SNAP INC. v. BLACKBERRY LIMITED
`IPR2019-00715
`
`Snap Inc. Ex. 1013 Page 0001
`
`

`

`US 9,507,778 132
`
`Page 2
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`5.583.763
`5.651.068
`5.761.662
`5.764.906
`5.781.879
`5.784.365
`5.794.210
`5.802.510
`5.835.087
`5.903.848
`5.920.854
`6.014.638
`6.021.403
`6.047.234
`6.098.065
`6.112.181
`6.157.924
`6.169.992
`6.212.552
`6.266.667
`6.314.365
`6.314.399
`6.324.519
`6.327.590
`6.446.065
`6.490.698
`6.502.033
`6.523.172
`6.571.279
`6.601.012
`6.662.195
`6.665.640
`6.694.316
`6.701.311
`6.701.315
`6.708.203
`6.731.940
`6.741.980
`6.757.661
`6.773.344
`6.781.920
`6.785.670
`6.789.073
`6.813.501
`6.816.850
`6.829.333
`6.834.195
`6.842.761
`6.845.370
`6.850.252
`6.853.913
`6.853.982
`6.882.977
`6.904.160
`6.931.254
`6.961.660
`6.961.731
`6.985.839
`7.010.492
`7.027.801
`7.058.508
`7.058.626
`7.062.510
`7.065.345
`7.065.483
`7.069.308
`7.073.129
`7.110.776
`7.143.091
`7.149.696
`7.181.438
`7.185.286
`7.194.512
`7.203.597
`7.209.915
`
`>>b>b>b>b>bififibi9
`
`carom0:1:macawwwwwmama-0:000u:wwwwwt:wwwwwwwwwwmwwawwwwwwwwwww»>
`
`M—MwM—.—M—.——MM-—M-—Mm-—mmm—mm—-—M-—-————.—m—.—.—.—-———.—.—.—.—.—.—.—.—.—
`
`B2
`82
`B 1
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B1
`
`1211996
`”11199?
`611998
`611998
`'11 1998
`'11 1998
`811998
`91 1998
`1 1 1998
`511999
`'111999
`112000
`212000
`412000
`812000
`812000
`1212000
`112001
`412001
`112001
`1 112001
`1 1 1200 1
`1 1 1200 1
`1212001
`912002
`1212002
`1212002
`212003
`512003
`712003
`1212003
`1212003
`212004
`312004
`312004
`312004
`512004
`512004
`612004
`812004
`812004
`812004
`912004
`1 112004
`1 112004
`1212004
`1212004
`112005
`112005
`212005
`212005
`212005
`412005
`612005
`12005
`1 112005
`1 112005
`112006
`312006
`412006
`612006
`612006
`612006
`612006
`612006
`612006
`712006
`912006
`1 112006
`1212006
`212002
`21200?
`312007
`412002
`412002
`
`Atohoson at al.
`Klomba et a].
`Dasan
`Edelstein et a1.
`Arnold et al.
`lkeda
`Goldhaber et 511.
`Jones
`1161':
`'l'akahashi
`Kirsch ct a].
`13ng0 ct a].
`Hon‘it‘z et al.
`Cherveny el :1].
`Skillen et 01.
`Shear et al.
`Austin
`Beall et 31.
`13111113 61 al.
`Olsson
`Smith
`Dcligne cl a].
`Eldering
`Chidlovskii 61 a].
`Nishioka or al.
`Howirz er al.
`Phuyal
`Martinez—Guerra e1 3].
`11ch (:1 a1.
`llorvitz ct al.
`Langseth et 31.
`Bennett et a].
`Langsofll or al.
`Biebosheimer et 01.
`Austin
`Maker el 3.].
`Nagendran
`langseth et a1.
`Blamr ct a1.
`Gabaj et a].
`Bates et al.
`Chiang et al.
`Lunenfeld
`Kinnlmen el al.
`Culliss
`Frazier
`Brandenberg e1 :11.
`Diamond et a1.
`Burkey et al.
`Hofiberg
`Cherveny cl 3].
`Smith el al.
`Miller
`Burgess
`Egner 01 a1.
`Underbrink (-21 a].
`Hoibrook
`Molamedi 61 a].
`Bassetl el al.
`11110 et a].
`(‘omhs et :11.
`Pan et al.
`Eldering
`Carlton et al.
`Decary ct al.
`Abrams
`Robans e1 :1].
`Sambin
`Charnock 01 3].
`8111101211 151 al.
`873110
`Zondervan
`Crocmor ct a].
`86.10 cl :1].
`Taboadn el a1.
