PTO/SB/57 (09-14)
`Approved for use through 07/31/2015. 0MB 0651-0064
`U.S. Patent and Trademark Office; U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
`Under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, no persons are required to respond to a collection of information unless it displays a valid 0MB control number.
`
`(Also referred to as FORM PTO-1465)
`REQUEST FOR EX PARTE REEXAMINATION TRANSMITTAL FORM
`
`Address to:
`Mail Stop Ex Parle Reexam
`Commissioner for Patents
`P.O. Box 1450
`Alexandria, VA 22313-1450
`
`Attorney Docket No.: __ 1_1_0_7_97_-_0_0_1 _9-_5_0_2 __
`
`Date:
`
`September 12, 2016
`- - - - - - - - - -
`1. 0 This is a request for ex patie reexamination pursuant to 37 CFR 1.510 of patent number
`06-04-2013
`issued
`D patent owner.
`~ third party requester.
`2. 0 The name and address of the person requesting reexamination is:
`
`8,457,228
`
`. The request is made by:
`
`Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
`416 Maetan-3 Dong, Yeongtong-Gu, Suwon-City
`Gyeonggi-Do, Korea 443-742, South Korea
`
`Samsung Electronics America, Inc.
`85 Challenger Road
`Ridgefield Park, NJ 07660
`
`3.
`
`Requester asserts D small entity status (37 CFR 1.27) or D certifies micro entity status (37 CFR 1.29).
`
`Only a patent owner requester can certify micro entity status. Form PTO/SB/15A or B must be attached to
`certify micro entity status.
`
`to Deposit Account No.
`
`18-1945
`
`18-1945
`37 CFR 1.26(c). If payment is made by credit card, refund must be to credit card account.
`
`enclosed. 37 CFR 1.510(b)(4).
`
`8.
`
`Nucleotide and/or Amino Acid Sequence Submission
`If applicable, items a. - c. are required.
`
`b. Specification Sequence Listing on:
`
`4. D a. A check in the amount of $ _____ is enclosed to cover the reexamination fee, 37 CFR 1.20(c)(1);
`0 b. The Director is hereby authorized to charge the fee as set forth in 37 CFR 1.20(c)(1)
`D c. Payment by credit card. Form PTO-2038 is attached; or
`0 d. Payment made via EFS-Web.
`5. 0 Any refund should be made by D check or 0 credit to Deposit Account No.
`6. 0 A copy of the patent to be reexamined having a double column format on one side of a separate paper is
`7. D CD-ROM or CD-R in duplicate, Computer Program (Appendix) or large table
`(cid:143) D Landscape Table on CD
`a. D Computer Readable Form (CRF)
`i. D CD-ROM (2 copies) or CD-R (2 copies); or
`ii. D paper
`c. D Statements verifying identity of above copies
`9. D A copy of any disclaimer, certificate of correction or reexamination certificate issued in the patent is included.
`10. 0 Reexamination of claim(s)
`21
`11. 0 A copy of every patent or printed publication relied upon is submitted herewith including a listing thereof on
`12. D An English language translation of all necessary and pertinent non-English language patents and/or printed
`
`Form PTO/SB/08, PTO-1449, or equivalent.
`
`publications is included.
`
`59067254_1
`
`is requested.
`
`Apple Exhibit 1010
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless
`IPR2020-00036
`Page 00001
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 1
`
`

`

`PTO/SB/57 (09-14)
`Approved for use through 07/31/2015. 0MB 0651-0064
`U.S. Patent and Trademark Office; U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
`Under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, no persons are required to respond to a collection of information unless it displays a valid 0MB control number.
`~ The attached detailed request includes at least the following items:
`A statement identifying each substantial new question of patentability based on prior patents and
`a.
`printed publications. 37 CFR 1.51 0(b)(1 ).
`
`b.
`
`An identification of every claim for which reexamination is requested, and a detailed explanation of the
`pertinency and manner of applying the cited art to every claim for which reexamination is requested.
`37 CFR 1.51 0(b)(2).
`
`D A proposed amendment is included (only where the patent owner is the requester). 37 CFR 1.51 0(e).
`~ It is certified that the statutory estoppel provisions of 35 U.S.C. 315(e)(1) or 35 U.S.C. 325(e)(1) do not
`prohibit requester from filing this ex parle reexamination request. 37 CFR 1.51 0(b)(6).
`~ a.
`
`It is certified that a copy of this request (if filed by other than the patent owner) has been served in its
`entirety on the patent owner as provided in 37 CFR 1.33(c).
`The name and address of the party served and the date of service are:
`
`13.
`
`14.
`
`15.
`
`16.
`
`Condo Roccia Koptiw LLP
`1800 JFK Boulevard, Suite 1700
`Philadelohia PA 19103
`
`; or
`September 12, 2016
`Date of Service:
`ob. A duplicate copy is enclosed since service on patent owner was not possible. An explanation of the
`efforts made to serve patent owner is attached. See MPEP 2220.
`
`17.
`
`Correspondence Address: Direct all communication about the reexamination to:
`
`~ The address associated with Customer Number: I
`OR
`
`(cid:143) Firm or
`
`Individual Name
`
`28120
`
`I
`
`Address
`
`City
`
`Country
`
`Telephone
`
`I State
`
`I Email
`
`I Zip
`
`18. ~ The patent is currently the subject of the following concurrent proceeding(s):
`
`(cid:143) a. Copending reissue Application No.
`(cid:143) b. Copending reexamination Control No.
`(cid:143) C. Copending Interference No.
`
`~ d. Copending litigation styled:
`See attached sheet
`
`WARNING: Information on this form may become public. Credit card information should not be
`included on this form. Provide credit card information and authorization on PTO-2038.
`
`/J. Steven Baughman/
`Authorized Signature
`
`J. Steven Baughman
`Typed/Printed Name
`
`September 12, 2016
`Date
`
`47,414
`Registration No.
`
`(cid:143) For Patent Owner Requester
`G For Third Party Requester
`
`59067254_1
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00002
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 2
`
`

`

`I. Rembrandt Wireless Techs., LP v. Samsung Elecs. Co., C.A. No. 2:13-cv-00213-JRG
`(E.D. Tex.)
`
`2. Rembrandt Wireless Techs., LP v. Samsung Elecs. Co., C.A. No. 2:16-cv-00170-JRG
`(E.D. Tex.)
`
`3. Rembrandt Wireless Techs., LP v. Samsung Elecs. Co., No. 2016-1729 (Fed. Cir.)
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00003
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 3
`
`

`

`-
`
`I
`
`m
`
`• >< =- --·
`
`., ---
`,.~ -· .. r--,,
`
`.N
`::1.·
`m
`
`t
`!
`.I
`I
`
`I
`..... ,Y,,-,-·~
`
`1m
`
`/1/
`
`FIG.,8
`
`14
`
`N en
`
`..:ii.
`
`181),7\
`
`~-
`
`I• '
`
`l
`!
`•
`r-
`
`'
`
`! !
`
`H
`
`QPSKfo, .. I·"'
`
`112-
`
`LROl ~~t½-i
`
`'I !Ill•!
`
`lL~OT
`MUlTiPUER
`COMPLEX
`FROM
`
`~ ' 1
`__ Adv/RM
`
`• •n••..-~ •,a: ~• '••••••
`
`•
`
`-
`
`rrc •
`
`•-•
`
`•
`
`r;,,>H•••~
`
`l8fo 11MHz
`
`1----
`
`CHI? TRACK Art
`
`CLOCK £NA&£
`
`wmc
`
`77
`
`ADVANCE /RETARD
`
`CHIP
`
`111
`
`22MHz
`
`,t:4JJHz HLSTMU
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00004
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 4
`
`

