throbber
WPKVGF!UVCVGU!RCVGPV!CPF!VTCFGOCTM!QHHKEG!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`DGHQTG!VJG!RCVGPV!VTKCN!CPF!CRRGCN!DQCTF!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`CRRNG!KPE/!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`x/!
`
`WPKNQE!3128!NNE!
`
`Rcvgpv!Qypgt!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`KRT312;.11167!
`
`RCVGPV!7-578-199!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`RCVGPV!QYPGT!RTGNKOKPCT[!TGURQPUG!VQ!RGVKVKQP!
`
`RWTUWCPV!VQ!48!E/H/T/!'53/218)c*!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`OKETQUQHV!EQTR/!
`GZJKDKV!2122
`
`Rcig!2!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1112
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`
`Vcdng!qh!Eqpvgpvu!
`
`K/
`
`KK/
`
`KKK/
`
`KX/
`
`X/
`
`KPVTQFWEVKQP!////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!2
`
`VJG!”199!RCVGPV!//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!2
`
`TGNCVGF!RTQEGGFKPIU!////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!4
`
`NGXGN!QH!QTFKPCT[!UMKNN!KP!VJG!CTV!//////////////////////////////////////!4
`
`RGVKVKQPGT!FQGU!PQV!RTQXG!C!TGCUQPCDNG
`NKMGNKJQQF!QH!WPRCVGPVCDKNKV[!HQT!CP[
`EJCNNGPIGF!ENCKO!//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!5
`
`C/
`
`D/
`
`Encko!Eqpuvtwevkqp!/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!5
`
`Vjg!Crrnkgf!Tghgtgpegu!Hckn!vq!Fkuenqug
`•eqorct]]kpi_0]g__!vjg!fgvgtokpgf!eqorqpgpv!cpf
`kphqtocvkqp!urgekh{kpi!cv!ngcuv!qpg!cffkvkqpcn
`eqorqpgpv!ewttgpvn{!korngogpvgf!kp!vjg!gngevtqpke
`fgxkeg!ykvj!cv!ngcuv!qpg!qh!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp
`ceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!cpf
`]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt
`vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–!)Kpfgrgpfgpv!Enckou!2-!22-!cpf
`32*!///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!6
`
`2/
`
`3/
`
`Eqng!kp!xkgy!qh!OceKppku!cpf!Gnitguu{
`)Rgvkvkqpgt”u!Rtqrqugf!Itqwpf!2*!Hcknu!vq
`Fkuenqug!•‡ngcuv!qpg!qh!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp
`ceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke
`fgxkeg!cpf!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–!/////////////////////////////!7
`
`Rkv|gn!kp!xkgy!qh!Eqng!cpf!Gnitguu{!)Rgvkvkqpgt”u
`Rtqrqugf!Itqwpf!3*!Hcknu!vq!Fkuenqug!•‡ngcuv
`qpg!qh!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!ceegrvcdng
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!cpf
`]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–!///////////////////////////!21
`
`kk!
`
`Rcig!3!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1113
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`
`E/
`
`Vjg!Rgvkvkqp!hcknu!vq!Rtqxg!Qdxkqwupguu!qh!Cp{!
`Fgrgpfgpv!Encko!//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!26
`
`VJG!RGVKVKQP!TGFWPFCPVN[!EJCNNGPIGU!CNN!
`ENCKOU!)ENCKOU!2.32*!//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!26
`
`VJG!EQPUVKVWVKQPCNKV[!QH!KPVGT!RCTVGU!TGXKGY!
`KU!VJG!UWDLGEV!QH!C!RGPFKPI!CRRGCN!/////////////////////////////////////!29
`
`XK/
`
`XKK/
`
`XKKK/ EQPENWUKQP!///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////!29
`
`!
`
`!
`
`kkk!
`
`Rcig!4!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1114
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`
`K/
`
`KPVTQFWEVKQP
`
`Wpknqe! 3128! NNE! )•Wpknqe–! qt! •Rcvgpv! Qypgt–*! uwdokvu! vjku! Rtgnkokpct{
`
`Tgurqpug!vq!Rgvkvkqp!KRT312;.11167!hqt!Kpvgt!Rctvgu!Tgxkgy!)•Rgv/–!qt!•Rgvkvkqp–*!
`
`qh! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! Rcvgpv! Pq/! 7-578-199! )•vjg! ”199! rcvgpv–! qt! •GZ2112–*! hkngf! d{!
`
`Crrng-! Kpe/! )•Rgvkvkqpgt–*/! Vjg! kpuvcpv! Rgvkvkqp! ku! rtqegfwtcnn{! cpf! uwduvcpvkxgn{!
`
`fghgevkxg!hqt!cv!ngcuv!vjg!tgcuqpu!ugv!hqtvj!jgtgkp/!
`
`KK/
`
`VJG!”199!RCVGPV
`
`Vjg!”199!rcvgpv!ku!vkvngf!•Tgeqphkiwtcvkqp!Ocpcigt!hqt!Eqpvtqnnkpi!Writcfgu
`
`qh!Gngevtqpke!Fgxkegu/–!"$# %199!rcvgpv!kuuwgf!Qevqdgt!26-!3113-!htqo!W/U/!Rcvgpv!
`
`Crrnkecvkqp!Pq/!1;0454-718!hkngf!Lcpwct{!Lwpg!41-!2;;;/!!
`
`Vjg! kpxgpvqtu! qh! vjg! ”199! rcvgpv! qdugtxgf! vjcv-! cv! vjg! vkog-! ocp{! fkhhgtgpv!
`
`gngevtqpke!fgxkegu-!uwej!cu!fgumvqr-!ncrvqr!cpf!rcnovqr!eqorwvgtu-!rgtuqpcn!fkikvcn!
`
`cuukuvcpvu! )RFCu*-! vgngrjqpgu-! vgngxkukqpu-! ugv.vqr! dqzgu! cpf! qvjgt! eqpuwogt!
`
`gngevtqpke! rtqeguukpi! fgxkegu-! kv! ycu! eqooqp! hqt! vjgtg! vq! dg! kortqxgogpvu! vq!
`
`uqhvyctg! qt! jctfyctg! eqorqpgpvu! qh! vjqug! gngevtqpke! fgxkegu/! Cpf! vjcv! wugtu! qh!
`
`vjqug!gngevtqpke!fgxkegu!yqwnf!qhvgp!rtghgt!vq!writcfg!vjgkt!fgxkegu-!kpetgogpvcnn{-!
`
`tcvjgt!vjcp!fkuectf!vjgkt!ewttgpv!fgxkegu!cpf!rwtejcug!pgy!qpgu/!Cpf!vjcv!hqt!ocp{!
`
`qh!vjqug!writcfgu-!kv!ycu!igpgtcnn{!pgeguuct{!vq!fgvgtokpg!kh!vjg!pgy!qt!kortqxgf!
`
`eqorqpgpv! ku! eqorcvkdng! ykvj! vjg! tguv! qh! vjg! fgxkeg-! cpf! kh! pqv-! yjcv! qvjgt!
`
`2!
