throbber
IPR2017-02018
`Exhibit 2014
`
`Conference Call
`
`Ruiz Food Products, Inc., Petitioner vs. Macropoint, LLC, Patent
`Owner
`
`September 21st, 2018
`
`Western Reserve Building
`1468 West 9th Street, Suite 440
`Cleveland, OH 44113
`Phone: 216.861.9270
`
`cadystaff@cadyreporting.com
`www.cadyreporting.com
`
`

`

`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`6
`
`7
`
`8
`
`9
`
`10
`
`11
`
`12
`
`13
`
`14
`
`15
`
`16
`
`17
`
`18
`
`19
`
`20
`
`21
`
`22
`
`23
`
`24
`
`25
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`1
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`RUIZ FOOD PRODUCTS, INC.,
`
`Petitioner,
`
`)
`)
`) Case IPR2017-020161
`) (Patent 8,275,358 B1)
`)
`) Case IPR2017-02018
`) (Patent 9,429,659 B1)
`)
`Patent Owner. )
`)
`
`vs.
`
`MACROPOINT, LLC,
`
`- - - - -
`Before MEREDITH C. PETRAVICK, TREVOR M. JEFFERSON,
`and NATHAN A. ENGELS,
`- - - - -
`
`The telephonic hearing, taken before me, the
`
`undersigned, Tracy Lam, Notary Public within and for
`
`the State of Ohio, taken via speakerphone at the
`
`offices of Cady Reporting Services, 1468 West 9th
`
`Street, Cleveland, Ohio, commencing at 11:00 a.m., the
`
`day and date above set forth.
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`2
`
`
`
`1 APPEARANCES:
`
`2
`
`3 On behalf of the Petitioner (via speakerphone):
`
`4 James Murphy, Esq.
` Ryan Murphy, Esq.
`5
`
`6
` On behalf of the Patent Owner (via speakerphone):
`7
` Kyle B. Fleming, Esq.
`8 Luis Carrion, Esq.
`
`9
`
`10
`
`11
`
`12
`
`13
`
`14
`
`15
`
`16
`
`17
`
`18
`
`19
`
`20
`
`21
`
`22
`
`23
`
`24
`
`25
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`3
`
`
`
`1 MR. MURPHY: Good morning, Your
`
`2 Honor. On behalf of Petitioner you have James
`
`3 Murphy and Ryan Murphy, both with Polsinelli.
`
`4 MR. FLEMING: Good morning. On
`
`5 behalf of Patent Owner this is Kyle Fleming.
`
`6 MR. CARRION: And Luis Carrion is
`
`7 also on the line.
`
`8 MR. FLEMING: And I believe we
`
`9 also have a court reporter on the line.
`
`10 PATENT JUDGE: Thank you.
`
`11 Patent Owner, I believe you requested the
`
`12 call regarding -- or a request to file a motion
`
`13 to dismiss.
`
`14 Let's begin with Patent Owner. Please
`
`15 explain your position.
`
`16 MR. FLEMING: Sure. The Federal
`
`17 Circuit recently issued a en banc ruling in a
`
`18 case called "Click to Call vs. Ingenio" in
`
`19 which it reversed what had been the board's
`
`20 presidential and informative decision that a
`
`21 prior action is voluntarily dismissed did not
`
`22 count with respect to the Section 315(b) bar
`
`23 for filing of petition.
`
`24 In this case prior to the petitions being
`
`25 filed by Ruiz, a real party in interest,
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`4
`
`
`
`1 FourKites had filed a declaratory judgment
`
`2 action challenging the validity of these
`
`3 patents. Now, that case had been dismissed
`
`4 without prejudice prior to the filing of the
`
`5 petitions. So based on the presidential and
`
`6 informative decisions at that time, that case
`
`7 was not considered for purposes of the 315 bar.
`
`8 However, it's Patent Owner's position
`
`9 that now you have Click to Call, the prior
`
`10 declaratory judgment filing is a bar to the
`
`11 action and the Petitioner lacks standing and
`
`12 the board lacks jurisdiction to continue.
`
`13 PATENT JUDGE: Petitioner, we
`
`14 understand from your e-mail that you have posed
`
`15 the request to file a motion.
`
`16 Can you explain your position, please?
`
`17 MR. MURPHY: Yes, Your Honor.
`
`18 The Click to Call decision is only about
`
`19 315(b), it's not about 315(a)(1), which would
`
`20 be the statute at issue here. In Click to
`
`21 Call, and numerous other cases, the Federal
`
`22 Circuit has specifically pointed out the
`
`23 difference between service of the complaint and
`
`24 the filing of an action, which is precisely the
`
`25 difference between 315(b) and 315(a)(1). So in
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`5
`
`
`
`1 our view we don't see the Click to Call
`
`2 decision as having the applicability that
`
`3 Patent Owner seems to contend with regard to
`
`4 315(a)(1).
