`
`
`
`EXHIBIT A
`EXHIBIT A
`
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0001
`
`
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence v. Patent Owner’s Evidence
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence
`• Quintana
`• Jacobi
`• Dr. Netland
`• Testing
`
`Patent Owner’s Evidence
`• Quintana’s Affidavit
`
`• Dr. Condon
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`2
`
`Ex.1046, p. 2 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0002
`
`
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence v. Patent Owner’s Evidence
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence
`• Quintana
`• Jacobi
`• Dr. Netland
`• Testing
`
`Patent Owner’s Evidence
`• Quintana’s Affidavit
`
`• Dr. Condon
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`4
`
`Ex.1046, p. 4 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0003
`
`
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence v. Patent Owner’s Evidence
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence
`• Quintana
`• Jacobi
`• Dr. Netland
`• Testing
`
`Patent Owner’s Evidence
`• Quintana’s Affidavit
`
`• Dr. Condon
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`9
`
`Ex.1046, p. 9 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0004
`
`
`
`Dr. Netland’s Testing Provides Further
`Confirmation
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1030, ¶¶17‐26; Ex.1031‐1033; see
`IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 13‐14; IPR2020‐
`01711, Paper 27, 11‐13; IPR2021‐00017,
`Paper 26, 12‐14; IPR2021‐00065, Paper 24,
`12‐14; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 14‐16.
`
`10
`
`Ex.1046, p. 10 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0005
`
`
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence v. Patent Owner’s Evidence
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence
`• Quintana
`• Jacobi
`• Dr. Netland
`• Testing
`
`Patent Owner’s Evidence
`• Quintana’s Affidavit
`
`• Dr. Condon
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`11
`
`Ex.1046, p. 11 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0006
`
`
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence v. Patent Owner’s Evidence
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence
`• Quintana
`• Jacobi
`• Dr. Netland
`• Testing
`
`Patent Owner’s Evidence
`• Quintana’s Affidavit
`
`• Dr. Condon
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`12
`
`Ex.1046, p. 12 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0007
`
`
`
`…But Dr. Condon Testified He Did Not Read or
`Understand the Patents
`• Dr. Condon merely “flipped through”
`the ‘729 patent
`• Ex.1041, 176:2‐4
`• Dr. Condon “didn’t drill down into []
`the requirements of the ‘729 patent”
`• Ex.1041, 214:13‐15
`• Dr. Condon “would not be
`comfortable telling [NWM’s counsel]
`what [is] required” in the patents at
`issue
`• Ex.1041, 214:21‐22
`
`• Dr. Condon testified he had “not seen
`this before” when given the Notice of
`Allowance from the ‘729 patent file
`history
`• Ex. 1042, 239:11‐20
`• Dr. Condon testified regarding the
`‘905 patent: “I don’t remember
`reading the whole thing”
`• Ex.1042, 266:3‐7
`• Dr. Condon “didn’t analyze [the ‘155
`patent] other than to look at … the
`claim language.”
`• Ex.1042, 281:18‐282:1
`
`IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 2‐3; IPR2020‐01711, Paper 27, 2‐3;
`IPR2021‐00017, Paper 26, 2‐4; IPR2021‐00065, Paper 24, 2‐4;
`IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 2‐4.
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`14
`
`Ex.1046, p. 14 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0008
`
`
`
`…And Dr. Condon Testified He Does Not
`Understand Patent Claims
`• Dr. Condon testified he
`cannot tell the difference
`between a device or
`method claim
`• Ex.1042, 276:8‐12
`• Dr. Condon testified “I don’t even
`know if I’m capable of dissecting
`that exact piece of information
`out of the claim” when asked if
`claims require certain elements
`• Ex.1042, 257:4‐9
`IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 2‐3; IPR2020‐01711, Paper 27, 2‐3; IPR2021‐00017,
`Paper 26, 2‐4; IPR2021‐00065, Paper 24, 2‐4; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 2‐4.