`

`_...,r;;;ra;;,;;D~;.aC:;;~'O:;.;D;.;;Nlli;;;;Sl';;;,;'.l:i):..;;' D:;;;;at~e .~1:)~9;;;;~.--t:;~(X~-· ,-\;;,;;f:~~, ~-----------------BEST--copy;
`
`···~---------------.-..............
`
`--
`
`tm-,l
`Usie i11Wfmilfa,'l 1*l11«~!l:~!l'<:sTi J~F v
`A_opiit,,i(i,~,1 lnt(1iY1l.<J:!ll)l'l R~r,::_w:;;1 (PAIR)
`$'--'&!em r~;ords at ~~'l,US:;::,tt•.ij-:}V
`.
`.
`~~~~~~·
`
`,
`,t:.t·rt·1 n)b~:3
`,::.1-,1?)'.l ine.:1-~~ r<.
`l'&:M'-N
`t~_J:~W t>YEH D~f'-"'i~L't MH.:E*Z~1N. & ~Xi_.J::NRlST
`£~~ S, •OOf,N•~l:c ,:\li!itN\..'E, St!HE i.Mn
`P, ,:;,. 00~ :;,ni
`(cid:144)Rc-~,rll)() FL S.'.<l:'\$2
`
`~ 1.·
`J
`•··•
`'
`
`k~----------~--
`........ ~~~m.. ~ ~~tF'"T'""ro~,,..-~-· ---,---~~. ~!~-;v~_t-:-r--""1-f:'~fflS~*-
`f
`
`<:$l$i<~.~~«~~
`
`t)~,t~'/9""1
`
`O~l
`
`W--ffiYPU~ ..
`
`:'$
`
`-~·'.'!'l-~
`
`U~/:~:3/·;~~
`
`/Scl-1><, (;,Y(;i,c ;:/(/;','al,
`~~$:t..r..YH ,>,; ~-l:t.(cid:144)~':'
`1 :F' . .A.
`~-,i:u.-r
`~S,t,..~~~t,.~. l:«_H
`:"-~~S...~fi
`C,,~ll,)!8')),lc~!
`
`o - •• ,,,,,_ ... -~=~ 0~
`--~-~---~•"'""~-«H'"~ tl - ·~ •
`
`"1>.¾~-,..~~--""'-""W<<ll<~bl<
`~ 1= . u i -.... .ID_,_-U-~-ll-t---(cid:173)
`~•""'"~it~<=<""~·~
`i:, -~°"""'*"'
`w 1=1<'<(:.,-,="'""""""""''>l!-~1»-r..ii<>!1«>~,--. ::•, •,
`
`~-
`
`127
`-----------------------~···--------------------------
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00005
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 5
`
`

`

`File History Content Report
`
`ThH~ pctgi~ ~~;· not p;~rt ufthB offltit:l .U~~PTO· rt1(ord, It h;~s bf:en dt.:t:(:nnhH~d that s:.ont~~:•i 28
`~d.::;n-tin~~d ~)n thi~ .. do~:.un1i~nt ~~. ffti$SH1§. fr~Jrn tfH~ or~gh"ia~ }J~~ h1$torv re{ord.
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00006
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 6
`
`