`
`Rcig!5!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1115
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`eqorqpgpvu! yqwnf! pggf! ukownvcpgqwu! writcfkpi! kp! qtfgt! vq! rtqxkfg! vjg! fguktgf!
`
`eqorcvkdknkv{-! cpf! vjcv! ocmkpi! vjqug! eqorcvkdknkv{! fgvgtokpcvkqpu! eqwnf! dg!
`
`rctvkewnctn{!fkhhkewnv!kh!vjg!tcpig!qh!rquukdng!fgxkeg!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!ku!nctig!cpf!vjg!
`
`kpvgtcevkqp! coqpi! fgxkeg! eqorqpgpvu! ku! eqorngz/! GZ2112-! 2<23.4;/! Hwtvjgt-! vjg!
`
`kpxgpvqtu! qh! vjg! ”199! rcvgpv! cnuq! qdugtxgf! vjcv! yjkng! c! pwodgt! qh! fkhhgtgpv!
`
`vgejpkswgu!jcf!dggp!fgxgnqrgf!hqt!wrfcvkpi!eqorqpgpvu!qh!gngevtqpke!fgxkegu-!vjgtg!
`
`ygtg! pwogtqwu! rtqdngou! cpf! ujqtveqokpiu! ykvj! vjqug! gzkuvkpi! vgejpkswgu-!
`
`kpenwfkpi! uwej! cu! hcknkpi! vq! gpuwtg! eqorcvkdknkv{! coqpi! uqhvyctg! cpf! jctfyctg!
`
`eqorqpgpvu!hqt!c!xctkgv{!qh!fkhhgtgpv!gngevtqpke!fgxkegu/!Kf/-!2<41.3<25/!
`
`Ceeqtfkpi!vq!vjg!kpxgpvkqp!qh!vjg!”199!rcvgpv-!c!tgeqphkiwtcvkqp!ocpcigt!ku!
`
`rtqxkfgf!vjcv!oc{!dg!korngogpvgf!qp!c!eqorwvgt!qt!qvjgt!fcvc!rtqeguukpi!fgxkeg!vq!
`
`eqpvtqn!vjg!tgeqphkiwtcvkqp!qh!uqhvyctg!qt!qvjgt!eqorqpgpvu!qh!cp!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!
`
`uwej!cu!c!eqorwvgt-!rgtuqpcn!fkikvcn!cuukuvcpv!)RFC*-!ugv.vqr!dqz-!vgngxkukqp-!gve/!Kp!
`
`ceeqtfcpeg!ykvj!vjg!kpxgpvkqp-!c!tgeqphkiwtcvkqp!ocpcigt!tgegkxgu!c!tgeqphkiwtcvkqp!
`
`tgswguv-!g/i/-!c!uqhvyctg!writcfg!tgswguv!htqo!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg-!cpf!fgvgtokpgu!
`
`qpg!qt!oqtg!fgxkeg!eqorqpgpvu!vjcv!ctg!tgswktgf!vq!korngogpv!vjg!tgeqphkiwtcvkqp!
`
`tgswguv/! Vjg! tgeqphkiwtcvkqp! ocpcigt! cnuq! fgvgtokpgu-! g/i/-! htqo! kphqtocvkqp!
`
`uwrrnkgf!d{!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!cu!rctv!qh!vjg!tgswguv-!kfgpvkhkgtu!qh!qpg!qt!oqtg!
`
`cffkvkqpcn! eqorqpgpvu! ewttgpvn{! korngogpvgf! kp! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg/! Vjg!
`
`tgeqphkiwtcvkqp! ocpcigt! vjgp! eqorctgu! vjg! pggfgf! cpf! ewttgpvn{! korngogpvgf!
`
`3!
`
`Rcig!6!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1116
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`
`eqorqpgpvu! ykvj! rtgxkqwun{.uvqtgf! nkuvu! qh! mpqyp! ceegrvcdng! cpf! wpceegrvcdng!
`
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg/! Kh! vjg! pggfgf! cpf! ewttgpvn{! korngogpvgf!
`
`eqorqpgpvu!eqttgurqpf!vq!c!eqphkiwtcvkqp!qp!vjg!nkuv!qh!ceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu-!
`
`vjg!tgswguv! ku! crrtqxgf! cpf!vjg! pggfgf!eqorqpgpvu! ctg! fqypnqcfgf!qt!qvjgtykug!
`
`uwrrnkgf! vq! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg/! Kh! vjg! pggfgf! cpf! ewttgpvn{! korngogpvgf!
`
`eqorqpgpvu!eqttgurqpf!vq!c!eqphkiwtcvkqp!qp!vjg!nkuv!qh!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu-!
`
`vjg!tgswguv!ku!fgpkgf/!Vjg!kpxgpvkqp!gpuwtgu!vjcv!writcfgu!ctg!eqorcvkdng!ykvj!vjg!
`
`eqphkiwtcvkqp!qh!c!ikxgp!fgxkeg!dghqtg!vjg{!ctg!korngogpvgf!kp!vjcv!fgxkeg-!vjgtgd{!
`
`cxqkfkpi!rtqdngou!cuuqekcvgf!ykvj!kpeqpukuvgpv!writcfgu/!Kf/-!3<33.78!
`
`KKK/ TGNCVGF!RTQEGGFKPIU
`
`Vjg!hqnnqykpi!rtqeggfkpiu!ctg!ewttgpvn{!rgpfkpi!ecugu!eqpegtpkpi!W/U/!Rcv/
`
`Pq/!7-578-199!)GZ2112*/!
`
`Ecug!Ecrvkqp!
`
`Ecug!Pwodgt!
`
`Fkuvtkev! Ecug!Hkngf!
`
`Wpknqe!WUC-!Kpe/!gv!cn!x/!Crrng!
`Kpe/!
`
`2.29.ex.113;7
`
`VZYF! Crt/!1;-!3129!
`
`KX/ NGXGN!QH!QTFKPCT[!UMKNN!KP!VJG!CTV
`
`Vjg!Rgvkvkqp!cnngigu!vjcv!c!rgtuqp!qh!qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv!)•RQUKVC–*!•hqt
`
`vjg!”199!rcvgpv!yqwnf!jcxg!jcf!cv!ngcuv!c!Dcejgnqt”u!Fgitgg!kp!eqorwvgt!uekgpeg-!
`
`eqorwvgt! gpikpggtkpi-! qt! c! tgncvgf! uwdlgev! qt! vjg! gswkxcngpv-! cpf! vyq! {gctu! qh!
`
`gzrgtkgpeg!yqtmkpi!ykvj!fcvcdcugu-!eqorwvgt!pgvyqtmu-!cpf!tgncvgf!vgejpqnqikgu/–!
`
`4!
`
`Rcig!7!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1117
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`Rgv/! 8.9/! Ikxgp!vjcv!Rgvkvkqpgt! hcknu! vq! oggv! kvu!dwtfgp! qh!rtqqh! yjgp! rwtrqtvgfn{!
`
`crrn{kpi!kvu!qyp!fghkpkvkqp!qh!c!rgtuqp!qh!qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv-!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!fqgu!
`
`pqv!qhhgt!c!eqorgvkpi!fghkpkvkqp!hqt!rwtrqugu!qh!vjku!rtqeggfkpi/!!!!