`
`7.2 19.0 1 3
`7.236.969
`7.254.581
`7.257.570
`7.3 05 .445
`7.3 20.0 25
`7.343 .364
`7.395 .507
`7.4 04.084
`7.4 37.3 12
`7.45 I .102
`7.46 I . 168
`7.4 96.548
`7.522.995
`7.529.81 1
`7.562.122
`7.577.665
`7.584.2 l5
`7.624.104
`7.624.146
`7.634.465
`7.657.907
`7.681 .147
`7.7 25 .492
`7.7 29.901
`7.769.740
`7.769.745
`7.783 .622
`7.792.040
`7.802.724
`7.822.871
`7.831 .586
`7.865 .308
`7.925 .708
`200110013009
`200110035880
`200110047384
`200 [1'00 52058
`200210014742
`200 2100 19849
`200210019857
`2002100 23091
`200 2100 23230
`200210035605
`200 210049968
`200 210052786
`200210052875
`200 2-00 540 89
`200 210065 844
`2002100 692 18
`200210099695
`200210103870
`200210111956
`2002101 12035
`200210133400
`20021013833 1
`200210152267
`200 210 169840
`200210173971
`200 2101 78 161
`200 2101 98786
`2003100 08661
`2003100 09367
`2003100 09495
`200310027558
`200310032409
`200310033331
`200310033394
`200310065 762
`2003100698 77
`2003100 698 80
`20031”00 789 78
`2003100 809 92
`200310 1 262 50
`200310149574
`200310154293
`200310165 241
`200310191816
`2004100 10492
`
`Bl
`Bl
`BZ
`B2
`B2
`Bl
`B2
`B2
`B2
`32
`B2
`B1
`B1
`B2
`32
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`Bl
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`Bl
`B2
`Bl
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`{Kl
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`.41
`A1
`.41
`Al *
`(\l
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`A1
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`Al
`(\1
`
`512 007
`612 007
`812 007
`812007
`1212 007
`112 008
`31-2 008
`712 008
`712 008
`1012 008
`1 112008
`1212 008
`212 009
`41r2 009
`51120139
`712 009
`812 009
`912 009
`1 112009
`1 112 009
`1212 009
`212 0 10
`312010
`512 0 10
`612 0 10
`812 0 10
`812 0 10
`81120 10
`9120 10
`9120 10
`l 012 0 10
`l 112 0 10
`[1'20 1 l
`4120] l
`812 001
`1 112 001
`1 112 001
`1212 001
`212 002
`212 002
`212 002
`212002
`21'2 002
`312002
`412 002
`512 002
`512 002
`512002
`512 002
`612 002
`71'2 002
`812002
`812 002
`812 002
`912002
`912 002
`1012 002
`1 112 002
`1 112 002
`1 11-2 002
`1 212002
`112 003
`112003
`112 003
`2.12 003
`21r2 003
`212003
`212 003
`412 003
`412 003
`412 003
`412 003
`512003
`712 003
`81r2 003
`812 003
`912 003
`1012 003
`112 004
`
`Young at al.
`Skillen et :11.
`Johnson et 0.1.
`111156 01 al.
`Singh et a].
`Steinberg el al.
`Bram el al.
`Robarts (:1 a].
`Fransdonk
`Bhatia cl a1.
`Nowak
`Wan
`Ershov
`Nomp
`Thompson
`Oliver el al.
`Rameer e1 :1].
`Saari et al.
`Berkhin e1 a].
`Brogne et al.
`Sareen at 111.
`Pennan et a1.
`Richardson-Blmblu'y not al.
`Sittig at al.
`Richanlson-Bllnbury e1 31.
`Maninez
`Naaman
`Vandcrmolen cl :1].
`Nair el al.
`Nohr
`Stolorz at al.
`Reinor of 01.
`Athsanj
`Davis
`Greening et al.
`Musatov et 01.
`Croy
`0hran
`(Tonle et a].
`'1qu el al.
`Haijanto
`Silberbcrg or al.
`Bolnick et a1.
`McDowell or 31.
`Wilson cl 3.].
`Kim el :11.
`Smith et 3].
`Nicholas
`Robinson el al.
`SL111 el al.
`Abajian ct a].
`Shouji
`Yoo ct al.
`Carey
`Terry 61 a].
`Hosea 61 a].
`Lennon
`Sheldon el al.
`Stirpe at a].
`Brezin et a1.
`Tripp el al.
`Joyce et al.
`Morrison
`Adjaoute
`Eisinger
`Hutcheson at al.
`Sena et a].
`Stine at al.
`Stolorz et al.
`Grefenslelte e1 :11.
`Harrison et al.
`Lardin ct a1.
`Haines
`Jhanji
`Rudrnnn
`Zmnlek
`Fransdonk
`Landress et al.
`Zhao et al.
`
`705126
`
`Snap Inc. Ex. 1013 Page 0002
`Snap Inc. EX. 1013 Page 0002
`
`

`

`US 9,507,778 132
`
`Page 3
`
`[56)
`
`References Cited
`
`U_S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`172004 C0111:
`200470015588 Al
`272004 Andersson et aL
`200470030798 .41
`272004 01111111
`200470034152 Al
`372004 866721111451.
`200470043758 .41
`372004 Austin-Lane 61111.
`200470044736 7111
`4.72004 Kobuya cl 31
`200470070502 Al
`772004 (010an
`200470139025 Al
`772004 Rechsteiner
`200470139047 711
`772004 (-0115
`200470143341 Al
`20047015247? m 872004 W“ e, 111.
`200470133329 Al
`972004 Kontny et a1,
`
`200470203851 A1
`200470203909 Al
`2004702056229 711*
`
`1072004 ‘7er et aL
`1072004 Koster
`1072004 Rosenlmltz
`
`606F17.-"30861
`7157207
`
`200470209602 711
`200470243523 Al
`200470260804 Al
`200470267880 711
`200570005242 .11
`200570015451 .41
`200570015599 Al
`200570050027 A1
`200570050043 711*
`200570055321 711
`200570050331 Al
`200570065950 Al
`200570065980 Al
`200570070060 A1
`200570086187 Al
`200570105552 Al
`200570103213 A1
`200570120005 A1
`200570131727 Al
`20057011493017 Al
`200570151840 Al
`200570159220 Al
`2005-0159970 Al
`200570150030 A1
`200570165699 Al
`200570155240 Al
`200570171955 .41
`200570177385 Al
`200570182824 Al
`200570133110 Al
`20057013777735 Al
`200570192025 51
`200570203301 Al
`200570216295 .41
`200570215300 Al
`200570219375 Al
`2005702341731 Al
`200570273510 Al
`200670020631 A1
`200570025013 Al
`200670026067 711
`200670026170 711*
`200670031108 Al
`200670036588 r417*
`200570040719 Al
`200670047553 Al
`200570047515 Al
`200670053058 711
`200670069612 Al
`200570059515 Al
`200670069749 Al
`200670074853 Al
`200670085392 Al
`2006700815419 Al
`200670089876 Al
`200670106847 Al"
`200670116924 A1
`2001570123053 Al
`200670129313 Al
`
`1072004 Joyce o1 a1.
`1272004 Ozer et al.
`1272004 Grabamik 01 a].
`1272004 Paliejunas
`172005 1103711:
`172005 Sheldon 61711.
`172005 “731131115111
`3.72005 Yeh
`372005 Pyhalammj 61 a1.
`372005 Fratkina
`3.72005 Htlyuh at 51
`372005 Chaganli e1 31.
