:2;25353
`
`4O@CA /G=I 1# /G>LECDN
`
`Xzrrfw~
`
`3M NDA FO@CA ARKALEAI?A@ EI K=NAIN GENEC=NEJI.
`
`Hfxjx%g~%^jfw
`
`5633
`
`4;73
`
`46;3
`
`<53
`
`793
`
`3
`
`&(
`%
`
`%$
`&
`
`%*’
`
`&,
`
`&$$,
`
`&$$-
`
`&$%$
`
`&$%%
`
`&$%&
`
`&$%’
`
`&$%(
`
`&$%)
`
`&$%*
`
`&$%+
`
`&$%,
`
`&$%-
`
`<:1
`
`Fxxnlsji%Hfxjx
`
`Fhhzxfyntsx%ns%Fxxnlsji%Hfxjx
`
`:DEM ?D=LN @EMKG=SM NDA IOH>AL JB 8=NAIN 0=MAM =MMECIA@ NJ NDA MAGA?NA@ FO@CA >=MA@ JI NDA TGEIC @=NA JB NDA
`?JHKG=EIN" =M QAGG =M NDA IOH>AL JB 8=NAIN /??OM=NEJIM EI NDJMA ?=MAM#
`
`Mxgjh#Dodq#G1#Doeuljkw
`
`%,-$
`
`%’$&
`
`($$
`
`&(,
`
`G~%Ymj%Szrgjwx
`
`Wjrjinjx
`
`2ECD
`
`5JQ
`
`/PAL=CA
`
`Nsozshyntsx
`
`8LAGEHEI=LS 3IFOI?NEJIM
`
`8ALH=IAIN 3IFOI?NEJIM
`
`:AHKJL=LS 9AMNL=EIEIC 7L@ALM
`
`!%%"(,,",+&
`
`!)"()+
`
`!+"),*",-%
`
`$
`
`)
`
`$
`
`’%+
`
`’
`
`&
`
`&&
`
`&
`
`$
`
`*
`
`Hqfnr%Htsxywzhyntsx
`
`0G=EH 0JIMNLO?NEJIM
`
`Ijyjwrnsfyntsx
`
`3IBLEICA@
`
`6JN OIAIBJL?A=>GA
`
`6JN EIP=GE@
`
`6JN EIBLEICA@
`
`;IAIBJL?A=>GA
`
`3IP=GE@
`
`kwwsv=22vhdufk1grfnhwqdyljdwru1frp2sdwhqw2mxgjh249<9423Bsulqw@wuxh
`
`DISH Ex. 1022, p. 1
` DISH v. BBiTV
` IPR2020-01280
`
`429
`
`

