1
`
`
` 1 UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`
`
` 2 - - -
`
`
` 3 BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
` 4 - - -
`
` 5 INTEL CORP., CAVIUM, LLC, and DELL, INC.
`
` 6 Petitioners
`
` 7 v.
`
` 8 ALACRITECH, INC.
`
` 9 Patent Owner
`
`10
`
`11 - - -
`
`12 Case IPR2018-00226(Patent 7,124,205)
` Case IPR2018-00234(Patent 8.805,948)
`13 Case IPR2018-00401(Patent 7,945,699)
`
`14 - - -
`
`15
`
`16 Record of Oral Hearing
`
`17 Held: October 18, 2019
`
`18 10:00 a.m. (PT)
`
`19
`
`20 - - -
`
`21
` BEFORE: DANIEL N. FISHMAN
`22
` CHARLES J. BOUDREAU
`23
` Administrative Patent Judges
`24
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`2
`
`
` 1 APPEARANCES:
`
`
`
` 2
`
`
` 3 ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER INTEL CORP.:
`
` 4 GARLAND STEPHENS, ESQ.
` Weil, Gotshal & Manges
` 5 700 Louisiana
` Houston, TX 77002
` 6 713.546.5011
` garland.stephens@weil.com
` 7
`
` 8
` ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER CAVIUM, LLC:
` 9
` KARINEH KHACHATOURIAN, ESQ.
`10 Rimon, P.C.
` 2479 East Bayshore Road, Suite 210
`11 Palo Alto, CA 94303
` 650.461.4433
`12 karinehk@rimonlaw.com
`
`13
`
`14 ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER DELL, INC.:
`
`15 BRADY COX, ESQ.
` Alston & Bird LLP
`16 1950 University Avenue, 5th Floor
` East Palo Alto, CA 94303
`17 214.922.3443
` brady.cox@alston.com
`18
`
`19
` ON BEHALF OF PATENT OWNER ALACRITECH, INC.
`20
` JOSEPH PAUNOVICH, ESQ.
`21 Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP
` 865 South Figueroa Street, 10th Floor
`22 Los Angeles, CA 90017
` 213.443.3257
`23 joepaunovich@quinnemanuel.com
`
`24
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`3
`
`
` 1 JUDGE FISHMAN: This is Judge
`
` 2 Fishman. This is a conference call
`
` 3 regarding IPR 2018-00226, 234, and 401.
`
` 4 We have Judge Boudreau on the line, I
`
` 5 believe Judge Siu is unavailable for the
`
` 6 call.
`
` 7 Can we first get a quick roll
`
` 8 call. Who is on the line for petitioner?
`
` 9 MR. STEPHENS: Good afternoon,
`
`10 Your Honor, Garland Stephens from Weil,
`
`11 Gotshal & Manges representing petitioner,
`
`12 Intel Corporation.
`
`13 JUDGE FISHMAN: Anyone else
`
`14 with you for petitioner?
`
`15 MR. COX: This is Brady Cox
`
`16 with Alston & Bird for petitioner Dell.
`
`17 MS. KHACHATOURIAN: And Karineh
`
`18 Khachatourian for petitioner Cavium.
`
`19 JUDGE FISHMAN: And for patent
`
`20 owner?
`
`21 - - -
`
`22 (No response.)
`
`23 - - -
`
`24 JUDGE FISHMAN: Anyone on the
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`4
`
`
` 1 line for patent owner?
`
` 2 - - -
`
` 3 (No response.)
`
` 4 - - -
`
` 5 JUDGE FISHMAN: The petitioner,
`
` 6 Mr. Stephens, do you know, was patent
`
` 7 owner planning on attending, did you have
`
` 8 any feedback from them?
`
` 9 MR. STEPHENS: I don't believe
`
`10 that I saw any feedback from them. I'm a
`
`11 little surprised that they haven't
`
`12 joined, but I don't know any more than
`
`13 that.
`
`14 JUDGE FISHMAN: Let's give it a
`
`15 moment or two.
`
`16 Did you happen to engage a
`
`17 court reporter, by any chance?
`
`18 MR. STEPHENS: There is a court
`
`19 reporter on the line.
`
`20 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Let's
`
`21 get a transcript of the call as soon as
`
`22 possible.
`
`23 MR. STEPHENS: Okay.
`
`24 JUDGE FISHMAN: Let's give it
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`5
`
`
` 1 another minute or two to see if anybody
`
` 2 is joining.
`
` 3 MR. STEPHENS: Sure.
`
` 4 JUDGE FISHMAN: I'm going to go
`
` 5 ahead and mute my mike here.
`
` 6 - - -
`
` 7 JUDGE FISHMAN: Haven't heard
`
` 8 anyone else join. Is there anyone on the
`
` 9 call for patent owner?
