`
`
`

ÿ
`ÿ ÿÿÿÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ

ÿÿÿÿ
`!ÿ"
`
`-./.ÿ1ÿ23456-
`
`789:;<ÿ:>ÿ?@AAÿBC>DEÿBFGHEÿI>ÿ78E9:>E8
`:JÿK:FCL8ÿM89<N
`
`OPÿQIRRISTÿUNÿ7SVWOSXT YXRZÿ[\]ÿ[^^[
`
`_`8ÿa8HÿZ:;bÿK:FCL8ÿM89G;<c8><dEÿ;8E9:>E8ÿ<:ÿ<`8ÿV89<NÿAAÿG<<GLbÿHGEÿ8JJ8L<Ce8ÿC>
`
`cG>PÿG;8GEÿfg<ÿEgJJ8;8DÿJ;:cÿFG9E8EÿC>ÿF8GD8;E`C9ÿG>DÿL::;DC>G<C:>ÿG>DÿGÿFGLbÿ:J
`
`9;:98;ÿ9FG>>C>hÿG>Dÿ<;GC>C>h]ÿGLL:;DC>hÿ<:ÿGÿD;GJ<ÿ;89:;<ÿfPÿG>ÿC>D898>D8><
`
`L:>EgF<G><ÿJ:;ÿ<`8ÿD89G;<c8><N
`
`_`8ÿJ;G>bÿGEE8EEc8><ÿfPÿ<`8ÿL:>EgF<G><]ÿTLUC>E8Pÿiÿj:c9G>P]ÿEGCDÿ<`G<ÿcG>P
`
`:JJCL8;EÿDCDÿ>:<ÿb>:HÿH`:ÿHGEÿC>ÿL`G;h8ÿ:;ÿH`:cÿ<`8PÿE`:gFDÿ;89:;<ÿ<:ÿGJ<8;ÿ<`8
`
`G<<GLbNÿI<ÿGFE:ÿEGCDÿ<`G<ÿE:c8ÿ:JJCL8;EÿC>ÿ<`8ÿJC8FDÿGL<8DÿHC<`:g<ÿDC;8L<C:>ÿJ;:cÿJC8FD
`
`L:ccG>D8;EN
`
`_`8ÿ;89:;<ÿGFE:ÿJ:g>Dÿ<`G<ÿf8J:;8ÿV89<NÿAA]ÿ<`8ÿD89G;<c8><dEÿDCEGE<8;ÿ9FG>EÿC>
`
`FG;h8ÿc8GEg;8ÿJGCF8Dÿ<:ÿ<Gb8ÿC><:ÿGLL:g><ÿGÿ9:EECfF8ÿ<8;;:;CE<ÿG<<GLb]ÿ<`G<ÿ<`8ÿ9:FCL8
`
`98;J:;c8DÿJ8HÿFG;h8kELGF8ÿD;CFFEÿG>DÿECcgFG<C:>E]ÿG>Dÿ<`G<ÿE8>C:;ÿF8GD8;Eÿ;8L8Ce8D
`
`FC<<F8ÿDCEGE<8;k;8E9:>E8ÿ<;GC>C>hN
`
`_`8ÿ;89:;<]ÿ`:H8e8;]ÿCEÿc8GEg;8DÿC>ÿC<EÿJC>DC>hE]ÿ>:<C>hÿ<`G<ÿ>:ÿ:>8ÿL:gFDÿ`Ge8
`
`G><CLC9G<8DÿV89<NÿAAÿG>Dÿ<`G<ÿ<`8ÿD89G;<c8><ÿ98;J:;c8DÿcG>Pÿ<GEbEÿGDcC;GfFPN
`
`Q`CF8ÿF8GD8;E`C9ÿFG9E8E]ÿC>8JJ8L<Ce8ÿ9FG>>C>hÿG>DÿGÿFGLbÿ:JÿL::;DC>G<C:>ÿG<ÿ<`8ÿEL8>8
`
`H8;8ÿGc:>hÿ<`8ÿc:E<ÿE8;C:gEÿJFGHE]ÿ<`8PÿDCDÿ>:<ÿGJJ8L<ÿH`G<ÿcG>PÿL:>ECD8;8Dÿ<:ÿf8
`
`
`
`