`
`5 In addition to that, we would also note
`
`6 that there is a number of other sort of factual
`
`7 scenarios relative to a declaratory judgment
`
`8 action that could affect the scope of that with
`
`9 regard to 315(a)(1); and would also preclude
`
`10 its application in this case.
`
`11 PATENT JUDGE: Can you explain
`
`12 what you mean by that?
`
`13 MR. MURPHY: Yeah. There are
`
`14 issues related to the subject matter
`
`15 jurisdiction of that declaratory judgment
`
`16 action if it should be treated as a
`
`17 counterclaim; and either one of those as
`
`18 examples would preclude the application of
`
`19 315(a)(1).
`
`20 PATENT JUDGE: And so I guess
`
`21 just to be clear, is it -- I understand in the
`
`22 petition FourKites was termed a real-party in
`
`23 interest for the avoidance of data.
`
`24 Is it petitioner's position that
`
`25 FourKites is, in fact, a real party in
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`6
`
`
`
`1 interest? That's not a point of contention.
`
`2 MR. MURPHY: That's correct,
`
`3 Your Honor. FourKites is a real party in
`
`4 interest and they were named, as you noted, in
`
`5 the petition as such.
`
`6 PATENT JUDGE: Patent Owner, do
`
`7 you want to respond to Petitioner's position?
`
`8 MR. FLEMING: Sure. I mean, we
`
`9 certainly appreciate that the Click to Call
`
`10 decision itself dealt with 315(b). However,
`
`11 the underlying holding from the Fifth Circuit
`
`12 is -- you can't "unring the bell," so to speak,
`
`13 and once the triggering event occurs to either
`
`14 start the clock or to trigger the bar under
`
`15 315, there is no one doing it. And the court
`
`16 went through a Chevron analysis and I think
`
`17 that it applied the same Chevron analysis with
`
`18 315(a) you would come to the same result that
`
`19 the federal circuit did with 315(b).
`
`20 PATENT JUDGE: Okay. Patent
`
`21 Owner or Petitioner, I suppose, for that
`
`22 matter, do either of y'all anticipate needing
`
`23 discovery for this motion?
`
`24 MR. FLEMING: This is Kyle
`
`25 Fleming for the Patent Owner. Since I
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`7
`
`
`
`1 understand that there is no dispute that
`
`2 FourKites is a real party in interest, we don't
`
`3 see that there would be the need for any
`
`4 discovery.
`
`5 MR. MURPHY: And, Your Honor,
`
`6 the Petitioner. I don't anticipate the need
`
`7 for discovery, but if you grant the
`
`8 authorization to file the motion, depending
`
`9 what is in the motion, you know, I'd want to at
`
`10 least reserve the right to request it if
`
`11 necessary prior to anticipate what their
`
`12 argument is going to be.
`
`13 PATENT JUDGE: Right. Patent
`
`14 Owner, how many pages and what sort of timing
`
`15 would you anticipate for this motion if it were
`
`16 to be filed?
`
`17 MR. FLEMING: I mean, based on
`
`18 my draft I would say something on the order of
`
`19 10 pages at 14 point type; and we could have it
`
`20 on file certainly by Tuesday or Wednesday of
`
`21 next week in both matters.
`
`22 PATENT JUDGE: Petitioner, what
`
`23 sort of timing and how long for a reply would
`
`24 you anticipate?
`
`25 MR. MURPHY: Your Honor, the
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`8
`
`
`
`1 page length, you know, I would request probably
`
`2 in the order of 15 pages. I think there is
`
`3 going to be a pretty substantial amount of law
`
`4 and facts that have to be analyzed here.
`
`5 Plus, this is essentially an issue of
`
`6 first impression considering the Click to Call
`
`7 case didn't deal with 315(a)(1), so we don't
`
`8 have any direct guidance on that.
`
`9 As far as timing, we would want two weeks
`
`10 probably from when we receive the Patent
`
`11 Owner's motion to respond.
`
`12 PATENT JUDGE: Okay. Give me a
`
`13 few minutes to confer with Judge Petravick and
`
`14 Judge Jefferson and we'll get back with you in
`
`15 just a few minutes.
`
`16 MR. MURPHY: Okay. Thank you,
`
`17 Your Honor.
`
`18 MR. FLEMING: Thank you.
`
`19 PATENT JUDGE: Okay. Thank you.
`
`20 Again, this is Nathan Engels.
`
`21 Patent Owner, do you anticipate a reply
`
`22 to petitioner's response?
`
`23 MR. FLEMING: I guess, yes,
`
`24 based on what I have heard on this call. It
`
`25 sounds like there might be some issues that
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`9
`
`
`
`1 they raise that they haven't articulated, so
`
`2 I'm not sure I could discuss them in advance.
