KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
`KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
`
`KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
`KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
`
`KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
`KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
`
`345678ÿ:6;67:
`:7<3=5657:ÿ;48ÿ7><?;4@7ÿ<ABB5::5A4
`
`

`   
`"#$%ÿ"ÿ'()($*#"+"*,"-"#./012ÿ"#$%
`LA=BÿMGNO
`C;:?54@6A4Dÿ8E<EÿFGHIJ
`P;443;Qÿ=7RA=6ÿR3=:3;46ÿ6Aÿ:7<65A4ÿMSÿA=ÿMHTUVÿALÿ6?7ÿ:7<3=5657:ÿ7><?;4@7ÿ;<6ÿALÿMJSIÿLA=
`6?7ÿL5:<;QÿW7;=ÿ74878ÿ87<7BX7=ÿSMDÿFGMYA=
`:5=53:ÿ>Bÿ?AQ854@:ÿ54<E
`Z6=;4:565A4ÿ=7RA=6ÿR3=:3;46ÿ6Aÿ:7<65A4ÿMSÿA=ÿMHTUVÿALÿ6?7ÿ:7<3=5657:ÿ7><?;4@7ÿ;<6ÿALÿMJSI
`LA=ÿ6?7ÿ6=;4:565A4ÿR7=5A8ÿL=ABÿKKKKKKKKKKÿ6AÿKKKKKKKK
`<ABB5::5A4ÿL5Q7ÿ43BX7=ÿGGMNSIFJH
`[\]^_`ÿb^cdÿefÿgdhij`g^b`ÿ^jÿjkd_ifidlÿibÿi`jÿ_m^g`dgn
`ÿ
`8opqrqso
`StNSJMYHMM
`ÿ
`[u`^`dÿegÿe`mdgÿvwgijli_`iebÿef
`[yz{zuzÿ\ck|e}dgÿyldb`ifi_^`iebÿ~wcdgn
`ib_egkeg^`iebÿegÿegh^bix^`iebn
`ÿÿ
`MFJGÿ;€o‚oÿƒ„ÿ…†oÿ;‡osˆ‰qŠDÿMM…†ÿLpƒƒs
`ÿ
`4orÿWƒs‹Dÿ4orÿWƒs‹
`MGMGI
`ÿ
`[Œllgdjjÿefÿkgib_ik^|ÿd]d_w`idÿeffi_djn
`[Žikÿeldn
`=oˆŠ…sq…‘Šÿ…opo’†ƒoÿ‚‡“osDÿˆ‰p‚Uˆÿqsoqÿ‰ƒUo”ÿTFMFVÿHtINHMGG
`:o‰‚sˆ…ˆoŠÿsoˆŠ…osoUÿ’‚sŠ‚q…ÿ…ƒÿ:o‰…ˆƒÿMFT“Vÿƒ„ÿ…†oÿ;‰…”
`ÿ
`4q‡oÿƒ„ÿ7q‰†ÿ7•‰†qoÿƒÿC†ˆ‰†ÿ=oˆŠ…osoU”
`6ˆ…poÿƒ„ÿ7q‰†ÿ<pqŠŠ”
`ÿ
`–—22—˜ÿ™1—š.›ÿœ)ÿžŸ ¡ÿ¢#/##"ÿœ¡)ÿ'0)¡
`£0¡ÿ¤'¥¦ÿ§Ÿ—¨Ÿÿ™¡Ÿ¡š1ÿ©).¡1
`:o‰‚sˆ…ˆoŠÿsoˆŠ…osoUÿ’‚sŠ‚q…ÿ…ƒÿ:o‰…ˆƒÿMFTVÿƒ„ÿ…†oÿ;‰…”
`4ƒo
`T6ˆ…poÿƒ„ÿ‰pqŠŠV
`ª˜¥(š1¡ÿ¨«ÿš0¡š.ÿ2).ÿ(¬ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ('ÿÿ®¡ŸŸ$.˜—®˜ÿ'¡'—˜¡¥ÿ('' ¡)›ÿ'ÿ¥¡¬(˜¡¥ÿ(˜ÿ¯ Ÿ¡ÿ°#±ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ™¡š )(1(¡'ÿ²š1/ÿÿÿÿ³¡'ÿÿPÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ¤—ÿÿZ
`ª˜¥(š1¡ÿ¨«ÿš0¡š.ÿ2).ÿ(¬ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ('ÿ˜—1ÿ)¡¦ ()¡¥ÿ1—ÿ¬(Ÿ¡ÿ)¡œ—)1'ÿœ )' ˜1ÿ1—ÿ™¡š1(—˜ÿ",ÿ—)ÿ"±´¥µÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ²š1/ÿÿÿÿ³¡'ÿÿZÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ¤—ÿÿP
`ª˜¥(š1¡ÿ¨«ÿš0¡š.ÿ2).ÿ®0¡10¡)ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ´"µÿ0'ÿ¬(Ÿ¡¥ÿŸŸÿ)¡œ—)1'ÿ)¡¦ ()¡¥ÿ1—ÿ¨¡ÿ¬(Ÿ¡¥ÿ¨«ÿ™¡š1(—˜ÿ",ÿ—)ÿ"±´¥µÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ™¡š )(1(¡'ÿ¶-š0˜­¡
`²š1ÿ—¬ÿ"·,°ÿ¥ )(˜­ÿ10¡ÿœ)¡š¡¥(˜­ÿ"*ÿ2—˜10'ÿ´—)ÿ¬—)ÿ' š0ÿ'0—)1¡)ÿœ¡)(—¥ÿ101ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ®'ÿ)¡¦ ()¡¥ÿ1—ÿ¬(Ÿ¡ÿ' š0ÿ)¡œ—)1'µÿ˜¥ÿ´*µÿ0'ÿ¨¡¡˜ÿ' ¨¸¡š1ÿ1—
`' š0ÿ¬(Ÿ(˜­ÿ)¡¦ ()¡2¡˜1'ÿ¬—)ÿ10¡ÿœ'1ÿ·#ÿ¥«'/ÿÿÿÿ³¡'ÿÿPÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ¤—ÿÿZ
`ª˜¥(š1¡ÿ¨«ÿš0¡š.ÿ2).ÿ®0¡10¡)ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ0'ÿ' ¨2(11¡¥ÿ¡Ÿ¡š1)—˜(šŸŸ«ÿ˜¥ÿœ—'1¡¥ÿ—˜ÿ(1'ÿš—)œ—)1¡ÿ¹¡¨ÿ'(1¡›ÿ(¬ÿ˜«›ÿ¡ž¡)«ÿª˜1¡)š1(ž¡ÿº1
`»(Ÿ¡ÿ)¡¦ ()¡¥ÿ1—ÿ¨¡ÿ' ¨2(11¡¥ÿ˜¥ÿœ—'1¡¥ÿœ )' ˜1ÿ1—ÿ¯ Ÿ¡ÿ°#±ÿ—¬ÿ¯¡­ Ÿ1(—˜ÿ™$£ÿ¥ )(˜­ÿ10¡ÿœ)¡š¡¥(˜­ÿ"*ÿ2—˜10'ÿ´—)ÿ¬—)ÿ' š0ÿ'0—)1¡)ÿœ¡)(—¥ÿ101ÿ10¡
`)¡­('1)˜1ÿ®'ÿ)¡¦ ()¡¥ÿ1—ÿ' ¨2(1ÿ˜¥ÿœ—'1ÿ' š0ÿ¬(Ÿ¡'µ/ÿÿÿÿ³¡'ÿÿPÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ¤—ÿÿZ
`ª˜¥(š1¡ÿ¨«ÿš0¡š.ÿ2).ÿ(¬ÿ¥('šŸ—' )¡ÿ—¬ÿ¥¡Ÿ(˜¦ ¡˜1ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)'ÿœ )' ˜1ÿ1—ÿª1¡2ÿ°#±ÿ—¬ÿ¯¡­ Ÿ1(—˜ÿ™$%ÿ('ÿ˜—1ÿš—˜1(˜¡¥ÿ0¡)¡(˜›ÿ˜¥ÿ®(ŸŸÿ˜—1ÿ¨¡
`š—˜1(˜¡¥›ÿ1—ÿ10¡ÿ¨¡'1ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1¼'ÿ.˜—®Ÿ¡¥­¡›ÿ(˜ÿ¥¡¬(˜(1(ž¡ÿœ)—-«ÿ—)ÿ(˜¬—)21(—˜ÿ'11¡2¡˜1'ÿ(˜š—)œ—)1¡¥ÿ¨«ÿ)¡¬¡)¡˜š¡ÿ(˜ÿ½)1ÿªªªÿ—¬ÿ10('ÿ»—)2ÿ"#$
`%ÿ—)ÿ˜«ÿ2¡˜¥2¡˜1ÿ1—ÿ10('ÿ»—)2ÿ"#$%/ÿÿÿÿZ
`ª˜¥(š1¡ÿ¨«ÿš0¡š.ÿ2).ÿ®0¡10¡)ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ('ÿÿŸ)­¡ÿšš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)›ÿ˜ÿšš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)›ÿÿ˜—˜$šš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)›ÿ—)ÿÿ'2ŸŸ¡)ÿ)¡œ—)1(˜­
`š—2œ˜«/ÿ™¡¡ÿ10¡ÿ¥¡¬(˜(1(—˜'ÿ—¬ÿ¾Ÿ)­¡ÿšš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)›¿ÿ¾šš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)¿ÿ˜¥ÿ¾'2ŸŸ¡)ÿ)¡œ—)1(˜­ÿš—2œ˜«¿ÿ(˜ÿ¯ Ÿ¡ÿ"*¨$*ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ¶-š0˜­¡ÿ²š1/
`À)­¡ÿšš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)ÿPÿ²šš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)ÿZÿ
`ÿ™2ŸŸ¡)ÿ)¡œ—)1(˜­ÿš—2œ˜«ÿZ
`¤—˜$šš¡Ÿ¡)1¡¥ÿ¬(Ÿ¡)ÿZ
`ÿ
`ÿ
`´º—ÿ˜—1ÿš0¡š.ÿ(¬ÿÿ'2ŸŸ¡)ÿ)¡œ—)1(˜­ÿš—2œ˜«µ
`ª˜¥(š1¡ÿ¨«ÿš0¡š.ÿ2).ÿ®0¡10¡)ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ('ÿÿ'0¡ŸŸÿš—2œ˜«ÿ´'ÿ¥¡¬(˜¡¥ÿ(˜ÿ¯ Ÿ¡ÿ"*¨$*ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ²š1µ/ÿÿÿÿ³¡'ÿÿZÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ¤—ÿÿP
`£0¡ÿ­­)¡­1¡ÿ2).¡1ÿžŸ ¡ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1Á'ÿš—22—˜ÿ'1—š.ÿ0¡Ÿ¥ÿ¨«ÿ˜—˜$¬¬(Ÿ(1¡'ÿ'ÿ—¬ÿ ˜¡ÿ,#›ÿ*#"+ÿ®'ÿ¢+›Ã##›*·*›±°°/ÿÿ²ŸŸÿ¡-¡š 1(ž¡
`—¬¬(š¡)'ÿ˜¥ÿ¥()¡š1—)'ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1ÿ0ž¡ÿ¨¡¡˜ÿ¥¡¡2¡¥›ÿ'—Ÿ¡Ÿ«ÿ¬—)ÿ10¡ÿœ )œ—'¡ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ¬—)¡­—(˜­ÿšŸš Ÿ1(—˜›ÿ1—ÿ¨¡ÿ¾¬¬(Ÿ(1¡'¿ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1/
`£0¡ÿ˜ 2¨¡)ÿ—¬ÿ'0)¡'ÿ—¬ÿ10¡ÿ)¡­('1)˜1Á'ÿš—22—˜ÿ'1—š.ÿ— 1'1˜¥(˜­ÿ'ÿ—¬ÿ˜ )«ÿ,"›ÿ*#"Äÿ®'ÿ°›Ä"±›"+#›,+·/
`8A<3B746:ÿ54<A=RA=;678ÿXWÿ=7L7=74<7
`ª˜¬—)21(—˜ÿ(˜šŸ ¥¡¥ÿ(˜ÿ— )ÿ¥¡¬(˜(1(ž¡ÿœ)—-«ÿ'11¡2¡˜1ÿ¬—)ÿ— )ÿ*#"Äÿ˜˜ Ÿÿ2¡¡1(˜­ÿ—¬ÿ'1—š.0—Ÿ¥¡)'ÿ'š0¡¥ Ÿ¡¥ÿ1—ÿ¨¡ÿ0¡Ÿ¥ÿ—˜ÿ£0 )'¥«›ÿ©«
`"Ûÿ*#"Äÿ('ÿ(˜š—)œ—)1¡¥ÿ¨«ÿ)¡¬¡)¡˜š¡ÿ(˜ÿª1¡2'ÿ"#›ÿ""›ÿ"*›ÿ",ÿ˜¥ÿ"°ÿ—¬ÿ½)1ÿªªªÿ—¬ÿ10('ÿ)¡œ—)1/
`ÿ
`             !