`
`X/
`
`RGVKVKQPGT!FQGU!PQV!RTQXG!C!TGCUQPCDNG!NKMGNKJQQF!
`QH!WPRCVGPVCDKNKV[!HQT!CP[!EJCNNGPIGF!ENCKO!
`
`! R
`
`gvkvkqpgt!jcu!vjg!dwtfgp!qh!rtqqh!vq!guvcdnkuj!gpvkvngogpv!vq!tgnkgh/!48!E/H/T/!
`
`©53/219)e*! )•tgxkgy! ujcnn! pqv! dg! kpuvkvwvgf! hqt! c! itqwpf! qh! wprcvgpvcdknkv{! wpnguu!
`
`/!/!/!vjgtg!ku!c!tgcuqpcdng!nkmgnkjqqf!vjcv!cv!ngcuv!qpg!qh!vjg!enckou!ejcnngpigf!/!/!/!ku!
`
`wprcvgpvcdng–*/!Vjg!Rgvkvkqp!hcknu!vq!oggv!vjku!dwtfgp/!
`
`Vjg!Rgvkvkqp!tckugu!vjg!hqnnqykpi!ejcnngpigu<!
`
`Enckou!
`
`Itqwpf!
`2!
`3!
`
`2.32!
`2.32!
`
`Tghgtgpeg)u*!
`Eqng2-!OceKppku3!cpf!Gnitguu{4!
`Rkv|gn5-!Eqng-!cpf!Gnitguu{!
`
`C/
`
`Encko!Eqpuvtwevkqp!!
`
`Rcvgpv!Qypgt!uwdokvu!vjcv!vjg!Dqctf!pggf!pqv!eqpuvtwg!cp{!encko!vgto!kp!c!
`
`rctvkewnct! ocppgt! kp! qtfgt! vq! cttkxg! cv! vjg! eqpenwukqp! vjcv! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! ku!
`
`uwduvcpvkxgn{!fghkekgpv/!Ygnnocp-!Kpe/!x/!Gcuvocp!Ejgo/!Eq/-!753!H/4f!2466-!2472!
`
`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`! 2
`
`!GZ2113-!W/U/!Rcvgpv!Pq/!6-863-153/!!
`3!GZ2114-!REV!Crrnkecvkqp!Rwdnkecvkqp!Pq/!YQ!;804165;/!
`4!GZ2115-!W/U/!Rcvgpv!Pq/!7-55;-834/!
`5!GZ2116-!W/U/!Rcvgpv!Pq/!8-173-876/!
`
`5!
`
`Rcig!8!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1118
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`
`)Hgf/! Ekt/! 3122*! )•pggf! qpn{! dg! eqpuvtwgf! vq! vjg! gzvgpv! pgeguuct{! vq! tguqnxg! vjg!
`
`eqpvtqxgtu{–*/!Jqygxgt-!kp!vjg!gxgpv!vjcv!vtkcn!ku!kpuvkvwvgf-!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!tgugtxgu!
`
`vjg!tkijv!vq!qdlgev!vq!Rgvkvkqpgt”u!rtqrqugf!eqpuvtwevkqp!cpf!rtqxkfg!Rcvgpv!Qypgt”u!
`
`rtqrqugf!eqpuvtwevkqp/!
`
`D/
`
`Vjg!Crrnkgf!Tghgtgpegu!Hckn!vq!Fkuenqug!•eqorct]]kpi_0]g__!vjg
`fgvgtokpgf!eqorqpgpv!cpf!kphqtocvkqp!urgekh{kpi!cv!ngcuv!qpg
`cffkvkqpcn!eqorqpgpv!ewttgpvn{!korngogpvgf!kp!vjg!gngevtqpke
`fgxkeg!ykvj!cv!ngcuv!qpg!qh!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!ceegrvcdng
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!cpf!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp
`wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–
`)Kpfgrgpfgpv!Enckou!2-!22-!cpf!32*
`
`Vjg! Rgvkvkqp”u! vyq! itqwpfu! tgfwpfcpvn{! ejcnngpigu! enckou! 2.32-! ykvjqwv!
`
`rtqxkfkpi! cp{! cnngigf! lwuvkhkecvkqp! hqt!uwej! kpghhkekgpv! tgfwpfcpekgu-! cpf!vjwu!vjg!
`
`Dqctf! ujqwnf! qpn{! eqpukfgt! qpg! qh! vjg! vyq! itqwpfu! )Ugg! Ugevkqp! XK-! dgnqy*/!
`
`Tgictfnguu-! pqpg! qh! vjg! crrnkgf! tghgtgpegu! wpfgt! gkvjgt! qh! Rgvkvkqpgt”u! itqwpfu!
`
`fkuenqugu! vjg! tgswktgf! encko! nkokvcvkqpu! •eqorct]]kpi_0]g__! vjg! fgvgtokpgf!
`
`eqorqpgpv!cpf!kphqtocvkqp!urgekh{kpi!cv!ngcuv!qpg!cffkvkqpcn!eqorqpgpv!ewttgpvn{!
`
`korngogpvgf!kp!vjg! gngevtqpke!fgxkeg! ykvj! cv!ngcuv!qpg!qh! ]]c_0]vjg__! nkuv!qh! mpqyp!
`
`ceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg! cpf! ]]c_0]vjg__! nkuv! qh! mpqyp!
`
`wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–!qh!kpfgrgpfgpv!enckou!2-!22-!
`
`cpf!32/!!Oqtg!rctvkewnctn{-!pqpg!qh!vjg!crrnkgf!tghgtgpeg!fkuenqugu!nkuvu!qh! mpqyp!
`
`ceegrvcdng!cpf!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu/!!!
`
`6!
`
`Rcig!9!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1119
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`
`2/
`
`Eqng!kp!xkgy!qh!OceKppku!cpf!Gnitguu{!)Rgvkvkqpgt”u!Rtqrqugf
`Itqwpf!2*!Hcknu!vq!Fkuenqug!•‡ngcuv!qpg!qh!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh
`mpqyp!ceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!cpf
`]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg
`gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–
`
`Kp!Rgvkvkqpgt”u!rtqrqugf!Itqwpf!2-!hqt!vjg!encko!nkokvcvkqp!tgswktkpi!cv!ngcuv!
`
`qpg!qh!c!•nkuv!qh!mpqyp!ceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–!cpf!c!
`
`•nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–-!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!
`
`tgnkgu!gzenwukxgn{!qp!Eqng!hqt!cnngigfn{!fkuenqukpi!gkvjgt!qpg!qh!vjg!tgswktgf!nkuvu/6!!
`
`Jqygxgt-! Eqng! hcknu! vq! fkuenqug! gkvjgt! c! nkuv! qh! mpqyp! ceegrvcdng!
`
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu! qt! c! nkuv! qh! mpqyp! wpceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke!
`
`fgxkeg-!cu!tgswktgf!d{!vjg!encko!ncpiwcig/!Vjg!rnckp!ncpiwcig!qh!vjg!encko!nkokvcvkqp!
