`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`Agenda item
`3
`Title:
`Draft Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #50 v0.2.0
`(Athens, Greece, 20 – 24 August, 2007)
`Approval
`MCC Support
`
`Document for:
`Source:
`
`R1-073896
`
`Fact Summary
`Meeting:
`Dates:
`Venue:
`Host:
`Attendees:
`Documents:
`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #50
`20th through 24th August, 2007
`Athenaeum Intercontinental Hotel, Athens, GREECE
`European Friends of 3GPP
`203 delegates
`652 (including some withdrawn and post-meeting artefacts)
`
`Patrick Mérias
`ETSI Mobile Competence Center
`F-06921 Sophia Antipolis Cedex
`Tel: +33 4 92 94 42 06
`
`Patrick.merias@etsi.org
`
`APPLE 1046
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`Table of contents
`
`R1-073896
`
`
`Executive summary ......................................................................................................................................... 3
`1
`Opening of the meeting ........................................................................................................................ 5
`1.1
`Call for IPR ....................................................................................................................................................... 5
`2
`Approval of the agenda ......................................................................................................................... 5
`3
`Approval of the minutes from previous meeting ............................................................................... 5
`4
`Election of 3GPP RAN WG1 Officials ................................................................................................. 6
`5
`Liaison statement handling .................................................................................................................. 7
`6
`Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6, Rel-7 ................................................................................... 8
`7
`Evolved UTRA and UTRAN ............................................................................................................... 17
`7.1
`Updated Physical Layer Specifications ...................................................................................................... 17
`7.2
`Finalization of TS 36.211 .............................................................................................................................. 18
`7.2.1
`Downlink reference signals .................................................................................................................... 19
`7.2.2
`Uplink reference signals ......................................................................................................................... 22
`7.2.3
`Downlink Control Signaling .................................................................................................................... 25
`7.2.4
`Uplink Control Signaling ......................................................................................................................... 29
`7.2.5
`Mapping of virtual resource blocks to physical resource blocks ....................................................... 35
`7.2.6
`Remaining details on DL MIMO, TX diversity and beamforming ...................................................... 38
`7.2.7
`SSC, PSC ................................................................................................................................................. 40
`7.2.8
`PBCH ......................................................................................................................................................... 40
`7.2.9
`RACH......................................................................................................................................................... 40
`7.3
`Finalization of TS 36.212 .............................................................................................................................. 42
`7.4
`Finalization of TS 36.213 .............................................................................................................................. 47
`7.4.1
`Timing synchronization ........................................................................................................................... 47
`7.4.2
`UL/DL Power Control .............................................................................................................................. 47
`7.4.3
`Inter-cell Interference Coordination ....................................................................................................... 48
`7.4.4
`RACH timing and preamble sequence selection ................................................................................ 48
`7.4.5
`UE Procedures for downlink shared channel ...................................................................................... 49
`7.4.6
`UE Procedures for uplink shared channel ........................................................................................... 49
`7.5
`Finalization of TS 36.214 .............................................................................................................................. 50
`8.
`Combination of Higher Order Modulation and MIMO in HSDPA .................................................. 51
`9. MBSFN Downlink Optimized Broadcast 3.84Mcps TDD ............................................................... 51
`10. Closing of the meeting ........................................................................................................................ 53
`Annex A: List of participants at RAN1 #50 ............................................................................................. 54
`Annex B: TSG RAN WG1 meetings in 2007 .......................................................................................... 55
`Annex C: List of CRs agreed at RAN1#50 .............................................................................................. 56
`Annex D: List of Outgoing LSs from RAN1#50 ...................................................................................... 57
`Annex E: List of Tdocs at RAN1 #50 ....................................................................................................... 58
`Annex F: List of actions ............................................................................................................................. 59
`
`
`
` 2
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`Executive summary
`3GPP TSG WG RAN1 #50 meeting took place in the Athenaeum Intercontinental hotel, Athens, GREECE.
`
`The meeting started at 9:15 on Monday 20th August and finished at 17:00 on Friday 24th August 2007.