`

`:2;25353
`
`3RADB *I>K -& *I?OFDEQ
`
`Mxgjh#Dodq#G1#Doeuljkw
`
`<E>Q QUMBP LC M>QBKQ @>PBP ALBP QEB
`
`GRADB AB@FAB)
`
`%12 $&5)05))4
`
`%12 $&5)05 ",&..)0+)34
`
`%12 $&5)05 ".&44-7(&5-104
`
`<97; 2KSBPQJBKQP 44, A’?’> +O>VLP 4F@BKPFKD >KA -BSBIL
`
`18 2K@& C’H’> 1BTIBQQ%8>@H>OA ,LJM>KU
`
`:O>KPJFPPFLK 7C -FDFQ>I 2KCLOJ>QFLK$ .&D& :BIBDO>MEF@ ,LJJR
`
`0IL?>I/LRKAOFBP ;9 2K@&
`
`-BII :B@EKLILDFBP 2K@&
`
`.IB@QOF@ -FDFQ>I ->Q> 8OL@BPPFKD
`
`7<=
`
`=;
`
`797
`
`768
`
`6BLAOLK 4QA&
`
`+BII 9BJF@LKAR@QLO$ 44,
`
`<;
`
`->Q> 9@>MB 4FJFQBA
`
`<8
`
`755
`
`6=9
`
`9>JPRKD .IB@QOLKF@P *JBOF@>$ 2K@&
`
`9>JPRKD .IB@QOLKF@P ,L&$ 4QA&
`
`<<
`
`<8
`
`<7
`
`->Q> 8OL@BPPFKD 9UPQBJP 7O 5BQELAP$ 9MB@F>IIU *A>MQBA /L
`
`67=
`
`<FOBIBPP ,LJJRKF@>QFLK 6BQTLOHP
`
`>>
`
`*J>VLK&@LJ$ 2K@&
`
`:BIBMELKF@ ,LJJRKF@>QFLK
`
`;;
`
`;=
`
`1>JJLKA -BSBILMJBKQ 2KQBOK>QFLK>I$ 2K@&
`
`6=8 ;9*$ 2K@& C’H’> 6=8 9BJF@LKAR@QLOP ;9*$ 2K@&
`
`8F@QLOF>I ,LJJRKF@>QFLK$ .&D& :BIBSFPFLK
`
`<7
`
`*JBOF@>K 8>QBKQP 44,
`
`<6
`
`9IFKDPELQ 8OFKQFKD 44,
`
`;8
`
`4!4 ,>KAIB ,LJM>KU 44,
`
`;5
`
`9LQBO> :P@EBQQBO$ 2K@&
`
`;5
`
`-BII 2K@&
`
`5BAF>:BH 2K@&
`
`5BAF>:BH ;9* 2K@&
`
`:;
`
`:;
`
`:;
`
`;6
`
`;6
`
`9BJF@LKAR@QLO -BSF@BP ( .IB@QOF@ 9LIFA 9Q>QB -BSF@BP 6LQ 7
`
`:7
`
`:O>KPJFPPFLK
`
`9<
`
`8RIPB :B@EKFNRB
`
`87
`
`.5, ,LOMLO>QFLK
`
`,LFK%/OBBA 7O 4FHB *MM>O>QRP
`
`:8
`
`7>
`
`#6/’)3 1* !((64&5-104
`
`#6/’)3 1* !((64&5-104
`
`#6/’)3 1* "&4)4
`
`:EFP @E>OQ AFPMI>UP QEB QLM M>OQFBP >PPBOQFKD M>QBKQ
`FKCOFKDBJBKQ @I>FJP "LO TEL E>SB ABCBKABA >D>FKPQ
`@I>FJP LC M>QBKQ FKS>IFAFQU$ RKBKCLO@B>?FIFQU LO
`RKM>QBKQ>?FIFQU# FK @>PBP >PPFDKBA QL QEB PBIB@QBA GRADB$
`O>KHBA ?U KRJ?BO LC 8>QBKQ *@@RP>QFLKP&
`
`:EFP @E>OQ AFPMI>UP QEB QLM M>OQFBP >@@RPBA LC M>QBKQ
`FKCOFKDBJBKQ "LO TEL E>SB >PPBOQBA @I>FJP LC M>QBKQ
`FKS>IFAFQU$ RKBKCLO@B>?FIFQU LO RKM>QBKQ>?FIFQU# FK @>PBP
`>PPFDKBA QL QEB PBIB@QBA GRADB$ O>KHBA ?U KRJ?BO LC
`8>QBKQ *@@RP>QFLKP&
`
`:EFP @E>OQ PELTP QEB QLM ,I>PPFW@>QFLKP CLO M>QBKQP FK
`@>PBP >PPFDKBA QL QEB PBIB@QBA GRADB O>KHBA ?U KRJ?BO
`LC @>PBP&
`
`kwwsv=22vhdufk1grfnhwqdyljdwru1frp2sdwhqw2mxgjh249<9423Bsulqw@wuxh
`
`DISH Ex. 1022, p. 2
` DISH v. BBiTV
` IPR2020-01280
`
`529
`
`

`

`7l8l2020
`
`Judge Alan D. Albright
`
`Judge Alan D. Albright
`
`@DocketNavigator
`
`How quickly does the judge process cases?
`
`Time to Milestones
`
`I Claim Construction
`I Pate ntee Decisions
`PETEHTEE MSJ
`
`Infringement
`
`*
`
`I O
`
`.
`
`Patent not invalid —
`Patent enforceable
`0
`
`Patent Challenger Decisions
`Patent Challenger MSJ
`Noninfringement
`
`Patent invalid
`Remedies
`
`Damages
`InchOngoing Royalty
`Enhncd Damfmty Fees
`Sa n cti o n s
`
`I Trials
`Be nc h Trial
`
`O
`
`o
`
`.-
`
`.
`
`O
`
`0*
`.0-
`0
`
`0
`
`| Transters & Stays
`Transfer
`
`—
`Stay —
`| Termination
`Likely Settlement
`
`*
`Mature Termination *
`
`1yr
`
`2yr
`
`3yr
`
`4w
`
`This chart shows the average and median times to reach key litigation Milgfitgngfi in F’QLQHL Qgsgfi assigned to the selected judge. Each colored horizontal line {called a “box
`plot") shows the time between the filing of the complaint and the named milestone. The left and right ends of the box labeled 50% are respectively the first— and third—quartiles.
`The lighter line shows events between the 2nd and 98th percentile. The remaining points are outliers. represent at most 4% of the data. and are not shown. However. the true
`minimum and maximum are included in the accompanying table and the mean includes outliers. Fewer than ten events occurring in a category are shown as dots instead of a box
`plot.
`
`Median
`average
`1—-50%;
`
`https:llsearohoocketnavig atonoomlpaten tljudg BM 6961 l0?print=true
`
`DISH Ex. 1022, p. 3
`DISH v. BBiTV
`
`|PR2020-01280
`
`3l6
`
`