`

`Complementary Code Keying Made Simple
`
`t~ f.!/~~ !~Kt flJ ot t!,;; l>i~ S~!l'd
`!!l<l~Sil:-n o! !ml l!,!ol>fill:s,11
`S!\<"®nl S.::<l'!~i:llecs C<.>mp-~!,s,y
`C-Oll<$ ~m;i (CCX)~ th;:,
`.,-,-..xk,~tii'm ,,.,'l\<l,11<.' fur 5,:S &,'4 1 i Ml:ll-':> <i~ •l.ll~ m ,~
`2.4GHl ®i"R:!, fn'<l MW 1>:gn r;!'.~ s~ci~ca~on IS ~ ~
`l:)'11, m~!\1ld !;,~r \his yi.,a, S<o:! ,:s,o',,s m;il implem"1l CCK
`ti-_~,i, s!,~d'; ~ 1 f'CC t~,~~ 1wo ~-'fli!/ll s:or.a)
`p~$;1;:n~ l<:ll$.W8ntl r,,c,,._""""-"-'f !Btl!>} ci,;p~ oo« S"-~ll!<.<
`li:<s11 i;;1&,'S<i oo~~i!l &ii n><l iurx;~>O/l,; =a,m1.ry !I} l.~-.p!cl:mw1l
`CC->( ~1'3!i0-'1 ~ wx:~ ~ !~¢ ~ rate AA'>-<i &.~, 11
`s ,~ , d tl>e:<<0 :~s~,>.b&,1!3 pm<;~S'"}f !C~ {~ ... Hl'.<l,l!lf~
`Md !:Ill Hl",!;~ll!HA ~ll<!N<s !::~'>&ma\ ~k!:< d&lS ,~l~ i,1
`W!!'.l"!~ tAt>; Sl,'Sc!e~S !,~'l&~'ig ill !Ile 2.40!-lt !SM bom>:t.
`This ~--!~Ism noisl wsl ~"'Clili/l 1h& CCK moo:.<i&!kln
`~~;;,10:l w-x:ii:re a N!'A'-lOOlA ~~"<) tildkl m,::h~~
`ih;;t tile <l~s;1,~ ~~n•w ~.m ;,sew i<r-plem;:n\ a liigtt ,~s
`>;,,'!~ !),."'-""-«> !l~.Sl!d il@~~f !>Mti,",!) tX::K 1Tox:!l.<<1ti<ce,.
`
`Com:pmmcntary Scqtienacs
`·iw s~ o! (~ m<;~l<;1Sl~n !:ii :;,:~"M~l >Sl$t1!5!Ne ,i, 1h;sl
`~ '!:ii ntit. !0\111:<l: i,1 '-"$,Y m-~~ la•l~¾s "" oi\ll!al
`m:1·,m·vr1k~fa~:~ &~~~ ~i~ 0000 k1r th~:< &f;~~i:ist> 00?.fS.
`CCl'i: has as i<ce~s ~1 li,:i<)rma~,:,n ,;m,o,y ro 1he st~'Cl ,~!
`oo,~~r.ta,y seiwsn~s Oro o! i~ !frJ;t ~<><:1>1>,1 W>W<"$ on
`111,s ~ubl*~l w«rs ~~'d t~ 1SlSi ti-,< Mw.--el J.!':. G"';a,>' !~:!.
`~ w&s !:t"ll:*mb'd w~n ~;s, p,oo,o1m o! !mi!~lq.i
`pofy't~h~~al~ ~~t~: ${) ~ ~).lad (~;:f~'n ~~ ~\
`~wtt-atJ-tu~ ot ~ ~"ei;i:~orrc-~tet. Q~, p...~-er •OO~t~s n,.~
`!ii<:< !J!'i:'llS{lie~ o! ~ eo,ep,0-,,g,,1;,,·1 S<!>'.!>'81'(~ "'~* "~ l'l
`,~t~()f ~ se~~s: ,~ ~~~$ *nd ~t~ ~U; ·tn a: mtgfa,m
`~~~~n~Wf. &s~~s ~:N'J m~t ;r-: ~~ $,~h'U--t~:t'f.'~r
`i!pp!:ta(:;,~, G~!ay ~,Jm:! lM (cid:144)-~~nl>\>'ffl;.~l)' ~"1:',i-'~l~ "00
`m;,ltsemil.liel!:ll\,' t'l9!-,'1!a~'1!l ~;;J pi.,ll!;i~r,,:l & l~W pi!~f !~} ~
`wl~h ~~ .~~~ th@:.f.'.~'NJfl~$ 1,"S:~ b:r~~i''f•:.!t\"npj!:~1~~
`S~@ne<:<& 3M :h(;w l;J ~1~~~:t1> lt<ll'l. O!!~"l' .s;;!hors ha,,i,
`,;>l!i:lll\llw(j ~$<$ ()l'I t)~,y a~i jl>')@~$j, :;<.1'/SS wi~ ()O~l
`,,~;s._li:.,'><> $lm,'><«l~s ($, ?}. &1 l<Xaci:i;,' «:!""! i~ ~
`m,itoii:,.~:llll::~l&y s~~~ &"Ill 111,'i&! 311.' ~'<lll o! 11$.
`impmta>'lt P"il!~l,s,s'/ W& <.t,ui ~ !I!':> oe~M!On .JS! a t.m&ry
`~ll<<'f$!~'1f:Hotl!:<,' ~~>)Cl:; 0< <::iXJe. ;\. t>inl!t\>' :;<.>,.~~<i,:tll\1~
`w-~ ;1; ;;i Siilioo! ot ll1:Si m<:<i!lc ~ ! l.i$~~ o! c,xl~ lwm·~
`~ fX'l}'!m~ rod®,·~ !!o~t .!Jm'.11 CC><=~ lire
`;:x::l,\,phtl:~S <=>,1lg~l~ "~
`Tli:;s !ollowlfls) l\:9l!i<~• tQ,· tilM,y S(Nl,~<f>tol&·y ~<l<..'<s~ l:z
`IX>rr0»~d iN!Af'\ i,om i'l, $,-..s-,,,..m1fS •'Mo>l:l~lias~
`Ci,mi>,~'1ll!>'\>' COO®'!l'ii:
`Ct->~~=i<ll}' ~~. {tlro !1S!llrwli !<ic ~ ~-y
`ro~roo•ilMy n~i,mc~ o.· ss,!i&&, ~'risso a pair (}I
`
`ffi,l:IS.~ 1'n~$ hm~ l,.._~)t!*!><'."~S h~ ltie·Pfflf>'.'t<'iy !11al ~
`f•.s11001 ~!~,~<JI !~ ~a.'M wl!h Stlf ~,
`S<.'1-i&ia~ ii,'., WIS wi<S,; i~. eQ~l \« 100 r .. moo,: ,1! ~irs cl
`~:~~ ~11l<ll\ls \ol)ll ~ ~ma ~1Wlll><1n l'lc !ha f>!M-1.
`
`~ s1,mrOOl$'f ~~1~~ ~1'<a~~iji®t$,~ ~~!<.~'\<
`<~b;,.~kl~¼®m«>'IS!i'~i:ly .st1e.&r~. Wa~-•
`&~"<f>.'<;;;l~~t s«i<,'l.'>~1,cm~t"-t
`
`~~~, 1-.>1 i,;'lffi IS! tika <llem,mm s<.s'li, e ~•al..m ~
`, .md S ~i;r, oi ,m,%. s~,n~i::s Y>-lili a is&P'lf~ ~<t 1;
`wn!!ress S..~er,._-., it h~ 4 pa;;::s o! 1;11,~1111 &i-etl!&-<>tis wl~ .s
`s~i,a<al'~" <•f 1 a~:, p@l} o! ~1S &>em!!~$. ts..~ 1
`~"m"'.sml!f$ ~•% re>,'<Jlt$ <:ll ,~ <slem~! :l<l'<m!) ll!t
`s~~~~-'.$ rst l f 2 ~nd "3,:,
`tlltll~ 1, ll:l$!,l.l!..t1S l:lr e...-a~r AA~ l'!'.1~
`$-\,Ql.$&~~1,0,ffi:tl
`
`~
`
`s
`~------------t-------
`"-
`i
`,s
`i
`------,l.~~,~,- -~~~--------
`W& ~¥IS -
`lt>sl ~~~rn~l)' Ci::®$ j i ( l~ a ®e,l
`('<.'Sl®S~).~. S<l li<.'W®el.'!liai i :m , :~~ ll1ll!!!
`v01-:1M ~ <»~*el t<m:~li,)i,s'.> !l M:n~ 00! ~l
`,'S>m~,~ ~ a,e~•~en~ /",Ji &~~pe•tr !!l~
`l~~,r ~~~ 8~'0ff<3ltl\~ ~~.~<:1··~ ~•» IM1~~t&
`=~ i>l me.:er<.>im11\. Thi~ l$ 1:lm Pffll."ill'!)l ~ misk®
`
`oom¢emim1i,,y e;:;.;)Qs. ~s.il ~} !!:~!>SI ="loo~!~
`<::,-S~)~ a!>-c)<l ,;,. p:;i~ ,,! ~0>~,>.~<3,Y S<l>~S '-'<<!l> ~
`
`129
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00007
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 7
`
`