`
`10 - - -
`
`11 (No response.)
`
`12 - - -
`
`13 JUDGE FISHMAN: Apparently not.
`
`14 We don't like to have any ex-parte
`
`15 communications, so let's not discuss any
`
`16 major substance here. We'd like to
`
`17 reschedule the call, looking at the
`
`18 panel's availability at the moment.
`
`19 Is next Tuesday afternoon open
`
`20 for counsel?
`
`21 MR. COX: Your Honor, I have a
`
`22 Markman hearing on that day at the ITC.
`
`23 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Let me
`
`24 leave the date open for now. We'll send
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`6
`
`
` 1 a new email out requesting the parties
`
` 2 identify some times that will work.
`
` 3 But without getting into any
`
` 4 major substance, one issue that was
`
` 5 raised in the request for this had to do
`
` 6 with extending a date deadline for
`
` 7 motions to respond until, I'm quoting,
`
` 8 "after any Federal Circuit appeals become
`
` 9 final."
`
`10 To our knowledge there has been
`
`11 no appeal on any of these three cases.
`
`12 I'm not asking you to divulge any
`
`13 strategy, but is that still the case?
`
`14 Are we missing any information here? I
`
`15 don't believe the deadline has expired,
`
`16 but is there a plan to appeal or you
`
`17 don't care to divulge that?
`
`18 MR. STEPHENS: Your Honor, we
`
`19 are still contemplating whether or not to
`
`20 file an appeal. As I'm sure you're
`
`21 probably aware, there's, you know,
`
`22 ongoing developments about the
`
`23 appealability of rulings of this kind.
`
`24 And so we have not reached a definitive
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`7
`
`
` 1 decision whether to do it or not.
`
` 2 But, as you noted, the time to
`
` 3 file the Notice of Appeal is not yet
`
` 4 expired, so we do want to maintain that
`
` 5 option. And perhaps we should have
`
` 6 indicated in the email that my colleague,
`
` 7 Melissa Hotze sent, that the time to file
`
` 8 a Motion to Expunge could expire a short
`
` 9 time after the Notice of Appeal would be
`
`10 due, if none is filed.
`
`11 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay, that's
`
`12 fine. I just wanted to confirm that we
`
`13 weren't missing something and you had
`
`14 already filed.
`
`15 So your email is intended to be
`
`16 directed at appeals that Intel may file
`
`17 or petitioners here may file but have not
`
`18 yet decided.
`
`19 MR. STEPHENS: That's correct.
`
`20 JUDGE FISHMAN: That's what you
`
`21 were referring to, okay. I wasn't sure
`
`22 if there was some other appeal that was
`
`23 being referred to.
`
`24 Okay. We will try and organize
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`8
`
`
` 1 another phone call for some point next
`
` 2 week, see if we can get some dates from
`
` 3 both parties that will work. Not sure if
`
` 4 something happened on our end to
`
` 5 miscommunicate with patent owner.
`
` 6 MR. PAUNOVICH: I apologize,
`
` 7 Your Honor, this is Joe Paunovich, I
`
` 8 joined just a moment ago, I didn't want
`
` 9 to interrupt. I apologize for being
`
`10 late, but I am here on behalf of
`
`11 Alacritech, patent owner. So I'm happy
`
`12 to address any issues or questions that
`
`13 you have for us.
`
`14 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay, good
`
`15 enough. Let's move ahead. If you may
`
`16 have heard, we just asked one question
`
`17 and that was confirming our understanding
`
`18 that no appeal has yet been filed,
`
`19 petitioners apparently are considering
`
`20 whether or not to file an appeal. The
`
`21 question was really directed to the email
`
`22 that requested this phone call mentions
`
`23 appeals and we were concerned if there
`
`24 was some other appeal that was being
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`9
`
`
` 1 addressed.
`
` 2 So we understand that the
`
` 3 appeal of concern is potential for
`
` 4 appeals on these three case. So that
`
` 5 said, that pretty much covers everything
`
` 6 we just discussed.
`
` 7 So let's move ahead with
`
` 8 petitioner. Your request for the phone
`
` 9 call was regarding extending the deadline
`
`10 for Motions to Expunge. If you would
`
`11 like to explain what you're looking for
`
`12 and the duration of any such motion,
`
`13 let's proceed.
`
`14 MR. STEPHENS: Yes, Your Honor,
`
`15 thank you. Again, Garland Stephens for
`
`16 petitioner Intel Corporation.
`
`17 Petitioner requests that the
`
`18 deadline to file a motion to expunge be
`
`19 extended to 45 days after any appeals
`
`20 filed in this case are final, or, in the
`
`21 alternative, 45 days after the expiration
`
`22 of the time for filing of a Notice of
`
`23 Appeal in case of no appeal actually
`
`24 filed.