`
`
` 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-1
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`"#$%&ÿ()ÿ*(+,&+,-
`
`

`   
`ÿ
`./0/1.ÿ34ÿ5678/9:.ÿ/9;<ÿ=98ÿ.1>./8/=0/?.
`@ABCÿD604ÿBAEFÿ=991=7ÿ0?G60H
`H=>7?ÿ6Dÿ;69H?9H.
`/IJKÿ9L<ÿ
`8JMNOPQIPLR
`G=0Hÿ/
`ÿ
`ÿ
`S,&TÿUVÿWX-Y+&--
`S,&TÿU[Vÿ\Y-]ÿ^#_,(`-
`S,&TÿUWVÿb+`&-(%c&dÿe,#))ÿ*(TT&+,-
`S,&TÿZVÿg`(h&`,Y&-
`S,&TÿiVÿj&k#%ÿg`(_&&dY+k-
`S,&TÿlVÿmY+&ÿe#)&,nÿoY-_%(-X`&-
`G=0Hÿ//
`ÿ
`ÿ
`S,&TÿqVÿm#`]&,ÿ)(`ÿ\&kY-,`#+,r-ÿ*(TT(+ÿstXY,nuÿ\&%#,&dÿe,(_]v(%d&`ÿm#,,&`-ÿ#+dÿS--X&`ÿgX`_v#-&-ÿ()ÿstXY,nÿe&_X`Y,Y&-
`S,&TÿxVÿe&%&_,&dÿ^Y+#+_Y#%ÿo#,#
`S,&TÿfVÿm#+#k&T&+,r-ÿoY-_X--Y(+ÿ#+dÿ[+#%n-Y-ÿ()ÿ^Y+#+_Y#%ÿ*(+dY,Y(+ÿ#+dÿ\&-X%,-ÿ()ÿyh&`#,Y(+-
`S,&Tÿf[VÿzX#+,Y,#,Yc&ÿ#+dÿzX#%Y,#,Yc&ÿoY-_%(-X`&-ÿ[$(X,ÿm#`]&,ÿ\Y-]
`S,&TÿpVÿ^Y+#+_Y#%ÿe,#,&T&+,-ÿ#+dÿeXhh%&T&+,#`nÿo#,#
`S,&TÿwVÿ*v#+k&-ÿY+ÿ#+dÿoY-#k`&&T&+,-ÿ{Y,vÿ[__(X+,#+,-ÿ(+ÿ[__(X+,Y+kÿ#+dÿ^Y+#+_Y#%ÿoY-_%(-X`&
`S,&Tÿw[Vÿ*(+,`(%-ÿ#+dÿg`(_&dX`&-
`S,&TÿwWVÿy,v&`ÿS+)(`T#,Y(+
`G=0Hÿ///
`ÿ
`ÿ
`S,&TÿUaVÿoY`&_,(`-uÿs|&_X,Yc&ÿy))Y_&`-ÿ#+dÿ*(`h(`#,&ÿ}(c&`+#+_&
`S,&TÿUUVÿs|&_X,Yc&ÿ*(Th&+-#,Y(+
`S,&TÿUZVÿe&_X`Y,nÿy{+&`-vYhÿ()ÿ*&`,#Y+ÿW&+&)Y_Y#%ÿy{+&`-ÿ#+dÿm#+#k&T&+,ÿ#+dÿ\&%#,&dÿe,(_]v(%d&`ÿm#,,&`-
`S,&TÿUiVÿ*&`,#Y+ÿ\&%#,Y(+-vYh-ÿ#+dÿ\&%#,&dÿ"`#+-#_,Y(+-ÿ#+dÿoY`&_,(`ÿS+d&h&+d&+_&
`S,&TÿUlVÿg`Y+_Yh#%ÿ[__(X+,#+,ÿ^&&-ÿ#+dÿe&`cY_&-
`G~OIÿ/
`ÿ
`ÿ
`S,&TÿUqVÿs|vY$Y,-ÿ#+dÿ^Y+#+_Y#%ÿe,#,&T&+,ÿe_v&dX%&-
`S,&TÿUxuÿ^(`TÿUa€ÿeXTT#`n
`ÿ
`ÿeYk+#,X`&-
`ÿÿ
`
`             !
`
`
`ÿ
`ÿ
`Z
`Ua
`Uf
`Uf
`Uf
`Up
`ÿ
`Uw
`ZZ
`Zi
`lU
`lU
`lU
`lU
`lZ
`ÿ
`lZ
`lZ
`lZ
`lZ
`lZ
`ÿ
`li
`li
`ll
`
` 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-2
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`"#$%&ÿ()ÿ*(+,&+,-
`
`

`   
`ÿ
`./01ÿ3
`3145ÿ6789:;<=::
`">?-ÿ@++A#%ÿB&C(D,ÿ(+ÿE(DFÿGHIJÿCD&-&+,-ÿ?+)(DF#,?(+ÿ)(DÿK?D?A-ÿLMÿN(%O?+P-ÿQ+RSÿTUN(%O?+P-VWSÿÿ">&ÿ,&DF-ÿUX&YVÿUA-YV
`U(ADYVÿ#+OÿU(ADÿR(FC#+ZVÿ#-ÿA-&Oÿ>&D&?+ÿ#+OÿA+%&--ÿ(,>&DX?-&ÿ-,#,&Oÿ(Dÿ?+O?R#,&Oÿ$ZÿR(+,&[,YÿD&)&Dÿ,(ÿK?D?A-ÿLMÿB#O?(ÿQ+RSÿTUK?D?A-
`LMVWÿ#+Oÿ?,-ÿ-A$-?O?#D?&-S
`\]^]_`ÿa5ÿbcde]fg`ÿ3fh7
`K?D?A-ÿLMÿ?-ÿ#ÿX>(%%ZI(X+&Oÿ-A$-?O?#DZÿ()ÿN(%O?+P-SÿÿN(%O?+P-ÿX#-ÿ?+R(DC(D#,&Oÿ?+ÿ,>&ÿK,#,&ÿ()ÿi&%#X#D&ÿ(+ÿM#ZÿjGY
`jHGkSÿÿN(%O?+P-ÿ>#-ÿ+(ÿ(C&D#,?(+-ÿ?+O&C&+O&+,ÿ()ÿ?,-ÿ-A$-?O?#DZÿK?D?A-ÿLMS
`0ldmn]cf`o]pÿq]noÿr]sl^ntÿ5le]m
`@-ÿ()ÿi&R&F$&DÿkGYÿjHGuYÿv?$&D,ZÿM&O?#ÿ*(DC(D#,?(+ÿTUv?$&D,ZÿM&O?#VWÿ$&+&)?R?#%%Zÿ(X+&OYÿO?D&R,%Zÿ#+Oÿ?+O?D&R,%ZY
`#CCD([?F#,&%Zÿuwxÿ()ÿ,>&ÿ(A,-,#+O?+Pÿ->#D&-ÿ()ÿN(%O?+P-yÿR(FF(+ÿ-,(RzSÿÿv?$&D,ZÿM&O?#ÿ(X+-ÿ?+,&D&-,-ÿ?+ÿ#ÿD#+P&ÿ()ÿF&O?#Y
`R(FFA+?R#,?(+-ÿ#+Oÿ&+,&D,#?+F&+,ÿ$A-?+&--&-S
`\]^]_`ÿa5ÿ0me]cÿ3fh7
`{&ÿ,D#+-F?,ÿFA-?RYÿ-C(D,-Yÿ&+,&D,#?+F&+,YÿR(F&OZYÿ,#%zYÿ+&X-Yÿ,D#))?Rÿ#+OÿX&#,>&DÿR>#++&%-Yÿ#-ÿX&%%ÿ#-ÿ?+)(,#?+F&+,ÿ-&D|?R&-Yÿ?+
`,>&ÿ}+?,&OÿK,#,&-ÿ(+ÿ#ÿ-A$-RD?C,?(+ÿ)&&ÿ$#-?-ÿ,>D(AP>ÿ(ADÿ,X(ÿCD(CD?&,#DZÿ-#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(ÿ-Z-,&F-SÿÿKA$-RD?$&D-ÿR#+ÿ#%-(ÿD&R&?|&ÿFA-?R
`#+Oÿ(,>&DÿR>#++&%-YÿC%A-ÿ)&#,AD&-ÿ-AR>ÿ#-ÿK?D?A-LMÿ~+ÿi&F#+Oÿ#+OÿMZKLMYÿ(|&Dÿ(ADÿQ+,&D+&,ÿD#O?(ÿ-&D|?R&Yÿ?+R%AO?+Pÿ,>D(AP>
`#CC%?R#,?(+-ÿ)(DÿF($?%&ÿO&|?R&-Yÿ>(F&ÿO&|?R&-ÿ#+Oÿ(,>&DÿR(+-AF&Dÿ&%&R,D(+?Rÿ&A?CF&+,Sÿÿ{&ÿ#D&ÿ#%-(ÿ#ÿ%&#O&Dÿ?+ÿCD(|?O?+PÿR(++&R,&O
`|&>?R%&ÿ-&D|?R&-Sÿ~ADÿR(++&R,&Oÿ|&>?R%&ÿ-&D|?R&-ÿ#D&ÿO&-?P+&Oÿ,(ÿ&+>#+R&ÿ,>&ÿ-#)&,ZYÿ-&RAD?,Zÿ#+OÿOD?|?+Pÿ&[C&D?&+R&ÿ)(Dÿ|&>?R%&
`(C&D#,(D-ÿX>?%&ÿCD(|?O?+PÿF#Dz&,?+Pÿ#+Oÿ(C&D#,?(+#%ÿ$&+&)?,-ÿ,(ÿ#A,(F#z&D-ÿ#+Oÿ,>&?DÿO&#%&D-S
`@-ÿ()ÿi&R&F$&DÿkGYÿjHGuYÿX&ÿ>#Oÿ#CCD([?F#,&%ZÿkGSkÿF?%%?(+ÿ-A$-RD?$&D-Sÿÿ~ADÿ-A$-RD?$&D-ÿ?+R%AO&€
`-A$-RD?$&D-ÿA+O&Dÿ(ADÿD&PA%#Dÿ#+OÿO?-R(A+,&OÿCD?R?+PÿC%#+-‚
`-A$-RD?$&D-ÿ,>#,ÿ>#|&ÿCD&C#?OYÿ?+R%AO?+PÿC#ZF&+,-ÿF#O&ÿ(DÿOA&ÿ)D(Fÿ#A,(F#z&D-ÿ)(Dÿ-A$-RD?C,?(+-ÿ?+R%AO&Oÿ?+ÿ,>&ÿ-#%&ÿ(D
`%&#-&ÿCD?R&ÿ()ÿ#ÿ|&>?R%&‚
`-A$-RD?$&D-ÿ,(ÿ(ADÿQ+,&D+&,ÿ-&D|?R&-ÿX>(ÿO(ÿ+(,ÿ#%-(ÿ>#|&ÿ-#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(ÿ-A$-RD?C,?(+-‚ÿ#+O
`R&D,#?+ÿ-A$-RD?$&D-ÿ,(ÿ(ADÿX&#,>&DYÿ,D#))?Rÿ#+OÿO#,#ÿ-&D|?R&-ÿX>(ÿO(ÿ+(,ÿ#%-(ÿ>#|&ÿ-#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(ÿ-A$-RD?C,?(+-S
`~ADÿCD?F#DZÿ-(ADR&ÿ()ÿD&|&+A&ÿ?-ÿ-A$-RD?C,?(+ÿ)&&-YÿX?,>ÿF(-,ÿ()ÿ(ADÿRA-,(F&D-ÿ-A$-RD?$?+Pÿ,(ÿ#++A#%Yÿ-&F?I#++A#%YÿA#D,&D%Zÿ(D
