`ABBC
`
`&7WT><>89:; :X /<>9U *:@7;_7<U6 )S5&5 c*:@7;_7<UD&7WT5d
`
`ABBA
`
`/K :X /<>9U *:@7;_7<U6 )S5&5 c*:@7;_7<U /Kd
`
`ABB\
`
`ABBE
`
`ABBH
`
`ABBR
`
`ABBI
`
`ABBF
`
`ABBG
`
`+9W<:@:X8 )<7@@ /:Y[^87< &9W89:;><Z6 [5 AE\ P\V 7V5 CGGIQ
`c+9W<:@:X8D&9W89:;><Zd
`
`&7WT><>89:; :X ">8S>; 3:?7;@879; 9; ’^[[:<8 :X +:89:; X:< Pro
`Hac Vice (VY9@@9:; c3:?7;@879;D&7WT5d
`
`.9<@8 &7[:@989:; $<>;@W<9[8 :X )78989:;7<]@ %‘[7<86 17;e>Y9; 1
`17V7<@:;6 .7_5 AF6 ABAA c17V7<@:;D&7[:5d
`
`(YZ ,5 ,><T@:;6 17;e>Y9; 15 17V7<@:;6 >;V a:S; ’>;49:=>;;96
`Applens And Launchtile: Two Designs For One-Handed Thumb
`Use On Small Devices6 /2# ABBH f )()%*’g ’Y>TT &7=9W7@ C
`c17V7<@:;D)>[7<d
`
`’7W:;V &7WT><>89:; :X /<>9U *:@7;_7<U6 )S5&5 c*:@7;_7<UDA;VD
`&7WT5d
`
`"A (V=7<89@7Y7;8 K9V7: P^[T:>V7V -W85 CF6 ABBIQ P>=>9T>_T7 >8
`S88[@ghh???5Z:^8^_75W:Yh?>8WSi=j2k\’F/<‘XA@Q c"AD
`(V=7<89@7Y7;8DK9V7:d
`
`":;D.9;>T *7e7W89:; :X ([[T9W>89:; ":5 CBh\CH6AHB PT>87< 9@@^7V
`>@ !5’5 )>87;8 F6BGH6FIGQ6 Y>9T7V +><5 A\6 ABBR5 cABBRDB\DA\
`":;D.9;>T *7e7W89:;d
`
`ABCB
`
`!5’5 )^_T9W>89:; ":5 ABBEhBBACRE\ c2:@S9;:d
`
`ABCC
`
`*7@7<=7V
`
`ABCA
`
`/:;<>V 25 1T9Wl7;@8:<X7<6 NeoNode N1, Can A Unique Interface
`Put This Compelling Smart Phone On The Map? )7; /:Y[^89;U
`+>U>m9;7 c)7;D/:Y[^89;UD+>U>m9;7D"CD)S:;7D*7=97?d
`
`999
`
`4
`
`

`

`ABC\
`
`/:;<>V 25 1T9Wl7;@8:<X7<6 Neonode N2, A New Version Of The
`Phone That Pioneered Touchscreens6 )7; /:Y[^89;U +>U>m9;76
`":=5 E6 ABBI c)7;D/:Y[^89;UD+>U>m9;7D"AD)S:;7D*7=97?d
`
`ABCE
`
`19TT 27;;7@@Z6 The Neonode N26 $<7;V 2^;87<6 (^U5 CF6 ABBF
`c$<7;VD2^;87<D(<89WT7d
`
`ABCH
`
`$<7;V 2^;87<6 (_:^8 [>U7 c$<7;VD2^;87<D(_:^8d
`
`ABCR
`
`"7:;:V7 "CY .9<@8 #Y[<7@@9:; c8;lU<TD+7V9>D[:@8d
`
`ABCI
`
`$;lU<T (_:^8 )>U7 c8;lU<TD+7V9>D(_:^8d
`
`ABCF
`
`ABCG
`
`a^<7l 1<7^;9;U7< )S& &9@@7<8>89:;6 ":=5 C\6 ABCG c)S&D
`&9@@7<8>89:;d
`
`$9Y:8SZ 15 3776 If Android Is A “Stolen Product,” Then So Was
`The Iphone6 (<@ $7WS;9W>6 .7_5 A\6 ABCA c(<@D$7WS;9W>D(<89WT7d
`
`ABAB
`
`(;V<7>@ 2:TT>8m &9@@7<8>89:;6 -W85 ABCH c2:TT>8mD&9@@7<8>89:;d
`
`ABAC
`
`Hunting The iPhone Killer; Swedish Neonode Generates Buzz For
`Device6 */* L9<7T7@@6 ([<5 I6 ABBI c9)S:;7D,9TT7<d
`
`ABAA
`
`&7WT><>89:; :X !TX +><87;@@:; c+><87;@@:;D&7WT5d
`
`ABA\
`
`&7WT><>89:; :X a:@7[S ’S>9; c’S>9;D&7WT5d
`
`ABAE
`
`&7WT><>89:; :X +><W^@ 1>WlT^;V c1>WlT^;VD&7WT5d
`
`ABAH
`
`%‘W7T ’[<7>V@S778 V:W^Y7;89;U "7:;:V7 @>T7@ c"7:;:V7D’>T7@d
`
`ABAR
`
`/-".#&%"$#(3 &7WT><>89:; :X )7< 1Z@87V8 c1Z@87V8D&7WT5d
`
`ABAI
`
`"7:;:V7 /:;X9V7;89>T #;=7@8Y7;8 +7Y:<>;V^Y6 a>;5 ABBE
`c"7:;:V7D#;=7@8Y7;8D+7Y:d
`
`9=
`
`5
`
`

`

`ABAF
`
`ABAG
`
`AB\B
`
`AB\C
`
`AB\A
`
`AB\\
`
`AB\E
`
`AB\H
`
`/-".#&%"$#(3 ’>Y@^;U 39W7;@7 (U<77Y7;8 c’>Y@^;UD
`39W7;@7D(U<77Y7;8d
`
`"7:;:V7 "CY <7=97?6 a^;5 AG6 ABBI P>=>9T>_T7 >8
`S88[@ghh???5Z:^8^_75W:Yh?>8WSi=j$eD,’AlX#<BQ c"7:;:V7D"CYD
`<7=97?d
`
`!@7< -;T9;7 /:YY7;8@ :X "7:;:V7 "A 9;@8<^W89:;@ X9TY
`c"7:;:V7D/:YY7;8@DCd
`
`!@7< -;T9;7 /:YY7;8@ :X "7:;:V7 "A -=7<=97? c"7:;:V7D
`/:YY7;8@DAd
`
`!@7< -;T9;7 /:YY7;8@ :X "7:;:V7 "A ^;_:‘ >;V <7=97? =9V7:
`c"7:;:V7D/:YY7;8@D\d
`
`L9l9[7V9> n ([[T7 9)S:;7 <7T7>@7 V>87@ cL9l9[7V9>D9)S:;7D
`*7T7>@7D&>87@d
`
`L9l9[7V9> n ’>Y@^;U 4>T>‘Z <7T7>@7 V>87@ cL9l9[7V9>D’>Y@^;U
`4>T>‘ZD*7T7>@7D&>87@d
`
`*7@[:;@7 8: ":;D.9;>T -XX9W7 (W89:; :X ([[T9W>89:; ":5
`CBh\CH6AHB PT>87< 9@@^7V >@ !5’5 )>87;8 F6BGH6FIGQ6 @^_Y9887V +><5
`CE6 ABBF5 cABBFDB\DCE -XX9W7D(W89:;D*7@[:;@7d
`
`AB\R
`
`"7:;:V7 8S7 :;TZ :<9U9;>T6 ’7[5 C\6 ABBI P>=>9T>_T7 >8
`S88[@ghh???5Z:^8^_75W:Yh?>8WSi=j&G"\2C<’‘2lQ c!@7<DK9V7:d
`
`AB\I
`
`%Y>9T _Z 8S7 1:><V6 .7_5 AH6 ABAA c1:><VD%Y>9Td
`
`AB\F
`
`#%%% &9W89:;><Z &7X9;989:; :X M’S7TTO c#%%% &9W89:;><Zd
`
`AB\G
`
`ABEB
`
`!’ #;XT>89:; />TW^T>8:< P>=>9T>_T7 >8
`S88[@ghh???5^@9;XT>89:;W>TW^T>8:<5W:YhQ c#;XT>89:;D/>TW^T>8:<d
`
`%^<: &:TT>< %‘WS>;U7 *>87 P%!* !’&Q D 29@8:<9W>T /S><8
`P>=>9T>_T7 >8 S88[@ghh???5Y>W<:8<7;V@5;78hAHEFh7^<:DV:TT><D
`7‘WS>;U7D<>87DS9@8:<9W>TDWS><8Q c%^<:D&:TT><D%‘WS>;U7D*>87d
`
`=
`
`6
`
`

