Oketqdkcn!eqoowpkvkgu!kp!vjg!jwocp!
`uocnn!kpvguvkpg<!eqwrnkpi!fkxgtukv{!
`vq!ogvcigpqokeu
`
`TGXKGY
`
`Vjg!icuvtqkpvguvkpcn!vtcev!ku!vjg!ockp!ukvg!yjgtg!vjg!eqpxgtukqp!cpf!cduqtrvkqp!qh!hqqf!
`eqorqpgpvu!vcmgu!rnceg/!Vjg!jquv.fgtkxgf!rj{ukqnqikecn!rtqeguugu!cpf!vjg!tgukfkpi!
`oketqqticpkuou-!gurgekcnn{!kp!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg-!eqpvtkdwvg!vq!vjku!pwvtkgpv!uwrrn{/!Vq!
`ektewoxgpv!ucornkpi!rtqdngou!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg-!ugxgtcn!oqfgn!u{uvgou!jcxg!dggp!
`fgxgnqrgf!vq!uvwf{!oketqdkcn!fkxgtukv{!cpf!hwpevkqpcnkv{!kp!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!Kp!cffkvkqp-!
`ogvcigpqokeu!qhhgtu!pqxgn!rquukdknkvkgu!vq!ickp!kpukijv!kpvq!vjg!igpgvke!rqvgpvkcn!cpf!
`hwpevkqpcn!rtqrgtvkgu!qh!vjgug!oketqdkcn!eqoowpkvkgu/!Jgtg-!cp!qxgtxkgy!ku!rtgugpvgf!qh!vjg!
`oquv!tgegpv!kpukijvu!kpvq!vjg!fkxgtukv{!cpf!hwpevkqpcnkv{!qh!vjg!oketqqticpkuou!kp!vjg!jwocp!
`icuvtqkpvguvkpcn!vtcev-!ykvj!c!hqewu!qp!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!
`
`Vjg! jwocp! icuvtqkpvguvkpcn! )IK*! vtcev! ku! cp
`qticp!vjcv!ku!qh!etkvkecn!korqtvcpeg!kp!vjg!rtqe.
`guugu! kpxqnxgf! kp! hqqf! eqpxgtukqp! cpf! cduqtr.
`vkqp-!cpf!jgpeg!guugpvkcn!hqt!uwrrn{kpi!vjg!dqf{
`ykvj!vjg!crrtqrtkcvg!gpgti{!cpf!guugpvkcn!pwvtk.
`gpvu/! Kp! cffkvkqp-! kv! rnc{u! c! rtqokpgpv! tqng! kp
`fghgpfkpi!vjg!dqf{!cickpuv!kpiguvgf!cpf!kpvtwf.
`kpi!oketqqticpkuou!d{!vjg!nqy!rJ!kp!vjg!uvqo.
`cej!cpf!vjg!eqxgtcig!qh!vjg!uwthcegu!qh!vjg!vtcev
`ykvj!c!owewu!nc{gt/!Vjku!jquv!fghgpug!ku!hwtvjgt
`ckfgf! d{! o{tkcfu! qh! urgekcnk|gf! tgukfgpvkcn
`oketqdgu!vjcv!eqnqpk|g!vjg!uwthcegu!cu!ygnn!cu!vjg
`nwogp!qh!vjg!jwocp!IK!vtcev/!Vjgug!eqoogp.
`ucnu-!vqigvjgt!ykvj!vjg!hqqf.kpiguvgf-!qt!vtcpukgpv
`oketqqticpkuou-!ctg!vgtogf!oketqdkqvc/!
`Vjg!crrtqzkocvgn{!8.o!nqpi!IK!vtcev!ecp!dg
`fkxkfgf!kp!ugxgtcn!cpcvqokecnn{!fkuvkpev!tgikqpu-
`uvctvkpi! htqo! vjg! oqwvj-! xkc! vjg! guqrjciwu! vq
`vjg! uvqocej-! rtqeggfkpi! vq! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg
`)fkxkfgf! kpvq! fwqfgpwo-! lglwpwo! cpf! kngwo-
`tgurgevkxgn{*!cpf!vjg!nctig!kpvguvkpg!)fkxkfgf!kpvq
`egewo-! eqnqp! ]ykvj! cp! cuegpfkpi-! vtcpuxgtug-
`fguegpfkpi! cpf! ukioqkf! rctv_! cpf! tgevwo-
`tgurgevkxgn{*! cpf! gpfkpi! cv! vjg! cpwu! )Hkiwtg 2*/
`Encuukecnn{-! vjg! oketqdkqvc! ykvjkp! vjg! fkhhgtgpv
`tgikqpu!ygtg!uvwfkgf!d{!ewnvwtg.fgrgpfgpv!vgej.
`pkswgu-! ngcfkpi! vq! wpfgtguvkocvgf! cpf! kpeqo.
`rngvg! xkgyu! qh! vjg! oketqdkcn! fkxgtukv{! kp! vjg
`IK vtcev/! Ykvj! vjg! fgxgnqrogpv! qh! tkdquqocn
`TPC! )tTPC*.dcugf! cpf! qvjgt! ewnvwtg.kpfg.
`rgpfgpv!crrtqcejgu-!vjg!mpqyngfig!qh!vjg!vqvcn
`oketqdkcn! fkxgtukv{! ykvjkp! vjg! jwocp! IK! vtcev
`jcu! kpetgcugf! eqpukfgtcdn{! ]2_/! Vjku! kpetgcug! kp
`mpqyngfig!jqnfu!gurgekcnn{!vtwg!hqt!vjg!oketq.
`dkqvc!tgukfkpi!kp!vjg!nqygt!tgikqpu!qh!vjg!nctig
`kpvguvkpg-! ukpeg! ucornkpi! htqo! vjg! vgtokpcn
`eqnqp!ku!tgncvkxgn{!gcu{/!D{!eqpvtcuv-!xgt{!nkvvng!ku
`mpqyp! cdqwv!
`vjg! oketqdkcn! eqoowpkvkgu
`
`tgukfkpi!kp!vjg!nqygt!rctvu!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg
`fwg!vq!ucornkpi!fkhhkewnvkgu!ecwugf!d{!vjg!kpce.
`eguukdknkv{!qh!vjg!kngwo!cpf!vjg!pggf!vq!rtqeguu
`ucorngu!cpcgtqdkecnn{/!Cu!d{!hct!vjg!nctiguv!rctv
`qh!hqqf!fkiguvkqp!cpf!cduqtrvkqp!vcmgu!rnceg!kp
`vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg-! kv! ku! guugpvkcn! vq! qxgteqog
`ucornkpi! fkhhkewnvkgu! kp! qtfgt! vq! qdvckp! c! hwnn
`wpfgtuvcpfkpi!qh!vjg!rtqeguugu!cpf!kpvgtcevkqpu
`vjcv!iq!qp!kp!vjku!rctv!qh!vjg!IK!vtcev/!Kp!cffk.
`vkqp-!dgecwug!vjku!ku!chvgt!vjg!uvqocej-!vjg!hktuv
`tgikqp!qh!vjg!kpvguvkpg!yjgtg!hqqf!cpf!eqoogp.
`ucn! oketqdgu! oggv-! c! hwtvjgt! wpfgtuvcpfkpi! ku
`pgeguuct{!vq!rquukdn{!kphnwgpeg!qt!gxgp!oqfwncvg
`vjg! oketqdkqvc! d{! fkgvct{! cnvgtcvkqpu/! Hwtvjgt.
`oqtg-! vjg! oketqdkqvc!eqorqukvkqp! qh! vjg! uocnn
`kpvguvkpg! okijv! kphnwgpeg! gxgpvu! kp! vjg! nctig
`kpvguvkpg!cpf!yknn!rnc{!cp!gxgp!oqtg!korqtvcpv
`tqng! kp!kpfkxkfwcnu!yjq! jcf! rctv!qt! cnn!qh! vjgkt
`nctig!kpvguvkpg!tgoqxgf/
`
`Rj{ukqnqi{!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg
`Vjg!kpvgtcevkqpu!dgvyggp!vjg!oketqdkqvc!cpf!vjg
`jquv!egnnu!ctg!nctign{!kphnwgpegf!d{!ugxgtcn!rj{ukq.
`nqikecn!hcevqtu/!Vjgug!ecp!dg!fkxkfgf!kpvq!jquv!hce.
`vqtu!uwej!cu!vtcpukv!vkog!]3_-!koowpg!tgurqpug!]4-5_
`cpf! ugetgvqt{! rtqfwevu! )icuvtke! cekf! ]6_-! dkng! ]7_-
`rcpetgcvke!gp|{ogu!]co{ncug-!vt{rukp_!]8_!cpf!jqt.
`oqpgu!]g/i/-!kpuwnkp-!inweciqp_!]9_*-!cpf!gpxktqp.
`ogpvcn! hcevqtu-! uwej! cu! rJ! ];-21_! cpf! fkgvct{
`eqorqpgpvu!]22_/!Vtcpukv!qh!vjg!nkswkf!eqpvgpvu!kp
`vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg!ku!cp!wpfgtuvwfkgf!ctgc!]23_-!dwv
`ykvj!guvkocvgf!vtcpukv!vkogu!dgvyggp!41 okp!cpf
`4/6 j! ]24_-!vtcpukv!ku!hcuvgt!vjcp!hwtvjgt!fqyp!vjg
`IK!vtcev-!tgfwekpi!vjg!itqyvj!qh!oketqqticpkuou
`kp! vjg! nwogp! qh! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg! ]25˜27_/! Vjku
`nkokvgf!itqyvj!ku!cnuq!tgfwegf!d{!vjg!hcev!vjcv-!qh
`vjg!fkgvct{!ectdqj{ftcvgu!rcuukpi!vjtqwij!vjg!IK
`vtcev-!qpn{!vjg!gcukn{!fkiguvkdng!eqorqpgpvu!ecp!dg
`
`cpf-
`
`Mg{yqtfu<!icuvtqkpvguvkpcn!
`vtcev-!IK!vtcev!oqfgn!u{uvgou-!
`ogvcigpqoke-!oketqdkqvc-!
`uocnn!kpvguvkpg
`
`*"+-!)%
`
`21/3328028571;24/3/4/396!«!3118!Hwvwtg!Ogfkekpg!Nvf!!KUUP!2857.1;24
`
`!)3118*!!3)4*-!396˜3;6
`
`396
`
`Page 1
`
`SHIRE EX. 2032
`KVK v. SHIRE
`IPR2018-00290
`
`