`
`tgswktgu!vjcv!vjg!nkuvu!dg<!)2*!rtgxkqwun{!fgvgtokpgf!)k/g/-!•mpqyp–*!cpf!)3*!urgekhke!
`
`vq! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg! kp! swguvkqp! )k/g/-! •hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg–*/! Vjku!
`
`6
`
`! Vjg! Rgvkvkqp! j{rqvjgvkecnn{! cpf! eqpfkvkqpcnn{! rtqrqugu! c! eqodkpcvkqp! ykvj!
`OceKppku! qpn{! hqt! vjg! rwtrqugu! qh! vjg! ukvwcvkqp! yjgtg! •vjg! fgxkeg! eqorqpgpv!
`tgswktgf! vq! korngogpv! vjg! tgeqphkiwtcvkqp! tgswguv–! ku! c! rctvkewnct! eqorqpgpv!
`tgswguvgf!d{!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg/!Rgv/!34=!ugg!cnuq!Rgv/!29.2;!)fguetkdkpi!OceKppku!
`cu! fkuenqukpi! c! wugt! vgtokpcn! tgswguvkpi! •c! rctvkewnct! uqhvyctg! oqfwng–! hqt!
`kpuvcnncvkqp/*/!Vjg!Rgvkvkqp!cnuq!rtqrqugu!c!j{rqvjgvkecn!eqodkpcvkqp!ykvj!Gnitguu{!
`qpn{!hqt!vjg!rwtrqugu!qh!vjg!ukvwcvkqp!yjgtg!vyq!nkuvu!ctg!fggogf!tgswktgf/!Ugg!Rgv/!
`34.39! )fguetkdkpi! Gnitguu{! cu! fkuenqukpi!c! u{uvgo! yjgtg! c! icvgyc{! eqorctgu! vjg
`tguqwtegu!qh!vjg!eqorwvgt!pggfgf!d{!cp!gzgewvcdng!qdlgev!ykvj!vjg!tguqwtegu!cnnqygf
`qt! rtqjkdkvgf! d{! c! Ugewtkv{! Rqnke{/*/! Vjwu-! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! tgnkgu! uqngn{! qp! Eqng! hqt
`cnngigfn{! fkuenqukpi! vjg! encko! tgswktgogpv! qh! c! •nkuv! qh! mpqyp! ceegrvcdng
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu/–
`
`7!
`
`Rcig!;!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!111;
`
`

`

`requirement is further confirmed by the specification of the ’088 patent:
`
`IPR2019-00056
`U.S. Patent 6,467,088
`
`the reconfiguration manager 10
`In step 104 of FIG. 2,
`generates a potential upgrade configuration that will satisfy
`the received request. The reconfiguration manager in step
`
`106 then
`
`. If the upgrade configuration as generated
`in step -
`is determined in step 108 to correspondto one of the known
`
`bad configurations, the reconfiguration manager in step 110
`
`
`
`
`
`If the resulting set of potential upgrade configurations is
`determined in step 112 to be empty,
`the reconfiguration
`manager in step 114 denies the upgrade,
`
`
`
`and communicates this denial in its response to deviceX.If
`
`step 112 indicates that the set is not empty, a particular set
`of upgrade configuration is selected in step 116, and the
`
`upgrade is approved in step SeeR
`may be
`based at
`least
`in part on one or more established
`criteria, such as least expensive, maximum improvement in
`system operating speed, most
`recently modified, most
`energy efficient, or other suitable criteria. The reconfigura-
`tion manager or other server associated therewith then
`downloads the upgrade to device X in step 120.
`
`EX1001, 4:62-5:18 (highlighting added).
`
`As seen in the passages above, the claim language requires a previously
`
`determined set of known bad configurations that can be searched and a previously
`
`determined set of known good configurations that can be searched for a current
`
`configuration for a specific electronic device (i.e. “device X”). In other words, the
`
`claim language requires that the list contain previously determined acceptable or
`
`Page 10 of 24
`APPLE EXHIBIT 1011 - PAGE 0010
`
`

`

`IPR2019-00056
`U.S. Patent 6,467,088
`
`unacceptable configurations specific to the electronic device in question. Colefails
`
`to disclose either suchlist.
`
`Asthe Petition shows, Cole only discloses and utilizes a list of all available
`
`updates without regard to the electronic device. The example given by Cole itself
`
`(and used in the Petition) is illustrative, stating, that the “table list[s] code updates
`
`available in content server 17”:
`
`client 14. (In practice, the meta data can be arranged in a
`relational data base to facilitate the correlation). The first
`
`
`two columns of the following tablelistcodeupdatesavail-
`ableincontentserver17and the meta data for these code
`updates. The first two columns of this table are used for the
`initial correlation of the basic system information obtained
`from client 14 to the meta data (column 2) stored in selection
`server 12.
`
`
`
`Basis System
`Information’
`Code Updates Meta Data
`
`
`
`Device Driver
`ABCTDE.DRY
`
`Netcomber 2.0
`
`BIOS Level 123
`BIOS date 1/1/96
`Mother Board ID
`XYZ
`BIOS Level 123
`BIOS date 1/1/s%6
`Mother Board ID
`RYE
`BIOS Level 456
`BIOS date 2/16
`Mother Board ID
`XYZ
`
`
`Device Driver
`FGHILDRY
`
`EX1002, 4:1-24 (highlighting added).
`
`In other words, Cole merely looks to apply any and all code updates that are
`
`Page 11 of 24
`APPLE EXHIBIT 1011 - PAGE 0011
`
`

`

`IPR2019-00056
`U.S. Patent 6,467,088
`
`stored in its content server 17, without regard for the specific electronic device and
`
`
`certainly not utilizing a list of known acceptable/unacceptable configurations for the
`
`specific electronic device. Cole makes this clearer in stating:
`
`“Tn the illustrated embodiment, this determination is made
`
`by correlating the meta data in data base 13 to the basic
`
`system information obtained from client 14. Matches
`
`between the meta data and the basic system information
`
`indicate
`
`that
`
`the
`
`corresponding code updates
`
`are
`
`potentially appropriate for client 14.”
`
`EX1002, 3:62-4:1 (emphasis added).
`
`As disclosed above,
`
`the system of Co/e merely iterates through every
`
`available code update available, without information or knowledge about known
`
`acceptable or unacceptable configurations for the electronic device, as is required
`
`by the claim language. Even a match of Cole’s “meta data” can only be described
`
`by Cole as a potentially appropriate.
`
`This is further confirmed by the example from Cole:
`
`In this example. the BIOS level 123. BIOS date Jan. 1.
`1996 and mother board ID XYZ basic system information
`obtained from client 14 is consistent with a device driver file
`named ABCDE.DRY. and Netcomber (trademark of Inter-
`national Business Machines Corporation) version 2.0.
`However, device driver file named FGHU.DRV requires
`BIOSlevel 456 so
`
`14andiseliminatedfrom
`
`furtherconsideration.
`
`Page 12 of 24
`APPLE EXHIBIT 1011 - PAGE 0012
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`
`GZ2113-!5<36.44!)jkijnkijvkpi!cffgf*/!
