IPR2020-00308, No. 2009-17 Exhibit - Exhibit 2009 (P.T.A.B. Apr. 17, 2020)

From: Whilt, Nicholas nwhilt@omm.com
`Subject: RE: Neodron v. Lenovo Group Ltd et al
`Date: April 7, 2020 at 11:37 AM
`To: Reza Mirzaie rmirzaie@raklaw.com, Fountain, Aaron aaron.fountain@dlapiper.com
`Cc: Sanabria, Cecilia Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan.com, Mireya Ballesteros mballesteros@raklaw.com,
`Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team@ﬁnnegan.com, rak_neodron@raklaw.com, Dell-Neodron-ITC
`Dell-Neodron-ITC@alston.com, #WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM@omm.com,
`#Neodron-Samsung-OMM NeodronSamsungOMM@omm.com, DLA 1162 dla1162@dlapiper.com, AmazonNeodronITC
`AmazonNeodronITC@mofo.com, CTyler@perkinscoie.com, Wang, Chao (Perkins Coie) WWang@perkinscoie.com
`Reza,
`For the ‘747 Patent, Samsung will agree with Neodron’s proposed compromise
`construction of “Plain and ordinary meaning, which is ‘ﬁrst electrode in which the
`resistance of the material varies in relation to applied force’”.
`Regards,
`Nick
`
`From: Reza Mirzaie <rmirzaie@raklaw.com>
`Sent: Thursday, April 2, 2020 8:27 PM
`To: Fountain, Aaron <aaron.fountain@dlapiper.com>
`Cc: Sanabria, Cecilia <Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan.com>; Mireya Ballesteros
`<mballesteros@raklaw.com>; Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team <Lenovo_Neodron-
`N.D.Cal_Team@ﬁnnegan.com>; rak_neodron@raklaw.com; Dell-Neodron-ITC <Dell-
`Neodron-ITC@alston.com>; #WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM
`<WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM@omm.com>; #Neodron-Samsung-OMM
`<NeodronSamsungOMM@omm.com>; DLA 1162 <dla1162@dlapiper.com>;
`AmazonNeodronITC <AmazonNeodronITC@mofo.com>; CTyler@perkinscoie.com;
`Wang, Chao (Perkins Coie) <WWang@perkinscoie.com>
`Subject: Re: Neodron v. Lenovo Group Ltd et al
`
`[EXTERNAL MESSAGE]
`
`Hello all,
`
`Please see the attached doc, with some additional compromises. We will endeavor to get you
`all additional information and compromises as well, but wanted to get you this third round
`of slight modifications in the meantime.
`
`Thanks.
`Reza
`
`Reza Mirzaie
`Russ August & Kabat
`12424 Wilshire Blvd., 12th Floor
`Los Angeles, CA 90025
`(310) 979-8251
`rmirzaie@raklaw.com
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`On Apr 2, 2020, at 11:23 AM, Reza Mirzaie <rmirzaie@raklaw.com> wrote:
`
`We can use this one: 424-292-2492.
`
`Talk soon.
`
`Reza Mirzaie
`Russ August & Kabat
`12424 Wilshire Blvd., 12th Floor
`Los Angeles, CA 90025
`(310) 979-8251
`rmirzaie@raklaw.com
`
`On Apr 2, 2020, at 11:11 AM, Fountain, Aaron
`<aaron.fountain@dlapiper.com> wrote:
`
`The 90 minute window works for DLA. Is there a call in number?
`
`
`Aaron Fountain
`
`DLA Piper LLP (US)
`401 Congress Avenue Ste 2500
`Austin, TX 78701-3799
`512.457.7190
`
`1000 Louisiana Street Ste 2800
`Houston, TX 77002-5005
`713.425.8490
`
`aaron.fountain@dlapiper.com
`www.dlapiper.com
`
`From: Sanabria, Cecilia <Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, April 01, 2020 10:27 PM
`To: rmirzaie@raklaw.com
`Cc: Mireya Ballesteros <mballesteros@raklaw.com>;
`Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team <Lenovo_Neodron-
`N.D.Cal_Team@ﬁnnegan.com>; rak_neodron@raklaw.com; Dell-
`Neodron-ITC <Dell-Neodron-ITC@alston.com>;
`#WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM
`<WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM@omm.com>; #Neodron-
`Samsung-OMM <NeodronSamsungOMM@omm.com>; DLA
`1162 <dla1162@dlapiper.com>; AmazonNeodronITC
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`1162 <dla1162@dlapiper.com>; AmazonNeodronITC
`<AmazonNeodronITC@mofo.com>; CTyler@perkinscoie.com;
`Wang, Chao (Perkins Coie) <WWang@perkinscoie.com>
`Subject: RE: Neodron v. Lenovo Group Ltd et al
`
`[EXTERNAL]
`Works for Lenovo and Motorola.