`
`3 For example, the idea that maybe you should
`
`4 treat declaratory judgment with a counterclaim
`
`5 or something like that. So I would think that
`
`6 some kind of reply would likely be needed.
`
`7 PATENT JUDGE: Okay. Well, I
`
`8 thank you very much for being on the call. We
`
`9 will issue an order hopefully later today or
`
`10 Monday. Thank you very much.
`
`11 MR. FLEMING: Thank you very
`
`12 much.
`
`13 MR. MURPHY: Thank you, Your
`
`14 Honor.
`
`15 - - - - -
`
`16 (Thereupon, the hearing was concluded.)
`
`17 - - - - -
`
`18
`
`19
`
`20
`
`21
`
`22
`
`23
`
`24
`
`25
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`10
`
` THE STATE OF OHIO, ) SS:
`
` COUNTY OF CUYAHOGA. )
`
`
`
` I, Tracy Lam, a Notary Public within and
`
`
`
` for the State of Ohio, duly commissioned and
`
`
`
` qualified, do hereby certify that the foregoing is
`
`
`
` a true and correct transcript of the testimony so
`
`
`
` given.
`
`
`
` I do further certify that this hearing was
`
`
`
` taken at the time and place in the foregoing
`
`
`
` caption specified. I do further certify that I am
`
`
`
` not a relative, counsel or attorney of either
`
`
`
` party, or otherwise interested in the event of this
`
`
`
` action.
`
`
`
` IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my
`
`
`
` hand and affixed my seal of office at Cleveland,
`
`
`
` Ohio, on this 5th day of October, 2018.
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Tracy Lam, Notary Public
`
` within and for the State of Ohio
`
` My Commission expires November 12, 2022.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
`
`

`

`Conference Call
`
`Ruiz Food Products, Inc., Petitioner vs. Macropoint, LLC, Patent
`Owner
`
`September 21st, 2018
`
`Western Reserve Building
`1468 West 9th Street, Suite 440
`Cleveland, OH 44113
`Phone: 216.861.9270
`
`cadystaff@cadyreporting.com
`www.cadyreporting.com
`
`

`

`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`1
`
`commission
`10:12
`
`commissioned
`10:10
`
`decisions 4:6
`
`declaratory
`4:1,10 5:7,15 9:4
`(5)
`
`complaint 4:23
`
`depending 7:8
`
`
`
`
`
`315a1 4:19,25
`5:4,9,19 8:7 (6)
`
`315b 3:22
`4:19,25 6:10,19
`(5)
`
`5th 10:5
`
`9th 1:16
`
`about 4:18,19
`
`above 1:18
`
`action 3:21
`4:2,11,24 5:8,16
`10:10 (7)
`
`addition 5:5
`
`advance 9:2
`
`315a 6:18
`
`5:10,18
`
`c 1:10
`
`applied 6:17
`
`cady 1:16
`
`appreciate 6:9
`
`are 5:13
`
`call 3:12,18
`4:9,18,21 5:1 6:9
`8:6,24 9:8 (10)
`
`argument 7:12
`
`called 3:18
`
`concluded 9:16
`
`didn't 8:7
`
`articulated 9:1
`
`can 4:16 5:11
`
`confer 8:13
`
`attorney 10:10
`
`can't 6:12
`
`considered 4:7
`
`authorization 7:8
`
`caption 10:10
`
`considering 8:6
`
`avoidance 5:23
`
`carrion 2:8 3:6,6
`
`contend 5:3
`
`difference
`4:23,25
`
`direct 8:8
`
`discovery 6:23
`7:4,7
`
`b 2:7
`
`b1 1:6,9
`
`back 8:14
`
`banc 3:17
`
`case 1:2017,7
`3:18,24 4:3,6 5:10
`8:7 (8)
`
`contention 6:1
`
`discuss 9:2
`
`continue 4:12
`
`dismiss 3:13
`
`cases 4:21
`
`correct 6:2 10:10
`
`certainly 6:9
`7:20
`
`could 5:8 7:19
`9:2
`
`dismissed 3:21
`4:3
`
`dispute 7:1
`
`affect 5:8
`
`affixed 10:10
`
