Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 1 of 17 PageID# 4865
`
`UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
`NEWPORT NEWS DIVISION
`
`FRANCIS W. HOOKER, JR.,
`for himself and on behalf of all
`similarly situated individuals,
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`V.
`
`SIRIUS XM RADIO INC.
`
`Defendant.
`
`Case No.: 4:13-cv-00003 (AWA/LRL)
`
`FINAL ORDER APPROVING SETTLEMENT AND CERTIFYING THE
`SETTLEMENT CLASS
`
`The Settlement Agreement entered into on August 5,2016 (the "Settlement Agreement")
`
`between Plaintiff Francis W. Hooker, Jr. and Defendant Sirius XM Radio Inc. ("Sirius XM") in
`
`this action (the "Action"), as well as between Sirius XM and Plaintiffs Erik Knutson, Yefim
`
`Elikman, and Anthony Parker in the related cases Knutson v. Sirius XM Radio Inc., No. 12-cv-
`
`0418-AJB-DHB (S.D. Gal.) {'"Knutson"); Elikman v. Sirius XM Radio Inc., No. 15-cv-02093
`
`(N.D. 111.) Elikman"); and Parker v. Sirius XM Radio Inc., No. 15-cv-01710-JSM-EAJ (M.D.
`
`Fla.) (^''Parker") (together, the "Litigation"), was presented at the Final Approval Hearing on
`
`December 20, 2016. The Court having determined that notice of the Final Approval Hearing was
`
`given in accordance with the Preliminary Approval Order (Dkt. No. 188) to members of the
`
`Settlement Class and that the notice was adequate,
`
`IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that:
`
`1.
`
`In addition to the terms defined in this order, the Court incorporates the definitions in
`
`the Settlement Agreement for the purposes of this Order.
`
`2. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of the Litigation and over all
`
`members of the Settlement Class.
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-1
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 2 of 17 PageID# 4866
`
`3. Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(b)(3), the Action is finally certified, for settlement
`
`purposes only, as a class action on behalf of the Settlement Class members as defined in Section
`
`2 of the Settlement Agreement.
`
`4. Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 23, Plaintiff Francis W. Hooker, Jr., Erik Knutson, Yefim
`
`Elikman and Anthony Parkerare certified as the ClassRepresentatives, solelyfor the purposes of
`
`effectuating the Settlement, and Michael A. Caddell and Cynthia B. Chapman of Caddell &
`
`Chapman, Christopher Colt North and William L. Downing of The Consumer and Employee
`
`Rights Law Firm, P.C., Abbas Kazerounian of the Kazerouni Law Group, APC, Joshua B.
`
`Swigart of Hyde & Swigart, Myles McGuire of McGuire Law, P.C. and Michael J. McMorrow
`
`of McMorrow Law, P.C. are certified as Class Counsel.
`
`5. The Notice has been disseminated to the Settlement Class in the manner directed in
`
`the Preliminary Approval Order, and a declaration from Settlement Administrator Epiq Systems,
`
`Inc. ("Epiq") attesting to the proof of mailing of the Notice to the Settlement Class has been filed
`
`with the Court (Dkt. No. 191). The Court finds that the Notice fairly and accurately informed
`
`Settlement Class Members of the material aspects of this Litigation and the proposed settlement,
`
`and thereby satisfied the requirements of due process and constituted the best practicable notice
`
`under the circumstances. The Notice apprised Class members of the pendency of the Litigation,
`
`their right to object or exclude themselves from the proposed settlement, and their right to appear
`
`at the Final Approval Hearing, and it conformed with the requirements of Federal Rule of Civil
`
`Procedure 23(c)(2).
`
`6. The notice provisions of the Class Action Fairness Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1715, have been
`
`satisfied. Dkt. No. 187.