`

`----------------------------------....... _
`
`❖-,
`
`t'l<'l
`
`>},j
`
`i>!l<~ ~ "~m<'!l11:l>, >m*~ o ,o l, .~ ..• , N. In" ffl.~l<>'cti,~
`'™i<>r~'nll!S'il'¥il :s.e,\"~ sr" (11';"1"1 i:>i,:
`t:~ ~ !. ~~3r~J
`'1 ~ l.1>,~,~i
`'.'
`lci,:,$ll)( i~ ;w,1 ~~tl'"'N¢~ laji «n<I !li\l &~ c.',m;.>!,~,oon!<.tf ;1
`''j+dj~•il $1-(l
`~,'!J.iqi+ t'i) x;\'t,
`
`S:> ,~,, 1;<N<> ~=s- ""' m-.1ls'ild ~is~iim<iw t¼
`a<..<!❖~-O<<®!i•~ pr@~~- i.::,t tior~ e<.•'llPll8o:®-'1lllry ~s,
`
`!c!®,ltl~ til!lc &ul®:.>H~~ J.l'Of.'iOt'ly ol bin&"f
`C<•ll>Pi~~nt;i,y C<1>~S ~'&;;~a rnw~r cl at~
`~•~~~J<s~ \tt,si ~ \l~i!M ln i.,r<~'WS~~ &el\\ ~
`Cl1,'!!j'>-~W~t;s,-~ ~~s, Tue ~~l!W ~ f ~r< ~fl<$,~
`,;s!,,ri,=s !4l • (Ile) Rll' mell<>:.sds ot ~raii~!.l <>Jmii!il~;y
`{:Q\.~$ ..
`
`Pofyph~tw C{t(:f~5
`~ ~1 W\>. ~"'-'ll <1~s~,fue,.l" ~~<il:".)' {~1'!>f.'~lle\l')' ()C<(!a
`~l>lll', i~l'is t.,~;;;- ~~,,phll:~8' Q'.lfW~8l'tli!iy t.t•~~- 'Ille
`l<in~~liW,<(>..-,,;l:<;~lC\ mll~t!ia~,y~,.mr.as
`w.i,~ ~O-":i::~~'ll,~n!&I)' ~nil!~ Uke;<;i~ & p,::-fy(!llas;;
`c.-,n~*mer1a,,• c,::,oo s} a ~~\lllin..."il ~.a\ll\1!J. o.:~=~•Y
`f""~'l'!>S, <~ &t<sffier<IS- ni ~'k-t< -
`i>M"°" f>$ra,~,,mra
`!'to' ~•a•>'f'!<:1 il pc~<plt- <~ ~,!<.l f-Ot'tl.;,in ~m~<l~
`n,1,,,i;igl<x.l:' ~i\1~! pi:~ Th<l ~-000 OO\ ®lln<llS l~ l!'I&
`H,~~ OOl!.1 i rnt,.r, t&!e <lr;,c!l $lllOOSr<l l$ .a ,;C<fflllet
`<>.~rnsn\i!iy wmi wt. rtv>t !~ lo &J ~s-~m<mlS ~, s,., a
`""lmt"'r ~ !l1'l S"l. <>I e<.1<~ r<t>m~<,."~ !1, ,j, j, ,.,'} a11l3 !:ha
`"°@ ~l l& ~!l&t"i!.<:.:!tutc·~t'! l:l)l· ll\iO StU~I~tlll'>~ ~~iir
`oo-:ic,~d Pl~kt,,;,:!<' ro-r !);nar-1 ~ - ir< <\OO<lk:>.~. 1ne 1.:=.~~
`~-1 i ~-0®~ tl;i.ve t~n ~<r> !l! j!00.!}\1$ l)OO>'.t ~V<>ilo'"IS~
`di!!Wn<.e pl(lW~ f.X ~isl~ ~'?>' !lo! ~"'-"tf •~~s !1>
`"'>l<l:i,.,m «m:rornna"l• {10}
`
`Wll<lre n i$> th:,, !il"',llll <'fl 11':<1 i:oxl<l w<mJ.
`l!> 11•~k<e il: ss {1,m~»~ ,o i>i:il,~ !!'it1 kl-~ <:~1::li!lo;l ~
`soo~ c~i*S ~:li °h{$y& {.':f"i~ :i:i$~n !)<.~;'$!( ~'W1 fml'imum t(~~~
`
`~i,t~
`l0:>1'$ l!>S\ ~'-100.'l<-"e/o l aml t k<i !lw illlh>OO~atl',,e ;;n.'jle/l~·
`<)! \Wl:f t>il'a')' <)©l,t:>l">~'tl!.l.'~' ()<),_~$. n>~ 2 ii; 3 \,W,Af<~{l~
`,)l 1!1>1< &<.,1@,:m.,!;s\l('ln !:i!1'~~~ .½r S!.l.~=~~s 1 a,<d t T,w
`r;.vi,~- "~ tin ,mst;: m 11>8 ,::ooe~ ;i,:,~ ,s ai18llll,'(X;.~ Ii(cid:144)
`e<1l,'.,C~~'all$lk~ ~.,nefa~1 ·~ ,l>!> ~Utt~ ~iO &Ul.Ct&/~i>li<lli
`<1:.im, • .,.,t,~9 loe >1U=.:m~!al1W> <J! ~· dis,~&i ~¾lnlll <)iler e$
`ph~S<S ~Ml~ (X ir~ '>"d!>$l, !'1 '1:;:,ll~ :l lh<s q "~ q lemi:s
`i,.,<im..,s;:;nt \h!.l. ~!!ilm"<"i ~!-" l~ ·>1.<.<rnl'>«' <.>l l]:~nw~,i.~
`;:ntt ~~~-~~~nf$~~ ~'}~"f..«.:n ih~ sh~~'d ~~ ~fill~~~
`~~" ~ m~ WI!> sMl -c, a,,,1 ,~,~,'II a ni&xlmo..'ffl. i.e. .. l\. f'o.'
`a~ ~in"' i;hli'l& th& 9 i<;i,1 ~ !11:l'ffiS !ll!l 111:fi,mi;w(l ,1ml
`t-,ct_»l ti i''~
`' 1 l»$,d)
`
`1
`
`. .-.......... ~.-------,-----_____ ............ ,-~--------------------~
`
`Jnt~a
`
`130
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00008
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 8
`
`

