From:
`To:
`Cc:
`
`Subject:
`Date:
`
`Frost, Claudia
`Heather Kim; Jonathan K. Waldrop
`Jensen, Travis; Apple-Fintiv_OHS; steve.ravel@kellyhart.com; J. R. Johnson; atindel@andytindel.com; Mark
`Mann (mark@TheMannFirm.com); Fintiv
`RE: Fintiv v. Apple
`Friday, March 20, 2020 7:49:55 AM
`
`Heather et al,
`We are not available at that time. Would 10:30 or 11 am CT on Tuesday, March 24 work for you all?
`Claudia
`
`-----Original Message-----
`From: Heather Kim <HKim@kasowitz.com>
`Sent: Thursday, March 19, 2020 7:53 PM
`To: Jonathan K. Waldrop <JWaldrop@kasowitz.com>
`Cc: Frost, Claudia <cfrost@orrick.com>; Jensen, Travis <tjensen@orrick.com>; Apple-Fintiv_OHS <Apple-
`Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com>; steve.ravel@kellyhart.com; J. R. Johnson <JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com>;
`atindel@andytindel.com; Mark Mann (mark@TheMannFirm.com) <mark@themannfirm.com>; Fintiv
`<Fintiv@kasowitz.com>
`Subject: Re: Fintiv v. Apple
`
`How about 2pm Pacific on Monday, March 23? Thank you.
`
`On Mar 19, 2020, at 4:09 PM, Jonathan K. Waldrop
`<JWaldrop@kasowitz.com<mailto:JWaldrop@kasowitz.com>> wrote:
`
`6 feet apart!! Be safe, Claudia and Travis!
`
`Jonathan K. Waldrop
`Kasowitz Benson Torres LLP
`333 Twin Dolphin Drive,
`Suite 200
`Redwood Shores, California 94065
`Tel. (650) 453-5425
`Fax. (650) 362-2445
`JWaldrop@kasowitz.com
`
`-------- Original Message --------
`From: "Frost, Claudia" <cfrost@orrick.com<mailto:cfrost@orrick.com>>
`Date: Thu, March 19, 2020 4:08 PM -0700
`To: Heather Kim <HKim@kasowitz.com<mailto:HKim@kasowitz.com>>
`CC: "Jensen, Travis" <tjensen@orrick.com<mailto:tjensen@orrick.com>>, Apple-Fintiv_OHS <Apple-
`Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com<mailto:Apple-Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com>>,
`steve.ravel@kellyhart.com<mailto:steve.ravel@kellyhart.com>, "J. R. Johnson"
`<JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com<mailto:JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com>>,
`atindel@andytindel.com<mailto:atindel@andytindel.com>, "Mark Mann
`(mark@TheMannFirm.com<mailto:mark@TheMannFirm.com>)"
`<mark@themannfirm.com<mailto:mark@themannfirm.com>>, Fintiv
`<Fintiv@kasowitz.com<mailto:Fintiv@kasowitz.com>>
`Subject: Re: Fintiv v. Apple
`
`Heather,
`Thank you for your response to my March 13 email. Unfortunately, Travis Jensen and I are in an all day mediation
`
`Apple Ex. 1039, p. 1
`Apple v. Fintiv
`IPR2020-00019
`
`

