Michael Stanwyck
`
`From:
`Sent:
`To:
`Cc:
`
`Subject:
`
`Iturralde, Enrique W. <EIturralde@brownrudnick.com>
`Monday, September 24, 2018 3:26 PM
`Rob Sokohl; Jonathan Tuminaro; Rubino, Vincent J.
`Fabricant, Alfred R.; Lambrianakos, Peter; Ryan Richardson; Dohm Chankong; PTAB
`Account
`RE: Google v. AGIS, IPR2018-01080, -01083, -01084, -01086, -01087, and -01088
`
`Rob,(cid:3)
`
`(cid:3)R
`
`egarding(cid:3)your(cid:3)first(cid:3)request,(cid:3)if(cid:3)Google(cid:3)cannot(cid:3)provide(cid:3)us(cid:3)with(cid:3)the(cid:3)scope(cid:3)of(cid:3)its(cid:3)proposed(cid:3)Petitioner(cid:3)Replies,(cid:3)then(cid:3)we(cid:3)
`cannot(cid:3)give(cid:3)you(cid:3)a(cid:3)definitive(cid:3)position.(cid:3)(cid:3)In(cid:3)your(cid:3)e(cid:882)mail(cid:3)to(cid:3)the(cid:3)Board,(cid:3)you(cid:3)may(cid:3)state(cid:3)the(cid:3)following:(cid:3)"Regarding(cid:3)Google's(cid:3)first(cid:3)
`request,(cid:3)AGIS(cid:3)consents(cid:3)to(cid:3)Google's(cid:3)request(cid:3)to(cid:3)the(cid:3)extent(cid:3)that(cid:3)the(cid:3)proposed(cid:3)replies(cid:3)are(cid:3)substantively(cid:3)identical(cid:3)to(cid:3)
`Petitioner's(cid:3)Replies(cid:3)in(cid:3)IPR2018(cid:882)01079,(cid:3)IPR2018(cid:882)01081,(cid:3)IPR2018(cid:882)01082,(cid:3)and(cid:3)IPR2018(cid:882)01085.(cid:3)(cid:3)AGIS(cid:3)opposes(cid:3)any(cid:3)proposed(cid:3)
`reply(cid:3)that(cid:3)would(cid:3)differ(cid:3)in(cid:3)substance(cid:3)from(cid:3)the(cid:3)Petitioner's(cid:3)Replies(cid:3)as(cid:3)previously(cid:3)filed(cid:3)in(cid:3)IPR2018(cid:882)01079,(cid:3)IPR2018(cid:882)01081,(cid:3)
`IPR2018(cid:882)01082,(cid:3)and(cid:3)IPR2018(cid:882)01085."(cid:3)(cid:3)
`
`(cid:3)Y
`
`our(cid:3)second(cid:3)request(cid:3)amounts(cid:3)to(cid:3)an(cid:3)early(cid:3)motion(cid:3)to(cid:3)submit(cid:3)Supplemental(cid:3)Information(cid:3)which(cid:3)is––by(cid:3)rule––typically(cid:3)
`reserved(cid:3)for(cid:3)post(cid:882)institution(cid:3)practice.(cid:3)(cid:3)The(cid:3)Board(cid:3)has(cid:3)not(cid:3)considered(cid:3)this(cid:3)extraordinary(cid:3)request(cid:3)in(cid:3)any(cid:3)of(cid:3)the(cid:3)Google(cid:882)
`AGIS(cid:3)proceedings.(cid:3)(cid:3)The(cid:3)Board(cid:3)did(cid:3)not(cid:3)authorize(cid:3)(and(cid:3)Google(cid:3)did(cid:3)not(cid:3)request(cid:3)on(cid:3)the(cid:3)previous(cid:3)conference(cid:3)call)(cid:3)the(cid:3)filing(cid:3)of(cid:3)
`supplemental(cid:3)exhibits(cid:3)with(cid:3)Petitioner's(cid:3)Replies.(cid:3)(cid:3)You(cid:3)have(cid:3)not(cid:3)provided(cid:3)any(cid:3)reason(cid:3)or(cid:3)explanation(cid:3)of(cid:3)good(cid:3)cause(cid:3)for(cid:3)the(cid:3)
`Board(cid:3)to(cid:3)change(cid:3)the(cid:3)rules(cid:3)in(cid:3)this(cid:3)particular(cid:3)instance.(cid:3)(cid:3)Thus,(cid:3)we(cid:3)believe(cid:3)that(cid:3)a(cid:3)conference(cid:3)call(cid:3)is(cid:3)necessary,(cid:3)and(cid:3)we(cid:3)await(cid:3)
`your(cid:3)explanation(cid:3)before(cid:3)providing(cid:3)you(cid:3)with(cid:3)our(cid:3)position.
`
`(cid:3)R
`
`egards,
`Enrique(cid:3)(cid:3)(cid:3)(cid:3)(cid:3)
`(cid:3)
`
`From: Rob Sokohl [mailto:RSOKOHL@sternekessler.com]
`Sent: Monday, September 24, 2018 2:16 PM
`To: Iturralde, Enrique W.; Jonathan Tuminaro; Rubino, Vincent J.
`Cc: Fabricant, Alfred R.; Lambrianakos, Peter; Ryan Richardson; Dohm Chankong; PTAB Account
`Subject: RE: Google v. AGIS, IPR2018-01080, -01083, -01084, -01086, -01087, and -01088
`
`External E-mail. Use caution accessing links or attachments.
`
`Counsel,(cid:3)we(cid:3)have(cid:3)not(cid:3)yet(cid:3)decided(cid:3)what(cid:3)we(cid:3)will(cid:3)argue(cid:3)in(cid:3)any(cid:3)future(cid:3)replies.(cid:3)(cid:3)We(cid:3)see(cid:3)no(cid:3)need(cid:3)to(cid:3)have(cid:3)a(cid:3)
`conference(cid:3)call(cid:3)(unless(cid:3)the(cid:3)Board(cid:3)wants(cid:3)one)(cid:3)given(cid:3)the(cid:3)previous(cid:3)discussions(cid:3)with(cid:3)the(cid:3)Board(cid:3)on(cid:3)this(cid:3)issue.(cid:3)(cid:3)We(cid:3)
`will(cid:3)simply(cid:3)inform(cid:3)the(cid:3)Board(cid:3)of(cid:3)our(cid:3)request(cid:3)via(cid:3)email.
`
`ob Sokohl
`Director
`Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox P.L.L.C.
`Email: rsokohl@skgf.com
`Direct: 202.772.8677 Main: 202.371.2600
`
`Administrative Assistant: Maya Bennett
`Direct Dial: 202.772.8843
`
`1
`
`ob
`
`(cid:3)R
`
`(cid:3)(cid:3)R
`
`Google Ex. 1029
`Google v. AGIS
`IPR2018-01083
`
`