`Best,
`Cecilia
`
`From: Reza <rmirzaie@raklaw.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, April 1, 2020 11:16 PM
`To: Sanabria, Cecilia <Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan.com>
`Cc: Mireya Ballesteros <mballesteros@raklaw.com>;
`Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team <Lenovo_Neodron-
`N.D.Cal_Team@ﬁnnegan.com>; rak_neodron@raklaw.com; Dell-
`Neodron-ITC <Dell-Neodron-ITC@alston.com>;
`#WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM
`<WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM@omm.com>; #Neodron-
`Samsung-OMM <NeodronSamsungOMM@omm.com>; DLA
`1162 <dla1162@dlapiper.com>; AmazonNeodronITC
`<AmazonNeodronITC@mofo.com>; Tyler, M. Craig (Perkins
`Coie) <CTyler@perkinscoie.com>; Wang, Chao (Perkins Coie)
`<WWang@perkinscoie.com>
`Subject: Re: Neodron v. Lenovo Group Ltd et al
`
`EXTERNAL Email:
`
`We are currently not available for that entire period of time, but
`can be available from Noon to 1:30 PM PST. Please conﬁrm that
`90-minute window works.
`
`Thanks.
`Reza
`
`
`On Apr 1, 2020, at 8:08 PM, Sanabria, Cecilia
`<Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan.com> wrote:
`
`Dear Reza,
`Thank you. We will review these for discussion
`during our call.
`Regarding the call, we will likely need at least a two-
`hour call to have a meaningful meet and confer on
`the dozen or so patents Neodron asserts against the
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`the dozen or so patents Neodron asserts against the
`various Defendants. We are still conﬁrming
`availability amongst all the defendants, but
`tentatively, we propose a call for tomorrow at noon-
`2pm Paciﬁc. Please conﬁrm you are available during
`that time. Otherwise, please provide us with your
`availability for a two-hour call tomorrow. Given that in
`the WDTX cases briefs are due in about two weeks,
`we have a CMC in the NDCA case on Friday, and
`that the parties exchanged constructions over a
`week ago, we want to move forward with the meet
`and confer asap.
`Best,
`Cecilia
`
`From: Reza Mirzaie <rmirzaie@raklaw.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, April 1, 2020 10:05 PM
`To: Sanabria, Cecilia
`<Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan.com>
`Cc: Mireya Ballesteros <mballesteros@raklaw.com>;
`Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team <Lenovo_Neodron-
`N.D.Cal_Team@ﬁnnegan.com>;rak_neodron@rakla
`w.com; Dell-Neodron-ITC <Dell-Neodron-
`ITC@alston.com>;
`#WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM
`<WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM@omm.com>;
`#Neodron-Samsung-OMM
`<NeodronSamsungOMM@omm.com>; DLA 1162
`<dla1162@dlapiper.com>; AmazonNeodronITC
`<AmazonNeodronITC@mofo.com>; Tyler, M. Craig
`(Perkins Coie) <CTyler@perkinscoie.com>; Wang,
`Chao (Perkins Coie) <WWang@perkinscoie.com>
`Subject: Re: Neodron v. Lenovo Group Ltd et al
`
`EXTERNAL Email:
`
`Hello,
`
`Please see the attached redlined document for
`tomorrow’s discussion. We should now be in
`agreement on a few terms.