`
`Cu!ujqyp!kp!vjg!rcuucig!cdqxg-!vjg!u{uvgo!qh!Eqng!kvgtcvgu!vjtqwij!gcej!cpf!
`
`gxgt{!eqfg!wrfcvg!cxckncdng!qp!kvu!eqpvgpv!ugtxgt!28!ykvjqwv!cp{!rtkqt!tgictf!hqt!vjg!
`
`gngevtqpke!fgxkeg/!Kpfggf-!vjg!u{uvgo!qh!Eqng!kvgtcvgu!vjtqwij!gcej!cpf!gxgt{!eqfg!
`
`wrfcvg!cxckncdng!gcej!cpf!gxgt{!vkog!kv!ku!twp!ykvjqwv!kphqtocvkqp!qt!mpqyngfig!qh!
`
`cp{!rtgxkqwu!kvgtcvkqpu/!Vjwu-!vjgtg!ku!pqvjkpi!kp!Eqng!vjcv!fkuenqugu!etgcvkpi!c!nkuv!
`
`qh! ceegrvcdng! qt! wpceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! urgekhke! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg/!
`
`Nkmgykug-! vjgtg! ku! pqvjkpi! kp! Eqng! vjcv! fkuenqugu! rtgxkqwun{! fgvgtokpkpi! cpf!
`
`ockpvckpkpi!uwej!c!nkuv/!!
`
`Vjwu-! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! ujqwnf! dg! fgpkgf! dgecwug! kv! hcknu! vq! ujqy! vjg! tgswktgf!
`
`•eqorct]]kpi_0]g__! vjg! fgvgtokpgf! eqorqpgpv! cpf! kphqtocvkqp! urgekh{kpi! cv! ngcuv!
`
`qpg! cffkvkqpcn! eqorqpgpv! ewttgpvn{! korngogpvgf! kp! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg! ykvj! cv!
`
`ngcuv! qpg! qh! ]]c_0]vjg__! nkuv! qh! mpqyp! ceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke!
`
`fgxkeg!cpf!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!
`
`fgxkeg–-!kp!kvu!rtqrqugf!Itqwpf!2/!!
`
`3/
`
`Rkv|gn!kp!xkgy!qh!Eqng!cpf!Gnitguu{!)Rgvkvkqpgt”u!Rtqrqugf
`Itqwpf!3*!Hcknu!vq!Fkuenqug!•‡ngcuv!qpg!qh!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh
`mpqyp!ceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!cpf
`]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg
`gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–
`
`Ukoknctn{-! cpf! cu! fguetkdgf! kp! Ugevkqp! X/D/2-! cdqxg-! Rgvkvkqpgt”u! rtqrqugf!
`
`21!
`
`Rcig!24!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1124
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`Itqwpf!3!cnuq!hcknu!hqt!vjg!encko!nkokvcvkqp!tgswktkpi!cv!ngcuv!qpg!qh!c!•nkuv!qh!mpqyp!
`
`ceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg–! cpf! c! •nkuv! qh! mpqyp!
`
`wpceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg–/! Jgtg-! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! tgnkgu!
`
`rtkoctkn{!qp!Rkv|gn-!vq!jgfigu!kvu!dgvu!wukpi!Eqng!kp!vjg!kfgpvkecn!ocppgt!cu!kp!kvu!
`
`rtqrqugf!Itqwpf!2!•vq!vjg!gzvgpv–!Rkv|gn!ku!ncemkpi/!!Jqygxgt-!Rkv|gn!˜!lwuv!nkmg!Eqng!
`
`˜!hcknu!vq!fkuenqug!vjg!tgswktgf!encko!nkokvcvkqp/ 7!!
`
`Ukoknct! vq! Eqng”u! fghkekgpekgu-! pqvjkpi! kp! Rkv|gn! fkuenqugu! gkvjgt! c! nkuv! qh!
`
`mpqyp!ceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!qt!c!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!
`
`vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg-!cu!tgswktgf!d{!vjg!encko!ncpiwcig/!Cu!fkuewuugf!kp!Ugevkqp!
`
`X/D/2-!cdqxg-!vjg!rnckp!ncpiwcig!qh!vjg!encko!nkokvcvkqp!tgswktgu!vjcv!vjg!nkuvu!dg<!)2*!
`
`rtgxkqwun{! fgvgtokpgf! )k/g/-! •mpqyp–*!cpf! )3*!urgekhke! vq! vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg!kp!
`
`swguvkqp!)k/g/-!•hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg–*/!Vjku!tgswktgogpv!ku!hwtvjgt!eqphktogf!d{!
`
`vjg!urgekhkecvkqp!qh!vjg!”199!rcvgpv<!!
`
`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`! 7
`
`!Lwuv!nkmg!ykvj!Eqng-!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!rtqrqugu!c!j{rqvjgvkecn!eqodkpcvkqp!ykvj!Gnitguu{!
`qpn{!hqt!vjg!rwtrqug!qh!c!ukvwcvkqp!yjgtg!vyq!nkuvu!ctg!fggogf!tgswktgf/!Ugg!Rgv/!64.
`67! )fguetkdkpi! Gnitguu{! cu! fkuenqukpi! c! u{uvgo! yjgtg! c! icvgyc{! eqorctgu! vjg!
`tguqwtegu!qh!vjg!eqorwvgt!pggfgf!d{!cp!gzgewvcdng!qdlgev!ykvj!vjg!tguqwtegu!cnnqygf!
`qt!rtqjkdkvgf!d{!c!Ugewtkv{!Rqnke{/*/!
`
`22!
`
`Rcig!25!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1125
`
`

`

`IPR2019-00056
`U.S. Patent 6,467,088
`
`the reconfiguration manager 10
`In step 104 of FIG. 2,
`generates a potential upgrade configuration that will satisfy
`the received request. The reconfiguration manager in step
`
`106 then
`
`. [f the upgrade configuration as generated
`in step -
`is determined in step 108 to correspondto one of the known
`
`bad configurations, the reconfiguration manager in step 110
`
`If the resulting set of potential upgrade configurationsis
`determined in step 112 to be empty,
`the reconfiguration
`
`manager in step 114 denies the upgrade,
`
`If
`X.
`in its response to device
`and communicatesthis denial
`step 112 indicates that the set is not empty, a particular set
`of upgrade configuration is selected in step 116, and the
`
`upgrade is approved in step IISascompatiblewiththe
`ao e selection in step
`may be based at
`least in part on one or more established
`criteria, such as least expensive, maximum improvement in
`system operating speed, most
`recently modified, most
`energy efficient, or other suitable criteria. The reconfigura-
`tion manager or other server associated therewith then
`downloads the upgrade to device X in step 120.
`
`EX1001, 4:62-5:18 (highlighting added).
`
`As seen in the passage above,
`
`the claim language requires a previously
`
`determined set of known bad configurations that can be searched and a previously
`
`determined set of known good configurations that can be searched for a current
`
`configuration of a specific electronic device (i.e. “device X’’). In other words, the
`
`claim language requires that the list contain previously determined acceptable or
`
`unacceptable configurations specific to the electronic device in question. Pitzel fails
`
`to disclose either suchlist.