`F(+,>%ZÿC%#+-Sÿÿ{&ÿ())&DÿO?-R(A+,-ÿ)(DÿCD&C#?Oÿ%(+P&Dÿ,&DFÿ-A$-RD?C,?(+ÿC%#+-Yÿ#-ÿX&%%ÿ#-ÿ#ÿFA%,?C%&ÿ-A$-RD?C,?(+ÿO?-R(A+,Sÿÿ{&ÿ#%-(
`O&D?|&ÿD&|&+A&ÿ)D(Fÿ#R,?|#,?(+ÿ#+Oÿ(,>&Dÿ)&&-Yÿ,>&ÿ-#%&ÿ()ÿ#O|&D,?-?+Pÿ(+ÿ-&%&R,ÿ+(+IFA-?RÿR>#++&%-Yÿ,>&ÿO?D&R,ÿ-#%&ÿ()ÿ-#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(-
`#+Oÿ#RR&--(D?&-Yÿ#+Oÿ(,>&Dÿ#+R?%%#DZÿ-&D|?R&-Yÿ-AR>ÿ#-ÿ(ADÿX&#,>&DYÿ,D#))?Rÿ#+OÿO#,#ÿ-&D|?R&-S
`~ADÿ-#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(-ÿ#D&ÿCD?F#D?%ZÿO?-,D?$A,&Oÿ,>D(AP>ÿ#A,(F#z&D-‚ÿD&,#?%ÿ-,(D&-ÿ+#,?(+X?O&‚ÿ#+Oÿ,>D(AP>ÿ(ADÿX&$-?,&Sÿÿ{&ÿ>#|&
`#PD&&F&+,-ÿX?,>ÿ&|&DZÿF#ƒ(Dÿ#A,(F#z&Dÿ,(ÿ())&Dÿ-#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(-ÿ?+ÿ,>&?Dÿ|&>?R%&-Sÿÿ{&ÿ#%-(ÿ#RA?D&ÿ-A$-RD?$&D-ÿ,>D(AP>ÿF#Dz&,?+Pÿ,(
`(X+&D-ÿ#+Oÿ%&--&&-ÿ()ÿCD&|?(A-%ZI(X+&Oÿ|&>?R%&-ÿ,>#,ÿ?+R%AO&ÿ)#R,(DZI?+-,#%%&Oÿ-#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(-ÿ,>#,ÿ#D&ÿ+(,ÿRADD&+,%Zÿ-A$-RD?$?+Pÿ,(ÿ(AD
`-&D|?R&-SÿK#,&%%?,&ÿD#O?(ÿ-&D|?R&-ÿ#D&ÿ#%-(ÿ())&D&Oÿ,(ÿRA-,(F&D-ÿ()ÿR&D,#?+ÿD&+,#%ÿR#DÿR(FC#+?&-S
`.^cg^m„„]fg{&ÿ())&Dÿ#ÿOZ+#F?RÿCD(PD#FF?+Pÿ%?+&ACÿ()ÿR(FF&DR?#%I)D&&ÿFA-?RÿC%A-ÿ-C(D,-Yÿ&+,&D,#?+F&+,YÿR(F&OZYÿ,#%zYÿ#+Oÿ+&X-Y
`?+R%AO?+P€#+ÿ&[,&+-?|&ÿ-&%&R,?(+ÿ()ÿFA-?RÿP&+D&-YÿD#+P?+Pÿ)D(FÿD(RzYÿC(Cÿ#+Oÿ>?CI>(Cÿ,(ÿR(A+,DZYÿO#+R&Yÿƒ#……Yÿv#,?+ÿ#+OÿR%#--?R#%‚
`%?|&ÿC%#ZI$ZIC%#Zÿ-C(D,-ÿ)D(FÿF#ƒ(Dÿ%&#PA&-ÿ#+OÿR(%%&P&-‚
`#ÿFA%,?,AO&ÿ()ÿ,#%zÿ#+Oÿ&+,&D,#?+F&+,ÿR>#++&%-ÿ)(Dÿ#ÿ|#D?&,Zÿ()ÿ#AO?&+R&-‚
`#ÿX?O&ÿD#+P&ÿ()ÿ+#,?(+#%Yÿ?+,&D+#,?(+#%ÿ#+Oÿ)?+#+R?#%ÿ+&X-‚ÿ#+O
`ÿ
`j
`             !
`
`
`
`
` 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-3
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`#$%&'ÿ)*ÿ+),-',-.
`
`

`   
`ÿ/'01&2.34'ÿ&353-'6ÿ72,ÿ18$,,'&.9
`:27ÿ634'7.'ÿ.;'1-725ÿ)*ÿ;7)<7$553,<=ÿ3,1&263,<ÿ)27ÿ&3,'2;ÿ)*ÿ'01&2.34'ÿ5$-'73$&=ÿ3.ÿ$ÿ.3<,3*31$,-ÿ63**'7',-3$-)7ÿ*7)5ÿ-'77'.-73$&
`7$63)ÿ$,6ÿ)-8'7ÿ$263)ÿ',-'7-$3,5',-ÿ;7)436'7.9ÿÿ>'ÿ5$?'ÿ18$,<'.ÿ-)ÿ)27ÿ;7)<7$553,<ÿ&3,'2;ÿ*7)5ÿ-35'ÿ-)ÿ-35'ÿ$.ÿ@'ÿ.-734'ÿ-)ÿ$--7$1-
`,'@ÿ.2%.173%'7.ÿ$,6ÿ)**'7ÿ1),-',-ÿ@8318ÿ$;;'$&.ÿ-)ÿ$ÿ%7)$6ÿ7$,<'ÿ)*ÿ$263',1'.ÿ$,6ÿ-)ÿ)27ÿ'03.-3,<ÿ.2%.173%'7.9ÿÿ#8'ÿ18$,,'&ÿ&3,'A2;.
`*)7ÿ)27ÿ.'7431'.ÿ$7'ÿ$4$3&$%&'ÿ$-ÿ.3732.0591)59
`BCDEFCEDÿHIJKLÿMEFNKOE
`>'ÿ.-7'$5ÿ.'&'1-ÿ52.31ÿ$,6ÿ,),A52.31ÿ18$,,'&.ÿ)4'7ÿ-8'ÿP,-'7,'-9ÿÿ:27ÿP,-'7,'-ÿ7$63)ÿ.'7431'ÿ$&.)ÿ3,1&26'.ÿ1'7-$3,ÿ18$,,'&.ÿ$,6
`*'$-27'.ÿ-8$-ÿ$7'ÿ,)-ÿ$4$3&$%&'ÿ),ÿ)27ÿ.$-'&&3-'ÿ7$63)ÿ.'7431'9ÿÿQ11'..ÿ-)ÿ)27ÿP,-'7,'-ÿ7$63)ÿ.'7431'ÿ3.ÿ)**'7'6ÿ-)ÿ.2%.173%'7.ÿ*)7ÿ$ÿ*''9ÿÿ>'
`$&.)ÿ)**'7ÿ$;;&31$-3),.ÿ-)ÿ$&&)@ÿ1),.25'7.ÿ-)ÿ$11'..ÿ)27ÿP,-'7,'-ÿ7$63)ÿ.'7431'ÿ),ÿ.5$7-;8),'.=ÿ-$%&'-.=ÿ1)5;2-'7.=ÿ8)5'ÿ6'431'.ÿ$,6
`)-8'7ÿ1),.25'7ÿ'&'1-7),31ÿ'R23;5',-9
`S3732.TUÿP,-'7,'-ÿV$63)ÿ)**'7.ÿ&3.-','7.ÿ',8$,1'6ÿ;7)<7$553,<ÿ63.1)4'7Wÿ$,6ÿ-8'ÿ$%3&3-Wÿ-)ÿ1),,'1-ÿ@3-8ÿ1),-',-ÿ1277',-&W
`;&$W3,<ÿ$17)..ÿ)27ÿ1)55'713$&A*7''ÿ52.31=ÿ.;)7-.=ÿ1)5'6W=ÿ,'@.=ÿ-$&?ÿ$,6ÿ',-'7-$3,5',-ÿ18$,,'&.ÿ)7ÿ$4$3&$%&'ÿ-87)2<8ÿS3732.TUÿ:,
`X'5$,69S3732.TUÿ:,ÿX'5$,6ÿ)**'7.ÿ)27ÿP,-'7,'-ÿ7$63)ÿ.2%.173%'7.ÿ&3.-',3,<ÿ),ÿ)27ÿ),&3,'ÿ5'63$ÿ;&$W'7ÿ$,6ÿ),ÿ.5$7-;8),'.ÿ-8'ÿ$%3&3-W
`-)ÿ18)).'ÿ-8'37ÿ*$4)73-'ÿ';3.)6'.ÿ*7)5ÿ$ÿ1$-$&)<ÿ)*ÿ1),-',-ÿ@8','4'7ÿ-8'Wÿ@$,-9ÿÿUWSTUÿ;'753-.ÿ.2%.173%'7.ÿ-)ÿ;'7.),$&3Y'ÿ)27
`'03.-3,<ÿ1)55'713$&A*7''ÿ52.31ÿ$,6ÿ1)5'6Wÿ18$,,'&.ÿ-)ÿ17'$-'ÿ$ÿ5)7'ÿ-$3&)7'6ÿ&3.-',3,<ÿ'0;'73',1'9ÿÿ+8$,,'&A.;'13*31ÿ.&36'7.ÿ$&&)@
`2.'7.ÿ-)ÿ17'$-'ÿ)4'7ÿZ[[ÿ4$73$-3),.ÿ)*ÿ'$18ÿ)*ÿ5)7'ÿ-8$,ÿ\[ÿ18$,,'&.ÿ%Wÿ$6]2.-3,<ÿ18$7$1-'73.-31.ÿ&3?'ÿ&3%7$7Wÿ6';-8=ÿ*$53&3$73-W=ÿ52.31
`.-W&'=ÿ-'5;)=ÿ7'<3),=ÿ$,6ÿ52&-3;&'ÿ)-8'7ÿ18$,,'&A.;'13*31ÿ$--73%2-'.9ÿÿS3732.TUÿ:,ÿX'5$,6ÿ$,6ÿUWSTUÿ$7'ÿ)**'7'6ÿ-)ÿ)27ÿP,-'7,'-
`7$63)ÿ.2%.173%'7.ÿ$-ÿ,)ÿ'0-7$ÿ18$7<'9
`^_`a>'ÿ$7'ÿ6'4'&);3,<ÿ$ÿ;7)621-=ÿ@8318ÿ@'ÿ1$&&ÿbcd[efÿg*)75'7&Wÿ1$&&'6ÿSTUZhi=ÿ-8$-ÿ1)5%3,'.ÿ)27ÿ.$-'&&3-'ÿ$,6ÿP,-'7,'-ÿ.'7431'.
`3,-)ÿ$ÿ.3,<&'=ÿ1)8'.34'ÿ3,A4'831&'ÿ',-'7-$3,5',-ÿ'0;'73',1'9ÿcd[eÿ3.ÿ'0;'1-'6ÿ-)ÿ$&&)@ÿ2.ÿ-)ÿ-$?'ÿ$64$,-$<'ÿ)*ÿ$64$,1'6ÿ3,A6$.8
`3,*)-$3,5',-ÿ.W.-'5.9ÿÿcd[eÿ3.ÿ3,-',6'6ÿ-)ÿ&'4'7$<'ÿ-8'ÿ2%3R23-)2.ÿ.3<,$&ÿ1)4'7$<'ÿ)*ÿ)27ÿ.$-'&&3-'ÿ3,*7$.-721-27'ÿ$,6ÿ&)@ÿ6'&34'7Wÿ1).-.