`
`
`
`On the first day, 20th of August, the election of WG RAN1 Chairman and Vice Chairmen took place and the result of the
`election was as follows:
`New Chairman:
`
`New Vice Chairmen:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger (Telefon AB LM Ericsson, ETSI)
`Dr. Sadayuki Abeta (NTT DoCoMo Inc. ARIB)
`Dr. Juho Lee (Samsung Electronic Co., Ltd, TTA)
`
`
`
`The week was scheduled as follows:
`
` Monday: Agenda items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7.1 and 7.2.3 – Parallel session (from 5:00PM) for 6 (TS on FDD only) and
`continuing discussions on 7.2.3.
`
` Tuesday: Agenda items 7.2.1 and 7.2.4 – Parallel session (from 6:30PM) for 6 (TS on TDD only) and continuing
`discussions on 7.2.4
`
` Wednesday: Agenda items 7.2.2 and 7.3 – Parallel session (from 7:00PM) for 7.5 and continuing discussions on
`7.3
`
` Thursday: Agenda items 7.2.5, 7.2.9, 7.2.6, 6 (reviewing early in the week decisions), 8. and 9. – Farewell dinner
`for the departing Chairmen and Vice-Chairmen at 8:30PM
`
` Friday: Agenda items revisiting 7.1, 5 and 6, 7.4.2 and 7.4.5.
`
`Agenda items 7.2.7, 7.2.8, 7.4.1, 7.4.3, 7.4.4 and 7.4.6 have not been treated due to lack of time.
`
`
`The list of action points that required RAN1 close follow-up is listed in Annex F (end of document).
`
`
`
`
`
`The number of contribution documents for this meeting was 631, and those documents were categorized as followed.
`Input
`Discussed
`Document
`Document
`25
`25
`66
`66
`540
`113
`
`Agenda Item
`Liaison statement handling
`Maintenance of Rel7
`Evolved UTRA and UTRAN
`
`
`
`3
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`
`
`The following set of documents is missing. The corresponding contributions have not been handed over by companies.
`
`R1-073271
`
`UL power control details
`
`R1-073367
`
`eNode-B Measurements
`
`Qualcomm Europe
`
`Motorola
`
`R1-073415
`
`Performance of LTE DL multi-user MIMO
`
`Freescale Semiconductor
`
`R1-073500
`
`Preamble Indication for Non-Synchronized RACH
`
`LG Electronics
`
`R1-073543
`
`PUCCH channel coding: block coding vs convolutional coding
`
`Samsung
`
`R1-073625
`
`Remaining issues on random access
`
`R1-073694
`
`Uplink Power Control Method for E-UTRA
`
`R1-073695
`
`Investigation on Effect of Overload Indicator for Uplink Inter-cell Power
`Control
`
`R1-073696
`
`Multiplexing Method of Control Signals in PDCCH
`
`Panasonic
`
`NTT DoCoMo
`
`NTT DoCoMo
`
`NTT DoCoMo
`
`4
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`Opening of the meeting
`1
`Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger (RAN1 Chairman) welcomed the participants to the 50th RAN WG1 meeting and opened the
`meeting at 09:15.
`
`Mr. Andreas Bury from NXP Semiconductors welcomed the delegates on behalf of the European Friends of 3GPP.
`
`Call for IPR
`1.1
`The Chairman drew attention to Members’ obligations under the 3GPP Partner Organizations’ IPR policies. Every
`Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Partner Organization or Organizations of which it is a
`member any IPR owned by the Individual Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become
`essential to the work of 3GPP.
`
`
`The attention of the members of this Technical Specification Group is drawn to the fact that 3GPP
`Individual Members have the obligation under the IPR Policies of their respective Organizational Partners
`to inform their respective Organizational Partners of Essential IPRs they become aware of.
`
`The members take note that they are hereby invited:
`
`to investigate in their company whether their company does own IPRs which are, or are likely to become
`Essential in respect of the work of the Technical Specification Group.
`
`to notify the Director-General, or the Chairman of their respective Organizational Partners, of all
`potential IPRs that their company may own, by means of the IPR Statement and the Licensing declaration
`forms (e.g. see the ETSI IPR forms http://webapp.etsi.org/Ipr/).