`
`On the disputed terms for which one or more
`Defendants believe the term is indeﬁnite, per our
`most recent conversation, though defendants have
`not stated speciﬁcally why they believe the term is
`indeﬁnite, we have volunteered exemplary intrinsic-
`record cites on the terms. We do this despite: (a)
`believing Defendants’ position to be objectively
`without merit in light of the relevant legal and
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`without merit in light of the relevant legal and
`POSITA standards; (b) having no obligation to do so;
`and (c) the fact that the Defendants bear the burden
`on indeﬁniteness. We hope this will lead to a
`resolution of at least some of the many indeﬁniteness
`arguments Defendants currently have asserted.
`
`Thanks. Talk soon.
`Reza
`
`
`Reza Mirzaie
`Russ August & Kabat
`12424 Wilshire Blvd., 12th Floor
`Los Angeles, CA 90025
`(310) 979-8251
`rmirzaie@raklaw.com
`
`
`On Apr 1, 2020, at 7:51 AM, Reza
`Mirzaie <rmirzaie@raklaw.com> wrote:
`
`Hi,
`
`We are tied up all day today, but are free
`to chat tomorrow at 10 or 10:30 am PST
`and free again between Noon and 1 pm
`PST. Any of those times work for your
`side?
`
`In the meantime, we will send additional
`compromises, edits and other
`clariﬁcations. We will also send some of
`the other cites we discussed during
`Monday’s call.
`
`If Defendants have any compromises,
`please feel free to send those in the
`meantime as well.
`
`Thanks
`Reza
`
`Reza Mirzaie
`Russ August & Kabat
`12424 Wilshire Blvd., 12th Floor
`Los Angeles, CA 90025
`(310) 979-8251
`rmirzaie@raklaw.com
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`rmirzaie@raklaw.com
`
`
`On Mar 31, 2020, at 7:18
`PM, Sanabria, Cecilia
`<Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan
`.com> wrote:
`
`Hi Reza,
`
`To follow up on our call on
`Monday, please let us know
`if you are available tomorrow
`afternoon to continue
`discussing the claim
`construction issues. We can
`be available after 1 pm ET.
`Best,
`Cecilia
`
`From: Reza Mirzaie
`<rmirzaie@raklaw.com>
`Sent: Monday, March 30,
`2020 11:16 AM
`To: Sanabria, Cecilia
`<Cecilia.Sanabria@ﬁnnegan
`.com>
`Cc: Mireya Ballesteros
`<mballesteros@raklaw.com>
`; Lenovo_Neodron-
`N.D.Cal_Team
`<Lenovo_Neodron-
`N.D.Cal_Team@ﬁnnegan.co
`m>; rak_neodron@raklaw.co
`m; Dell-Neodron-ITC <Dell-
`Neodron-ITC@alston.com>;
`#WDTXNEODRONSAMSUN
`GOMM
`<WDTXNEODRONSAMSUN
`GOMM@omm.com>;
`#Neodron-Samsung-OMM
`<NeodronSamsungOMM@o
`mm.com>; DLA 1162
`<dla1162@dlapiper.com>;
`AmazonNeodronITC
`<AmazonNeodronITC@mof
`o.com>; Tyler, M. Craig
`(Perkins Coie)
`<CTyler@perkinscoie.com>;
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`<CTyler@perkinscoie.com>;
`Wang, Chao (Perkins Coie)
`<WWang@perkinscoie.com>
`Subject: Re: Neodron v.
`Lenovo Group Ltd et al
`
`EXTERNAL Email:
`
`Hi,
`
`We can use this dial-in: 424-
`292-2492.
`
`Talk soon.
`
`Reza Mirzaie
`Russ August & Kabat
`12424 Wilshire Blvd., 12th
`Floor
`Los Angeles, CA 90025
`(310) 979-8251
`rmirzaie@raklaw.com
`
`
`On Mar 30,
`2020, at 8:10
`AM, Sanabria,
`Cecilia
`<Cecilia.Sanabri
`a@ﬁnnegan.com
`> wrote:
`
`Hi Reza,
`
`Thank you for
`your email. We
`can discuss
`these during our
`meet and confer
`today at noon
`Paciﬁc/3pm ET.
`If you can
`circulate a dial-in
`so the
`defendants can
`join, we’d greatly
`appreciate it.