`@3-8ÿ-8'ÿ-@)A@$Wÿ1)552,31$-3),ÿ1$;$%3&3-Wÿ)*ÿ@37'&'..ÿP,-'7,'-ÿ.'7431'ÿ-)ÿ;7)436'ÿ1),.25'7.ÿ.'$5&'..ÿ$11'..ÿ-)ÿ)27ÿ1),-',-=ÿ3,1&263,<
`)27ÿ&34'ÿ18$,,'&.=ÿS3732.TUÿ:,ÿX'5$,6ÿ;7)<7$553,<ÿ$,6ÿ5)7'ÿ;'7.),$&3Y'6ÿ52.31ÿ.'7431'.9ÿÿ#8'ÿ@37'&'..ÿP,-'7,'-ÿ1),,'1-3),
`3,1&26'6ÿ3,ÿcd[eÿ@3&&ÿ',$%&'ÿ',8$,1'6ÿ.'$718ÿ$,6ÿ7'1)55',6$-3),.ÿ*2,1-3),.=ÿ5$?3,<ÿ63.1)4'7Wÿ)*ÿ)27ÿ1),-',-ÿ3,ÿ-8'ÿ4'831&'ÿ'$.3'7
`-8$,ÿ'4'79ÿÿcd[eÿ@3&&ÿ$&.)ÿ$&&)@ÿ1),.25'7.ÿ-)ÿ5$,$<'ÿ$.;'1-.ÿ)*ÿ-8'37ÿ.2%.173;-3),.ÿ637'1-&Wÿ-87)2<8ÿ-8'37ÿ4'831&'.jÿ'R23;5',-9
`kKlDFKmnDKLCÿLoÿHIJKLl
`pqrstuvwxy
`>'ÿ63.-73%2-'ÿ.$-'&&3-'ÿ7$63).ÿ-87)2<8ÿ-8'ÿ.$&'ÿ$,6ÿ&'$.'ÿ)*ÿ,'@ÿ4'831&'.9ÿÿ>'ÿ8$4'ÿ$<7''5',-.ÿ@3-8ÿ'4'7Wÿ5$])7ÿ$2-)5$?'7ÿ-)
`)**'7ÿ.$-'&&3-'ÿ7$63).ÿ3,ÿ-8'37ÿ4'831&'.9ÿÿS$-'&&3-'ÿ7$63).ÿ$7'ÿ$4$3&$%&'ÿ$.ÿ$ÿ*$1-)7Wÿ)7ÿ6'$&'7A3,.-$&&'6ÿ);-3),ÿ3,ÿ.2%.-$,-3$&&Wÿ$&&ÿ4'831&'
`5$?'.ÿ.)&6ÿ3,ÿ-8'ÿz,3-'6ÿS-$-'.9
`U).-ÿ$2-)5$?'7.ÿ3,1&26'ÿ$ÿ.2%.173;-3),ÿ-)ÿ)27ÿ7$63)ÿ.'7431'ÿ3,ÿ-8'ÿ.$&'ÿ)7ÿ&'$.'ÿ)*ÿ-8'37ÿ,'@ÿ4'831&'.9ÿÿP,ÿ1'7-$3,ÿ1$.'.=ÿ@'
`7'1'34'ÿ.2%.173;-3),ÿ;$W5',-.ÿ*7)5ÿ$2-)5$?'7.ÿ3,ÿ$64$,1'ÿ)*ÿ-8'ÿ$1-34$-3),ÿ)*ÿ)27ÿ.'7431'9ÿÿ>'ÿ.8$7'ÿ@3-8ÿ1'7-$3,ÿ$2-)5$?'7.ÿ$ÿ;)7-3),
`)*ÿ-8'ÿ7'4',2'.ÿ@'ÿ6'734'ÿ*7)5ÿ.2%.173%'7.ÿ2.3,<ÿ4'831&'.ÿ'R23;;'6ÿ-)ÿ7'1'34'ÿ)27ÿ.'7431'9ÿÿ>'ÿ$&.)ÿ7'35%27.'ÿ4$73)2.ÿ$2-)5$?'7.ÿ*)7
`1'7-$3,ÿ1).-.ÿ$..)13$-'6ÿ@3-8ÿ-8'ÿ.$-'&&3-'ÿ7$63).ÿ3,.-$&&'6ÿ3,ÿ,'@ÿ4'831&'.=ÿ3,1&263,<ÿ3,ÿ1'7-$3,ÿ1$.'.ÿ8$76@$7'ÿ1).-.=ÿ',<3,''73,<
`'0;',.'.ÿ$,6ÿ;7)5)-3),$&ÿ$,6ÿ$64'7-3.3,<ÿ'0;',.'.9
`{xw|}sqy~ÿ‚ƒw„ÿ…w†}‡~wy
`>'ÿ$1R237'ÿ.2%.173%'7.ÿ-87)2<8ÿ-8'ÿ.$&'ÿ$,6ÿ&'$.'ÿ)*ÿ;7'43)2.&Wÿ)@,'6ÿ4'831&'.ÿ@3-8ÿ*$1-)7WA3,.-$&&'6ÿ.$-'&&3-'ÿ7$63).9ÿÿ>'ÿ8$4'
`',-'7'6ÿ3,-)ÿ$<7''5',-.ÿ@3-8ÿ5$,Wÿ$2-)5$?'7.ÿ-)ÿ5$7?'-ÿ.2%.173;-3),.ÿ-)ÿ;2718$.'7.ÿ$,6ÿ&'..''.ÿ)*ÿ4'831&'.ÿ@8318ÿ3,1&26'ÿ.$-'&&3-'
`7$63).ÿ.)&6ÿ-87)2<8ÿ-8'37ÿ1'7-3*3'6ÿ;7'A)@,'6ÿ;7)<7$5.9ÿÿ>'ÿ$&.)ÿ@)7?ÿ637'1-&Wÿ@3-8ÿ*7$,183.'ÿ$,6ÿ3,6';',6',-ÿ6'$&'7.ÿ),ÿ;7)<7$5.ÿ*)7
`,),A1'7-3*3'6ÿ4'831&'.9
`>'ÿ8$4'ÿ6'4'&);'6ÿ.W.-'5.ÿ$,6ÿ5'-8)6.ÿ-)ÿ36',-3*Wÿ;2718$.'7.ÿ$,6ÿ&'..''.ÿ)*ÿ;7'43)2.&Wÿ)@,'6ÿ4'831&'.ÿ@8318ÿ3,1&26'ÿ.$-'&&3-'
`7$63).ÿ$,6ÿ8$4'ÿ'.-$%&3.8'6ÿ5$7?'-3,<ÿ;&$,.ÿ-)ÿ;7)5)-'ÿ)27ÿ.'7431'.ÿ-)ÿ-8'.'ÿ;)-',-3$&ÿ.2%.173%'7.9
`ÿ
`c
`             !
`
`" 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-4
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`"#$%&ÿ()ÿ*(+,&+,-
`
`

`   
`ÿ./01234&ÿ-&%%ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ6#75(-ÿ756&8,%9ÿ,(ÿ8(+-:;&6-ÿ,<6(:=<ÿ(:6ÿ>&$-5,&?ÿÿ@#,&%%5,&ÿ6#75(-ÿ#6&ÿ#%-(ÿ;#6A&,&7ÿ#+7ÿ75-,65$:,&7ÿ,<6(:=<
`+#,5(+#%ÿ#+7ÿ6&=5(+#%ÿ6&,#5%&6-?
`BCDÿFGHIJJKHIÿLGMKNÿFOPHIQP
`R:6ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ6#75(ÿ-9-,&;-ÿ#6&ÿ7&-5=+&7ÿ,(ÿS6(T57&ÿ8%&#6ÿ6&8&S,5(+ÿ5+ÿ;(-,ÿ#6&#-ÿ7&-S5,&ÿT#65#,5(+-ÿ5+ÿ,&66#5+Uÿ$:5%75+=-ÿ#+7ÿ(,<&6
`($-,6:8,5(+-?ÿÿ4&ÿ8(+,5+:#%%9ÿ;(+5,(6ÿ(:6ÿ5+)6#-,6:8,:6&ÿ#+7ÿ6&=:%#6%9ÿ&T#%:#,&ÿ5;S6(T&;&+,-ÿ5+ÿ,&8<+(%(=9?
`R:6ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ6#75(ÿ-9-,&;-ÿ<#T&ÿ,<6&&ÿS65+85S#%ÿ8(;S(+&+,-V
`W-#,&%%5,&-Uÿ,&66&-,65#%ÿ6&S&#,&6-ÿ#+7ÿ(,<&6ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ)#85%5,5&-X
`W-,:75(-Xÿ#+7
`W6#75(-?
`Y10/3320/Z[ÿ]/^^/Z0^213ÿ./_/10/^Zÿ1`aÿb0c/^ÿY10/3320/ÿd1e23202/Z
`fghijjkhilmÿÿ4&ÿS6(T57&ÿ(:6ÿ-&6T58&ÿ,<6(:=<ÿ#ÿ)%&&,ÿ()ÿ)5T&ÿ(6$5,5+=ÿ-#,&%%5,&-Uÿ,>(ÿ5+ÿ,<&ÿ@565:-ÿ-9-,&;Uÿnopqÿ#+7ÿnoprUÿ#+7ÿ,<6&&
`5+ÿ,<&ÿsoÿ-9-,&;UÿsoptUÿsopuÿ#+7ÿsopq?ÿÿR:6ÿsopqÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ-&6T&-ÿ#-ÿ#ÿ-S#6&ÿ)(6ÿ$(,<ÿ,<&ÿsoÿ#+7ÿ@565:-ÿ-9-,&;-?
`R:6ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ8(+-,&%%#,5(+ÿ(S&6#,&-ÿ5+ÿ=&(-,#,5(+#69ÿ(6$5,-?ÿv:65+=ÿwxyrUÿ>&ÿ,6#+-5,5(+&7ÿ,<&ÿ@565:-ÿ+&,>(6Aÿ,(ÿ#ÿ=&(-,#,5(+#69
`(6$5,ÿ-9-,&;ÿ:-5+=ÿ(:6ÿnopqÿ#+7ÿnoprÿ-#,&%%5,&-?ÿz-ÿS#6,ÿ()ÿ,<5-ÿ-&6T58&ÿ,6#+-5,5(+Uÿ5+ÿwxyrUÿ(:6ÿnopyUÿnopwÿ#+7ÿnoptÿ-#,&%%5,&-Uÿ><58<
`<#7ÿ(S&6#,&7ÿ5+ÿ<5=<%9ÿ5+8%5+&7ÿ&%%5S,58#%ÿ(6$5,-Uÿ>&6&ÿ;(T&7ÿ5+,(ÿ75-S(-#%ÿ(6$5,-?ÿ{+ÿwxyrUÿ>&ÿ#%-(ÿ&+,&6&7ÿ5+,(ÿ#+ÿ#=6&&;&+,ÿ)(6ÿ,<&
`7&-5=+ÿ#+7ÿ8(+-,6:8,5(+ÿ()ÿ,>(ÿ+&>ÿ-#,&%%5,&-Uÿ@sop|ÿ#+7ÿ@sop}Uÿ><58<ÿ>&ÿS%#+ÿ,(ÿ%#:+8<ÿ5+,(ÿ=&(-,#,5(+#69ÿ(6$5,-ÿ5+ÿwxy~ÿ#+7ÿwxwxU
`6&-S&8,5T&%9Uÿ#-ÿ6&S%#8&;&+,-ÿ)(6ÿsoptÿ#+7ÿsopu?
`fghijjkhiÿ€l‚ƒg„imÿÿ4&ÿ7(ÿ+(,ÿ<#T&ÿ5+p(6$5,ÿ5+-:6#+8&ÿS(%585&-ÿ8(T&65+=ÿ(:6ÿ-#,&%%5,&-Uÿ#-ÿ>&ÿ8(+-57&6ÿ,<&ÿS6&;5:;ÿ8(-,-ÿ,(ÿ$&
`:+&8(+(;58#%ÿ6&%#,5T&ÿ,(ÿ,<&ÿ65-Aÿ()ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ)#5%:6&?
`…iƒƒilhƒkgjÿ†i‡ighiƒlmÿÿ{+ÿ-(;&ÿ#6&#-ÿ>5,<ÿ<5=<ÿ8(+8&+,6#,5(+-ÿ()ÿ,#%%ÿ$:5%75+=-Uÿ-:8<ÿ#-ÿ:6$#+ÿ8&+,&6-Uÿ-5=+#%-ÿ)6(;ÿ(:6ÿ-#,&%%5,&-
`;#9ÿ$&ÿ$%(8A&7ÿ#+7ÿ6&8&S,5(+ÿ()ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ-5=+#%-ÿ8#+ÿ$&ÿ#7T&6-&%9ÿ#))&8,&7?ÿÿ{+ÿ(,<&6ÿ#6&#-ÿ>5,<ÿ#ÿ<5=<ÿ7&+-5,9ÿ()ÿ+&ˆ,ÿ=&+&6#,5(+
`>56&%&--ÿ-9-,&;-ÿ(:6ÿ-&6T58&ÿ;#9ÿ&ˆS&65&+8&ÿ5+,&6)&6&+8&?ÿ{+ÿ;#+9ÿ()ÿ,<&-&ÿ#6&#-Uÿ>&ÿ<#T&ÿ7&S%(9&7ÿ,&66&-,65#%ÿ6&S&#,&6-ÿ,(ÿ-:SS%&;&+,
`#+7ÿ&+<#+8&ÿ(:6ÿ-5=+#%ÿ8(T&6#=&?ÿÿ4&ÿ(S&6#,&ÿ(T&6ÿyUxxxÿ,&66&-,65#%ÿ6&S&#,&6-ÿ#86(--ÿ,<&ÿ‰+5,&7ÿ@,#,&-ÿ#-ÿS#6,ÿ()ÿ(:6ÿ-9-,&;-?