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`10
`
`
` 1 That is similar to relief
`
` 2 that's been granted in other IPRs by the
`
` 3 board. I can give you one example,
`
` 4 Sanofi versus Immunex, we have IPR
`
` 5 2017-01879, Document 90. And we knew
`
` 6 that -- we anticipate filing a Motion to
`
` 7 Expunge at the conclusion of all the
`
` 8 proceedings for some of the commercially
`
` 9 sensitive material that's in the record
`
`10 and wanted to preserve the ability to do
`
`11 that, and yet still preserve the ability
`
`12 for the record to be intact for any
`
`13 potential appeals.
`
`14 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Patent
`
`15 owner, any comment?
`
`16 MR. PAUNOVICH: We don't oppose
`
`17 the extension of time to file the Motion
`
`18 to Expunge, but want to just make sure
`
`19 it's clear that we would reserve the
`
`20 right to oppose that motion or motions if
`
`21 they are filed.
`
`22 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Just to
`
`23 clarify, Petitioner, you're referring to
`
`24 a Motion to Expunge as opposed to the
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`11
`
`
` 1 documents becoming public.
`
` 2 At the moment everything has
`
` 3 been sealed. We have not yet addressed
`
` 4 all the motions to seal. To be honest,
`
` 5 we delayed on that for a couple of
`
` 6 reasons. Without getting into details,
`
` 7 we have some concerns, some question
`
` 8 about some of the redactions that were
`
` 9 proposed with regard to the
`
`10 indemnification arrangements. It is
`
`11 public record, to our knowledge, that an
`
`12 indemnification agreement exists. And
`
`13 it's public knowledge that there was
`
`14 intervention based at least in part on
`
`15 that indemnification. That was part of
`
`16 the basis for us to drag our feet, to be
`
`17 honest, on motions to seal.
`
`18 Is it your intention that the
`
`19 Motion to Expunge would be in the
`
`20 alternative to maintaining the seal and
`
`21 rather eliminating these documents?
`
`22 MR. STEPHENS: I believe that's
`
`23 correct, Your Honor, at least once the
`
`24 proceedings are complete, that we would
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`12
`
`
` 1 move to expunge the documents that
`
` 2 hopefully will have been sealed up to
`
` 3 that point.
`
` 4 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. And,
`
` 5 again, to clarify, your suggestion would
`
` 6 be 45 days after the deadline for appeal
`
` 7 is passed, if you choose not to appeal,
`
` 8 which would be roughly 45 days plus a
`
` 9 week or so, I forget exactly what the
`
`10 deadline is right now.
`
`11 MR. STEPHENS: Yes. I believe
`
`12 it's coming up fairly soon, so I think
`
`13 that's correct. I don't recall the exact
`
`14 deadline either, Your Honor, but I know
`
`15 it hasn't passed yet and it's coming up
`
`16 fairly soon.
`
`17 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Or, in
`
`18 the alternative, if you do file appeals,
`
`19 you want to extend that deadline for
`
`20 expungement until after the Federal
`
`21 Circuit has ruled. Does that mean ruled
`
`22 and after your request for a rehearing,
`
`23 if you lose? What would be the deadline
`
`24 you're seeking if you do decide to file
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`13
`
`
` 1 an appeal?
`
` 2 MR. STEPHENS: Once the appeal
`
` 3 becomes final, you know, it's difficult
`
` 4 at this time to anticipate all of the
`
` 5 potential administrative activities, but
`
` 6 once 45 days after the appeal becomes
`
` 7 final is what we had in mind.
`
` 8 MR. PAUNOVICH: So would that
`
` 9 be the mandate, the issuance of the
`
`10 mandate, 45 days?
`
`11 MR. STEPHENS: Again, after the
`
`12 appeal becomes final, so after any
`
`13 ability to file a motion for a hearing on
`
`14 bond or a petition for certiorari.
`
`15 JUDGE FISHMAN: If there were a
`
`16 mandate, the mandate could follow beyond
`
`17 that?
`
`18 MR. STEPHENS: I'm not an
`
`19 expert on administrative procedure post
`
`20 Federal Circuit appeals, so I can't say
`
`21 precisely what the specific
`
`22 administrative action that would result
`
`23 in the deal being final is, off the top
`
`24 of my head. But that's what we have in
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`14
`
`
` 1 mind, once the appeal becomes final, that
`
` 2 we'd have some reasonable period to file
`
` 3 a Motion to Expunge.
`
` 4 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. I have
`
` 5 not yet heard that I'm going to be
`
` 6 appointed to the Federal Circuit, so.
`
` 7 MR. STEPHENS: I apologize for
`
` 8 not researching that, but the basic
`
` 9 notion here is fairly simple. And if you
`
`10 want something more precise, then simply
`
`11 that the appeal becomes final or the
`
`12 Notice of Appeal deadline has passed
`
`13 without a notice being filed, we can
`
`14 propose something. I'd have to research
`
`15 that a little bit.
