(-
`
`C
`
`i compass.dooketnavigatortomfipatentfbinderf—“JIG
`
`a.
`
`{T O 8 o
`
` l Robins Hap-Ian LLP fl Westlaw its Lee-ass
`
`fig Docketi‘xautgator
`
`L][ FFIE
`
`L][ FRCF' G Eoog!e Patents 6 seetity
`
`to! Practical Law
`
`fl“ Robins KepIentpree... @ Icrtt aeIetieity m i-otsl'tot
`
`.;:. Documents Search
`
`EH Ado Now Tao
`Tattle ot-Contenu
`
`Doc-Jrrents SEEF‘CF'
`
`E New FoIoe-
`
`Documents Flue-rs
`
`t: Htoa
`
`Types oroocument
`Moron to stay aenoing
`EeaKatII=tatxtIn
`
`.e.
`I.-Iot.on to Stay . eno .ng Inte
`Partes FE" 9"“
`
`_
`
`Moton to my new: Eng CEIM
`I
`Re'tew
`
`Judges
`Patrlotc J. Scnl.‘t:
`
`“ti-TEPS
`'"'
`FEE .
`"”
`Q
`
`F'FIINT
`
`'erw
`SPFCNS
`Ir
`T-oe oI'Docu-net't
`1'
`valor to Stay FEW-[Hg =v-te' Partes Pet-lest
`
`35:. a, a---=.: egg
`_ Fat—.ors CT; firm
`L Simplification of Issues
`
`Result ow :-tlon
`
`Case
`
`Doc uroerrts Search
`
`:>-:.-tleo In FE'. gre "-'.EI:| In FIE—L
`
`:_':D"1Ni: :. t" -.
`Trim: :
`{'- " _..-:|1EIEQ '
`'
`'
`
`:
`
`.t-e :'
`
`..'.
`
`t-'
`
`Date
`
`Bee. 25. Lola
`
`7 nee-J ts
`_I
`'-
`E is: 4
`
`The oo.rt grant-ac #- start o aint ‘rs Ttotlo" to say Its UE'CIEf-EI‘DT f-EiI'Et' actIon Iteno'tvgr a tnlro party's ‘DE'fl‘G‘S tor threesomes rat-aw hetat. se the pote'tial s'-Tt_:—'tkatlon o1' ssoes tayo'ao a oartal stay. '{Lt t't'ro oarty; too 13 ootmons I'or 5"“.E'r panes [E's'le'n- o'a rim-fir oI' joer-anoaot'sj oatet-t t-alrts. IHIZIIJIJI'Q. all out two oI'Ihe oalrrts at ssoe In t" 's :a se.
`-‘t w- oospeno oontest: sales :1st jettuseoj Catheter ourlng toe gentle-tog.l of we stay aoo want- twootits rema'r'lng Ines-too, cerersas tjoot'losstess ano a"tI:IoatIont.tr't-.s smefitylng t'te traI. -C--.'er these tontesslonstoe Court 11nos that a easy urml soon tlme EE‘TE [PTAEE oetloes woathar'to Inst'tuta-‘es'ew on raj petltons Is tta'rarteo.’
`
`..F'alrrJI'r; states that -7 too Cour. game a stay.
`
`fi‘filfi" ll: 51E? F‘E"-E"g i"tE' Panes EE'h-IE'AI
`
`G'amed
`
`. '.'---
`'
`.'
`'
`.
`.'.-
`o-‘a-ey—oao-os tow.
`
`'
`
`-
`
`:5es
`
`.-
`
`.
`
`'=.
`
`.=--
`
`:
`
`+1
`
`5
`
`FIE-III. I35. 5-1015
`
`Feo. 25. lot-d
`
`E r
`I
`
`E j.
`HI
`
`EDIT HLTERS
`
`motto- to Stay PEI"-Et“tg CBHI FletIet-t-
`:
`-. E
`-
`'
`..
`
`- Fat—.ors Coos oareo
`
`G'ameo
`
`'-.'- ._
`" .= t-:
`{I-"-I:'.-'-I}"{l?5 I'D-“HI
`
`._ '. e.
`
`:-
`
`RIEIIEICECI FHtEFS
`
`" “5'51”? CIT-V 01"?"
`r Jtea-alt oI' Droa-r
`I
`-_ega I: sue
`, _'_-oges
`I Courts
`
`_
`_
`r Jocume“t FII no E'ETI:
`' Cm 1“ '"EI Date
`' C a“ 5‘51”:
`I OtflCUIT'E
`,
`e; 3595 my .33.; ”um Type
`
`L Prejudice Frosn 5tay.-Taafi:al Advantage
`Eta.- o’ ate-:5: 'ga
`- Fecor: Co's :ereo
`'- Ft-edustion of Litigation Burden
`Stay of:' -----a 'gs
`- Fattots Co'soe-teo
`L
`.