`
`Approval of the agenda
`
`
`
`
`
` 2
`
`
`
`Draft Agenda for RAN1#50 meeting
`R1-073777
`Dirk Gerstenberger (Chairman) proposed the agenda for the meeting.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: The agenda was approved.
`
`RAN1 Chairman
`
`(R1-073240)
`
`Approval of the minutes from previous meeting
`
` 3
`
`
`
`Draft report of RAN1#49b meeting
`R1-073241
`The document was presented by Patrick Mérias
`Discussion (Question / Comment): Typo mistake to be solved. Mr Chairman commented on the added information w.r.t
`post RAN#36 voting issues  this was supposed to be reported at plenary meeting.
`Decision: The document is noted and shall be revised in R1-073815 during the week.
`
`MCC Support
`
`Draft report of RAN1#49b meeting
`R1-073815
`Decision: The document is agreed.
`
`
`
`MCC Support
`
`5
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`Election of 3GPP RAN WG1 Officials
`
`4
`
`
`
`The position of Chairman had a single candidate, Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger (Telefon AB LM Ericsson, ETSI) who was
`appointed to the position of WG RAN1 Chairman.
`
`
`
`The first position of Vice Chairman had four candidates, Dr. Sadayuki Abeta (NTT DoCoMo, ARIB), Dr. Juho Lee
`(Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd, TTA), Mr. Tang Hai (CATT, CCSA) and Mr. Xiang Guang Che (Nokia Corporation,
`ETSI). The result of the first ballot for the first position was as follows:
`
`Total Votes cast was 93
`
`Dr. Sadayuki Abeta :
`
`41 votes (44,086%)
`
`Dr. Juho Lee:
`
`Mr Tang Hai:
`
`
`
`
`
`24 votes (25,806%)
`
`16 votes (17,204%)
`
`Mr Xiang Guang Che:
`
`12 votes (12,903%)
`
`Dr. Juho Lee, Mr. Tang Hai and Mr. Xiang Guang Che decided to withdraw from a second ballot round for the first
`position of Vice Chairman and Dr. Sadayuki Abeta (NTT DoCoMo, ARIB) was therefore appointed to the first position of
`WG RAN1 Vice Chairman.
`
`
`
`The second position of Vice Chairman had three candidates, Dr. Juho Lee (Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd, TTA), Mr. Tang
`Hai (CATT, CCSA) and Mr. Xiang Guang Che (Nokia Corporation, ETSI). The result of the first ballot for the second
`position was as follows:
`
`Total Votes cast was 95
`
`Dr. Juho Lee:
`
`Mr Tang Hai:
`
`
`
`
`
`64 votes (67,368%)
`
`17 votes (17,895%)
`
`Mr Xiang Guang Che:
`
`14 votes (14,737%)
`
`Mr. Tang Hai and Mr. Xiang Guang Che decided to withdraw from a second ballot round for the second position of Vice
`Chairman and Dr. Juho Lee (Samsung Electronic Co., Ltd, TTA) was therefore appointed to the second position of WG
`RAN1 Vice Chairman.
`
`
`
`6
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`5
`
`Liaison statement handling
`
`Receiver performance and enhanced CELL_FACH state
`R1-073242
`The document was presented by (…) from LGE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted and RAN1 decided to leave the answer to RAN4.
`
`RAN2, LGE
`
`Reply LS on physical layer aspects of Enhanced CELL_FACH state in
`R1-073243
`FDD from WG1
`The document was presented by Eliza Wong from Alcatel-Lucent.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`RAN2, Alcatel-
`Lucent
`
`LS on Introduction of Very low bit rate WB-AMR Combinations into
`R1-073244
`25.993
`The document was presented by Joern Krause from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Comments from other companies will be checked during the week. Reply LS document
`shall be done in R1-073816 (action point is obsolete and document is withdrawn from Tdoc list – see hereafter)
`Friday 24th
`
`RAN2, NSN
`
`There is new LS from RAN2 in R1-073880 that supersedes the previous in R1-073244.
`
`LS on Introduction of RAB Combination into 25.993
`R1-073880
`The document was presented by Joern Krause from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Extra time is provided for full check until 31/08 and Reply LS shall be in R1-073883 by the
`5th of September.