`

`Oketqdkcn!eqoowpkvkgu!kp!vjg!jwocp!
`uocnn!kpvguvkpg<!eqwrnkpi!fkxgtukv{!
`vq!ogvcigpqokeu
`
`TGXKGY
`
`Vjg!icuvtqkpvguvkpcn!vtcev!ku!vjg!ockp!ukvg!yjgtg!vjg!eqpxgtukqp!cpf!cduqtrvkqp!qh!hqqf!
`eqorqpgpvu!vcmgu!rnceg/!Vjg!jquv.fgtkxgf!rj{ukqnqikecn!rtqeguugu!cpf!vjg!tgukfkpi!
`oketqqticpkuou-!gurgekcnn{!kp!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg-!eqpvtkdwvg!vq!vjku!pwvtkgpv!uwrrn{/!Vq!
`ektewoxgpv!ucornkpi!rtqdngou!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg-!ugxgtcn!oqfgn!u{uvgou!jcxg!dggp!
`fgxgnqrgf!vq!uvwf{!oketqdkcn!fkxgtukv{!cpf!hwpevkqpcnkv{!kp!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!Kp!cffkvkqp-!
`ogvcigpqokeu!qhhgtu!pqxgn!rquukdknkvkgu!vq!ickp!kpukijv!kpvq!vjg!igpgvke!rqvgpvkcn!cpf!
`hwpevkqpcn!rtqrgtvkgu!qh!vjgug!oketqdkcn!eqoowpkvkgu/!Jgtg-!cp!qxgtxkgy!ku!rtgugpvgf!qh!vjg!
`oquv!tgegpv!kpukijvu!kpvq!vjg!fkxgtukv{!cpf!hwpevkqpcnkv{!qh!vjg!oketqqticpkuou!kp!vjg!jwocp!
`icuvtqkpvguvkpcn!vtcev-!ykvj!c!hqewu!qp!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!
`
`Vjg! jwocp! icuvtqkpvguvkpcn! )IK*! vtcev! ku! cp
`qticp!vjcv!ku!qh!etkvkecn!korqtvcpeg!kp!vjg!rtqe.
`guugu! kpxqnxgf! kp! hqqf! eqpxgtukqp! cpf! cduqtr.
`vkqp-!cpf!jgpeg!guugpvkcn!hqt!uwrrn{kpi!vjg!dqf{
`ykvj!vjg!crrtqrtkcvg!gpgti{!cpf!guugpvkcn!pwvtk.
`gpvu/! Kp! cffkvkqp-! kv! rnc{u! c! rtqokpgpv! tqng! kp
`fghgpfkpi!vjg!dqf{!cickpuv!kpiguvgf!cpf!kpvtwf.
`kpi!oketqqticpkuou!d{!vjg!nqy!rJ!kp!vjg!uvqo.
`cej!cpf!vjg!eqxgtcig!qh!vjg!uwthcegu!qh!vjg!vtcev
`ykvj!c!owewu!nc{gt/!Vjku!jquv!fghgpug!ku!hwtvjgt
`ckfgf! d{! o{tkcfu! qh! urgekcnk|gf! tgukfgpvkcn
`oketqdgu!vjcv!eqnqpk|g!vjg!uwthcegu!cu!ygnn!cu!vjg
`nwogp!qh!vjg!jwocp!IK!vtcev/!Vjgug!eqoogp.
`ucnu-!vqigvjgt!ykvj!vjg!hqqf.kpiguvgf-!qt!vtcpukgpv
`oketqqticpkuou-!ctg!vgtogf!oketqdkqvc/!
`Vjg!crrtqzkocvgn{!8.o!nqpi!IK!vtcev!ecp!dg
`fkxkfgf!kp!ugxgtcn!cpcvqokecnn{!fkuvkpev!tgikqpu-
`uvctvkpi! htqo! vjg! oqwvj-! xkc! vjg! guqrjciwu! vq
`vjg! uvqocej-! rtqeggfkpi! vq! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg
`)fkxkfgf! kpvq! fwqfgpwo-! lglwpwo! cpf! kngwo-
`tgurgevkxgn{*!cpf!vjg!nctig!kpvguvkpg!)fkxkfgf!kpvq
`egewo-! eqnqp! ]ykvj! cp! cuegpfkpi-! vtcpuxgtug-
`fguegpfkpi! cpf! ukioqkf! rctv_! cpf! tgevwo-
`tgurgevkxgn{*! cpf! gpfkpi! cv! vjg! cpwu! )Hkiwtg 2*/
`Encuukecnn{-! vjg! oketqdkqvc! ykvjkp! vjg! fkhhgtgpv
`tgikqpu!ygtg!uvwfkgf!d{!ewnvwtg.fgrgpfgpv!vgej.
`pkswgu-! ngcfkpi! vq! wpfgtguvkocvgf! cpf! kpeqo.
`rngvg! xkgyu! qh! vjg! oketqdkcn! fkxgtukv{! kp! vjg
`IK vtcev/! Ykvj! vjg! fgxgnqrogpv! qh! tkdquqocn
`TPC! )tTPC*.dcugf! cpf! qvjgt! ewnvwtg.kpfg.
`rgpfgpv!crrtqcejgu-!vjg!mpqyngfig!qh!vjg!vqvcn
`oketqdkcn! fkxgtukv{! ykvjkp! vjg! jwocp! IK! vtcev
`jcu! kpetgcugf! eqpukfgtcdn{! ]2_/! Vjku! kpetgcug! kp
`mpqyngfig!jqnfu!gurgekcnn{!vtwg!hqt!vjg!oketq.
`dkqvc!tgukfkpi!kp!vjg!nqygt!tgikqpu!qh!vjg!nctig
`kpvguvkpg-! ukpeg! ucornkpi! htqo! vjg! vgtokpcn
`eqnqp!ku!tgncvkxgn{!gcu{/!D{!eqpvtcuv-!xgt{!nkvvng!ku
`mpqyp! cdqwv!
`vjg! oketqdkcn! eqoowpkvkgu
`
`tgukfkpi!kp!vjg!nqygt!rctvu!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg
`fwg!vq!ucornkpi!fkhhkewnvkgu!ecwugf!d{!vjg!kpce.
`eguukdknkv{!qh!vjg!kngwo!cpf!vjg!pggf!vq!rtqeguu
`ucorngu!cpcgtqdkecnn{/!Cu!d{!hct!vjg!nctiguv!rctv
`qh!hqqf!fkiguvkqp!cpf!cduqtrvkqp!vcmgu!rnceg!kp
`vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg-! kv! ku! guugpvkcn! vq! qxgteqog
`ucornkpi! fkhhkewnvkgu! kp! qtfgt! vq! qdvckp! c! hwnn
`wpfgtuvcpfkpi!qh!vjg!rtqeguugu!cpf!kpvgtcevkqpu
`vjcv!iq!qp!kp!vjku!rctv!qh!vjg!IK!vtcev/!Kp!cffk.
`vkqp-!dgecwug!vjku!ku!chvgt!vjg!uvqocej-!vjg!hktuv
`tgikqp!qh!vjg!kpvguvkpg!yjgtg!hqqf!cpf!eqoogp.
`ucn! oketqdgu! oggv-! c! hwtvjgt! wpfgtuvcpfkpi! ku
`pgeguuct{!vq!rquukdn{!kphnwgpeg!qt!gxgp!oqfwncvg
`vjg! oketqdkqvc! d{! fkgvct{! cnvgtcvkqpu/! Hwtvjgt.
`oqtg-! vjg! oketqdkqvc!eqorqukvkqp! qh! vjg! uocnn
`kpvguvkpg! okijv! kphnwgpeg! gxgpvu! kp! vjg! nctig
`kpvguvkpg!cpf!yknn!rnc{!cp!gxgp!oqtg!korqtvcpv
`tqng! kp!kpfkxkfwcnu!yjq! jcf! rctv!qt! cnn!qh! vjgkt
`nctig!kpvguvkpg!tgoqxgf/
`
`Rj{ukqnqi{!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg
`Vjg!kpvgtcevkqpu!dgvyggp!vjg!oketqdkqvc!cpf!vjg
`jquv!egnnu!ctg!nctign{!kphnwgpegf!d{!ugxgtcn!rj{ukq.
`nqikecn!hcevqtu/!Vjgug!ecp!dg!fkxkfgf!kpvq!jquv!hce.
`vqtu!uwej!cu!vtcpukv!vkog!]3_-!koowpg!tgurqpug!]4-5_
`cpf! ugetgvqt{! rtqfwevu! )icuvtke! cekf! ]6_-! dkng! ]7_-
`rcpetgcvke!gp|{ogu!]co{ncug-!vt{rukp_!]8_!cpf!jqt.
`oqpgu!]g/i/-!kpuwnkp-!inweciqp_!]9_*-!cpf!gpxktqp.
`ogpvcn! hcevqtu-! uwej! cu! rJ! ];-21_! cpf! fkgvct{
`eqorqpgpvu!]22_/!Vtcpukv!qh!vjg!nkswkf!eqpvgpvu!kp
`vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg!ku!cp!wpfgtuvwfkgf!ctgc!]23_-!dwv
`ykvj!guvkocvgf!vtcpukv!vkogu!dgvyggp!41 okp!cpf
`4/6 j! ]24_-!vtcpukv!ku!hcuvgt!vjcp!hwtvjgt!fqyp!vjg
`IK!vtcev-!tgfwekpi!vjg!itqyvj!qh!oketqqticpkuou
`kp! vjg! nwogp! qh! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg! ]25˜27_/! Vjku
`nkokvgf!itqyvj!ku!cnuq!tgfwegf!d{!vjg!hcev!vjcv-!qh
`vjg!fkgvct{!ectdqj{ftcvgu!rcuukpi!vjtqwij!vjg!IK
`vtcev-!qpn{!vjg!gcukn{!fkiguvkdng!eqorqpgpvu!ecp!dg
`
`cpf-
`
`Mg{yqtfu<!icuvtqkpvguvkpcn!
`vtcev-!IK!vtcev!oqfgn!u{uvgou-!
`ogvcigpqoke-!oketqdkqvc-!
`uocnn!kpvguvkpg
`
`*"+-!)%
`
`21/3328028571;24/3/4/396!«!3118!Hwvwtg!Ogfkekpg!Nvf!!KUUP!2857.1;24
`
`!)3118*!!3)4*-!396˜3;6
`
`396
`
`Page 1
`
`