`

`tomorrow. Please suggest some dates and times for a call next week.
`Best regards
`Claudia
`
`Sent from my iPhone
`
`On Mar 19, 2020, at 11:47 AM, Heather Kim <HKim@kasowitz.com<mailto:HKim@kasowitz.com>> wrote:
`
`H
`
`i Claudia,
`
`We are available for a call tomorrow at 11am Pacific.
`
`Thanks,
`Heather
`
`From: Frost, Claudia [mailto:cfrost@orrick.com]
`Sent: Friday, March 13, 2020 4:02 AM
`To: Heather Kim <HKim@kasowitz.com<mailto:HKim@kasowitz.com>>; Jensen, Travis
`<tjensen@orrick.com<mailto:tjensen@orrick.com>>; Apple-Fintiv_OHS <Apple-
`Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com<mailto:Apple-Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com>>;
`steve.ravel@kellyhart.com<mailto:steve.ravel@kellyhart.com>; J. R. Johnson
`<JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com<mailto:JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com>>
`Cc: atindel@andytindel.com<mailto:atindel@andytindel.com>; Mark Mann
`(mark@TheMannFirm.com<mailto:mark@TheMannFirm.com>)
`<mark@TheMannFirm.com<mailto:mark@TheMannFirm.com>>; Fintiv
`<Fintiv@kasowitz.com<mailto:Fintiv@kasowitz.com>>
`Subject: RE: Fintiv v. Apple
`
`**EXTERNAL EMAIL**
`
`________________________________
`Counsel,
`
`For a variety of reasons, including myriad Coronavirus complications and the production by Fintiv of 50,000 pages
`of documents – Fintiv’s first substantial document production in the case on Tuesday, March 10 – we are not be able
`to accommodate the rescheduling of the deposition of Mr. Salume to March 16 in New York. We also request that
`Mr. Salume (Fintiv’s Chairman) sit for his deposition in Austin, which is where Fintiv has its only US facility,
`where all of its relevant witnesses are located or are willing to travel for trial and where all of its relevant documents
`are located. See, e.g., Fintiv’s Resp. to Apple’s Mtn. to Transfer Venue at 4; Fintiv’s Initial Disclosures at 13.
`
`As set forth in my email of March 8, with respect to scheduling these depositions we need to receive: (i) the dates
`you propose for each of the Rule 30(b)(1) witnesses we have noticed (and their respective Rule 30(b)(6) topics, if
`any); (ii) dates for the additional three witnesses we identified in our March 8 email; (iii) dates for the Rule 30(b)(6)
`deposition(s) we noticed on January 3, 2020, with the names of the deponents and the topics each will cover; and
`(iv) the status of the horse trade you proposed and discussed in our emails of March 5 and 8.
`
`In addition to the 11 Rule 30(b)(1) depositions we need to take (subject to the horse trade we emailed about), we
`have an as yet undetermined number of Rule 30(b)(6) depositions of Fintiv to take since we have not been told who
`the witnesses will be or the topics they will cover. Fintiv has noticed the depositions of 12 Apple individuals
`(subject to the horse trade) and has noticed the Rule 30(b)(6) deposition of Apple on 42 topics. On top of this, at
`last count, Fintiv has noticed 9 additional third-party depositions across the country (including California, New
`York, Chicago, Austin and San Antonio), which will need to be coordinated if they are to go forward.
`
`We have presented two Apple witnesses for deposition already, offered dates in February for others which you
`declined (e.g., Chris Sharp), confirmed (prior to complications resulting from coronavirus) dates for seven other
`witnesses, at least one of which you later cancelled (e.g., Mark Rollins), and have generally been offering dates and
`
`Apple Ex. 1039, p. 2
`Apple v. Fintiv
`IPR2020-00019
`
`