`

`CCK M .. '<dumtl-tJn
`S,c, n<1>~ k>r ~ p,i<l"~,- on ~= t~< cs:.-ias. Nu,., N$fs
`.s~ llOWir.!3 !E:E!:' Sl~11'.!s«:l i.t&. J l ~ •1lel i~ l~Ul\}
`mo...~ls;a~!;;ll\'o>"a~- Sk:t.e ;,\~~'e!S~:-~•(cid:173)
`$13,~ ~cl"-'"l (0$&3l 1e<,$--.,,..,q~ is 1>-~~~ !lletil;;)~ i;al~
`~'lt>l~,c,--i scwime, .!h!> (;tlff'j)lam~-Ma,y ~tX$~ o:lel!Wd ii~
`!he ~ii S!M'1atll ;iro i!'ll&md l"' as ~i,resa!31ll9 (cid:144):lOOll
`t~aU!ID ~ ' ma lS.~00 Ills..~·~ !ile ;,,.~ 00,'>(l\s<:<Jl~ o!
`!~ OSSS -~i<lm1. Sil~~1<:1!l sp,e~'lin9 .,\oo ,~sp,a~n9
`!~ 100 l.m.~iJI loo cm&i.!'1~'19 !)l\')@S<ilt>Q l;lilin !'\ 0$SS S,,S!~i$.
`S00 ll~SllOI> ~ AN!lll~l ~:,f IDO<l' i."1 b,.~l<J';.,i,Jll'I
`~'ll!>'l<'li<~&i'<d pr~n11 ;;)am, for ITT>"-" !;!!'!; tw!< !11 lh$
`<Si,.<l>i'-'(1 -~ CCX: moo,.<laii<:lfi as ,i,,mwrl !'!f !M fl02 .1 ~ &all
`$:isn~ro.
`Ti><l· '!:EE $~$. 11 t~""•e,im,y ~;>ra&<llfl!J cooi,s ~s »
`.::ooe ~~ o st.">:! a ~~<iµ-.,.,,;i raia 01 'i i M~nifi,1~. nm a
`C<.'l""f.'ie.: C~p$ <l(lltWN,<;!l <> ~•1.<ffe. S>s1~1. 8)' ffiiiK<!l,! !lie
`~twl nu<> t.:.~n MS.~ it.i<s 1 , i.ltii;,;, l'<'SV~!O<m <S,'<;'Js ,'I!
`or.~1sp~:i:1)9 th~ $:Sm* &ppm.<::«'-3$tt- 00~1~w.!rt!:h ~ ~,s~ fo.r th~
`~~~~~ s0:i .. 1 •i OPS.~ w~lN<t~m ~h-enstt:f S:~1::>w~ng t~r :~ n,J,~::(cid:173)
`<N~p,.,ng t~)~* ~~ ~N~ lSM b~::t "fh:$ ~ --~•¢,iHlis~ }C;
`l11M~ing .:;W<"tl,~f} $\fS!.IJ>"« ljmm~:s.1! «i & \'/ll'&i~$. .l/<N
`"'-';"'<>!!; $-.'Id '""" ona IB~'SS.'11 for "'1•<sc'Sl~ QC!( <l* !'1{l
`"'"'i!"i;s~~'l:l !~din~, 1ts llk!t C('.!{ <:>:.:l>' ;,,::,.,ds ,m,
`®r~~--d ':{·om the ~~l(.\-.:t~J ~rw..i~~:
`
`;,,~1~ C is !oo um& wO<i:i ""ill) lSS !l>S! I>':' M$tl !~t Yrn;,
`"!ffi%,"<l ~l:>g !i.>1111<;1& i1 t>SW l<l !J"'""-'1'!.11! \~ ~~<,, ss:z !Cl
`Mtll 1 l &'m ~(¼~ l:l~!il <ma•. Thu• a Sl$1lS8l -:"ll !he
`11 ~\':Ode$<!! ls ,>~M ~ !he S.-. .EMu,la .hta /il!i: .. Th<:<
`j:ilrar11e;,:im <iJl • ~ da1<,-,cmi® ll',<s ph~-1.1 ¥~ ,:,i ml:
`Cl~'l\0<@' ~ $.~'l a,ltl ilm :iS!i~M iri 100 802. l l !<>¢' llS!IJ
`::;~~l~•-$, ;::w ~h~ , l:Mt¢-."-' da-".» ntt~ ~l-~~~ ~f')~~ ~~$.~~~
`ii ~...S <sl ~,!<tr~~ ,\! 5.ti~~ps ... ~i• pa, •-.,,mt.'f>I sia
`1m=r~!!&i. ;:'<)I' !he t•>i~;;> m th~ disc<~,<i>~ !fi,3 'I'\~~
`n'>O<.!<s""'~-@~<ll:c"'d. ~''"'(I\(cid:144)!"~"'"
`;l.. in«," t1a,-ssm:1
`nwoo a sm,i&l ~ s~~am 1$. l<.'<l:l !::> \ht> Nf'A~t3l,1 A ~!la<l<l
`r;~aSM< ¥la th<! Ml'l\~lHl MAC. ·nm ,mta llli 'S!ma,,, ~
`~>l~ioo-.~•~.., t>\~S i>'il {<.0; ®, <i.'S.. ..... ,;<(~i \'o>M~ <ffl· ;,,~ !l's-<>
`;,$!) !ll'Sl !~ fa~ in ~~- it>>' <i !,,'ls .~>'!l ,,,_;~ 1U llr~OO<l >~
`PM~ (;'.~ffil)'>el~t'S.<,>l , ~ &(:Wfdi"'J ~) ~~'"f- $.~~, 111
`;,.._::.,m ::i .. Toll' ~~"it i$ !::l>s!l'1 o>:1 <'ill!S,a::l!ll! QPSK
`,i~!all>:>fl ais $~"l~(l le. T&til* >i.
`
`TAIS.U. .l- $'ii~ l>MA~re~ fi~~.s;m:i =1.:~
`mmr
`" f · \>i<:P<~Pl!cllJl;~mi:i, __ . ]
`!
`~~
`1
`-M·t~!
`
`----------· ... ·. ·------------------------
`
`t.e\'$ ~~ ~ti a~*ms:~ \II ~'e· !mw a l!<l,~ rode w::o>::l i~
`~ e t l A~m~1j) i!le 11 Ml:v...<t1 rm:® lSl!d .a ~ta toll i!l~'1!
`!j~Sl>dt,t!tl, ,;S!l,,--,®•" l l'.) 1 j{l l Q 1, Th!Jtli'®l 1~hl<!4
`<$1, (!Ii::, l'.)1 Si'l <N « 'If, ill ii' Sim&.<.f <1~
`Q'S, d2 ~,(!~S¢1l'1"' ~
`!S!l,Wlx11:slJ~"-'iif't
`(fl, di)« !()*'rj~" ""-~
`
`S<!l:iSl!!Wil'tl lhe ~'®$~ P3mm&<wrv~~ i<ll<i !he-~ m,'l:(i
`~ : : i ~ r.i1RI:
`
`~ ;!'I; i*~O ,c, /)••,"l.:.•'i+~l~~ .. $~~ ... $11,,;-~/X~, ii)jf.11:-~'lf-tY~••2~~
`.Ji:it~:iclS~_ i~~~ x"':,:l:?.:l, ($·~,; ..... :1:1·2\ ~~1t-t-:>:}, &~,c}l
`
`ill:» >Xi$ $" .~ i $t-~ ~
`;:: "iw:s2~+i~:t~2~, ~~~~is\1"1s, (cid:144)>..1~:) i~¥-
`'•"'~~ :.,.~ · 6~
`-~ ---~~
`~,3~ .:. '
`...... ,..vy·--~~:Q-~.,,..,.~-•'..X, t., ... ,T ~, .......... ~~-- """'wz-:-J,,.Q.'X,•c,
`... ~»~l't ... ill-~(~, ~x <-~~,~·l
`
`·~
`
`l':.'<>W loll'<>~~ >)()w lt<<> !i!'ll.c'Y'Jo)tl< ~~-~ !"~~<>< "~""
`~~""'m!u ,.,~8':111\<a ~l•s/t~rao;;)~ll',$
`t<imt:i~ oi ll'.l> ""'~rm. ~~tlifl{l l::, E~®ll ::, l'iil <S!!e
`lnat ~lil~<l iwam-~w,:,1 iS wrna~·~ ,:,& i s~ <sl !iw
`00!.1!! W/Jfd ,w i! ijf>'S¼lia:ly,Ql~S ~ w!'IO-'<l ~ - ll',l$ !S
`irnp<)<l&,! in !M ,,,,,.ii•) ;mp~,11<>-«l~km <'ll ill!!< C¢i(
`<rs:-~1,,m !l.$ '~'-' "'-"-~3 "'"""·
`
`131
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00009
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 9
`
`

`

`i<'t ~« ~~i>'<l1 !!'So CCK m,,"<k.,~sd '-'ll'>'11>il><m l8 el)<r,ert~i
`l'(:<r, 11:ns~>!.l !« ~iS.~I ''-"'"' ::olffl>' ~m,~>~li)I\. ~,9w<l ~
`l!h(><S<S ·~~ dt1:rr,Mui~tm· ti!,UOl ~! ~<l !'lf'.ll.'SB$ l A.
`Pilff>OOllkl!::f.!.') o! •l~ CCk 111l'Jduil>!~d ~"3l is ®M
`w.~-,m.i,,!l>j ;,,, !h~ Mi='A:3001/1 0.3f:<.'00l"'!d pr<XOS'®f 01' a
`!"-Al<!: riW•••"f im;)lM)efll~!ioo '>\<l'.<lti'l wai= 8 <:!!'Is,·~
`!1\3t,;;hoo !~la!' ai:<J f<'lsl Wi!lis-~ "tl{l~'m t:<1-,.-,.-;k. A MW! ol lS~
`(s">ll'~ial~tS ~<l"'~ by l< l:>~~l ~~~ .-,.,i:,,8 ~la,1>\~3
`>011'.«;/'< &O{.~ 'ml$ li'l!Sl$ll\1tl~19l','lli>;,l i', llii& l'>l ~'1,<l >:!&1:3 \~~ (ill
`!!'<,;! l ~!<.~$ t;,m). Tiiu nt'w! l b~!o (\I ti'la $-{lit ~;s WS:<i:i!
`Mi OOISYmt!'«l~ !mm ~lit Of'Si( plli$$& it lhe IS)'~, flg,,,1~
`'..! ~~ ll>ll Hf,~1$1A~~pi~ln!he 'll!.-~'S
`N,i$M il llml\l'blod< ®19-<am. Tl\.'$~ i f \ t~ •~(>
`l*Sl<i'*-" m~ VSi! (lt\ Si Ge P1Q-~eS!! t~~ •11 j™' f!f:/ll'
`i<OO! s.~!lon- lo«< ~<$1 e,:,n,s,~~<s, Elh61,!!<t ~~a ~a
`tl>111$, i<""' ~'ti(, ®.t~~'l tiit ~ '*~lil'll> OO!ll*!ll., ffll'lu<>)>:!
`m;s,~~~t-i.~~t(l$l$ ~ - ;~~e t=mw
`!mm>im&1Sa J11 ~ ~"!J~~tt. ~~.,."\! ~®¢~'® ~
`>11ll.l'~ts til$t ~Mmlksc, i 1~s m~ ~ sn imi
`Hl'MM{)S oossma,\<J jSl'l:'<.'®S<I!.
`
`,tM~.i:\ !,t\'ll.'1'1ll,.,~:!'<:)R
`
`~,~~ 1. el.IX:~ rnMSMl>!(cid:144)f
`C!~(;OO'
`fig!.ml i S!\t'>m l~ ~t •:llag>;sm o! !Ni CCK <!'»(1\.>!.;!lr,s(cid:173)
`~lt-i;<,•lt Th<! .:.Ul;l\lt -(>': !~ HF,'3W1A ~!;lls ~"!><<i¼lr i%
`~il~"llleQ l"-'<-l tl)1'll'l ,u~ ls,<.1 !<J ,a, b-,,rl.~I fr, pa;:Sl!ei ~ ~
`¢'n::<li! lrnl! 9$1'-' ~<m <t! ttli> Sc\*100! ml& <!l i,ID!i-MH,t Si~
`t,lt$ <;I ~Wm,,,< !Rll;>!.>'! M't 1.$:..'U l!l «S<~~l <!rn! :>! 1:,4 C®'j!!«<"
`<;~Jm, -~ i!S<il ~ l!l a d<lfu,-,,.'!)!i&l m,::,o,'\,j~~f C~t,is <M
`~-it,~r s! ~ <.ll ~ =~ siu!;)<Jl i!>'l} -~,s,:lil i<l -OPS!< moo,~a
`ta., ~~w, lh& !l Cl'i:P !k'"®P*• ~000 \\<~"4 r~ \)\i1p,;l$ ;_if lha
`di!~~•~ ~!Ol' ere lh,:1 ! ~m:! O o,,ip,<!$ k, ~o.~
`""~ti i::11U8l>-~ '2 l\'>f 9ern!~til:l-tl et~;,p~ ~.¼l$- A<1<l !ll&i. ls.
`$$:S>'lf>lli!l:y CCK m,d:.~i!li(m '"' a ,w,~t1'Jlt
`
`,i=s,;:,;r,~~-...l
`
`, ____ _,,
`
`¢00l!W.."!l0
`C<!/li:t$.!.1'.™™llim:=
`!1'/>'l)
`
`CQl,$ ~m l~ (>
`,~~WtW>'1ffllS
`~-
`
`Ol:;a«,:.~cl
`
`~ ..
`
`i>E"reCT
`
`m~MN'l'W
`
`~lf~~n,.~ *'~
`
`132
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00010
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 10
`
`