`
`RAN2, NSN
`
`
`
`LS on HS-SCCH less + MIMO
`R1-073245
`The document was presented by (…) from Qualcomm.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`R1-073713
`
`Draft reply to LS on HS-SCCH less + MIMO [R1-073245]
`
`RAN2, Qualcomm
`
`Philips, Ericsson,
`Nokia, Nokia
`Siemens
`Networks, NXP
`Semiconductors
`
`The document was presented by Matthew Baker from Philips.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted and proposal agreed in principle. Revised LS in R1-073817 shall be prepared to reflect the
`approval of related CRs.
`Friday 24th
`
`Reply LS on HS-SCCH less + MIMO
`R1-073817
`The document was presented by Matthew Baker from Philips.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`RAN1, Philips
`
`7
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`Update on Relevant RAN5 Agreed CRs to TS 34.108
`R1-073248
`The document was presented by Sadayuki Abeta from NTT DoCoMo.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`Physical Layer Aspects of eMBMS Counting
`R1-073246
`The document was presented by Nick Anderson from IPWireless.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`RAN5, NTT
`DoCoMo
`
`RAN2, IPWireless
`
`Draft reply to LS on Physical Layer Aspects of eMBMS Counting [R1-
`R1-073714
`073246]
`The document was presented by Matthew Baker from Philips.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Draft reply further to offline discussion shall be done in R1-073818 before the end of the
`week.
`Friday 24th
`
`Philips, NXP
`Semiconductors
`
`Draft reply to LS on Physical Layer Aspects of eMBMS Counting [R1-
`R1-073818
`073246]
`The document was presented by Matthew Baker from Philips.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed. Final reply in R1-073884
`
`Philips, NXP
`Semiconductors
`
`
`
`[DRAFT] LS on Complementary Time Domain Filter for Neighbour
`R1-073247
`Cell Measurements
`The document was presented by Ylva Jading from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`Liaison Statement to RAN1 on LTE Transmission of SU-1 of System
`R1-073287
`Information
`The document was presented by Erik Dahlman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`New incoming LS received during Athens’ meeting
`
`LS on the dynamic range of the UE transmission power
`R1-073857
`The document was presented by Robert Love from Motorola.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`RAN4, Ericsson
`
`RAN2, Ericsson
`
`RAN4, Motorola
`
` 6
`
`Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6, Rel-7
`
`CR to TS25.201
`
`8
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`R1-073450
`
`25201 CR035 “Minor modification related to EDCH in 1.28Mcps
`TDD”
`
`The document was presented by (…) from (…).
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Revision is to be prepared in R1-073830.
`
`R1-073830
`
`25201 CR035r1 (Rel-7, F) "Minor modification related to EDCH in
`1.28Mcps TDD"
`The document was presented by (…) from (…).
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`ZTE, CATT, TD-
`TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications
`
`
`
`ZTE, CATT, TD-TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications
`
`
`CR to TS25.211
`
`25211CR242 "PICH associated HS-SCCH for Enhanced
`R1-073324
`CELL_FACH"
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Revision is to be prepared in R1-073825.