`372005 Hyatt 1:1 711.
`472005 1:111" ct a].
`472005 (316mm 8].
`572005 Oslcrling
`572005 Rjise et :11.
`572005 Nye
`572005 Sagan
`”772005
`.VIoIgenslem el 31
`772005 171171111511 61 711.
`1.772005
`“71155“ .31 21.].
`772005 Btlytlkkokten cl 8].
`772005 Dawson
`772005 1.171111142115011
`7772005 Kim
`872005 111111 at a].
`872005 1111118111.
`872005 c6116
`372005 Anderson
`3.72005 Tsaj
`972005 Kaplan
`972005 571013511503,“ et 31
`972005 Abrahmnsohn
`972005 Appclman c1 :11.
`1072005 Hasegawa 01 a1.
`1072005 Morgenstcrn
`1272005 551-1011
`172006 Choong Wan o1 a1.
`272005 Krafl
`272006 Nicholas e1 31.
`272006 Kreiller el 3].
`272005 Oran
`272006 Frank o1 al.
`272005 Plimi
`372005 Wade”
`372005 Ravin
`372006 1-Iotchk1'ss 0181.
`372005 Hurt ct al.
`372005 Ban
`372006 Her): 01 a].
`472006 Lillet al.
`472006 Wang cl :11.
`472006 Rosen
`472006 Boys
`572006 Eckardt £1 a].
`672006 AngCIQS et al.
`672006 Scanncll. Jr,
`672006 Becker
`
`70776
`
`707710
`
`70773
`
`............... 7077101
`
`672006 Doshi
`200670129605 A1
`772006 Oustiougov el :11.
`200670161894 Al
`772006 Hllnsinger el :11.
`200670168591 A1
`872006 Gaxg at al.
`200670173838 A1
`872006 Moore
`200670173985 Al
`82006 Lee _
`200670178822 Al
`872006 Fuseller 12121.1.
`200670184508 Al
`87.2006 Mills
`_
`200579184579 01
`972006 Sawiampl
`200670213330 Al
`972006 Amcrally cl 8].
`200670212401 A1
`1072006 Rtlnge et a].
`200670227945 A1
`1072006 Yang ct 4"
`20067023506 01
`1072006 Othmer cl 8].
`200670236257 A1
`200670242126 81* 1072006 1=i1zhugh
`200670242139 Al
`1072006 Bulterfield et 31.
`
`70773
`
`200670242259 A1
`200670258368 A1
`200570282455 01
`200770013550 Al
`20077001509 01
`200770032244 Al“
`200770043766 A1
`200770067104 A1
`200770057267 Al
`2007700725“ Al
`200770073583 Al
`200770073641 Al
`200770036051 01
`200770087755 Al
`200770088852 A1
`200770100956 Al
`200770113753 7“
`200770115373 781*
`200770121343 Al
`200770130137 A1
`2011770136048 A1
`200770136235 Al
`200770136256 Al
`2007701361589 Al
`200770143345 Al
`2007701501138 Al
`200770150359 A1
`200770155411 Al
`200770161382 A1
`200770162850 A1
`200770168430 Al
`200770173265 Al
`200770179792 Al
`200770185599 Al
`200770185858 Al‘
`200770192299 Al
`200770198506 Al
`200770198563 01
`200770203591 A1
`200770219708 A1
`200770233585 A1
`200770239348 Al
`200770239517 Al
`200770259653 Al
`200770250508 01
`200770250604 7‘1
`200770271297 A1
`200770271340 01
`200770273758 Al
`200770276940 A1
`200770282621 Al
`20070232675 Al
`200770288278 Al
`200870005313 Al
`200870005651 Al
`200370010206 Al
`2001170021957 Al
`200870026804 A1
`200870028031 A1
`200870040283 Al
`200870046298 Al
`200370070588 Al
`200870086356 A1
`
`.
`34872313
`
`_
`45574561
`
`1072006 Vailalh et al.
`1172006 Granitoct 8].
`”72006 Lee
`172007 Casey
`172007 Casey
`272007 Counts et al.
`272007 Nicholas 61 al.
`372007 Mays
`3712007
`Ives
`3-2007 Mch e141-
`372007 Groufel a].
`372007 Perry ct al.
`472007 Robbms
`47,2007 Hofibel‘g
`472007 Levkowtz
`572007 Kumar
`572007 15mm“
`572007 Gallagher et a].
`572007 Atazky etal-
`672007 Oliver el 21].
`672007 Richardson-Blmbury et al.
`672007 Hess
`672007 Kapur el 5.].
`672007 Richardson-Burlbury et a1.
`672007 Jones at al.
`672007 Balcom 01 81.
`672007 1.111101 8].
`772007 Momson
`772007 Melinger etal.
`772007 Adler
`772007 311111 e1 :11.
`"772007 Hams
`872007
`K777711777
`872007 Robinson at 3].
`872007 Lu ..................... (3061:17730864
`872007 Zuckcrbcrg of a].
`872007 Aflaran Rczaci cl :1].
`872007
`00174740 ct aL
`872007 Bowermzm
`972007 Brasche e1 :11.
`1072007 Ben Simonet a].
`1072007 Cheung
`1072007 Chung fit all
`1172007 Tang etal.
`1172007 Barry ct al.
`1172007 Hacuser 61417
`1172007 Jaflb et a1.
`1172007 Goodman ‘31 all
`1172007 Mendoza et al.
`1172007 Aan or al.
`1272007 Altman etal.
`1272007 Varghese
`1272007 Alexander El 211.
`172008 Flake et al.
`172008 Grct'cnstclte cl £1.17
`172008 Coleman
`172008 Medved at 21].
`172008 Barfly 01 a].
`172008 Bailey et a].
`272008 Morris
`272008 Ben-Yehuda el 21].
`372008 Morin
`472008 Glassman 01 a].