`

`Com·:Jush:ms
`c,,_..,·,p,~IM>~l~f',' ~~ ll!:l':! OCK m,'ld~~li()<> "'s "dopt.w· ~
`:fEE ~'l. ll'm 002. \ l d«lll S·l,&r,~fd l>a!vll l:<¼t1,:l;,,ss:,,/h,ut A
`MW M'S*OO.M~,,~~- != !n~i. !!w HFA~!'lii\..
`im,.">lsmll:MS !l<& CO< "'~~nm li:> a<:l<l'1<.<2 fahs1<~! tiaia
`~* :c:,1:;.<erwi~~% ~~: T~:e. ~# Ms~~ ~9(:~~-:.:1
`lellt=~lmpm~'1!c:'I p.sd,¢! &m.,, m* P<)®f>'l'l&~~ !rt ,.,,,,;l\i,:i,.s!h
`~~<Wlm!!>1!s ~'m..""¢l !h& <!~~ -Of il M!<f •~~;,,,i,(cid:173)
`~~~1:lt~t~,ure.,
`
`Bibll~'<t~phy
`m /1..<\~l't}l\ C • .incte-c<Sf. ,!- 'l'.'m.Jh ~k.f~- ~sS~
`Ekl&nrs,~1 fJ! too S!M~<'d", <.l,;,c: (E(;l:. ,,~ 1 H1a.<s1Ji
`!~l ~(.ay, M,J.E., •~1l<:> ¾:llltoi3 ~~1=i1)! ~w ii-s
`;lp;:>l~,i!l!!i> !<i $..<> PR<>vm.~ Dl~'!O~ cl ln!r&:COO
`~}t~'\ J,. w. ~~- ,l).~m, v~. ~,, ~~ 1, p.~1~t
`y'<i,'f 1!sSl.
`
`l2l (W~\<,1--\,!E, 'Musi..iil~pac!~•Ml!'/,J.Opl.$®.,',m,
`'hi- J~. pA<l'r: l~\l-
`(4} <,,~~ M,J .. !::, "C<ll!l!)tlSffle<lllSt';,' S!i~~•. l~E Trams. Oh
`l~m3l~l1 'ft~l)', ,~!'.<ti! l S§1, p.a2-$,'
`
`(S} Hilimi:l$,, RC., 'f"~wS«ltt Cool.le~ »,i!h Good I';,~
`• m1<· 'tia~ (l>"t Jrn\-,,m~kn1
`C<>llil!&\mn 1'>'-'00l1.!©0
`1h<.'O<l', 0,,:/mr 1$-:ll, i!,2M,;,:Sr.
`
`{ff! F<stn~, !tl., '1"~~~e ~~il'.Wlll) G<:<;:tl N(,iipeli-..~~
`\}<im,is$ti<>.~ PR'l!,1<,':H<~', ii::t'ifi Ti3f\~. <m !ri!()lm~ll<:m
`T~t: ,i;,m_,&l' ~!'!!re, ll--4:l---4S.
`f/l ~1/Sll!, <S.fl,. 'Ol.<lller~ <.:~~ l<>t !¾A.~ fl~••, l~li;
`Tiar>&, <m ll)l<ti:m.-:;l:@ ,.~,- -1,">t l ~ ' ~-400,-400.
`(8) Si'-'<'$S<l&lly.. i:t, "Mul~~'l;j~ COm~®t31)1 ,-<ls~$~,
`!~~~ <lR,~ "'' lilk~n~1 rr~~), ~'<)/, ff-;?~, l>,'i;!. 5
`!;,epl. l~<t~. P-~~-~,
`l::iJ 1'ieng, C. C, ~m:l Uu, CJ .... , "C<<mpll!f!W~l~· Sets I>!'
`$'3>:ttrern:.fls', !EEE Tl~~$. i;m h1tmn<a'<llw, ttt&oit wt it,
`i!l, 1'i!>. ts, $,}pi°<)<~< l~?:2.
`\l(l! Has!Rm\ K-, H;i!!ll$(i, S., ~ , M., 30:! ~n., C.,
`~~(cid:144)~Nle~IS' c~ ~119 t,r fl.MS~ l~
`Wk~ss (:U.''1ffi\lt1<~"-l<l'ln: Pi=~s@ lhe 1m
`~£:~ '"lj!ma,<ooai S}""!Xlffilffl im Ct•c!J>1S. !!>"l-1
`S'S,<si~~-
`
`tl l) Hl~~i:11;!£; l,<\: Os,/8. S..~, l!>1~<-sli C*~l~,
`Ar~~rfkl>. t)t'<,l. N<,), 4'7€>,
`\~~! Amrnn, c. ~nd ,•\f!llislet. M., ·c~i,;; ~11ikl!~ ~t¼,~
`1 l~~s /,;<r Hl>;)n R&(~ a@. JI ~wnlOO<l", Wiwle~
`s~~""~'lll.® ii!)' i:%-s:i:i,~ (',Oll&-:smnc<.< ·
`f'l-0,,~!\. ~"19 ',l,00,
`
`133
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00011
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 11
`
`

`

`t
`,;,
`
`~
`~
`;,:
`
`I
`~ ;
`g
`~ «:
`"' I
`"' /;,. ~,
`! g
`
`ll,
`
`134
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00012
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 12
`
`