`Šh‹iƒÿfghijjkhiÿŒg„kjkhkilmÿÿ4&ÿ8(+,6(%ÿ#+7ÿ8(;;:+58#,&ÿ>5,<ÿ(:6ÿ-#,&%%5,&-ÿ)6(;ÿ)#85%5,5&-ÿ5+ÿ(6,<ÿz;&658#?ÿv:65+=ÿwxyrUÿ>&
`;#5+,#5+&7ÿ&#6,<ÿ-,#,5(+-ÿ5+ÿŽ#+#;#ÿ#+7ÿ8:#7(6ÿ,(ÿ8(+,6(%ÿ#+7ÿ8(;;:+58#,&ÿ>5,<ÿ,<6&&ÿ()ÿ(:6ÿ@565:-ÿ-#,&%%5,&-UÿnopyUÿnopwÿ#+7ÿnop
`t?ÿ4&ÿS%#+ÿ,(ÿ&+7ÿ(S&6#,5(+-ÿ5+ÿŽ#+#;#ÿ#+7ÿ8:#7(6ÿ5+ÿwxy|?ÿR:6ÿ-#,&%%5,&-ÿ#6&ÿ;(+5,(6&7Uÿ,6#8A&7ÿ#+7ÿ8(+,6(%%&7ÿ$9ÿ#ÿ,<567ÿS#6,9
`-#,&%%5,&ÿ(S&6#,(6?
`Y0a2‘ZR:6ÿS6(=6#;;5+=ÿ(65=5+#,&-ÿ)6(;ÿ-,:75(-ÿ5+ÿ&>ÿ’(6Aÿ*5,9ÿ#+7ÿ4#-<5+=,(+ÿv?*?ÿ#+7Uÿ,(ÿ#ÿ%&--&6ÿ&ˆ,&+,Uÿ)6(;ÿ-;#%%&6ÿ-,:75(-ÿ5+
`“(-ÿz+=&%&-Uÿ#-<T5%%&ÿ#+7ÿ#ÿT#65&,9ÿ()ÿ-;#%%&6ÿT&+:&-ÿ#86(--ÿ,<&ÿ8(:+,69?ÿÿR:6ÿ8(6S(6#,&ÿ<&#7”:#6,&6-ÿ5-ÿ$#-&7ÿ5+ÿ&>ÿ’(6A
`*5,9?ÿÿ•(,<ÿ(:6ÿ&>ÿ’(6Aÿ*5,9ÿ#+7ÿ4#-<5+=,(+ÿv?*?ÿ())58&-ÿ<(:-&ÿ)#85%5,5&-ÿ)(6ÿS6(=6#;;5+=ÿ(65=5+#,5(+UÿS6(=6#;;5+=ÿS&6-(++&%ÿ#+7
`)#85%5,5&-ÿ,(ÿ,6#+-;5,ÿS6(=6#;;5+=?
`.1a2‘Z4&ÿ7(ÿ+(,ÿ;#+:)#8,:6&ÿ6#75(-?ÿÿ4&ÿ<#T&ÿ#:,<(65–&7ÿ;#+:)#8,:6&6-ÿ#+7ÿ75-,65$:,(6-ÿ,(ÿS6(7:8&ÿ#+7ÿ75-,65$:,&ÿ6#75(-Uÿ#+7ÿ<#T&
`%58&+-&7ÿ(:6ÿ,&8<+(%(=9ÿ,(ÿT#65(:-ÿ&%&8,6(+58-ÿ;#+:)#8,:6&6-ÿ,(ÿ7&T&%(SUÿ;#+:)#8,:6&ÿ#+7ÿ75-,65$:,&ÿ6#75(-ÿ:+7&6ÿ8&6,#5+ÿ$6#+7-?ÿÿ4&
`7(ÿ;#+#=&ÿT#65(:-ÿ#-S&8,-ÿ()ÿ,<&ÿS6(7:8,5(+ÿ()ÿ-#,&%%5,&ÿ6#75(-?ÿÿ"(ÿ)#85%5,#,&ÿ,<&ÿ-#%&ÿ()ÿ6#75(-Uÿ>&ÿ;#9ÿ-:$-575–&ÿ#ÿS(6,5(+ÿ()ÿ,<&ÿ6#75(
`;#+:)#8,:65+=ÿ8(-,-ÿ,(ÿ6&7:8&ÿ,<&ÿ<#67>#6&ÿS658&ÿ,(ÿ8(+-:;&6-?
`ÿ
`u
`             !
`
`
` 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-5
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`"#$%&ÿ()ÿ*(+,&+,-
`
`

`   
`ÿ./0012314ÿ6178291ÿ:1;<821=
`>&ÿ#?&ÿ#ÿ%&#@&?ÿA+ÿB?(CA@A+DÿE(++&E,&@ÿC&FAE%&ÿ-&?CAE&-GÿHI?ÿE(++&E,&@ÿC&FAE%&ÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ#?&ÿ@&-AD+&@ÿ,(ÿ&+F#+E&ÿ,F&ÿ-#)&,JK
`-&EI?A,Jÿ#+@ÿ@?ACA+Dÿ&LB&?A&+E&ÿ)(?ÿC&FAE%&ÿ(B&?#,(?-ÿMFA%&ÿB?(CA@A+DÿN#?O&,A+Dÿ#+@ÿ(B&?#,A(+#%ÿ$&+&)A,-ÿ,(ÿ#I,(N#O&?-ÿ#+@ÿ,F&A?
`@&#%&?-Gÿÿ>&ÿ())&?ÿ#ÿB(?,)(%A(ÿ()ÿ%(E#,A(+P$#-&@ÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ,F?(IDFÿ,M(PM#JÿMA?&%&--ÿE(++&E,ACA,JKÿA+E%I@A+Dÿ-#)&,JKÿ-&EI?A,JKÿE(+C&+A&+E&K
`N#A+,&+#+E&ÿ#+@ÿ@#,#ÿ-&?CAE&-Kÿ?&N(,&ÿC&FAE%&-ÿ@A#D+(-,AE-Kÿ#+@ÿ-,(%&+ÿ(?ÿB#?O&@ÿC&FAE%&ÿ%(E#,(?ÿ-&?CAE&-GÿÿHI?ÿE(++&E,&@ÿC&FAE%&
`$I-A+&--ÿB?(CA@&-ÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ,(ÿ-&C&?#%ÿ#I,(N#O&?-KÿA+E%I@A+DÿQEI?#KÿQI@AKÿRA#,ÿ*F?J-%&?KÿS(+@#KÿSJI+@#AKÿT#DI#?ÿU#+@ÿV(C&?KÿWA--#+K
`XI$#?Iÿ#+@ÿ"(J(,#G
`XI$-E?A$&?-ÿ,(ÿ(I?ÿE(++&E,&@ÿC&FAE%&ÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ#?&ÿ+(,ÿA+E%I@&@ÿA+ÿ(I?ÿ-I$-E?A$&?ÿE(I+,ÿ(?ÿ-I$-E?A$&?P$#-&@ÿ(B&?#,A+DÿN&,?AE-G
`.Y0Y4Y>&ÿ(M+ÿ#BB?(LAN#,&%JÿZ[\ÿ()ÿ,F&ÿ&]IA,Jÿ()ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#ÿS(%@A+D-ÿ`+EGÿabXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#cdKÿ,F&ÿ-#,&%%A,&ÿ?#@A(ÿB?(CA@&?
`A+ÿ*#+#@#GÿÿXI$-E?A$&?-ÿ,(ÿ,F&ÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ())&?&@ÿ$JÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#ÿ#?&ÿ+(,ÿA+E%I@&@ÿA+ÿ(I?ÿ-I$-E?A$&?ÿE(I+,ÿ(?ÿ-I$-E?A$&?P$#-&@
`(B&?#,A+DÿN&,?AE-G
`H+ÿ_#JÿefKÿfgehKÿ(I?ÿ-I$-A@A#?JKÿXA?AI-ÿ^_Kÿ&+,&?&@ÿA+,(ÿ#+ÿ#??#+D&N&+,ÿ#D?&&N&+,ÿa,F&ÿbQ??#+D&N&+,ÿQD?&&N&+,cdÿMA,F
`XA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#GÿiI?-I#+,ÿ,(ÿ,F&ÿQ??#+D&N&+,ÿQD?&&N&+,KÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ#+@ÿE&?,#A+ÿ*#+#@A#+ÿ-F#?&F(%@&?-ÿMA%%ÿ)(?Nÿ#ÿ+&MÿE(NB#+J
`,(ÿ#E]IA?&ÿ-F#?&-ÿ()ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#ÿ+(,ÿ#%?&#@Jÿ(M+&@ÿ$Jÿ,F&NÿBI?-I#+,ÿ,(ÿ#ÿB%#+ÿ()ÿ#??#+D&N&+,ÿa,F&ÿb"?#+-#E,A(+cdGÿ`+ÿE(++&E,A(+
`MA,Fÿ,F&ÿ"?#+-#E,A(+KÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#j-ÿ-F#?&F(%@&?-ÿMA%%ÿ$&ÿ&+,A,%&@ÿ,(ÿ&%&E,ÿ,(ÿ?&E&AC&Kÿ)(?ÿ&#EFÿ-F#?&ÿ()ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#ÿF&%@K
`*klGmgÿanGXGÿkZGmgÿ#-ÿ()ÿ_#JÿefKÿfgehdÿA+ÿaAdÿE#-FKÿaAAdÿ-F#?&-ÿ()ÿ(I?ÿE(NN(+ÿ-,(EOKÿaAAAdÿ#ÿ-&EI?A,Jÿ&LEF#+D&#$%&ÿ)(?ÿ-F#?&-ÿ()ÿ(I?
`E(NN(+ÿ-,(EOKÿ(?ÿaACdÿ#ÿE(N$A+#,A(+ÿ,F&?&()oÿB?(CA@&@ÿ,F#,ÿ+(ÿN(?&ÿ,F#+ÿmg\ÿ()ÿ,F&ÿ,(,#%ÿE(+-A@&?#,A(+ÿA+ÿ,F&ÿ"?#+-#E,A(+ÿa(?ÿIBÿ,(ÿZm
`NA%%A(+ÿ-F#?&-dÿMA%%ÿ$&ÿA--I&@ÿA+ÿ(I?ÿE(NN(+ÿ-,(EOÿ#+@ÿ&LEF#+D&#$%&ÿ-F#?&-GÿQ%%ÿ()ÿ,F&ÿ($%AD#,A(+-ÿ()ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿI+@&?ÿ,F&
`Q??#+D&N&+,ÿQD?&&N&+,ÿ#?&ÿDI#?#+,&&@ÿ$JÿS(%@A+D-G
`R(%%(MA+Dÿ,F&ÿ"?#+-#E,A(+KÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿA-ÿ&LB&E,&@ÿ,(ÿF(%@ÿ#ÿ[g\ÿ&E(+(NAEÿA+,&?&-,ÿ#+@ÿZZ\ÿC(,A+DÿA+,&?&-,ÿA+ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_
`*#+#@#KÿMA,Fÿ,F&ÿ?&N#A+@&?ÿ()ÿ,F&ÿC(,A+DÿB(M&?ÿ#+@ÿ&E(+(NAEÿA+,&?&-,ÿF&%@ÿ$JÿX%#ADF,ÿ*(NNI+AE#,A(+-ÿ#+@ÿH$&%J-Oÿ_&@A#Kÿ,M(ÿ()
`XA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#j-ÿEI??&+,ÿ*#+#@A#+ÿ-F#?&F(%@&?-GÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ&LB&E,-ÿ,(ÿE(+,?A$I,&ÿ,(ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#ÿ#BB?(LAN#,&%JÿnGXGÿkf[m
`NA%%A(+ÿA+ÿE(++&E,A(+ÿMA,Fÿ,F&ÿ"?#+-#E,A(+ÿa#--INA+Dÿ,F#,ÿ#%%ÿ-F#?&F(%@&?-ÿ&%&E,ÿ,(ÿ?&E&AC&ÿE#-FÿA+ÿE(++&E,A(+ÿMA,Fÿ,F&ÿ"?#+-#E,A(+dK
`MFAEFÿ#N(I+,ÿA-ÿ&LB&E,&@ÿ,(ÿ$&ÿI-&@ÿ,(ÿB#Jÿ,F&ÿE#-FÿE(+-A@&?#,A(+ÿ,(ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#j-ÿ-F#?&F(%@&?-ÿ#+@ÿMA%%ÿ$&ÿ@&E?&#-&@
`B?(B(?,A(+#,&%JÿA)ÿ-F#?&F(%@&?-ÿ&%&E,ÿ,(ÿ?&E&AC&ÿE(+-A@&?#,A(+ÿA+ÿ-F#?&-ÿ()ÿ(I?ÿE(NN(+ÿ-,(EOÿ(?ÿ-&EI?A,A&-ÿ&LEF#+D&#$%&ÿ)(?ÿ(I?