`
`Best,
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`Best,
`Cecilia
`
`From: Reza
`<rmirzaie@rakla
`w.com>
`Sent: Thursday,
`March 26, 2020
`1:27 AM
`To: Sanabria,
`Cecilia
`<Cecilia.Sanabri
`a@ﬁnnegan.com
`c: Mireya
`Ballesteros
`<mballesteros@
`raklaw.com>;
`Lenovo_Neodro
`n-N.D.Cal_Team
`<Lenovo_Neodr
`on-
`N.D.Cal_Team@
`ﬁnnegan.com>; r
`ak_neodron@ra
`klaw.com; Dell-
`Neodron-ITC
`<Dell-Neodron-
`ITC@alston.com
`>;
`#WDTXNEODR
`ONSAMSUNGO
`MM
`<WDTXNEODR
`ONSAMSUNGO
`MM@omm.com
`>; #Neodron-
`Samsung-OMM
`<NeodronSamsu
`ngOMM@omm.c
`om>; DLA 1162
`<dla1162@dlapi
`per.com>;
`AmazonNeodron
`ITC
`<AmazonNeodro
`nITC@mofo.com
`>; Tyler, M. Craig
`(Perkins Coie)
`<CTyler@perkin
`scoie.com>;
`
`>C
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`scoie.com>;
`Wang, Chao
`(Perkins Coie)
`<WWang@perki
`nscoie.com>
`Subject: Re:
`Neodron v.
`Lenovo Group
`Ltd et al
`
`EXTERNAL Email:
`
`Hello Cecilia,
` think we might
`be talking past
`each other.
`
`For a number of
`terms that we do
`not believe
`require
`construction,
`we’ve stated
`“Plain and
`ordinary
`meaning; no
`construction
`necessary.” We
`just don’t think
`we need to re-
`word the claim
`language for
`these.
`
`For a similar
`number of terms,
`you all say
`essentially the
`same thing:
`“Plain and
`ordinary
`meaning, which
`is” followed by a
`quote of the
`disputed claim
`language.
`Objectively,
`that is virtually
`identical to what
`we did and
`
` I
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`we did and
`it indicates you
`also don’t
`believe the term
`requires
`construction.
`
`In any event, per
`my email
`yesterday, we
`have i moused
`additional
`compromise
`constructions.
`They are
`reﬂected in the
`attached
`document.
`
`Happy to have a
`follow-up chat on
`Monday at
`Noon. By the
`way, I assume
`you mean Noon
`PST, right?
`
`Talk soon.
`Reza
`
`
`
`
`On
`Mar
`25,
`2020
`, at
`1:23
`PM,
`San
`abria
`ecil
`ia
`<Ce
`cilia.
`San
`abria
`@ﬁn
`nega
`
`,C
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`nega
`n.co
`m>
`wrot
`e:
`
`Dear
`Rez
`a,
`The
`parti
`es
`were
`requi
`red
`to
`exch
`ange
`prop
`osed
`cons
`tructi
`ons
`last
`Frid
`ay.
` Yet,
`nearl
`y a
`wee
`ater,
`Neo
`dron
`has
`conti
`nued
`to
`fail
`to
`provi
`de
`its
`prop
`osal
`s for
`the
`vast
`majo
`rity
`
`kl
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`rity
`of
`the
`term
`s at
`issu
`e,
`inste
`ad
`mer
`ely
`sayi
`ng
`"plai
`nd
`ordin
`ary
`mea
`ning”
`with
`out
`indic
`ating
`what
`that
`plain
`and
`ordin
`ary
`mea
`ning
`is.
` In
`parti
`cular
`, if
`you
`disa
`gree
`that
`what
`defe
`ndan
`ts
`have
`offer
`ed in
`their
`prop
`osed
`
`na
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`osed
`cons
`tructi
`ons
`is in
`fact
`the
`plain
`and
`ordin
`ary
`mea
`ning
`of a
`parti
`cular
`term
`hen
`the
`parti
`es
`have
`isp
`ute
`abou
`lai
`cop
`e, so
`Neo
`dron
`need
`s to
`provi
`de
`its
`alter
`nate
`expl
`anati
`on of
`the
`plain
`and
`ordin
`ary
`mea
`ning.