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`15
`
`Ex.1046, p. 15 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0009
`
`
`
`…And Dr. Condon Testified He Does Not
`Understand Anticipation or Obviousness
`• Dr. Condon testified he
`“would have to say no” and
`“couldn’t explain it” when
`asked if he has an
`understanding of obviousness
`• Ex.1042, 257:10‐14
`• Dr. Condon testified “it’s not
`crystal clear to me” when
`asked if he has an
`understanding of anticipation
`• Ex.1041, 178:10
`
`IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 2‐3; IPR2020‐01711, Paper 27, 2‐3; IPR2021‐00017,
`Paper 26, 2‐4; IPR2021‐00065, Paper 24, 2‐4; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 2‐4.
`
`IPR2020‐01573 Ex.2019, ¶267 (see Paper 29, 12; Paper 35, 2; Paper 52, 10‐11) see also IPR2020‐01711, Ex.2019, ¶245 (see Paper 17, 13;
`Paper 27, 2; Paper 39, 10‐12); IPR2021‐00017, Ex.2019, ¶191 (see Paper 17, 10; Paper 26, 2; Paper 38, 10‐12); IPR2021‐00065, Ex.2019,
`¶135 (see Paper 18, 10; Paper 24, 2; Paper 41, 10‐11); IPR2021‐00066, Ex.2019, ¶224 (see Paper 17, 12; Paper 25, 2; Paper 39, 10‐11).
`.
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`16
`
`Ex.1046, p. 16 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0010
`
`
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence v. Patent Owner’s Evidence
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence
`• Quintana
`• Jacobi
`• Dr. Netland
`• Testing
`
`Patent Owner’s Evidence
`• Quintana’s Affidavit
`
`• Dr. Condon
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`18
`
`Ex.1046, p. 18 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0011
`
`
`
`Quintana Discloses Creating a “Strip” of TM (‘729,
`cl.1 / ’155, cl.1 / ’885, cl.1 / ’905, cl.1)
`
`• Quintana (Ex.1004) discloses:
`• improvement on prior techniques that failed due to reclosure/scarring of
`incision
`• “achiev[ing] a section” of TM
`• “stripping” TM
`• “remaining cells can enlarge”
`• Dr. Netland confirms Quintana creates/removes “strips” of TM
`(Ex.1003)
`• Dr. Netland’s additional testing confirms Quintana discloses “strips” of
`TM (Ex.1030)
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`28
`
`Ex.1046, p. 28 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0012
`
`
`
`Spencer and Becker Show Incising TM Does
`Not Work
`
`Becker (Ex.1035)
`
`Ex.1035, 2; see IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 8‐9; IPR2020‐01711,
`Paper 27, 7‐8; IPR2021‐00017, Paper 26, 8; IPR2021‐00065, Paper
`24, 8; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 11.
`
`Spencer (Ex.1036)
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1036, 5‐6; see IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 8‐9;
`IPR2020‐01711, Paper 27, 7‐8; IPR2021‐00017, Paper
`26, 8; IPR2021‐00065, Paper 24, 8; IPR2021‐00066,
`Paper 25, 11.
`
`30
`
`Ex.1046, p. 30 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0013
`
`
`
`Dr. Condon Did Not Review Becker or Spencer
`
`IPR2020‐01573, Ex.1041, 91:9‐11, 132:20‐22; IPR2020‐01711, Ex.1041, 91:9‐
`11, 132:20‐22; IPR2021‐00017, Ex.1041, 91:9‐11, 132:20‐22; IPR2021‐00065,
`Ex.1041, 91:9‐11, 132:20‐22; IPR2021‐00066, Ex.1041, 91:9‐11, 132:20‐22.