`
`Snap Inc. Ex. 1013 Page 0003
`Snap Inc. EX. 1013 Page 0003
`
`

`

`US 9,507,778 132
`
`Page 4
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`200810086431 Al
`200810091796 Al
`200810096664 Al
`200810102911 Al
`200810104061 Al
`20081010422? Al
`200810109761 Al
`200810109843 A1
`200810114751. Al
`200810120183 Al
`200310120303 Al
`200810120690 Al
`200810133750 Al
`200810147655 Al
`200810147743 .41
`200810148175 Al
`2003-0154730 Al
`2008101632814 Al
`200810l‘12632 Al
`£03810:37:23 A:
`230313282886 it
`200810501250 Al
`200810320001 Al
`2009.-0005987 [“1
`20091000535 Al
`200910012934 .41
`200910012965 Al
`200910043844 Al
`200910044132 Al
`200910063254 Al
`200910070186 Al
`200910073191 Al
`200910076889 Al
`200910100052 Al
`200910l06356 Al
`200910135517 Al
`200910132941 Al
`2009110144141 Al
`3333135323; 1::
`’
`200910165051 Al
`333323130232 ::
`200910187637 .41
`200910204484 Al
`200910204672 Al
`2009.-"0204676 Al
`2009.-"0216606 A1
`20091022,302 Al
`2009.0525303 Al
`200910234814 Al
`200910234909 (\1
`2009110249482 Al
`2009.-"0265431 Al
`2009'028199? 2‘1
`200910299337 Al
`200910313545 Al
`200910320047 Al
`200910323519 Al
`2009.-0323037 Al
`20101000263 5 Al
`2010_.-'00}4444 Al
`201010063993 Al
`201010070368 Al
`20l010118025 Al
`201010125563 Al
`201010125569 Al
`201010125604 Al
`201010125605 Al
`201010185642 Al
`
`412008 Robinson el al.
`412008 Story et al.
`412008 Bamy el al.
`512008 Campbell el al.
`512008 Rezaci
`512008 Bimie et al.
`512008 Stambaugh
`512008 Ullah
`512008 Cramer et al.
`512008 Park‘
`512008 3431111162: el al.
`512008 Norlander et a].
`612008 Grabamik cl :1].
`612008 Sinlm ct al.
`612008 Taylor et al.
`612008 Nam'nan el :11.
`612008 Gottnares
`712008 Martinez et al.
`712008 81111111131191
`13230:
`finen
`l
`1112038 11111::01 a I
`1212008 Handy et 211
`1212008 Gaddam i
`112009 V’engrofl at al'
`1.12009 Forslall at al.
`112009 Yerigan
`112009 Franken
`212009 Zimmet et al.
`212009 ('ombel et a].
`312009 Paul el :11.
`312009 Builen et a].
`312009 Smith 01 al.
`312009 Jhanji
`412009 Stem et al.
`412009 Erase et al.
`513009 Krishnaswamy ‘31 31-
`512009 Pilskalns et al.
`012009 l)ontinowska cl 31'
`3:333 gavis e: at
`'_
`avts e a '
`6";2009 AMI}:
`:‘éggg 3111531"; el 31‘
`712009 Winn131:11.
`812009 Johnson
`3.2009 Jotha et :11
`812009 Parkinson et a].
`”009 C00?
`et al.
`9&009 Higgins
`9&009 Higgins
`912009 Boerries el al.
`9’12009 Strandeil Ct al.
`10112009 301:3th
`10,1200.)
`Janie et al.
`1112009 Jain
`12,9009 Steelberg et a].
`[212009 Kalpelly at al.
`1212009 Khan et al.
`12.12009 Pun
`1213009 Higgins et al.
`112010 Eklnnd
`1.12010 Ghanadan et a]_
`312010 Higgins 01 a].
`312010 C1101 01 a].
`5120l0 Smith el al.
`5120l0 Nair el al.
`512010 Nair at a].
`512010 Martinez et al.
`512010 Nair Ct :11.
`712010 Higgins el al.
`
`1020000036897
`KR
`1020000054319
`KR
`Iii—20000064105
`KR
`1020030049173
`KR
`ill-0801662
`KR
`109-0060043333
`KR
`103007034094
`KR
`13533313311132
`g:
`“1020061116196
`W0
`“I'D-20061116196 4"
`W0
`W0 W0 3001.022”? ‘
`‘-
`wo
`“1030071027433
`wo
`wo 2007070358
`“10
`“1020071 [3540
`
`712000
`912000
`1.112000
`612003
`212005
`512006
`39007
`2%;
`1112006
`1.112006
`212007
`312007
`61200?
`10.2007
`
`.
`..
`‘
`__
`01 HER PUBLIC-4110915
`
`to Content:
`Davis. M. et al. (Oct. [046. 2004). "From Context
`Leveraging Context to Inl'er Media Metadata” MM’W New York.
`New york
`Davis. M. et al. “From Context to Content: Leveraging C01110911 for
`MOb'lc mod'a Manda”),
`Davis. M. et :11. (Apr. 2-7. 2005 ). “MMMZ: Mobile Media Metadata
`for Media Sharing.” CHI 2005 Portland. Oregon.
`Davis. M. et a]. “Mobile Media Metadata for Mobile 1111381118."
`Davis. M. et al. “Using Context and Similarin for Face and
`I—ocaiion Identificalionf‘
`--Photo Sharing." located at <11ttp:.-"1
`l-‘lickr. “Welcome to lilickr-
`Wfiickrcomb- visited on Feb. 26. 2007. one page.
`Goldberger. J. et 01. “The Hungarian Clustering Method.“ located at
`<ht1p:11schelatgoogles.com1scholaflnum=20&hl=en&lr=
`&9=cache:vbwslsmICisJ:www.openu.ac.il.-"Personal_sites.-"
`taminassa-Publicationsfhcm.
`pdf-l-go[fiber-genelustering+1nethod+hungarian> visited on Mar. 1.
`2007, Naive pagan
`Graham. A. et 3]. (Jul. 1311?. 2002). “Time as Essence for Photo
`Browsing 'I‘hrough Personal Digital Libraries."JC‘DL '02 Portland.
`Oregon.