` We
`
`ms
`
`tc
`
`,t
`
`ad
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

` We
`prop
`osed
`eet
`and
`conf
`er
`with
`all
`Defe
`ndan
`ts on
`Frid
`ay,
`but
`we
`need
`to
`have
`your
`prop
`osed
`cons
`tructi
`ons
`well
`in
`adva
`nce
`to
`have
`ea
`ningf
`ul
`meet
`and
`conf
`er.
`Plea
`se
`conﬁ
`rm
`you
`will
`provi
`de
`us
`with
`ALL
`
`am
`
`am
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ALL
`of
`your
`cons
`tructi
`ons
`toda
`y.
`We
`can
`mov
`e the
`meet
`and
`conf
`er to
`Mon
`day
`at
`noon
`.
`Best
`ecil
`ia
`Fro
`m: R
`eza
`Mirz
`aie
`<rmi
`rzaie
`@ra
`klaw.
`com
`>
`Sent
`: Tu
`esda
`y,
`Marc
`h 24,
`2020
`11:3
`M
`To:
`San
`abria
`ecil
`
`,C
`
`,C
`
`0P
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`Cecil
`ia
`<Ce
`cilia.
`San
`abria
`@ﬁn
`nega
`n.co
`m>
`Cc:
`Mire
`ya
`Balle
`stero
`mb
`alles
`teros
`@ra
`klaw.
`com
`>;
`Leno
`vo_
`Neo
`dron
`.D.
`Cal_
`Tea
`Len
`ovo_
`Neo
`dron
`.D.
`Cal_
`Tea
`m@f
`inne
`gan.
`com
`>; ra
`k_ne
`odro
`n@r
`akla
`w.co
`m;
`
`m<
`
`-N
`
`s<
`
`-N
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`m;
`Dell-
`Neo
`dron
`-ITC
`<Del
`l-
`Neo
`dron
`TC
`@al
`ston.
`com
`>;
`#WD
`TXN
`EOD
`RON
`SAM
`SUN
`GO
`MM
`<WD
`TXN
`EOD
`RON
`SAM
`SUN
`GO
`MM
`@o
`mm.
`com
`>;
`#Ne
`odro
`n-
`Sam
`sung
`M
`Ne
`odro
`nSa
`msu
`ngO
`MM
`@o
`mm.
`
`M<
`
`-I
`
`-O
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`mm.
`com
`>;
`DLA
`1162
`<dla
`1162
`@dl
`apip
`er.co
`m>;
`Ama
`zon
`Neo
`dron
`ITC
`<Am
`azon
`Neo
`dron
`ITC
`@m
`ofo.c
`om>;
`Tyler
`, M.
`Crai
`Per
`kins
`Coie
`CT
`yler
`@pe
`rkins
`coie.
`com
`>;
`Wan
`g,
`Cha
`Per
`kins
`Coie
`W
`Wan
`g@p
`erkin
`
`)<
`
`o(
`
`g(
`
`)<
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`erkin
`scoi
`e.co
`m>
`Subj
`ect:
`Re:
`Neo
`dron
`v.
`Leno
`vo
`Grou
`p Ltd
`et al
`
`EXTE
`RNA
`L Em
`ail:
`
`Hell
`o,
`
`Here
`are
`som
`reli
`mina
`ry
`com
`pro
`mise
`cons
`tructi
`ons.
`As
`you
`will
`see,
`we
`are
`now
`in
`agre
`eme
`nt on
`som
`ddit
`ional
`
`ea
`
`ep
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ional
`disp
`uted
`term
`s—
`and
`clos
`e to
`agre
`eme
`nt on
`som
`the
`isp
`uted
`term
`s.
`
`We
`likely
`will
`send
`you
`oup
`le
`mor
`om
`pro
`mise
`prop
`osal
`omo
`rrow,
`likely
`for
`disp
`uted
`term
`s for
`the
`’072,
`’784,
`and/
`or
`the
`’960
`
`eo
`
`rd
`
`ac
`
`ec
`
`st
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`’960
`pate
`nts.
`
`Talk
`soon
`ez
`a
`
`
`Rez
`irz
`aie
`Rus
`ug
`ust
`ab
`at
`1242
`ils
`hire
`Blvd.
`2th
`Floo
`os
`Ang
`eles,
`CA
`9002
`310
`79-
`8251
`rmirz
`aie
`@ra
`klaw.