`

`ABEC
`
`’Y><8[S:;7 ’S9[Y7;8@ &7WT9;7V 9; 8S7 .:^<8S o^><87< 1^8 ABAC
`L>@ ’89TT > 4<:?8S J7>< ?98S > H5Ip #;W<7>@7 9; ’S9[Y7;8@6
`(WW:<V9;U 8: #&/6 a>;5 AI6 ABAC P>=>9T>_T7 >8
`S88[@ghh???59VW5W:YhU78V:W5e@[iW:;8>9;7<#Vj[<!’EFF\BFAAQ
`c’Y><8[S:;7D’S9[Y7;8@d
`
`ABEA
`
`&7WT><>89:; :X )><S>Y 27;V9X><
`
`ABE\
`
`ABEE
`
`ABEH
`
`&>=9V ):U^76 Mac OS 9: The Missing Manual6 .9<@8 %V989:;6 +><WS
`ABBB c"-$ .#3%&d
`
`’7W:;V &7[:@989:; $<>;@W<9[8 :X )78989:;7<]@ %‘[7<86 17;e>Y9; 1
`17V7<@:;6 a^TZ AA6 ABAA c17V7<@:;DA;VD&7[:5d
`
`.9;>T -XX9W7 (W89:; 9; ([[T9W>89:; ":5 CBh\CH6AHB PT>87< 9@@^7V >@
`!5’5 )>87;8 F6BGH6FIGQ6 Y>9T7V a^TZ CC6 ABBF c.9;>TD-XX9W7D(W89:;d
`
`=9
`
`7
`
`

`

`I.
`
`SECONDARY CONSIDERATIONS STRONGLY SUPPORT A
`FINDING OF NONOBVIOUSNESS.
`
`)78989:;7< X>9T@ 8: Y7>;9;UX^TTZ WS>TT7;U7 "7:;:V7]@ @S:?9;U 8S>8
`
`"7:;:V7]@ 9;;:=>89=76 @?9[7D_>@7V ^@7< 9;87<X>W7 ?>@ 7XX^@9=7TZD[<>9@7V _Z
`
`9;V^@8<Z :_@7<=7<@6 >W>V7Y9> >;V 8S7 ^@7<@5 )-*6 \DCI5 $7TT9;UTZ6 ’>Y@^;U]@
`
`<7[<7@7;8>89=7@ [<7@W97;8TZ <7X7<<7V 8: "7:;:V7]@ @?9[9;U ^@7< 9;87<X>W7 >@ M8S7
`
`X^8^<7 :X Y:_9T7 [S:;7@O >;V <7W:U;9m7V M?7 ;77V 8S9@O _7X:<7 T9W7;@9;U 8S7
`
`]FIG]@ >[[T9W>89:;5 )-*6 CCDCAq %‘5 ABAR c1Z@87V8D&7WT5d rG5 )<>9@7 >;V T9W7;@9;U
`
`:X 8S9@ @:<8 9@ S7;]@ 8778S <><76 [><89W^T><TZ ?S7; 98 W:Y7@ X<:Y > @:[S9@89W>87V [><8Z
`
`?S: ;:?6 AB Z7><@ >X87< 8S7 X>W86 WT>9Y@ 8S7 9;=7;89:;@ ?7<7 :_=9:^@5
`
`/:;8<><Z 8: )78989:;7<]@ WT>9Y :X > T>Wl :X ;7‘^@ P*7[TZ6 \BQ6 8S7 [<>9@7 9@
`
`@[7W9X9W>TTZ V9<7W87V 8:?><V@ 8S7 @?9[9;U 9;87<X>W7 W>[8^<7V _Z 8S7 MUT9V9;U 555
`
`>?>ZO T9Y98>89:; TZ9;U >8 8S7 S7><8 :X 8S7 WT>9Y@5 See, e.g56 %‘5 ABBF P8:^89;U @?9[7
`
`U7@8^<7@Qq %‘5 ABCA6 AD\ PM’?9[76 @?9[76 @?9[7OQq %‘5 ABAC6 A P[<>9@9;U M9;8^989=7
`
`[>@@>U7 :X 8S7 X9;U7< :=7< 8S7 @W<77;OQq %‘5 ABC\6 C PM9X 8S7 9)S:;7]@ @?9[7@ >;V
`
`8>[@ @77Y X^8^<9@89W6 8S7Z ><7 ;:86O <7X7<7;W9;U 8S7 "7:;:V7]@ [<7=9:^@TZD
`
`V7=7T:[7V 9;87<X>W7Qq %‘5 ABAB6 F P"7:;:V7 ?>@ M8S7 X9<@8 Y:_9T7 8: ^@7 @?9[7
`
`U7@8^<7@OQ5
`
`)78989:;7< WT>9Y@ 8S>8 Mc;d798S7< "7:;:V7]@ <7@[:;@7 ;:< 98@ W987V
`
`V7WT><>89:;@ >;>TZm7 8S7 "7:;:V7 V7=9W7@ :; > T9Y98>89:;D_ZDT9Y98>89:; _>@9@5O
`
`*7[TZ6 AG5 $S9@ 9@ 9;W:<<7W85 +<5 ’S>9; >;V &<5 *:@7;_7<U 7‘[T>9;7V S:? 8S7
`
`C
`
`8
`
`

`

`"Ch"A [S:;7@ [<>W89W7V 7>WS 7T7Y7;8 :X WT>9Y C5 %‘5 ABA\ c’S>9;D&7WT5d rrEDRq
`
`%‘5 ABBI c*:@7;_7<UDA;VD&7WT5d rrEBDEC5 $S7 )-*6 Y:<7:=7<6 7‘[T>9;7V S:?
`
`"7:;:V7]@ "Ch"A [<>W89W7V 8S7 WT>9Y@ >;V S:? 8S7 [<>9@7 W:<<7@[:;V7V 8: 8S7
`
`W:<7 MUT9V9;U 555 >?>ZO T9Y98>89:;5 )-*6 HDCI5
`
`$S7 :;TZ T9Y98>89:; )78989:;7< W:;87;V@ ?>@ ;:8 @S:?; 9@ 8S7 M<7[<7@7;8>89:;
`
`:X 8S7 X^;W89:; 9@ ;:8 <7T:W>87V :< V^[T9W>87V V^<9;U 8S7 UT9V9;U5O *7[TZ6 \BD\C5
`
`$S9@ 8:: 9@ 9;W:<<7W85 +<5 ’S>9; 87@89X97V 8S>8 Mc_d:8S 8S7 "7:;:V7 "C >;V "A
`
`[<7@7;87V 8S<77 9W:;@ 9; > @8<9[ >T:;U 8S7 T:?7< 7VU7 :X 8S7 V9@[T>ZO >;V 8S>8
`
`Mc;d:;7 :X 8S7 9W:;@ ?7<7 <7T:W>87V :< V^[T9W>87V V^<9;U 8S7 @?9[9;U U7@8^<75O %‘5
`
`ABA\ c’S>9;D&7WT5d rRq %‘5 CBHI c4:7<8md CHCgABDCHAgI P"C >;V "A 7>WS S>=7
`
`8S<77 [<9;87V 9W:;@Q5 $S7@7 9W:;@ ><7 <7>V9TZ =9@9_T7g
`
`$S<77 9W:;@ 8S>8 ><7 ;:8
`<7T:W>87V :< V^[T9W>87V
`
`%‘5 ABCF c)S&D&9@@7<8>89:;d Gq %‘5 ABAB c2:TT>8mD&9@@7<8>89:; d F5
`
`)78989:;7< 9;W:<<7W8TZ W:;87;V@ 8S>8 8S7 9W:;@ W>;;:8 Y778 8S7 WT>9Y@ _7W>^@7
`
`8S7Z ><7 M[<9;87VO :; 8S7 V7=9W75 *7[TZ6 \C5 1^8 WT>9Y C :;TZ <7k^9<7@ 8S>8 8S7
`
`A
`
`9
`
`