`

`7i8i2020
`
`Judge Alan D. Albright
`
`
`
`Judge Alan D. sleight @ Docket N avigato r
`
`How quickly does the judge decide motions?
`
`Motion Pendency
`
`I Claim Construction Order [Markman]
`
`I Motion to Transfer Venue for Convenience (23 USC §1404ian
`
`I Motion to Stay Pending Inter Partes Review
`I
`
`Q
`
`I
`
`o
`
`I Motion to Dismiss - Failure to State a Claim [FRCP 12lb}{6))
`
`I Motion to Transfer for improper Venue {23 USC §1406{a)}
`
`1m
`
`2m
`
`3m
`
`4m
`
`5m
`
`5m
`
`'i’m
`
`Sm
`
`This chart shows how quickly the selected judge issues specific types of decisions. Each colored horizontal line [called a “boo: plot”) shows the average and median number of
`days between the filling ofo motion and issuance of a decision on the motion. For claim construction Workman]: orders‘ the box plot shows the average and median number
`of days between a claim construction hearing and issuance of o cioim construction order. The left and right ends of the box labeled 50% are respectively the first- and third-
`quartiles. The lighter line shows events between the 2nd and 98th percentile. The remaining points are outliers. represent at most 4% of the data, and are not shown. Fewer than
`ten motion rulings are shown as dots instead of a boot plot.
`
`Median
`Average
`-_'_'-50%g
`
`https:iisearch.docketnavigatorcomipatentijudgefl6961i0?print=true
`
`DISH Ex. 1022, p. 4
`DISH v. BBiTV
`
`|PR2020-01280
`
`4i6
`
`

