(-
`
`C
`
`i compass.dooketnavigatortomfipatentfbinderf—“JICI
`
`a.
`
`{T O 8 o
`
` l Robins Hap-Ian LLP fl Westlaw fie Lee-see
`
`fig Docketi‘xautgator
`
`L][ FFIE
`
`L][ FRCF' G Eeegte Patents 6 Spotify as Practical Law at Robins Kaplah:Prac... @ Icrtt Relativity m i-otsl'tot
`
`.;:. Documents Search
`
`EH Ado Haw Tan-
`Tattle ot-Contenu
`
`Doom-ants Search
`
`a New Fame
`
`Documents Fllters
`
`t Htoa
`
`Types orancument
`Mot-on to Stay T-“enoing
`Eeexat11=tatxttn
`
`moton to Sta}.- T—‘teno .ng Inte '
`Partes FE" 9"“
`
`Moton E SE? Deno Eng CEIM
`I
`Re"lew
`
`Judges
`Patrlotc J. Scnl.‘t:
`
`“ti-TEPS
`'"'
`FEE .
`"”
`Q
`
`DnlNT
`
`'erw
`SPFCNS
`Ir
`T-oa oI'DIu-net't
`1'
`wales to s:ayI=e*<1=1g=v-tet Panes Pet-less
`
`is; of 3.___.=C fig:
`_ Fat-.ors CT; firm
`L Simplification of Issues
`
`Result 3w :-tlon
`
`Case
`
`Doc umerrts Search
`
`ZETEIE'IZI In FE'. gra r-teo In FIE—L
`
`.
`..-
`-
`. Tr-.
`LED-1N?”— :. t" -.
`:
`T'l '
`‘3
`' "" 31959 '
`'
`
`: .t-s :'
`
`..'.
`
`t-'
`
`Date
`
`Bee. as. zero
`
`7 nee-J ts
`_I
`'-
`E is: 4
`
`The court grantee #- start o aint ‘rs Ttotlot' '.|'.‘ :a'gr Its oeslaratoy' rec-'et' acoon peno'tvg a tnlra oa-te's oetIth for threes-tomes rarest hesat. sa- the pots-"tie: s'-TI_:—'1'katlon o1' ssoes TB'HI'EC- a partal stay. '{Lt tt'ro sang; fed 13 aetmons for itser panes res-lets o'a nxa'rzer IJT:IJE¢Endi’ft'Ef;I3tE’-1I:'alfls.II'II:||.|I:II"1§. all out two o‘IIhe dealers at save In t' 's :a se.
`-‘t w- oespeno oontesr: sa-es ofIts jettuseoj Catheter ourlng tne |:IenI:Ie“t::.l or he stay aao wane eat-emits rema'r'lng Ines-Jetty cerersas tjotn'loss'tess ano E"'JEIF|E-UIIII'II.I"JI..E smafiylng t'te traI. -C--.'er these contesslons.t'te Court IInos that a 5E3! urml sac" Ilme as see [PTAEE oetloes weather-to Inst'tute-‘es'ett- on :t'tej petttons Is tta'rarteo.’
`
`..F'aIn'JI'r; states that -t the Court game a stay.
`
`fi‘filfi" 1|: 51E? F‘E"-E‘"g i"tE' Panes REVIEW
`
`G'anreo
`
`. '.'---
`'
`.'
`'
`.
`.'.-
`o-‘a-e-x—oao-os taste.
`
`'
`
`-
`
`'-.'- ._
`" .= t-:
`{I-"-I:'.'-I}"-:I?5 twat
`
`._ '. e.
`
`:-
`
`:5es
`
`.-
`
`.
`
`'=.
`
`.=--
`
`:
`
`+1
`
`5
`
`FIE-III. I35. 3-315
`
`Fee. 25. lot-d
`
`E r
`I
`
`E j.
`HI
`
`EDIT HLTERS
`
`I:
`
`mono- to Stay Pet'ta‘ttg {Etta Fhe-I-1e.'.-
`-. E
`-
`'
`..
`
`- Fat-.ors C3";r oereo
`
`G'anteo
`
`RIEIIEICECI FHtEFS
`
`" “5'51”? CIT-V 01"?"