`

`<7[<7@7;8>89:; :X > X^;W89:; M9@ [<:=9V7V6O >;V V:7@ ;:8 [<7WT^V7 [<9;87V 9W:;@5 #8
`
`9@ ^;V9@[^87V 8S>8 8S7 [<9;87V 9W:;@ ><7 ;:8 <7T:W>87V :< V^[T9W>87V V^<9;U @?9[9;U5
`
`%=7; 9X 8S7 [<9;87V 9W:;@ ?7<7 8: _7 9U;:<7V6 8S7 ><<:?@6 W:;8<><Z 8:
`
`)78989:;7<]@ W:;87;89:;6 T9l7?9@7 ><7 ;:8 MV^[T9W>87cVd during 8S7 UT9V9;U Y:89:;5O
`
`*7[TZ6 \C5 $S7 =9V7: [<:=9V7V 8: 8S7 %‘>Y9;7< W:;X9<Y@ 8S>8 >VV989:;>T ><<:?@
`
`>[[7>< ^[:; 8:^WS9;U ?98S:^8 <7U><V 8: ?S78S7< > @?9[7 T>87< :WW^<@5 %‘5 ABBF
`
`c"AD(V=7<89@7Y7;8DK9V7:d BgBBgCH6 BgBBgAHDAR6 BgBBg\ED\H5
`
`%‘5 ABBF6 BgBBgEB
`
`Id.6 BgBBgEC
`
`Id.6 BgBBgE\
`
`\
`
`10
`
`

`

`$S7 ><<:?@6 T9l7 T9US8@ :; > <^;?>Z6 ><7 Y7>;8 8: @S:? > [:87;89>T [>8S?>Z
`
`X:< @?9[9;U5 #;V77V6 8S7 >VV989:;>T ><<:?@ Y>Z >[[7>< 9; > V9<7W89:; :<8S:U:;>T 8:
`
`8S7 7;@^9;U @?77[6 X^<8S7< 9;V9W>89;U 8S7 ><<:?@ ><7 ;:8 V^[T9W>87V during 8S7
`
`@?77[5 .:< 9;@8>;W76 >8 BgBCgB\DCgBH6 8S7 ><<:?@ Y^T89[TZ =7<89W>TTZ ^[:; > 8:^WS
`
`V7@[987 > T>87< S:<9m:;8>T @?9[7g
`
`Id.6 BgBCgBE
`
`Id.6 BgBCgBH
`
`)78989:;7< >TT7U7@ 8S>8 ’>Y@^;U]@ [<>9@7 :X "7:;:V7]@ [S:;7@ 9@ MS7><@>ZO
`
`P*7[TZ6 \AQ6 _^8 [><8Z >VY9@@9:;@ ><7 ;:8 MS7><@>ZO [><89W^T><TZ ?S7; [<:XX7<7V 8:
`
`@S:? @8>87 :X Y9;V5 See .ED5 *5 %VID5 bb FBCPVQPAQ6 FB\P\Q5 +:<7:=7<6 )78989:;7<
`
`V:7@ ;:8 V7;Z 8S>8 98@ <7[<7@7;8>89=7@ [<>9@7V "7:;:V7]@ ^@7< 9;87<X>W76 Y^WS T7@@
`
`[<:XX7< 87@89Y:;Z :X 98@ :?; 8: W:;8<>V9W8 +<5 1Z@87V8]@ >WW:^;85 %=7; 9X
`
`’>Y@^;U]@ 7‘7W^89=7@ S>V > @9V7_>< 9; ,:<7>;6 98 V:7@ ;:8 WS>;U7 ?S>8 8S7Z @>9V 8:
`
`+<5 1Z@87V8 :< 8S7 X>W8 8S>8 8S7Z T9W7;@7V "7:;:V7]@ 87WS;:T:UZ @::; 8S7<7>X87<5
`
`%‘5 CBHF c%<9l@@:;D&7[:5d IHgAHDIRgA5 )78989:;7<]@ W:;87Y[:<>;7:^@ ?:<V@ >;V
`
`>W89:;@ _7T97 8S79< ABDZ7><DT>87< >88:<;7Z ><U^Y7;8@5
`
`E
`
`11
`
`

`

`)78989:;7< >887Y[8@ 8: V:?;[T>Z 98@ :?; T9W7;@9;U :X 8S7 ]FIG]@ >[[T9W>89:;
`
`
`
`6 ><U^9;U 8S>8 M"7:;:V7 S>@ ;:8 @S:?; 8S7 >U<77Y7;86 ?S9WS W:=7<@
`
`Y^T89[T7 [>87;8 >[[T9W>89:;@ >;V :8S7< 87WS;:T:UZ6 9@ 8S7 V9<7W8 <7@^T8 :X 8S7 ^;9k^7
`
`WS><>W87<9@89W@ :X 8S7 WT>9Y7V 9;=7;89:;6 >@ :[[:@7V 8: 8S7 :8S7< T9W7;@7V
`
`87WS;:T:UZ6 @^WS >@ m.:<W75O *7[TZ6 \\5 1^8 8S9@ ?>@ ;:8 > T9W7;@7 8: > _^;VT7V
`
`[<:V^W8 :< S^;V<7V@ :X >[[T9W>89:;@5 *>8S7<6 8S7 T9W7;@7 W:;W7<;7V two @[7W9X9W>TTZ
`
`9V7;89X97V >[[T9W>89:;@6 8S7 m.:<W7 >[[T9W>89:; PW:;W7<;9;U 8S7 T9US8 _7>Y
`
`W:;8<:TT7V 8:^WSD@W<77;Q >;V 8S7 ]FIG]@ >[[T9W>89:; PW:;W7<;9;U 8S7 @:X8?><7 X:<
`
`9;87<>W89:; ?98S 8S7 :[7<>89;U @Z@87YQ5 %‘5 ABAF c’>Y@^;UD(U<77Y7;8d CDA5
`
`+:<7:=7<6 8S7 ]FIG >[[T9W>89:; 98@7TX ?>@ @[7W9X9W>TTZ ;>Y7V M"7;:O Pid.Q ?S9WS
`
`?>@ @[7W9X9W>TTZ <7X7<7;W7V 9; 8S7 1>WlU<:^;V :X 8S7 >U<77Y7;8g
`
`$S7 c"7:;:V7d Y:_9T7 S>;V@78@ ><7 _>@7V :; 8S7 T9US8 _7>Y W:;8<:TT7V
`
`8:^WSD@W<77;6 Mm.:<W7O6 and software for interaction with the
`
`operating system of the device, “Neno”. "7:;:V7 9@ 9; [:@@7@@9:; :X
`
`87WS;:T:UZ6 D 9;WT^V9;U m.:<W7 and Neno n 9;87TT7W8^>T [<:[7<8Z <9US8@
`
`>;V l;:?DS:? X:< V7=7T:[Y7;8 :X Y:_9T7 S>;V@78@ P8S7 sO"7:;:V7
`
`#)*OQ5
`
`%‘5 ABAF6 Aq id. PM"7:;:V7 39W7;@7V $7WS;:T:UZO 9;WT^V7V <9US8@ 8: 8S7 ]FIG
`
`>[[T9W>89:; >;V "7;:Q5 ’>Y@^;U ?>@ WT7><TZ 9;87<7@87V 9; _:8S m.:<W7 >;V "7;:
`
`>;V6 9;V77V6 T9W7;@7V "7:;:V7]@ 87WS;:T:UZ 7‘WT^@9=7TZ5 Id.6 E5 ":< ?>@ 8S7
`
`>U<77Y7;8 [<:Y[87V _Z > 8S<7>8 :X T989U>89:;6 > [<9:< _^@9;7@@ <7T>89:;@S9[ :< :8S7<
`
`H
`
`12
`
`