`
`7. The Court certifies, solely for purposes of effectuating the Settlement, the Settlement
`
`Class defined as follows:
`
`All natural persons residing in the United States (including all
`territories and other political subdivisions of the United States)
`who (a) received programming on a promotional basis from Sirius
`XM in connection with the purchase or lease of a new or used
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-2
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 3 of 17 PageID# 4867
`
`vehicle that ended no later than April 5, 2016; (b) were the
`recipients of one or more telephone calls made by or on behalf of
`Sirius XM to their wireless, cell or mobile phone numbers after
`February 15, 2008 and before July 5, 2016; and (c) never were or
`became paying subscribers prior to July 5, 2016. Excluded from
`the class definition are any employees, officers, or directors of
`Sirius XM, and any attorneys appearing in this case, and any judge
`assigned to hear this case as well as their immediate family and
`staff
`
`8. Solely for the purposes of the settlement, the Court finds that the prerequisites for a
`
`class action under Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(a) and (b)(3) have been satisfied in that: (i) the Settlement
`
`Class Members are so numerous that joinder of all Settlement Class members is impracticable;
`
`(ii) there are questions of law and fact common to the Settlement Class members; (iii) the claims
`
`of the Class Representatives are typical of the claims of the Settlement Class members; (iv) the
`
`Class Representatives will fairly and adequately represent the interests of the Settlement Class;
`
`(v) the questions of law and fact common to the Settlement Class members predominate over any
`
`questions affecting only individual Settlement Class members; and (vi) certifying the Settlement
`
`Class is superior to other available methods for the fair and efficient adjudication of the
`
`controversy.
`
`9. The Court
`
`finally approves the terms of the Settlement Agreement and the
`
`amendment thereto (together the "Settlement Agreement") and the Settlement described therein
`
`as fair, reasonable, and adequate and in the best interests of the Settlement Class in light of the
`
`complexity, expense, and probable duration of further litigation, the risk and delay inherent in
`
`possible appeals, and the risk of collecting any judgment on behalf of the Class. In arriving at
`
`this conclusion, the Court has considered, among other things:
`
`(1) the posture of the case at the time settlement was proposed,
`
`(2) the extent of discovery that had been conducted,
`
`(3) the circumstances surrounding the negotiations, and
`
`(4) the experience of counsel in the area of consumer class action litigation.
`
`In re
`
`Lube, 921?.2d 155,159(4thCir. 1991.)
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-3
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 4 of 17 PageID# 4868
`
`10. The Court finds that this Action was settled after sufficient discovery.
`
`11. The Court further finds that the Settlement is the product of arm's length negotiations
`
`presided over by a competent mediator.
`
`12.The Court further finds that Class Counsel are experienced in the area of consumer
`
`class action litigation.
`
`13. The Court dismisses with prejudice all released claims belonging to the Class
`
`Representatives and Class Members who did not timely and validly request exclusion from the
`
`Settlement Class. Except as expressly provided in the Settlement Agreement, each of the parties,
`
`including each Settlement Class Member, shall bear his, her, or its own costs and attorney's fees.