`1301:. A. et al. (May 23-26. 2006). “Generating Summaries for Large
`Collections of Geo-Referenced Photographs." WWW 2006 Edin-
`burgh. Scotland.
`Jaife. A. et al. (Oct. 26-27. 2006). "Generating Summaries and
`Visualizatimt
`for Large Colleclions of Geo—Referenced Pholu—
`311113115." Mm 015820.111 Bubm‘ calf-EMA
`-
`-
`-
`-
`.
`105111. D._et al. (Oct. 15-16. 2004).
`[he Story Picturing angIne.
`l-Inding |:11te Images to Illustrate a Story Ustng Mutual Reinforce-
`238“" MR 04 Ne“ Yo’k‘ New..Y°’k'
`_
`1 amnan. M. et al. (Nov. 2003).
`from Where to What.vMetadata
`Sharing for Digital Photographs w1th Geographic Coordinates.“ 111
`011 1111? Move to Meaningfid Dimmer .Sjorems 2003: Coopa‘S. DOA.
`“"4 ODBASE 3' Mm's‘m“ ‘2 31' eds" PF" 19H”:
`.
`.
`Nail“ R. ET. 8.1 (NOV. 6‘] l. .2005). “Phulfl [MOI BTDWSIBg Mlliil-{ESEI’
`P110“) COllECllGl’lS.” MM’flj Singapore. pp. 223-224..
`0‘ Hare. .\l. ct al. ‘(Totnblnaiton of Content Analysts and Context
`Features for Digllfll Photograph Retrieval."
`Pigeatl. A. et al. (Jun. 17. 2005). “Organizing a Personal Image
`Colleclinn with Stallslical Model-Based 1C1, Clustering on Spatia-
`Temporal Camera Phone 0491303133,
`Sarvas. R. et al. (Jun. 6-9. 2004). "Metadata Creation System for
`Mobile Images.“ MobiSys'fl-a‘ Boston. Massachusetts. pp. 36-48.
`Toyama. K. et al. (Nov. 2-8. 2003). “Geographic Location Tags on
`Digitai Images." MM '03: Berkeley: California.
`U.S. Appl. No. 111593.668, filed Nov. 6. 2006. for Namnan et al.
`U.S. Appl. No. 111593.869, filed Nov. 6. 2006. for Naaman et al.
`U.S. Appl. No. 12.-"409.867. filed Mar. 24. 2009. King.
`U.S. Appl. .\lo. 121540.098. filed Aug. 12. 2009. Maninez.
`U.S. Appl. No. 121536.892. filed Aug. 6. 2009. King.
`U.S. Appl. No. 121540.588. filed Aug. 13. 2009. ’l'endjoukian.
`U.S. Appl. No. 121015.115. flied Jan. 16. 2006. Higgins.
`U.S. Appl. No. 121180.486. filed Jul. 25. 2008. Higgins.
`
`Snap Inc. Ex. 1013 Page 0004
`Snap Inc. EX. 1013 Page 0004
`
`

`

`US 9,507,778 132
`Page 5
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Asup. Jefi‘el a1 .. "Conceptualizing New Mobile Devices by (Ithserv-
`ing Gossip and Social Network Formal ion Amongst the Extremely
`Mobile". ITEE Technical Report #459. Dec. 19. 2005. pp. 1-71.
`Conhaim. Wallys “3.. “Social networks: the Internet continues to
`evolve: where is the money in all
`this? That
`is whal venture
`capitalists are asking. (Perspectives)”. Information Today. 22. 9.
`35(2). Oct. 2005. (pp. 1-5 of attached).
`Davis. Marc ct al.. “lil'om Context to Content: Leveraging Context
`to Infer Media Metadata”. ACM Press. Oct. 10. 2004. pp. 1-8.
`Kaasinen. 15.. “Behaviour & lnforrnntion Technology”. Taylor &
`Francis. vol. 24. No.
`l. Jan.3Feb. 2005. pp. 37-49. (Abstract only
`attached).
`Konomi. Shin'ichi et al.. “Supporting Colocated Interactions Using
`RFID and Social Network Displays”. Pervasive Computing. .1111.—
`Sep. 2006 . vol. 5. No. 3. pp. 48—56 (pp. 1-4 of attached).
`Lin. F. et al.. “A unified framework for managing Web-based
`services”. Information Systems and e-Business Management. vol.
`3. Oct. 2005. p. 299. (pp. 1-15 of attached).
`Meta. (fade. “MySpace Nation“. PC Magazine. Jun. 2l. 2006. pp.
`[-10 attached.
`Perkowitz. Mike et al.. “Utilizing Online Communities to Facilitate
`Physical World Interactions". The lntemational Conference on
`Communities and Technologies. Sep. 19. 2003. Amsterdam. pp.
`1 6.
`Roush. Wade. “Social Machines”. Continuous Computing Blog. Jul.
`5. 2005. pp. 1-21.
`Roush. Wade. “Social Machines“. Technology Review. Aug. 2005.
`pp. 45-51.
`Sheppard. Brelt. “The Rights Stuff: The integralion of Enterprise
`Digital Rights Management
`Into an Enterprise Architecture".
`ECantent. vol. 29. No. 9. Nov. 2006. p. 38. 40-44. (pp. 1-7 of
`attached).
`for Today’s Digital Market".
`Voigltl.
`Joan et al.. “Lessons
`ADWEEKCOM. Oct. 2. 2006. pp. [-6.
`“Companies add new communication fizatllres to photo sharing".
`Digital Imaging Digest. Feb. 2006. pp. 1-2.
`“Dave.TV and Eye Music Network Empower Users Io (.‘reale Their
`()Wn Music TV Channel on Their Sites With New II’TV Channel”.
`wwwdavenwcorru'2006. Sep. 13. 2006. pp. [-2.
`“Digital rights management: a primer: developing a user-friendly
`means of protecting eontent.(l’rofile)". Screen Digest. No. 420. p.
`305. Sep. 2006. (pp. 1-9 of attached).
`“Emerging Markets: What media 2.0 can offer advertisers". Cam-
`paign. Oct. 2'3. 2006. p. 26. (pp. 1-5 of attached).