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`31
`
`Ex.1046, p. 31 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0014
`
`
`
`Dr. Netland’s Testing Confirms Quintana Obtained
`“Strips” of TM
`
`Ex.1030, ¶17‐26; Ex.1031‐1033; see IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 13‐14; IPR2020‐
`01711, Paper 27, 11‐13; IPR2021‐00017, Paper 26, 12‐14; IPR2021‐00065, Paper
`24, 12‐14; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 14‐16.
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`35
`
`Ex.1046, p. 35 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0015
`
`
`
`Patent Owner Reimagines Quintana
`
`• Dr. Condon admits Quintana’s procedure could leave TM on needle
`tip thereby admitting removal of TM
`• Patent Owner wrongly equates Quintana’s use of terms “section” and
`“stripping” with “incising” or “opening”
`• Quintana’s “key concern” was improving on prior techniques that
`failed due to reclosure of incision (and Patent Owner ignores Spencer
`and Becker)
`
`IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 13.
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`36
`
`Ex.1046, p. 36 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0016
`
`
`
`Patent Owner Offers No Definition of “Stripping”
`Because It Means “Removing”
`
`Ex.1037, 2; see IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 11; IPR2020‐01711,
`Paper 27, 10; IPR2021‐00017, Paper 26, 10‐11; IPR2021‐00065,
`Paper 24, 10‐11; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 13.
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`Ex.1038, 1; see IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 11; IPR2020‐01711,
`Paper 27, 10; IPR2021‐00017, Paper 26, 10‐11; IPR2021‐00065,
`Paper 24, 10‐11; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 13.
`42
`
`Ex.1046, p. 42 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0017
`
`
`
`Dr. Condon’s Testimony and Annotated Figure
`Demonstrate Quintana’s Needle Has Two Cutting
`Parts and Thus Meets the Board’s Constructions
`
`Ex.1043, 192; see IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 17‐18; IPR2020‐
`01711, Paper 27, 15; IPR2021‐00017, Paper 26, 16; IPR2021‐
`00065, Paper 24, 16‐17; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 18.
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`50
`
`Ex.1046, p. 50 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0018
`
`
`
`Dr. Condon’s Testimony and Annotated Figure
`Demonstrate Quintana’s Needle Has Two Cutting
`Parts and Thus Meets the Board’s Constructions
`• “dual blade device”
`• “dual refers to two, and
`blade in context, refers to a
`cutting part”(IPR2020‐01573, Paper
`22, 17)
`• “knife blades”
`• “knife refers to a cutting
`instrument, and blades, in
`context, refers to plural
`cutting parts”(IPR2020‐00065,
`Paper 11, 16)
`
`Ex.1043, 192; see IPR2020‐01573, Paper 35, 17‐18; IPR2020‐
`01711, Paper 27, 15; IPR2021‐00017, Paper 26, 16; IPR2021‐
`00065, Paper 24, 16‐17; IPR2021‐00066, Paper 25, 18.
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`51
`
`Ex.1046, p. 51 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0019
`
`
`
`Dr. Condon Testifies Patent Provides No Indication
`How to Measure Bluntness or Sharpness
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`70
`
`IPR2020-01711, Ex.1042, 281:5-282:9 (see Paper 27, 20 n.9).
`
`Ex.1046, p. 70 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0020
`
`
`
`Petitioner Has Shown By Preponderance of the
`Evidence That the Challenged Claims of the ‘729,
`‘155, ‘885, 905, and ‘544 Patents Are Unpatentable
`
`Petitioner’s Evidence
`• Quintana
`• Jacobi
`• Dr. Netland
`• Testing
`
`Patent Owner’s Evidence
`• Quintana’s Affidavit
`
`• Dr. Condon
`
`Petitioner New World Medical, Inc., IPR Nos. 2020‐01573,
`2020‐01711, 2021‐00017, 2021‐00065, 2021‐00066
`DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT – NOT EVIDENCE
`
`92
`
`Ex.1046, p. 92 of 98
`
`Patent Owner Ex. 2035-0021
`
`