`
`14. Pursuant to Paragraph 5 of the Settlement Agreement, upon the Effective Date the
`
`Class Representatives and each of the Settlement Class Members shall be deemed to have, and
`
`by operation of this Judgment shall have released and forever discharged Sirius XM, its past,
`
`present or future officers, directors, insurers, general or limited partners, divisions, stockholders,
`
`agents,
`
`the telemarketing vendors currently known as Afni, Convergys, Dial America,
`
`iPaceSetters, Results, Servicom, StraightForward, Sykes and Career Horizons,
`
`Inc. dba
`
`TeleServices Direct, attorneys, employees, legal representatives, trustees, parents, associates,
`
`affiliates, subsidiaries, partners, heirs, executors, administrators, purchasers, predecessors,
`
`successors and assigns
`
`(collectively,
`
`the "Released Parties")
`
`from any and all claims,
`
`counterclaims,
`
`lawsuits, set-offs, costs, losses, rights, demands, charges, complaints, actions,
`
`causes of action, obligations, or liabilities of any and every kind, including without limitation (i)
`
`those known or unknown or capable or not capable of being known, (ii) those which are
`
`unknown but might be discovered or discoverable, and (iii) those accrued, unaccrued, matured or
`
`not matured existing on or before August 5,2016, that arise out of or in any way relate or pertain
`
`to claims, no matter how styled, (a) that were asserted, or attempted to be asserted, or that could
`
`have been asserted in the Litigation, or (b) alleging use by any or all of the Released Parties or by
`
`any vendor retained by the Released Parties of any "automatic telephone dialing system,"
`
`"automatic dialer," "automated dialer," "predictive dialer," "dialer," and/or any "artificial or
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-4
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 5 of 17 PageID# 4869
`
`prerecorded voice" (to the fullest extent that those terms are used, defined, or interpreted under
`
`the TCPA, relevant regulatory or administrative promulgations, and case lawr) to make telephone
`
`calls to a wireless, cell or mobile telephone number in connection with efforts to contact or
`
`attempt to contact Class Members on behalfof Sirius XM, including but not limited to (i) claims
`
`arising underor relating to the TCPAor any similarstate or federal law, (ii) statutory or common
`
`law claims predicated upon any alleged violations of the TCPA or any similar state or federal
`
`law, and (iii) statutory or common law claims predicated upon and/or arising from the use by any
`
`or all of the Released Partiesor by any vendor retained by the Released Parties of any "automatic
`
`telephone dialing system," "automatic dialer," "automated dialer," "predictive dialer," "dialer,"
`
`and/or "artificial or prerecorded voice" (collectively,the "Released Rights").
`
`15. The Class Representatives and all Settlement Class members are enjoined from
`
`commencing, prosecuting,
`
`instituting, continuing, or
`
`in any way participating in the
`
`commencement or prosecution of any suit asserting any of the Released Rights againstany of the
`
`Released Parties.
`
`16.The Settlement Agreement and any related negotiations, statements, or proceedings
`
`shall not be construed or deemed evidence of an admission by any of the Released Parties or any
`
`other person of any fault, liability, or wrongdoing as to any facts or claims asserted in the
`
`Litigation.
`
`17. Settlement Class members were afforded a reasonable opportunity to request
`
`exclusion from the Settlement. Only 191 timely requests for exclusion were received by Epiq.
`
`The persons who timely requested exclusion from the Settlement are listed in Exhibit A hereto.
`
`The Court hereby excludes the persons listed in Exhibit A from the Settlement, and they are not
`
`bound by the final judgment in this Action.
`
`18. The Court approves a service award of $10,000 to Plaintiff Francis W. Hooker, Jr.
`
`and $2,500 each to Class Representatives Eric Knutson, Yefim Elikman, and Anthony Parker.
`
`The Court finds that
`
`these amounts are reasonable in light of the Class Representatives'
`
`contributions to the litigation, with the larger award to Mr. Hooker being justified by the greater
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-5
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 6 of 17 PageID# 4870
`
`inconvenience he experienced from having beendeposed andresponding to discovery requests in
`
`this Action.
`
`19. If the Effective Date does not occur, this Judgment shall be void as provided in the
`
`Settlement Agreement.
`
`20. The Settlement Class members were given an opportunity to object to the settlement.
`
`Only two objections to the Settlement or fee petition were received by Court, from Mr. Helfand
`
`and Mr. Sweeney. (Dkt. Nos. 189 and 190.) The Court finds that Mr. Helfand and Mr. Sweeney
`
`have not complied with the Preliminary Approval Order requirements for filing objections and
`
`further finds that Mr. Helfand and Mr. Sweeney are not members of the Class. Their objections
`
`are therefore stricken. (Dkt. No. 188 H 18.) Furthermore, the Court finds the objections are
`
`without merit and hereby overrules the objections. All Settlement Class Members who failed to
`
`file a timely and valid objection to the settlement are deemed to have waived any objections and
`
`are bound by the terms of the Settlement Agreement, including the release and this Final Order
`
`and Judgment.
`
`21. This Order constitutes a judgment for purposes of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 58.