`

`7W:;:Y9W <7>@:; 8S>8 Y9US8 V9@W:^;8 ’>Y@^;U]@ ^;V7;9>_T7 9;87<7@8 9; 7‘WT^@9=7TZ
`
`T9W7;@9;U 8S7 87WS;:T:UZ5 #;V77V6 8S7 >U<77Y7;8 ?>@ X:< > e:9;8 [<:V^W8
`
`V7=7T:[Y7;8 [<:U<>Y _7W>^@7 ’>Y@^;U @>? "7:;:V7]@ 87WS;:T:UZ >@ 8S7 MX^8^<7
`
`:X Y:_9T7 [S:;7@O >;V <7W:U;9m7V M?7 ;77V 8S9@5O $7TT9;UTZ6 )78989:;7< [<:=9V7@
`
`;: 87@89Y:;Z :< :8S7< 7=9V7;W7 W:;W7<;9;U 98@ :?; Y:89=>89:;5
`
`)78989:;7< >T@: 9;W:<<7W8TZ W:;87;V@ 8S>8 4:7<8m M>VY9887V 8S7 WT>9Y7V
`
`U7@8^<7D_>@7V 9;87<X>W7 ?>@ ;:8 ;7?5O *7[TZ6 \A5 L<:;U5 4:7<8m Y7<7TZ @8>87V >
`
`[>TY [9T:8 ^@7V > @8ZT^@D_>@7V @T9V9;U X:< MY>l9;U > <7=7<@7 87‘89;UO P%‘5 CBHI
`
`c4:7<8md \IgADC\Q >;V :8S7< V7=9W7@ S>V > 8:^WSD_>@7V @Z@87Y PCFgIDCIQ5 4:7<8m
`
`V9V ;:8 @^UU7@8 8S7 [>87;87V 9;=7;89:;@ ?7<7 ;:8 M;7?5O )78989:;7< >T@: W:;87;V@
`
`8S7 ABBA /71#$ V7Y:;@8<>89:; @S:^TV _7 V9@<7U><V7V _7W>^@7 8S7 V7=9W7 >TT7U7VTZ
`
`V9V ;:8 S>=7 > ?:<l9;U 8:^WS 9;87<X>W75 )78989:;7< V9@<7U><V@ 8S7 ?98;7@@]@
`
`87@89Y:;Z 8S>8 8S7 [<:8:8Z[7 S>V M> V9@[T>ZO >;V M> Y:=9;U =9V7: @S:?9;U
`
`V9XX7<7;8 8S9;U@ Z:^ W:^TV V: ?98S 8S7 V7=9W75O %‘5 CBHF c%<9l@@:;d CBHgCHDCF6
`
`CBIg\DR P"7:;:V7]@ V7=7T:[Y7;8 :X @?77[9;Uh@?9[9;UhUT9V9;U 9;87<X>W7 @8><87V
`
`_7X:<7 /71#$Q5
`
`II.
`
`PETITIONER FAILS TO SHOW ACTIVATION BY “GLIDING …
`AWAY” (ALL CLAIMS).
`
`$S7 WT>9Y@ <7k^9<7 M>W89=>89;U c>d X^;W89:;O =9> >; :[7<>89:; ?S7<79; M8S7
`
`:_e7W8 UT9Vc7@d >T:;U 8S7 8:^WS @7;@989=7 ><7> >?>Z X<:Y 8S7 8:^WS7V T:W>89:;5O %‘5
`
`CBBC c]FIGd WT5 C5 29<>Z>Y>D\BI6 S:?7=7<6 V9@WT:@7@ > MV<>UU9;UO Y:89:;6 ;:8 >
`
`R
`
`13
`
`

`

`MUT9V9;UO Y:89:;5 )78989:;7< W:;87;V@ 8S>8 MUT9V9;U N >?>ZO 7;W:Y[>@@7@ >
`
`MV<>UD>;VDV<:[O >;V6 9;V77V6 >;Z Y:=7Y7;8 >?>Z X<:Y 8S7 <7[<7@7;87V X^;W89:;5
`
`)78989:;7<]@ [:@989:; 9@ W:;8<><Z 8: 8S7 [T>9; Y7>;9;U >;V 8S7 9;8<9;@9W <7W:<V5 See
`
`’7W89:; ##5(5 )78989:;7<]@ >T87<;>89=7 [:@989:; 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI V:7@ ;:8 V9@WT:@7
`
`> MV<>UD>;VDV<:[O >T@: X>9T@5 See ’7W89:; ##515
`
`A.
`
`The Plain Meaning And The Intrinsic Record Confirm That
`“Gliding … Away” Is Distinct From A Drag-And-Drop.
`
`C5
`
`$S7 )T>9; +7>;9;U /:;X9<Y@ M4T9V9;UO (;V M&<>UU9;UO (<7
`&9@89;W85
`
`)78989:;7< <7T97@ @:T7TZ :; 29<>Z>Y>D\BI 8: @S:? MUT9V9;U N >?>ZO P)7856
`
`HFDHGQ6 _^8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI V:7@ ;:8 V9@WT:@7 > UT9V7h@?9[75 #;@87>V6 29<>Z>Y>D\BI
`
`Y>l7@ WT7><6 at least 14 times6 8S>8 98@ Y:=7Y7;8 9@ > dragging Y:=7Y7;85 %‘5
`
`CBBR c29<>Z>Y>D\BId Hg\DCA P[7; MY:=7@ Pi.e., dragsQO :; 8S7 @W<77;Qq (_@8<>W8
`
`PM#X 8S7 ^@7< 8:^WS7@ >; 9W:; 555 ?98S > [:9;8 :X 8S7 [7; >;V drags the pen 555 9X 8S7
`
`^@7< 8:^WS7@ 8S7 ?9;V:? ?98S 8S7 [:9;8 :X 8S7 [7; >;V drags 8S7 [7; 555OQq CgHADHH
`
`PM98 9@ >; :_e7W8 :X 8S7 [<7@7;8 9;=7;89:; 555 9; ?S9WS 8S7 ^@7< W>; >W89=>87 555 >
`
`V7@9U;>87V X^;W89:; 555 ?S7; 8S7 ^@7< drags > [7;5OQq CgHRDHG PM#8 9@ >;:8S7< :_e7W8
`
`:X 8S7 [<7@7;8 9;=7;89:; 555 9; ?S9WS > @8><89;U :< 7;V9;U [:@989:; :X > dragging
`
`operation W>; _7 V7@9U;>87V 555OQq RgCBDCC6 RgAIDAG6 IgGDAE6 WT@5 C6 \6 Hq )-*6 ARD
`
`\B5 #;V77V6 29<>Z>Y>D\BI Y>l7@ WT7>< 8S>8 > M^@7< W>; >W89=>87 :< V7>W89=>87 8S7
`
`I
`
`14
`
`