# $

"
`"  % % $&
` 
`


`
`
`
`



"'"()*+
`
` ,
`
`Apple Inc. 1022
`U.S. Patent No. 9,445,251
`
`

`

`5/9/2018
`  
`
`Report on 9/11 Finds Flaws In Response ofPolice Dept. - The New York Times
`
`

ÿ
`ÿ ÿÿÿÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ

ÿÿÿÿ
`!ÿ"
`
`the department's primary goal that day: the effective evacuation of the World Trade
`-./ÿ1/234-5/6-78ÿ249534:ÿ;<3=ÿ-.3-ÿ13:>ÿ-./ÿ/??/@-9A/ÿ/A3@B3-9<6ÿ<?ÿ-./ÿC<4=1ÿD431/
`Center, saving thousandsoflives.
`E/6-/4Fÿ83A96;ÿ-.<B83618ÿ<?ÿ=9A/8G
`
`Still, the draft is unblinking in its assessmentof the lapses that day. While
`H-9==Fÿ-./ÿ143?-ÿ98ÿB6I=96J96;ÿ96ÿ9-8ÿ388/885/6-ÿ<?ÿ-./ÿ=328/8ÿ-.3-ÿ13:GÿC.9=/
`providing few details or examples, it concluded that the response suffered from a
`24<A9196;ÿ?/Kÿ1/-39=8ÿ<4ÿ/L352=/8Fÿ9-ÿ@<6@=B1/1ÿ-.3-ÿ-./ÿ4/82<68/ÿ8B??/4/1ÿ?4<5ÿ3
`"perceived lack of a single strong operational leader" and "unclear roles and
`772/4@/9A/1ÿ=3@Jÿ<?ÿ3ÿ896;=/ÿ8-4<6;ÿ<2/43-9<63=ÿ=/31/477ÿ361ÿ77B6@=/34ÿ4<=/8ÿ361
`responsibilities among someseniorleadership."
`4/82<689I9=9-9/8ÿ35<6;ÿ8<5/ÿ8/69<4ÿ=/31/48.92G77
`
`Those conclusionswere basedin part on interviews with more than 100 department
`D.<8/ÿ@<6@=B89<68ÿK/4/ÿI38/1ÿ96ÿ234-ÿ<6ÿ96-/4A9/K8ÿK9-.ÿ5<4/ÿ-.36ÿMNNÿ1/234-5/6-
`commandersandofficers, a survey of 700 moreofficers of varying ranks and a
`@<55361/48ÿ361ÿ<??9@/48Fÿ3ÿ8B4A/:ÿ<?ÿONNÿ5<4/ÿ<??9@/48ÿ<?ÿA34:96;ÿ436J8ÿ361ÿ3
`review of documents, including internal reports and radio transmissions.Inits
`4/A9/Kÿ<?ÿ1<@B5/6-8Fÿ96@=B196;ÿ96-/463=ÿ4/2<4-8ÿ361ÿ4319<ÿ-436859889<68GÿP6ÿ9-8
`survey, the consultants found, for example, that 38 percent of officers who wentto
`8B4A/:Fÿ-./ÿ@<68B=-36-8ÿ?<B61Fÿ?<4ÿ/L352=/Fÿ-.3-ÿQRÿ2/4@/6-ÿ<?ÿ<??9@/48ÿK.<ÿK/6-ÿ-<
`Lower Manhattansaid that they were unsure to whom they should report.
`S<K/4ÿT36.3--36ÿ8391ÿ-.3-ÿ-./:ÿK/4/ÿB68B4/ÿ-<ÿK.<5ÿ-./:ÿ8.<B=1ÿ4/2<4-G
`
`But the 88-page draft, a copy of which was obtained by The New York Times,
`UB-ÿ-./ÿRRV23;/ÿ143?-Fÿ3ÿ@<2:ÿ<?ÿK.9@.ÿK38ÿ<I-396/1ÿI:ÿD./ÿW/KÿX<4JÿD95/8F
`does notsingle out any individualpolice official for praise or criticism. It was based
`1</8ÿ6<-ÿ896;=/ÿ<B-ÿ36:ÿ9619A91B3=ÿ2<=9@/ÿ<??9@93=ÿ?<4ÿ24398/ÿ<4ÿ@49-9@985GÿP-ÿK38ÿI38/1
`on four monthsof research by the consulting firm, which traditionally reviews