`

`witnesses on a rolling basis.
`
`We have far too many depositions to schedule between us to handle this piecemeal. I suggest we have a call next
`week to discuss this, to identify the Rule 30(b)(6) witnesses and topics and to work on a plan and schedule for all of
`the fact depositions and the other deadlines in the overall schedule for this case. All of this will be subject to
`Coronavirus complications, of course, which are rapidly escalating and evolving and exacerbating the challenges
`this scheduling situation is posing.
`
`Please let me know if you are amenable to an omnibus scheduling call and when you would be available next week.
`
`Best regards,
`
`Claudia
`
`From: Heather Kim <HKim@kasowitz.com<mailto:HKim@kasowitz.com>>
`Sent: Thursday, March 12, 2020 6:41 PM
`To: Jensen, Travis <tjensen@orrick.com<mailto:tjensen@orrick.com>>; Frost, Claudia
`<cfrost@orrick.com<mailto:cfrost@orrick.com>>; Apple-Fintiv_OHS <Apple-
`Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com<mailto:Apple-Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com>>;
`steve.ravel@kellyhart.com<mailto:steve.ravel@kellyhart.com>; J. R. Johnson
`<JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com<mailto:JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com>>
`Cc: atindel@andytindel.com<mailto:atindel@andytindel.com>; Mark Mann
`(mark@TheMannFirm.com<mailto:mark@TheMannFirm.com>)
`<mark@TheMannFirm.com<mailto:mark@TheMannFirm.com>>; Fintiv
`<Fintiv@kasowitz.com<mailto:Fintiv@kasowitz.com>>
`Subject: RE: Fintiv v. Apple
`
`Counsel,
`
`Following up on the below, please let us know whether you intend to depose Mr. Salume on March 16 so that we
`can make arrangements.
`
`Thank you,
`
`Heather
`
`Heather Kim
`Kasowitz Benson Torres LLP
`333 Twin Dolphin Drive, Suite 200
`Redwood Shores, CA 94065
`Tel. (650) 453-5419
`Fax. (650) 362-9316
`HKim@kasowitz.com
`
`This e-mail and any files transmitted with it are confidential and may be subject to the attorney-client privilege. Use
`or disclosure of this e-mail or any such files by anyone other than a designated addressee is unauthorized. If you are
`not an intended recipient, please notify the sender by e-mail and delete this e-mail without making a copy.
`
`Apple Ex. 1039, p. 3
`Apple v. Fintiv
`IPR2020-00019
`
`

`

`From: Heather Kim
`Sent: Wednesday, March 11, 2020 1:02 PM
`To: 'Jensen, Travis' <tjensen@orrick.com<mailto:tjensen@orrick.com>>; Frost, Claudia
`<cfrost@orrick.com<mailto:cfrost@orrick.com>>; Apple-Fintiv_OHS <Apple-
`Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com<mailto:Apple-Fintiv_OHS@orrick.com>>;
`steve.ravel@kellyhart.com<mailto:steve.ravel@kellyhart.com>; J. R. Johnson
`<JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com<mailto:JR.Johnson@kellyhart.com>>
`Cc: atindel@andytindel.com<mailto:atindel@andytindel.com>; 'Mark Mann
`(mark@TheMannFirm.com<mailto:mark@TheMannFirm.com>)'
`<mark@TheMannFirm.com<mailto:mark@TheMannFirm.com>>; Fintiv
`<Fintiv@kasowitz.com<mailto:Fintiv@kasowitz.com>>
`Subject: Fintiv v. Apple
`
`Counsel,
`
`Adolfo Salume is available for deposition on Monday, March 16, at our NYC office. Please advise as soon as
`possible whether Apple accepts this date.
`
`Thank you,
`Heather
`
`NOTICE TO RECIPIENT | This e-mail is meant for only the intended recipient of the transmission, and may be a
`communication privileged by law. If you received this e-mail in error, any review, use, dissemination, distribution,
`or copying of this e-mail is strictly prohibited. Please notify us immediately of the error by return e-mail and please
`delete this message from your system. Thank you in advance for your cooperation.
`
`For more information about Orrick, please visit http://www.orrick.com<http://www.orrick.com>.
`
`In the course of our business relationship, we may collect, store and transfer information about you. Please see our
`privacy policy at https://www.orrick.com/Privacy-Policy<https://www.orrick.com/Privacy-Policy> to learn about
`how we use this information.
`
`NOTICE TO RECIPIENT | This e-mail is meant for only the intended recipient of the transmission, and may be a
`communication privileged by law. If you received this e-mail in error, any review, use, dissemination, distribution,
`or copying of this e-mail is strictly prohibited. Please notify us immediately of the error by return e-mail and please
`delete this message from your system. Thank you in advance for your cooperation.
`
`For more information about Orrick, please visit http://www.orrick.com<http://www.orrick.com/>.
`
`In the course of our business relationship, we may collect, store and transfer information about you. Please see our
`privacy policy at https://www.orrick.com/Privacy-Policy<https://www.orrick.com/Privacy-Policy> to learn about
`how we use this information.
`
`Apple Ex. 1039, p. 4
`Apple v. Fintiv
`IPR2020-00019
`
`