`

`TGXKGY!˜!Dqqklkpm-!\qgvgpfcn-!Mnggtgdg|go!'!fg!Xqu!
`
`Figure 1. Schematic representation of the anatomy of the human gastrointestinal tract with the average length, pH and
`density of microbiota per segment.
`
`!
`
`Fcvc!dcugf!qp!rwdnkecvkqpu!d{!Gxcpu!cpf!eqnngciwgu-!2;99!];_=!Oqqtg!cpf!Jqnfgtocp-!2;85!]21_=!Jcq!cpf!Ngg-!3115!]22_=!Hcnnkpidqti!cpf!
`eqnngciwgu-!2;;1!]8;_=!Ikndgtv!cpf!eqnngciwgu-!2;99!]91_=!OeFqwicnn!cpf!eqnngciwgu-!2;;4!]92_=!OePgkn!cpf!eqnngciwgu-!2;98!]93_=!
`[qwpidgti!cpf!eqnngciwgu-!2;98!]94_/!Kocig!oqfkhkgf!htqo!]95_/
`
`vcmgp!wr!d{!vjg!jquv!cpf!vjg!oketqdkqvc/!Jgtg-
`vjg!jquv.fgtkxgf!owewu!hqtou!cp!korqtvcpv!ect.
`dqp!uqwteg!hqt!vjg!kngcn!oketqdkqvc-!etgcvkpi!jcdk.
`vcvu! hqt! owequcn! rqrwncvkqpu! vjcv! okijv! dg
`korqtvcpv! hqt! eqnqpk|kpi! nwokpcn! ocvgtkcn! ]27_/
`Vqyctfu!vjg!vgtokpcn!rctv!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg-
`vtcpukv!tcvg!tgfwegu!cpf!vjg!pwodgt!qh!oketqdkcn
`egnnu! kpetgcugu! tcrkfn{-! yjkng! vjg! rtqrqtvkqp! qh
`cpcgtqdke!urgekgu!kpetgcugu!cu!ygnn!]28_/
`Ugetgvqt{! eqorqpgpvu! cpf! gp|{ogu! hqtogf
`d{!vjg!jwocp!dqf{!ckf!vjg!fkiguvkqp!qh!urgekhke
`fkgvct{! eqorqpgpvu! cpf! ctg! ockpn{! ugetgvgf! kp
`vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!Hqt!kpuvcpeg-!dkng!cekfu-!u{p.
`vjguk|gf! d{! vjg! nkxgt! htqo! ejqnguvgtqn-! ctg
`ugetgvgf! kpvq! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg! vq! hceknkvcvg! c
`oqtg! ghhgevkxg! hcv! fgitcfcvkqp! d{! icuvtke! cpf
`rcpetgcvke!nkrcugu!]29_/!Fkhhgtgpv!v{rgu!qh!pwvtkgpv
`fqug.tgurqpukxg!ogejcpkuou!tgiwncvg!vjg!tgngcug
`qh!gp|{ogu!kp!vjg!kpvguvkpg!dwv!cnuq!vjg!rcuucig
`
`vjtqwij!vjg!kpvguvkpg/!Hqt!kpuvcpeg-!icuvtke!gor.
`v{kpi! ku! tgiwncvgf! d{! pgicvkxg! hggfdcem! eqpvtqn
`d{!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg-!yjkej!kp!kvu!vwtp!ku!oqfw.
`ncvgf! d{! vjg! rtgugpeg! qh! urgekhke! hqqf! eqorq.
`pgpvu! kp! vjg! nwogp! qh! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg! ]2;_/
`Oqtgqxgt-! hqqf! gzrquwtg-!nkmg! ejgykpi-! cntgcf{
`uvkowncvgu!ucnkxct{!hnqy! ]31_!cpf!vjg!ugetgvkqp!qh
`fkiguvkxg!gp|{ogu!d{!vjg!rcpetgcu!]32-33_/!Icuvtke
`nkrcug! u{pvjguku! cpf! cevkxkv{! ctg! cnuq! kpfwegf
`wrqp!qtcn!hcv!gzrquwtg!]34_/
`Qpg!qh!vjg!gpxktqpogpvcn!hcevqtu!vjcv!jcu!dggp
`uvwfkgf!oquv!ku!vjg!rJ!ejcpig!fwtkpi!hqqf!vtcpukv
`vjtqwij!vjg!IK!vtcev/!Ogcuwtgogpvu!qh!IK!nwokpcn
`rJ!fcvc!kp!pqtocn!jgcnvj{!xqnwpvggtu!ujqygf!rJu
`tcpikpi! htqo! 6/6! vq! 8/1! kp! vjg! rtqzkocn! uocnn
`kpvguvkpg! )Hkiwtg 2*/! Vjg! rJ! tkugu! itcfwcnn{! vq
`7/6˜8/6!kp!vjg!fkuvcn!kngwo!];_!ecwugf!d{!vjg!dwhhgt.
`kpi!qh!vjg!cekfke!icuvtke!eqpvgpvu!d{!cnmcnkpg!rcp.
`etgcvke! ugetgvkqpu! kp! vjg! rtqzkocn! kngwo/! Yjkng
`
`397
`
`)3118*!!3)4*
`
`%.-.+$!,#'$(#$!&+).*
`
`