`<6ÿ?<B4ÿ5<6-.8ÿ<?ÿ4/8/34@.ÿI:ÿ-./ÿ@<68B=-96;ÿ?945FÿK.9@.ÿ-4319-9<63==:ÿ4/A9/K8
`managementpractices. The companyis performing a similar review for the Fire
`5363;/5/6-ÿ243@-9@/8GÿD./ÿ@<5236:ÿ98ÿ2/4?<4596;ÿ3ÿ8959=34ÿ4/A9/Kÿ?<4ÿ-./ÿY94/
`Department.
`Z/234-5/6-G
`
`Evenasit addressedflaws-- whatit called shortfalls -- the report noted the
`[A/6ÿ38ÿ9-ÿ3114/88/1ÿ?=3K8ÿVVÿK.3-ÿ9-ÿ@3==/1ÿ8.<4-?3==8ÿVVÿ-./ÿ4/2<4-ÿ6<-/1ÿ-./
`heroic performanceof so manyofficers and the department's own sacrifices.
`./4<9@ÿ2/4?<4536@/ÿ<?ÿ8<ÿ536:ÿ<??9@/48ÿ361ÿ-./ÿ1/234-5/6-78ÿ<K6ÿ83@49?9@/8G
`"Twenty-three members of the N.Y.P.D. gave their own lives on that day," the report
`77DK/6-:V-.4//ÿ5/5I/48ÿ<?ÿ-./ÿWGXG\GZGÿ;3A/ÿ-./94ÿ<K6ÿ=9A/8ÿ<6ÿ-.3-ÿ13:F77ÿ-./ÿ4/2<4-
`said. "Nothingin this report is intendedto detract from the courageousactions."
`8391Gÿ77W<-.96;ÿ96ÿ-.98ÿ4/2<4-ÿ98ÿ96-/61/1ÿ-<ÿ1/-43@-ÿ?4<5ÿ-./ÿ@<B43;/<B8ÿ3@-9<68G77
`
`Deputy Commissioner Michael P. O'Looney, the department's chief spokesman,
`Z/2B-:ÿE<559889<6/4ÿT9@.3/=ÿ\Gÿ]7S<<6/:Fÿ-./ÿ1/234-5/6-78ÿ@.9/?ÿ82<J/8536F
`refused to discuss the report, which is expected to be released next week by Mayor
`4/?B8/1ÿ-<ÿ198@B88ÿ-./ÿ4/2<4-FÿK.9@.ÿ98ÿ/L2/@-/1ÿ-<ÿI/ÿ4/=/38/1ÿ6/L-ÿK//JÿI:ÿT3:<4
`Michael R. Bloomberg and Police Commissioner RaymondW.Kelly. Top
`T9@.3/=ÿ^GÿU=<<5I/4;ÿ361ÿ\<=9@/ÿE<559889<6/4ÿ^3:5<61ÿCGÿ_/==:GÿD<2
`departmentofficials and key mayoralaides have already been briefed on the report's
`1/234-5/6-ÿ<??9@93=8ÿ361ÿJ/:ÿ53:<43=ÿ391/8ÿ.3A/ÿ3=4/31:ÿI//6ÿI49/?/1ÿ<6ÿ-./ÿ4/2<4-78
`conclusions.
`@<6@=B89<68G
`
`"The mayoris traveling, and we don't have a comment," said William
`77D./ÿ53:<4ÿ98ÿ-43A/=96;Fÿ361ÿK/ÿ1<67-ÿ.3A/ÿ3ÿ@<55/6-F77ÿ8391ÿC9==935
`Cunningham, Mr. Bloomberg's director of communications.
`EB6696;.35FÿT4GÿU=<<5I/4;78ÿ194/@-<4ÿ<?ÿ@<55B69@3-9<68G
`
`A spokeswoman for former Mayor Rudolph W.Giuliani, Sunny Mindel, also
``ÿ82<J/8K<536ÿ?<4ÿ?<45/4ÿT3:<4ÿ^B1<=2.ÿCGÿa9B=9369FÿHB66:ÿT961/=Fÿ3=8<
`declined commentonhis behalf. "Wecan't respondto a report that we have not seen
`1/@=96/1ÿ@<55/6-ÿ<6ÿ.98ÿI/.3=?Gÿ77C/ÿ@367-ÿ4/82<61ÿ-<ÿ3ÿ4/2<4-ÿ-.3-ÿK/ÿ.3A/ÿ6<-ÿ8//6
`
`https://www.nytimes.com/2002/07/27/nyregion/report-on-9-11 -finds-flaws-in-response-of-police-dept.html?mcubz=0
`
`

