Trials
`Gene Cherng; Jonathan Tuminaro; Trials
`Mike Ray; Michael Specht; Daniel Block; Trent W. Merrell; Tyler Dutton; Robert Freitas; Christopher O"Brien;
`Wenchong Shu; Melanie Arlantico
`RE: IPR2019-01523, -01525, -01526, and -01527 -- Sur-replies to POPRs
`Wednesday, January 22, 2020 1:26:02 PM
`image003.png
`image004.png
`image005.png
`
`From:
`To:
`Cc:
`
`Subject:
`Date:
`Attachments:
`
`Counsel:
`
`No call is necessary. Petitioner is authorized to file a reply (no more than 5 pages, due one week from
`receipt of this email) in IPR2019-01526, IPR2019-01523, and IPR2019-01525 addressing the issues
`outlined below. Petitioner may not file additional evidence. Patent Owner may, if it wishes, file a sur-
`reply (also no more than 5 pages, due one week after filing of Petitioner’s reply). The parties should
`reference this email as authorization.
`
`Regards,
`
`Andrew Kellogg,
`Supervisory Paralegal
`Patent Trial and Appeal Board
`USPTO
`andrew.kellogg@uspto.gov
`(571)272-7822
`
`From: Gene Cherng <GCherng@fawlaw.com>
`Sent: Tuesday, January 21, 2020 3:11 AM
`To: Jonathan Tuminaro <JTUMINAR@sternekessler.com>; Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: Mike Ray <MRAY@sternekessler.com>; Michael Specht <MSPECHT@sternekessler.com>; Daniel
`Block <DBLOCK@sternekessler.com>; Trent W. Merrell <TMERRELL@sternekessler.com>; Tyler
`Dutton <TDUTTON@sternekessler.com>; Robert Freitas <RFreitas@fawlaw.com>; Christopher
`O'Brien <COBrien@sternekessler.com>; Wenchong Shu <WSHU@sternekessler.com>; Melanie
`Arlantico <MArlantico@fawlaw.com>
`Subject: RE: IPR2019-01523, -01525, -01526, and -01527 -- Sur-replies to POPRs
`
`Dear Board,
`
`Patent Owners Aquila Innovations Inc. (-01526, ’519 patent and -01525, ’614 patent),
`and Collabo Innovations, Inc. (-01523, ’575 patent) oppose Petitioner’s request for leave
`to file replies to each of the preliminary responses, and are available for a conference
`call on Friday from 2 to 4pm ET. Patent Owners are not available on Tuesday and
`Wednesday at the times identified by AMD.
`
`Regards,
`
`Gene H. Cherng
`
`AQUILA - Ex. 2004
`
`

`

`350 Marine Parkway, Suite 200
`Redwood Shores, CA 94065
`D (650) 730-5502 · F (650) 593-6301
`www.fawlaw.com
`
`
`
`From: Jonathan Tuminaro <JTUMINAR@sternekessler.com>
`Sent: Monday, January 20, 2020 1:05 PM
`To: Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: Gene Cherng <GCherng@fawlaw.com>; Mike Ray <MRAY@sternekessler.com>; Michael Specht
`<MSPECHT@sternekessler.com>; Daniel Block <DBLOCK@sternekessler.com>; Trent W. Merrell
`<TMERRELL@sternekessler.com>; Tyler Dutton <TDUTTON@sternekessler.com>; Robert Freitas
`<RFreitas@fawlaw.com>; Christopher O'Brien <COBrien@sternekessler.com>; Wenchong Shu
`<WSHU@sternekessler.com>; Melanie Arlantico <MArlantico@fawlaw.com>
`Subject: IPR2019-01523, -01525, -01526, and -01527 -- Sur-replies to POPRs
`
`Dear PTAB,
`
`Petitioner AMD seeks the Board’s permission to file sur-replies to the Patent Owner
`Preliminary Responses in IPR2019-01526 (’519 patent), IPR2019-01523 (’575 patent), and
`IPR2019-01525 (’614 patent). The basis for each request is set forth below.
`
`IPR2019-01526 and IPR2019-01523. Consistent with the recent POP decision in Hulu v.
`Sound View Innovations, Petitioner AMD seeks the Board’s permission to file (i) a 5-page sur-
`reply to the POPR in IPR2019-01526 to address the printed-publication status of Exhibit 1005
`and (ii) a 5-page sur-reply to the POPR in IPR2019-01523 to address the printed-publication
`status of Exhibit 1006. And, consistent with the Hulu decision, AMD seeks the Board’s
`permission to add additional evidence supporting the status of these exhibits as printed
`publications.
`
`IPR2019-01525. AMD seeks the Board’s permission to file a 5-page sur-reply to address two
`issues raised in the POPR. First, AMD seeks permission to address the POPR’s misapplication
`of the Hologic decision with respect to alternative claim constructions. And, second, AMD
`seeks permission to show, contrary to the arguments in the POPR, that Petitioner did show on
`the record how the claimed “unit cell” is met.
`
`The Patent Owner indicated that it would oppose AMD’s requests. AMD is available for a
`teleconference Tuesday, January 21 from 9am to 11am ET, Wednesday, January 22 from 9am
`to noon ET, and Friday, January 24 from 2pm to 4pm ET.
`
`Regards,
`Jonathan
`Counsel for Petitioner AMD
`
`
`Jonathan Tuminaro, Ph.D.
`Director
`Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox P.L.L.C.
`1100 New York Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20005
`
`

`

`Email: jtuminar@sternekessler.com
`Direct: 202.772.8967
`Administrative Assistant: Earnesteen Ginn-White
`Main: 202.371.2600 Direct: 202.772.8574
`
`Notice: The information in this electronic transmission (including any attachments)
`may contain confidential or legally privileged information and is intended solely for
`the individual(s) or entity(ies) named above. If you are not an intended recipient or
`an authorized agent, you are hereby notified that reading, distributing, or otherwise
`disseminating or copying, or taking any action based on the contents of this
`transmission is strictly prohibited. Any unauthorized interception of this
`transmission is illegal under the law. If you have received this transmission in error,
`please immediately notify the sender by return email and then destroy all copies of
`the transmission.
`
`