`Thursday 23rd
`
`Nokia Siemens
`Networks, Nokia
`
`
`
`25211CR242r1 (Rel-7, F) "PICH associated HS-SCCH for Enhanced
`R1-073825
`CELL_FACH"
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`Nokia Siemens
`Networks, Nokia
`
`
`
`25211CR243 "Clarification for CPC feature"
`R1-073325
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`Nokia Siemens
`Networks, Nokia
`
`25.211CR245 Clarifications on the use of S-CCPCH pilot bits for
`R1-073336
`MBSFN FDD feature
`The document was presented by (…) from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`Ericsson
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`25211CR246 “Clarification on MICH”
`R1-073342
`The document was presented by Eliza Wong from Alcatel-Lucent.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): Mr Chairman suggested changing WI to MBMS L1 and category to A
`Decision: Document is agreed in principle, according the changes to cover sheet. Rel-6 CR (Cat F) shall also be prepared
`in R1-073826
`Thursday 23rd
`
`Alcatel-Lucent
`
`
`
`R1-073826
`
`25211CR247 (Rel-6, F) "Clarification on MICH"
`
`Alcatel-Lucent
`
`9
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`The document was presented by Eliza Wong from Alcatel-Lucent and covered both releases 6 and 7.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`25.211 CR0232r3 (Rel-7, C) “Enhanced F-DPCH”
`
`R1-073343
`The document was presented by (…) from Qualcomm.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`CR to TS25.212
`
`Qualcomm
`Europe
`
`
`
`Nokia Siemens
`
`16QAM modulation selection algorithm for HSUPA
`R1-073326
`Networks, Nokia
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN and explains issues concerning the algorithm for modulation
`selection and outlines a solution proposal. Associated CR is in R1-073327.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`25212CR252 “16QAM modulation selection for HSUPA”
`R1-073327
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`Nokia Siemens
`Networks, Nokia
`
`
`
`25.212CR253 Clarifications of MIMO
`R1-073337
`The document was presented by Johan Bergman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): MCC is asked to change font color from red to black in section 4.6B.1 when
`implementing the CR.
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`Ericsson
`
`
`
`25.212CR254 “Clarifications of CPC and MIMO”
`R1-073339
`The document was presented by Johan Bergman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`Ericsson
`
`
`
`25.212 CR255 (Rel-7, F) "RM1 transparent for HS-SCCH-less
`R1-073344
`operation"
`The document was presented by (…) from Qualcomm.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Further check is required with RAN2 to make certain the problem is taken care of in RRC.
`LS to RAN2 shall be prepared in R1-073827.
`
`Qualcomm
`Europe
`
`
`
`LS on maximum transport block size for HS-SCCH-less operation
`R1-073827
`The document was presented by Matthew Baker from Philips.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`RAN1, Philips
`
`
`
`10
`
`

`

`R1-073896
`
`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`CR to TS25.213
`
`25.213 CR090 (Rel-7, D) "Editorial changes in 25.213 for 16QAM
`R1-073346
`specification"
`The document was presented by (…) from Qualcomm.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`Qualcomm
`Europe
`
`
`
`
`CR to TS25.214
`
`25214CR452 “CPC preamble and postamble clarification for CQI
`R1-073328
`transmission”
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted and shall be revised in R1-073828.
`Friday 24th
`
`Nokia Siemens
`Networks, Nokia
`
`
`
`Nokia Siemens
`25214CR452r2 "CPC preamble and postamble clarification for CQI
`R1-073877
`Networks, Nokia
`transmission"
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN as R1-073828 has been further revised during the week.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`25214CR453 “Removal of
`R1-073329
`Inactivity_Threshold_for_UE_Grant_Monitoring definition”
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`25214CR454 “Corrections to HS-DSCH procedures for
`R1-073330
`CELL_FACH and MIMO”
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted and shall be revised in R1-073829.
`Friday 24th
`
`Nokia Siemens
`Networks, Nokia
`
`
`
`Nokia Siemens
`Networks, Nokia
`
`
`
`Nokia Siemens
`25214CR454r2 "Corrections to HS-DSCH procedures for
`R1-073861
`Networks, Nokia
`CELL_FACH and MIMO"
`The document was presented by Karri Ranta-aho from NSN as R1-073829 has been further revised during the week to
`align with “Type3” naming.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`R1-073332
`
`Rel-7 E-DPDCH gain factor calculation
`
`The document was presented by (…) from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`11
`
`Nokia, Nokia
`Siemens
`Networks
`
`
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073333
`
`25214CR456 “Correction to Rel-7 E-DPDCH gain factor
`calculation”
`The document was presented by (…) from NSN.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted and shall be revised in R1-073831.
`Friday 24th
`
`R1-073896
`
`Nokia, Nokia
`Siemens
`Networks
`
`
`
`Nokia, Nokia Siemens
`25214 CR456r2 (Rel-7,F) "Correction to Rel-7 E-DPDCH gain factor
`R1-073864
`Networks, Philips
`calculation"
`The document was presented by (…) from NSN as R1-073831 has been further revised during the week.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed in principle and final revision to make the correct change marks in R1-073866.