`r Jteas-It oI' Droer
`I
`-_ega I: sue
`
`I _'_-oges
`I Court-1
`
`it :tocume-t F||'-"g state
`I C 35-:- F: ”19 Date
`' C a” 5‘51”:
`I Quezon-e
`,
`e; 3595 we" .33.; ”um Type
`
`L Prejudice Froan Stag-Tactical Advantage
`Eta,- o’ ate-:5: 'gs
`- Facor: L's-s :ereo
`'- Ft-edustion of Litigation Burden
`RE'I: of: -----c 'gs
`
`- Platters Co'sse-teo
`
`Srmplrficatron of Issues
`‘31:" o'J-I' :: ' s
`_ Far”, ,1?er
`L 5139B {If Litigation
`
`.T’te wsmess met-too'tr'at -s the s.t:jer_t otthe {patients} :ar' oa ss'rrtsac to as
`The court grant-es oefer'oants rt'ot'o-n to stay pe'ctng CBII': rat.I aw t:eI:ause1:'-e poter-tle 5'-‘l'l'.'.‘5'fl:E|'|J|:|'l or =ss..«es stage otthe case as»: at urcse promote. a'to 'eoun'or :rrthe omen or I‘lIgation taweo a stay. 'Elnoe the oeg=trlng otthls oasetne Court "as has grate ooehts a’xut tr'e 'eallolty ot[o alrm‘!‘ s; D3!E""£..
`. Ste." =-" the st-Ike'y awe-T. that t"e HTAS does not the that any :Iairr' .'.- watlotne F'TeEI's :tIetIsIon MI ."eoert'taless s-I'I'ttlh‘j the tssses. I!- teat-“Joner Ir- a car-I res-law's amp-pen 1'.'-:rr- asserting. 'n the :E'arlot 11-}!th any.t-.'allolt,' a'gur'Ient that. was ra'sec " a cat-'- [E's'IE'J-I c-‘oteeolng t'at 'e-saIta-o 'r a ‘InaI writta-n oss's'o'.
`to. ones: He? lets use a :ornptrte' to do 'JIEs'. .
`.Flnally. It Is amt totlng t'tet
`'J'IE' Suntan-e Coon nas resenhy g-anteo certlora-I -- ‘.'-.'.'II:| cases that ate tete-e'arttto t-t.'-s I-‘tlga‘fion.
`ato it h" I E taunt. to has-e tte :t-enettt ot the 5upre-na- Cesrt's oec:s'o.-s '4 these cases“
`Stay of D'C’ZE‘EI
`'gs
`- Facors terse-eta:
`
`'- Prejudice From Stays-Tammi advantage
`The oo-s-rt grantee oe'eraants recto-H to stay- pe'to-"g CBII-t rare-2. e-I: telecteo ruler-tars cla'nt of snoue pre,t.o|-:e."-" [o-alnte‘l'sj wCr'C'Z. joefenoantj '“ecgeo :ts bets' :1.- proceecsitsg-Jeit“ Escort-tat,- etren atte'trrln; IIsCSI-I reelew c-etrton. a'-1.-e '.'.“'- ante-Eng fin t'e :IsIntIon of sea-slag a stag. T'te Coun 's .z'taheturttisse'rI nets-tel: 'sa'n'alrto fola‘rt’tfj. {In}l names was are heltg :uEC for
`'nttngeme-t-t [or who haoeoe-en margeowrtr 'r‘t'ttgentenrt 113}' see; ICEIt'It-t
`'E'1"E".-'J. T--:—.-etc-e -'t
`-.-.-' aintest a ways oe true t-tat I’EE pE'Iy seeing. car-I resIeI-e 'r'tll” be Insert-en: In Iit'gataa".
`.
`. To [meter-unts; reort. Ito": DC“. seek a sta3.I urfi1itr‘te P'TtEIE gratteo reelet-r— aeo. as seen as retiree. -.-.-asgtan1:eo. [nets-"cam: smgnt a stay. es-e' t-ou -. acne-:5 tase wettest ate-.s-oagrsoo see 1toe.- stateo at the
`war-cmat "earl-'1; is fat as Ihe Corals CD."CE""EI:|. [IIIE'I'EI‘IJBTf cit: EM'E'yfl'lll'tg r.g."t.‘
`
`.‘t-‘ctior to tag Patti-1g Rte-exarn'qt o'!