`

`Oketqdkcn!eqoowpkvkgu!kp!vjg!jwocp!uocnn!kpvguvkpg!˜!TGXKGY
`
`jwocp!rj{ukqnqi{!ku!ygnn!gswkrrgf!vq!cduqtd!uko.
`rng! uwictu! )k/g/-! inwequg! cpf! icncevqug*! cpf! vq
`tgngcug!oqpquceejctkfgu!htqo!ugxgtcn!fkuceejctkfgu
`)g/i/-!uwetqug-!ncevqug!cpf!ocnvqug*!]35_-!kvu!ecrcekv{
`vq! wvknk|g! qvjgt-! oqtg! eqorngz! rqn{uceejctkfgu! ku
`xgt{! nkokvgf! ]36_/! Vjku! ocvgtkcn! kpenwfgu! rqn{uce.
`ejctkfgu! htqo! eqorqpgpvu! qh! rncpv! egnn! ycnnu
`)kpenwfkpi! egnnwnqug-! z{ncp! cpf! rgevkp*! cu! ygnn! cu
`wpfkiguvgf! uvctej! ]37_/! Vjg! cxckncdknkv{! qh! vjgug
`rqn{uceejctkfgu! hqt! vjg! eqnqpke! oketqdkqvc! kp! c
`pqtocn! Yguvgtp! fkgv! xctkgu! dgvyggp! 27! cpf
`69 i0fc{!]38_/!Qykpi!vq!vjg!hgtogpvcvkqp!qh!vjgug
`wpfkiguvgf! fkgvct{! ectdqj{ftcvgu! vq! ujqtv! ejckp
`hcvv{!cekfu!d{!vjg!eqnqpke!oketqdkqvc!]39_-!vjg!rJ
`ftqru! kp! vjg! egewo! vq! kpetgcug! itcfwcnn{! kp! vjg
`fguegpfkpi!eqnqp!cpf!tgevwo!wr!vq!8/6!];-3;_/!
`
`Oqfgn!u{uvgou!qh!vjg!jwocp!
`uocnn!kpvguvkpg
`Kp!xkvtq
`Vq!ektewoxgpv!vjg!ucornkpi!rtqdngou!cuuqekcvgf
`ykvj! vjg! nqecvkqp! qh! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg! kp! vjg
`jwocp!dqf{-!ugxgtcn!
`!oqfgn!u{uvgou!jcxg
`dggp!ugv!wr!vq!hqnnqy!fkiguvkxg!rtqeguugu!cpf!vjg
`oketqdkcn! eqorqukvkqp! kp! vkog/! Vjgug! kpenwfg
`vjg! eqorwvgt.eqpvtqnngf! oqfgn! fgxgnqrgf! d{
`Oqnn{! cpf! eqnngciwgu! ]41_-! vjg! Ukowncvqt! qh! vjg
`Jwocp!
`Kpvguvkpcn! Oketqdkcn!
`Gequ{uvgo
`)UJKOG*.oqfgn! ! ]42_! cpf! vjg! VPQ! Kpvguvkpcn
`Oqfgn! )VKO*/! Vjgug! u{uvgou! gpcdng! hcuv! tgrtq.
`fwekdng!gzrgtkogpvu!wpfgt!eqpvtqnngf!eqpfkvkqpu-
`cnvjqwij! xcnkfcvkqp! qh! vjgug! u{uvgou! ku! fkhhkewnv
`dgecwug! kv! tgswktgu! eqorctkuqp! ykvj! vjg! nctign{
`kpceeguukdng!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!Kp!cffkvkqp-!vjgtg!ctg
`korqtvcpv!nkokvcvkqpu!kpenwfkpi!vjg!tgrtgugpvcvkxg
`ejctcevgt!qh!vjg!oketqdkqvc!kpqewnwo!wugf!vq!eqn.
`qpk|g!vjg!
`!u{uvgou-!cpf!vjg!cdugpeg!qh!jquv
`egnnu!cpf!owequcn!nc{gt!]37_/!Uvwfkgu!wukpi!jquv!egnn
`nkpgu-! nkmg! Eceq.3! cpf! vjg! owewu! rtqfwekpi
`JV3;.OVZ-!jcxg!dggp!wugf!cu!
`!u{uvgou
`vq!uvwf{!vjg!cfjgtgpeg!qh!rtqdkqvke!uvtckpu!vq!vjg
`eqnqpke! grkvjgnkcn! egnnu! ]43_! qt! kpvguvkpcn! egnn
`tgurqpugu!wrqp!gzrquwtg!vq!owequcn!dcevgtkc!]44_/
`Vq!fcvg-!pq!
`!eq.ewnvwtg!uvwfkgu!hqt!vjg!uocnn
`kpvguvkpg!jcxg!dggp!eqpfwevgf!fwg!vq!cdugpeg!qh
`uwkvcdng!egnn!nkpgu/!Jqygxgt-!cu!nqpi!cu!xcnkfcvkqp
`qh!vjg!rtgfkevkxg!xcnwg!qh!
`!oqfgnu!hqt!vjg!
`!ukvwcvkqp!tgockpu!wprtqxgp-!vjgug!uvwfkgu!yknn
`pqv!tgcnn{!eqpvtkdwvg!vq!qwt!wpfgtuvcpfkpi!qh!vjg
`jquv˜oketqdg!kpvgtcevkqpu/!
`
`Kp!xkxq
`Ugxgtcn! cpkocn! oqfgn! u{uvgou! ctg! ygnn! crrtgek.
`cvgf!fwg!vq!rtcevkecn!tgcuqpu<!ownvkrng!ukvgu!qh!vjg
`IK!
`vtcev-! cu! ygnn! cu! dqvj!
`vjg! cvvcejgf
`
`)g/i/- owequcn*! cpf! nwokpcn! oketqdkqvc! ecp! dg
`ucorngf!cpf!eqorctgf/!Vjg!dguv!
`!cpkocn
`oqfgn! u{uvgo! kp! vgtou! qh! rj{ukqnqi{-! cpcvqo{-
`koowpqnqi{! cpf! oketqdkcn! eqorqukvkqp! ku! vjg
`rki!]45-46_/!Cv!rtgugpv!vjqwij-!vjg!vtcpuncvkqp!htqo
`vjg!cpkocn!vq!vjg!jwocp!ukvwcvkqp!tgockpu!fkhhk.
`ewnv!cpf!pqv!xgt{!ygnn!xcnkfcvgf/!Qpeg!vjku!rtqd.
`ngo! ku! dtkfigf-! vjg! eqodkpcvkqp! qh! igto.htgg
`vgejpqnqi{!)ipqvqdkqvkeu*!cpf!igpgvkecnn{!fghkpgf
`cpkocn!oqfgnu!okijv!etgcvg!hwvwtg!qrrqtvwpkvkgu
`vq!fghkpg! oketqdkcn!geqnqi{!ykvjkp!vjg! fkhhgtgpv
`tgikqpu! qh! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg-! wpfgt! tkiqtqwun{
`eqpvtqnngf!gpxktqpogpvcn!eqpfkvkqpu!]36_/
`Icuvtqgpvgtqnqikuvu! jcxg! gzrnqtgf! xctkqwu
`ogvjqfu! vq! ucorng! vjg! fkhhgtgpv! tgikqpu! qh! vjg
`kpceeguukdng!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!Vjg!fgxgnqrogpv!qh
`cfxcpegf!gpfqueqrke!vqqnu!jcu!ocfg!ucornkpi!qh
`vjg! egewo! xkc! pcucnn{! cfokpkuvgtgf! kpvguvkpcn
`vwdgu!rquukdng!]47_-!qhhgtkpi!rquukdknkvkgu!vq!ucorng
`dqvj! nwokpcn! cpf! owequcn! ukvgu/! Cnvgtpcvkxgn{-
`eqnqpqueqr{! cnnqyu! vjg! eqnngevkqp! qh! ucorngu
`htqo! vjg! kngwo! kp! c! tgncvkxgn{! gcu{-! dwv! swkvg
`kpxcukxg! ocppgt!
`]48_/! Jqygxgt-! wukpi! vjku
`crrtqcej! ucorng! eqnngevkqp! ku! tguvtkevgf! vq! vjg
`fkuvcn!rctv!qh!vjg!kngwo/!Dkqru{!ucornkpi!fwtkpi
`c!
`)rtgxgpvkxg*!
`uwtikecn! qrgtcvkqp! rtqxkfgu
`cpqvjgt! ogcpu! vq! eqnngev! ucorngu! htqo! vjg
`owequcn!rctv!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg!]49-4;_/
`Ugxgtcn! tgugctejgtu! jcxg! ektewoxgpvgf! vjg
`kpceeguukdknkv{!rtqdngo!qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg!d{
`wukpi!
`!oqfgn!u{uvgou/!Qpg!vjcv!jcu!dggp
`wugf! kp! ugxgtcn! uvwfkgu! ku! vjg! kngquvqo{! rcvkgpv
`]51˜53_<!c!rgtuqp!yjq!wpfgtygpv!uwtikecn!tgoqxcn
`qh!jku!qt!jgt!eqnqp!fwg!vq!c!fkugcug!qeewttkpi!kp
`vjku! rctv! qh! vjg! IK! vtcev! )g/i/-! Etqjp”u! fkugcug-
`wnegtcvkxg! eqnkvku-! ecpegt! qt! rqn{rquku*/! Fwtkpi
`vjku!qrgtcvkqp-!vjg!vgtokpcn!rctv!qh!vjg!kngwo!ycu
`eqppgevgf!vq!gkvjgt!vjg!cpwu!)ecnngf!kngcn!rqwej*
`qt!vq!c!uvqoc!kp!vjg!cdfqokpcn!ycnn!qh!vjg!rcvkgpv
`)ecnngf!Dtqqmg!kngquvqo{*!]51_/!Cu!c!eqpugswgpeg-
`eqnngevkqp!qh!vjg!kngquvqo{!ghhnwgpv!qhhgtu!wpkswg
`cpf!pqpkpxcukxg!ceeguu!vq!vjg!nwokpcn!oketqdkqvc
`qh!vjg!fkuvcn!kngwo/!Oqtgqxgt-!ucornkpi!cv!fkhhgt.
`gpv! vkog! rqkpvu! ykvj! c! ukping! kngquvqo{! rcvkgpv
`qhhgtu!qrrqtvwpkvkgu!vq!kpxguvkicvg!vjg!uvcdknkv{!qh
`vjg! oketqdkqvc! cu! uwej! qt! kp! tgncvkqp! vq! fkgvct{
`ejcpigu!qt!kpvgtxgpvkqpu!]3-54˜56_/!
`
`Oketqdkcn!fkxgtukv{
`Qxgt!vjg! rcuv! fgecfg-! vjg! mpqyngfig! qh!jwocp
`oketqdkcn! fkxgtukv{! kp! vjg! IK! vtcev! jcu! dggp
`gzrcpfgf!d{!d{rcuukpi!ewnvkxcvkqp!uvtcvgikgu!ykvj
`oqngewnct!vgejpkswgu/!Vjku!gzrnqukqp!qh!kphqtoc.
`vkqp!ku!ockpn{!hwgnngf!d{!vjg!wug!qh!uocnn!uwdwpkv
`tkdquqocn! TPC! )27U tTPC*! igpg! ugswgpegu! cu
`
`%.-.+$!,#'$(#$!&+).*
`
`yyy/hwvwtgogfkekpg/eqo
`
`398
`
`Page 3
`
`