`

`V7@9U;>87V X^;W89:; only by dragging 8S7 [7; \5O Id.6 IgGDCB5 $S>8 9@6 > V<>U 9@
`
`<7k^9<7V >;V > UT9V7h@?9[7 ?9TT ;:8 V:55
`
`M&<>UU9;U6O e.g., > @>Wl :X _<9Wl@6 9@ ;:8 MUT9V9;U6O e.g.6 > X9U^<7 @l>87<5
`
`M&<>UU9;UO >;V MUT9V9;UO ><7 ;7>< :[[:@987@ >;V W:;;:87 7;89<7TZ V9XX7<7;8
`
`Y:=7Y7;8@5 ":8>_TZ6 )78989:;7< V:7@ ;:8 >VV<7@@ 8S7 [T>9; Y7>;9;U6 ;:< 7‘[T>9;
`
`?SZ > MdraggingO Y:=7Y7;8 ?:^TV _7 > MUT9V9;UO Y:=7Y7;85 $7TT9;UTZ6
`
`)78989:;7<]@ 7‘[7<8 S>@ ;:8 [7<X:<Y7V any >;>TZ@9@ :; 8S7 V9XX7<7;W7 _78?77; 8S7
`
`[T>9; Y7>;9;U :X MUT9V9;UO >;V MV<>UU9;UOg
`
`o5 LS>8 9@ 8S7 V9XX7<7;W7 _78?77; 8S7 [T>9; Y7>;9;U :X UT9V9;U >
`
`[7; >@ :[[:@7V 8: V<>UU9;U > [7;i
`
`(5
`
`# V:;]8 <7W>TT [7<X:<Y9;U >; >;>TZ@9@ V9@89;U^9@S9;U _78?77; >;Z
`
`[:@@9_T7 V9XX7<7;W7 9; 8S7 Y7>;9;U@ :X 8S7 87<Y@ MUT9V9;UO >;V
`
`MV<>UU9;UO 9; YZ <7[:<8@5
`
`%‘5 ABEE c17V7<@:;DA;VD&7[:5d AHgCBDCIq AEgHDCF P<7X^@9;U 8: 7‘[T>9;
`
`^;V7<@8>;V9;U :X MUT9V9;UOQq \\g\DAHq \EgADG5
`
`F
`
`15
`
`

`

`17W>^@7 )78989:;7< >;V 98@ 7‘[7<8 S>=7 ;:8 V7Y:;@8<>87V 8S>8 > MV<>UO 9@
`
`MUT9V9;U 555 >?>Z6O )78989:;7< X>9T@ 8: [<:=7 any :X 8S7 WT>9Y@ ><7 :_=9:^@ ^;V7< 8S7
`
`[T>9; Y7>;9;U5
`
`A5
`
`$S7 ([[T9W>;8 &9@WT>9Y7V M&<>UD>;VD&<:[5O
`
`$S9@ W:;WT^@9:; 9@ W:;X9<Y7V _Z 8S7 [<:@7W^89:; S9@8:<Z5 $S7 ([[T9W>;8
`
`Y>V7 expressly WT7>< 8S>8 MUT9V9;U 555 >?>ZO 9@ V9@89;W8 X<:Y > MV<>UD>;VDV<:[
`
`:[7<>89:;Og
`
`Hoshino does not teach gliding > X9;U7< away X<:Y >; 9W:;5 Instead6
`
`Hoshino teaches a drag-and-drop operation X:< Y:=9;U >; 9W:;5
`
`%‘5 CBB\ c)<:@7W^89:;D29@8:<Zd CICq )-*6 b###5(5C5
`
`%‘5 CBB\6 CIB5 $S7@7 WT7>< @8>87Y7;8@ :[7<>87 >@ > [<:@7W^89:; V9@WT>9Y7< 8S>8 8S7
`
`WT>9Y7V MUT9V9;U 555 >?>ZO T9Y98>89:; V:7@ ;:8 7;W:Y[>@@ MV<>UD>;VDV<:[O
`
`:[7<>89:;@5 )-*6 ACDA\ PW989;U W>@7@Q5 ":8>_TZ6 )78989:;7< V:7@ ;:8 V9@89;U^9@S
`
`)>87;8 -?;7<]@ W>@7@5 )78989:;7< :;TZ W987@ Omega Eng’g, Inc. v. Raytek Corp.6
`
`\\E .5\V C\CE6 C\AE P.7V5 /9<5 ABB\Q ?S9WS [<:=9V7@ 8S>8 >; >Y_9U^:^@ @8>87Y7;8
`
`V:7@ ;:8 :[7<>87 >@ > V9@WT>9Y7<5 See *7[TZ6 F5 1^8 8S7 ([[T9W>;8]@ WT7><
`
`@8>87Y7;8@ >_:=7 ><7 ;:8 >Y_9U^:^@5
`
`G
`
`16
`
`

`

`)78989:;7< >;V 98@ 7‘[7<8 ?S:TTZ 9U;:<7V 8S9@ [<:@7W^89:; S9@8:<Z5 )7856 HFDRB5
`
`#8@ 7‘[7<8 V9V ;:8 W:;V^W8 >;Z >;>TZ@9@ :X V<>UD>;VDV<:[5 )-*6 \CD\\5 $S7
`
`*7[TZ]@ ^;89Y7TZ ><U^Y7;8@ W:;W7<;9;U 8S7 [<:@7W^89:; S9@8:<Z X>9T5 )78989:;7<
`
`W:;87;V@ 8S>8 "7:;:V7 Y9@<7[<7@7;8@ 2:@S9;:]@ V9@WT:@^<7 >;V >[[T9W>;8]@ <7T>87V
`
`><U^Y7;8@ P*7[TZ6 RQ6 _^8 8S9@ 9@ X>T@75 .9<@86 )78989:;7<]@ U7;7<>T ><U^Y7;8@ >_:^8
`
`8S7 [<7W9@7 ;>8^<7 :X 8S7 V9XX7<7;W7 _78?77; 2:@S9;: >;V 8S7 WT>9Y@ ><7 9<<7T7=>;85
`
`$S7 .7V7<>T /9<W^98 S>@ <7e7W87V 8S7 [<:[:@989:; M8S>8 [<:@7W^89:; V9@WT>9Y7<
`
`>[[T97@ :;TZ ?S7; >[[T9W>;8@ >887Y[8 8: :=7<W:Y7 > WT>9Y <7e7W89:;5O Uship
`
`Intellectual Props., LLC v. United States6 ICE .5\V C\CC6 C\CH P.7V5 /9<5 ABC\Q5
`
`"7‘86 )78989:;7< W987@ 8S7 %‘>Y9;7<]@ <7e7W89:; :=7< 2:@S9;: P%‘5 CBB\
`
`c)<:@7W^89:;D29@8:<Zd CIGDCFBQ6 _^8 8S>8 ?>@ _7X:<7 8S7 ([[T9W>;8 V9@89;U^9@S7V
`
`8S7 WT>9Y7V UT9V9;U X<:Y 2:@S9;:]@ MV<>UD>;VDV<:[O :[7<>89:;5 )78989:;7< >T@:
`
`W987@ 8S7 ([[T9W>;8]@ V9@W^@@9:; :X 2:@S9;:]@ M[^@SD9; :[7<>89:;O >;V 98@ MV<>U
`
`:[7<>89:;O _^8 8S7<76 8S7 ([[T9W>;8 Y7<7TZ Y>V7 WT7>< 8S>8 ;798S7< :X 2:@S9;:]@
`
`:[7<>89:;@ @>89@X97V 8S7 WT>9Y@ Pid.6 CIBQ5 (@ 8: 8S7 8>_T7 V9@89;U^9@S9;U 8S7 WT>9Y7V
`
`M;:=7T 8:^WSD>;VDUT9V7O X<:Y 2:@S9;:]@ MW:;=7;89:;>T N V<>UD>;VDV<:[O6
`
`)78989:;7< WT>9Y@ 8S>8 8S7 M[<9Y><ZO V9@89;W89:; 9@ >W89=>89:; 9; <7@[:;@7 8: > MS><V
`
`8:^WSO P*7[TZ6 IQ6 9U;:<9;U 8S>8 8S9@ V9@89;W89:; 9@ T9@87V T>@85
`
`)78989:;7< Y>l7@ 8S<77 ><U^Y7;8@ :X k^7@89:;>_T7 <7T7=>;W7 W:;W7<;9;U 8S7
`
`([[T9W>;8]@ @8>87Y7;8g
`
`CB
`
`17
`
`

