`
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`_________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`_________________
`
`
`APPLE INC.,
`Petitioner
`
`v.
`
`LBT IP I LLC,
`Patent Owner
`_________________
`
`
`Inter Partes Review Case No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`
`
`
`
`PETITIONER APPLE INC.’S REPLY REMAND BRIEF
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`I.
`
`Introduction
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`The specification of the ’774 Patent describes two different embodiments that
`
`rely on two different “threshold values.” LBT’s entire brief focuses on the battery
`
`level embodiment, which is described at columns 11-13 (and which includes Figure
`
`4). Intentionally or otherwise, LBT completely ignores the GPS signal level
`
`embodiment described in columns 7-10. Ultimately, LBT’s argument does nothing
`
`to answer the Board’s question because the operation of the battery level
`
`embodiment is not in dispute between the parties. Instead, the dispute revolves
`
`around what to do with the GPS signal level embodiment disclosed in the portions
`
`of the specification that LBT ignores. The dispute is simply whether that
`
`embodiment is part of the claims or not. As discussed in the opening brief and below,
`
`the GPS signal level embodiment is absolutely part of the “multitude of threshold
`
`values” in claim 8. There is no limitation in the claims, or in the specification, that
`
`would compel a conclusion that excludes the GPS signal level embodiment.
`
`Moreover, LBT’s position runs the risk of violating fundamental legal principles of
`
`claim construction that may lead to further appellate issues. Because nothing in
`
`claim 8 limits its application to only the battery level embodiment, and because the
`
`language of claim 8 uses the broad and expansive “comprising” language, the Board
`
`must find that the “multitude of threshold values” includes both battery level and
`
`GPS signal level.
`
`
`
`1
`
`
`
`
`
`II. Argument
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`First, LBT’s argument divorces GPS signal levels from the “power level that
`
`is monitored and adjusted by the battery power level monitor.” Id. LBT advances
`
`the argument that “in context, the ‘multitude of threshold values’ can only be battery
`
`power level threshold values.” Id., 2-3. But this fundamentally ignores the operation
`
`of GPS receivers and the impact of a GPS signal level on the power level of the
`
`battery. Indeed, the inventors of the ’774 Patent realized that GPS signal levels are
`
`intimately tied together with a high drain on the power level of the battery:
`
`GPS satellite communication signals may be obstructed or partially
`blocked, hindering tracking and monitoring capability. Not only is a
`GPS transceiver receiving a weak GPS signal [e.g., a weak GPS signal
`level], but also the GPS transceiver is depleting battery power in failed
`attempts to acquire communication signals…
`’774 Patent, 3:2-8. Tellingly, LBT does not cite or discuss this portion of the
`
`specification in its brief.
`
`Second, LBT ignores the express embodiment that correlates GPS signal
`
`levels with the threshold value. LBT instead focuses solely on the Fig. 4 battery level
`
`embodiment. LBT provides pages and pages of argument and citations that solely
`
`discuss the battery level embodiment. But this discussion is unhelpful because it
`
`ignores the fact that the ’774 Patent discloses two embodiments that (allegedly) save
`
`power of the tracking device. The first is disclosed in column 7 where the inventors
`
`
`
`2
`
`
`
`
`note that the “designated [GPS] antennas, e.g., antennas 122a, 122b, detect[] a first
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`signal level, e.g., a low signal level or threshold value.”1 ’774 Patent, 7:55-59.
`
`Here, the inventors expressly and explicitly equate the GPS signal levels from the
`
`GPS antennas 122a/b with a “threshold value.” This portion of the specification
`
`completely refutes LBT’s arguments, which is likely why LBT ignored it. Because
`
`this embodiment was discussed extensively in Apple’s opening brief2 it will not be
`
`addressed further here except to note that it would be error to adopt a construction
`
`that reads out an embodiment of the specification. See, e.g., Pacing Techs., LLC v.
`
`Garmin Int'l, Inc., 778 F.3d 1021, 1026 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
`
`The third problem with LBT’s argument is that it ignores the claim language
`
`itself. Limitation 8d reads as follows:
`
`wherein the battery power level monitor measures a power level of the
`charging unit and adjusts a power level applied to location tracking
`circuitry responsive one or more signal levels, the power level
`comprising a multitude of threshold values determined by a user or
`system administrator to intermittently activate or deactivate the location
`tracking circuitry to conserve power of the charging unit in response to
`the estimated charge level of the charging unit.
`
`
`1 As noted in Apple’s opening brief, antennas 122a/b are the GPS antennas and, thus,
`can only be detecting a GPS signal level, not a battery level. Paper 43, Apple’s Claim
`Construction Brief, 1, 3-4.
`2 Paper 43, Apple’s Claim Construction Brief.
`
`
`
`3
`
`
`
`
`’774 Patent, Claim 8(d). As discussed above, and in Apple’s opening brief, there are
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`two specific embodiments disclosed in the ’774 Patent for the threshold values—one
`
`for the GPS signal level and one for the battery level. Paper 43, 6-7 (noting that
`
`“threshold value” is only used twice in the ’774 Patent, once for battery power level
`
`and once for GPS signal level). It would be reversible error to exclude one of these
`
`embodiments unless the claim language expressly limits it to one of these
`
`embodiments. Pacing Techs. 778 F.3d at 1026. Nothing in the claim limits it to the
`
`battery level embodiment.