`

`:2;25353
`
`.J;>< &B8D )! &B9G@>?I
`
`Mxgjh#Dodq#G1#Doeuljkw
`
`,EL ;E I?< AJ;><NH ;<I<GC@D8I@EDH
`
`:ECF8G< L@I? EI?<G AJ;><H%
`
`Fqfs%I3%Fqgwnlmy%Ijyjwrnsfyntsx
`
`\IY]%Ijyjwrnsfyntsx
`
`Ijyjwrnsfyntsx%ns%fqq%Inxywnhy%Htzwyx
`
`++"(/
`
`7<G;@:I
`
`04.
`
`1I?<G
`
`6
`
`6
`
`++"(/
`
`6
`
`7<G;@:I
`
`8
`
`858
`
`757
`
`8>>
`
`6:5 ;; 6=5
`
`++"(/
`
`7<G;@:I
`
`67
`
`66
`
`6:
`
`>
`
`8
`
`:
`
`=7<
`
`=>6
`
`:9<
`
`79<
`
`7
`
`7
`
`7
`
`<
`
`69
`
`6:
`
`:6; 8=5
`
`65=5
`
`785:
`
`666=
`
`04.
`
`04.
`
`6=
`
`9
`
`6;
`
`68
`
`:<
`
`>
`
`:7
`
`7796
`
`<8<
`
`8868
`
`698=
`
`78:9
`
`1I?<G
`
`1I?<G
`
`Nskwnslji
`
`Sty%zsjsktwhjfgqj
`
`Sty%ns{fqni
`
`Nskwnslji
`
`Sty%zsjsktwhjfgqj
`
`Sty%ns{fqni
`
`Nskwnslji
`
`Sty%zsjsktwhjfgqj
`
`Sty%ns{fqni
`
`Sty%nskwnslji
`
`Zsjsktwhjfgqj
`
`Ns{fqni
`
`Sty%nskwnslji
`
`Zsjsktwhjfgqj
`
`Ns{fqni
`
`Sty%nskwnslji
`
`Zsjsktwhjfgqj
`
`Ns{fqni
`
`5?@H :?8GI H?ELH 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH @D :8H<H
`8HH@>D<; IE I?< H<B<:I<; AJ;>< 98H<; ED I?< HI8>< E= I?<
`FGE:<<;@D> 8I I?< I@C< E= I?< 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@ED! *8:?
`:EBEG<; B@D< G<FG<H<DIH I?< 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH
`G<D;<G<; @D 8 HF<:@Q: IMF< E= FGE:<<;@D>! O++(/P H?ELH
`28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;< @D +3(2 $# +@D;@D>H E= +8:I
`8D; (ED:BJH@EDH E= /8L =EBBEL@D> 9<D:? IG@8BH! O7<G;@:IP
`H?ELH 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;< @D AJGM K<G;@:IH!
`O04.P H?ELH 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;< @D 4JCC8GM
`.J;>C<DI EG;<GH! O1I?<GP @D:BJ;<H 28I<DI
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH G<D;<G<; @D 8BB EI?<G IMF<H E= :EJGI
`;E:JC<DIH! ’BJ< H?8;<H G<FG<H<DI 28I<DI
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG 28I<DI<<H! 3<; H?8;<H
`G<FG<H<DI 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG 28I<DI
`(?8BB<D><GH!
`
`5?@H :?8GI H?ELH 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH @D :8H<H QB<; @D
`I?< H<B<:I<; AJ;><NH ?EC< :EJGI EG 8><D:M 98H<; ED I?<
`HI8>< E= I?< FGE:<<;@D> 8I I?< I@C< E= I?< 28I<DI
`)<I<GC@D8I@ED! *8:? :EBEG<; B@D< G<FG<H<DIH I?< 28I<DI
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH G<D;<G<; @D 8 HF<:@Q: IMF< E=
`FGE:<<;@D>! O++(/P H?ELH 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;<
`@D +3(2 $# +@D;@D>H E= +8:I 8D; (ED:BJH@EDH E= /8L
`=EBBEL@D> 9<D:? IG@8BH! O7<G;@:IP H?ELH 28I<DI
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;< @D AJGM K<G;@:IH! O04.P H?ELH
`28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;< @D 4JCC8GM .J;>C<DI
`EG;<GH! O1I?<GP @D:BJ;<H 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH G<D;<G<;
`@D 8BB EI?<G IMF<H E= :EJGI ;E:JC<DIH! ’BJ< H?8;<H
`G<FG<H<DI 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG 28I<DI<<H!
`3<; H?8;<H G<FG<H<DI 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG
`28I<DI (?8BB<D><GH!
`
`5?@H :?8GI H?ELH 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH @D :8H<H QB<; @D
`8DM 6D@I<; 4I8I<H )@HIG@:I (EJGI EG I?< (EJGI E= +<;<G8B
`(B8@CH 98H<; ED I?< HI8>< E= I?< FGE:<<;@D> 8I I?< I@C<
`E= I?< 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@ED! *8:? :EBEG<; B@D< G<FG<H<DIH
`I?< 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH G<D;<G<; @D 8 HF<:@Q: IMF< E=
`FGE:<<;@D>! O++(/P H?ELH 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;<
`@D +3(2 $# +@D;@D>H E= +8:I 8D; (ED:BJH@EDH E= /8L
`=EBBEL@D> 9<D:? IG@8BH! O7<G;@:IP H?ELH 28I<DI
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;< @D AJGM K<G;@:IH! O04.P H?ELH
`28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH C8;< @D 4JCC8GM .J;>C<DI
`EG;<GH! O1I?<GP @D:BJ;<H 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH G<D;<G<;
`@D 8BB EI?<G IMF<H E= :EJGI ;E:JC<DIH! ’BJ< H?8;<H
`G<FG<H<DI 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG 28I<DI<<H!
`3<; H?8;<H G<FG<H<DI 28I<DI )<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG
`28I<DI (?8BB<D><GH!
`
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG 28I<DI<<H
`
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG 28I<DI<<H
`
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG 28I<DI<<H
`
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG &::JH<; -D=G@D><GH
`
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG &::JH<; -D=G@D><GH
`
`)<I<GC@D8I@EDH I?8I =8KEG &::JH<; -D=G@D><GH
`
`kwwsv=22vhdufk1grfnhwqdyljdwru1frp2sdwhqw2mxgjh249<9423Bsulqw@wuxh
`
`DISH Ex. 1022, p. 5
` DISH v. BBiTV
` IPR2020-01280
`
`829
`
`