`

`Hoshino does not teach gliding a finger away from an icon. Instead,
`
`Hoshine teaches a drag-and-drop operation for moving anicon.
`
`In
`
`Ex 10038ProsecutionHistory|Petitioner first imagines a distinction
`
`between “gliding ... away from an icon”and|the limitation}‘gliding ... away from|
`
`
`
`
`
`thetouchedlocationa—But the pending claim languageat the time was in fact
`
`
`
`
`
`icsthetouchedlocationis“wheretherepresentation[é.2..an]
`
`1S
`
`J
`
`istincti
`
`difference!
`
`39
`gliding away “from the touched location,” and not “gliding away from an icon.”
`
`BecBS ection I Big he Reply,
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`emphasizesthe“movinganicon”portionjofthephrase“adragjandidropoperation|
`
`for moving an icon” ignoring
`
`away” from “drag jandadrop
`
`to mention, and underline, that Hoshino’s 1s a “draggand4drop|
`
`ded
`
`butthat
`
`madePgliding...away”anda“dragjandadrop”operation.|
`
`9 also arguesthat “‘[t]he claim amendments}—donotamountfto
`
`disclaimer.’ §But the disclaimer arises from the Applicant’s statements Mn accord,
`
`e claim amendmentsicontirm that not all “movements” are gliding ... away.”
`
`18
`
`

`

`M8S7 <7[<7@7;8>89:; :X 8S7 X^;W89:; 9@ ;:8 <7T:W>87V :< V^[T9W>87V V^<9;U 8S7
`
`UT9V9;UO @^UU7@8@ > V<>UD>;VDV<:[ 9@ 7;W:Y[>@@7V _Z MUT9V9;U5O $: 8S7 W:;8<><Z6
`
`8S9@ T9Y98>89:; <79;X:<W7@ 8S>8 > V<>UD>;VDV<:[ 9@ 7‘WT^V7V5
`
`\5
`
`)78989:;7<]@ ):@989:; $S>8 (;Z +:=7Y7;8 /:;@898^87@ M4T9V9;UO
`#@ !;@^_@8>;89>87V (;V /:;8<><Z $: $S7 #;8<9;@9W *7W:<V5
`
`)78989:;7<]@ ><U^Y7;8 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI V9@WT:@7@ MUT9V9;U N >?>ZO 9@
`
`_>@7V :; 8S7 [<7Y9@7 8S>8 MUT9V9;U N >?>ZO 9@ @>89@X97V _Z >;Z Y:=7Y7;8 >?>Z
`
`X<:Y 8S7 <7[<7@7;87V X^;W89:;5 *7[TZ6 \ PMregardless of whether Hirayama-307’s
`
`icon 41 is dragged 555 8S7 [7; @89TT moves away 555OQq CG PM29<>Z>Y>D\BI @9Y9T><TZ
`
`V7@W<9_7@g 8S7 ^@7< 8:^WS7@ 8S7 [7; V:?; c>;Vd moves the pen to the display area
`
`N5OQq CR P<7X7<<9;U 8: > MV<>UhUT9V7 movement5OQ5 )78989:;7< V:7@ ;:8 7‘[T>9; S:?
`
`>;Z Y:=7Y7;8tT78 >T:;7 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ MV<>UU9;UOtW:^TV _7 MUT9V9;U6O >;V
`
`)78989:;7<]@ [:@989:; 9@ W:;8<><Z 8: 8S7 [T>9; Y7>;9;U >;V 8S7 [<:@7W^89:; S9@8:<Z5
`
`#; [<:@7W^89:;6 8S7 T9Y98>89:; :<9U9;>TTZ <7>Vg
`
`moving 9; > V9<7W89:; from > @8><89;U [:9;8 8S>8 9@ 8S7 <7[<7@7;8>89:; c:X
`
`> X^;W89:;d N to @>9V V9@[T>Z ><7>5
`
`%‘5 CBB\ c)<:@7W^89:;D29@8:<Zd \AR5 #; X^<8S7< [<:@7W^89:; >X87< 8S7 WT>9Y@ ?7<7
`
`<7e7W87V6 8S7 ([[T9W>;8 M7;W:^<>U7VO 8S7 %‘>Y9;7< 8: M?>8WS 8S7 =9V7:
`
`V7Y:;@8<>89:; :X 8S7 "A Y:_9T7 [S:;7h[7<@:;>T V9U98>T >@@9@8>;W7 V7=9W7O M[<9:< 8:
`
`<7=97?9;U ([[T9W>;8]@ ><U^Y7;8@5O %‘5 AB\H cABBFDB\DCE -XX9W7D(W89:;D
`
`CA
`
`19
`
`

`

`*7@[:;@7d CHDCRq %‘5 ABBF c"AD(V=7<89@7Y7;8DK9V7:d5 (@ 8S7 =9V7: @S:?@6 8S7
`
`MUT9V9;U N >?>ZO U7@8^<7 9@ > @7>YT7@@ M@?9[9;UO U7@8^<7g
`
`%‘5 ABBF c"AD(V=7<89@7Y7;8DK9V7:d PBBgARDBBgAIQ5
`
`$S7 %‘>Y9;7< >Wl;:?T7VU7V 8S7 M@?9[9;UO U7@8^<76 _^8 V787<Y9;7V 8S>8 8S7
`
`MY:=9;U N X<:Y N 8:O T>;U^>U7 ?>@ 8:: _<:>V 8: @: T9Y98 8S7 WT>9Y@g
`
`$S7 %‘>Y9;7< <7=97?7V 8S7 V7Y:;@8<>89:; >@ 7;W:^<>U7V _Z 8S7
`
`([[T9W>;85 In light of the video demonstration, the Examiner can now
`
`see the difference between the prior art of record and the present
`
`application. L98S 8S>8 _79;U @>9V 8S7 %‘>Y9;7< X77T@ 8S>8 8S7
`
`T9Y98>89:;@6 >@ WT>9Y7V6 ?7<7 <7>@:;>_TZ 9;87<[<787V >;V 8S7 W^<<7;8
`
`T9Y98>89:;@ ><7 @89TT 8:: _<:>V 8: @^UU7@8 ?98S:^8 <7@7><WS ?S>8 ?>@
`
`@S:?; 9; 8S7 =9V7: V7Y:;@8<>89:;5
`
`%‘5 ABEH c.9;>TD-XX9W7D(W89:;d CR51
`
`1 )78989:;7< [^<[:<87V 8: 9;WT^V7 8S7 X9T7 S9@8:<Z P%‘5 CBB\Q _^8 :Y9887V
`
`Y>87<9>T :XX9W7 >W89:;@6 9;WT^V9;U :;7@ V9<7W8TZ W:;8<><Z 8: 98@ ><U^Y7;8@6 @^WS >@
`
`%‘S9_98 ABEH5 $: 8S7 7‘87;8 )78989:;7< :_e7W8@ 8: 8S7 X9T9;U :X %‘S9_98 ABEH6 8S7
`
`C\
`
`20
`
`