`
`12
`
`Page 15 of 24
`APPLE EXHIBIT 1011 - PAGE 0015
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`Rkv|gn!fkuenqugu!kp!kvu! •OGVJQF! QH!QRGTCVKQP–!ugevkqp!vjcv!vjg!enkgpv!
`
`eqorwvgt!kpkvkcvgu!cp!writcfg!tgswguv!qh!qpg!qt!oqtg!eqorqpgpvu!vjtqwij!vjg!wugt!
`
`ceeguukpi!c!rnwtcnkv{!qh!ygd!rcigu!jquvgf!qp!c!eqphkiwtcvkqp!ugtxgt-!yjgtg!cv!ngcuv!
`
`qpg!qh!vjg!ygd!rcigu!jcu!kphqtocvkqp!cdqwv!qpg!qh!vjg!eqorqpgpvu/!GZ2116-!8<26.
`
`41/! D{! kvu! qyp! fguetkrvkqp-! vjg! eqphkiwtcvkqp! ugtxgt! qh! Rkv|gn! ogtgn{! jquvu! c!
`
`ecvcnqiwg!qh!cnn!cxckncdng!eqorqpgpvu!hqt!vjg!wugt!vq!ejqqug!htqo/!Pqvjkpi!kp!vjcv!
`
`vtcpucevkqp!ujqyu!qt!wvknk|gu!vjg!tgswktgf!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!ceegrvcdng!qt!wpceegrvcdng!
`
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg/!Kp!qvjgt!yqtfu-!jquvkpi!c!ecvcnqiwg!qh!gxgt{!
`
`cxckncdng! eqorqpgpv! ykvjqwv! tgictf! hqt! vjg! urgekhke! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg! ku! pqv! vjg!
`
`tgswktgf! nkuv! qh! mpqyp! ceegrvcdng! qt! wpceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! urgekhke!
`
`gngevtqpke!fgxkeg/!!
`
`Vjg!Rgvkvkqp”u!ejgtt{.rkemgf!htciogpv!qh!c!swqvg!htqo!Rkv|gn!hctgu!pq!dgvvgt/!
`
`Vjg!Rgvkvkqp!ctiwgu-!d{!ugngevkpi!c!htciogpv!qh!c!ugpvgpeg!qwv!qh!cp!gpvktg!ugevkqp!
`
`htqo! Rkv|gn-! vjcv! vjg! nkokvcvkqp! ku! ogv! dgecwug! vjg! eqorqpgpv! ugtxgt! cnngigfn{!
`
`•ugngev]u_! eqorqpgpvu! vjcv! ctg! eqorcvkdn{! qrgtcdng! ykvj! vjg! enkgpv/–! Rgv/! 59/!
`
`Jqygxgt-! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! rtgugpvu! vjg! swqvgf! htciogpv! kp! eqpenwuqt{! hcujkqp! cpf!
`
`ykvjqwv!eqpvgzv/!C!tgxkgy!qh!vjg!tgngxcpv!ugevkqp!kp!hwnn!tgxgcnu!vjcv!wrqp!vjg!u{uvgo!
`
`qh!Rkv|gn!fgvgtokpkpi!c!wugt”u!writcfg!tgswguv!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!jcu!pqv!gzrktgf-!hqt!
`
`vjcv!rctvkewnct!eqorqpgpv-!vjg!writcfg!jcpfngt!oqfwng!ugngevu!crrtqrtkcvg!xgtukqp)u*!
`
`qh! vjg! writcfg! vq! ugpf! dcem! vq! vjg! wugt/! Ugg! GZ2116-! ;<3;.21<41/! Gxgp! kp! vjcv!
`
`24!
`
`Rcig!27!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1127
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`uegpctkq-! vjg! u{uvgo! fguetkdgu! vjg! writcfg! jcpfngt! ugctejkpi! coqpi! cnn! qh! vjg!
`
`rquukdng!xgtukqpu)u*!qh!vjg!eqorqpgpvu!kp!fgvgtokpkpi!yjcv!vq!ugpf!dcem!vq!vjg!wugt/!
`
`Pqvjkpi!kp!vjcv!vtcpucevkqp!ujqyu!qt!wvknk|gu!vjg!tgswktgf!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!ceegrvcdng!qt!
`
`wpceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg/! Kp! qvjgt! yqtfu-! ugctejkpi!
`
`vjtqwij!cnn!rquukdng!xgtukqp)u*!qh!vjg!eqorqpgpv)u*!ykvjqwv!tgictf!hqt!vjg!urgekhke!
`
`gngevtqpke! fgxkeg! ku! pqv! vjg! tgswktgf! nkuv! qh! mpqyp! ceegrvcdng! qt! wpceegrvcdng!
`
`eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!urgekhke!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg/!
`
`Oqtgqxgt-!cu!cntgcf{!ujqyp!kp!Ugevkqp!X/D/2-!cdqxg-!Rgvkvkqpgt”u!tgnkcpeg!qp!
`
`Eqng! cnuq! hcknu/! Vjg! u{uvgo! qh! Eqng! kvgtcvgu! vjtqwij! gcej! cpf! gxgt{! eqfg! wrfcvg!
`
`cxckncdng!qp!kvu!eqpvgpv!ugtxgt!ykvjqwv!cp{!rtkqt!tgictf!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!fgxkeg/!Kp!
`
`qvjgt!yqtfu-!vjg!u{uvgo!qh!Eqng!ogtgn{!kvgtcvgu!vjtqwij!gcej!cpf!gxgt{!eqfg!wrfcvg!
`
`cxckncdng!gcej!cpf!gxgt{!vkog-!ykvjqwv!kphqtocvkqp!qt!mpqyngfig!qh!cp{!rtgxkqwu!
`
`kvgtcvkqpu/!Cu!uwej-!vjgtg!ku!pqvjkpi!kp!Eqng!vjcv!fkuenqugu!etgcvkpi!c!nkuv!qh!ceegrvcdng!
`
`qt! wpceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! urgekhke! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg-! pqt! ku! vjgtg!
`
`cp{vjkpi!kp!Eqng!vjcv!fkuenqugu!rtgxkqwun{!fgvgtokpkpi!cpf!ockpvckpkpi!uwej!c!nkuv/!
`
`Ugg!Ugevkqp!X/D/2-!cdqxg/!
`
`Vjwu-! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! ujqwnf! dg! fgpkgf! dgecwug! kv! hcknu! vq! ujqy! vjg! tgswktgf!
`
`•eqorct]]kpi_0]g__! vjg! fgvgtokpgf! eqorqpgpv! cpf! kphqtocvkqp! urgekh{kpi! cv! ngcuv!
`
`qpg! cffkvkqpcn! eqorqpgpv! ewttgpvn{! korngogpvgf! kp! vjg! gngevtqpke! fgxkeg! ykvj! cv!
`
`ngcuv! qpg! qh! ]]c_0]vjg__! nkuv! qh! mpqyp! ceegrvcdng! eqphkiwtcvkqpu! hqt! vjg! gngevtqpke!
`
`25!
`
`Rcig!28!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1128
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`fgxkeg!cpf!]]c_0]vjg__!nkuv!qh!mpqyp!wpceegrvcdng!eqphkiwtcvkqpu!hqt!vjg!gngevtqpke!