`
`
`
`R1-073334
`
`Update to 64QAM CQI tables
`
`The document was presented by Arto Lethi from Nokia.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`R1-073335
`
`25214CR457 “Clarification to applicability of CQI tables in Rel. 7”
`
`The document was presented by Arto Lethi from Nokia.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`Nokia, Nokia
`Siemens
`Networks
`
`Nokia, Nokia
`Siemens
`Networks
`
`
`
`
`
`25.214CR458 “Clarifications of MIMO and 64QAM”
`R1-073338
`The document was presented by Johan Bergman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted and suggestion is made for offline discussion to merge, if possible, R1-073335 and R1-
`073338. Merged CR should be in R1-073832.
`Thursday 23rd
`
`Ericsson
`
`
`
`25.214 CR458r1 (Rel-7, F) "Correction of 64QAM CQI tables"
`R1-073832
`The document was presented by Johan Bergman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`25.214CR459 Clarifications of CPC
`R1-073340
`The document was presented by Johan Bergman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`Ericsson, Philips, Nokia,
`Nokia Siemens Networks
`
`Ericsson
`
`
`
`25.214 CR460 (Rel-7, F) "E-DPDCH scaling when UE is at max
`R1-073345
`power"
`The document was presented by Juan Montojo from Qualcomm.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Discuss off line during the week and revised CR shall be in R1-073862.
`
`Qualcomm
`Europe
`
`
`
`12
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`Friday 24th
`
`R1-073896
`
`25.214 CR460r1 (Rel-7, F) "E-DPDCH scaling when UE is at max
`R1-073862
`power"
`The document was presented by Juan Montojo from Qualcomm.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed in principle and final revision to make the correct change marks in R1-073865.
`
`Qualcomm Europe
`
`
`
`R1-073812
`CQI tables for HSDPA MIMO
`The document was presented by Johan Bergman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`Ericsson
`
`
`
`R1-073838
`25.214 CR462r1 (Rel-7, F) "Correction of MIMO CQI tables
`The document was presented by Johan Bergman from Ericsson.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted. Due to late revision, grant is given for email approval until 31st August.
`
`Ericsson, Philips, Nokia,
`Nokia Siemens Networks
`
`
`CR to TS25.215
`
`25215 CR176 “Adding GANSS related measurements in the FDD
`R1-073341
`physical layer measurements”
`The document was presented by Eliza Wong from Alcatel-Lucent.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): Mr Chairman suggested changing WI to MBMS L1 and category to A
`Decision: Document is noted and shall be revised in R1-073814.
`Thursday 23rd
`
`Alcatel-Lucent,
`Orange
`
`
`
`25215 CR176r1 "Adding GANSS related measurements in the FDD
`R1-073814
`physical layer measurements"
`The document was presented by Eliza Wong from Alcatel-Lucent.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`Alcatel-Lucent, Orange
`
`
`CR to TS25.221
`
`R1-073807
`
`Introduce TD-SCDMA industry standard in CCSA to 3GPP
`
`RITT, CMCC,
`ZTE, CATT, TD-
`TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications,
`Alcatel Shanghai
`Bell
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE and gives an introduction of the main differences between TD-SCDMA
`industry standard in CCSA and 3GPP (1.28Mcps TDD specification). Main changes for 3GPP release 7 specifications are
`also introduced.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): Mr Chairman suggested to discuss the topic in RAN and to create the WI definition.
`Technical comments are welcomed from other companies but due to late submission, the analyzing of the proposed CRs
`was not possible in Athens. Extra time should be granted for further investigation.
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`(R1-073448)
`
`13
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`R1-073443
`
`25221 CR144 “Introduction of multi-frequency operation for
`1.28Mcps TDD”
`
`RITT, CMCC,
`ZTE, CATT, TD-
`TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications,
`Alcatel Shanghai
`Bell
`
`
`
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): No comments
`Decision: Document is noted. Extra time for further review is given and CR shall be reviewed on 23rd August.
`Thursday 23rd
`Decision: Document is technically endorsed. It’s asked RAN to clarify the work item situation.
