From: Roberto Devoto <devoto@fr.com>
`Sent: Wednesday, October 3, 2018 11:43 AM
`To: Trials <Trials@USPTO.GOV>
`Cc: IPR39843-0042IP1 <IPR39843-0042IP1@fr.com>; IPR39843-0042IP2 <IPR39843-0042IP2@fr.com>; IPR39843-0043IP1 <IPR39843-
`0043IP1@fr.com>; IPR39843-0044IP1 <IPR39843-0044IP1@fr.com>; IPR39843-0045IP1 <IPR39843-0045IP1@fr.com>; IPR39843-0045IP2
`<IPR39843-0045IP2@fr.com>; IPR39843-0046IP1 <IPR39843-0046IP1@fr.com>; IPR39843-0046IP2 <IPR39843-0046IP2@fr.com>; IPR39843-
`0047IP1 <IPR39843-0047IP1@fr.com>; IPR39843-0048IP1 <IPR39843-0048IP1@fr.com>; PTAB Inbound <PTABInbound@fr.com>; Nathan
`Lowenstein <lowenstein@lowensteinweatherwax.com>; Sangeeta G. Shah (sshah@brookskushman.com) (sshah@brookskushman.com)
`<sshah@brookskushman.com>; Karl Renner <renner@fr.com>; Jeremy Monaldo <Monaldo@fr.com>; AXF-PTAB <AXF-PTAB@fr.com>; Craig A.
`Deutsch <deutsch@fr.com>; David Holt <DTH@fr.com>; Nicholas Stephens <nstephens@fr.com>; Kenneth Weatherwax
`<weatherwax@lowensteinweatherwax.com>
`Subject: Re: IPR2018-01106/1108/1113/1114/1120/1122/1124/1125/1126/1127: Request for Board call
`
`Honorable Board:
`
`As a follow-up to our e-mails of September 28th and October 1st (below), we wanted to provide the Board with additional time for
`convening the Board call. We have conferred with opposing counsel, and we are all available for a Board call on October 8th from 1-5pm
`EDT.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Rob Devoto
`
`Counsel for Petitioner
`
`Roberto J. Devoto
`Principal
`Fish & Richardson P.C.
`1000 Main Street, S.W., Suite 1000
`Washington, DC 20024
`devoto@fr.com<mailto:devoto@fr.com>
`M: 703.731.8596
`O: 202.626.6393
`F: 202.783.2331
`________________________________
`From: Roberto Devoto
`Sent: Monday, October 1, 2018 3:31 PM
`To: Trials@uspto.gov
`Cc: IPR39843-0042IP1; IPR39843-0042IP2; IPR39843-0043IP1; IPR39843-0044IP1; IPR39843-0045IP1; IPR39843-0045IP2;
`IPR39843-0046IP1; IPR39843-0046IP2; IPR39843-0047IP1; IPR39843-0048IP1; PTAB Inbound; Nathan Lowenstein; Sangeeta G. Shah
`(sshah@brookskushman.com) (sshah@brookskushman.com); Karl Renner; Jeremy Monaldo; AXF-PTAB; Craig A. Deutsch; David
`Holt; Nicholas Stephens; Kenneth Weatherwax
`Subject: Re: IPR2018-01106/1108/1113/1114/1120/1122/1124/1125/1126/1127: Request for Board call
`
`Honorable Board:
`
`After meeting and conferring with counsel for Patent Owner (SEVEN Networks) on Friday, September 28 and Monday, October 1,
`counsel for Petitioner (Samsung) wishes to address the following topics on the conference call with the Board that we requested in our
`September 28 e-mail (below):
`
`Issues Where The Parties Have Reached Agreements
`
`• Samsung requests seal of Exhibit 3001, which includes confidential communications between the parties that were undertaken regarding
`a case specific discovery dispute to ease the administrative burden of these specific proceedings and with the good faith assumption that
`they would be maintained confidential. The content of Exhibit 3001 are not themselves believed to inform the ultimate legal issues of this
`case. SEVEN Networks does not oppose.
`
`• Samsung requests a 10-page initial brief, to be filed by October 12th, to address RPI/privity issues raised by SEVEN Networks in Patent
`
`