`

`..... ,l ..
`
`Ail l,i,;,~8 '!)100\I~~ ~rn rn!lrn.>l:i,::tun.'<l, >h~oo,-'11~1 Md l$Sl!Ri :..'lsw<1'\} iSOW,,."-O q<slW1.y $\<Ill=,
`~l!>~,~~ C,::,11W•$~l':1 ~~~~·,:x,rtlrlc!.l!;:;>M r~~, t¢ >i~ ,l.l ~l>slt>) ~.;..{k~~!lill~~!Jsl-~-
`-,~-?<-¢'",,--°"_-.-.. <$-,-~ «:«ii!)~~~~l .~-..")~ Jo:l$9)~-~~~ ~~ ~ ri:#f ~~~S~Q~~~.»~~6$6.~ ~)q(j,,.~~
`~~~;~~~,&:~~~Kl~"i:}'~':iW~~~:i;:~~~"R'~~~~~'«P~~"•~~~~~lOt-~·~~tc,~~-~•·$J~i-~
`~',. ~ ~~X~~'.'J,•-~~-..,~)"¼,'{,'J,,,~,O.~.~ ~1t-.~-*))'~'8XM.;' "1(,o.',l»( ii!~N-k'~~&1t~«~~.(1$'~~~,j.$,~~&,'$,of,X:,"l-R"~~..,,:t.!,;x-,.,.~ ~
`~~~~~~~.~~~~«~~~~~~~p.~~~~~ ... (!C~=!~~'P'i~ .. ~lX.~~
`~~ ~¼.~rr.~t:-0~ ~~~-3~ ~!'$~ ·C1'S'f..'li~~ ~t~1 ;iS pr~~ ~~~st;½ ~in~~\~tr.a u~~~--~-~~~~
`-
`S,..<$,'t§S Office: Hemiqt,<altM$
`~A~!'!lC-'
`t~C<s'!><l"~
`"· 0- !l<ll< Sil..'\-~~ s:l-2!l>I
`~~«-R-~
`fl,t.: (3~lP~-M{>.;Q
`r~~ ~ti~ r2+n~!l
`
`A!S!\11
`~)!§1-s.llR~
`~-~ ~: $,K, l, ~kw l>,'<,n.•i,
`r~s,.,~a . .i
`~~l*m
`,H.:~-2-l:$-1~:IS
`f'AA: &IS!!-N\$ 1&-~
`
`!;1.!00l>lt
`;~•'Sil:!,_",
`l,1',>ta>,~Col-~
`100, I¼~ ~ ~ ~1-S.I~<)
`1 >3!3 a.v""*&<., e.~m
`lt:.l.: tl~~ ~.:t;Mlf H
`PAA:· f~ a..1~.az.($.
`
`135
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00013
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 13
`
`

`

`' '
`
`Carl Andren, Systems Engineering,
`
`Harris Semieonductor
`
`Introduction
`ff~'ril! .~~ ~ ~ &
`ci!.ip s-et ~ !m~~~ W!rel= .L~ A~
`t-fo~oiks (\VLANs} ~ wul ~\Wlde l !» 1 l
`~~ ~ m m:e ::1-4 Oat lS-~ ~d. ti:~~
`~'I_ ~ ~rml rtiOOll~~ ~~ i1l ~~t
`hi~ ~ . ~~~ to ttie lRlm 802.H
`wt.AN' ~ TMs s4~~ will. rrovW~
`mi~IIY w1tti ~ ~n,11 :w ~!lffl~t
`~~ ! f t l ~-m'l,~~ist_~~~r,f
`5-:5 ~d l J MBps. for~ =i,. d;.& ~ m~
`~l.t To~ ·•@.ip .Sl:;t Wffl ~~ ~ ¢$I ~
`@~Mg PRJSM W!..A:N ~ ·~ ·dl,e ~~
`RP and ft/ ~'<:SS\ <;f l.Cs! w~~em:w wlih ia
`and ~~
`MW ~<!:~ )'l!'\.~~Silr
`pwg1WnmaN~ MAC, Tuw, 11 will <.}lful' a m.dy
`up~ µatll iu ndlu sssm-af~ ml.O wl$!lt ~
`inoo;-pomtis ffil!c !WW ~S,
`
`A~~w~~~lo~
`rom~~ a~~m~~w~tiulld
`-Ol'!- ili~ 001. l l m~ hut &ehllm Mgh~ dallS
`~- M---~· SkO!'tl-<13~ l(eya~ was~~
`
`a!! ili~ b~st' mmiu!&i:loo. mo~ for hlg.!s = m
`lila t.4 GHi UlM bAAd-
`Th§$' ~~ ~
`~:ui ~~,lW• ey ~ tt;,-s ~a
`~,fr ~ moo& tM~~~ ~ the ~
`
`~m~l!! atld ll~ Wh:!th ~ f ~ & izj>
`~~~~'
`~ l'h&y a!~~&I Keylssg
`(MBOR') fflooi!latfou ls w&l! ~ &ad !lliS ~
`$0WIS: U, h&V,'S ~g ~ ft was
`~sl~ly ~I:! m ttia ~~ where oissilloi
`siss¢imlen• l®!m~e!! WOOi ~mm~
`With ·1ma10~ imp,!~~~ l® w,.~lsmqllll'
`~'i: ~di ® ~ tM ~f'l~ity wSl! ~ hl~b.,
`T~, w'lth wi~oo ~ hnp¼n~t&tiU¾
`W$ ¢lin. tff~vcly llM' mis ~h~~~ >!Sid i,~fa ~
`~~!$ 1:<fhl~1:¢m,fl~~!f ~~~
`
`,---r-------------,
`il~~
`If~££~ l
`c=:=1
`
`L,............. _
`
`__1
`
`136
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00014
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 14
`
`