`
`16 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Let me
`
`17 leave the phone briefly and confer with
`
`18 my colleagues.
`
`19 - - -
`
`20 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. We are
`
`21 going to authorize a brief motion
`
`22 requesting extension. We will
`
`23 temporarily extend the time in a short
`
`24 order that we'll issue in the next day or
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`15
`
`
` 1 so. We will extend the time at least as
`
` 2 long as it takes us to decide on this
`
` 3 motion. So we will authorize a brief
`
` 4 motion for petitioner. If there is an
`
` 5 opposition, we'll have a brief opposition
`
` 6 authorized. I would like to think this
`
` 7 is a very brief and simple issue to
`
` 8 discuss.
`
` 9 Petitioner, would you be good
`
`10 with no more than five pages and let's
`
`11 say by, let's see, Wednesday, the 23rd?
`
`12 MR. STEPHENS: Yes, that's
`
`13 fine. And also we will run it by the
`
`14 patent owner before we file, so hopefully
`
`15 we can file something that's not opposed.
`
`16 JUDGE FISHMAN: That would be
`
`17 great. If there is an opposition, patent
`
`18 owner, would similar five pages and
`
`19 Monday, the 28th, be workable?
`
`20 MR. PAUNOVICH: Yes, that would
`
`21 be fine, Your Honor.
`
`22 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. I'd like
`
`23 to think we don't need a reply to the
`
`24 opposition. I would like to think this
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Hearing - October 18, 2019
`
`16
`
`
` 1 is a simple matter to discuss in brief.
`
` 2 Does that work for everyone?
`
` 3 MR. STEPHENS: Yes, Your Honor.
`
` 4 MR. PAUNOVICH: Yes, Your
`
` 5 Honor.
`
` 6 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Go
`
` 7 ahead. Please get a transcript of the
`
` 8 call filed as soon as possible. We will
`
` 9 issue a brief order to this effect,
`
`10 probably won't get out today, but we'll
`
`11 get it out early next week. But you can
`
`12 presume this authorization will be
`
`13 granted.
`
`14 Anything else, Mr. Paunovich?
`
`15 MR. PAUNOVICH: No, Your Honor.
`
`16 Thank you very much.
`
`17 JUDGE FISHMAN: Okay. Thank
`
`18 you all, and have a good day.
`
`19 - - -
`
`20 (Hearing concluded at 10:21
`
`21 a.m. PT)
`
`22 - - -
`
`23
`
`24
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`17
`
`
` 1 CERTIFICATE
`
`
`
` 2 I HEREBY CERTIFY that the proceedings
`
`
` 3 are contained fully and accurately in the
`
` 4 stenographic notes taken by me upon the
`
` 5 hearing taken on October 18, 2019, and that
`
` 6 this is a true and correct transcript of same.
`
` 7
`
` 8
` --------------------------
` 9 MADALENE FOSTER ROHDE
`
`10 Registered Professional Reporter
`
`11
`
`12
`
`13
`
`14
`
`15
`
`16 (The foregoing certification of this
`
`17 transcript does not apply to any reproduction
`
`18 of the same by any means unless under the
`
`19 direct control and/or supervision of the
`
`20 certifying reporter.)
`
`21
`
`22
`
`23
`
`24
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`18
`
`
` 1 LAWYER'S NOTES
`
`
`
` 2 ______________________________________________
`
`
` 3 ______________________________________________
`
` 4 ______________________________________________
`
` 5 ______________________________________________
`
` 6 ______________________________________________
`
` 7 ______________________________________________
`
` 8 ______________________________________________
`
` 9 ______________________________________________
`
`10 ______________________________________________
`
`11 ______________________________________________
`
`12 ______________________________________________
`
`13 ______________________________________________
`
`14 ______________________________________________
`
`15 ______________________________________________
`
`16 ______________________________________________
`
`17 ______________________________________________
`
`18 ______________________________________________
`
`19 ______________________________________________
`
`20 ______________________________________________
`
`21 ______________________________________________
`
`22 ______________________________________________
`
`23 ______________________________________________
`
`24 ______________________________________________
`
`
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`

`

`Intel Corp Cavium v.