`.
`.
`
`SrmpllficatI-on of Issues
`‘31"‘I3'3'C-CEC ' a
`_ Fat“; [THEE
`L Stage of Litigation
`
`.T’te ous:ness met-too'tr'at -s we s.I::jer_l otthe [oatentsg :ar' oe soonec to as
`The court grant-so oefer'oants r'Iot'o-n to stay pe'ott'g CHM re“.I err; oetausett'e poter-tla sit-raritlaauon o'I' =ss..4es stage otthe case an o7 urose promote. a'to teoun'or orthe omen o't I‘Itgatton favored a stay. 'Elnte the oeg=trlng orthls oasetne Court "as has grate ooshts stout true 'tlallolt'y ot[o aInIt‘!‘ s; ease-“5..
`. SE." =-" the st-Ike'y awe-T. that t"e HTLE does not 11h: that any :Ialrr' .'.- wallet-ta F'Tma's oetlslon MI ."eoertoaless s-n'ollry toe tsssest t!- teat-toner Ir- a com roelety's esoppeo 1'.'-:rr- asserting. 'n the :t'fitlot 11-}!th any.r-.'allolty e'gur'Ient that. was ra'sec " a call-'- retnleae c-‘otaaolng t'at 'esetlta-o 'r a ‘InaI written oso's'o'.
`to. o.'.s: 'HEy lets use a comp-met to do 'JIEs'. .
`.FInaIIy. It Is too-tr rotlng t'tat
`'J'IE' Suo'ETE Court nas retenhy g-anteo CEEIIZIra‘I
`-- ‘.'-.'.'II:| cases that ate tates'antto t-t.'-s t-‘ogaoon.
`ato it to I :a rant. to hate t'EE benefit of the 5upre-ne Cosrt's oec:s'o.-s 'r- these cases“
`Stay of lace-e: 'gs
`- Facors III-'E'JE'E'G
`
`'- Prejudice From 5tay.'Tact'I:al advantage
`The oo-s-rt grantao o'e'eroants motto" to stay peso-Hg CBII-t reo'eve a-t: tel-acted plei'ttlt's slant of snoue pra,t.o|-:s-."-" [o-alnte‘l'sj wo'os. joefenoantj '“aogeo tts bets oy proceeoitg-Jelt“ Escort-e3- etren ante-hung IIsCSI-I reelew oatlton. a'-1.-e '.'."'- among fin t't-a notlon of seetlog a stay. T'tta Coun 's maoetoosoe'o oats-Fla 'sa'n'aIrto fola‘rt’trj. Clo-yl par-.Ies woo are oeltg :uEC for
`'nttngerte-t-t to who haweoe-en margeowltr 'r‘t'ttgentenrt 113}'59Er' CEIa-t testes-t T-a.-etc-e -'t
`-.-.-'
`aintost a ways oe t-‘ue t-tat I’EE pa-Iy seetlttg. CEI-I rE'I-IE-t'.‘ 'e'JIII oe 'I'I'III'CI'I-‘EG In Iit'gatzoo.
`.
`. To [meter-unto; reolt. Ito": not seek a stay mm the FITaIa gratteo [Ell-IE'H— and. as soon as res-lets was-granted. [ouster-cam: so..g.1t a Stay. es-e' t-ou -. ttco..-:o "at-E -.-.-atteo atet-.--:-aysoo see 1to».- tt‘aoeo at the
`war-cmet "earl-'1; is fat as Ihe Co...—.Is cot-'ce'teo. {oetev'oaotj- cit: eye‘yrthlng r.gt't.‘
`
`.‘t-‘ctior to tay Feto’ 'tg aa-emm'oat o'!
`:
`3 str :t C L: F-t:-:eot.-a- IEE _es
`- Stay or Prose-es “gs
`'- Condit-ons oi Stay
`:- str-at C :- -. Protaoo'al Iss ,es
`- EITBy of Fr:-:ee:- 'gs
`'- LiFt of Stay
`to In: t'I-e ate-ts. rotalntltt'. aster-2e Court to Irr oae t-‘arlo..s sonottoha rot uesltonao e _ a.’t' 't or oet'enoants tC-'-'t-‘I...EnC-E tha'-' oe'ta-t-Ior home the P111. . .Tt-s :Gal't o'oea DEF: act asa 'na Ist'ate 5.,
`roaeeo'. s'or one otthreaoate. -'.5 were at to ..oeo fiatrer than r-"o'ett'
`tastca'rroato-n ate-t
`enttl '
`The court oetieo oainttlt's I'IECI'II'D" to rr'oolt‘ tEEErmE ot a statI
`El
`F'
`.