# $

"
`"  % % $&
` 
`


`
`
`
`



"'"()*+
`
`2/4
` ,
`
`

`

`5/9/2018
`  
`
`Report on 9/11 Finds Flaws In Response ofPolice Dept. - The New York Times
`
`

ÿ
`ÿ ÿÿÿÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ

ÿÿÿÿ
`!ÿ"
`
`that was leaked to The New York Times,"she said.
`./0.ÿ203ÿ450657ÿ.8ÿ9/5ÿ:52ÿ;8<6ÿ9=>53?@@ÿ3/5ÿ30=7A
`
`Last night, Bernard B. Kerik, who was police commissionerat the timeof the
`B03.ÿC=D/.?ÿE5<C0<7ÿEAÿF5<=6?ÿ2/8ÿ203ÿG84=H5ÿH8>>=33=8C5<ÿ0.ÿ./5ÿ.=>5ÿ8Iÿ./5
`attack and served until the end of Mr. Giuliani's term on Dec. 31, could not be
`0..0H6ÿ0C7ÿ35<J57ÿKC.=4ÿ./5ÿ5C7ÿ8IÿL<AÿM=K4=0C=@3ÿ.5<>ÿ8CÿN5HAÿOP?ÿH8K47ÿC8.ÿQ5
`reached for comment. But oneseniorpolice official who was involved in the response
`<50H/57ÿI8<ÿH8>>5C.AÿEK.ÿ8C5ÿ35C=8<ÿG84=H5ÿ8II=H=04ÿ2/8ÿ203ÿ=CJ84J57ÿ=Cÿ./5ÿ<53G8C35
`played down thecriticism in the report. "Every day police officers are faced with
`G40R57ÿ782Cÿ./5ÿH<=.=H=3>ÿ=Cÿ./5ÿ<5G8<.Aÿ@@SJ5<Rÿ70RÿG84=H5ÿ8II=H5<3ÿ0<5ÿI0H57ÿ2=./
`unimaginable situations, and every day they adapt and survive anddotheir jobs," he
`KC=>0D=C0Q45ÿ3=.K0.=8C3?ÿ0C7ÿ5J5<Rÿ70Rÿ./5Rÿ070G.ÿ0C7ÿ3K<J=J5ÿ0C7ÿ78ÿ./5=<ÿT8Q3?@@ÿ/5
`said. Noting that 25 percentof the officers queried in the report were unsatisfied
`30=7Aÿ:8.=CDÿ./0.ÿUVÿG5<H5C.ÿ8Iÿ./5ÿ8II=H5<3ÿWK5<=57ÿ=Cÿ./5ÿ<5G8<.ÿ25<5ÿKC30.=3I=57
`with their supervision that day, the official said that on most days, more than half of
`2=./ÿ./5=<ÿ3KG5<J=3=8Cÿ./0.ÿ70R?ÿ./5ÿ8II=H=04ÿ30=7ÿ./0.ÿ8Cÿ>83.ÿ70R3?ÿ>8<5ÿ./0Cÿ/04Iÿ8I
`the department's officers would say the samething.
`./5ÿ75G0<.>5C.@3ÿ8II=H5<3ÿ28K47ÿ30Rÿ./5ÿ30>5ÿ./=CDA
`
`Billed as a forward-looking report, the documentis filled with recommendations
`E=4457ÿ03ÿ0ÿI8<20<7X4886=CDÿ<5G8<.?ÿ./5ÿ78HK>5C.ÿ=3ÿI=4457ÿ2=./ÿ<5H8>>5C70.=8C3
`on how the department could improveits responseto a future eventof this scope.
`8Cÿ/82ÿ./5ÿ75G0<.>5C.ÿH8K47ÿ=>G<8J5ÿ=.3ÿ<53G8C35ÿ.8ÿ0ÿIK.K<5ÿ5J5C.ÿ8Iÿ./=3ÿ3H8G5A
`Officers should be directed to staging areas instead of flooding thesceneitself, the
`YII=H5<3ÿ3/8K47ÿQ5ÿ7=<5H.57ÿ.8ÿ3.0D=CDÿ0<503ÿ=C3.507ÿ8IÿI4887=CDÿ./5ÿ3H5C5ÿ=.354I?ÿ./5
`report said. More expansive and frequent emergencydrills should be undertaken to
`<5G8<.ÿ30=7AÿL8<5ÿ5ZG0C3=J5ÿ0C7ÿI<5WK5C.ÿ5>5<D5CHRÿ7<=443ÿ3/8K47ÿQ5ÿKC75<.065Cÿ.8
`prepare for the next major catastrophe andbetter analysis should be performed