`

`TGXKGY!˜!Dqqklkpm-!\qgvgpfcn-!Mnggtgdg|go!'!fg!Xqu!
`
`ewnvwtg.kpfgrgpfgpv! octmgtu! qh! oketqdkcn! vczc/
`Fkhhgtgpv!27U!tTPC.dcugf!vgejpkswgu!ctg!uwkvc.
`dng!hqt!fkhhgtgpv!kpxguvkicvkqpu-!kpenwfkpi!kfgpvkhk.
`ecvkqp! qh! oketqdkcn! urgekgu-! swcpvkhkecvkqp! qh
`oketqdkcn!vczc-!qt!dtqcf!eqorctkuqpu!qh!oketqdkcn
`eqoowpkvkgu! ]57_/! Uvwfkgu! dcugf! qp! vjgug! vgej.
`pkswgu! tgxgcngf! vjcv! vjg! oclqtkv{! qh! kpvguvkpcn
`oketqdgu! dgnqpi! vq! rtgxkqwun{! wpmpqyp! )qt
`wpewnvkxcvgf*! nkpgcigu! ]57˜5;_/! Kp! cffkvkqp-! kv
`ujqygf! vjcv! vjg! owequc.cuuqekcvgf! dcevgtkcn
`eqoowpkv{! ku! jquv! urgekhke! cpf! wpkhqton{! fku.
`vtkdwvgf!cnqpi!vjg!IK!vtcev!]49-61_-!cnvjqwij!vjgtg
`ku! cnuq! gxkfgpeg! vjcv! vjg! dcevgtkc! fq! pqv! eqog
`kpvq! eqpvcev! ykvj! vjg! owequc! ]62_/! Kp! vgtou! qh
`oketqdkcn! pwodgtu-! vjg! uvqocej! cpf! rtqzkocn
`
`uocnn! kpvguvkpg! eqpvckp! tgncvkxgn{! nqy! coqwpvu
`dgecwug!qh!nqy!rJ!cpf!tcrkf!nwokpcn!hnwz!kp!vjku
`tgikqp!]63_/!Cekf.vqngtcpv!ncevqdceknnk!cpf!uvtgrvq.
`eqeek! rtgfqokpcvg! kp! vjg! wrrgt! uocnn! kpvguvkpg/
`Vqyctfu! vjg! fkuvcn! kngwo-! oketqdkcn! pwodgtu! cu
`ygnn!cu!oketqdkcn!fkxgtukv{!kpetgcugu!)Hkiwtg 2*!]22_/
`Qpn{!c!uocnn!pwodgt!qh!uvwfkgu!crrnkgf!oqnge.
`wnct!vgejpkswgu!vq!kfgpvkh{!vjg!oketqdkcn!rqrwnc.
`vkqp! rtgugpv! kp! tgikqpu! qh! vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg
`)Hkiwtg 3*/!Ycpi!cpf!eqnngciwgu!fgoqpuvtcvgf!vjcv
`! cpf!
`! enwuvgtu! ZKXc! cpf
`ZK!dgnqpigf!vq!vjg!fqokpcpv!urgekgu!rtgugpv!kp
`dkqru{!ucorngu!htqo!vjg!kngcn!owequc!qh!qpg!kpfk.
`xkfwcn! ]59_/! Kp!c!uwdugswgpv! uvwf{-!kv! ycu!ujqyp
`vjcv!
`!cpf!
`!ygtg!fqokpcpv
`
`Figure 2. Overview of molecular studies performed to study the phylogenetic distribution of 16S rRNA gene sequences
`in the human jejunum and distil ileum.
`
`!+
`
`Tguwnvu!dcugf!qp!ugswgpeg!cpcn{uku!qh!iwv!eqpvgpvu!htqo!vjtgg!gnfgtn{!kpfkxkfwcnu!cv!cwvqru{/
`‰Tguwnvu!dcugf!qp!ugswgpeg!cpcn{uku!qh!kngcn!ghhnwgpv!htqo!ugxgp!kngquvqo{!rcvkgpvu/
`
`399
`
`)3118*!!3)4*
`
`%.-.+$!,#'$(#$!&+).*
`
`