`_
`.
`F
`I3|
`‘9
`:
`'EI
`. f9
`"E
`S
`I
`. F'
`'oanage prooaeolngs oe‘rote t'e F'TCI. not MII the Coort 'tnoose :ono'tlons tt-at ate.to some Eta-ea. orosoaottn-a t:I-s:ot-Ier_-.l sartotterts related to toe teeta'rt raton proceeolngs'
`
`3-:—"Ieo
`
`:
`-
`--'s ": '. ":
`o-os-:.--oos‘.2 :EIhIHI-
`
`s
`
`:
`
`-.
`
`-'
`
`Ja" ELEM:
`
`E y-
`HI
`
`e *ortte PTD.t“!-a Court's-I not
`
`.‘t-‘ctior to tay Feto’ 'tg Rte-autatn't'at o':
`
`I:
`
`‘t-totIo-t to Stay Peottog aeaee-n “at-L“
`
`
`Sta" o'r 2"-:-:=r 'ga
`- Fsttors CTE'C-Er-EC
`
`G'an'eo
`
`Dar'Iled
`
`:
`-
`--'s ": '. ":
`CI-DEI-:-.'-CII:EI‘.21E|h"'JI-
`
`.= -
`.
`.'
`:
`-
`'
`t. ..
`o-ooce-oses! tot-IN:
`
`r.
`
`-'
`
`s
`
`.
`
`:
`
`:
`
`:
`
`Jul.15.2-:I:IEI
`
`Jun o-E aooa
`
`E e-
`“I
`
`E I,
`Ill:
`
`'- Likelihood 0f Sucoess [Stay]
`‘the Ian: tr'at joetenoat'tj has asItac the PTO to teeter-11a [are ones stamens-Inset; proves notrtng Btr'Ju'. the oatet't's gualtty aw: =s t"ere‘rote nota so'lr'ant reasonto grant a :TE'y thyme can as-r mat a oatert he teetatrs'oeonte Ihere 'a-:t that e Iltfgant 'tas asiteotta— PT-CI to BEEN”? a oater't does not neantrat the patent 's I'selyto he Tosno Int-am. By :ontraz. w .1 the F1”: grans a
`CEEEETE’EEEGI'I requa:.th=s means that he JTCI has oaer'nltec :l'lEEt'E oats-..est 'aises 'a suostaotle "aw questton o1' oate'taasttty‘ est-.h r- spa-:ttothe :hatlengeo patent oalrtts.
`..Itt-e PTO grants {oerenoa.'ts'_ !'C—:HEH"EED" 'en:|uest'.'..lt'I respect to toe [toatant-In-ss't atlssetej. [oaleroantj 'naythen move.
`to- a flay oenot'g 'eettartl‘ation"
`
`:-
`
`tt-‘Lti
`
`:- to tay Feto’ 'tg Reasm't'at o':
`
`
`:ey o'at-
`F to:
`- Factors C.- soar-so
`
`G'an'eo
`
`: "'-;--- s
`-
`-':. ": '. ":
`CI-[IB-C'JEIEE1 DEN:
`
`': t'
`
`.to'.
`
`1. EDGE
`
`E r
`I
`
`{it Elnoer Infotmatlor
`
`e
`
`[:1 Enter fitter eraser by deem
`
`IP R2020_00131
`'- Prejudice From 5tay.'Tac1.'-cal Advantage
`.
`'51E'_.'G"':'-'-:-CEC 'ga
`Medtron lc V. Teleflex
`_ Farm [THEE
`.
`.
`.
`L
`:
`-
`-
`Ermp'mflm “f '55“
`Medtron Ic EthbIt 1893 - Page 1
`CI-aret'oarrts' mot-2r". to stay a corsoioahe: rhatter was QBFCEIZI G’p’Et' oIa'r'Ilt's objector" that one o‘rthe t"-ee patents :s not't "EE!E‘.‘I'-'13'flcl1.'l1'f-""E Loatett t'at 's tot in TEEP'E'FEEEHGH: Is so moo-tam to[o'aln1.-'T_!. not'tlng prevent [o'alntllfi- T'orr c-arrlsslng wthota Jejuoite Its :Iatrsoeltt' tassel: to trat oatet-t are: ootgmg a seoaset-a salt InequIng on't.I [t'at patent. Set!" an aoo'oaot woe: mane=Tto'-:—
`
`T
`
`IPR2020-00131
`Medtronic v. Teleflex
`Medtronic Exhibit 1893 - Page 1
`
`