`

`7i8f2020
`
`Judge Alan D. Albright
`
`Judge Alan D. Albright
`@DocketNavigator
`
`
`Does the court tend to find
`
`Does the court tend to find
`
`patents invalid?
`
`patents infringed?
`
`Patents with Invalidity
`Determinations for Alan D. Albright
`
`Patents with Invalidity
`Determinations in WDTX
`
`Patents with Infringement
`Determinations for Alan D. Albright
`
`Patents with Infringement
`Determinations in WDTX
`
`All
`Asserted -
`Patent;
`99.24%
`
`526
`
`_ Invalid
`036%
`
`Asserted
`All ‘
`Patents
`911496
`
`1,608
`
`Invalid
`d 2.85%
`
`All
`Asserted -
`Patents
`99.62%
`
`526
`
`Infringed
`_ 0.33%
`
`a
`Assened _
`Patents
`98.51%
`
`1,608 —-
`
`lnfringed
`131%
`
`I All Assertecl Patents I Invalid
`
`IAII Asserted Patents I Invalid
`
`I All Asserted Patents
`I Infringed
`
`I All Asse rted Patents
`I lnfring ed
`
`This chart shows the proponion of patents
`before this judge with Patent
`Determinations of invalidity. The number
`in the center represents the total number
`of patents in cases before thisjudge. The
`colored segments highlight the proportion
`ofthose patents for which any claims
`were found invalid by this judge.
`
`This chart shows the percentage of
`patents in cases filed in the selected court
`that have at least one Determination of
`invalidity.
`
`This chart shows the proportion of patents
`before this judge with Patent
`Determinations of infringement. The
`number in the center represents the total
`number of patents in cases before this
`judge. The colored segments highlight the
`proportion ofthose patents for which any
`claims were found infringed by thisjudge.
`
`This chart shows the percentage of
`patents in cases filed in the selected court
`that have at least one Determination of
`infringement.
`
`How do the judge’s outcomes compare
`
`with otherjudges?
`
`Alan D. Albright Outcomes
`
`WDTX Outcomes
`
`National Outcomes
`
`Patent Challenger
`W9” \
`59.09 ‘
`
`Patentee Won
`
`“ 913935
`
`22
`
`Patent
`Challenger won I
`
`59.52%
`
`Patentee Won
`
`‘-' 7, 59%
`
`158
`
`Patent
`C ha ll eng er -.
`Won
`54.19%
`
`18,475
`
`\ Non-Merits Dismissal
`31.82%
`
`\ Non-Merits
`Dismissal
`22.28%
`
`Patentee Won
`183496
`
`\ Non-Merits Dismissal
`210%
`
`Non—Merits Dismissal
`I Patent Challenger Won I Patentee Won
`lSettled
`
`Non-Merits Dismissal
`I Patent Challenger Won I Patentee Won
`I Settled
`
`Non—Merits Dismissal
`I Patent Challenger Won I Patentee Won
`lSettled
`
`This chart shows Patent Aggiisajignsthat have
`Outcomes inW assigned to the selected
`judge. By default. the chart does not reflect Patent
`Accusations that were settled or voluntarily dismissed. or
`Patent Accusations that are still pending. See our Official
`mp3 to view the current date range that our Outcomes
`data covers.
`
`This chart shows Patent Ag; isgjigns that have
`Outcomes in Balm in the selected judge's home
`court. Ely default. the chart does not reflect Patent
`Accusations that were settled or voluntarily dismissed. or
`Patent Accusations that are still pending. See our Official
`Sflpfi to view the current date range that our Outcomes
`data covers.
`
`This chart shows Patent Agggsatignsthat have
`Outcomes in Balm in any federal district court.
`By default. the chart does not reflect Patent Accusations
`that were settled or voluntarily dismissed. or Patent
`Accusations that are still pending. See our Official
`mpg to view the current date range that our Outcomes
`data covers.
`
`https:iisearch.docketnavigator.oomi'patentijudgeir 16961i0?print=true
`
`DISH Ex. 1022, p. 6
`DISH v. BBiTV
`
`|PR2020-01280
`
`6f?)
`
`