`

`Oketqdkcn!eqoowpkvkgu!kp!vjg!jwocp!uocnn!kpvguvkpg!˜!TGXKGY
`
`kp! dkqrukgu! qh! vjg! fkuvcn! kngwo! yjgtgcu! vjg
`.
`.
`! itqwr! )oquvn{
`uvtgrvqeqeek*!cpf!
`!ygtg!oquv!cdwp.
`fcpv! kp! lglwpcn! dkqru{! ucorngu! ]64_/! Kp! cpqvjgt
`
`Hkiwtg!4/!Uejgocvke!tgrtgugpvcvkqp!qh!eqpuvtwevkqp!cpf!
`uetggpkpi!uvtcvgikgu!qh!ogvcigpqoke!nkdtctkgu!htqo!
`icuvtqkpvguvkpcn!vtcev!ucorngu/
`
`uvwf{-!oqngewnct!vgejpkswgu!ygtg!crrnkgf!vq!kngcn
`cpf! lglwpcn! eqpvgpvu! eqnngevgf! ykvjkp! ugxgtcn
`jqwtu! chvgt! vjg! fgegcug! qh! vjtgg! kpfkxkfwcnu
`)ecwugu!qh!fgcvj!ygtg!cqtvke!fkuqtfgtu!qt!wvgtkpg
`egtxkecn!ecpegt*/!Vjg!tguwnvu!ujqygf!vjcv!uvtgrvq.
`eqeek-! gpvgtqeqeek-! ncevqdceknnk-!
`cpf!
`! ygtg! coqpi! vjg! fqokpcpv
`itqwru!rtgugpv!]28_/!Tgegpvn{-!vjg!oketqdkcn!fkxgt.
`ukv{!cpf!uvcdknkv{!qh!kngcn!ghhnwgpv!ucorngu!qh!ugxgp
`kngquvqo{!rcvkgpvu!ygtg!kpxguvkicvgf!d{!fgpcvwt.
`kpi!itcfkgpv!ign!gngevtqrjqtguku!hqnnqygf!d{!enqp.
`kpi! cpf! ugswgpekpi! qh! c! tcpfqo! enqpg! nkdtct{-
`tgxgcnkpi! jquv.urgekhke! eqoowpkvkgu! qh! dcevgtkc
`ykvj! nqy! vgorqtcn! uvcdknkv{! qxgt! c! rgtkqf! qh
`3 yggmu!eqorctgf!ykvj!vjg!tgncvkxgn{!uvcdng!hgecn
`oketqdkqvc!]65_/!Enquvtkfkc!rtqxgf!vq!dg!vjg!fqok.
`pcpv! vczc! kp! cnn! kpfkxkfwcnu! cpf! uvtgrvqeqeek-
`twokpqeqeek!cpf!gwdcevgtkc!ygtg!rtgugpv!kp!oquv
`kpfkxkfwcnu!)Dqqklkpm!
`-!Wprwdnkujgf!Fcvc*/!Vjg!uvwfkgu
`fguetkdgf!cdqxg!cntgcf{! icxg!kpfkecvkqpu!hqt! vjg
`oketqdkqvc! eqorqukvkqp! kp! vjg! fkhhgtgpv! tgikqpu
`qh!vjg!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!Jqygxgt-!hct!oqtg!ewnvwtg.
`kpfgrgpfgpv!uvwfkgu-! kpenwfkpi! qp! uocnn! kpvguvk.
`pcn! ocvgtkcn! htqo! c! ykfg! xctkgv{! qh! kpfkxkfwcnu-
`ctg!guugpvkcn!vq!igv!c!eqorngvg!rgturgevkxg!qh!vjgug
`jquv.urgekhke!eqoowpkvkgu/
`
`Cu!vjg!chqtgogpvkqpgf!uvwfkgu!ctg!nctign{!dcugf!qp
`27U tTPC!igpg!ugswgpegu-!vjg!tguwnvu!ecppqv!dg
`kpvgtrtgvgf!dg{qpf!vjg!fguetkrvkqp!qh!vjg!oketq.
`dkcn!fkxgtukv{/!D{!eqpvtcuv-!ogvcigpqokeu!ecp!rtq.
`xkfg!c!uwtxg{!qh!vjg!oketqdkcn!fkxgtukv{-!cu!ygnn!cu
`cp!kpxgpvqt{!qh!rqvgpvkcn!hwpevkqpu-!vjgtgd{!qhhgt.
`kpi! c! ogcpu! vq! nkpm! fkxgtukv{! vq! hwpevkqpcnkv{/
`Jqygxgt-! vjg! ghhgevu! vjcv! ucorng! jcpfnkpi! cpf
`enqpkpi!dkcu!okijv!jcxg!qp!qz{igp.ugpukvkxg!igp.
`gtc! nkmg!
`! cpf! IE.tkej! qticpkuou! nkmg
`-!tgurgevkxgn{-!ujqwnf!dg!vcmgp!kpvq
`ceeqwpv/! Vjg! vgto! ogvcigpqokeu! tghgtu! vq
`igpqoke!cpcn{uku!qh!c!eqoowpkv{!d{!eqodkpkpi
`vjg! eqortgjgpukxg! cpcn{uku! qh! cp! qticpkuo”u
`igpgvke!ocvgtkcn!)igpqokeu*!ykvj!vjg!ugrctcvg!uvc.
`vkuvkecn!cpcn{ugu!qh!c!ugv!qh!tgncvgf!fcvc!)ogvc.cpcn.
`{uku*!
`]66-67_/! C! ogvcigpqoke!
`nkdtct{! ecp! dg
`eqpuvtwevgf!d{!gzvtcevkpi!FPC!htqo!vjg!oketq.
`dkcn!eqoowpkv{!wpfgt!uvwf{!hqnnqygf!d{!enqpkpi
`qh!uocnn!qt!nctig!FPC!htciogpvu!kp!c!uwkvcdng!jquv
`)wuwcnn{!
`*!xgevqt!)Hkiwtg 4*/!Rtqxkfgf!vjcv!vjg
`enqpgf! FPC! htciogpvu! ctg! nctig! gpqwij! vq
`gpeqfg! eqorngvg! qrgtqpu! vjg{! oc{! fktgev! vjg
`u{pvjguku! qh! eqorngz! oqngewngu! qt! gp|{ogu! kp
`vjg!jgvgtqnqiqwu!jquv!wugf!hqt!enqpkpi!]67_/!Vjg
`ewttgpv! uetggpkpi! crrtqcejgu! qh! ogvcigpqogu
`ecp! dg! ugswgpeg.ftkxgp! qt! hwpevkqp.ftkxgp! ]68_-
`
`%.-.+$!,#'$(#$!&+).*
`
`yyy/hwvwtgogfkekpg/eqo
`
`39;
`
`