`E(NN(+ÿ-,(EOG
`"F&ÿ"?#+-#E,A(+ÿF#-ÿ$&&+ÿ#BB?(C&@ÿ$Jÿ,F&ÿ-,(EOF(%@&?-ÿ()ÿXA?AI-ÿ^_ÿ*#+#@#ÿ#+@ÿF#-ÿ?&E&AC&@ÿ,F&ÿ?&]IA?&@ÿE(I?,ÿ#BB?(C#%Gÿ"F&
`"?#+-#E,A(+ÿ?&N#A+-ÿ-I$p&E,ÿ,(ÿ?&E&AB,ÿ()ÿ*#+#@A#+ÿV#@A(P"&%&CA-A(+ÿ#+@ÿ"&%&E(NNI+AE#,A(+-ÿ*(NNA--A(+ÿ#BB?(C#%Gÿi&+@A+Dÿ?&E&AB,
`()ÿ,FA-ÿ#BB?(C#%Kÿ,F&ÿ"?#+-#E,A(+ÿA-ÿ&LB&E,&@ÿ,(ÿE%(-&ÿ&#?%JÿA+ÿ,F&ÿ,F&ÿ-&E(+@ÿ]I#?,&?ÿ()ÿfge[G
`q371;ÿ:1;<821=
`rsttuvwxyzÿ|wws}~€ÿÿHI?ÿB?(D?#NNA+DÿA-ÿ#C#A%#$%&ÿ)(?ÿE(NN&?EA#%ÿ&-,#$%A-FN&+,-Gÿÿ*(NN&?EA#%ÿ-I$-E?AB,A(+ÿ#EE(I+,-ÿ#?&
`#C#A%#$%&ÿ,F?(IDFÿB?(CA@&?-ÿ()ÿA+P-,(?&ÿ&+,&?,#A+N&+,ÿ-(%I,A(+-ÿ#+@ÿ@A?&E,%Jÿ)?(NÿI-Gÿ*&?,#A+ÿE(NN&?EA#%ÿ-I$-E?A$&?-ÿ#?&ÿA+E%I@&@ÿA+ÿ(I?
`-I$-E?A$&?ÿE(I+,G
`‚yuzzxuÿƒuzu„x€xs~ÿ‚uv„xwuÿÿ*&?,#A+ÿ()ÿ(I?ÿNI-AEÿEF#++&%-ÿ#?&ÿ())&?&@ÿ#-ÿB#?,ÿ()ÿE&?,#A+ÿB?(D?#NNA+DÿB#EO#D&-ÿ(+ÿ,F&ÿ…`XS
`W&,M(?Oÿ-#,&%%A,&ÿ,&%&CA-A(+ÿ-&?CAE&GÿÿXI$-E?A$&?-ÿ,(ÿ,F&ÿ…`XSÿW&,M(?Oÿ-#,&%%A,&ÿ,&%&CA-A(+ÿ-&?CAE&ÿ#?&ÿ+(,ÿA+E%I@&@ÿA+ÿ(I?ÿ-I$-E?A$&?
`E(I+,GXI$-E?A$&?-ÿ,(ÿ,F&ÿ)(%%(MA+Dÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ#?&ÿ+(,ÿA+E%I@&@ÿA+ÿ(I?ÿ-I$-E?A$&?ÿE(I+,KÿI+%&--ÿ,F&ÿ#BB%AE#$%&ÿ-&?CAE&ÿA-ÿBI?EF#-&@ÿ$Jÿ,F&
`-I$-E?A$&?ÿ-&B#?#,&%Jÿ#+@ÿ+(,ÿ#-ÿB#?,ÿ()ÿ#ÿ?#@A(ÿ-I$-E?AB,A(+ÿ,(ÿ(I?ÿ-&?CAE&-†
`ƒvy„uzÿ‡x~ˆÿÿ>&ÿ())&?ÿ"?#C&%ÿUA+OKÿ#ÿ-IA,&ÿ()ÿ@#,#ÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ,F#,ÿA+E%I@&-ÿD?#BFAE#%ÿM&#,F&?Kÿ)I&%ÿB?AE&-Kÿ-B(?,-ÿ-EF&@I%&-ÿ#+@
`-E(?&-ÿ#+@ÿN(CA&ÿ%A-,A+D-G
`‰uyzŠƒxtuÿƒvy‹‹xwÿ‚uv„xwu€ÿÿ>&ÿ())&?ÿ-&?CAE&-ÿ,F#,ÿB?(CA@&ÿD?#BFAEÿA+)(?N#,A(+ÿ#-ÿ,(ÿ?(#@ÿE%(-A+D-Kÿ,?#))AEÿ)%(Mÿ#+@ÿA+EA@&+,ÿ@#,#
`,(ÿE(+-IN&?-ÿMA,FÿE(NB#,A$%&ÿA+PC&FAE%&ÿ+#CAD#,A(+ÿ-J-,&N-G
`ÿ
`m
`             !
`
`
` 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-6
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`"#$%&ÿ()ÿ*(+,&+,-
`
`

`   
`ÿ./012345/ÿ7/089/:ÿ;/:<4=/>?ÿÿ@&ÿ())&Aÿ-&B&A#%ÿA&#%C,DE&ÿF&#,G&Aÿ-&ABDH&-ÿI&-DJ+&Iÿ)(AÿDEKA(BD+Jÿ-D,L#,D(+#%ÿ#F#A&+&--ÿD+
`B&GDH%&MÿE#AD+&ÿ#+IN(Aÿ#BD#,D(+ÿL-&O
`PQRSTUVUVQW
`XYZ[\\]Z[ÿ_Y`]a
`@&ÿ)#H&ÿ-DJ+D)DH#+,ÿH(EK&,D,D(+ÿ)(Aÿ$(,Gÿ%D-,&+&A-ÿ#+Iÿ#IB&A,D-&A-ÿD+ÿ(LAÿ-#,&%%D,&ÿA#ID(ÿ$L-D+&--MÿD+H%LID+Jÿ)A(EÿKA(BDI&A-ÿ()
`A#ID(ÿ(Aÿ(,G&Aÿ#LID(ÿ-&ABDH&-OÿÿbLAÿIDJD,#%ÿH(EK&,D,(A-ÿ#A&ÿE#cD+JÿD+CA(#I-ÿD+,(ÿB&GDH%&-MÿFG&A&ÿF&ÿ#A&ÿHLAA&+,%dÿ,G&ÿ%&#ID+Jÿ#%,&A+#,DB&
`,(ÿ,A#ID,D(+#%ÿefNgfÿA#ID(O
`3:0h484ij01ÿklmnlÿ.0h4i?ÿÿbLAÿ-&ABDH&-ÿH(EK&,&ÿFD,Gÿ,A#ID,D(+#%ÿefNgfÿA#ID(Oÿÿo&B&A#%ÿ,A#ID,D(+#%ÿA#ID(ÿH(EK#+D&-ÿ#A&
`-L$-,#+,D#%ÿ&+,D,D&-ÿ(F+D+Jÿ%#AJ&ÿ+LE$&A-ÿ()ÿA#ID(ÿ-,#,D(+-ÿ(Aÿ(,G&AÿE&ID#ÿKA(K&A,D&-Oÿÿ"G&ÿA#ID(ÿ$A(#IH#-,D+JÿD+IL-,AdÿD-ÿGDJG%d
`H(EK&,D,DB&Oÿÿ"A#ID,D(+#%ÿefNgfÿ$A(#IH#-,&A-ÿ#A&ÿ#%-(ÿ#JJA&--DB&%dÿKLA-LD+Jÿp+,&A+&,ÿA#ID(MÿFDA&%&--ÿp+,&A+&,C$#-&IÿID-,AD$L,D(+
`#AA#+J&E&+,-ÿ#+IÿI#,#ÿ-&ABDH&-O
`"A#ID,D(+#%ÿefNgfÿA#ID(ÿG#-ÿ#ÿF&%%C&-,#$%D-G&IÿI&E#+Iÿ)(AÿD,-ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿ#+Iÿ())&A-ÿ)A&&ÿ$A(#IH#-,-ÿK#DIÿ)(Aÿ$dÿH(EE&AHD#%
`#IB&A,D-D+JÿA#,G&Aÿ,G#+ÿ$dÿ-L$-HADK,D(+ÿ)&&-Oÿÿf#+dÿA#ID(ÿ-,#,D(+-ÿ())&AÿD+)(AE#,D(+ÿKA(JA#EED+Jÿ()ÿ#ÿ%(H#%ÿ+#,LA&Mÿ-LHGÿ#-ÿ%(H#%ÿ+&F-
`#+Iÿ-K(A,-Oÿÿ"G&ÿ#B#D%#$D%D,dÿ()ÿ,A#ID,D(+#%ÿ)A&&ÿefNgfÿA#ID(ÿA&ILH&-ÿ,G&ÿ%Dc&%DG((Iÿ,G#,ÿHL-,(E&A-ÿF(L%Iÿ$&ÿFD%%D+Jÿ,(ÿK#dÿ)(Aÿ(LA
`-L$-HADK,D(+ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿ#+IMÿ$dÿ())&AD+Jÿ)A&&ÿ$A(#IH#-,-MÿD,ÿE#dÿDEK(-&ÿ%DED,-ÿ(+ÿFG#,ÿF&ÿH#+ÿHG#AJ&ÿ)(Aÿ(LAÿ-&ABDH&-O
`qj8/:j/82r0>/hÿsi5t/848i:>?ÿÿp+,&A+&,ÿA#ID(ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿ(),&+ÿG#B&ÿ+(ÿJ&(JA#KGDHÿ%DED,#,D(+-ÿ#+IÿKA(BDI&ÿ%D-,&+&A-ÿFD,GÿA#ID(
`KA(JA#EED+Jÿ)A(Eÿ#HA(--ÿ,G&ÿH(L+,Adÿ#+Iÿ#A(L+Iÿ,G&ÿF(A%IOÿÿf#u(Aÿ(+%D+&ÿKA(BDI&A-MÿD+H%LID+JÿeE#v(+MÿeKK%&Mÿw((J%&ÿx%#dMÿx#+I(A#M
`oK(,D)dÿ#+IÿDy&#A,z#ID(MÿE#c&ÿGDJGÿ)DI&%D,dÿIDJD,#%ÿ-,A&#E-ÿ#B#D%#$%&ÿ,GA(LJGÿ,G&ÿp+,&A+&,ÿ)(Aÿ)A&&ÿ(AMÿD+ÿ-(E&ÿH#-&-Mÿ)(Aÿ%&--ÿ,G#+ÿ,G&
`H(-,ÿ()ÿ#ÿ-#,&%%D,&ÿA#ID(ÿ-L$-HADK,D(+Oÿÿ*&A,#D+ÿ()ÿ,G&-&ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿD+H%LI&ÿ#IB#+H&Iÿ)L+H,D(+#%D,dMÿ-LHGÿ#-ÿK&A-(+#%Dv#,D(+Mÿ#+Iÿ#%%(Fÿ,G&
`L-&Aÿ,(ÿ#HH&--ÿ%#AJ&ÿ%D$A#AD&-ÿ()ÿH(+,&+,Oÿÿ"G&-&ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿH(EK&,&ÿIDA&H,%dÿFD,Gÿ(LAÿ-&ABDH&-Mÿ#,ÿG(E&MÿD+ÿB&GDH%&-Mÿ#+IÿFG&A&B&Aÿ#LID(
`&+,&A,#D+E&+,ÿD-ÿH(+-LE&IO
`kh<0j=/hÿqj2{0>9ÿqj|i804j5/j8ÿ;}>8/5>?ÿÿ~&#A%dÿ#%%ÿ#L,(E#c&A-ÿG#B&ÿI&K%(d&Iÿ(Aÿ#A&ÿK%#++D+Jÿ,(ÿI&K%(dÿD+,&JA#,&IÿEL%,DE&ID#
`-d-,&E-ÿD+ÿI#-G$(#AI-MÿD+H%LID+JÿD+ÿE#+dÿH#-&-ÿeKK%&ÿ*#Ax%#dÿ#+Iÿe+IA(DIÿeL,(ÿ#+IÿKA(ILH,-ÿ)A(EÿeKK%&ÿ#+Iÿw((J%&Oÿÿ"G&-&