`

`#; <7@[:;@7 >;V X:TT:?9;U >; %‘>Y9;7<D9;87<=97?6 8S7 ([[T9W>;8 >Y7;V7V
`
`8S7 WT>9Y X<:Y Mmoving 9; > V9<7W89:; from > @8><89;U [:9;8 N to @>9V V9@[T>Z ><7>O
`
`8: Mgliding >T:;U 8S7 8:^WS @7;@989=7 ><7> away X<:Y 8S7 T:W>89:;5O %‘5 CBB\
`
`c)<:@7W^89:;D29@8:<Zd \ARD\AI6 \E\ P>Y7;VY7;8 M8: [<:[7<TZ WT>9Y 8S7 [<7@7;8
`
`9;=7;89:;5OQ5 $S7 ([[T9W>;8 <7[7>87VTZ 7Y[S>@9m7V 8S>8 8S7 WT>9Y7V MUT9V9;U N
`
`>?>ZO 9@ ;:8 e^@8 >;Z Y:=7Y7;8 _^8 > MUT9V9;UO :< M@?9[9;UO U7@8^<75 Id.6 \HI6
`
`ARG5
`
`LS9T7 )78989:;7<]@ [:@989:; V7[7;V@ ^[:; >;Z 8Z[7 :X Y:=7Y7;8 _79;U >
`
`MUT9V76O )78989:;7< V9V ;:8 @^_@8>;89>87 8S9@ [:@989:; ^;V7< 8S7 [T>9; Y7>;9;U5 &<5
`
`17V7<@:;6 V9V ;:8 [7<X:<Y >;Z M>;>TZ@9@ :X >;Z [:87;89>T V9@89;W89:; _78?77; 8S7
`
`87<Y UT9V9;U > [7; >;V Y:=9;U > [7; 9; >;Z :X YZ <7[:<8@6 @: 8S>8]@ ;:8 >; :[9;9:;
`
`# S>=75O %‘5 ABEE c17V7<@:;DA;VD&7[:5d AHgAHDARgFq see alsoid.6 \\g\DAHq \EgADG
`
`P;: >;>TZ@9@ :X > @?9[7 U7@8^<7 =9@DuD=9@ > V<>UD>;VDV<:[Q5
`
`1:><V @S:^TV 8>l7 :XX9W9>T ;:89W7 :X 8S7 :Y9887V :XX9W7 >W89:;5 Merial Limited v.
`
`Virbac6 #)*ABCEDBCAIG6 )>[7< C\6 C\DCE Pa>;5 AA6 ABCHQ P8>l9;U ;:89W7 :X
`
`%^<:[7>; [>87;8 >[[T9W>89:; 7=7; 8S:^US ;798S7< [><8Z S>V Y>V7 98 :X <7W:<VQq
`
`Ericsson Inc. v. Intellectual Ventures II LLC6 #)*ABCEDBBGCG6 )>[7< \I6 CR ;5CB
`
`P)$(16 &7W5 I6 ABCHQ P@>Y7Q5
`
`CE
`
`21
`
`

`

`)78989:;7< W:;87;V@ > V<>UD>;VDV<:[ :[7<>89:; V9@WT:@7@ MUT9V9;U >?>ZO
`
`_7W>^@7 Mc8dS7 WT>9Y7V sUT9V9;U N >?>Z] X:W^@7@ :; S:? >;V ?S7<7 > [7;hX9;U7<
`
`9;87<>W8@ ?98S 8S7 8:^WS @7;@989=7 ><7>6 ?S7<7>@ sV<>UD>;VDV<:[] 9@ >_:^8 S:? 8S7
`
`@Z@87Y <7>W8@ 8: 8S>8 9;87<>W89:;5O *7[TZ6 A5 $S9@ 9@ 9;W:<<7W85 .9<@86 98 <7T97@ :; 8S7
`
`^;@^[[:<87V >@@^Y[89:; 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ V<>UD>;VDV<:[ :[7<>89:; V9@WT:@7@
`
`8S7 WT>9Y7V MUT9V9;U N >?>ZO @9Y[TZ _7W>^@7 8S7 ^@7< MY:=7@ Pi.e5 V<>U@Q 8S7
`
`[:9;8 :X 8S7 [7;5O %‘5 CBBR c29<>Z>Y>D\BId Hg\DCA5 ’7W:;V6 > V<>UD>;VDV<:[
`
`:[7<>89:; M<7X7<c@d to a combination of a user action and a system response N5O
`
`%‘5 ABBH c17V7<@:;D&7[:5d CEBgAHDCECgCA5
`
`B.
`
`Petitioner’s Argument That Hirayama-307’s Operation Is Not
`Drag-And-Drop Is Incorrect.
`
`)78989:;7< >T@: ><U^7@ 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ :[7<>89:; 9@ ;:8 > V<>UD>;VDV<:[5
`
`*7[TZ6 CCDCA6 CFDAB52 $S9@ 9@ >_@^<V5 (@ V9@W^@@7V 9; ’7W89:; ##5(5C6 29<>Z>Y>D
`
`\BI Y>l7@ <7[7>87VTZ WT7>< 8S>8 98@ Y:89:; 9@ > MV<>UU9;UO Y:89:;6 :X87; <7X7<<9;U
`
`8: > MV<>UU9;U :[7<>89:;5O %‘5 CBBR c29<>Z>Y>D\BId CgHRDHGq IgAADAE5 29<>Z>Y>D
`
`\BI 9@ ;:8 e^@8 > MV<>UU9;U :[7<>89:;6O 98 9@ :;7 9; ?S9WS >; 9W:; 9@ Y:=7V P>;V
`
`7;T><U7V :< <7V^W7VQ X<:Y :;7 T:W>89:; 8: > specific T:W>89:; WS:@7; _Z 8S7 ^@7<5
`
`2 *7U><VT7@@ :X ?S78S7< 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ :[7<>89:; 9@ > V<>UD>;VDV<:[6 98@
`
`Y:=9;UhV<>UU9;U :X 8S7 [7; 9@ ;:8 @S:?; 8: V9@WT:@7 MUT9V9;U N >?>ZO ^;V7< 98@
`
`[T>9; Y7>;9;U5 See ’7W89:; ##5(5C6 \5
`
`CH
`
`22
`
`

`

`Id.6 CgHRDHG PM@8><89;U :< 7;V9;U [:@989:; N W>; _7 V7@9U;>87V 555OQq CgRBDR\ PM>
`
`[:@989:; :X > ?9;V:?6 i.e.6 > [:@989:; :X >; 7;T><U7V 9W:;6 W>; _7 V787<Y9;7V ?98S
`
`7>@75OQ5 29<>Z>Y>D\BI6 8S^@6 9; 98@ :?; WT7>< 87<Y@6 9@ > MV<>UU9;U :[7<>89:;O 9;
`
`?S9WS >; 9W:; 9@ V<:[[7V >8 > @[7W9X9W6 ^@7<DWS:@7;6 T:W>89:;5 LS>8 9@ Y:<76
`
`29<>Z>Y>D\BI Y>l7@ WT7>< 8S>8 8S7 9W:; V9@[T>Z7V 9@ @S:?; >@ _79;U Y:=7V V^<9;U
`
`8S7 MV<>UD>;VDV<:[5O Id.6 AgHDF PMthe icon display coordinate position is moved 9;
`
`>WW:<V>;W7 ?98S 8S7 Y:=7Y7;8 :X 8S7 [:@989:; W::<V9;>87 :X 8S7 [:9;8 :X 8S7 [7;5OQ5
`
`29<>Z>Y>D\BI 9@ > k^9;87@@7;89>T MV<>UD>;VDV<:[5O
`
`)78989:;7<]@ ><U^Y7;8@ 8: 8S7 W:;8<><Z XTZ 9; 8S7 X>W7 :X 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@
`
`WT7>< 87>WS9;U@5 )78989:;7< W:;87;V@ 8S>8 > MV<>UD>;VDV<:[O Y^@8 V9@[T>Z >; 9W:;
`
`_79;U =9@9_TZ Y:=7V6 X^<8S7< W:;87;V9;U 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ 9W:; 9@ ;:8 @S:?; 8:
`
`_7 Y:=7V5 *7[TZ6 CB6 CA5 $S9@ 9@ 7;89<7TZ W:;8<><Z 8: 29<>Z>Y>D\BI ?S9WS Y>l7@
`
`WT7>< 8S7 M9W:; display coordinate position is movedO ?98S 8S7 [7;]@ Y:=7Y7;85
`
`%‘5 CBBR c29<>Z>Y>D\BId AgRDFq ’7W89:; ###5(6 infra5 1^8 7=7; 9X6 arguendo6
`
`29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ 9W:; ?7<7 ;:8 =9@9_TZ V<>UU7V6 8S>8 8:: ?:^TV _7 9YY>87<9>T
`
`_7W>^@7 > V<>UD>;VDV<:[ :[7<>89:; V:7@ ;:8 <7k^9<7 > @[7W9X9W =9@^>T X77V_>Wl5 %‘5
`
`ABBI c*:@7;_7<UDA;VD&7WT5d rrHG6 RC5 ’: T:;U >@ 8S7 :_e7W8 9@ T:U9W>TTZ V<>UU7V
`
`>;V V<:[[7V ?S7<7 8S7 X9;U7<h@8ZT^@ T7>=7@ 8S7 @W<77;6 8S7 :[7<>89:; 9@ > WT>@@9W
`
`V<>UD>;VDV<:[5 Id5 #;V77V6 )78989:;7< 7T@7?S7<7 ><U^7@ > V<>UD>;VDV<:[ :[7<>89:;
`
`CR
`
`23
`
`