`

`M &id Ill' psm mthtl lll.<W ll:.ll ~ W: .<t I, ~ ~~d~~ w~ 0 0~
`
`Fp 1; ll®wis how ~ WJSll~ {'$
`M'OOK ~.~ i n u~ i ~~on
`In:·~ lSM ~ ~' v~ of k~fu.& ~· ro~ ~ fa~~~~ Ill"$~ fwlrtioo i.$
`~~. ~idl!s 'lh~ s.ittn" ~ lb.~ <S!(lsimi an:u I
`l!~ 6= * ~ m'M' ~miai ~m ht~
`~-d, This~~ tM ·~. m·tne mlit
`' I , '~ ~ llw 1 md {::! dl~l!h ~ ~
`M
`~~ i s a~gy mow un~ lnM ~ ~ ~ ~ oo ro~ lb:!$~~, Bl·
`soi.it k:ker wim.131, bm h h~ tha mne
`~~~ ~ ~~ !bl$ by us~ ~
`~"~ud•ihl:<satm"~~~' ~ M,d m~ ~ {If mi~
`~ ~ 1s ~ t o !1 Mffl;~ ~ l <fil
`fa.l\~~- Th~~ ~t<)~ ti·~~·~
`~ WI ro H i8 oo;~ ~ Mlk. Thi~
`~oo{.
`lill~'3c pl&e~ ~ oon•~ ~el~ ~
`Th~mt'<StWcli~ ~ - ~
`~ !s iii$ W!il$1s fun~~m ~. ~ ~ a~!ilt ~ l
`tf!,:; lSM b@.t (Wh!dt is ~ 2-40 ro :tffl GH:(l
`~ip w,,.~ ~ 2) ~ • ~ h~ tM
`wbh al!owim~ ~ ~ ~ - ~t,n ~
`too O!!!!cl ~4- W)'m ~- ~h-e nl~~ 4
`~s!ify, M~"<M t.i:! slw ~ . ~ ~
`oo~cy ~S~~ mt~ toit
`i:fam:oolll ~be~~ll:l.l:aiM~d.
`r~~-
`,,,,,
`,,,,,, -·-:--77om7
`1w mlghtoo ~ fut lS!<&mp!i!, ~ &'l«:U ~ lll:I
`~)K l$ ii ~<et' &.~i m<>twlltti1Jll
`1
`!
`- - - , - - , ¢j l'! ~ ~;::::.:.-:.-:.:.--""""""!·if')
`/"'
`...!..'t' ~
`
`&.T-"<j t!r
`
`w!>.~li m~ that it ~t~ §UW-~$ i\.ir t~
`~ ~ ~ ·rs ~· ~ .~~ ~4
`to!~~foi- l~~md !lllll~,
`·1tt
`!h!! b~t\f ~ ,~ , th~
`mooull!Wt &$~ l, ~~, ~ ls usul!llj,, ·uu, <"-l!S~
`&..'Id ~ ~ R ~W in= ~~~U\im !ht
`~"~ ~ . ~ ll>~ for ttie. ~ i i of
`1M . i ip~ .~ ~~ fti:r u~. cl' thee
`<)Ul!W~ ~®~, "fbe. dtmOO~ lS \;~
`~ me ~e. ~ =i!!t ~ ~iptes
`the. P!U&l-'i 1
`~lit we ab~~/ ~~<1d ~(cid:144)
`anm~, ~ tll,., ~!ls~! ~itry !or
`~~fatioo '1'l!S ~p!e. m ~!~de ~~~
`~~w:.'I oo ! y s~~ l!Se.'l\!r~,
`M ~.,.- ~~ keym~ (MO.\-')= ~
`~!i-owi. m ~ * ~~raitfo:.~ ef tn&ll)" :rtandAA"!
`wavf~ Sllcl! &S FSK
`
`~ m;:m~ af Wt bl!8it ~ FigW'IJ 3 ~~
`~~~ l i t thee 4 ~® ~ tif the
`~~ mooomkm ~~- ~~, i.tl.~ ~'\".!
`i@,lt l ~ 2 ~ ~ s ~ ~tlWn l!:s
`b,s~k:,dty ~tti.&s !be ~ fSf ~ l Md/'lif Q
`~ ! l!p:,.~J funoo<m, For ih1:< S,j ~
`moo~ lh_. ~~ ~ fs ~ lmi:i 4 bit:
`l!.i!!b~ w~:) «tm."<'le bit11~ili,s~
`ft.m~~1S! ~~$ of !m· s« of S \,hi!,s tae >JI bit s~
`t~ ~lllri~'> Tb ~~th~
`lll~.ilPSK~~ !h~· ~b)- ~v~ ~ l
`$Sid Q m<'>:!ts!""-'n.'S in plitllllt,\, T.:i l'\~'1!c l l. &Wp,s
`!llOOtli~, !he. Input fus l! ~~ iut(cid:144) 1
`
`n,~ ~d ~~ t>::< m,xM~ ~ [ ~d Q
`
`~~Is iil~~OO'li.)',
`
`2
`
`137
`
`IPR2020-00036 Page 00015
`
`Rembrandt Wireless
`Ex. 2012
`Apple Inc. v. Rembrandt Wireless Technologies, LP, IPR2020-00034
`Page 15
`
`

`

`~'la ~a! ~~ily ~ m alooru.t$ p!i~
`'fo m&%e $f !1:!~m.l na¥t tilt $lt!!'!!l
`~!dlb ~ me ~\S®g m,1 ! oS m~~Qis,
`tis~l'~l~~- Th~ is: 1111t a lq¢ el.ll!~ ~ lhti
`r-~_:,_,, ____ ,__H__
`!hf ,;;~!pprog ~ i, %~ llt ll M~ while tlls
`lit~ ~ l e ~ ~ ®I ~ lh~
`1i1m.~ ili111 <J11~!l bit~ !I ~ , !!w· ~ ~ ~ tii.e ~ &sm~ ii~• <:AA
`l!Yttlhol ro.s w ~ .I# lJ75 M~. Th~ ~ m~ tu b)k ~ * .!'tt. fo a jilr~
`, _ _ l -11-- --- ,. __
`---~--. - 7
`-
`-·
`l s- . - - - __ ,,,,_
`! ::J cr:ITJ 1:::::::
`l
`i~~ c:: . ::J f
`I
`I
`!
`H,~-<o-«" ~~-.,o•~«~ ~~-,., 1,'
`~-,~-) ~--
`'f
`\
`-
`i ' " : .~ ; ; ; ;~ L1lilI1D
`~ fJIDT1111TI
`i•·-
`
`t- ~""""""""""""'
`
`* $
`
`i<~
`\~~
`
`*~
`1 • -
`\~ -
`
`-
`
`I.
`
`,___,,I
`
`,....,_..,_,...
`
`<:!>OJI H~
`
`~ l l~
`j
`
`t l~
`, _
`
`i ~~ M•~.-.LX .. _, / X
`
`fi ~ s, sn-,-w the m:s.\::t1lpl!t'tl!t at moouWilm ffl~
`L.-
`~re tti ph~t amhl$uey,
`Thiis !1tW !ht
`ma~ it e<1Sy w m~ ~ !!Y•Wffl m~~le
`~le! ~ l i t~ fl%-
`wit.'l mii ~:Ul ~blun<i ~~, Smi::,1t the,
`the <itm~l~*m
`rsr ttlit
`~~ rate. =a~ ro~ thti imly th~ m;ss
`moo~:rait.ly i~ ttte <$Ill,!!~~'
`~~Of~ $h()Wl1 m fl§i~ 4,
`l::.(1~~ W~".n ~ fo J W.Rl, l:i)e ~ fu:lffi ·~·~
`~ ~m,id\!~ ~ltii ~ b~d ~
`h~ I~ tilt &tli t!ocl: ~-
`~ ~01!~ ~ tilmfui&l sh~i~~ ~ Ille ~~I
`MOK m~oo bliS ~ mown t()
`Iii!~<~ 3l~tzy (!,~) ~er l!!iNO ~ $ l l~ ~ f ~ wll~rt fut l ~ :!. l<-~s ~
`!h!Ut JaPSK ~'¢ 1~ ~!#~ ~ pm~i~,
`were~ ii:<~<{~~ demoo~tioo ofili!!
`Th~ m~\.~ th¢ ~ronn ~ll tt;:;m ~lW~
`~l>.~ 1:11td !l~~t and~~ 1 &3.<.i :l M!Si,s
`thee ~~ e , , Thi:s ~-a the m~ Thee tmgin&i ~00!!~ did nor ~ is
`tffli:;.'~, $
`mwul&.<..k>tt t¢ ~~ ~ w11:r!~~ !n\l:!S ~~ fut ~mt ~tllcy ~fkinJ
`~w ',\,'ff¢fo.-ms, ~m there= ~ !ms i,er ~ !t w~ ~wk u. rea~ fut ~'it~
`ry!ll\>ol w,1'h tMs .tt,~~t!un,.ii n~lllly k~ ~~ oot?ilde \bl$ m ~ ~ lb; p!i=
`m= 1..¼.,NQ ~ tU>sK. but .tl!tl ~ is ~ :in "the~ oomisln. ~ ~ plsilsJS
`~~ lJ a s u~ ~ lh&'ll: a
`Jniniml~.
`;
`n..t ~tram oi' ful$ w~"~ kl
`lll!illii'!~t)S!. Wtlh ttw mw ~ ~'ionllf
`(l~ffi'.!'' ~ n«~ to ~lare tho
`the W:-1 l
`.sim:,'lt.\ ~-hWI
`IS .~ ~&mf
`!IS.
`MOOK m:~ Tue ~ i i i fol'~~.
`~~~'l>f«mL
`.
`~~t d~ Ill~ th~ ~m- ~asll bl!:
`Th~ mu.~ ~~ . e , will ~peml
`M t.¾e SN:R ~m! ~¾~ d'~'Sl ~ l.l!ttw
`~~for~ tM ~OK ~w:rs, Thi$
`w~~fulffl, Wf ~ ~ ~ ~!mWaoo».,
`l l~ >) ~l)l~ m1S~~ ,m4 >) W•\I
`lflls ~ wm
`lt W&S ~®Ii !lot ro $11~ ~ l