`-d-,&E-ÿH(E$D+&ÿH(+,A(%ÿ()ÿ#LID(ÿ&+,&A,#D+E&+,ÿ)A(Eÿ#ÿB#AD&,dÿ()ÿ-(LAH&-MÿD+H%LID+JÿefNgfNyÿA#ID(ÿ$A(#IH#-,-Mÿ-#,&%%D,&ÿA#ID(M
`p+,&A+&,ÿA#ID(Mÿ-E#A,KG(+&ÿ#KK%DH#,D(+-ÿ#+Iÿ-,(A&Iÿ#LID(MÿFD,Gÿ+#BDJ#,D(+ÿ#+Iÿ(,G&Aÿ#IB#+H&Iÿ#KK%DH#,D(+-ÿ-LHGÿ#-ÿA&-,#LA#+,ÿ$((cD+J-M
`E(BD&ÿ-G(Fÿ,DE&-ÿ#+Iÿ)D+#+HD#%ÿD+)(AE#,D(+Oÿÿp+,&A+&,ÿA#ID(ÿ#+Iÿ(,G&AÿI#,#ÿ#A&ÿ,dKDH#%%dÿH(++&H,&Iÿ,(ÿ,G&ÿ-d-,&Eÿ,GA(LJGÿ#+ÿp+,&A+&,C
`&+#$%&Iÿ-E#A,KG(+&ÿ(AÿFDA&%&--ÿE(I&EÿD+-,#%%&IÿD+ÿ,G&ÿB&GDH%&Mÿ#+Iÿ,G&ÿ&+,DA&ÿ-d-,&EÿE#dÿ$&ÿH(+,A(%%&Iÿ$dÿ,(LHG-HA&&+ÿ(AÿB(DH&
`A&H(J+D,D(+Oÿÿ"G&-&ÿ-d-,&E-ÿ&+G#+H&ÿ,G&ÿ#,,A#H,DB&+&--ÿ()ÿp+,&A+&,C$#-&IÿH(EK&,D,(A-ÿ$dÿE#cD+Jÿ-LHGÿ#KK%DH#,D(+-ÿE(A&ÿKA(ED+&+,M
`&#-D&Aÿ,(ÿ#HH&--Mÿ#+Iÿ-#)&Aÿ,(ÿL-&ÿD+ÿ,G&ÿH#AO
`{4:/=8ÿr:i0h=0>8ÿ;08/1148/ÿ0jhÿs0€1/ÿkh4i?ÿÿeÿ+LE$&Aÿ()ÿKA(BDI&A-ÿ())&Aÿ-K&HD#%Dv&Iÿ#LID(ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿ,GA(LJGÿ&D,G&AÿIDA&H,
`$A(#IH#-,ÿ-#,&%%D,&ÿ(AÿH#$%&ÿ#LID(ÿ-d-,&E-Oÿÿ"G&-&ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿ#A&ÿ,#AJ&,&Iÿ,(ÿ)D‚&Iÿ%(H#,D(+-MÿE(-,%dÿD+CG(E&Oÿÿ"G&ÿA#ID(ÿ-&ABDH&ÿ())&A&Iÿ$d
`IDA&H,ÿ$A(#IH#-,ÿ-#,&%%D,&ÿ#+IÿH#$%&ÿ#LID(ÿD-ÿ(),&+ÿD+H%LI&Iÿ#-ÿK#A,ÿ()ÿ#ÿK#Hc#J&ÿ()ÿIDJD,#%ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿFD,GÿBDI&(ÿ-&ABDH&Mÿ#+IÿBDI&(
`HL-,(E&A-ÿJ&+&A#%%dÿI(ÿ+(,ÿK#dÿ#+ÿ#IID,D(+#%ÿE(+,G%dÿHG#AJ&ÿ)(Aÿ,G&ÿ#LID(ÿ-&ABDH&O
`ƒ89/:ÿ{4„4801ÿl/h40ÿ;/:<4=/>?ÿÿ"G&ÿ#LID(ÿ&+,&A,#D+E&+,ÿE#Ac&,K%#H&ÿH(+,D+L&-ÿ,(ÿ&B(%B&ÿA#KDI%dMÿFD,Gÿ#ÿ-,&#Idÿ&E&AJ&+H&ÿ()
`+&FÿE&ID#ÿK%#,)(AE-ÿ,G#,ÿH(EK&,&ÿFD,Gÿ(LAÿ-&ABDH&-ÿ+(Fÿ(Aÿ,G#,ÿH(L%IÿH(EK&,&ÿFD,Gÿ,G(-&ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿD+ÿ,G&ÿ)L,LA&O
`…†Y‡‡]ˆÿX[†‰]ˆ[Š
`
`eÿ+LE$&Aÿ()ÿKA(BDI&A-ÿH(EK&,&ÿFD,Gÿ(LAÿ,A#))DHÿ-&ABDH&-Oÿÿp+CI#-Gÿ+#BDJ#,D(+ÿD-ÿ,GA&#,&+&Iÿ$dÿ-E#A,KG(+&-ÿ,G#,ÿKA(BDI&ÿI#,#
`-&ABDH&-ÿ,GA(LJGÿ#ÿIDA&H,ÿB&GDH%&ÿD+,&A)#H&Oÿÿf(-,ÿ()ÿ,G&-&ÿ-E#A,KG(+&-ÿ())&AÿwxoÿE#KKD+JÿFD,Gÿ-(KGD-,DH#,&IÿI#,#C$#-&Iÿ,LA+C$dC,LA+
`+#BDJ#,D(+O‹aŒŒ[ˆZ[`ÿ[Ž]ˆ\[ÿX[†‰]ˆ[Š
`bLAÿH(++&H,&IÿB&GDH%&ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿ$L-D+&--ÿ(K&A#,&-ÿD+ÿ#ÿGDJG%dÿH(EK&,D,DB&ÿ&+BDA(+E&+,ÿ#+IÿH(EK&,&-ÿFD,Gÿ-&B&A#%ÿKA(BDI&A-M
`D+H%LID+Jÿ&ADv(+ÿ"&%&E#,DH-Oÿÿb+o,#AMÿ#ÿIDBD-D(+ÿ()ÿw&+&A#%ÿf(,(A-Mÿ#%-(ÿ())&A-ÿH(++&H,&IÿB&GDH%&ÿ-&ABDH&-ÿD+ÿwfÿB&GDH%&-Oÿÿ@&ÿ#%-(
`H(EK&,&ÿFD,GÿFDA&%&--ÿI&BDH&-ÿ-LHGÿ#-ÿE($D%&ÿKG(+&-ÿ#+IMÿ,(ÿ#ÿ%&--&Aÿ&‚,&+,MÿFD,Gÿ-d-,&E-ÿI&B&%(K&IÿD+,&A+#%%dÿ$dÿ#L,(E#c&A-Oÿÿ@&
`H(EK&,&ÿ#J#D+-,ÿ(,G&AÿH(++&H,&IÿB&GDH%&ÿ-&ABDH&ÿKA(BDI&A-ÿ)(Aÿ#L,(E#c&Aÿ#AA#+J&E&+,-ÿ(+ÿ,G&
`ÿ
`
`             !
`
`
` 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-7
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`"#$%&ÿ()ÿ*(+,&+,-
`
`

`   
`ÿ$#-.-ÿ()ÿ.++(/#,.(+0ÿ-&1/.2&ÿ34#%.,5ÿ#+6ÿ1&%.#$.%.,50ÿ,&27+.2#%ÿ2#8#$.%.,.&-ÿ#+6ÿ-5-,&9-ÿ24-,(9.:#,.(+0ÿ-2(8&ÿ()ÿ-&1/.2&0ÿ.+64-,15
`&;8&1.&+2&0ÿ8#-,ÿ8&1)(19#+2&ÿ#+6ÿ81.2&<
`=>?@ABC@BDÿF@GHIJDK>B
`L-ÿ(8&1#,(1-ÿ()ÿ#ÿ81./#,&%5M(N+&6ÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ-5-,&90ÿN&ÿ#1&ÿ1&O4%#,&6ÿ$5ÿ,7&ÿP**ÿ4+6&1ÿ,7&ÿ*(994+.2#,.(+-ÿL2,ÿ()ÿQRST0
`81.+2.8#%%5ÿN.,7ÿ1&-8&2,ÿ,(U
`V,7&ÿ%.2&+-.+Oÿ()ÿ(41ÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ-5-,&9-W
`V81&/&+,.+Oÿ.+,&1)&1&+2&ÿN.,7ÿ(1ÿ,(ÿ(,7&1ÿ4-&1-ÿ()ÿ1#6.(ÿ)1&34&+2.&-Wÿ#+6
`V2(98%.#+2&ÿN.,7ÿP**ÿ14%&-ÿ&-,#$%.-7&6ÿ-8&2.).2#%%5ÿ)(1ÿX<Y<ÿ-#,&%%.,&-ÿ#+6ÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ1#6.(ÿ-&1/.2&-<
`L+5ÿ#--.O+9&+,ÿ(1ÿ,1#+-)&1ÿ()ÿ2(+,1(%ÿ()ÿ(41ÿP**ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ94-,ÿ$&ÿ#881(/&6ÿ$5ÿ,7&ÿP**<ÿÿ"7&ÿP**Z-ÿ(16&1ÿ#881(/.+Oÿ,7&
`9&1O&1ÿ()ÿ(41ÿN7(%%5M(N+&6ÿ-4$-.6.#150ÿ[&1+(+ÿ\&1O&1ÿ*(18(1#,.(+0ÿN.,7ÿ#+6ÿ.+,(ÿ]\ÿY#,&%%.,&ÿ^#6.(ÿ_(%6.+O-ÿ`+2<ÿ.+ÿa4%5ÿbccdÿe,7&
`f\&1O&1ghÿ1&34.1&-ÿ4-ÿ,(ÿ2(98%5ÿN.,7ÿ2&1,#.+ÿ/(%4+,#15ÿ2(99.,9&+,-ÿN&ÿ9#6&ÿ#-ÿ8#1,ÿ()ÿ,7&ÿP**ÿ\&1O&1ÿ81(2&&6.+O<ÿÿi&ÿ$&%.&/&ÿN&
`2(98%5ÿN.,7ÿ,7(-&ÿ2(99.,9&+,-<
``+ÿQRRj0ÿN&ÿN&1&ÿ,7&ÿN.++.+Oÿ$.66&1-ÿ)(1ÿP**ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ,(ÿ(8&1#,&ÿ#ÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ6.O.,#%ÿ#46.(ÿ1#6.(ÿ-&1/.2&ÿ#+6ÿ81(/.6&ÿ(,7&1
`#+2.%%#15ÿ-&1/.2&-<ÿÿk41ÿP**ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ)(1ÿ(41ÿY.1.4-ÿ-#,&%%.,&-ÿ&;8.1&ÿ.+ÿbcbbÿ#+6ÿbcbl<ÿÿk41ÿP**ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ)(1ÿ(41ÿ]\ÿ-#,&%%.,&-ÿ&;8.1&
`.+ÿbcQd0ÿbcbQÿ#+6ÿbcbb<ÿÿi&ÿ#+,.2.8#,&ÿ,7#,0ÿ#$-&+,ÿ-.O+.).2#+,ÿ9.-2(+642,ÿ(+ÿ(41ÿ8#1,0ÿ,7&ÿP**ÿN.%%ÿ1&+&Nÿ(41ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ,(ÿ8&19.,