`

`Y>Z :WW^< ?98S:^8 =9@^>TTZ V^[T9W>89;U :< <7T:W>89;U 8S7 V<>UU7V 9W:;5 See *7[TZ6
`
`AADAH5
`
`$: >=:9V 8S7 9;7=98>_T7 W:;WT^@9:; 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI 9@ > MV<>UD>;VDV<:[6O
`
`)78989:;7< [<787;V@ ;:8 8: ^;V7<@8>;V P*7[TZ6 EQ ?S>8 98 Y7>;@ X:< M@:Y7 X:<Y :X
`
`>; :_e7W8O 8: _7 T:U9W>TTZ V<>UU7V :< M_7S>=7cd >@ 9X 98 9@ _79;U T:U9W>TTZ V<>UU7V5O
`
`1^8 @^WS > [S7;:Y7;:; 9@ X>Y9T9>< 8: 7=7; W>@^>T W:Y[^87< ^@7<@5 %‘5 ABBI
`
`c*:@7;_7<UDA;VD&7WT5d rrRBDRC P[<:=9V9;U X>Y9T9>< 7‘>Y[T7@Q5 (;V6 V7@[987
`
`)78989:;7<]@ >TT7U7V W:;X^@9:;6 98 W>;;:8 ^;V: 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ WT7>< V7@W<9[89:; :X
`
`98@ MV<>UU9;UO Y:=7Y7;8 >;V MV<>UU9;U :[7<>89:;5O
`
`)78989:;7< [<:W77V@ X<:Y >TT7U7V W:;X^@9:; 8: Y9;^89>76 ><U^9;U > V<>UD>;VD
`
`V<:[ :[7<>89:; Y^@8 M9;WT^V7 @[7W9X9W [<:U<>YY9;U :X 8S7 ^;V7<TZ9;U @Z@87Y 8:
`
`V7X9;7 987Y@ >@ > @:^<W7h@7T7W89:; :_e7W8@6 >;V 8><U78hV7@89;>89:; :_e7W8@ 8S>8
`
`<7W79=7 8S7 @:^<W7 =9> 8S7 sV<:[5]O *7[TZ6 H5 ’^WS ;7?X:^;V <7k^9<7Y7;8@ W>;;:8
`
`7<>@7 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ ^;Y9@8>l>_T7 WS><>W87<9m>89:; :X 98@ MV<>UU9;UO Y:=7Y7;8
`
`>;V :[7<>89:;6 >;V )78989:;7< V:7@ ;:8 7‘[T>9; ?SZ > MV<>UD>;VDV<:[O 9@ V7X9;7V _Z
`
`> [><89W^T>< @:^<W7 W:V7 9Y[T7Y7;8>89:;5 Contra %‘5 ABBI c*:@7;_7<UDA;VD&7WT5d
`
`rrRBDRC6 RI5 #; >;Z 7=7;86 29<>Z>Y>D\BI 9;WT^V7@ 7=7; 8S7@7 >TT7U7V
`
`[<7<7k^9@987@5 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ M@:^<W7h@7T7W89:; :_e7W8O 9@ 98@ 9W:;6 98@ @[7W9X9W
`
`8><U78 9@ 8S7 ^@7<D@[7W9X97V T:W>89:; 8S7<7 8S7 7;T><U7V 9W:; 9@ V<:[[7V5 )-*6 ARD
`
`CI
`
`24
`
`

`

`AFq %‘5 ABBH c17V7<@:;D&7[:5d CECgCBDCA PMX:< 7‘>Y[T76 Z:^ drop >; 9W:; :;8:
`
`8S7 @W<77;5OQ5
`
`)78989:;7< <7T97@ :; 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ .9U5 E(6 ><U^9;U 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@
`
`9W:;@ ><7 ;:8 >W89=>87V _Z > V<>UD>;VDV<:[6 _^8 _Z > @9Y[T7 Y:=9;U U7@8^<7 T><U7<
`
`8S>; > [<7DV7X9;7V V9@8>;W75 *7[TZ6 GDCB6 C\DCE6 CFDAB5 $S7 *7[TZ6CE >T@:
`
`[<7@7;8@ >; 9;W:<<7W8 >;;:8>89:; :X 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ .9U5 \( 8: @^UU7@8 8S>8
`
`9Y[T7Y7;8>89:; :X 29<>Z>Y>D\BI]@ .9U5 E >W89=>87@ >; 9W:; _Z > T:;U @?9[7g
`
`1^8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI S>@ ;:8S9;U 8: V: ?98S @?9[9;U :< UT9V9;U5 #8 <7X7<@ 8: 98@
`
`Y:89:; >@ > MV<>UU9;UO Y:89:;h:[7<>89:; CE 89Y7@ >;V ;7=7< :;W7 >@ > MUT9V9;UO :<
`
`M@?9[9;UO Y:89:;5 29<>Z>Y>D\BI W>; M:;TZO M>W89=>87O :< MV7>W89=>87O >; 9W:; _Z
`
`MV<>UU9;U 8S7 [7;6O 9; > WT>@@9W V<>UD>;VDV<:[ X>@S9:;5 %‘5 CBBR c29<>Z>Y>D\BId
`
`IgGDCBq )-*6 \HDEHq ’7W89:; ###5(5 ":< 9@ 8S7 X>W8 8S>8 29<>Z>Y>D\BI Y>Z
`
`9Y[T7Y7;8 > V<>UD>;VDV<:[6 9; [><86 _Z Y7>@^<9;U 8S7 V9@8>;W7 :X Y:=7Y7;8 :X 8S7
`
`[7; :X >;Z <7T7=>;W75 29<>Z>Y>D\BI 7‘[T>9;@ 8S>8 V787<Y9;9;U 8S7 V9@8>;W7 :X
`
`CF
`
`25
`
`

`

`pen coordinate 1s outside of the predetermined designated area (¢.¢., the hatched
`
`
`
`area in this embodiment).” Ex. 1006 |Hirayama4307] 5:61863 LOS|
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`movementof the pen is merely an alternative way for determining whether “the
`
`minimumveshiftamounttobecalculatedatthetimethepentouchestheiconas[the
`
`distance between the point touched within the icon and the bottom of the hatched
`
`arecamtEx..2007 [Rosenbergi2ndsDecl.| 23 n.1MFig. 4A itself
`
`
`
`Hirayama4307’s Figure 4Afis consistent with the balance of Hirayama
`
`disclosure. In step 2 (S2), the pen 1s placed within the “predetermined area of [an]
`
`icon group.” Thereafter, the pen shitts@ie], is “dragged,” [by a “large amount”
`
`HO}
`
`26
`
`

`

`P’EQ6 @: 8S7 [7; 9@ :^8@9V7 :X 8S7 V7@9U;>87V ><7>6 >X87< ?S9WS 8S7 V<>UU7V 9W:;
`
`PHgRHDRRQ 9@ M7;T><U7V 555 >@ > ?9;V:?O P’RQ5
`
`$S7 @>Y7 [<:W7@@ ?:<l@ 9; <7=7<@7 >@ @S:?; 9; .9U^<7 E16 ?S7<7 8S7 [7;
`
`8:^WS7@ 8S7 7;T><U7V 9W:; P’$AQ6 >;V :;W7 8S7 [7; >;V 8S7 7;T><U7V 9W:; ><7
`
`V<>UU7V _Z > T><U7 >Y:^;8 P’$EQ 98 9@ <7V^W7V P’$RQ >;V Y:=7V 8: 8S7
`
`M[<7V7