`com
`
`
`4W
`
`,1
`
`rL
`
`5(
`
`)9
`
`On
`
`.R
`
`aM
`
`sA
`
`&K
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`nMar24,2020,at1:58PM,RezaMirzaie<rmirzaie@raklaw.co
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`om>wrote: HelloCecilia, Wehavebeendiligentlyworki
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ingthroughtheseandcanprovideyouwithmanycompromiseco
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`onstrictionslatertoday,likelyaround730or8PMPST. Th
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`anks, Reza RezaMirzaieRussAugust&Kabat12424Wilshir
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`reBlvd.,12thFloorLosAngeles,CA90025(310)979-8251rmi
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`irzaie@raklaw.com
`
`OnMar24,2020,at12:37PM,Sanabria
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`a,Cecilia<Cecilia.Sanabria@finnegan.com>wrote: DearK
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`Kent, Wewantedtofollowuponthebelowaswehavenotheardf
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`fromNeodron. Pleaseconfirmyouwillprovideusyourcompr
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`romiseclaimconstructionpositionsforthetermsatissue,
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`,includingbyprovidingNeodron’sviewofwhatconstitutest
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`the“plainandordinarymeaning”ofeachrelevantclaimterm
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`m,todayby5pmET. Best,Cecilia From: Sanabria,Cecilia
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`a<Cecilia.Sanabria@finnegan.com> Sent: Monday,March
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`h23,20202:58PMTo: MireyaBallesteros<mballesteros@ra
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`aklaw.com>;Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team<Lenovo_Neodr
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ron-N.D.Cal_Team@finnegan.com>Cc: rak_neodron@raklaw
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`w.com;Dell-Neodron-ITC<Dell-Neodron-ITC@alston.com>
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`>;#WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM<WDTXNEODRONSAMSUNGOMM@omm.
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`.com>;#Neodron-Samsung-OMM<NeodronSamsungOMM@omm.co
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`om>;DLA1162<dla1162@dlapiper.com>;AmazonNeodronITC<A
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`AmazonNeodronITC@mofo.com>;Tyler,M.Craig(PerkinsCoi
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ie)<CTyler@perkinscoie.com>;Wang,Chao(PerkinsCoie)<
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`<WWang@perkinscoie.com>Subject: RE:Neodronv.LenovoG
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`GroupLtdetal DearKent, Wereceivedyourproposedconstru
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`uctionsandweredisappointedtoseethatNeodronfailedtop
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`provideconstructionsforthemajorityofthetermsintheli
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ist. Thisisneitherthegoaloftheexchangessetforthunde
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`erthelocalrulesnoragoodfaithstarttotheparties’negot
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`iationsonclaimconstruction. Furthertoourdiscussions
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`sduringtheM&CforLenovoandMotorolalastweek,pleasepro
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ovideusyourcompromiseclaimconstructionpositionsfort
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`thetermsatissueforallDefendantsintheNeodronWDTXandN
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`NDCALcases,includingbyprovidingNeodron’sviewofwhatco
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`onstitutesthe“plainandordinarymeaning”ofeachrelevan
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ntclaimterm,bytomorrow,Tuesdayat5pmETsowecanconside
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`erthem. Forthesakeofefficiency,allofthepartiescanth
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`henmeetandconferonFridayatnoonET,startingwiththepate
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`entsassertedagainstallDefendants. Best,Cecilia Ceci
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`iliaSanabriaAttorneyatLaw | bioFinnegan,Henderson,Farabow,
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`,Garrett&Dunner,LLP901NewYorkAvenue,NW,Washington,DC20001-
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`-4413202.408.4478|fax:202.408.4400| Cecilia.Sanabria@finne
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`egan.com | www.finnegan.com From: MireyaBallesteros<mb
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ballesteros@raklaw.com> Sent: Friday,March20,20205:
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`:54PMTo: Lenovo_Neodron-N.D.Cal_Team<Lenovo_Neodron-
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`-N.D.Cal_Team@finnegan.com>Cc: rak_neodron@raklaw.c
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`comSubject: Neodronv.LenovoGroupLtdetal EXTERNAL Ema
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`ail: DearCounsel: Attachedforservicepleasefindthef