`Alacritech
`
`A
`
`ability (3)
`
` 10:10,11;13:13
`about (2)
`
` 6:22;11:8
`action (1)
`
` 13:22
`activities (1)
`
` 13:5
`actually (1)
`
` 9:23
`address (1)
`
` 8:12
`addressed (2)
`
` 9:1;11:3
`administrative (3)
`
` 13:5,19,22
`after (10)
`
` 6:8;7:9;9:19,21;12:6,20,
`
` 22;13:6,11,12
`afternoon (2)
`
` 3:9;5:19
`Again (3)
`
` 9:15;12:5;13:11
`ago (1)
`
` 8:8
`agreement (1)
`
` 11:12
`ahead (4)
`
` 5:5;8:15;9:7;16:7
`Alacritech (1)
`
` 8:11
`already (1)
`
` 7:14
`also (1)
`
` 15:13
`Alston (1)
`
` 3:16
`
`Hearing
`October 18, 2019
`
`alternative (3)
`
` 9:21;11:20;12:18
`another (2)
`
` 5:1;8:1
`anticipate (2)
`
` 10:6;13:4
`anybody (1)
`
` 5:1
`Anyone (4)
`
` 3:13,24;5:8,8
`Anything (1)
`
` 16:14
`apologize (3)
`
` 8:6,9;14:7
`Apparently (2)
`
` 5:13;8:19
`appeal (21)
`
` 6:11,16,20;7:3,9,22;8:18,
`
` 20,24;9:3,23,23;12:6,7;
`
` 13:1,2,6,12;14:1,11,12
`appealability (1)
`
` 6:23
`appeals (8)
`
` 6:8;7:16;8:23;9:4,19;
`
` 10:13;12:18;13:20
`appointed (1)
`
` 14:6
`arrangements (1)
`
` 11:10
`asked (1)
`
` 8:16
`asking (1)
`
` 6:12
`attending (1)
`
` 4:7
`authorization (1)
`
` 16:12
`authorize (2)
`
` 14:21;15:3
`authorized (1)
`
` 15:6
`availability (1)
`
` 5:18
`aware (1)
`
` 6:21
`
`B
`
`based (1)
`
` 11:14
`basic (1)
`
` 14:8
`basis (1)
`
` 11:16
`become (1)
`
` 6:8
`becomes (5)
`
` 13:3,6,12;14:1,11
`becoming (1)
`
` 11:1
`been (5)
`
` 6:10;8:18;10:2;11:3;12:2
`before (1)
`
` 15:14
`behalf (1)
`
` 8:10
`being (5)
`
` 7:23;8:9,24;13:23;14:13
`believe (5)
`
` 3:5;4:9;6:15;11:22;12:11
`beyond (1)
`
` 13:16
`Bird (1)
`
` 3:16
`bit (1)
`
` 14:15
`board (1)
`
` 10:3
`bond (1)
`
` 13:14
`
`both (1)
`
` 8:3
`Boudreau (1)
`
` 3:4
`Brady (1)
`
` 3:15
`brief (6)
`
` 14:21;15:3,5,7;16:1,9
`briefly (1)
`
` 14:17
`
`C
`
`call (10)
`
` 3:2,6,8;4:21;5:9,17;8:1,
`
` 22;9:9;16:8
`Can (6)
`
` 3:7;8:2;10:3;14:13;
`
` 15:15;16:11
`can't (1)
`
` 13:20
`care (1)
`
` 6:17
`case (4)
`
` 6:13;9:4,20,23
`cases (1)
`
` 6:11
`Cavium (1)
`
` 3:18
`certiorari (1)
`
` 13:14
`chance (1)
`
` 4:17
`choose (1)
`
` 12:7
`Circuit (4)
`
` 6:8;12:21;13:20;14:6
`clarify (2)
`
` 10:23;12:5
`clear (1)
`
`Min-U-Script®
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`(1) ability - clear
`
`

`

`Intel Corp Cavium v.