`:
`3 str :t C as: F-:':-:C-El'.-'a- Iss _es
`- Start or Fra:ees “gs
`'- Condit‘ons oi Stay
`:- str-ct C :- -. Frateou'al Iss ,es
`- Ettay of Fr:-:ee:- 'gs
`'- LiFt of Stay
`The court oatieo aaintm's I'FCI'II'D" to rr'ootty tretertns ot a s'.a'_tI pend 'g 'eetea'rfnato-n ate: proceee'rgs'or one otthreeeate. -'.5 were -:t '4: ..oeo fiatrer than FY‘IZI'F‘I; to III". t'I-e stages. [zealntmj asIthe Court to Irrpose t-‘arlo..s :ond'L'GI'IS rot guesIIonaz- o agate: or oet'enoants teamenoe the'-' oertat-Ior name the P111. . .Tt-s Cosrt ones not act asa 'naglst'ate gorge *ortr-e P'Tots-a Counts-I not
`manage proceeolngs before t'e F‘TCI. not MII the Coort 'tnaose :ono'tlons tt-at are.to some est-ea. orosoectoe -.:I-s:otner_-.l sartnserts related to the tease-rt raron proceeolngs'
`
`Jet 21.231:
`
`E y-
`HI
`
`3-:—"Ieo
`
`:
`-
`u". ": '. ":
`o-oa-n-oostz :EIhIHI-
`
`s
`
`:
`
`-.
`
`-'
`
`.‘t-‘ctior to tag Feta-1g aaettarn'mt o':
`
`I:
`
`Wars-- 1-: Sta, Ila-tang aeeaa-n "ate-
`
`
`Ste" o' 2"-:-:=r 'gs
`- Fsotors Co's-terse
`
`G'an'.eo
`
`De-Ileo
`
`:
`-
`--'; ": '. ":
`o-oa-:.--oos'.2 :EIhIHI-
`
`.= -
`.
`.'
`:
`-
`'
`t. ..
`mace-oars! tat-IN:
`
`r.
`
`-'
`
`s
`
`.
`
`:
`
`:
`
`:
`
`JuI.15.J_-:I:IEI
`
`Jun C-E aaoa
`
`E a-
`“I
`
`E I,
`NE
`
`'- Likelihood 0f Sucoess [Stay]
`‘fhe Tan: tr'at joetenoat'tj has asItec the PTO b: teeten'ne [a-"e ort'te oetet'rE-In-seit; proves notrtng arrest the oatet't's gualtty and: s t"ere‘rs*te nota su‘rr'ent reasonto grant a say Afy'WE can as-r mat a hater: he teezafinedn'e rhere 'a-:t that a "man: “as asteot'e PTO to reesamlne a eater't does not neantrat the patent 's I'r:el,'to he fosno Int-am. E23: :ontraz. w .1'.I'IE' FTC grans a
`reesarrr'ttefion reque:.th=s means that the 3T0 has :Iaer'nltec :hEEt'E ties-..est also: 'a SUD-SETH "aw questIon of oate'taasttn,‘ est-.h r_ ape-:ttothe :hatlengeo patent calrtts.
`..Irt-e PTO grants {oerenoa.'ts'_ PIC—CRE'II"-3'ED" 'eguesttslt'I respect to the [teatent-Inss't atlssetej. [oarercantj 'nar'then move.
`9::- a stat- penot'g 'eeaemlflaiy"
`
`Elnoer
`nge
`
`'natIoe
`
`_
`.
`C] Other titer orat-ter by derauft
`
`II
`
`:-
`
`rt-‘ai
`
`:- to tag Feta-1g Reaam't'at o':
`
`G'an'.eo
`
`: "'-;--- s
`-
`-':. ": '. ":
`CI-[IB-C'JEIEE1 I151”:
`
`': t'
`
`not. 1.1308
`
`E r
`I
`
`
`-' 1g:
`is} o'Jt-
`- Factors C.- seer-e:
`'- F'rejetdice From Stag-Tactical Advantage
`51?} ETC-3E: 'gs
`Medtronic EXhibit 1493
`-Fs:tors Co's'sereo
`'- Sim lifitation of Issues
`'
`p
`He‘d-BITE. ”Uri” TCI 5H]? 3 CUE-”535C”: matter was gamed [WET 1371““; UDJECIW1M'IUI'IE oT‘J'Ie t""EE patents :5 n51." " ’EEFIE n'natlon. 'l1' the pat-aft Fat '5 '{I in TEEP'ETFIHE‘IIGI'I: IS in} I-miflt t5 [D'illTL-TE. not-fling FIFE'II'E'I'I'E [fl-Elm 'II'C‘I'I'I'I C'EFI'ISEII'IQ without JEJLKSEEE' IE- :lEmlll'itr 'E’E-fiel: 1G trat 33:9". 3'“: on‘ngmg El SEFIE‘.'ETE Eran ll'l's'lle'tlll'lg I:ll'l'zIt' [t'at patentf. 591C!" an aoo'oao'. HEIuiC maKEWFE
`
`v
`
`Page 1
`
`Medtronic Exhibit 1493
`
`