`G<5G0<5ÿI8<ÿ./5ÿC5Z.ÿ>0T8<ÿH0.03.<8G/5ÿ0C7ÿQ5..5<ÿ0C04R3=3ÿ3/8K47ÿQ5ÿG5<I8<>57
`afterward.
`0I.5<20<7A
`
`Reserveofficers should be held in check in case of a secondary attack, and the
`[535<J5ÿ8II=H5<3ÿ3/8K47ÿQ5ÿ/547ÿ=CÿH/5H6ÿ=CÿH035ÿ8Iÿ0ÿ35H8C70<Rÿ0..0H6?ÿ0C7ÿ./5
`departmentneedsto have greater coordination with other agencieslike the Fire
`75G0<.>5C.ÿC5573ÿ.8ÿ/0J5ÿD<50.5<ÿH88<7=C0.=8Cÿ2=./ÿ8./5<ÿ0D5CH=53ÿ4=65ÿ./5ÿ\=<5
`Departmentandfederal and state authorities, the report said.
`N5G0<.>5C.ÿ0C7ÿI575<04ÿ0C7ÿ3.0.5ÿ0K./8<=.=53?ÿ./5ÿ<5G8<.ÿ30=7A
`
`Analysts have notedthatfire and police commanders barely spoke that day to
`]C04R3.3ÿ/0J5ÿC8.57ÿ./0.ÿI=<5ÿ0C7ÿG84=H5ÿH8>>0C75<3ÿQ0<54Rÿ3G865ÿ./0.ÿ70Rÿ.8
`share information or coordinate strategy. Manyofthefirefighters who diedin the
`3/0<5ÿ=CI8<>0.=8Cÿ8<ÿH88<7=C0.5ÿ3.<0.5DRAÿL0CRÿ8Iÿ./5ÿI=<5I=D/.5<3ÿ2/8ÿ7=57ÿ=Cÿ./5
`collapse of the second tower were unawarethatthefirst tower had fallen, according
`H8440G35ÿ8Iÿ./5ÿ35H8C7ÿ.825<ÿ25<5ÿKC020<5ÿ./0.ÿ./5ÿI=<3.ÿ.825<ÿ/07ÿI0445C?ÿ0HH8<7=CD
`to interviews."Solving all internal improvementopportunities will not, by itself, be
`.8ÿ=C.5<J=523Aÿ@@^84J=CDÿ044ÿ=C.5<C04ÿ=>G<8J5>5C.ÿ8GG8<.KC=.=53ÿ2=44ÿC8.?ÿQRÿ=.354I?ÿQ5
`enough,"the report said.
`5C8KD/?@@ÿ./5ÿ<5G8<.ÿ30=7A
`
`Despite whatit called the perceived lack of a strong commanderand confusion
`N53G=.5ÿ2/0.ÿ=.ÿH04457ÿ./5ÿG5<H5=J57ÿ40H6ÿ8Iÿ0ÿ3.<8CDÿH8>>0C75<ÿ0C7ÿH8CIK3=8C
`among sometop Officials, the report found overall that the department acted
`0>8CDÿ38>5ÿ.8Gÿ8II=H=043?ÿ./5ÿ<5G8<.ÿI8KC7ÿ8J5<044ÿ./0.ÿ./5ÿ75G0<.>5C.ÿ0H.57
`effectively in 10 of whatit describedas the 16 critical tasks, including the rescue of
`5II5H.=J54Rÿ=CÿP_ÿ8Iÿ2/0.ÿ=.ÿ753H<=Q57ÿ03ÿ./5ÿP`ÿH<=.=H04ÿ.0363?ÿ=CH4K7=CDÿ./5ÿ<53HK5ÿ8I
`civilians, the evacuation of Lower Manhattan,traffic management, and the
`H=J=4=0C3?ÿ./5ÿ5J0HK0.=8Cÿ8IÿB825<ÿL0C/0..0C?ÿ.<0II=Hÿ>0C0D5>5C.?ÿ0C7ÿ./5
`protection of sensitive locations aroundthecity.
`G<8.5H.=8Cÿ8Iÿ35C3=.=J5ÿ48H0.=8C3ÿ0<8KC7ÿ./5ÿH=.RA
`
`It also said the police radio system performed well, although someofficials
`a.ÿ0438ÿ30=7ÿ./5ÿG84=H5ÿ<07=8ÿ3R3.5>ÿG5<I8<>57ÿ2544?ÿ04./8KD/ÿ38>5ÿ8II=H=043
`relied too heavily on cellphones, which the attack knockedout.
`<54=57ÿ.88ÿ/50J=4Rÿ8CÿH544G/8C53?ÿ2/=H/ÿ./5ÿ0..0H6ÿ6C8H657ÿ8K.A
`
`https://www.nytimes.com/2002/07/27/nyregion/report-on-9-11 -finds-flaws-in-response-of-police-dept.html?mcubz=0
`
`