`(8&1#,.(+ÿ()ÿ(41ÿ-#,&%%.,&-ÿ)(1ÿ,7&.1ÿ4-&)4%ÿ%./&-0ÿ#+6ÿO1#+,ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ)(1ÿ#+5ÿ1&8%#2&9&+,ÿ-#,&%%.,&-<
``+ÿ-(9&ÿ#1&#-0ÿN&ÿ7#/&ÿ.+-,#%%&6ÿ,&11&-,1.#%ÿ1&8&#,&1-ÿ,(ÿ-488%&9&+,ÿ(41ÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ-.O+#%ÿ2(/&1#O&<ÿÿ"7&ÿP**ÿ7#-ÿ&-,#$%.-7&6ÿ14%&-
`O(/&1+.+Oÿ,&11&-,1.#%ÿ1&8&#,&1-ÿ#+6ÿ7#-ÿO1#+,&6ÿ4-ÿ#ÿ%.2&+-&ÿ,71(4O7ÿbcbjÿ,(ÿ(8&1#,&ÿ(41ÿ1&8&#,&1ÿ+&,N(1m<
``+ÿ2&1,#.+ÿ2#-&-0ÿN&ÿ($,#.+ÿP**ÿ2&1,.).2#,.(+-ÿ)(1ÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ1#6.(-0ÿ.+2%46.+Oÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ1#6.(-ÿ,7#,ÿ.+2%46&ÿP\ÿ9(64%#,(1-<ÿÿi&
`$&%.&/&ÿ(41ÿ1#6.(-ÿ,7#,ÿ#1&ÿ.+ÿ81(642,.(+ÿ2(98%5ÿN.,7ÿ#%%ÿ#88%.2#$%&ÿP**ÿ14%&-<
`i&ÿ#1&ÿ1&34.1&6ÿ,(ÿ($,#.+ÿ&;8(1,ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ(1ÿ(,7&1ÿ#881(/#%-ÿ)1(9ÿ,7&ÿX+.,&6ÿY,#,&-ÿO(/&1+9&+,ÿ,(ÿ&;8(1,ÿ2&1,#.+ÿ&34.89&+,0
`-&1/.2&-ÿ#+6ÿ,&27+.2#%ÿ6#,#ÿ1&%#,&6ÿ,(ÿ(41ÿ-#,&%%.,&-ÿ#+6ÿ,7&.1ÿ(8&1#,.(+-<ÿÿ"7&ÿ,1#+-)&1ÿ()ÿ-427ÿ&34.89&+,0ÿ-&1/.2&-ÿ#+6ÿ,&27+.2#%ÿ6#,#
`(4,-.6&ÿ,7&ÿX+.,&6ÿY,#,&-ÿ(1ÿ,(ÿ)(1&.O+ÿ8&1-(+-ÿ.-ÿ-4$n&2,ÿ,(ÿ-,1.2,ÿ&;8(1,ÿ2(+,1(%ÿ#+6ÿ81.(1ÿ#881(/#%ÿ1&34.1&9&+,-ÿ)1(9ÿ,7&ÿX+.,&6ÿY,#,&-
`O(/&1+9&+,ÿe.+2%46.+Oÿ81(7.$.,.(+-ÿ(+ÿ,7&ÿ-7#1.+Oÿ()ÿ2&1,#.+ÿ-#,&%%.,&M1&%#,&6ÿO((6-ÿ#+6ÿ-&1/.2&-ÿN.,7ÿ*7.+#h<
`*7#+O&-ÿ.+ÿ%#Nÿ(1ÿ1&O4%#,.(+-ÿ1&%#,.+Oÿ,(ÿ2(994+.2#,.(+-ÿ8(%.25ÿ(1ÿ,(ÿ9#,,&1-ÿ#))&2,.+Oÿ(41ÿ-&1/.2&-ÿ2(4%6ÿ#6/&1-&%5ÿ#))&2,ÿ(41
`#$.%.,5ÿ,(ÿ1&,#.+ÿ(41ÿP**ÿ%.2&+-&-ÿ(1ÿ,7&ÿ9#++&1ÿ.+ÿN7.27ÿN&ÿ(8&1#,&<
`o>pqAKGrDsÿD>ÿtA>GAJCCKBG
``+ÿ2(++&2,.(+ÿN.,7ÿ(41ÿ-#,&%%.,&ÿ1#6.(ÿ94-.2ÿ81(O1#99.+O0ÿN&ÿ94-,ÿ+&O(,.#,&ÿ#+6ÿ&+,&1ÿ.+,(ÿ1(5#%,5ÿ#11#+O&9&+,-ÿN.,7ÿ,N(ÿ-&,-
`()ÿ1.O7,-ÿ7(%6&1-Uÿÿ_(%6&1-ÿ()ÿ2(851.O7,-ÿ.+ÿ94-.2#%ÿN(1m-ÿe,7#,ÿ.-0ÿ,7&ÿ94-.2ÿ#+6ÿ%51.2-hÿ#+6ÿ7(%6&1-ÿ()ÿ2(851.O7,-ÿ.+ÿ-(4+6ÿ1&2(16.+O-
`e,7#,ÿ.-0ÿ,7&ÿ#2,4#%ÿ1&2(16.+Oÿ()ÿ#ÿN(1mh<
`\4-.2#%ÿN(1m-ÿ1.O7,-ÿ7(%6&1-0ÿO&+&1#%%5ÿ-(+ON1.,&1-ÿ#+6ÿ94-.2ÿ84$%.-7&1-0ÿ7#/&ÿ$&&+ÿ,1#6.,.(+#%%5ÿ1&81&-&+,&6ÿ$5ÿ8&1)(19.+O
`1.O7,-ÿ(1O#+.:#,.(+-ÿ-427ÿ#-ÿ,7&ÿL9&1.2#+ÿY(2.&,5ÿ()ÿ*(98(-&1-0ÿL4,7(1-ÿ#+6ÿu4$%.-7&1-ÿefLY*Lugh0ÿv1(#62#-,ÿ\4-.20ÿ`+2<ÿefv\`gh
`#+6ÿYwYL*0ÿ`+2<ÿefYwYL*gh<ÿÿ"7&ÿ9#1m&,ÿ)(1ÿ1.O7,-ÿ1&%#,.+Oÿ,(ÿ94-.2#%ÿN(1m-ÿ.-ÿ27#+O.+Oÿ1#8.6%5<ÿY(+ON1.,&1-ÿ#+6ÿ94-.2ÿ84$%.-7&1-
`7#/&ÿN.,761#N+ÿ)1(9ÿ,7&ÿ,1#6.,.(+#%ÿ8&1)(19.+Oÿ1.O7,-ÿ(1O#+.:#,.(+-0ÿ8#1,.24%#1%5ÿLY*Luÿ#+6ÿv\`0ÿ#+6ÿ+&Nÿ&+,.,.&-0ÿ-427ÿ#-ÿx%($#%
`\4-.2ÿ^.O7,-ÿyy*ÿefx\^gh0ÿ7#/&ÿ$&&+ÿ)(19&6ÿ,(ÿ1&81&-&+,ÿ1.O7,-ÿ7(%6&1-<ÿ"7&-&ÿ(1O#+.:#,.(+-ÿ+&O(,.#,&ÿ)&&-ÿN.,7ÿ2(851.O7,ÿ4-&1-0
`2(%%&2,ÿ1(5#%,.&-ÿ#+6ÿ6.-,1.$4,&ÿ,7&9ÿ,(ÿ,7&ÿ1.O7,-ÿ7(%6&1-<ÿÿi&ÿ7#/&ÿ#11#+O&9&+,-ÿN.,7ÿ#%%ÿ()ÿ,7&-&ÿ(1O#+.:#,.(+-<ÿÿ"7&ÿ27#+O.+Oÿ9#1m&,
`)(1ÿ94-.2#%ÿN(1m-ÿ9#5ÿ7#/&ÿ#+ÿ#6/&1-&ÿ&))&2,ÿ(+ÿ4-0ÿ.+2%46.+Oÿ.+21&#-.+Oÿ(41ÿ2(-,-ÿ(1ÿ%.9.,.+Oÿ,7&ÿ94-.2#%ÿN(1m-ÿ#/#.%#$%&ÿ,(ÿ4-<
`Y(4+6ÿ1&2(16.+Oÿ1.O7,-ÿ7(%6&1-0ÿ,58.2#%%5ÿ%#1O&ÿ1&2(16ÿ2(98#+.&-0ÿ#1&ÿ81.9#1.%5ÿ1&81&-&+,&6ÿ$5ÿY(4+6w;27#+O&0ÿ#+ÿ(1O#+.:#,.(+
`N7.27ÿ+&O(,.#,&-ÿ%.2&+-&-0ÿ#+6ÿ2(%%&2,-ÿ#+6ÿ6.-,1.$4,&-ÿ1(5#%,.&-ÿ(+ÿ$&7#%)ÿ()ÿ1&2(16ÿ2(98#+.&-ÿ#+6ÿ8&1)(19.+Oÿ#1,.-,-<ÿÿX+6&1ÿ,7&
`z.O.,#%ÿu&1)(19#+2&ÿ^.O7,ÿ.+ÿY(4+6ÿ^&2(16.+O-ÿL2,ÿ()ÿQRRlÿ#+6ÿ,7&ÿz.O.,#%ÿ\.%%&++.49ÿ*(851.O7,ÿL2,ÿ()ÿQRRd0ÿN&ÿ9#5ÿ+&O(,.#,&
`1(5#%,5ÿ#11#+O&9&+,-ÿN.,7ÿ,7&ÿ(N+&1-ÿ()ÿ-(4+6ÿ1&2(16.+O-ÿ).;&6ÿ#),&1ÿP&$14#15ÿQl0ÿQRjb0ÿ(1ÿ.)ÿ+&O(,.#,.(+ÿ.-ÿ4+-422&--)4%0ÿ,7&ÿ1(5#%,5
`1#,&ÿ.-ÿ&-,#$%.-7&6ÿ$5ÿ,7&ÿ*(851.O7,ÿ^(5#%,5ÿv(#16ÿe,7&ÿf*^vghÿ()ÿ,7&ÿy.$1#15ÿ()ÿ*(+O1&--<
`ÿ
`j
`             !
`
`
` 
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2013-8
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00689
`
`

`

`"#$%&ÿ()ÿ*(+,&+,-
`
`

`   
`ÿ".&ÿ*/0ÿ.#-ÿ1--2&3ÿ1,-ÿ3&,&451+#,1(+ÿ4&6#431+6ÿ,.&ÿ4(7#%,7ÿ4#,&ÿ8#7#$%&ÿ$7ÿ2-ÿ2+3&4ÿ,.&ÿ-,#,2,(47ÿ%19&+-&ÿ9(:&41+6ÿ,.&
`8&4)(45#+9&ÿ()ÿ-(2+3ÿ4&9(431+6-ÿ)1;&3ÿ#),&4ÿ<&$42#47ÿ=>?ÿ=@ABÿ(:&4ÿ(24ÿ-#,&%%1,&ÿ3161,#%ÿ#231(ÿ4#31(ÿ-&4:19&?ÿ#+3ÿ,.&ÿ5#C1+6ÿ()
`&8.&5&4#%ÿD-&4:&4Eÿ9(81&-ÿ1+ÿ-288(4,ÿ()ÿ-29.ÿ8&4)(45#+9&-?ÿ)(4ÿ,.&ÿ)1:&F7&#4ÿ8&41(3ÿ&+31+6ÿ(+ÿG&9&5$&4ÿH=?ÿBI=AJÿÿK+3&4ÿ,.&ÿ,&45-ÿ()
`,.&ÿ*/0L-ÿ&;1-,1+6ÿ3&91-1(+?ÿM&ÿM1%%ÿ8#7ÿ#ÿ4(7#%,7ÿ$#-&3ÿ(+ÿ64(--ÿ4&:&+2&-?ÿ-2$N&9,ÿ,(ÿ9&4,#1+ÿ&;9%2-1(+-?ÿ()ÿ==Oÿ)(4ÿBI=AJÿÿ".&ÿ4#,&ÿ)(4
`BI=PÿM#-ÿ=IJ>OJÿQÿ84(9&&31+6ÿ1-ÿ2+3&4M#7ÿ$&)(4&ÿ,.&ÿ*/0ÿ,(ÿ3&,&451+&ÿ,.&ÿ4(7#%,7ÿ4#,&ÿ8#7#$%&ÿ$7ÿ2-ÿ2+3&4ÿ,.&ÿ-,#,2,(47ÿ%19&+-&
`9(:&41+6ÿ,.&ÿ8&4)(45#+9&ÿ()ÿ-(2+3ÿ4&9(431+6-ÿ)1;&3ÿ#),&4ÿ<&$42#47ÿ=>?ÿ=@ABÿ(:&4ÿ(24