`
`Without affecting the finality of the Final Order and Judgment in any way, the Court reserves
`
`continuing and exclusive jurisdiction over the parties, including all members of the Settlement
`
`Class, and the execution, consummation, administration, and enforcement of the terms of the
`
`Settlement Agreement.
`
`22. The parties to the Settlement Agreement are directed to consummate the settlement in
`
`accordance with the Settlement Agreement according to its terms. Without further Court Order,
`
`the parties may agree to reasonable extensions of time to carry out any of the provisions of the
`
`Settlement Agreement.
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-6
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 7 of 17 PageID# 4871
`
`23. There is no just reason for delay in the entry of this Order and Final Judgment. The
`
`Clerk of this Court is REQUESTED to enter this Order and Final Judgment.
`
`IT IS SO ORDERED.
`
`Dated:
`
`^
`
`OlC/
`
`Judge
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-7
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 8 of 17 PageID# 4872
`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-8
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 9 of 17 PageID# 4873
`
`PERSONS EXCLUDED FROM THE SETTLEMENT
`
`Rudolph Leblanc
`664 SE 71st Ave.
`HiUsboro OR 97123-3012
`
`Kent Peterson
`4307 LormarRd.
`Greensboro NC 27406-9343
`
`Beverly Miller
`5627HnierPl.
`Saint Louis MO 63136-4913
`
`Ronald Levi
`3220TalmadgeRd.
`Toledo OH 43606-1042
`
`BridgetDezinno
`72 Vans Dr.
`Hackettstown
`
`07840-2546
`
`Nancy Pierce
`244 Concord Dr.
`Madison AL 35758-8151
`
`Marion Gottfried
`75 RemickPkwy.Apt. D
`LockportNY 14094-3969
`
`Jae Lim
`703PumphreyAve.
`RockviUe MD 20851-1457
`
`John Kennett
`3212Spruce St.
`Midland MI 48640-6448
`
`Karen Kaufman
`360 Terrapin Trl.
`Brunswick GA 31525-8938
`
`Pamela Capen
`106 Bronwen Ct.
`Goose Creek SC 29445-7506
`
`Andrew N. Hasluem
`120Kimberly Ct.
`SenoiaGA 30276-1642
`
`Donald Roth
`3728Tango Dr.
`North Bend OH 45052-9518
`
`Jarilyn McCoy
`8622WintergreenSt.
`LansingMI 48917-8801
`
`CherylA. Rosenberg
`1668 Silverado Dr.
`Rockledge PL 32955-6130
`
`Dorotha P. West
`211 CypressSt. #1
`Sayre PA 18840-1400
`
`Brad Anderson
`3838 Fieldcrest Ln.
`Ypsilanti MI 48197-7460
`
`GingerRabem
`1275 Deer Trail Lakes Dr.
`Clarkesville GA 30523-2130
`
`YizhengCao
`3312 PeppermillDr. Apt. IB
`W Lafayette IN 47906-1099
`
`Ann Kitchen
`222 Western Dr.
`Medway OH 45341-9520
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-9
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 10 of 17 PageID# 4874
`
`Regina Martinez
`18023 Thornlake Ave.
`ArtesiaCA 90701-4247
`
`Mary Moore
`60022 Doc Carter Ln.
`Amory MS 38821-8925
`
`Ann R. Kavanaugh
`10881 Lake Thames Dr.
`Cincinnati OH 45242-3104
`
`Andrew N. Hasluem
`120 KimberlyCt.
`SenoiaGA 30276-1642
`
`Mohammadrez Iranmanesh
`114 Belaire Ct.
`Matawan NJ 07747-1130
`
`Kristen Ensign
`200 Towsontown Ct. Apt. 310
`TowsonMD 21204-4038
`
`Sara Humberstone
`8815 Emerson PI.
`Everett WA 98208-1947
`
`AngelaMartin
`229 Barker Rd. Apt. 107
`Michigan City IN 46360-7416
`
`Gwen Davis
`3090 Beechwood Dr. SE
`Marietta GA 30067-5416
`
`Judy Chard
`1011N 192nd Ct. Apt 114
`ElkhomNE 68022-2891
`
`Sean Kenny
`455ReynoldsMill Rd.