`“Reality Digital Debuts Opus“. wwwlighlreadingcom. Sep. 25.
`2555. pp. 1.
`“Reality Digital Making Media Move". wwrealitydigitalcom.
`Nov. 28. 2006. pp. 1-2.
`Nedos. A; Singh K.. Clarke S. Proximity Based Group Communi-
`cations for Mobile Ad Hoc Networks. Proximity-Based Group
`Communication: Global Smart Spaces; 1114; Oct. 3. 2003: 31
`pages.
`Brunato. M; Battiti R. “Pilgrim: A Location Broker and Mobility-
`Aware Recommendation System"; Technical report BIT-020092.
`Universita dj Trento. Oct. 2002; 8 pages.
`Backstroln et al.. Spatial Variation in Search Engine Queries.
`WWW‘2008. Beijing. China (Apr. 21-25. 2008).
`Gan el al.. Analysis ot‘Geograpltie Queries in a Search Engine Log.
`LocWeb 2008. Beijing. China (Apr. 22. 2008).
`Jones et al.. Geographic intention and Modification in Web Search.
`International Journal ot'Geographical Information Science. vol. 22
`No. 3. pp.
`l-20 (Jul. 2008).
`Sanderson et al.. Analyzing Geographic Queries; Department of
`Information Studies; University of Sheffield. UK; 2 pages.
`Go With the Flow. The Economist Technology Quarterly. vol. 382.
`Issue 8519. 4 pages. (Mar. 10. 2007).
`International Search Report and Written Opinion (PCT-11520093
`060426) dated May 4. 2010; 12 pages.
`International Search Report and Written Opinion tl’CTr‘US20093
`060324) dated Apr. 30. 2010; 12 pages.
`International Search Report (PCT3'1;525593'055329) dated Apr. 30.
`2010; 3 pages.
`International Search Report and Written Opinion (PC'1‘311820083
`085135) dated May 25. 2009; '3 pages.
`
`Snap Inc. Ex. 1013 Page 0005
`Snap Inc. EX. 1013 Page 0005
`
`”313-3-3-‘3-‘3-3-‘3-‘3-‘3-3-manpaomwaamp
`,—
`f-‘f-‘f-‘Cf—‘FImanna
`
`Appl. No. 123180.499. filed Jul. 25. 2008. Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123015.146. filed Jan. 16. 2008. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123041.033. filed Mar. 3. 2003. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123041.052. filed Mar. 3. 2008. Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123041.054. filed Mar. 3. 2008. Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123540.269. filed Aug. 12. 2009. Kalaboukis.
`Appl. No. 113969.815. filed Jan. 4. 2004. Davis.
`.Appl. No. 123182.111. filed Jul. 29. 2008. Davis.
`Appl. No. 123434.525. filed May 1. 2009. O‘Sullivan.
`.Appl. No. 123434.580. filed May 1. 2009. O’Sullivan.
`Appl. No. 123402.690. filed Mar. 19. 2009. Davis.
`.Appl. No. 123402.681. filed Mar. 19.2009.Athsnni.
`l—l
`nlernational Search Repon (PCT.3’US2009'030405) dated Sep. 23.
`rut
`009; 2 pages.
`l.S. Appl. No. 123041.054. filed Mar. 3. 2008; 64 pgs.
`.8. Appl. No. 123041.062. filed Mar: 3. 2008; 66 pgs.
`. Appl. No. 123041.088. filed Mar. 3. 2008; 66 pgs.
`.Appl. No. 123169.931. filed Jul. 9. 2008; 66 pgs.
`Appl. No. 123120.025. filed Jul. 9. 2003; 5? pgs.
`Appl. No. 123180.499. filed Jul. 25. 2008; 6'3 pgs.
`.Appl. No. 123180.486. filed Jul. 25. 2008165 pgs.
`International Search Report PC3T'US20093030406 dated Sep. 29.
`2009; 5 pages.
`International Search Report and Written Opinion PCT-“1.1320093
`034445 daled 01:1. 12. 2009: '3 pages.
`Office Action US. Appl. No. 123041.054 dated Oct. 27. 2010; 15
`pages.
`Office Action U.S. App]. No. 123041.062 dated Oct. 28. 2010; 12
`pages.
`International Search Report PCT3US2009303444-4 dated Sep. 18.
`2009; 2 pages.
`Oflice Action U.S. Appl. No. 123041.088 dated Oct. 4. 2010; 18
`pages.
`.Appl. No. 113952.007. filed Dec. 6. 2007. Davis.
`Appl. No. 113958.152. filed Dec. 17. 2007. [layashi.
`.Appl. No. 113952.825. filed Dec. 7. 2002. Davis.
`. Appl. No. 113960.368. filed Dec. 19. 2002. Madsen.
`Appl. No. 113953.454. filed Dec. 10. 2007. Davis.
`.Appl. No. 113953.494. filed Dec. 10. 2002. Davis.
`. Appl. No. 123236.668. filed Sep. 24. 2008. Davis.
`.Appl. No. 123595.594. filed Mar. 31. 2008. Martinez.
`. Appl. No. 123052.828. filed Mar. 28. 2008. Martinez.
`Appl. No. 123057.943. filed Mar. 28. 2008. Martinez.
`.Appl. No. 113969.751. filed Jan. 4. 2008. Martinez.
`Appl. No. 123145.145. filed Jun. 24. 2008. Davis.
`Appl. No. 123163.249. filed Jun. 2'3. 2008. Kalaboukis.
`.Appl. No. 123182.969. filed Jul. 30. 2008. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123182.813. filed Jul. 30. 2008. Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123163.314. filed Jun. 2'3. 2008. Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123153.395. filed Jun. 2'3. zoos. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123195.959. filed Aug. 21. 2008. Maninez.
`Appl. No. 123234.000. filed Sep. 19. 2008. Maninez.
`Appl. No. 123241.590. filed Sep. 30. 2008. Alltsani.
`Appl. No. 123241.682. filed Sep. 30. 2008. Davis.