`

`TGXKGY!˜!Dqqklkpm-!\qgvgpfcn-!Mnggtgdg|go!'!fg!Xqu!
`
`cpf! vjg! rquukdknkvkgu! cpf! nkokvcvkqpu! qh! vjgug
`crrtqcejgu! ctg! uwooctk|gf!
`kp! Vcdng! 2! cpf
`fkuewuugf!dgnqy/
`
`Vjgug! uvtcvgikgu! ocmg! wug! qh! gkvjgt! RET! qt
`j{dtkfk|cvkqp! crrtqcejgu! vq! uetggp! hqt! enqpgu
`vjcv! eqpvckp! igpgu! qh! kpvgtguv-! qt! tcpfqo
`ugswgpekpi! qh! ogvcigpqoke! enqpgu/! Vjg! hktuv
`crrtqcej!ycu! wugf! vq!eqorctg! vyq!nctig.kpugtv
`)$51 md*! ogvcigpqoke!
`nkdtctkgu! eqpuvtwevgf
`htqo! FPC! gzvtcevgf! htqo! hgecn! ucorngu! qh
`jgcnvj{! kpfkxkfwcnu! cpf! rcvkgpvu! ykvj! Etqjp”u
`fkugcug!)EF*/!Vjku!uvwf{!tgxgcngf!vjcv!vjg!fkxgt.
`ukv{!qh!vjg!
`!ycu!itgcvn{!tgfwegf!kp!EF
`rcvkgpvu!]69_/!C!tcpfqo!ugswgpekpi!crrtqcej!ycu
`wugf!kp!vjg!cpcn{uku!qh!vjg!jwocp!IK!vtcev!xktcn
`ogvcigpqog!nkdtct{!eqpuvtwevgf!htqo!c!hgecn!uco.
`rng!cpf!tgxgcngf!cdqwv!2311!xktcn!igpqv{rgu!]6;_/
`Cpqvjgt! tgegpvn{! rwdnkujgf! uvwf{! ocfg! wug! qh
`vtcpurquqp.ckfgf! ecrvwtg! )VTCEC*! vq! kpxguvk.
`icvg! rncuokf.gpeqfgf! vtckvu! kp! vjg! jwocp! iwv
`gequ{uvgo-!cpf!igpgu!gpeqfkpi!hqt!rjqurjqguvg.
`tcug! qt! rjqurjqj{ftqncug! gp|{ogu! eqwnf! dg
`fgvgevgf!]71_/!Kp!cffkvkqp-!nctig.uecng!ugswgpekpi
`qh! c! uocnn.kpugtv! nkdtct{! )3˜21! md*! qh! vjg! hgecn
`oketqdkqvc!ycu!tgegpvn{!tgrqtvgf!cpf!c!fgfkecvgf
`
`eqorctkuqp! ykvj! vjg! jwocp! igpqog! tgxgcngf
`gptkejogpv!qh!igpgu!gpeqfkpi!hwpevkqpu!tgncvgf
`vq!vjg!ogvcdqnkuo!qh-!hqt!kpuvcpeg-!in{ecpu!cpf
`cokpq!cekfu!]72_/!Kp!vjku!uvwf{-!
`!)qpg!qh
`vjg! rtgfqokpcpv! itqwru! kp! vjg! oketqdkqvc! qh
`jgcnvj{!kpfkxkfwcnu*!eqwnf!pqv!dg!fgvgevgf-!fgo.
`qpuvtcvkpi! vjg! ukipkhkecpv! kphnwgpeg! qh! FPC
`kuqncvkqp!cu!ygnn!cu!ejqkeg!qh!enqpkpi!u{uvgo!qp
`vjg!eqpuvtwevkqp!qh!vjg!ogvcigpqoke!nkdtct{/!
`Vqqnu! hqt! eqorctcvkxg! cpf! rquv.ogvcigp.
`qoke!cpcn{ugu!ctg!kpfkurgpucdng!vq!wpeqxgt!vjg
`ygcnvj! qh! kphqtocvkqp! gpeqfgf! d{! vjg! nctign{
`uecvvgtgf! rkgegu! qh! FPC! qh! wpmpqyp! urgekgu
`rtgugpv!kp!cp{!ogvcigpqoke!nkdtct{/!Hqt!vjg!tg.
`cuugodnkpi!qh!vjg!ugswgpegf!igpqogu-!uqhvyctg
`rcemcigu! jcxg! dggp! fgxgnqrgf-! dwv! fwg! vq! vjg
`koogpug!igpqoke!eqorngzkv{!qh!oketqdkcn!eqo.
`owpkvkgu-!ugxgtcn!uekgpvkuvu!rtghgt!vq!ektewoxgpv
`vjku! eqorwvcvkqpcnn{! kpvgpukxg! uvgr! ]73_/! Eqo.
`rctcvkxg!ogvcigpqog!cpcn{uku!ecp!dg!rgthqtogf
`qp!tcy!fcvc.ugvu!vq!tgxgcn-!hqt!kpuvcpeg-!pkejg.
`urgekhke!igpg.hwpevkqp!gptkejogpv!qt!vq!rtgfkev
`fkhhgtgpegu! kp! ukvg.urgekhke! ghhgevkxg! igpqog
`uk|gu!]74-75_/!
`Cu! vjg! hkgnf! qh! ogvcigpqokeu! ku! uvknn! kp! kvu
`kphcpe{-! eqpuvtwevkqp! cpf! cpcn{ugu! qh! ogvc.
`igpqogu! htqo! fkiguvkxg! gequ{uvgou-! gurgekcnn{
`
`Table 1. Comparison of available screening methods.
`Screening method
`Screening principle
`Advantages
`Sequence-driven
`RET!qt!j{dtkfk|cvkqp!
`
`FPC!ugswgpeg!
`eqpugpuwu
`
`Pq!rtqdngou!ykvj!jgvgtqnqiqwu!
`igpg!gzrtguukqp
`
`Tcpfqo!ugswgpekpi
`
`Ugswgpekpi!d{!
`rtkogt!ycnmkpi
`
`Pq!rtqdngou!ykvj!jgvgtqnqiqwu!
`igpg!gzrtguukqp
`
`Disadvantages
`
`Tgswktgu!c!fcvcdcug!cpf!cpcn{ugu!qh!vjg!
`FPC!ugswgpeg!eqpugpuwu!
`Pq!iwctcpvgg!vq!ceswktg!eqorngvg!hqtou!
`qh!igpgu!qt!igpg!enwuvgtu!
`Tgncvkxgn{!gzrgpukxg
`Jkij!tgfwpfcpe{!qh!igpgu!qh!
`okpqt kpvgtguv
`Qtkikpcn!jquv!urgekgu!ecppqv!dg!kfgpvkhkgf
`Igpgu!qh!kpvgtguv!oc{!dg!kpcevkxcvgf!
`d{!vtcpurquqpu!
`Qpn{!crrnkecdng!vq!kuqncvgf!urgekgu
`Fkhhkewnvkgu!vq!tgugodng!eqpvkiu!hqt!jkijn{!
`tgrgvkvkxg!igpqogu!fwg!vq!ujqtv!
`)€211!dcug!rckt*!ugswgpegu
`
`Ghhkekgpv!yc{!vq!uvwf{!hwpevkqpu!
`gpeqfgf!d{!c!nctig!tcpig!
`qh!rncuokfu
`Hwpevkqpcn!igpgu!ecp!fktgevn{!
`dg!nkpmgf!vq!urgekgu
`Nctig!coqwpvu!qh!FPC!cv!
`tgncvkxgn{!nqy!equvu!
`
`Vtcpurquqp.ckfgf!ecrvwtg!
`qh!rncuokfu!)VTCEC*
`
`Rncuokf!vciikpi!
`ykvj!vtcpurquqpu
`
`Qticpkuo.vctigvgf!
`ugswgpekpi!
`
`Rctcnngn!FPC!
`r{tqugswgpekpi
`
`Function-driven
`Gp|{og.cevkxkv{!uetggpkpi Fgvgevcdng!ejcpigu!
`fwg!vq!gp|{og!cevkxkv{!
`)g/i/-!jcnq!hqtocvkqp*
`Vtcrrkpi!vjg!qrgtqp!
`kpfwegf!d{!c!uwduvtcvg!
`cpf!uqtvkpi!d{!
`hnwqtguegpeg.cevkxcvgf!
`egnn!uqtvkpi
`
`Uwduvtcvg.kpfwegf!igpg!
`gzrtguukqp!)UKIGZ*
`
`Eqorngvgn{!pqxgn!igpgu!okijv!
`dg!fgvgevgf/!Eqorngvg!hqto!qh!
`igpg!qt!enwuvgt!ecp!dg!cpcn{|gf
`Hcuv!cpf!ejgcr!
`Uwduvtcvgu!vcmgp!wr!d{!vjg!
`e{vqrncuo!ecp!dg!wugf!kp!vjg!
`pcvkxg!hqto
`
`Ncdqt!kpvgpukxg
`Jgvgtqnqiqwu!gzrtguukqp!cpf!ugetgvkqp!
`guugpvkcn!hqt!fgvgevkqp
`Wrvcmg!qh!uwduvtcvg!guugpvkcn!hqt!fgvgevkqp
`Fgrgpfgpv!qp!tgeqipkvkqp!qh!vjg!rtqoqvgt!
`d{!jquv!vtcpuetkrvkqp!ocejkpgt{
`Ugpukvkxg!vq!qtkgpvcvkqp!qh!hwpevkqpcn!igpgu
`
`3;1
`
`)3118*!!3)4*
`
`%.-.+$!,#'$(#$!&+).*
`
`Page 6
`
`

