`
`




`
`
`  !"##$%&'()%(
` *+#,-./%&'0%1

1
` ,2-%&'31%

)


`
` 
`
`!4"!!456$7
`
`
`"$.".%

3."
` #.%,##8#..#

 00
` + !"##9"+
`
`
`6$$4&,&  
`
`
`
` &-4&!44! &
`
`
`
`44!
`4.."
`
`:
`
`6! 

!!
`4.. ;"
`
`
`
`4&

) (3
`
`<=>?@A@BCDEFDGF>H@A?=IF<JFKELBIDEMFNHJ<JF
`LJIJFN@B=EBFEDJFOMPOQMRSSF
`>?@CTIFUVWUF
`F
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```_
`
`

`

` 8.#".
`6$4..3%03%11%+#


`
`
`B@g?=FDGF>DEB=EBIF
`
` i& 6j6! $h
`
` h
`
`h ,&!$&2k(h
`
`h &!2!i!$&$h
`
`2h 2&2k -l114h
`
`h $8++" .':.h
`
`
`
`h 4"# "" $m.".
`h
`
`h 4"#8.-#." 0h
`
`2h !, $&6 (h
`
`h n#.o3h
`
`2h $6,,&p  4 $3h
`
`h i"8 +#

"8..#':8#
`:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%|s}~t{{h
`
`h :":;qrsth
`
`
`
`

h +#%%

":8#:;qrst%
`uvwxyyz{%|s}~t{{)h
`
`
`
`
`h +#



":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{0h
`
`0h +#
`
`":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{0

h
`
`(h +#00":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{0
`h
`
`3h +#((":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{03h
`
`
`
`h +#33":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{0)h
`
`1h +#":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{(h
`
`
`
`
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```€
`
`

`

`
`
`)h +#11":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{(

h
`
`h +#))":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{(
`h
`
`h +#

":8#:;qrst%uvwxyyz{%
`|s}~t{{((h
`
`
`
`h i"8 +#

"8..#':8#
`:;z‚ƒts%qrst%|s}~t{{(3h
`
`h :":;4./(h
`
`
`
`

h +#%%

":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{()h
`
`
`
`
`h +#



":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{1h
`
`0h +#
`
`":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{)h
`
`(h +#00":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{1h
`
`3h +#((":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{1
`h
`
`
`
`h +#33":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{1(h
`
`1h +#":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{1h
`
`)h +#11":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{11h
`
`h +#))":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{1)h
`
`h +#

":8#:;z‚ƒts%qrst%
`|s}~t{{)h
`
`2h 2!!p && $$ „, )h
`
`2h&i- $644!,)h
`
`„h *6&)

h
`
`
`
`
`
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```…
`
`

`

`  
`
`%"# 8.#%4%"#;# FF
`
`g@>K‡ADLE<F@E<FˆL@?CGC>@BCDEIF
`
` CJ†
`
`‰ , +#"# 8.#":+ ."4# 
`
`547'".+8."$"+ "'$..6:"#. 
`
`))1":+ ,#."#$5,$7"$5$7
`
`'"#+8."$"+"'+p8'6:"#. 
`
`
`
`