`Alacritech
`
` 10:19
`colleague (1)
`
` 7:6
`colleagues (1)
`
` 14:18
`coming (2)
`
` 12:12,15
`comment (1)
`
` 10:15
`commercially (1)
`
` 10:8
`communications (1)
`
` 5:15
`complete (1)
`
` 11:24
`concern (1)
`
` 9:3
`concerned (1)
`
` 8:23
`concerns (1)
`
` 11:7
`concluded (1)
`
` 16:20
`conclusion (1)
`
` 10:7
`confer (1)
`
` 14:17
`conference (1)
`
` 3:2
`confirm (1)
`
` 7:12
`confirming (1)
`
` 8:17
`considering (1)
`
` 8:19
`contemplating (1)
`
` 6:19
`Corporation (2)
`
` 3:12;9:16
`correct (3)
`
` 7:19;11:23;12:13
`could (2)
`
` 7:8;13:16
`counsel (1)
`
` 5:20
`couple (1)
`
` 11:5
`court (2)
`
` 4:17,18
`covers (1)
`
` 9:5
`Cox (3)
`
` 3:15,15;5:21
`
`D
`
`date (2)
`
` 5:24;6:6
`dates (1)
`
` 8:2
`day (3)
`
` 5:22;14:24;16:18
`days (6)
`
` 9:19,21;12:6,8;13:6,10
`deadline (10)
`
` 6:6,15;9:9,18;12:6,10,14,
`
` 19,23;14:12
`deal (1)
`
` 13:23
`decide (2)
`
` 12:24;15:2
`decided (1)
`
` 7:18
`decision (1)
`
` 7:1
`definitive (1)
`
` 6:24
`delayed (1)
`
` 11:5
`Dell (1)
`
` 3:16
`details (1)
`
` 11:6
`developments (1)
`
` 6:22
`didn't (1)
`
` 8:8
`difficult (1)
`
` 13:3
`directed (2)
`
` 7:16;8:21
`discuss (3)
`
` 5:15;15:8;16:1
`discussed (1)
`
` 9:6
`divulge (2)
`
` 6:12,17
`Document (1)
`
` 10:5
`documents (3)
`
` 11:1,21;12:1
`don't (8)
`
` 4:9,12;5:14;6:15,17;
`
` 10:16;12:13;15:23
`drag (1)
`
` 11:16
`due (1)
`
` 7:10
`duration (1)
`
` 9:12
`
`E
`
`early (1)
`
` 16:11
`effect (1)
`
` 16:9
`either (1)
`
` 12:14
`eliminating (1)
`
`Hearing
`October 18, 2019
`
` 11:21
`else (3)
`
` 3:13;5:8;16:14
`email (4)
`
` 6:1;7:6,15;8:21
`end (1)
`
` 8:4
`engage (1)
`
` 4:16
`enough (1)
`
` 8:15
`everyone (1)
`
` 16:2
`everything (2)
`
` 9:5;11:2
`exact (1)
`
` 12:13
`exactly (1)
`
` 12:9
`example (1)
`
` 10:3
`exists (1)
`
` 11:12
`ex-parte (1)
`
` 5:14
`expert (1)
`
` 13:19
`expiration (1)
`
` 9:21
`expire (1)
`
` 7:8
`expired (2)
`
` 6:15;7:4
`explain (1)
`
` 9:11
`Expunge (9)
`
` 7:8;9:10,18;10:7,18,24;
`
` 11:19;12:1;14:3
`expungement (1)
`
` 12:20
`
`Min-U-Script®
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200 (2) colleague - expungement
`
`

`

`Intel Corp Cavium v.
`Alacritech
`
`extend (3)
`
` 12:19;14:23;15:1
`extended (1)
`
` 9:19
`extending (2)
`
` 6:6;9:9
`extension (2)
`
` 10:17;14:22
`
`F
`
`fairly (3)
`
` 12:12,16;14:9
`Federal (4)
`
` 6:8;12:20;13:20;14:6
`feedback (2)
`
` 4:8,10
`feet (1)
`
` 11:16
`file (14)
`
` 6:20;7:3,7,16,17;8:20;
`
` 9:18;10:17;12:18,24;13:13;
`
` 14:2;15:14,15
`filed (8)
`
` 7:10,14;8:18;9:20,24;
`
` 10:21;14:13;16:8
`filing (2)
`
` 9:22;10:6
`final (8)
`
` 6:9;9:20;13:3,7,12,23;
`
` 14:1,11
`fine (3)
`
` 7:12;15:13,21
`first (1)
`
` 3:7
`FISHMAN (28)
`
` 3:1,2,13,19,24;4:5,14,20,
`
` 24;5:4,7,13,23;7:11,20;
`
` 8:14;10:14,22;12:4,17;
`
` 13:15;14:4,16,20;15:16,22;
`
` 16:6,17
`five (2)
`
` 15:10,18
`follow (1)
`
` 13:16
`forget (1)
`
` 12:9
`from (4)
`
` 3:10;4:8,10;8:2
`
`G
`
`Garland (2)
`
` 3:10;9:15
`getting (2)
`
` 6:3;11:6
`give (3)
`
` 4:14,24;10:3
`going (3)
`
` 5:4;14:5,21
`Good (4)
`
` 3:9;8:14;15:9;16:18
`Gotshal (1)
`
` 3:11
`granted (2)
`
` 10:2;16:13
`great (1)
`
` 15:17
`
`H
`
`happen (1)
`
` 4:16
`happened (1)
`
` 8:4
`happy (1)
`
` 8:11
`head (1)
`
` 13:24
`heard (3)
`
` 5:7;8:16;14:5
`hearing (3)
`
` 5:22;13:13;16:20
`honest (2)
`
` 11:4,17