`.Appl. No. 123206.122. filed Sep. 8. 21.108. Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123223.29]. filed Nov. 18. 2008. Nair.
`. Appl. No. 123223.345. filed Nov. 18. 2008. Nair.
`.Appl. No. 123241.198. filed Sep. 30. 2008. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123223.259. filed Nov. 11. 2008. Martinez.
`.Appl. No. 123339.355. filed Dec. 19. 2008, Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123329.038. filed Dec. 5. 2008. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123326.553. filed Dec. 2. 2008. Churchill.
`. Appl. No. 123242.656. filed Sep. 30. 2008. Burgener.
`.Appl. No. 123223.321. filed Nov. 18. 2008. Nair.
`.Appl. No. 123352.311. filed Jan. 21. 2009. Higgins.
`.Appl. No. 123352.332. filed Jan. 1. 2009. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123352.345. filed Jan. 1. 2009. Higgins.
`Appl. No. 123352.285. filed Jan. 21. 2009. Higgins.
`
`
`
` aaeoaeoaaaoumanagemeoanomamauaammamrent-(:3-rev-retreat-rdrrrrfir-rr—qv—e—g—fii—Hi—r-r
`
`

`

`US 9,507,778 32
`Page 6
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`International Search Report (PC'l'.-'C820097055503) dated Apr. 8.
`2010.: 3 pages.
`Written Opinion (PCTiUSZOOfi-"Ogfimfl dated .Iun. 29. 2009; 4
`pages.
`Written Opinion (P(‘T.-’U82008-"086948) dated May 21. 2009: 5
`pages.
`International Search Report and Written Opinion (PC'I'IUS2009J'
`051247) dated Jan. 25. 2010; 9 pages.
`International Search Report and Written Opinion (PCTJ'US2009J'
`046258) dated Dec. 23. 2009; 7 pages.
`Alrnicda. RB. et al.
`"A Community-Aware Search Engine.“
`WWW20U4. New York. NY. May 17-22. 2004. pp. 413-421.
`Anonymous. (Jul. 16. 2006). MyFantasyLeague Fantasy Football
`League Management—Features. located at éhttp:.-".tweb.archive.orgj
`webi'200607l60729007M.myfanlasyleague.com-"featureshlm >.
`last visited on Feb. [0. 2009. four pages.
`Anonymous. (Jul. 17. 2006). "Fantasy Football Lineup Analyzer-
`‘l‘ips for Who to Start & Who to Bench each Week." located at
`http:siweb.archive.org;'web.-"2 00607 17 t 633 S29i‘www.
`tantasytootbal|starters.com-"lineupAnalyzer.jsp>.
`last visited on
`Feb. 10. 2009. one page.
`Bharat. K.
`(Date Unknown). “SearchPad: Explicit Capture of
`Search Contest to Suppon Web Search." located at <http:i'.-"wrw9.
`orgfw9cdrom-“173 t'173.html >. last visited Aug. 1. 2007. 13 pages.
`Budzik.
`.I. et al. (2000). "User Interactions with Everyday Appli—
`cations as Context for Just-in—Time Information Access.“ Proceed-
`ings of the 2000 Conference on Intelligent User Interfaces. eight
`pages.
`(2001). “Placing Search in Context: The
`Finkelstein. L. et al.
`Concept Revisited.” WW.-"O.
`I-long Kong. May 2-5. 2001. pp.
`406414.
`.1. el al. (2004). “Further Experiments on Collaborative
`Freyne.
`Ranking in Community-Based Web Search.“ Artificial Intelligence
`Review. pp. 1-23.
`Lieberman. H. (1995) "Letizia: An Agent that Assins Web Brows-
`ing." Proceedings of the Fourteenth International Joint Conference
`on Artificial Intelligence. Aug. 20-25. 1995. six pages.
`Mitra. M. et al. (1998). “Improving Automatic Query Expansion."
`Proceedings of the AMC SIGIR. nine pages.
`Rhodes. BJ. el al. (1996). “Remembrance Agent: A Continuously
`Running Automated Information Retrieval System." Proceedings of
`the First International Conference on the Practical Application of
`Intelligent Agents and Multi Agent ‘l'echnolog' (PAAM). pp. 487-
`495. located at <http:i'i‘wwwcc.gatechedu.’fac.-'Tl1ad.Starner«"pf032_
`40__agents&ubicompi'remembrance-agent .
`. .>. last visited Aug. 1.
`2007. six pages.
`Sansbury. C. (Sep. 13. 2005). “Yahoo! Widget for BBC Sports
`News Scotland." 32.
`located at <http:.'.-"widgets.yahoo.coml’gal-
`leryi’view.php?widget—37220 >.
`last visited on Feb. 7. 2007. one
`page.
`Yahoo! Inc. (Dec. 7. 2005). “Yahoo! Widget Engine 3.0 Reference
`Manual Version 3.0." 300 pages.
`U.S. Appl. No. 127407.690. filed Mar. 19. 2009; 50 pages.
`US. Appl. No. 127407.68]. filed Mar. 19. 2009; 56 pages.
`International Search Report I’CT-'I.IS2008.-"088228 dated Sep. 30.
`2009‘ --2 pages.
`Written Opinion PC’I‘.-'US2008:'088228 dated Sep. 30. 2009 -5
`pages.
`U.S. Appl. No. 117562.973. filed Nov. 22. 2006, Martinez.
`11.8. Appl. No. II.-"562.974. filed Nov. 22. 2006. Maninez.
`U.S. Appl. No. 117562.976. filed Nov. 22. 2006. Martinez.
`U.S. Appl. No. 117593.869. filed Nov. 6. 2006. Naaman.
`1.1.3. Appl. No. 127237.709. filed Sep. 25. 200B. Martinez.
`U.S. Appl. No. 11.-"3S3.657. filed I‘eb. 13. 2006. Namnan.
`U.S. Appl. No. 113562.979. filed Nov. 22, 2006, Martinez.
`U.S. Appl. No. 127273.317. filed Nov. 18. 2008. Rahul Nair.