`York PA 17403-9316
`
`John Keltz
`164 Pine Ln.
`Baraesville OH 43713-1429
`
`Barbara Parker
`4310 TifFani Dr.
`AmarilloTX 79109-5072
`
`Srikanth Gondi
`1502Quail Ave.
`Sunnyvale CA 94087-4925
`
`Moreen Glover
`4372 Gum Branch Rd.
`Jacksonville NC 28540-9118
`
`James Bevins
`525 Hill Rd.
`Paris KY 40361-9737
`
`Sun Kim
`236 Fieldstone PI.
`CollegeSta TX 77845-6343
`
`PhyllisBobo
`22468 Bridges Rd.
`ToneyAL 35773-8394
`
`Eraest Vineyard
`2316 Vincinda Cir.
`KnoxvUleTN 37924
`
`Matthew D. McAtee
`537N Somerset Ter. Apt. 7
`OlatheKS 66062-5408
`
`Fredric Sparrevohn
`388 Flint Ave.
`Long Beach CA 90814-3206
`
`Michael D. Belcher
`902 Russellville Rd.
`Quinwood WV 25981
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-10
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 11 of 17 PageID# 4875
`
`FengminXie
`1506 Abelian Ave.
`RowlandHghts CA 917482-203
`
`Donna Smith
`5105 Ne Mariah Ln. Apt. 301
`Bremerton WA 98311-3619
`
`Travis Gilbert
`874 Saramy Ct.
`Lebanon OH 45036-8440
`
`Keny Esparza
`1413 Oakwood Ave.
`N Las VegasNV 89030-5214
`
`Lee Rucker
`3332 Lions Den Ct.
`Pueblo CO 81005-4031
`
`Chad Goetz
`PO Box 234
`LiverpoolNY 13088-0234
`
`Benjamin Card
`30310 Ridgeway Ct.
`Castaic CA 91384-3247
`
`Estate ofJohn D. Calloway
`27 Bryant Ln.
`AnstedWV 25812-8099
`
`Peter Pelayic
`3626 SchamberSt.
`RapidCity SD 57702-3354
`
`Patricia Stonebraker
`PO Box 418013
`N HighlandsCA 95660-5604
`
`Eric Light
`117 Triangle St.
`Danbuiy CT 06810-6924
`
`John Eddy
`4454 S Lakeshore Rd.
`Harbor Beach MI 48441-7957
`
`Diane Wilkerson
`1916 Madalyn Ct. NE
`Keizer OR 97303-2130
`
`Benjamin Raslavich
`2814 W Thornton Ave.
`Tampa FL 33611-4529
`
`June Nickel
`84 S EdgehillAve.
`Youngstown OH 44515-3230
`
`Dee A. Finken
`1201N Manhattan St.
`Amarillo TX 79107-7063
`
`Dean Moser
`505 W Alderwood Ave.
`SpokaneWA 99218-2803
`
`Diane Pearson
`1625 Waller St. SE
`Salem OR 97302-1342
`
`Elizabeth Anderson
`2421W St. Apt. 3
`Sacramento CA 95818-1856
`
`Jane Arnold
`3205 Lome Rd.
`El PasoTX 79925-4321
`
`Robert Brodie
`816 Se Williams Ct.
`WaukeelA 50263-8351
`
`Christie Rice
`56 W Del Rio St,
`Gilbert AZ 85233-8939
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-11
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 12 of 17 PageID# 4876
`
`Lisa Howard
`7151 North BrayRd.
`Mount Morris MI 48458-8989
`
`LotharUhl
`181E StaceyLn.
`TempeAZ 85284-4042
`
`Patricia Cummins
`2195 Waynesboro Shubuta Rd.
`Waynesboro MS 39367-9742
`
`Steven Lambert
`25815 Floyd Ave.