# $

"
`"  % % $&
` 
`


`
`
`
`



"'"()*+
`
`3/4
`, -
`
`

`

`5/9/2018
`  
`
`Report on 9/11 Finds Flaws In Response ofPolice Dept. - The New York Times
`
`

ÿ
`ÿ ÿÿÿÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ
`ÿ

ÿÿÿÿ
`!ÿ"
`
`At the sametimeit found whatit termed shortfalls in the search for and rescue
`-.ÿ.01ÿ2341ÿ.541ÿ5.ÿ6789:ÿ;03.ÿ5.ÿ.1<41:ÿ207<.63==2ÿ59ÿ.01ÿ213<>0ÿ67<ÿ39:ÿ<12>81
`of survivorsafter the collapse, assessing the potential risks of hazardous materials at
`76ÿ28<?5?7<2ÿ36.1<ÿ.01ÿ>7==3@21Aÿ32212259Bÿ.01ÿ@7.19.53=ÿ<52C2ÿ76ÿ03D3<:782ÿ43.1<53=2ÿ3.
`the trade centersite and possible secondary attacks, policing the disaster scene, and,
`.01ÿ.<3:1ÿ>19.1<ÿ25.1ÿ39:ÿ@7225E=1ÿ21>79:3<Fÿ3..3>C2Aÿ@7=5>59Bÿ.01ÿ:5232.1<ÿ2>191Aÿ39:A
`perhaps mostsignificantly, assessing and preventing furtherterrorist threats to the
`@1<03@2ÿ472.ÿ25B9565>39.=FAÿ32212259Bÿ39:ÿ@<1?19.59Bÿ68<.01<ÿ.1<<7<52.ÿ.0<13.2ÿ.7ÿ.01
`city.
`>5.FG
`
`Thereport also foundthat field commanders underused the department's
`H01ÿ<1@7<.ÿ3=27ÿ6789:ÿ.03.ÿ651=:ÿ>74439:1<2ÿ89:1<821:ÿ.01ÿ:1@3<.419.I2
`commandcenterat 1 Police Plaza and could not sufficiently deploy officers.
`>74439:ÿ>19.1<ÿ3.ÿJÿK7=5>1ÿK=3D3ÿ39:ÿ>78=:ÿ97.ÿ28665>519.=Fÿ:1@=7Fÿ7665>1<2G
`
`While the report said the department performed the pre-collapse rescue and
`L05=1ÿ.01ÿ<1@7<.ÿ235:ÿ.01ÿ:1@3<.419.ÿ@1<67<41:ÿ.01ÿ@<1M>7==3@21ÿ<12>81ÿ39:
`evacuationeffectively, it said the post-collapse search for survivors "proved
`1?3>83.579ÿ1661>.5?1=FAÿ5.ÿ235:ÿ.01ÿ@72.M>7==3@21ÿ213<>0ÿ67<ÿ28<?5?7<2ÿII@<7?1:
`extremely risky given the lack of equipment, training and supervision" among the