`
`While LBT focuses its argument on the three words “the power level,” it
`
`ignores the term “comprising.” As the Board is well aware, “‘[c]omprising’ is a term
`
`of art used in claim language which means that the named elements are essential, but
`
`other elements may be added and still form a construct within the scope of the
`
`claim.” Genentech, Inc. v. Chiron Corp., 112 F.3d 495, 501 (Fed.Cir.1997). Because
`
`of the term “comprising,” LBT invites error by suggesting “the ‘multitude of
`
`threshold values’ can only be battery power level threshold values” because this
`
`conclusion violates black letter law on claim construction. In essence, LBT’s
`
`argument would replace the phrase “comprising” with “consisting,” which is
`
`improper in the absence of any evidence overriding the presumption that exists with
`
`the use of the phrase “comprising.” Crystal Semiconductor Corp. v. TriTech
`
`Microelectronics Intl’l, Inc., 246 F.3D 1336, 1362 (Fed. Cir. 2001) (“When a patent
`
`
`
`4
`
`
`
`
`claim uses the word “comprising” as its transitional phrase, the use of “comprising”
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`creates a presumption that the body of the claim is open.”) LBT has done nothing to
`
`show that this presumption should be overcome to otherwise limit or narrow the
`
`normal use of the phrase “comprising.” Thus, the “multitude of threshold values”
`
`may include the power level of a battery but the claim is not limited to only those
`
`power levels given its use of the term “comprising.” Here, because the specification
`
`specifically describes GPS signal levels as another “threshold value,” the use of the
`
`phrase “comprising” compels a conclusion that the “threshold values” in claim 8 are
`
`not limited to only battery levels.
`
`
`
`Finally, the claim language itself dictates a conclusion that “threshold values”
`
`include both embodiments described in the specification. Limitation 8(d) discusses
`
`a “power level monitor” that measures the power of a battery (e.g., the charging
`
`unit). The device of claim 8 then adjusts the power level that is applied to the GPS
`
`(e.g., the “location tracking circuitry”) in response to one or more signal levels. The
`
`claim then recites the power level includes, but is not limited to, a multitude of
`
`threshold values that are used to intermittently activate or deactivate the GPS
`
`circuitry to conserve power. Based on the broad, plain language used in claim 8, the
`
`claim is describing not only the battery level embodiment columns 11-13, as relied
`
`upon by LBT, but also the precise GPS signal embodiment from column 7 through
`
`column 10.
`
`
`
`5
`
`
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`In the GPS signal embodiment, the “antennas 122a, 122b, detect[] a first
`
`
`
`
`signal level, e.g., a low signal level or threshold value.” ’774 Patent, 7:55-58. In that
`
`instance, the power level monitor would detect that threshold value (e.g., the low
`
`signal level). The ’774 Patent states “electrical circuitry associated with GPS signal
`
`acquisition …. may be, for instance, placed on standby or in a sleep mode,”which is
`
`the “deactivat[ing] the location tracking circuity to conserve power” described in
`
`limitation 8(d). Compare ‘774 Patent, 7:60-62 with Claim 8. Another variant of this
`
`same embodiment is described at column 9 where “when GPS signaling is not
`
`practicable” (e.g., you have a threshold value that indicates a low GPS signal level),
`
`and “the transceiver circuitry (e.g., transceiver 102, location tracking circuitry 114,
`
`and signal processing circuitry 104) consumes reduced power for GPS circuitry
`
`while the electronic tracking device communicates displacement vectors” through
`
`use of the accelerometer. ’774 Patent, 9:5-17. Again, the ’774 Patent’s disclosures
`
`match the claim language from claim 8(d) perfectly where it describes a power level
`
`that includes, but is not limited to, a scenario where GPS signal levels are low and
`
`GPS circuitry is deactivated to conserve power. And, in yet another variation of this
`
`embodiment, the ’774 Patent describes “receiv[ing] communication signal of
`
`sufficient signal strength,” e.g., a threshold value showing strong GPS signal levels,
`
`at which point “location tracking circuitry 114 are activated” while the
`
`accelerometer circuitry is deactivated (which will conserve battery power by turning
`
`
`
`6
`
`
`
`
`of unnecessary and duplicative hardware components). ’774 Patent, 10:58-67. This
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`variation of the GPS signal level embodiment encompasses the portion of claim 8(d)
`
`that “intermittently activate[s] … the location tracking circuitry to conserve power.”
`
`Id., Claim 8(d).
`
`
`
`Because there is no language in the claim that would otherwise exclude, or
`
`read out, the GPS signal level embodiment, it would be error to exclude GPS signal
`
`levels from the threshold value. Thus, the Board should construe “multitude of
`
`threshold values” to include both GPS signal levels and battery levels.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`/s/ Adam P. Seitz
`Adam P. Seitz, Reg. No. 52,206
`adam.seitz@eriseip.com
`ERISE IP, P.A.
`7015 College Blvd, Suite 700
`Overland Park, KS 66211
`(913) 777-5600 Telephone
`(913) 777-5601 Facsimile
`
`COUNSEL FOR PETITIONER
`APPLE INC.
`
`
`
`Dated: September 20, 2023
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`7
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Inter Partes Review No. IPR2020-01189
`U.S. Patent No. 8,497,774
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ON PATENT OWNER
`UNDER 37 C.F.R. § 42.105
`
`Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.6(e) and 42.105, the undersigned certifies that on
`
`September 20, 2023, a complete and entire copy of Petitioner Apple Inc.’s Reply
`
`Remand Brief was served via electronic filing with the Board and via Electronic Mail
`
`on the following practitioners of record for Patent Owner:
`
`Shaun D. Gregory (sgregory@taftlaw.com)
`Brian S. Seal (bseal@taftlaw.com)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`/s/ Adam P. Seitz
`Adam P. Seitz, Reg. No. 52,206
`adam.seitz@eriseip.com
`ERISE IP, P.A.
`7015 College Blvd, Suite 700
`Overland Park, KS 66211
`(913) 777-5600 Telephone
`(913) 777-5601 Facsimile
`
`COUNSEL FOR PETITIONER
`APPLE INC.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`8
`
`