`
`fgxkeg–-!kp!kvu!rtqrqugf!Itqwpf!3/!!
`
`E/
`
`Vjg!Rgvkvkqp!hcknu!vq!Rtqxg!Qdxkqwupguu!qh!Cp{!Fgrgpfgpv!Encko!!
`
`Vjg!fghkekgpekgu!qh!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!ctvkewncvgf!cdqxg!eqpegtpkpi!vjg!ejcnngpigf!
`
`kpfgrgpfgpv!enckou!crrn{!cnuq!vckpv!vjg!cpcn{uku!qh!vjg!ejcnngpigf!fgrgpfgpv!enckou/!!
`
`Ceeqtfkpin{-!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!ujqwnf!dg!fgpkgf!kp!kvu!gpvktgv{/!!
`
`XK/ VJG!RGVKVKQP!TGFWPFCPVN[!EJCNNGPIGU!CNN!ENCKOU!
`)ENCKOU!2.32*!!
`
`! V
`
`jg! Rgvkvkqp! tgfwpfcpvn{! ejcnngpigu! cnn! qh! vjg! enckou! qh! vjg! ”199! Rcvgpv-!
`
`ykvjqwv!rtqxkfkpi!cp{!cnngigf!lwuvkhkecvkqp!hqt!uwej!kpghhkekgpv!tgfwpfcpekgu/!Cu!vjg!
`
`Dqctf! jcu! rtgxkqwun{! gzrnckpgf-! •ownvkrng! itqwpfu-! yjkej! ctg! rtgugpvgf! kp! c!
`
`tgfwpfcpv! ocppgt! d{! c! rgvkvkqpgt! yjq! ocmgu! pq! ogcpkpihwn! fkuvkpevkqp! dgvyggp!
`
`vjgo-!ctg!eqpvtct{!vq!vjg!tgiwncvqt{!cpf!uvcvwvqt{!ocpfcvgu-!cpf!vjgtghqtg!ctg!pqv!cnn!
`
`gpvkvngf!vq!eqpukfgtcvkqp/–!Ugg!Nkdgtv{!Owv/!Kpu/!Eq/!x/!Rtqitguukxg!Ecu/!Kpu/!Eq/-!Pq/!
`
`EDO3123.11114-! Rcrgt! 8! )R/V/C/D/! Qev/! 36-! 3123*/! Uwej! tgfwpfcpekgu! rnceg! c!
`
`ukipkhkecpv! dwtfgp! qp! dqvj! vjg! Dqctf! cpf! vjg! rcvgpv! qypgt-! ecwukpi! wppgeguuct{!
`
`fgnc{-!eqorqwpfkpi!equvu!vq!cnn!rctvkgu!kpxqnxgf-!cpf!eqortqokukpi!vjg!cdknkv{!vq!
`
`eqorngvg!tgxkgy!ykvjkp!vjg!uvcvwvqt{!fgcfnkpg/!Kf/=!48!E/H/T/!'!53/2)d*=!ugg!cnuq!48!
`
`E/H/T/!'!53/219/!Cu!uwej-!cpcn{|kpi!vjg!rgvkvkqp!cpf!gnkokpcvkpi!tgfwpfcpv!itqwpfu!
`
`uvtgconkpgu!vjg!rtqeggfkpi/!Kfng!Htgg!U{u/-!Kpe/!x/!Dgtiuvtqo-!Kpe/-!KRT3123.11138-!
`
`26!
`
`Rcig!29!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1129
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`Rcrgt!37!cv!5.6!)R/V/C/D/!Lwpg!22-!3124*=!Nkdgtv{!Owv/-!EDO3123.11114-!Rcrgt!8!
`
`cv!3/!!
`
`Vjg! Rgvkvkqp! rtgugpvu! itqwpfu! vjcv! ctg! xgtvkecnn{! tgfwpfcpv! ykvj! tgurgev! vq!
`
`gcej! qvjgt/! Xgtvkecn! tgfwpfcpe{! •kpxqnxgu! c! rnwtcnkv{! qh! rtkqt! ctv! crrnkgf! dqvj! kp!
`
`rctvkcn! eqodkpcvkqp! cpf! kp! hwnn! eqodkpcvkqp/! Kp! vjg! hqtogt! ecug-! hgygt! tghgtgpegu!
`
`vjcp!vjg!gpvktg!eqodkpcvkqp!ctg!uwhhkekgpv!vq!tgpfgt!c!encko!qdxkqwu-!cpf!kp!vjg!ncvvgt!
`
`ecug!vjg!gpvktg!eqodkpcvkqp!ku!tgnkgf!qp!vq!tgpfgt!vjg!ucog!encko!qdxkqwu/–!Nkdgtv{!
`
`Owv/-! EDO3123.11114-! Rcrgt! 8! cv! 4/! ! Kp! uwej! kpuvcpegu! yjgtg! tgnkcpeg! qp! c!
`
`eqodkpcvkqp! cpf! ugrctcvg! tgnkcpeg! qp! c! rqtvkqp! vjgtgqh! ctg! dqvj! cnngigf! vq!
`
`uwhhkekgpvn{!rtgugpv!c!rtkoc!hcekg!ecug!qh!kpxcnkfkv{-!•]v_jgtg!owuv!dg!cp!gzrncpcvkqp!
`
`qh! yj{! vjg! tgnkcpeg! kp! rctv! oc{! dg! vjg! uvtqpigt! cuugtvkqp! cu! crrnkgf! kp! egtvckp!
`
`kpuvcpegu!cpf!yj{!vjg!tgnkcpeg!kp!yjqng!oc{!cnuq!dg!vjg!uvtqpigt!cuugtvkqp!kp!qvjgt!
`
`kpuvcpegu/–!Kf/!)gorjcuku!kp!qtkikpcn*/!
`
`Kh!qpg!qh!vjg!cnvgtpcvkxg!itqwpfu!ku!dgvvgt!htqo!cnn!rgturgevkxgu-!vjgp!vjg!Dqctf!
`
`ujqwnf!qpn{!eqpukfgt!vjg!uvtqpigt!itqwpf!cpf!pqv!dwtfgp!vjg!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!cpf!vjg!
`
`Dqctf!ykvj!vjg!ygcmgt!itqwpf/!Hwtvjgt-!kh!vjgtg!ku!pq!fkhhgtgpeg!kp!vjg!itqwpfu-!vjg!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!ujqwnf!cuugtv!qpn{!qpg!qh!vjg!itqwpfu/!Kf/!cv!23/!•Qpn{!kh!vjg!Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`tgcuqpcdn{! ctvkewncvgu! yj{! gcej!itqwpf!jcu! uvtgpivj! cpf! ygcmpguu! tgncvkxg!vq!vjg!
`
`qvjgt!ujqwnf!dqvj!itqwpfu!dg!cuugtvgf!hqt!eqpukfgtcvkqp/–!Kf/!)gorjcuku!cffgf*/!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt! ocmgu! pq! ghhqtv! vq! lwuvkh{! kvu! xgtvkecnn{! tgfwpfcpv! vjgqtkgu! d{!