`Sun City CA 92585-9708
`
`Susan Melton
`5200 28th St. N Lot 314
`St PetersburgFL 33714-2548
`
`James Thorp
`1613 Roncelli Rd.
`Lexington MO 64067-7188
`
`Rowland Monroe
`12512 Roseton Ave.
`Norwalk CA 90650-2361
`
`Gloria Ward
`13551 Belle Chasse Blvd. Unit 211
`Laurel MD 20707-8402
`
`Paulette Vispi
`49 Peach Tree Rd.
`Cheektowaga NY 14225-2901
`
`Kristen Crean
`3020 Mugavin Ct.
`Dayton OH 45424-5238
`
`Glenn Robinson
`2959 Marsann Ln.
`Dallas TX 75234-5015
`
`Robert Crow
`30213th St.
`Glen Dale WV 26038-1712
`
`Ronald West
`15014 E Castle Dr.
`Wichita KS 67230-9207
`
`Ernest Cannucci
`807Laurelridge Court
`Brooksville FL 34601-1269
`
`Sarah Schwartz
`3900 Island Blvd.Apt. B-106
`Aventura FL 33160-4914
`
`John Koebel
`100Ashbury Rd. Apt. 302
`HoUywoodFL 33024-1111
`
`Isabelle Cuellar
`6629 PamplonaPI.
`Atlanta GA 30349-8492
`
`Genieve Maestas
`7132 Marina PacificaDr. S Key 8
`LongBeach CA 90803-3818
`
`Gloria Salinas
`3308 Grinnell St.
`LubbockTX 79415-1517
`
`Aaron Schuhnan
`390WoodleyRd.
`Santa Barbara CA 93108
`
`Bruce Kennell
`1568 County Rd. 550N
`Eureka IL 61530-9677
`
`Heather Karstens
`176042nd St. S Apt. 304
`FargoND 58103-4492
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-12
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 13 of 17 PageID# 4877
`
`Raymond Skinner
`6896 Bronte Cir.
`Port St Lucie FL 34952-8233
`
`Richard Caron
`15125 Tilbury PI.
`Swan Point MD 20645-2203
`
`Frank Wilson
`2015 New York Ave.
`Lincoln Park MI 48146-3475
`
`Ruth Hoffinan
`149 Union St.
`Vemon Rockville CT 06066-3025
`
`Gabrielle Mandeville
`4613 E 24th PI.
`Tulsa OK 7411-43615
`
`Bobby Mitchell
`412 Twin Br.
`Prestonsburg KY 41653-8203
`
`Dora Ross
`4249 Hammock Trl.
`MimsFL 32754-2101
`
`Marian Engle
`11720 Collingwood Ct.
`Woodbridge VA 22192-1043
`
`Margaret Dowling
`PO Box 880383
`Port Saint Lucie FL 34988
`
`Donald Roth
`3728Tango Dr.
`North Bend OH 45052-9518
`
`Phyllis Hays
`346 Dean Rd.
`McKeeKY 40447-9069
`
`JiJun
`3033 BardinRd. Apt. 712
`Grand Prairie TX 75052-3869
`
`Roy Barton
`2120 Redbird Dr.
`Las VegasNV 89134-6160
`
`Jo Ann Beasley
`5005Guy St.
`Paragould AR72450-3784
`
`Alice Horn
`4862 School St. Apt. 2125
`AcworthGA 30101-4913
`
`Anita Beckett
`406Maplewood Rd.
`MerionSta PA 19066-1014
`
`Elizabeth Crawford
`11833 Oak Hill WayUnit B
`Henderson CO 80640-7731
`
`WalkiriaJorge
`6635 High Valley Ln.
`Alexandria VA 22315-5009
`
`Phoebe Dill
`109 Pebble Beach Dr.
`Trophy ClubTX 76262-9784
`
`James Clason
`PO Box 442
`Mocksville NC 27028-0442
`
`Ida Paone
`714 Preston Ln.
`Hatboro PA 19040-2322
`
`Kristopher Skadberg
`6101st St.
