`Exhibit 4
`
`
`
`
`
`NUVASIVE - EXHIBIT 2029
`Alphatec Holdings Inc. et al. v. NuVasive, Inc.
`IPR2019-00362
`
`
`
`Case 3:08-cv-01512-CAB-MDD Docu ment 407-5 Filed 10/27/11 PageiD.19250 Page 1 of 9
`
`EXHIBIT DTX-5134-R
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137288
`
`
`
`:9'Miiil:""\\;""'"'')1f!~ase 3:08-cv-01512-CAB-MDD Document 407-5 Filed 10/27/11 PageiD.19251 Page 2 of 9
`.
`- '··. ,.-· -~
`. ~ .
`.
`.- ~ _, . . -
`
`:<~1: AcroMed" Corporation
`
`-, .
`
`~ '.~I a
`~
`! • -
`
`I
`
`,.:
`
`~
`. ~ -I
`..
`~. '· ~
`,
`'
`
`;)303 CI\I?NEGIE AVE. CI.EVEIAND, 011110 411 11[1
`
`Request for Individual Custom Device
`(As required by Section 520 (b)
`of t:he Food, Drug & Cosmetic J\ct)
`
`. '
`I have determined thnt n special device will be necessary to
`provide most effective rcelief of a pati-ent condition described
`below. Available sta.nclard production devices are not completely
`suitable for this purpos-e.
`I agree that the custom devic.e will
`be used only by me for use for the patient named below.
`
`Please type or print:
`
`Patient Name:
`~L(-N' A-
`
`Patient Condition:
`ivrh.._ ~ a~
`Lc~ PelF+-~ Lq_-SJ
`~d ~ ~7 ~~ ?\1-
`
`~A<fdk?·f- c~~
`<!n-r t{ lr - r L.
`
`-, ,.
`
`; '• ~. '
`
`'
`'·
`:...,_,•. _
`
`' .
`... ~
`
`.. \
`
`Date
`
`rs rz ·lHJn 6-ltA)
`Print Name ··
`" G_fA
`. Ll 01 ~ n (c/, ~-~ 1-)/vA.'
`''
`7?
`Street Address
`C[(v~!currcf CJtf
`city
`State
`. (-z!~). "Sb~-2"1.:.6~
`TeLephone~umber
`
`Z ~ p
`
`F-!ool(
`
`'c·
`
`rf11\ll=ln~I\ITIAI INFORMATION
`
`DTX-5134-R
`Page 5
`
`DdUWinf'_. Mblblr
`
`DTX-5134
`
`BR0002730
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137289
`
`
`
`' ' !'.,
`
`. ,
`
`.~ :
`
`~~ ·-"'':"""T,''"
`· · "':- ·~
`Case 3:08-cv-01512-CAB-MDD Document 407-5 Filed 10/27/11 PageiD.19252 Page 3 of9 .
`..·.,
`
`. ;.
`
`;/:~. AcroMed" Corporation
`
`.
`,, .. ·
`
`. : 3303 CAI?NEGIE AVE . CLEVELAND. 01110 tl/111.'",
`
`Request for Individual Custom Device
`(As required by Section 520 (b)
`of the F'ood, Drug & Cosmetic Act)
`
`• '
`
`I have determined Ulilt a special device will be necessary to
`provide most effective relief of a patient condition described
`below. Available standnrd production devices are not completely
`suitable for this purpose.
`I agree that the custom device will
`be used only by me for use for the patient named below.
`
`~:.
`
`. : ..
`.
`,.,
`
`-~
`
`··.
`
`Please type or print:
`
`Patient Name:
`./( A-IZ e--AI
`
`Patient Condition:
`
`/{'~ Ld f?LIF~~ VSt-> ef-4 ~~ ~ ~vt. '!!/
`trlcw- L.r tn1e b/lA~ ·_pI
`~h-f.?r?=Ln~;:,_ r
`f/1..-(_
`67« k+ S I s~ c:w<•{ __..;,_ /Z~ A-ntAL~
`cN><A
`~ d,Ld"' r{ ,{ ~~[rr~ ::_
`f"tM= ~ hrlrlzr.ht, ,_~
`S' tvt 1 ... -J
`Description of Custom Device:
`
`~
`
`f'CV'"£u-·
`
`~~f wnh~ ca_1~s dt-:'c~hA ,_;.._ ~ e:w-'
`'II? rn 11'1. L11,.
`kl-t ~ - 14
`3 G tn rn. >c
`)(
`"2_ '1-rnf'h.
`~0 ,,n-. )<' 2'(- m~ ,X 17 fhrY?
`M cdruW"\ - I?-
`h.-,7. t'\
`
`f?t v,(
`
`Print Name · ·
`'&,_?1. n k- (,;,
`Z7 0 Cf
`street Address
`L f ~ v ( ( 0.. 0 cJ 0-lf
`state
`3G3-22~y
`'l'elephone Number
`
`l.f-t{--( IS
`Zip
`
`.....
`
`.·
`
`· l
`
`,, _.,_ ..
`
`r:nNFinFNTIAL INFORMATION
`
`DTX-5134-R
`Page 6
`
`BR0002731
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137290
`
`
`
`~~~Y€ase 3:08:.cv-01512-CAB-MDD Document 407-5 Filed 10/27/11 PageiD.19253 Page 4 of 9 _
`:.'· :,,..._-
`'0.
`.
`: -1-
`··->t(·
`
`'•
`
`t
`
`.'
`
`.
`
`. ' ' .
`
`.... :--
`
`,;';~_; AcroMed· Corporation
`
`•. 3JOJ CARNEGIE AVE. CLEVElAND, 01110 4.111~>
`
`Request for Individual Custom Device
`(As required by Section 520 (b)
`of the Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act)
`
`I have determined tl1~t ~ special device will be necessary to
`provide most effective relief of a patient condition described
`below. Available standard production devices are not completely
`sui table for this purpose.
`I agree that the custom device will
`be used only by me for use for the patient named below.
`
`Please type or print:
`
`Patient Name:
`~t:i VI "'of
`
`. Patient Condition:
`rf•l-1-f{,-e ,n~-lai-dc-h Ll.f-~ 1 • ~5c ----u ~tiLe~ Lr-s 1
`w,~ letr-1-(
`~ri-~CI f~br, IZ-fcc: ltJ!-tt~siJ L4-.J
`la.f--fAA (
`11/.e tf YJ-t ~ s c {-t 4' t1 v ~--1 we-t~ (f- pow e Y
`lrf f-:0., ~j ?rs
`:$ o ~ I b_r _ .
`rz_f~ nu. f+r?Jnj~rl ~ ~~~ ~d 1.-CJ.Jf-.e~ c~-~.-r:rr ~:
`1/tr( Ca.-- ~cZc fo ~:r ·-· ' !
`Description of Custom Device:
`·
`bn::J/c_ ~ ~c v-t-ws
`ca-q~~~-I _______________ _
`4
`C.evt bo//1
`(3 mm
`K L.j- YJ.1fl4.
`
`x:
`
`I
`
`•
`
`..
`
`.
`
`:· -- -,
`
`.
`
`j
`
`·- ·"
`
`__ _ , ·,-:
`
`·
`
`·' '
`··'
`.· : ...
`
`·(
`
`.,
`
`.· . _ _.
`
`. ·'·
`
`_.· ,
`
`Zip
`
`Print Name ·
`. 27oCj ~~ (] (u/,
`Street -Address
`CIt vfl Ca._ n c!. 0 tl-
`('-tc. J. s,;, ")- 22Cq-
`
`state
`
`city
`
`DTX-5134-R
`Page 7
`
`BR0002732
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137291
`
`.· ·• ' ; ':'.'\'
`. -~
`t: H·( .O:. : ··
`·' ·
`·>· ·j;
`' 1
`
`~
`
`~
`
`. 1
`
`. . .
`
`;
`
`•
`
`rnJ\ll=lnr=J\ITIAI 11\IFORMATION
`
`
`
`Case 3:08-cv-01512-CAB-MDD Document 407-5 Filed 10/27/11 PageiD.19254 Page 5 of 9
`
`,~[ AcroMecr Corporation
`
`3303 CAI'?NEGIE AVE . CI.EVEI.AND. 01110 t1t111 ~1
`
`Request for Individual Custom Device
`(As required by Section 520 (b)
`of the Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act)
`
`I have determined thilt i1 special device will be necessary to
`provide most effective relief of a pntient condition described
`below. Available stilndurd production devices are not completely
`suitable for this purpose.
`I agree that the custom device will
`be used only by me for use for the patient named below.
`
`·Please type or print:
`
`, Patient Name:
`
`j_ ,
`
`.·
`
`:.
`'
`; ·-
`
`· >
`
`Patient Condition:
`2 - Levl~L ~u..-ra-4-~ Lc. L~~ ~-4~1. t.--n~f-
`c.,___ .-v--p~ -17~ a....k.:_...,L_J
`c- ~"u • .f.,;._ .
`L
`IV.<.
`lA:;-n__ ~ ~~~ ~J!fi1 n.~ 2-~£ Pu-r
`
`~
`
`Description of custom Device:
`. ~ f cw..I-A.A..0... c~ Le--uh..f .A--:,_ ~ a-,__ ~
`'I< rr vJ1Vh ~L-t
`L~ -I\
`2-~ m r11
`4-7- rnm X
`
`.. ·. ·.
`
`:
`
`'
`
`, • ,'.
`
`I
`
`· .. ·,.-';
`·:1<_· ··.
`
`·-
`
`. .. .. ~ • .. -, . . '
`
`·. ' · . ·>
`
`CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
`
`Print Name ·
`Z7 oq ~a11 klr~ fS1vvf'
`street Address
`C L 8/-t ((VJ,.,cJ
`
`state
`
`Zip
`
`Telephone Number
`
`)
`
`DTX-5134-R
`Page 8
`
`BR0002733
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137292
`
`
`
`~ ..;.::."''~~'~;,"'Case 3:os.::cv-01512-CAB-MDD Document 407-5 Filed 10/27/11 PageiD.19255 Page 6 of 9
`'."'""·'·::::· ~ .
`
`• "
`
`. ·
`
`.
`
`'- - · -, ·-·~ -: ·
`
`. t.
`
`• ..
`' j o, •
`
`; ... .
`
`r:~~ .AcroMed· Corporation
`
`3303 C/\RNEGIE AVE. CLEVELAND. 01110 lll111~i
`
`Request for Individual custom Device
`(As required by Section 520 (b)
`of the Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act)
`
`I have determined that a special device will be necessary to
`provide most effective relief of a patient condition described
`below. Available standard production devices are not completely
`suitable for this purpose.
`I agree that the custom device will
`be used only by me for use for the patient named below.
`
`Please type or print:
`
`· · · Patient Name:
`
`T2 A-ND'-/
`
`Patient Condition:
`V C P 4, 'i 1 c-;._ L ~ - S J _
`~A-t LCD
`
`f-1-z,_£
`
`In r 1-uv-f.-" 4~£ .
`
`. -·,
`
`. ~- :• . .
`
`Description of custom Device:
`
`4- c4"' Ctt-~
`
`lsm...a...
`
`x- lsn...~ K Z\ ~~
`
`j ·
`
`Date
`
`Print Name '
`
`Street Address
`(_ LEVEltrN0) Oft
`state
`
`city
`
`Zip
`
`Telephone Number
`
`DTX-5134-R
`Page 9
`
`BR0002734
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137293
`
`. :.' · .
`
`'
`
`... . ,. :
`. i i .
`.... · . .
`' h '
`. ··~.~
`·"-·:·.::,· ...
`: :·;~:~,< · ..
`·· .. .
`": · •. ~~- -
`.'·· '
`... ).'-:· .::~ : .: '.
`'
`
`.. •
`
`. ' .. ··.:··: .•
`-
`
`. . . 1·,, . . .
`
`rnt~.ll=lnl=t\ITIAI INF()RMATION
`
`
`
`• .e-~:~"""-- t~~e 3:08-cv-01512-CAB-MDD Document 407-5 Filed 10/27/11 PageiD.19256 PagY~t-ftfJ
`
`Pesign of anterior cages. lumbar and cervical: • John W .. Brantigan, M.D.
`June 20, 1990
`
`Morphometric studies of lumbar vertebrae (Berry, J.L., Moran, J.M,, ' Berg,
`W.S .• Steffee, A.D. Spine 12:362-367, 1987) indicate that at LS, the ratio
`of A- P width to M- L width of vertebrae averages 0. 66. This ratio increases
`as follows:
`
`--Ls -
`IA
`L3
`L2
`Ll
`-Tl2
`
`'.66
`.68
`.68
`.69
`.71
`.-73
`
`I feel that the ratio of dimension of the cages should duplicate the known
`average dimensions of lumbar vertebrae. _For simplicity, the different sizes
`should maintain about the same ratio.
`-
`
`In the cervical area, -the M-L width is relatively greater~ with ratio closer
`to 0. 60, though I have not found published data reflecting this difference.
`Maintaining the anatomic ratio seems prudent.
`
`: <·
`
`. \_
`
`_ Anterior lumbar cages;
`
`--
`
`' D - 3.0 mm
`E - 4.0 mm
`F- 2.0 mm
`G-0.75mm .
`H - 4.0 mm
`
`-
`
`·
`
`.,·
`
`~axt fl
`Large-15
`
`Large-13
`
`Medium-14
`
`Medium-12
`
`Small-14
`
`Sma1l-12
`
`Sma11-10
`
`A
`
`B
`
`.
`
`'• .
`
`42 mm
`
`42 mm
`
`36 mm
`
`36 mm
`
`33 mm
`
`33 mm
`
`33 mm
`
`28 mm
`
`28 mm
`
`24 mm
`
`24 mm
`
`22 mm
`
`22 mm
`
`22 mm
`
`~
`
`15 mm
`
`14 mm
`
`14 mm
`
`12 mm
`
`14 mm
`
`12 mm
`
`10 mm
`
`CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
`
`. ·.
`
`DTX-5134-R
`Page 10
`
`BR0002735
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137294
`
`
`
`. l
`
`Case 3 : 08- cv-01512~AB - MDD
`A
`.
`. 1+-A./n:lZJOfL 4-6e:-r
`
`·-r4"-i
`; -•-1
`-H-+
`4~· ·-
`-~F:
`··l
`'
`l
`I
`'
`-~ -
`l
`~ ~
`
`I
`
`'
`
`'
`
`r- · ;
`
`·- -· _..
`
`.:-! · '
`
`.. '
`
`. 1
`
`.
`
`~
`
`. . . ~ -
`
`.. , .. J._ ;
`
`i .
`I
`
`.:-,
`
`! ··
`
`•..
`
`I
`
`. -
`
`.l .. ,JJ I l tr
`s~
`
`CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
`
`A
`
`·; -- ~ - :' . .
`
`, - -~-- ·' .- ·-.
`
`,,.
`
`•< .
`
`··l ·
`· c J
`
`;
`.. i
`
`'·---!---· ,.._ ... _.,_,
`;
`. '
`
`;
`
`Page 11
`
`BR0002736
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137295
`
`
`
`. ;
`. ; ,
`~~ r,_J
`-~-~-' · ··
`
`.
`
`f
`
`'J . . ·
`::.h
`
`r
`t
`c
`
`I
`
`~ ..
`
`' ~ri.L
`VttW
`
`'--- :
`
`. ;.
`
`{.
`
`I ! ...
`
`· ... '.~ --~-
`
`.{ __
`
`·-.;
`
`..
`
`. i.
`
`. .I ..
`
`----l
`
`····- -.J.
`
`. _ __ , __ : ..
`
`.•.:
`
`·!
`
`·;
`
`t· '·
`
`•. _; ,
`
`; .;.
`
`- :
`
`l
`
`I
`
`.t
`
`. ,·,
`
`-_;
`
`... ;
`
`:}
`
`. ~ -
`
`.;
`
`.. !
`
`- f
`
`I
`
`• . J
`
`_,.:E~·:' r
`
`;--j·~,
`
`~: ri~Ak·
`
`..
`
`.··
`
`·'
`
`'1
`
`,,_._ .i •. - ~-- .• . ' ..
`
`· -·--· - i ;.,_
`· _,
`
`... . ;
`
`.. . : .
`
`I •.· I 1
`
`·
`
`,_,
`
`.
`
`.;,.
`
`: . ~ -
`
`-
`
`; .
`
`. i ~· ·
`
`, .,
`
`~ . . . . . · '
`
`; . .
`
`· . .. : .
`
`. ..•
`
`·: .
`L--
`
`'
`1'>-<-W ~ : ..wt~~-r
`. ' J. - ~ ;
`
`l . - :
`
`... . -~
`
`.
`
`.....
`
`. ·.·.!
`
`..
`
`,·
`
`•.: . -.... :
`
`__ ,_ .. . ; ·· ·-- · .. ;;. · b···-
`
`·--1
`
`.;-
`
`CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
`
`DTX-5134-R .
`Page 12
`
`. . ~ .... : i ...,.·.-- ..
`
`. ~-
`
`. -;
`
`. : .-_ , ,
`
`· !
`
`· ..
`
`.. ;_. : :-
`:·!
`·-J
`
`'
`
`I
`
`. ! · · '
`-- -~ _;
`
`.. ·. ~ ': .
`
`BR0002737
`
`A TEC _LLI FOOO 137296
`
`