`

`(cid:3) F
`
`rom: Iturralde, Enrique W. [mailto:EIturralde@brownrudnick.com]
`Sent: Sunday, September 23, 2018 12:54 PM
`To: Jonathan Tuminaro; Rubino, Vincent J.
`Cc: Fabricant, Alfred R.; Lambrianakos, Peter; Rob Sokohl; Ryan Richardson; Dohm Chankong; PTAB Account
`Subject: Re: Google v. AGIS, IPR2018-01080, -01083, -01084, -01086, -01087, and -01088
`
`Counsel,
`
`In order for us to determine our position, please let us know whether you will include in your proposed
`replies/explanations any additional arguments that were not presented in your first set of Petitioner
`Replies.
`
`Also, do you intend to make both requests without proposing a conference call with the Board?
`
`Thanks,
`Enrique
`
`From: Jonathan Tuminaro <JTUMINAR@sternekessler.com>
`Date: Friday, September 21, 2018 at 12:25 PM
`To: "Rubino, Vincent J." <VRubino@brownrudnick.com>
`Cc: "Fabricant, Alfred R." <AFabricant@brownrudnick.com>, "Lambrianakos, Peter"
`<PLambrianakos@brownrudnick.com>, "Iturralde, Enrique W." <EIturralde@brownrudnick.com>, Rob
`Sokohl <RSOKOHL@sternekessler.com>, Ryan Richardson <RRICHARDSON@sternekessler.com>,
`"dchankong@sternekessler.com" <DCHANKONG@sternekessler.com>, "ptab@sternekessler.com"
`<PTAB@sternekessler.com>
`Subject: Google v. AGIS, IPR2018-01080, -01083, -01084, -01086, -01087, and -01088
`
`External E-mail. Use caution accessing links or attachments.
`________________________________
`Vincent,
`
`We intend to send the email below to the Board, seeking permission to (i) file a 3-page reply in
`IPR2018-01080, IPR2018-01086, and IPR2018-01088 and (ii) file the joint claim construction from the
`district court along with a one-page explanation in IPR2018-01083, IPR2018-01084, and IPR2018-
`01087.
`
`Please let us know if you will oppose Google’s requests. Please also let us know your availability for a
`call with the Board. If we do not hear from you by 5:00 pm ET on Monday, September 24, we will send
`the email to the Board.
`
`Regards,
`Jonathan
`
`==DRAFT EMAIL TO BOARD==
`
`2
`
`

`

`Dear Patent Trial and Appeals Board,
`
`Petitioner Google requests permission to:
`
`1. file a 3-page reply in IPR2018-01080, IPR2018-01086, and IPR2018-01088; and
`2. file the joint claim construction from the district-court proceeding along with a one-page explanation
`in IPR2018-01083, IPR2018-01084, and IPR2018-01087.
`
`Regarding (1), AGIS accused Google of a “lack of candor” for failing to identify claim constructions
`that LG, HTC, Huawei, Apple, and ZTE filed in district court after Google filed its IPR petitions.
`Google requests a reply to respond to this accusation. The Board granted a similar request in IPR2018-
`01079, IPR2018-01081, IPR2018-01082, and IPR2018-01085.
`
`Regarding (2), AGIS has not yet filed its POPR. Google requests permission to file the joint claim
`construction from the district court along with a one-page explanation to describe the claim-construction
`positions taken in the district court.
`
`Google reached out to AGIS about these requests on September 21. AGIS indicated that it [will/will not]
`oppose Google’s request.
`
`Regards,
`Jonathan Tuminaro
`Counsel for Petitioner Google
`
`[http://vm-shrpntprod/signaturecreator/sternekessler.png]
`
`Jonathan Tuminaro<http://www.sternekessler.com/professionals/jonathan-tuminaro>, Ph.D.
`
`Director
`
`Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & Fox P.L.L.C.<http://www.sternekessler.com/>
`
`1100 New York Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20005
`
`[http://vm-shrpntprod/signaturecreator/greenline.png]
`
`Email: jtuminar@sternekessler.com<mailto:jtuminar@sternekessler.com>
`
`Direct: 202.772.8967
`
`Administrative Assistant: Earnesteen Ginn-White
`
`Main: 202.371.2600 Direct: 202.772.8574
`
`3
`
`

`

`Notice: The information in this electronic transmission (including any attachments) may contain
`confidential or legally privileged information and is intended solely for the individual(s) or entity(ies)
`named above. If you are not an intended recipient or an authorized agent, you are hereby notified that
`reading, distributing, or otherwise disseminating or copying, or taking any action based on the contents
`of this transmission is strictly prohibited. Any unauthorized interception of this transmission is illegal
`under the law. If you have received this transmission in error, please immediately notify the sender by
`return email and then destroy all copies of the transmission.
`
`***********************************************************************************
`
`The information contained in this electronic message may be legally privileged and confidential under applicable law, and is intended only for
`the use of the individual or entity named above. If the recipient of this message is not the above-named intended recipient, you are hereby
`notified that any dissemination, copy or disclosure of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,
`please notify Brown Rudnick LLP, (617) 856-8200 (if dialing from outside the US, 001-(617)-856-8200) and purge the communication
`immediately without making any copy or distribution.
`
`To the extent Brown Rudnick is a "data controller" of the "personal data" (as each term is defined in the European General Data Protection
`Regulation) you have provided to us in this and other communications between us, please see our privacy statement and summary here which
`sets out details of the data controller, the personal data we have collected, the purposes for which we use it (including any legitimate interests
`on which we rely), the persons to whom we may transfer the data and how we intend to transfer it outside the European Economic Area.
`
`***********************************************************************************
`
`***********************************************************************************
`
`The information contained in this electronic message may be legally privileged and confidential under applicable law, and is intended only for the use of
`the individual or entity named above. If the recipient of this message is not the above-named intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any
`dissemination, copy or disclosure of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify Brown
`Rudnick LLP, (617) 856-8200 (if dialing from outside the US, 001-(617)-856-8200) and purge the communication immediately without making any copy
`or distribution.
`
`To the extent Brown Rudnick is a "data controller" of the "personal data" (as each term is defined in the European General Data Protection Regulation)
`you have provided to us in this and other communications between us, please see our privacy statement and summary here which sets out details of the
`data controller, the personal data we have collected, the purposes for which we use it (including any legitimate interests on which we rely), the persons
`to whom we may transfer the data and how we intend to transfer it outside the European Economic Area.
`
`***********************************************************************************
`
`4
`
`