`Honor (11)
`
` 3:10;5:21;6:18;8:7;9:14;
`
` 11:23;12:14;15:21;16:3,5,
`
` 15
`hopefully (2)
`
` 12:2;15:14
`Hotze (1)
`
` 7:7
`
`I
`
`identify (1)
`
` 6:2
`Immunex (1)
`
` 10:4
`indemnification (3)
`
` 11:10,12,15
`indicated (1)
`
` 7:6
`information (1)
`
` 6:14
`intact (1)
`
` 10:12
`Intel (3)
`
` 3:12;7:16;9:16
`intended (1)
`
` 7:15
`intention (1)
`
` 11:18
`interrupt (1)
`
` 8:9
`intervention (1)
`
` 11:14
`into (2)
`
` 6:3;11:6
`
`Hearing
`October 18, 2019
`
`IPR (2)
`
` 3:3;10:4
`IPRs (1)
`
` 10:2
`issuance (1)
`
` 13:9
`issue (4)
`
` 6:4;14:24;15:7;16:9
`issues (1)
`
` 8:12
`ITC (1)
`
` 5:22
`
`J
`
`Joe (1)
`
` 8:7
`join (1)
`
` 5:8
`joined (2)
`
` 4:12;8:8
`joining (1)
`
` 5:2
`JUDGE (30)
`
` 3:1,1,4,5,13,19,24;4:5,14,
`
` 20,24;5:4,7,13,23;7:11,20;
`
` 8:14;10:14,22;12:4,17;
`
` 13:15;14:4,16,20;15:16,22;
`
` 16:6,17
`just (6)
`
` 7:12;8:8,16;9:6;10:18,22
`
`K
`
`Karineh (1)
`
` 3:17
`KHACHATOURIAN (2)
`
` 3:17,18
`kind (1)
`
` 6:23
`
`Min-U-Script®
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`(3) extend - kind
`
`

`

`Intel Corp Cavium v.
`Alacritech
`
`knew (1)
`
` 10:5
`know (5)
`
` 4:6,12;6:21;12:14;13:3
`knowledge (3)
`
` 6:10;11:11,13
`
`L
`
`late (1)
`
` 8:10
`least (3)
`
` 11:14,23;15:1
`leave (2)
`
` 5:24;14:17
`line (4)
`
` 3:4,8;4:1,19
`little (2)
`
` 4:11;14:15
`long (1)
`
` 15:2
`looking (2)
`
` 5:17;9:11
`lose (1)
`
` 12:23
`
`M
`
`maintain (1)
`
` 7:4
`maintaining (1)
`
` 11:20
`major (2)
`
` 5:16;6:4
`make (1)
`
` 10:18
`mandate (4)
`
` 13:9,10,16,16
`Manges (1)
`
` 3:11
`
`Markman (1)
`
` 5:22
`material (1)
`
` 10:9
`matter (1)
`
` 16:1
`may (3)
`
` 7:16,17;8:15
`mean (1)
`
` 12:21
`Melissa (1)
`
` 7:7
`mentions (1)
`
` 8:22
`mike (1)
`
` 5:5
`mind (2)
`
` 13:7;14:1
`minute (1)
`
` 5:1
`miscommunicate (1)
`
` 8:5
`missing (2)
`
` 6:14;7:13
`moment (4)
`
` 4:15;5:18;8:8;11:2
`Monday (1)
`
` 15:19
`more (3)
`
` 4:12;14:10;15:10
`Motion (13)
`
` 7:8;9:12,18;10:6,17,20,
`
` 24;11:19;13:13;14:3,21;
`
` 15:3,4
`motions (5)
`
` 6:7;9:10;10:20;11:4,17
`move (3)
`
` 8:15;9:7;12:1
`much (2)
`
` 9:5;16:16
`
`N
`
`mute (1)
`
` 5:5
`
`need (1)
`
` 15:23
`new (1)
`
` 6:1
`next (4)
`
` 5:19;8:1;14:24;16:11
`none (1)
`
` 7:10
`noted (1)
`
` 7:2
`Notice (5)
`
` 7:3,9;9:22;14:12,13
`notion (1)
`
` 14:9
`
`O
`
`Hearing
`October 18, 2019
`
`oppose (2)
`
` 10:16,20
`opposed (2)
`
` 10:24;15:15
`opposition (4)
`
` 15:5,5,17,24
`option (1)
`
` 7:5
`order (2)
`
` 14:24;16:9
`organize (1)
`
` 7:24
`other (3)
`
` 7:22;8:24;10:2
`out (3)
`
` 6:1;16:10,11
`owner (9)
`
` 3:20;4:1,7;5:9;8:5,11;
`
` 10:15;15:14,18
`
`P
`
`off (1)
`
` 13:23
`Okay (17)
`
` 4:20,23;5:23;7:11,21,24;
`
` 8:14;10:14,22;12:4,17;14:4,
`
` 16,20;15:22;16:6,17
`on (17)
`
` 3:4,8,24;4:7,19;5:8,22;
`
` 6:11;8:4,10;9:4;11:5,14,17;
`
` 13:13,19;15:2
`once (4)
`
` 11:23;13:2,6;14:1
`one (3)
`
` 6:4;8:16;10:3
`ongoing (1)
`
` 6:22
`open (2)
`
` 5:19,24
`
`pages (2)
`
` 15:10,18
`panel's (1)
`
` 5:18
`part (2)
`
` 11:14,15
`parties (2)
`
` 6:1;8:3
`passed (3)
`
` 12:7,15;14:12
`patent (9)
`
` 3:19;4:1,6;5:9;8:5,11;
`
` 10:14;15:14,17
`PAUNOVICH (8)
`
` 8:6,7;10:16;13:8;15:20;
`
` 16:4,14,15
`perhaps (1)
`
` 7:5
`
`Min-U-Script®
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`(4) knew - perhaps
`
`

`

`Intel Corp Cavium v.