`
`
`
`TFCI mapping for S-CCPCH and 16QAM for 1.28 Mcps TDD
`
`CATT
`R1-073523
`MBSFN
`The document was presented by (…) from CATT and proposes a modification of the mapping of TFCI code words on S-
`CCPCH frames using 16QAM. It also demonstrates why TFCI physical channel bits should be mapped on a modulus
`signal point constellation.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`25221 CR145 (Rel-7, F) “TFCI mapping for S-CCPCH and
`R1-073524
`16QAM for 1.28 Mcps TDD MBSFN”
`The document was presented by (…) from CATT.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): No comments
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`CR to TS25.222
`
`CATT
`
`R1-073444
`
`25222 CR136 “Introduction of multi-frequency operation for
`1.28Mcps TDD”
`
`RITT, CMCC,
`ZTE, CATT, TD-
`TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications,
`Alcatel Shanghai
`Bell
`
`
`
`
`
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): No comments
`Decision: Document is noted. Extra time for further review is given and CR shall be reviewed on 23rd August.
`Thursday 23rd
`Decision: Document is technically endorsed. It’s asked RAN to clarify the work item situation.
`
`
`
`25222 CR137 (Rel-7, F) “TFCI mapping for S-CCPCH and
`R1-073525
`16QAM for 1.28 Mcps TDD MBSFN”
`The document was presented by (…) from CATT.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): No comments
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`CATT
`
`
`
`R1-073796
`
`Improved E-HICH signature allocation for LCR-TDD
`
`Spreadtrum
`Communications
`
`(R1-073471)
`
`14
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`R1-073896
`
`The document was presented by Ke Wang from CATT on behalf of Spreadtrum. Simulation results for the detection
`performance of E-HICH of LCR TDD and a modification on the allocation of E-HICH signature are proposed. Related CR
`to TS25222 is in R1-073797.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is noted.
`
`Spreadtrum
`25222 CR138r1 (Rel-7, C) “Improved E-HICH signature allocation
`R1-073797
`Communications
`method for LCR-TDD”
`The document was presented by Ke Wang from CATT on behalf of Spreadtrum.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`(R1-073472)
`
`
`CR to TS25.223
`
`R1-073445
`
`25223 CR046 “Introduction of multi-frequency operation for
`1.28Mcps TDD”
`
`RITT, CMCC,
`ZTE, CATT, TD-
`TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications,
`Alcatel Shanghai
`Bell
`
`
`
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): Typo error in last sentence needs correction. HS-DSCH shall be deleted.
`Decision: Document is noted. CR shall be revised in R1-073839.
`Thursday 23rd
`
`RITT, CMCC, ZTE,
`CATT, TD-TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications, Alcatel
`Shanghai Bell
`
`R1-073839
`
`25223 CR046r1 "Introduction of multi-frequency operation for
`1.28Mcps TDD"
`
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is technically endorsed. It’s asked RAN to clarify the work item situation.
`
`CR to TS25.224
`
`R1-073446
`
`25224 CR163 “Introduction of multi-frequency operation for
`1.28Mcps TDD”
`
`RITT, CMCC,
`ZTE, CATT, TD-
`TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications,
`Alcatel Shanghai
`Bell
`
`
`
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment): No comments
`Decision: Document is noted. New CR shall be prepared to make the change in annex A1 (R1-073840)
`Thursday 23rd
`
`R1-073840
`
`25224 CR163r1 "Introduction of multi-frequency operation for
`1.28Mcps TDD"
`
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is technically endorsed. It’s asked RAN to clarify the work item situation.
`
`RITT, CMCC, ZTE,
`CATT, TD-TECH,
`Spreadtrum
`Communications, Alcatel
`Shanghai Bell
`
`15
`
`

`

`
`3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #50b
`Shanghai, China, 8 – 12 October, 2007
`
`
`
`25224 CR164r1 “Improvement on the power control of E-PUCH in
`R1-073808
`1.28Mcps TDD”
`The document was presented by (…) from ZTE.
`Discussion (Question / Comment):
`Decision: Document is agreed.
`
`
`
`R1-073896
`
`ZTE
`
`(R1-073449)
`
`R1-073853
`