`S Carrington ND 58421-2111
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-13
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 14 of 17 PageID# 4878
`
`PerryJennings
`1710 Old Atlanta Rd.
`Gumming GA 30041-6924
`
`Joseph Ziaj
`1840S ArlingtonHt Rd.
`ArlingtonHeights IL 60705
`
`Tammy Garces
`58 Saunders Rd.
`Lynn MA 01904-1571
`
`Anna Cassell
`714 Park St.
`Bristol VA 24201-3432
`
`Anne Gandrud
`4749 Vincent Ave. S
`Minneapolis MN 55410-1843
`
`Rafal Koycinski
`517 S Emerson St.
`Mt Prospect IL 60056-3835
`
`James Ackerman
`1899 Allison St.
`Lakewood CO 80214-6025
`
`Clydeen Moller
`PO Box 231578
`EncinitasCA 92023-1578
`
`Darrin L Wenzel
`102 Madsen St.
`Grayling MI 49738-1916
`
`Ruben Cruz
`7230 Harbor Light Way
`Sacramento CA 95831-3201
`
`Raymond Skinner
`6896 Bronte Cir.
`Port St Lucie FL 34952-8233
`
`John Hydock
`4406 W 226th St.
`Fairview Park OH 44126-2221
`
`Mario Leal
`2716 Main Ave.
`Laredo TX 78040-2929
`
`Samlngram
`229 Scottsdale Dr.
`Wilmington NC 28411-6770
`
`John Melton
`5200 28th St. N Lot 314
`St Petersburg FL 33714-2548
`
`Christopher RaisI
`4653 Kingsbury Dr.
`Eagan MN 55122-2719
`
`Jesse Danielson
`1679 451st Ave.
`Montevideo MN 56265-4444
`
`William Lemon
`25112 Pine HI.
`LeesburgFL 34748-9470
`
`Douglas Fruth
`718 W Main St.
`NapoleonOH 43545-1404
`
`DavidB StegallJr.
`850 NW 3rd St.
`Lake Butler FL 32054
`
`Jennifer Eaker
`617SherrillRd.#2
`Sherrill NY 13461-1451
`
`Brian Knox
`700 Long Rd.
`Penn Hills PA 15235-4307
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-14
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 15 of 17 PageID# 4879
`
`Corine Assane
`6201 Garden Rose Path
`Austin TX 78754-2159
`
`Marietha Varona
`9702 Elm Way
`Tampa FL 33635-1010
`
`Lazaro Suarez
`9702Ehn Way
`Tampa FL 33635-1010
`
`Ming Cheng
`5517 Pershing Ave. Apt. 32
`Saint Louis MO 63112-4615
`
`John Brocko
`6133AlkireCt.
`ArvadaCO 80004-3972
`
`Renee Laurent
`927 Robin Rd.#G
`Amherst NY 14228-1002
`
`Serge Darchuke
`6830Radalyac Ct.
`Rio Linda CA 95673-2453
`
`Barbara Walter
`PO Box 222
`Redmond OR 97756-0037
`
`LizbethAguilar
`1230 Bardfield Ave.
`Garland TX 75041-5007
`
`Tracy Downs
`541N Wanamaker St.
`Philadelphia PA 19131-4839
`
`Kevin Pine
`2625 Kermeyer Cir. Apt. 14
`Carlsbad CA 92008-1668
`
`Michael Stark
`111 N RengstorfFAve. Apt. 169
`Mountain View CA 94043-4236
`
`AnthonyErcolani
`139 Front Ave.
`Salamanca NY 14779-1454
`
`Guillermo Chapa
`65 Varadero St.
`Brownsville TX 78526-1974
`
`Thomas Fox
`16133 Ventura Blvd. Ste 1200
`EncinoCA 91436-2416
`
`Epiq Systems
`10300 SW Allen Blvd.
`Beaverton OR 97005
`
`Ylaine Hetes
`1528 Blackbird Rd. NE
`Rio Rancho NM 87144-5110
`
`Velkys Monterrey
`38Torreys Post
`San Antonio TX 78240-5241
`
`RicardoSegovia
`110 North Ave.