`Alacritech
`
`period (1)
`
` 14:2
`petition (1)
`
` 13:14
`petitioner (12)
`
` 3:8,11,14,16,18;4:5;9:8,
`
` 16,17;10:23;15:4,9
`petitioners (2)
`
` 7:17;8:19
`phone (4)
`
` 8:1,22;9:8;14:17
`plan (1)
`
` 6:16
`planning (1)
`
` 4:7
`Please (1)
`
` 16:7
`plus (1)
`
` 12:8
`point (2)
`
` 8:1;12:3
`possible (2)
`
` 4:22;16:8
`post (1)
`
` 13:19
`potential (3)
`
` 9:3;10:13;13:5
`precise (1)
`
` 14:10
`precisely (1)
`
` 13:21
`preserve (2)
`
` 10:10,11
`presume (1)
`
` 16:12
`pretty (1)
`
` 9:5
`probably (2)
`
` 6:21;16:10
`procedure (1)
`
` 13:19
`proceed (1)
`
` 9:13
`proceedings (2)
`
` 10:8;11:24
`propose (1)
`
` 14:14
`proposed (1)
`
` 11:9
`PT (1)
`
` 16:21
`public (3)
`
` 11:1,11,13
`
`Q
`
`question (3)
`
` 8:16,21;11:7
`questions (1)
`
` 8:12
`quick (1)
`
` 3:7
`quoting (1)
`
` 6:7
`
`R
`
`raised (1)
`
` 6:5
`rather (1)
`
` 11:21
`reached (1)
`
` 6:24
`really (1)
`
` 8:21
`reasonable (1)
`
` 14:2
`reasons (1)
`
` 11:6
`recall (1)
`
`Hearing
`October 18, 2019
`
` 12:13
`record (3)
`
` 10:9,12;11:11
`redactions (1)
`
` 11:8
`referred (1)
`
` 7:23
`referring (2)
`
` 7:21;10:23
`regard (1)
`
` 11:9
`regarding (2)
`
` 3:3;9:9
`rehearing (1)
`
` 12:22
`relief (1)
`
` 10:1
`reply (1)
`
` 15:23
`reporter (2)
`
` 4:17,19
`representing (1)
`
` 3:11
`request (3)
`
` 6:5;9:8;12:22
`requested (1)
`
` 8:22
`requesting (2)
`
` 6:1;14:22
`requests (1)
`
` 9:17
`reschedule (1)
`
` 5:17
`research (1)
`
` 14:14
`researching (1)
`
` 14:8
`reserve (1)
`
` 10:19
`respond (1)
`
` 6:7
`response (3)
`
` 3:22;4:3;5:11
`result (1)
`
` 13:22
`right (2)
`
` 10:20;12:10
`roll (1)
`
` 3:7
`roughly (1)
`
` 12:8
`ruled (2)
`
` 12:21,21
`rulings (1)
`
` 6:23
`run (1)
`
` 15:13
`
`S
`
`Sanofi (1)
`
` 10:4
`saw (1)
`
` 4:10
`seal (3)
`
` 11:4,17,20
`sealed (2)
`
` 11:3;12:2
`seeking (1)
`
` 12:24
`send (1)
`
` 5:24
`sensitive (1)
`
` 10:9
`sent (1)
`
` 7:7
`short (2)
`
` 7:8;14:23
`similar (2)
`
` 10:1;15:18
`
`Min-U-Script®
`
`www.LexitasLegal.com/Premier Lexitas 888-267-1200
`
`(5) period - similar
`
`

`

`Intel Corp Cavium v.
`Alacritech
`
`simple (3)
`
` 14:9;15:7;16:1
`simply (1)
`
` 14:10
`Siu (1)
`
` 3:5
`something (5)
`
` 7:13;8:4;14:10,14;15:15
`soon (4)
`
` 4:21;12:12,16;16:8
`specific (1)
`
` 13:21
`STEPHENS (19)
`
` 3:9,1