`

`Oketqdkcn!eqoowpkvkgu!kp!vjg!jwocp!uocnn!kpvguvkpg!˜!TGXKGY
`
`vjg! uocnn! kpvguvkpg-! ctg! uvknn! nkokvgf/! Ykvj! vjg
`eqpvkpwqwu!fgxgnqrogpv!qh!pgy!uetggpkpi!ogvj.
`qfqnqikgu! cpf! pgy! ugswgpekpi! vgejpkswgu-! nkmg
`565!r{tqugswgpekpi! ]76_-!cpf!nkpmgf!vq!vjcv!vjg
`fgetgcug!kp!equvu-!vjg!ygcnvj!qh!kphqtocvkqp!htqo
`ogvcigpqoke!
`ugswgpeg.dcugf!
`cpcn{uku! yknn
`kpetgcug! kp! vjg!pgct!hwvwtg/!C! tgegpvn{!kpkvkcvgf
`qticpkuo.vctigvgf! crrtqcej! vjcv! ocmgu! wug! qh
`vjku! pqxgn! r{tqugswgpekpi! vgejpkswg! ckou! vq
`fgnkxgt!vjg!hwnn.igpqog!ugswgpegu!qh!211!tgrtg.
`ugpvcvkxg!urgekgu!htqo!vjg!fkuvcn!iwv!oketqdkqvc
`ykvjkp! 4 {gctu! )vjg! Jwocp! Iwv! Oketqdkqog
`Kpkvkcvkxg! ]JIOK_=! ]212_*/! Hqt! vjg! tgvtkgxcn! qh
`ugngevgf!pqpewnvwtgf!tgrtgugpvcvkxgu-!vjg!eqpuqt.
`vkwo! rtqrqugf! vjg! wug! qh! igto.htgg! okeg! ]77_
`eqodkpgf!ykvj!owewu!kuqncvkqp!d{!ncugt.ecrvwtg
`oketqfkuugevkqp! ]78-79_/! Vjg! ugswgpeg! kphqtoc.
`vkqp!tgngcugf!htqo!vjku!rtqlgev!ecp!rtqxkfg!c!mg{
`tghgtgpeg!hqt!ogvcigpqog!rtqlgevu!cpf!yknn!hwt.
`vjgt! ecvcn{|g! vjg! fgxgnqrogpv! qh! eqorctcvkxg
`cpf!rquv.igpqokeu!vqqnu/
`
`Yjgtgcu! ugswgpeg.ftkxgp! cpcn{uku! ku! pgeguuctkn{
`nkokvgf! vq! vjg! fkueqxgt{! qh! igpgu! kp! rtgxkqwun{
`fguetkdgf! hcoknkgu-! hwpevkqp.ftkxgp! uetggpkpi! qh
`nctig.kpugtv!nkdtctkgu!gpcdngu!vjg!fkueqxgt{!qh!pgy
`encuugu!qh!igpgu!ykvj!urgekhke!hwpevkqpu/!Kv!tgswktgu
`hwpevkqpcn! vtcpuetkrvkqp! cpf! vtcpuncvkqp! qh! vjg
`ogvcigpqog!enqpg!kp!vjg!jgvgtqnqiqwu!jquv!wugf
`hqt!nkdtct{!eqpuvtwevkqp/!Kp!cffkvkqp-!hqt!cv!ngcuv!c
`nctig!rctv!qh!vjg!hwpevkqpcn!uetggpkpi!ghhqtvu-!ugetg.
`vkqp!qh!vjg!gpeqfgf!rtqfwev)u*!ku!tgswktgf!hqt!rquk.
`vkxg!enqpg!kfgpvkhkecvkqp/!Ikxgp!vjg!hngzkdknkv{!qh!vjg
`gpfqigpqwu!vtcpuetkrvkqp!cpf!vtcpuncvkqp!ocejkp.
`gt{! qh!
`-! kv! ku! rtgfkevgf! vjcv! wr! vq! 51&! qh
`gp|{ocvke! rqvgpvkcn! htqo! gpxktqpogpvcn! FPC
`oc{!uweeguuhwnn{!dg!gzrtguugf!kp!
`!d{!tcpfqo
`enqpkpi!
`]7;_/! Ogvcigpqoke! uvwfkgu! vjcv! wugf
`gp|{og!cevkxkv{.dcugf!uetggpkpi!ngf!vq!vjg!fkueqx.
`gt{!qh!pqxgn!j{ftqncug!igpgu!kp!twogp!dcevgtkc!]81_-
`".inwecpcug!igpgu!kp!vjg!nctig!dqygn!qh!okeg!]82_-
`cpvkdkqvke! tgukuvcpeg! igpgu! kp! vjg! qtcn! ecxkv{! ]83_-
`cpf! igpgu! gpeqfkpi! nkrqn{vke! gp|{ogu! cpf! rjqu.
`rjcvcugu!kp!eqorquv!]84_/!Uetggpkpi!hqt!itqyvj!qp
`ugxgtcn! ectdqp.uqwtegu! qh! cp! kngcn! owequc! nkdtct{
`kfgpvkhkgf!ugxgtcn!enqpgu!ecrcdng!qh!z{ncp!cpf!egnnq.
`dkqug!fgitcfcvkqp!)Ngengte!O-!Rgtu/!Eqoo/*/!Cu!vjg!tguwnvu
`tgswktg! vjg! okpkpi! qh! tgncvkxgn{! nctig! igpqoke
`nkdtctkgu!qp!kpfkecvqt!cict!ogfkc!qt!nkswkf!ogfkwo
`vq!qdvckp!2˜6!rqukvkxgu!rgt!gp|{ocvke!uetggp-!vjg{
`ctg!swkvg!ncdqt!kpvgpukxg!]81_/
`Gptkejogpv! uvgru! hqt! oketqqticpkuou! jctdqt.
`kpi! fguktgf! vtckvu! jcxg! tgegpvn{! dggp! gornq{gf
`dghqtg!nkdtct{!eqpuvtwevkqp!vq!tgfweg!vjg!pwodgt
`
`qh!vguvgf!enqpgu!cpf!vq!kpetgcug!vjg!coqwpv!qh!jkvu
`kp! c! uetggp! ]85_/! Ctiwogpvu! cickpuv! gptkejogpvu
`ctg!vjg!hcxqtkpi!qh!vjg!hcuv.itqykpi!cpf!ewnvwtcdng
`rctv!qh!c!oketqdkcn!eqoowpkv{-!cpf!nquu!qh!oketq.
`dkcn!fkxgtukv{!]86_/!Gptkejogpv!ewnvwtgu!eqodkpgf
`ykvj! ogvcigpqoke! cpcn{uku! jcxg! pqv! {gv! dggp
`crrnkgf! vq! nkdtctkgu! qh! kpvguvkpcn! qtkikp! cu! oquv
`tgugctejgtu!ctg!oqtg!kpvgtguvgf!kp!vjg!qxgtcnn!hwpe.
`vkqpcnkv{!qh!vjg!oketqdkqvc!tcvjgt!vjcp!tgvtkgxkpi
`oketqqticpkuou!ykvj!fguktgf!hwpevkqpu/!
`Tgegpvn{-!c!jkij!vjtqwijrwv!uetggpkpi!uvtcvgi{-
`vgtogf!
`uwduvtcvg.kpfwegf!
`igpg.gzrtguukqp
`)UKIGZ*! uetggpkpi-! dcugf! qp! vjg! cevkxcvkqp! qh
`ecvcdqnke! igpgu! d{! xctkqwu! uwduvtcvgu! kp! eqpegtv
`ykvj! hnwqtguegpeg! cevkxcvgf! egnn! uqtvkpi! )HCEU*-
`ycu! rwdnkujgf! ]87_/! Vjku! uetggpkpi! vqqn! ocmgu
`ugok.cwvqocvgf!jkij!vjtqwijrwv!ugngevkqp!qh!rqu.
`kvkxg!enqpgu!rquukdng!]88_/!Jqygxgt-!korqtvcpv!eqp.
`uvtckpvu! qh! vjku! crrtqcej! ctg! rtgugpvgf! d{! vjg
`tgswktgogpvu! tgncvgf! vq! tgeqipkvkqp! )cpf! vtcpu.
`rqtv*! qh! vjg! kpfwekpi! uwduvtcvg! cu! ygnn! cu! vjg
`tgiwncvgf! rtqoqvqt! d{! vjg! eqttgurqpfkpi!
`.
`cevkpi! hcevqt! vjcv! ecp! gkvjgt! dg! gpeqfgf! d{! vjg
`enqpgf!kpugtv!qt!vjg!gzrtguukqp!jquv/!Cu!vjku!vgej.
`pkswg! ku! tcvjgt! pqxgn! kv! jcu! pqv! dggp! crrnkgf! vq
`ocp{! ogvcigpqoke!
`nkdtctkgu! {gv-! cnvjqwij
`cvvgorvu!vq!uetggp!c!ogvcigpqog!htqo!kpvguvkpcn
`qtkikp!ctg!qpiqkpi!]Octejguk!LT-!Rgtu/!Eqoo_/!
`Cp! cnvgtpcvkxg! hwpevkqp.ftkxgp! crrtqcej! ku
`hqnnqygf!yjgp!
`!gzrtguugf!igpgu!ctg!wugf!cu
`octmgtu!hqt!enqpg!ugngevkqp!rtkqt!vq!ugswgpekpi/
`Cu! cp! gzcorng-! yg! jcxg! gornq{gf! ugswgpegu
`tgvtkgxgf! htqo! TPC! hkpigtrtkpvkpi! rtqhkngu! qh
`vjg! kngcn! oketqdkqvc! vq! vtceg! vjg! gpeqfkpi
`ogvcigpqoke! enqpgu! kp! cp! kngcn! ghhnwgpv! ogvc.
`igpqoke!hquokf!nkdtct{/!Ugxgtcn!
`!gzrtguugf
`igpgu! ykvj! gkvjgt! wpmpqyp!
`hwpevkqpu! qt
`kpxqnxgf!kp!ectdqj{ftcvg!ogvcdqnkuo!eqwnf!uwe.
`eguuhwnn{! dg! fgvgevgf! kp! vjg! nkdtct{! cpf! uwdug.
`swgpv! cpcn{uku! qh!
`kpugtv! ugswgpegu! qh! vjg
`gpeqfkpi!nctig.kpugtv!enqpgu!ku!ewttgpvn{!qpiqkpi
`-!Wprwdnkujgf!Fcvc_/!
`]Dqqklkpm!EEIO!
`
`Eqpenwukqp!
`Vjg!oketqdkcn!gequ{uvgo!tgukfkpi!kp!vjg!jwocp
`iwv! ku! c! swkvg! eqorngz! qpg! vq! uvwf{-! cu! ocp{
`hcevqtu-! uwej! cu! oketqdkqvc-! fkgvct{! eqorq.
`pgpvu-! jquv! igpqv{rg! cpf! fkiguvkxg! gp|{ogu-
`kpvgtrnc{/! Kp! cffkvkqp-! vjg! ejcnngpigu! qh! uocnn
`kpvguvkpcn! oketqdkqvc! ucornkpi! rtqxkfg! jwtfngu
`kp! tgugctej! ckokpi! vq! uvwf{! vjku! tgikqp! qh! vjg
`jwocp! IK! vtcev! d{! oqngewnct! vgejpkswgu/! Vjg
`hgy!uvwfkgu!cxckncdng!ujqygf!vjcv!urgekgu!dgnqpi.
`kpi!vq!vjg!rj{nqigpgvke!rj{nc!qh!
`-!
`-!
`!qt! #.
`! ygtg
`
`%.-.+$!,#'$(#$!&+).*
`
`yyy/hwvwtgogfkekpg/eqo
`
`3;2
`
`Page 7
`
`

`

`TGXKGY!˜!Dqqklkpm-!\qgvgpfcn-!Mnggtgdg|go!'!fg!Xqu!
`
`coqpi!vjg!oquv!cdwpfcpv/!Ykvj!vjg!eqpvkpw.
`qwu!kpetgcug!qh!ewnvwtg.kpfgrgpfgpv!ogvjqfu!cu
`ygnn!cu!cxckncdknkv{!cpf!xcnkfcvkqp!qh!oqfgn!u{u.
`vgou-! tgugctejgtu! yknn! dg! rtqxkfgf! ykvj! cp
`kpetgcukpi!vqqndqz!vq!tgxgcn!oqtg!fgvcknu!qh!vjg
`fkxgtukv{! cpf! hwpevkqpcnkv{! qh! vjg! oketqdkqvc
`tgukfkpi!kp!vjg!jwocp!uocnn!kpvguvkpg/!Vjku!yknn
`tguwnv! kp! cp! kortqxgf! wpfgtuvcpfkpi! qh! vjg
`oketqdkcn! rtqeguugu! vjcv! qeewt! kp! vjku! nctign{
`kpc