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`followingdocument:
`
`·
`
`PLAINTIFFNEODRONLTD.’SPROPOSED
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`CONSTRUCTIONSPURSUANTTOP.L.R.4-2(a)
`
`
`
` Thankyou. M
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`MireyaBallesterosRussAugust&KabatAssistanttoMarcA.Fenster,
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`, BrianLedahl,AdamS.Hoffman,RezaMirzaie, JamesTsueiandShan
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`niWilliams12424WilshireBoulevard 12thFloorLosAngeles,CA900
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`025310826-7474310826-6991Faxmballesteros@raklaw.com ******
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`***************** *********** ** IRSCircular230Notice: Th
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`his communicationisnotintendedtobe usedandcannotbeused,for
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`r the purposeofavoidingU.S.federaltax-relatedpenaltiesorpr
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`romoting, marketing orrecommendingto anotherpartyanytax-r
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`elatedmatter addressedherein. -------------------- ------
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`------- -- Thiscommunicationshallnotcreate, waiveormodify
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`yanyright, obligation orliability,orbeconstruedto containo
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`orbeanelectronic signature. Thiscommunicationmay contain
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

` informationthatislegallyprivileged, confidentialorexemptf
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`from disclosure,andisintendedonlyfor thenamedaddressee(s).
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`. Ifyouare nottheintendedrecipient,please notethatanydiss
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`semination, distribution,orcopyingofthis communicationis p
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`prohibited. Thise-mailmessageisintendedonlyforindividual(s)towhomitisa
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`addressedandmaycontaininformationthatisprivileged,confidential,proprietary,orot
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`therwiseexemptfromdisclosureunderapplicablelaw.Ifyoubelieveyouhavereceivedthism
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`messageinerror,pleaseadvisethesenderbyreturne-mailanddeleteitfromyourmailbox.T
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`Thankyou.
`
`
`
`
`
`This e-
`mail
`messa
`ge is
`intende
`d only
`for
`individu
`al(s) to
`whom
`it is
`addres
`sed
`and
`may
`contain
`informa
`tion
`that is
`privileg
`ed,
`confide
`ntial,
`propriet
`ary, or
`otherwi
`se
`exempt
`from
`disclos
`ure
`under
`applica
`ble law.
`If you
`believe
`you
`have
`receive
`d this
`messa
`ge in
`error,
`please
`advise
`the
`sender
`by
`return
`e-mail
`and
`delete
`it from
`your
`mailbo
`x.
`Thank
`you.
`
`This e-mail message is
`intended only for
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`

`intended only for
`individual(s) to whom it is
`addressed and may
`contain information that is
`privileged, confidential,
`proprietary, or otherwise
`exempt from disclosure
`under applicable law. If
`you believe you have
`received this message in
`error, please advise the
`sender by return e-mail
`and delete it from your
`mailbox. Thank you.
`
`
`
`This e-mail message is intended only for
`individual(s) to whom it is addressed and
`may contain information that is privileged,
`confidential, proprietary, or otherwise
`exempt from disclosure under applicable
`law. If you believe you have received this
`message in error, please advise the sender
`by return e-mail and delete it from your
`mailbox. Thank you.
`
`
`
`
`
`This e-mail message is intended only for individual(s) to whom it is addressed
`and may contain information that is privileged, confidential, proprietary, or
`otherwise exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If you believe you have
`received this message in error, please advise the sender by return e-mail and
`delete it from your mailbox. Thank you.
`
`This e-mail message is intended only for individual(s) to whom it is addressed and may contain
`information that is privileged, confidential, proprietary, or otherwise exempt from disclosure under
`applicable law. If you believe you have received this message in error, please advise the sender
`by return e-mail and delete it from your mailbox. Thank you.
`
`The information contained in this email may be confidential and/or legally privileged.
`It has been sent for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). If the reader of this
`message is not an intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any unauthorized
`review, use, disclosure, dissemination, distribution, or copying of this communication,
`or any of its contents, is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication
`in error, please reply to the sender and destroy all copies of the message. To contact
`us directly, send to postmaster@dlapiper.com. Thank you.
`
`Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al v. Neodron Ltd
`Exhibit 2009
`IPR2020-00308
`
`

`