`

`Owner Preliminary Responses (POPRs). SEVEN Networks does not object subject to the Board’s agreement to SEVEN Networks getting
`a reply brief as set forth in the next bullet.
`
`• SEVEN Networks requests a 6-page reply brief, to be filed by October 19th. Samsung does not object and agrees that the reply can
`address the production provided by Samsung to SEVEN on September 13th and any RPI election made by Google on October 5th,
`irrespective of whether Samsung’s brief addresses or does not address these items.
`
`• SEVEN Networks requests to enter production received from Samsung on September 13th into the following proceedings involving
`SEVEN and Google: IPR2018-01047/1048/1049/1050/1051/1052/1094/1095/1101/1102/1103/1104/1115/1116/1117/1118. Samsung
`does not oppose this request, subject to the following conditions, which SEVEN Networks does not oppose: (1) SEVEN Networks agrees
`in advance to share with Samsung IPR counsel any additional privity or RPI production exchanged with Google in the Google IPR
`proceedings, upon receipt of that production, under the same sealing terms it was produced in the Google IPR proceedings, subject to
`Google’s agreement; (2) SEVEN Networks accepts without further modification the joint motion to seal sent by Samsung to SEVEN
`Networks on September 13th with the production; and (3) authorization from the Board and agreement by Google to seal Samsung’s
`production in the Google IPR proceedings under the same terms set forth in the joint motion to seal sent by Samsung to SEVEN
`Networks on September 13th with the production.
`
`Issues Where The Parties Have Not Reached An Agreement
`
`• Samsung requests limited reply briefing to address each of two issues raised by various POPRs filed by SEVEN Networks. Specifically,
`in the POPRs filed in each of IPR2018-01106, IPR2018-01108, IPR2018-01124, and IPR2018-01125, SEVEN Networks advances: (1)
`arguments alleging claim construction obligations of Samsung, and (2) arguments alleging bases for Board application of discretion under
`325(d). Samsung believes that each argument is flawed, either in its legal or factual foundation. SEVEN Networks opposes this request.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`Rob Devoto
`Counsel for Petitioner
`
`Roberto J. Devoto
`Principal
`Fish & Richardson P.C.
`1000 Main Street, S.W., Suite 1000
`Washington, DC 20024
`devoto@fr.com<mailto:devoto@fr.com>
`M: 703.731.8596
`O: 202.626.6393
`F: 202.783.2331
`________________________________
`From: Roberto Devoto
`Sent: Friday, September 28, 2018 6:31 PM
`To: Trials@uspto.gov
`Cc: IPR39843-0042IP1; IPR39843-0042IP2; IPR39843-0043IP1; IPR39843-0044IP1; IPR39843-0045IP1; IPR39843-0045IP2;
`IPR39843-0046IP1; IPR39843-0046IP2; IPR39843-0047IP1; IPR39843-0048IP1; PTAB Inbound; Nathan Lowenstein; Sangeeta G. Shah
`(sshah@brookskushman.com) (sshah@brookskushman.com); Karl Renner; Jeremy Monaldo; AXF-PTAB; Craig A. Deutsch; David
`Holt; Nicholas Stephens; Kenneth Weatherwax
`Subject: IPR2018-01106/1108/1113/1114/1120/1122/1124/1125/1126/1127: Request for Board call
`
`Honorable Board:
`
`In the above-referenced ten cases, Petitioner seeks to have Exhibit 3001 of the Board's orders issued on September 18th sealed. Petitioner
`requests a call with the Board to discuss this request. Patent Owner and Petitioner are in the process of meeting and conferring with an
`expectation to reach resolution between themselves in advance of a call with the Board on Tuesday or Wednesday. Petitioner and Patent
`Owner are available for a call with the Board on October 2, 1-5pm EST and October 3, 330-5pm EST.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Rob Devoto
`Counsel for Petitioner
`
`Roberto J. Devoto
`Principal
`Fish & Richardson P.C.
`1000 Main Street, S.W., Suite 1000
`Washington, DC 20024
`devoto@fr.com<mailto:devoto@fr.com>
`M: 703.731.8596
`O: 202.626.6393
`F: 202.783.2331
`
`****************************************************************************************************************************
`
`

`

`This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged
`information. Any unauthorized use or disclosure is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the
`sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message.
`****************************************************************************************************************************
`
`