‰ :''.#.;":+.8#." #)13
`
`'"'%+'+.%"#"%#."8.#.#
`
`
`
`
`‰ 8"'+ 8"'"8.8.."'+p8'6:"#. 
`
`.;)1()118#".'# #.+#%'.+ + +.
`
`#:+.'".-;.. 4m".;, )11"8" 
`
`)1)8"'...+:; :# #.+#.;"".-42."
`
`
`
`"#+8."
`
`0‰ ;#+ #:+.'"%.#.'"%
`
`+'".:%.;,")1)$.+"))08"'..
`
`.+%+:" +";..." "..++8.
`
`# #.+## #.+#.;"
`
`(‰ ;#8"+$.#8.'":#% "'%
`
`.;$.+"))0 ."))3#8.';"m".#
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```Š
`
` 
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`including Intel and Novell. My consulting work for Novell included creating
`8'.:, #8.';"m":8".'
`
`functional and test specifications for the installation of certain Novell software
`8..#.#.#".#..".:#.;"
`
`products in the context of a Novell NetWarelocal area network.
`
`"8.#..‹.:.k"".;"m
`
`6.
`I was Vice President of Research and Development for Counterpoint
`3‰ ;#24"#.&#":+."8.".
`
`Systems Foundry,Inc. (acquired in 1997 by Extended Systems,Inc., later spun off,
`$ #.+#8" %5Œ8")) ‹.$ #.+#%%."#8%
`
`and currently operating as OpenSynergy,Inc.) from September 1996 to September
`8"". ".'# $ "' %7"+$.+"))3.$.+"
`
`1999. My development group created the infrared beaming capability that 3Com
`))), :+.'"8"..""+'. ..
`+
`
`Corporation employed in their PalmOS handheld devices. My development group
`"".+ ."4+ $:#, :+.'"8
`
`also created infrared and Bluetooth development platforms that have become de
`#".""8..:+.."+#..:+
`
`facto standards in the embedded/handheld device market worldwide.
`.#."#.+:+"m.;";
`
`7.
`I was Chair of the Test and Interoperability Committee of the Infrared
`
`‰ ;#".#.."". ++...""
`
`Data Association (IrDA) from February 1998 to October 1999, and served as a
`.##.5"7"+"8" ))1. .")))%#":#
`
`member of the IrDA Architecture Council from February 1998 to April 2008.
`I
`++".""..8"8"+"8" ))1."

1
`
`was also a member of the Infrared Object Exchange (IrOBEX) Working Group
`;##++"."" Ž.‹'5" „7k"m'i"8
`
`from January 2002 to December 2005, helping to define standards for data object
`"+*8" 



.+"

(%'.#."#".Ž.
`
`exchange in IrDA and Bluetooth.
`‹'"8..
`
`8.
`I created and presented short courses on embedded systems, data
`1‰ "."#.#".8"##+# #.+#%.
`
`communications, software quality, and software engineering at the Embedded
`++8.#%#.;"Œ8. %#.;"'"'..+
`
`APPLE
`dccfX
`EXHIBIT 1006 - PAGE 0005
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```
`
`

`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`Systems Conference, Portable by Design Conference, Wind River Developers
`$ #.+#"%4". #'"%k&:":"#
`
`Conference, and other industry venues over a nine-year period from 1997 to 2005.
`"%."8#." :8#:" """+)).

(
`
`9.
`Since July 1987, I have taught college-level courses on computer
`)‰ $*8 )1%:.8'.' :8"##+8."
`
`organization
`and
`assembly
`language
`programming,
`operating
`systems,
`"'/.  ##+  '8' "'"++'% ".' # #.+#%
`
`programming languages, databases, data communications, systems performance
`
`"'"++''8'#%.##%.++8.#%# #.+#""+
`
`analysis, software quality, and software engineering.
` ##%#.;"Œ8. %#.;"'"'
`
`10.
`I have authored or co-authored two books on networking and data
`‰ :8."" 8.".;m#.;"m'.
`
`communications,
`57
`academic
`papers
`(21
`of which
`involved
`data
`++8.#% ( + "# 5

  ; :: .
`
`communications), six standards documents for the Infrared Data Association, and
`++8.#7%#‹#."#8+.#"."".##.%
`
`43 trade journal and magazine publications (including articles on network
`0
`."Ž8"+'/8.#58'".#.;"m
`
`administration, network productinstallation, and data communications).
`+#.".%.;"m"8.#..%.++8.#7
`
`11.
`I have
`served in leadership positions,
`including Organizing
`‰ :#":"##.#%8' "'/'
`
`Committee, Technical Program Committee, Panel Moderator, Session Chair,
`++..%4"'"+++..%4,"."%$##"%
`
`Tutorial Instructor, and Reviewer, at academic conferences focused on data
`8."#."8."%&:;"%.+"#8#.
`
`communications and software quality.
`These conferences include the ACM
`++8.##.;"Œ8. #"#8.,
`
`SIGMOBILEInternational Conference on Mobile Computing and Networking,the
`$i, !.".",+8.'.;"m'%.
`
`ACM Symposium on Mobile Ad Hoc Networking & Computing,
`the IEEE
`,$ +#8+,-.;"m'+8.'%.
`
`GLOBECOM General Symposium,
`the IEEE International Conference on
`i!  ,i"$ +#8+%.."."
`
`Computer Communications and Networks,
`the IEEE Symposium on Ad Hoc
`+8."++8.#.;"m#%.$ +#8+-
`
`APPLE
`dccfX
`EXHIBIT 1006 - PAGE 0006
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```a
`
`
`
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`Wireless Networks, the IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference Symposium on
`k"##.;"m#%.28"' "$ +#8+
`
`Integrated Heterogeneous Wireless Networks, the IEEE Wireless Communications
`.'".-."'8#k"##.;"m#%.k"##++8.#
`
`and Networking Conference,
`the International Conference on Evaluation and
`.;"m'"%..".":8.
`
`Assessment in Software Engineering, the International Symposium on Empirical
`####+.$.;"'"'%..".$ +#8++"
`
`Software Engineering and Measurement, and the International Conference on
`$.;"'"',#8"+.%.."."
`
`Open Source Systems.
` $8"$ #.+#
`
`12.
`I have served as a reviewer for academic journals focused on data
`

‰ :#":#":;""+Ž8"#8#.
`
`communications
`and mobile
`computing including TEEE Transactions on
`++8.#++8.'8'"#.#
`
`Information Technology in Biomedicine and IEEE Transactions on Wireless
`"+.' +"#.#k"##
`
`Communications.
`I have also served as a reviewer for academic journals focused
`++8.#:##":#":;""+Ž8"#8#
`
`on software engineering, including IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering
`#.;"'"'%8'"#.#$.;"'"'
`
`and Methodology,
`IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering, Empirical
`,.' %"#.#$.;"'"'%+"
`
`Software Engineering, and Information and Software Technology.
`$.;"'"'%"+.$.;"' 
`
`13.
`I was the founder and Director of the Mobile Computing Laboratory
`
`‰ ;#.8"".".,+8.'!"." 
`
`in the Computer Science Department of Brigham Young University in Provo, Utah
`.+8."$".+."'+p8'6:"#. 4":%6.
`
`from 2000 to
`2008,
`conducting research in short-range wireless
`data
`"+

.

1%8.'"#"#". "';"##.
`
`communications, with emphasis on infrared and Bluetooth data communications.
`++8.#%;.+##""8...++8.#
`
`14. During my tenure as Director of the Brigham Young University
`0‰ 8"'+ .8"#"."."'+p8'6:"#. 
`
`Mobile Computing Laboratory, I advised twelve graduate students (11 Master of
`,+8.'!"." %:#.;:'"8.#.8.#5,#."
`
`APPLE
`dccfX
`EXHIBIT 1006 - PAGE 0007
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```‘
`
` 0
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`$.#.".7;#"#"8#.
`
`++8.#
`
`(‰ ;#.8"".".$j8 !"." .
`
`+8."$".+."'+p8'6:"#. 4":%6."+
`
`

3.

(%8.'"#"+"#.;"'"'
`
`3‰ 8"'+ .8"#"."."'+p8'6:"#. 
`
`$j8 !%:#'"8.#.8.#51,#."$.#
`
`.".7;#"#"8#+"#.;"
`
`'"'
`
`‰ ":."'+p8'6:"#. ' "#";"
`
`


`
`
`1‰ ..#"'+ "##Œ8.#%
`
`‹"%8.#"#.".+ 8""88+:.% ;
`
`#..#‹
`
`CCJ† T@B=AC@?IFA=’C=“=<F
`
`)‰ +..." "'#%8.+ ;"m%
`
`:‹"#.8 ' /'..#..+#"+.
`
`
`
`"#.:"##m.".+#+:.".;
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```”
`
` (
`
`
`
`
`
`..#
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`

‰ :":;6$4..3%03%115.nl11..o7
`
`5„7
`
`

‰ :":;8"#..;'""# 
`
` 6$4..(%(

%0

5nqrsto75„

7•
`
` 4.48.k )
`(0)5nuvwxyyz{o7
`
`5„
`7•
`
` 6$4..3%00)%

`5n|s}~t{{o75„07•
`
`: 6$4..%3

%3(5nz‚ƒtso75„(7
`
`
`
`

‰ :#m.#";.".""##.:
`
`
`
`"'"

##"#8''#.%"+.%..8"#".
`
`.+#.l11..:##m.#".#...".
`
`.""".:"..+.':..l11
`
`
`
`.., #"":.#".
`
`
`
`

`‰ .#.+ m;'%:."#.4.."
`
`4.."l#8##"++..6

8"".#.;.l11
`
`
`
`...#.+ m;'%:."#.6


`
`%..#.+ ".%:..;.6

".
`
`+:."#...%p##"$*:$".#.
`
`+ m;'%#+" :."#..l11...
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^```–
`
` 3
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`‹.. +8.88#".":#.+.#..;:."#.
`
`.4.."%%.4.. ;"%6

%".l11..%+
`
`.;"%":.":"% ."#...;8."
`
`#+ Ž8'+.
`
`

0‰ +'+#..+ "+#8.'".—(("
`
`8""+ .+, +#.#; .'.."#8.#.#
`
`" .""'#".'..: ...
`
`
`
`CCCJ† A=?=’@EBF?=‡@?FIB@E<@A<IF
`
`
`

(‰ +..." ".8"##.#".%:
`
`"+8.".#.#.;.."":.."+'+ #
`
`, 8"#.'.;##;# 
`
`

3‰ 4.."l#8##"++....++ 
`
`n..o+...+#"#.."‹. "". 
`
`#'""".""%...+.##8""'.
`
`""#.+4.."l#8##"++.."+
`
`+...". "#.%."""..‹"## ##.
`
`+..%#'#.++..##" ;#"+##8"
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^``_`
`
` 
`
`
`
`.""".
`
` 
`
`

`

`27.
` Petitioner’s counsel has informed me that a patent claim can be
`
`

‰ 4.."l#8##"++....+
`
`  
`
`considered to have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art at the time
`#".::8#."#"" #m."....+
`
`the application was filed. This means that, even if all of the requirements of a
`..;##+#..%:."Œ8"+.#
`
`claim are not found in a single prior art reference, the claim is not patentable if the
`+".8#'""".""%.+#....
`
`differences between the subject matter in the prior art and the subject matter in the
`"#.;.#8Ž.+.."."""..#8Ž.+..".
`
`claim would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art at the time
`+;8::8#."#"" #m."....+
`
`the application wasfiled.
`..;#
`
`28.
`Petitioner’s counsel has informed methat a determination of whether
`

1‰ 4.."l#8##"++..."+.;."
`
`a claim would have been obvious should be based upon several factors, including,
`+;8::8##8#8#:"."#%8'%
`
`among others:
`+'."# 
`
`e
`the level of ordinary skill in the art at the time the application wasfiled;
`˜‰.:"" #m."....+..;#•
`
`e
`the scope and content of the prior art; and
`˜‰.#...""".•
`
`e what differences, if any, existed between the claimed invention and the
`˜‰;."#% %‹#..;.+:..
`
`priorart.
`
`""".
`
`29.
`Petitioner’s counsel has informed me that a single reference can
`

)‰ 4.."l#8##"++..#'""
`
`render a patent claim obvious if any differences between that reference and the
`""..+:8# "#.;.."".
`
`claims would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill
`in the art.
`+#;8::8#."#"" #m.".
`
`Alternatively, the teachings of two or more references may be combined in the
`.".: %..'#.;"+"""#+ +.
`
`same way as disclosed in the claims, if such a combination would have been
`#+; ###.+#%#8+.;8:
`
`APPLE
`dccfX
`EXHIBIT 1006 - PAGE 0011
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^``__
`
` 1
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`obvious to one having ordinary skill
`in the art.
`In determining whether a
`:8#.:'"" #m.".."+';."
`
`combination based on either a single reference or multiple references would have
`+.#."#'"""+8.""#;8:
`
`been obvious,it is appropriate to consider, among otherfactors:
`:8#%.#""..#"%+'."."# 
`
`e whether the teachings of the prior art references disclose known concepts
`˜‰;."..'#.""".""###m;.#
`
`combined in familiar ways, and when combined, would yield predictable
`++"; #%;+%;8 ".
`
`results;
`"#8.#•
`
`e whether a person of ordinary skill
`in the art could implement a
`˜‰;.""#"" #m.".8++.
`
`predictable variation, and would see the benefit of doing so;
`
`".:".%;8#..'#•
`
`e whether the claimed elements represent one of a limited number of
`˜‰;.".++.#""#.+.8+"
`
`known design choices, and would have a reasonable expectation of
`m;#'#%;8:"#‹..
`
`success by those skilled in the art;
`#8## .##m.".•
`
`e whether a person of ordinary skill would have recognized a reason to
`˜‰;.""#"" #m;8:"'/"#.
`
`combine known elements in the mannerdescribed in the claim;
`+m;+.#.+"#".+•
`
`e whether there is some teaching or suggestion in the prior art to make the
`˜‰;."."##+.'"#8''#.."""..+m.
`
`modification or combination of elements claimed in the patent; and
`+."+.+.#+...•
`
`e whether the innovation applies a known technique that had been used to
`˜‰;.".:.#m;.Œ8..8#.
`
`improve a similar device or method in a similar way.
`+":#+":"+.#+"; 
`
`30.
`_Petitioner’s counsel has informed me that one of ordinary skill in the
`
`‰ 4.."l#8##"++.."" #m.
`
`art has ordinary creativity, and is not an automaton. Petitioner’s counsel has
`".#"" ".:. %#.8.+.4.."l#8##
`
`APPLE
`dccfX
`EXHIBIT 1006 - PAGE 0012
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^``_€
`
` )
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`"++..#"':8###%.#+"....."+
`
`:8###8#'..#'.":"+...'
`
`#"
`
`C’J† D’=A’C=“FDGFBH=F™RSSFN@B=EBF
`
` @
`
`J† Iš››œžFŸ F¡¢£F@¤¤£¥£¦FC§¨£§¡©Ÿ§F
`
`
`‰ l11..".#.."'."'8".
`
`.":l11..%#.".5„7..m;'#..%
`
`
`
`""..#'.%8+".Œ8#‹#."8.':
`
`+.#xª«%
`

05„78."'....%.#‹#.'
`
`.Œ8#.8."."#.;+8."#.;"
`
`
`"";""#8"#
`..##".#..%#"#8..#
`
`#%n‹#.#"+":.Œ8#"+''"'8".
`
`.":#%#8..+.. ."+.#..o
`
`xª«%

( )5„7
`
`
`
`
`

‰ '8"
`.l11..%""8;%8#.".#‹+
`
`# #.+""'8"'.":xª«%
` 1 5„7# #.+
`
`
`
`
`
`xª«% 0 0(5n.Œ8¬.. ¬";"#.;"
`
`."#o7% (

()% 3(

`%

 05„7
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^``_…
`
` 
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`8#"'8".+'"58."7%.;"m58.87%
`
`.":58.'"7xª«%
` 1 %( 0 (05„7
`
`
`™RSSF­œ¡£§¡MFGC‡JF®F¯=°URRU±F¯@§§Ÿ¡œ¡£¦±J
`
`
`
`.":8#8+"#.;""";"+.#
`
`l11..%

() 30%
`



0%3
`
`(5„7"'8".+'"
`
`8##.m;'8".#%;n.²³;#.
`
`#.;"+.#¬"m;.;"m;.'.""".";#
`
`+.oxª«%
`
`) 0

5„7#n#.on #."""#..
`
`dccfX
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^``_Š
`
` 
`
`
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`of information indicative of component compatibility.” Jd., 4:6-8 (EX1001). For
`"+..:+.+.. oxª«%0 3 15„7"
`
`example, the list can be implemented in a graphical form, “as a stored table, set of
`‹+%.#.++.'""+%n##.".%#.
`
`tables, or other type of list in a memory of the reconfiguration manager ..., as a
`.#%".". #.++" ."'8".+'"¬%#
`
`po[r]tion of a program executed by the reconfiguration manager..., or in any other
`²"³."'"+‹8. ."'8".+'"¬%" ."
`
`suitable format.” Id., 3:64-4:2 (EX1001).
`#8."+.oxª«%
` 30 0

5„7
`
`33.
`The ’088 patent provides an example of an electronic device that
`
`
`
`‰ l11..":#‹+.":..
`
`stores “version 1.1 of a software component A, version 2.3 of a software
`#."#n:"##.;"+.%:"#


`#.;"
`
`component B, and version 2.0 of a software component C.”
`ZId., 3:20-25
`+.%:"#

#.;"+.oxª«%
`



(
`
`(EX1001). Using this example,
`the patent describes how the reconfiguration
`5„76#'.#‹+%...#"#;."'8".
`
`manager can receive a request indicating that the device “wants to upgrade ... to
`+'"":"Œ8#..'...:n;.#.8'"¬.
`
`include version 2.0 of software component A.”
`J/d., 4:12-15 (EX1001). The
`8:"#

#.;"+.oxª«%0 

(5„7
`
`request can include a list of components already on the device.
`Jd., 4:15-19
`"Œ8#.8#.+.#" .:xª«%0 ( )
`
`(EX1001).
`5„7
`
`34.
`The reconfiguration manager
`then processes
`the request,
`and
`
`0‰ "'8".+'"."###."Œ8#.%
`
`determines whether the requested upgrade is compatible with other components of
`."+#;."."Œ8#.8'"#+.;.."+.#
`
`the device.
`Id., 4:27-31 (EX1001). Using the above example, the reconfiguration
`.:xª«%0


`5„76#'.:‹+%."'8".
`
`manager determines whether the “requested upgrade, in this case version 2.0 of
`+'"."+#;.".n"Œ8#.8'"%.##:"#


`
`component A, is compatible with other components of [the] device ... i.e., version
`+.%#+.;.."+.#².³:¬%:"#
`
`2.3 of component B and version 2.0 of component C.” Id., 4:28-32 (EX1001).
`


`+.:"#

+.oxª«%0

1
`

5„7
`
`APPLE
`dccfX
`EXHIBIT 1006 - PAGE 0015
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^``_
`
` 
`
`12
`


`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`Depending on the result of this determination,
`the upgrade request
`is either
`'."#8..#."+.%.8'""Œ8#.#."
`
`approved as compatible with the current configuration of the device, or denied as
`":#+.;..8"".'8"..:%"#
`
`incompatible with the current configuration of the device.
`Id., 5:4-29 (EX1001).
`+.;..8"".'8"..:xª«%( 0

)5„7
`
`If compatible, the requested upgrade is delivered from the reconfiguration manager
`+.%."Œ8#.8'"#:""+."'8".+'"
`
`to the device as part of the response. Id., 4:33-37 (EX1001).
`..:#".."##xª«%0
`
`
`5„7
`
`35.
`As the cited prior art demonstrates, at
`the time of the alleged
`
`(‰ #..""".+#.".#%...+.'
`
`invention, the problems associated with upgrade compatibility were well-known,
`:.%."+###.;.8'"+.. ;"; m;%
`
`and multiple solutions to these problems had been developed. As the discussion
`+8.#8.#..#"+#:#.#8##
`
`below demonstrates, the purported invention of the ’088 patent provided nothing
`;+#.".#%.8"".:..l11..":.'
`
`new,and only rehashed knowntechniques for upgrading devices.
`;% "#m;.Œ8#"8'"':#
`
`B.
`Person of Ordinary Skill in the Art
`gJ† N£´Ÿ§FŸ FD¦©§œžFIµ©¤¤F©§F¡¢£F@¡F
`36.
`I have been informed that a person of ordinary skill in the art is a
`
`3‰ :"+.."#"" #m.".#
`
`hypothetical person who is presumed to have knowntherelevantart at the time of
` .."#;#"#8+.:m;.":."....+
`
`the invention.
`.:.
`
`37.
`It is my opinion that a person of ordinary skill in the art (““POSA”) at
`
`
`‰ .#+ .."#"" #m.".5n4 $o7.
`
`the time the ’088 patent wasfiled, is a person who hadat least a Bachelor’s Degree
`..+.l11..;#%#"#;.#."l#'"
`
`in computer science, computer engineering, or a related subject or the equivalent,
`+8."#%+8."'"'%"".#8Ž.".Œ8:.%
`
`and two years of experience working with databases, computer networks, and
`.; "#‹";"m';..##%+8.".;"m#%
`
`APPLE
`dccfX
`EXHIBIT 1006 - PAGE 0016
`XYZ[\[]^_``a^b^cdeX^``_a
`
` 
`
`13
`
`
`
`related technologies.
`"..'#
`
` 
`
`

`

`  
`
`
`1‰ #+ "##‹"%:8"#.'.
`
`.#"#"" #m.":.:#8":#
`
`".+ #8"##:".8"#+ ""8"."%+ #
`
`Œ8#.#.4 $...+...;#
`
`
`)‰  ###.".":8.#:8###"". ##8#
`
`##..;..'"#":.+ 8#."8'. #
`
`"" #m."....+.'.l11..
`
`>J† NŸ´£¶š¡©Ÿ§FH©´¡ŸžF
`
`0‰ 8"#....l11..8#

+#%;##
`
`6$4..