`Laredo TX 78045-7701
`
`Eric Byman
`5262Jacob Ct.
`Virginia BchVA23464-2518
`
`Binyamin Pinkus
`6234 N Monticello Ave.
`ChicagoIL 60659-1106
`
`Michelle Turner
`3040 Timberglenn Rd.
`San Antonio TX 75287
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-15
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 16 of 17 PageID# 4880
`
`Joseph Zertuche
`1646 Stevens Ave.
`San Antonio TX 78210
`
`Geraldine Huron
`1414 Leal St.
`San Antonio TX 78207
`
`Sandra Brown
`163Mountain Valley
`San Antonio TX 78227
`
`JacquelineRedding
`226 Primavera Dr.
`San Antonio TX 78212
`
`Marsha Morgan
`16006 Walnut Creek Dr.
`San Antonio TX 78247-5622
`
`Travis Rendon
`152E Pecan St. Apt. #1001
`San Antonio TX 78205
`
`Louis Ibarra
`527 Future Dr.
`San Antonio TX 78213-3423
`
`Joey Santos
`3016 PotomalLoop
`Laredo TX 78046-7313
`
`Joey Santos
`3016 PotomalLoop
`Laredo TX 78046-7313
`
`CynthiaZambrano
`2917 Barrios St. Rear
`Laredo TX 78043-5511
`
`Abraham Benavides
`1102Harland
`LoredoTX 78045
`
`Rick Biaiek
`810 Bluebell Rd.
`KerrvilleTX 78028
`
`Jennifer Trent Vertulli
`8910 Woodland Pkwy.
`BoemeTX 78015
`
`Gerard Vertulli
`8910 Woodland Pkwy.
`BoemeTX 78015
`
`Jose Flores
`350Redfish
`Laredo TX 78043
`
`Clarissa Arambula
`506 Sandpiper Ln.
`Laredo TX 78045
`
`Letty Santos
`3016Potomal Loop
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`Mariana Quiroga
`140 Shadow Knolls
`Boeme TX 78006
`
`Brandon Reyes
`2117 Pearson Way
`Round Rock TX 78665
`
`Javier A. Martinez
`391lKatianaDr.
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`Amada Sarli
`2911S Arkansas
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`Sylvia Pina
`2509 Robert Ln.
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-16
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`

`

`Case 4:13-cv-00003-AWA-LRL Document 209 Filed 12/22/16 Page 17 of 17 PageID# 4881
`
`Rudy De Los Santos
`5726ElamWay
`San Antonio TK 78261
`
`Jose S. Olazaran
`6019 Colt Dr.
`Laredo TX 78043
`
`Sara A. Vela
`4527Santa Anita Loop
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`Diana Lara
`SOWS Martin
`Laredo TX 78045
`
`Melissa Santos
`3016 PotomacLoop
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`Antonio Hurtado
`3016Potomac Loop
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`Jamie Bialek
`7819 Dunhill Coach
`San Antonio TX 78255
`
`Leticia Cisneros
`314Esperanza Dr.
`Laredo TX 78041
`Kate Soulsby
`125 W Mistletoe
`
`San Antonio TX 78212
`
`Claudia Martinez
`608AngelaDr.
`Laredo TX 78046
`
`ArianaEspinoza
`810 E 4th St.
`HeameTX 77859
`
`Ricardo Segovia
`110 North Ave.
`Laredo TX 78045-7701
`
`Samuel Salazar
`612 Waxwing Cedar Dr.
`Laredo TX 78045-8875
`
`Latonya Cotton
`233 2nd St.
`AnguillaMS 38721-9517
`
`Thelma Agredano
`805 Bartolome Ln.
`Laredo TX 78043-5184
`
`SergioMinjares
`506SandpiperLn.
`Laredo TX 78045-4160
`
`Fraunhofer Ex 2017-17
`Sirius XM v Fraunhofer, IPR2018-00682
`
`