`
`27!
`
`Rcig!2;!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!112;
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`gzrnckpkpi!yj{!•vjg!tgnkcpeg!kp!rctv!]g/i/-!qp!vjg!rtkoct{!tghgtgpeg!cnqpg_!oc{!dg!
`
`vjg!uvtqpigt!cuugtvkqp!cu!crrnkgf!kp!egtvckp!kpuvcpegu!cpf!yj{!vjg!tgnkcpeg!kp!yjqng!
`
`]g/i/-!vjg!hwnn!eqodkpcvkqp!qh!kfgpvkhkgf!tghgtgpegu_!oc{!cnuq!dg!vjg!uvtqpigt!cuugtvkqp!
`
`kp! qvjgt! kpuvcpegu/–! Kf/! Kpfggf-! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! fqgu! pqv! gxgp! cempqyngfig! vjg!
`
`icoguocpujkr!qh!jgfikpi!kvu!dgvu!vjtqwij!vjg!tgfwpfcpe{!qh!Itqwpfu!2!cpf!3/!!
`
`Vjg!Dqctf!kp!Gk|q!Eqtr/!x/!Dcteq!P/X/8!!hncvn{!tglgevgf!c!ukoknct!cvvgorv!vq!
`
`jgfig! dgvu! cpf! wppgeguuctkn{! ownvkrn{! vjg! yqtm! qh! dqvj! vjg! Dqctf! cpf! vjg! Rcvgpv!
`
`Qypgt/!Vjg!Dqctf!vjgtg!hqwpf!kpuwhhkekgpv!vjg!rgvkvkqpgt”u!•eqpenwuqt{!cuugtvkqp–!
`
`vjcv! •]v_q! vjg! gzvgpv! ]vjg! hktuv! rtkqt! ctv! tghgtgpeg_! oc{! pqv! gzrnkekvn{! vgcej–! vjg!
`
`nkokvcvkqp-! vjg! ugeqpf! rtkqt! ctv! tghgtgpeg! •gzrnkekvn{! vgcejgu! vjku! nkokvcvkqp/–! Vjg!
`
`Dqctf!gzrnckpgf!vjcv!•uwej!cp!cuugtvkqp!hcknu!vq!tguqnxg!vjg!gzcev!fkhhgtgpegu!uqwijv!
`
`vq!dg!fgtkxgf!htqo–!vjg!ugeqpf!rtkqt!ctv!tghgtgpeg/!Kf/!!!
`
`Vjg!Dqctf”u!rtgegfgpvkcn!cwvjqtkv{!qp!vjgug!rtqegfwtcn!kuuwgu!ku!engct/!Jgtg-!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt! korgtokuukdn{! uggmu! vjg! dgpghkv! qh! fkhhgtgpv! dkvgu! cv! vjg! crrng-! ykvjqwv!
`
`rtqxkfkpi! c!dk.fktgevkqpcn! gzrncpcvkqp! qh!vjg! tgncvkxg! uvtgpivju! cpf! ygcmpguugu!qh!
`
`gcej!tgfwpfcpvn{!qhhgtgf!itqwpf/!Kh!Rgvkvkqpgt!dgnkgxgu!vjg!qdxkqwupguu!ejcnngpigu!
`
`ctg!pgeguuct{!vq!cfftguugu!egtvckp!ygcmpguugu!qh!vjg!ejcnngpig!dcugf!qp!vjg!Eqng.
`
`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`!KRT3125.11469-!Rcrgt!22!)R/V/C/D/!Lwn{!34-!3125*!
`
`! 8
`
`28!
`
`Rcig!31!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1131
`
`

`

`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`
`OceKppku.Gnitguu{! eqodkpcvkqp-! Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`ku! qdnkicvgf!
`
`vq! ctvkewncvg!
`
`vjqug!
`
`ygcmpguugu! kp! vjg! Rgvkvkqp! kvugnh/! Dgecwug! Rgvkvkqpgt! ejqug! vq! pqv! qhhgt! uwej!
`
`eqpeguukqpu-!rtguwocdn{!hqt!uvtcvgike!tgcuqpu-!vjg!Dqctf!pggf!pqv!cpf!ujqwnf!pqv!
`
`eqpukfgt!vjg!ogtkvu!qh!vjg!tgfwpfcpv!ejcnngpigu!dcugf!qp!qdxkqwupguu/!!
`
`XKK/ VJG!EQPUVKVWVKQPCNKV[!QH!KPVGT!RCTVGU!TGXKGY!KU!VJG
`UWDLGEV!QH!C!RGPFKPI!CRRGCN
`
`Kp! c! rgpfkpi! crrgcn! vq! vjg! Hgfgtcn! Ektewkv-! Rqnctku! Kppqxcvkqpu! Nvf/! x/
`
`Mkpiuvqp!Vgejpqnqi{-!Pq/!29.12879-!Fmv/!Pq/!38-!vjg!rcvgpv!qypgt!Rqnctku!ctiwgf!
`
`vjcv! vjg! Dqctf”u! crrqkpvogpv! qh! cfokpkuvtcvkxg! rcvgpv! lwfigu! xkqncvgu! vjg!
`
`Crrqkpvogpvu! Encwug! qh! Ctvkeng! KK-! cpf! vjcv! vjgkt! fgekukqpu! owuv! dg! ugv! cukfg-!
`
`dgecwug!cfokpkuvtcvkxg!rcvgpv!lwfigu!ctg!•crrqkpvgf!d{!vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Eqoogteg-!
`
`kp!eqpuwnvcvkqp!ykvj!vjg!Fktgevqt–!qh!vjg!WURVQ-!dwv!ykvjqwv!crrqkpvogpv!d{!vjg!
`
`Rtgukfgpv!cpf!eqphktocvkqp!d{!vjg!Ugpcvg!kp!xkqncvkqp!qh!Ctvkeng!KK-!Ugevkqp!3-!Encwug!
`
`3!qh!vjg!Eqpuvkvwvkqp/!Qwv!qh!cp!cdwpfcpeg!qh!ecwvkqp-!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!jgtgd{!cfqrvu!
`
`vjku!eqpuvkvwvkqpcn!ejcnngpig!pqy!vq!gpuwtg!vjg!kuuwg!ku!rtgugtxgf!rgpfkpi!vjg!crrgcn/!
`
`XKKK/ EQPENWUKQP
`
`Hqt!cv!ngcuv!vjg!tgcuqpu!ugv!hqtvj!cdqxg-!Wpknqe!tgurgevhwnn{!tgswguvu!vjcv!vjg
`
`29!
`
`Rcig!32!qh!35
`CRRNG!GZJKDKV!2122!.!RCIG!1132
`
`

`

`Dqctf!fgp{!cnn!ejcnngpigu!kp!vjg!kpuvcpv!Rgvkvkqp/9!
`
`Fcvg<!Hgdtwct{!9-!312;!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`Tgurgevhwnn{!uwdokvvgf-!
`
`KRT312;.11167!
`W/U/!Rcvgpv!7-578-199!
`!
`
`D{<!0u0!Dtgvv!C/!Ocpitwo!
`
`Dtgvv!C/!

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket