THE JOURNAL OF THE PATTERN RECOGNITION SOCIETY
`
`SPECIAL ISSUE: IMAGE DATABASES
`GUEST EDITORS: JOHN C. M. LEE and ANIL JAIN
`
`PATTERN
`RECOGNITION
`
`Page 1 of 5 i
`
`PERGAMON
`
`AVIGILON EX. 201
`IPR2019-00236
`
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`IPR2019-00236
`Page 1 of 5
`
`

`

`
`
`
`adesSa
`
`uiPerald
`
`eda
`ad
`
`a
`
`va
`
`
`
`M, AHMADI, Canada
`GRAZIA ALBANUESL, Italy
`AKRAM ALDROUBI, U\S.A,
`YIANNIS ALOIMONOS, U.S.A
`1, ANDREADIS, Greece
`MASAYOSHLI AOKI, Japan
`ROBERT H. ASENDORF, U.S.A
`NIKOS ASIMOPOULOS, U.S.A
`HENRY5S. BAIRD, U.S.A
`RICHARD A. BALDOCK, UK
`HENRYM., BEISNER, U.S.A
`R, BERGEVIN, Canada
`I ROSS BEVERIDGE, U.S.A
`BIR BHANU, U.S.A
`PRABIR BHATTACHARYA,
`USA.
`ZHAOQI BIAN, China
`CAROLYN M. BIORKLUND,
`USA,
`RUUD M. BOLLE. USA
`N, BOURBAKIS, U.S.A
`ALAN C. BOVIK, U.S.A.
`ERNESTO BRIBIESCA, Mexico
`ALFRED BRUCKSTEIN,
`Israel
`J. BRYANT. U.S.A
`MICHAEL BUAS, US.A
`FERRY CAELLI, Australia
`VIRGINIO CANTONI, Luly
`B,
`B, CHAUDHURLE, India
`HOMER H. CHEN. U.S.A
`SU-SHING CHEN, U.S.A
`H. D. CHENG, USA
`RAJ S, CHHIKARA, U.S.A
`LUIGI CINQUE,
`Italy
`RICHARD W. CONNERS, U.S.A
`KNUT CONRADSEN, Denmark
`CHRISTIAN EH, DEBRUNNER,
`USA
`Italy
`ALBERTO DEL BIMBO,
`EDWARD J. DELP, U.S.A
`MITA LD. DESAL USA
`MICHEL DHOME, France
`STANLEY DUNN, USA
`MASAKAZU EJIRI, Japan
`KURT ENSLEIN. U.S.A,
`
`Managing Editor: BLAIRE V. MOSSMAN
`P.O. Box 13177, Scottsdale, AZ 85267-3177
`
`Associate Editors
`JIA-GUU LEU, U.S.A
`MARTIN A. FISCHLER, USA
`PATRICK J. FLYNN, U.S.A
`S. LEVIALDE,
`Italy
`C.CLLI, USA
`HERBERT FREEMAN, U.S.A
`JOYDEEP GHOSH, U.S.A
`XIAOBO LI, Canada
`PING LIANG, U.S.A
`MARK L. GILLENSON, U.S.A
`MICHAEL LINDENBAUM.
`LEV GOLDFARB, Canada
`Isracl
`D. B GOLDGOF, U.S.A
`GUY LORETTE, France
`YIFAN GONG, U-S.A
`NIKOLAI GORSRKY, Russia
`HONG-QIAN LU, U.S.A
`YI LU, U.S.A
`ARDESHIR GOSHTASBY,
`MICHAEL MAGEE. U.S.A
`USA
`ABHIJIT MAHALANOBIS
`JAMES GRAHAM, UK
`USA
`ERIK GRANUM., Denmark
`HENRI MAITRE, France
`WILLIAM Z. GROSKY, USA
`JOHN W. MARTIN, USA
`LALIT GUPTA, U.S.A
`PETER MEER, U.S.A
`ADOLFO GUZMAN, U.S.A
`R. MEHROTRA.U.S.A
`EDWIN RL HANCOCK, U.K
`ROBERTA, MELTER, U.S.A
`ANDREW J. TIANSON, U.S.A
`ROGER MOHR, France
`Jo
`P. HATON, France
`RICHARD MOORE, USA
`THOMAS C, HENDERSON
`USA
`JEAN-VINCENT MOREAU,
`France
`WILLIAM A. HOFF, ULS.A,
`RADU HORAUD, France
`SHIGEO MORISHIMA, Japan
`RANDY MOSS, U.S.A
`JAMES H, HOWARD, JR, U.S.A
`JONATHAN J. HULL. U.S.A
`YASUAKI NAKANO.Japan
`N. NANDHAKUMAR, U.S.A
`ATSUSHI IMIYA, Japan
`LAWRENCE O°GORMAN.,
`HORACE H,
`S,
`IP, Hong Kong
`US.A
`ANIL KL JAIN, USA
`PATRICK L, ODELL. U.S.A
`RAMESII JAIN, USA
`R.
`§.
`JOHANNES, US.A
`HIDEMITSU OGAWA, Japan
`STELIOS C. ORPHANOUDARKIS.,
`MOSHE KAM. U.S.A
`
`Greece
`RANGACHAR KASTURI
`USA
`MASAKI OSHIMA, Japan
`DAVID W. PAGLIERONI. U.S.A
`E, KAWAGUCHI. Japan
`Y.-H, PAO, U.S.A
`KLARA KEDEM,
`Israel
`CHAN M, PARK, Korea
`H.R. KESHAVAN, U.S.A
`M. PAWLAK, Canada
`A, KHOTANZAD, U.S.A
`YUN PENG, USA
`TADAHIRO KITAFLASHIE, Japan
`MICHAEL A, PENNA, USA
`JOVORITTLER. UR
`JEROME K. PERCUS, ULS.A.
`JACK KOPLOWITZ, U.S.A
`JIM PIPER. U.S.A
`WALTER G. KROPATSCH,
`REJEAN PLAMONDON. Canada
`Auslila
`PING-CHUEN PONG,
`ADAM KRZYZAK, Canada
`JAMES S.
`J. LEE, U.S.A
`Hong Kong
`N, RANGANATHAN, U.S.A
`REINER LENZ, Sweden
`
`
`A. RAVISHANKAR RAQ),
`USA
`S. RAUDYS. Lithuania
`T. REED. U.S.A
`CELSO RIBEIRO, Brazil
`MICHAEL ROBINSON, U.S.A
`A. ROSENFELD, U.S.A
`FRANK H, RUDDLE, U.S.A
`HANAN SAMET, U.S.A
`J, SCHUERMANN, Germany
`SHOKRI Z. SELIM, Saudi Arabia
`ISHWAR K, SETHL, U.S.A
`MUBARAK SHAH, U.S.A
`LINDA G. SHAPIRO, U.S.A
`THOMAS SHERMER, U.S.A
`FRANK Y. SHIH. U.S.A
`YOSHIAKI SHIRAL, Japan
`M. SHRIDHAR, U.S.A
`JACK SKLANSKY, U.S.A
`MICHAEL SPANN. U.K
`SARGUR N. SRIHARI, U.S.A
`M. D, SRINATH, U.S.A
`LOUISE STARK, U.S.A.
`GEORGE STOCKMAN. U.S.A
`CHING Y. SUEN, Canada
`KOKICHI SUGIHARA, Japan
`SHINICHE TAMURA, Japan
`STEVEN L. TANIMOTO, US.A
`TORFINN TAXT. Norway
`MOHAN M, TRIVEDI, U.S.A
`LEONARD UHR, USA,
`JULIAN R. ULLMANN, U.K
`SCOTT UMBAUGH, U.S.A
`MICHAEL UNSER, U.S.A
`JOHN W, VAN NESS, U.S.A
`ANDREW M. WALLACE,
`U.K
`HARRYWECHSLER.U.S.A
`MICHAEL WERMAN, Israel
`ROLAND WILSON. U.K
`YEE-HONG YANG, Canada
`N, YOKOYA, Japan
`DEAN M. YOUNG, U.S.A
`MARSHALL YOVITS, U.S.A
`SOTIRIOS G, ZIAVRAS, USA
`
`Production Editor: ELLIOTT M. NOBLE
`Elsevier Science Lid, The Boulevard,
`Langford Lane. Kidlington, Oxford OXS IGB. UK
`Published Monthly. Copvright © 1997 Pattern Recognition Socicts
`
`Subscription Rates
`Annual Institutional Subscripbon Rates 1997; Europe. The CIS andJapan 2350.00 Dutch Guilders, All other countries USS1451,00, Associated Personal Subseriplion
`rales are available on request
`for
`those whose institutions arelibrary subscribers. Members of the Pattern Recagnilinn Society will receive the journal free of charge
`ais part of
`their membership to the Suctety, Dutch Guilder prices exclude VAT, Non-VAT registered customers in the European Community will be charged the
`appropriate VATin addition to the price listed. Prices inghide postage and insurance and are subject to change without nelice
`For orders, claims, product enquisies (no manuscript enyutries) please contact the Customer Support Department al the Regional Sales Ollice nearest lo you
`Any enquiry relating © subscriptions should be sent lo: The Americas: Elsevier Science Customer Support Department, P.O, Box 948, New York, NY 10010, USA
`[Tels (4
`1) 212-633-3730/1-888 4ES-INFO. Fax: (4 1) 212-633-3080. E-mail: usinfo-fe clseviercom), Japan: Elsevier Scienee Customer Suppert Depariment, 9-15
`Higashi-Azabu |-chome, Minato-ku. Tokyo 106. Japan (Tek: (+ 3) 5561-50330 Pas: (7 3) S561-3047. E-mail: kyfb4035\o nifty serve or gp]
`Asia Pacilic (excluding Japan): Elsevier Science (Singapore) Pte Lid, Now | Temasek Avenue, 17-01 Millenia Tower, Singapore 039192, (Tel: (+ 65) 434-3727. Fax: (+ 65)
`337-2230, E-mail: asiainfole elsevier.comsg} Rest of the World: Elsevier Science Customer Service Departinent. P.O, Box 211,
`1001 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
`[Tel: (4 31) 20-485-3757. Fas: (1 31) 20-485-3432) E-mail: nlinfo-be elsevier.nl]
`Back Issues. Back issues ofall previously published volumes.
`in both hard copy and on microform, are available direet from Elsevier Science offices (Oxford and New
`York}. Complete volumes angsingle issues can be purchased for 1990-1995, Earlier issues are available in high quality photo-duplicated copies as complete volumes only
`Back volumes on microfilm are available from UME, 300 North Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor, MT 48106, USA
`PERIODICALS POSTAGE PAID AT RAHWAY, NEWJERSEY. PatterRecognition ASSN 0031-3203) is published monthly, January to December, by Elsevier
`Science Ltd, The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OXS 1GB, UK. The annual subscription in the U.S.A,
`is $1451.00, Pattern Recognition is distributed by
`Mercury Aifieight International Ltd, 10 Camptown Road, Evington, New Jersey 07 FE 1-1105 POSTMASTER: please send address corrections to Paticrn Recognition,
`co Elsevier $
`
`ience Regional Sales Olive, Customer Support Department, 655 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10010, U.S.A (Tel: (= 1) 212-633-3731) 1 888
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`4ES-INFO) Fax: (+ 1) 212-633-3680. E-mail: usinfo-f/v/elsevier com]
`IPR2019-00236
`
`
`
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`IPR2019-00236
`Page 2 of 5
`
`

`

`
`
`
`estt4Y U)
`3 1997
`
`|
`MITA D
`Universityof Texas
`|
`
`San Antonitor BX. OP yd
`MICHEL D
`{¢;
`Universite Blaise Pasca
`
`
`Aujbiere, France
`STANLEY DUNN
`Rutgers University
`
`Piscataway, NJ
`
`MASAKAZU EJI
`Hitachi Central R¢search Laboratory
`Tokyo, Japan
`
`KURT ENSLED!
`
`
`Health Designs
`Rochester, NY
`MARTINA. FISCHLER
`SRI Internationpl
`Menlo Park, C \
`PATRICKJ. FLYNN
`Washington State University
`Pullman, WA
`HERBERT FREEMAN
`Rutgers University
`New Brunswick, NJ
`JOYDEEP GHOSH
`The University of Texas
`Austin, TX
`MARKL. GILLENSON
`University of Miami
`Coral Gables, FL
`LEV GOLDFARB
`University of New Brunswick
`Fredericton, N.B., Canada
`D. B. GOLDGOF
`University of South Florida
`Tampa, FL
`YIFAN GONG
`Texas Instruments
`Dallas, TX
`NIKOLAI GORSKY
`AcademyofSciences of Russia
`St. Petersburg, Russia
`ARDESHIR GOSHTASBY
`Wright State University
`Dayton, OH
`JAMES GRAHAM
`University of Manchester
`Manchester, U.K.
`ERIK GRANUM
`Aalborg University
`Aalborg, Denmark
`WILLIAM J. GROSKY
`Wayne State University
`Detroit, MI
`LALIT GUPTA
`Southern Illinois University
`Carbondale, IL
`
`S p
`
`Aany
`
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`
`IPR2019-00236
`
`M. AHMADI
`University of Windsor
`Windsor, Ontario, Canada
`G. ALBANESI
`University of Pavia
`Pavia, Italy
`AKRAM ALDROUBI
`National Institute of Health
`Bethesda, MD
`YIANNIS ALOIMONOS
`University of Maryland
`College Park, MD
`I. ANDREADIS
`Democritus University of Thrace
`Xanthi, Greece
`MASAYOSHI AOKI
`Seikei University
`Tokyo, Japan
`ROBERT H. ASENDORF
`Los Altos Hills, CA
`NIKOS ASIMOPOULOS
`Blacksburg, VA
`HENRYS. BAIRD
`AT&T Bell Laboratories
`Murray Hill, NJ
`RICHARD A. BALDOCK
`Western General Hospital
`Edinburgh, U.K.
`HENRYM. BEISNER
`IBM Corporation
`Gaithersburg, MD
`R. BERGEVIN
`Universite Laval
`Ste-Foy, PQ, Canada
`J. ROSS BEVERIDGE
`Colorado State University
`Fort Collins, CO
`BIR BHANU
`University of California
`Riverside, CA
`PRABIR BHATTACHARYA
`University of Nebraska
`Lincoln, NE
`
`ZHAOQI BIAN
`Tsinghua University
`Beijing, China
`CAROLYNM. BJORKLUND
`Lockheed Palo Alto Research Laboratory
`Palo Alto, CA
`RUUD M. BOLLE
`IBM
`Yorktown Heights, NY
`N. BOURBAKIS
`Binghamton University
`Binghamton, NY
`
`a
`
`ASSOCIATE EDITORS
`
`ALANC. BOVIK
`University of Texas
`Austin, TX
`ERNESTO BRIBIESCA
`Col. Avante
`Mexico D.F.
`
`ALFRED BRUCKSTEIN
`Technion—lsrael Inst. of Technology
`Haifa, Israel
`J. BRYANT
`Texas A & M University
`College Station, TX
`MICHAEL BUAS
`Federal Communications Commission
`Washington, DC
`TERRY CAELLI
`Curtin University of Technology
`Perth, WA, Australia
`VIRGINIO CANTONI
`Universita degli Studi di Pavia
`Pavia, Italy
`B. B. CHAUDHURI
`Indian Statistical Institute
`Calcutta, India
`HOMER H. CHEN
`AT&T Bell Laboratories
`Holmdel, NJ
`SU-SHING CHEN
`University of North Carolina
`Charlotte, NC
`H. D. CHENG
`Utah State University
`Logan, UT
`RAJ S. CHHIKARA
`University of Houston
`Houston, TX
`
`LUIGI CINQUE
`Universita degli Studi La Sapienza
`Rome,Italy
`RICHARD W. CONNERS
`Virginia Polytechnic Inst. & SU
`Blacksburg, VA
`KNUT CONRADSEN
`Technical University of Denmark
`Lyngby, Denmark
`CHRISTIAN H. DEBRUNNER
`Martin Marietta
`Denver, CO
`ALBERTO DEL BIMBO
`Universita di Firenze
`Firenze, Italy
`EDWARDJ. DELP
`Purdue University
`West Lafayette, IN
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`0031-3203(1997)30:4;1-X
`
`Arabia
`
`A.
`WA
`
`pan
`an
`U.S.A
`
`S.A
`
`AL
`ael
`
`da
`
`3A.
`JS.A
`
`cription
`f charge
`rged the
`
`,USA
`nt, 9-15
`
`x: (+65)
`lerlands.
`
`ind New
`res only
`
`Elsevier
`buled by
`ognition,
`30/1 888
`
`
`
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`IPR2019-00236
`Page 3 of 5
`
`

`

`Pattern Recognition is the official journal of the Pattern Recognition Society. The Society was formedto fill a
`need for information exchange among research workers in the pattern recognition field. Up to now, we
`“pattern-recognitionophiles” have been tagging along in computerscience, information theory, optical processing
`techniques, and other miscellaneousfields. Because this work in pattern recognition presently appears in widely
`spread articles and as isolated lectures in conferences in many diverse areas, the purpose of the journal Pattern
`Recognition ts to give all of us an opportunity to get together in one place to publish our work. The journal will
`thereby expedite communication among researchscientists interested in pattern recognition.
`Weconsider pattern recognition in the broad sense, and we assume that the journal will be read by people
`with a commoninterest in pattern recognition but from many diverse backgrounds. These include high
`energy physics, target recognition, biological taxonomy, meteorology, space science, oceanography, character
`recognition, optical instrumentation, industrial applications, neuron physiology, and many others.
`The publication policy is to publish (1) new original articles that have been appropriately reyiewed by
`competent scientific people, (2) reviews of developmentsin the field, and (3) pedagogical papers covering specific
`areas of interest in pattern recognition. Various special issues will be organized from time to time on current
`topics of interest to Pattern Recognition.
`
`
`
`© 1997 Pattern Recognition Society
`is a condition of publication that manuscripts submitted to this journal have not been published and will not be
`It
`simultaneously submitted or published elsewhere. By submitting a manuscript, the authors agree that the copyright for their
`article is transferred to the Pattern Recognition Society if and whenthe article is accepted for publication. However, assignment
`of copyright is not required from authors who work for organizations which do not permit such assignment. The copyright
`covers the exclusive rights to reproduce and distribute the article, including reprints, photographic reproductions, microform
`or uny other reproductions ofsimilar nature, and translations. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a
`retrieval system or transmitted in any formor by any means, electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying,
`recording or otherwise, without permission in writing from the copyright holder.
`U.S. Copyright Law Applicable to Users in the U.S.A.
`Photocopying Information for Users in the U.S.A, The Item-Fee Code for this publication indicates that authorization to
`photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by the copyright holder for libraries and other users registered with
`the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service provided the stated fee for copying, beyond that
`permitted by Section 107 or 108 of the United States Copyright Law,
`is paid. The appropriate remittance of $17.00 per copy
`per article is paid directly to the Copyright Clearance Center Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, U.S.A.
`Permission for other use. The copyright owner’s consent does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion,
`for creating new works, orfor resale. Specific written permission must be obtained from the publisher for such copying
`Disclaimer, Whilst every effort is made by the publishers and editorial board to see that no inaccurate or misleading data,
`opinion or statement appear in this journal, they wish to make it clear that the data and opinions appearing in the articles
`and advertisements herein are the sole responsibility of the contributor or advertiser concerned. Accordingly, the publishers, the
`editorial board and editors and their respective employees, officers and agents accept no responsibility or liability whatsoever
`for the consequences of any such inaccurate or misleading data, opinion or statement.
`The Hem-Fee Code for this publication is: 0031-3203/97 $17.00 + .00
`O™The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information
`Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984.
`
`
`
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`IPR2019-00236
`
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`IPR2019-00236
`Page 4 of 5
`
`

`

`J.C. M. Lee and A. Jain
`
`537
`
`Editorial
`
`S. Gutta and H. Wechsler
`
`N. W. Campbell,
`W. P. J. Mackeown,
`B. T. Thomas and T. Troscianko
`
`T. P. Minka and R. W. Picard
`
`N. V. Patel and I. K. Sethi
`
`M. V. Srinivasan, S. Venkatesh
`and R. Hosie
`
`J. D. Courtney
`
`S. Sclaroff
`
`J. Zhang, J. Wu, D. Zhong
`and S. W. Smoliar
`
`539
`
`555
`
`565
`
`583
`
`593
`
`607
`
`627
`
`643
`
`Face recognition using hybrid classifiers
`
`Interpreting image databases by region classification
`
`Interactive learning with a “society of models”
`
`Video shot deflection and characterization for video
`databases
`
`Qualitative estimation of camera motion parameters
`from video sequences
`
`Automatic video indexing via object motion analysis
`
`Deformable prototypes for encoding shape categories in
`image databases
`
`An integrated system for content-based video retrieval
`and browsing
`
`
`
`AVIGILONEX. 2011
`
`IPR2019-00236
`
`AVIGILON EX. 2011
`IPR2019-00236
`Page 5 of 5
`
`