`1N.<141=Fÿ<52CFÿB5?19ÿ.01ÿ=3>Cÿ76ÿ1O85@419.Aÿ.<35959Bÿ39:ÿ28@1<?52579IIÿ3479Bÿ.01
`responders. It also foundthatintelligence efforts were not well coordinated. There
`<12@79:1<2GÿP.ÿ3=27ÿ6789:ÿ.03.ÿ59.1==5B19>1ÿ1667<.2ÿ;1<1ÿ97.ÿ;1==ÿ>77<:593.1:GÿH01<1
`was "no central pointfor collation and systemic analysis of information regarding
`;32ÿII97ÿ>19.<3=ÿ@759.ÿ67<ÿ>7==3.579ÿ39:ÿ2F2.145>ÿ393=F252ÿ76ÿ5967<43.579ÿ<1B3<:59B
`the incident, with leaders acting largely on personal observations."
`.01ÿ59>5:19.Aÿ;5.0ÿ=13:1<2ÿ3>.59Bÿ=3<B1=Fÿ79ÿ@1<2793=ÿ7E21<?3.5792GII
`
`The secondhalf of the report chronicles the perceptionsofthe officers
`H01ÿ21>79:ÿ03=6ÿ76ÿ.01ÿ<1@7<.ÿ>0<795>=12ÿ.01ÿ@1<>1@.5792ÿ76ÿ.01ÿ7665>1<2
`interviewed or surveyed about how the department responded or should improve.
`59.1<?51;1:ÿ7<ÿ28<?1F1:ÿ3E78.ÿ07;ÿ.01ÿ:1@3<.419.ÿ<12@79:1:ÿ7<ÿ2078=:ÿ54@<7?1G
`Nearly half, for example, said they would like better rescue and evacuationtraining.
`Q13<=Fÿ03=6Aÿ67<ÿ1N34@=1Aÿ235:ÿ.01Fÿ;78=:ÿ=5C1ÿE1..1<ÿ<12>81ÿ39:ÿ1?3>83.579ÿ.<35959BG
`Only 20 percentsaid they felt confident that the department had developed adequate
`R9=FÿSTÿ@1<>19.ÿ235:ÿ.01Fÿ61=.ÿ>7965:19.ÿ.03.ÿ.01ÿ:1@3<.419.ÿ03:ÿ:1?1=7@1:ÿ3:1O83.1
`plans to respond to emergencies. Therest of those polled said they either lacked such
`@=392ÿ.7ÿ<12@79:ÿ.7ÿ141<B19>512GÿH01ÿ<12.ÿ76ÿ.0721ÿ@7==1:ÿ235:ÿ.01Fÿ15.01<ÿ=3>C1:ÿ28>0
`confidenceor did not have an opinion.
`>7965:19>1ÿ7<ÿ:5:ÿ97.ÿ03?1ÿ39ÿ7@59579G
`
`© 2018 The New York Times Company
`Uÿ ÿÿÿ
`!ÿ"ÿV
`" $
`
`https://www.nytimes.com/2002/07/27/nyregion/report-on-9-11 -finds-flaws-in-response-of-police-dept.html?mcubz=0
`
`

# $

"
`"  % % $&
` 
`


`
`
`
`



"'"()*+
`
`4/4
`, ,
`
`