`U.S. Appl. No. 117593.668. filed Nov. 6. 2006. Naaman.
`
`Allen James F.. “Maintaining Knowledge About Temporal Inter-
`vals“. Corrununications of the ACM. Nov. 1983. vol. 26. No. 11 pp.
`832-843; 12 pages.
`Press Release. “QUALCOMM Conducts First Live Demonstration
`of Fl. Technology on a Wireless Handset". Qualcomm Inc.. San
`Diego. Sep. 27. 2005‘. 3 pages.
`Medialilo. I‘LO Technology Overview. Qualcornm Inc. Copyright
`2007: 24 pages.
`Notification ot‘Transmitta] of the International Search Repon and
`the Written Opinion of the International Search Authority. or
`Declaration (PC'TIU82007r"084797) dated Mar. 2 l. 2008; l 1 pages.
`International Search Report (PC'II-US20073084807) dated May 27.
`2008; 3 pages.
`International Preliminary Report on Palenlahility (N.‘T.-'US.2007-"
`084807) dated May 26. 2009; 5 pages.
`International Search Report (PC'fr'US20107026063) dated May 27.
`2008; 3 pages.
`Rekimoto. et al.. “CyberCode: designing augmented reality envi-
`ronlnents with visual tags.“ Proceedings of DARE 2000 on Design-
`ing augmented reality environments. Elsinore. Demnark. pp.
`[-11
`Apr. 12-14. 2000.
`computing”.
`ubiquitous
`“Sernaeode-URI. Bareodes—practieal
`located at httpL-“fsernacoduorg visited on Apr. 13. 2007:. 3 pages.
`“'I'cchnical White Paper: Choosing the best 21) barcodc format for
`mobile apps." Semacodc. Jul. 15. 2006; pp. [-7 located at httpn"!
`semacode.org-'abouL-“teehnica]i'whitepaperi'best2__d_code.pdt'.
`Carbonell.
`J. et al.
`(Aug. 24-28. 1998). ”the Use of MMR.
`Diversity-Based Reranking for Reordering Documents and Produc-
`ing Summaries.“ SIGIR ‘98: Proceedings of die 2] S Annual
`International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Develop-
`ment in Information Retrieval: Metboume. Australia WB. Croft et
`al. eds.. pp. 335-336.
`Cooper. M. ct al. (Nov. 2-8. 2003). “Temporal Event Clustering for
`Digital Photo Collections." MM‘03 Berkeley. California. pp. 364-
`373.
`to Content:
`Davis. M. et al. (Oct. 10-l6. 2004). “From Context
`Leveraging Context lo Infer Media Metadala.” MM’04 New York.
`New York. 9 pages.
`Davis. M. ct :11. “From Contest to Content: Leveraging Context for
`Mobile Media Metadata.“ 9 pages.
`Davis. M. et at. (Apr. 2-7. 2005). “MMM2: Mobile Media Metadata
`for Media Sharing." (TI-II 2005 Portland. Oregon. 4 pages.
`Davis. M. et at. “Mobile Media Metadata for Mobile Imaging." Jun.
`27-30. 2004. 4 pages.
`Davis. M. et al. “Using Context and Similarity for Face and
`Location Identification.“ 10 pages.
`l-‘lickr. Welcome to Iilickr- Photo Sharing. located at <http:-'.-'www
`flickr.com > visited on Feb. 26. 2007. one page.
`Gargi. U. (Aug. 7. 2003). “Consumer Media Capture: Time-Based
`Analysis and Event Clustering." Technical Report HPI..—2003-|65
`HP Laboratories Palo Alto. pp.
`l-IS.
`Goldberger. J. et al. The Hungarian Clustering Method. located at
`<http:.-"r'sch olar.googlescoms'scholar‘? nurn=20&h [Ten&lr-—
`&9=eache:vbWslsm1CisJ :ww.openu
`.aci l-'“Personal _Sites-"
`tarnirtassa."Publicationsi'hcm.
`pdf+goldberger+clustering+mcthod+hungarian> visited on Mar. 1.
`2007. twelve pages.
`Graham. A. et al. (Jul. 13-17. 2002). Time as Essence for Photo
`Browsing Through Personal Digital Libraries. JCDI. ‘02 Portland.
`Oregon. 11 pages.
`Jalfe. A. et al. (May 23-26. 2006). “Generating Summaries for Large
`Collections of Geo—Referenced Photographs.” WW’ 2006 Edin-
`burgh. Scotland. 2 pages.
`Jalfc. A. et al. (Oct. 26-27. 2006). "Generating Summaries and
`Visualization for Large CoIIections ot' Geo-Referenced Photo-
`graphs." MIR '06 Santa Barbara. California. 1] pages.
`Joshi. D. et al. (Oct. 15-16. 2004). “The Story Picturing Engine:
`Finding Elite Images to Illustrate a Story Using MiituaI Reinforce-
`ment." MIR '04 New York. New York. 9 pages.
`Naarnan. M. et al. (Nov. 2003). “From Where to What: Metadala
`Sharing for Digital Photographs with Geographic Coordinates." In
`on the Move to Meaningful Internet Systems 2003: Coop-"S. DOA.
`and ODBASL’. R. Meersrnan ct al. eds.. pp. 196-217.
`
`Snap Inc. Ex. 1013 Page 0006
`Snap Inc. EX. 1013 Page 0006
`
`

`

`US 9,507,778 32
`Page 7
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Naarnan. M. et al. (Jun. 7-11. 2004). “Automatic Organization for
`Digital Photographs with Geographic Coordinates” Proceedings of
`the Fourth ACM."IF.F.F. Joint Conference on Digital libraries Global
`Reach and Diverse Impact: Tucson. Arizona. pp. 53-62.
`Nair. R. et al. (Nov. 6-l l. 2005). “Photo L0l: Browsing Multi-User
`Photo Collections." MM‘OS Singapore. pp. 223-224.
`0’ Hate. N. et al. "Combination of Content Analysis and Context
`Features for Digital Photograph Retrieval.“ 7 pages.
`Pigeau. A. et at. (Jun.