`again 8:20
`
`also 3:7,9 5:5,9
`(4)
`
`bar 3:22 4:7,10
`6:14 (4)
`
`based 4:5 7:17
`8:24
`
`certify
`10:10,10,10
`
`challenging 4:2
`
`before 1:2,10,13
`
`chevron 6:16,17
`
`am 1:17 10:10
`
`begin 3:14
`
`amount 8:3
`
`analysis 6:16,17
`
`analyzed 8:4
`
`anticipate 6:22
`7:6,11,15,24 8:21
`(6)
`
`appeal 1:2
`
`appearances 2:1
`
`applicability 5:2
`
`application
`
`behalf 2:3,6 3:2,5
`(4)
`
`being 3:24 9:8
`
`believe 3:8,11
`
`bell 6:12
`
`between 4:23,25
`
`board 1:2 4:12
`
`board's 3:19
`
`both 3:3 7:21
`
`circuit 3:17 4:22
`6:11,19 (4)
`
`clear 5:21
`
`cleveland 1:17
`10:10
`
`click 3:18
`4:9,18,20 5:1 6:9
`8:6 (7)
`
`clock 6:14
`
`come 6:18
`
`counsel 10:10
`
`doing 6:15
`
`count 3:22
`
`draft 7:18
`
`counterclaim
`5:17 9:4
`
`county 10:10
`
`duly 10:10
`
`either 5:17
`6:13,22 10:10 (4)
`
`court 3:9 6:15
`
`email 4:14
`
`cuyahoga 10:10
`
`engels 1:11 8:20
`
`data 5:23
`
`date 1:18
`
`esq 2:4,4,7,8 (4)
`
`essentially 8:5
`
`day 1:18 10:5
`
`event 6:13 10:10
`
`deal 8:7
`
`example 9:3
`
`dealt 6:10
`
`examples 5:18
`
`commencing
`1:17
`
`decision 3:20
`4:18 5:2 6:10 (4)
`
`expires 10:12
`
`explain 3:15 4:16
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`5:11
`
`fact 5:25
`
`facts 8:4
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`2
`
`good 3:1,4
`
`6:1,4 7:2 (5)
`
`length 8:1
`
`nathan 1:11 8:20
`
`grant 7:7
`
`interested 10:10
`
`let's 3:14
`
`necessary 7:11
`
`guess 5:20 8:23
`
`factual 5:6
`
`guidance 8:8
`
`far 8:9
`
`hand 10:10
`
`federal 3:16 4:21
`6:19
`
`few 8:13,15
`
`fifth 6:11
`
`file 3:12 4:15
`7:8,20 (4)
`
`filed 3:25 4:1
`7:16
`
`filing 3:23
`4:4,10,24 (4)
`
`has 4:22
`
`haven't 9:1
`
`having 5:2
`
`heard 8:24
`
`hearing 1:13
`9:16 10:10
`
`hereby 10:10
`
`hereunto 10:10
`
`ipr2017020161
`1:2017
`
`ipr201702018 1:7
`
`issue 4:20 8:5 9:9
`
`issued 3:17
`
`issues 5:14 8:25
`
`its 5:10
`
`itself 6:10
`
`james 2:4 3:2
`
`jefferson 1:10
`8:14
`
`like 8:25 9:5
`
`need 7:3,6
`
`likely 9:6
`
`line 3:7,9
`
`llc 1:9
`
`needed 9:6
`
`needing 6:22
`
`next 7:21
`
`long 7:23
`
`no 6:15 7:1
`
`luis 2:8 3:6
`
`many 7:14
`
`matter 5:14 6:22
`
`matters 7:21
`
`maybe 9:3
`
`notary 1:14
`10:10,5
`
`note 5:5
`
`noted 6:4
`
`november 10:12
`
`now 4:3,9
`
`first 8:6
`
`fleming 2:7
`3:4,5,8,16
`6:8,24,25 7:17
`8:18,23 9:11 (12)
`
`food 1:4
`
`foregoing
`10:10,10
`
`forth 1:18
`
`fourkites 4:1
`5:22,25 6:3 7:2 (5)
`
`holding 6:11
`
`honor 3:2 4:17
`6:3 7:5,25 8:17
`9:14 (7)
`
`hopefully 9:9
`
`how 7:14,23
`
`however 4:8 6:10
`
`i'd 7:9
`
`i'm 9:2
`
`idea 9:3
`
`further 10:10,10
`
`impression 8:6
`
`inc 1:4
`
`informative 3:20
`4:6
`
`get 8:14
`
`give 8:12
`
`given 10:10
`
`going 7:12 8:3
`
`judge 3:10 4:13
`5:11,20 6:6,20
`7:13,22
`8:12,13,14,19 9:7
`(13)
`
`judgment 4:1,10
`5:7,15 9:4 (5)
`
`jurisdiction 4:12
`5:15
`
`just 5:21 8:15
`
`kind 9:6
`
`know 7:9 8:1
`
`kyle 2:7 3:5 6:24
`
`lacks 4:11,12
`
`lam 1:14 10:10,5
`
`later 9:9
`
`me 1:13 8:12
`
`mean 5:12 6:8
`7:17
`
`number 5:6
`
`numerous 4:21
`
`meredith 1:10
`
`occurs 6:13
`
`might 8:25
`
`october 10:5
`
`minutes 8:13,15
`
`office 1:1 10:10
`
`monday 9:10
`
`offices 1:16
`
`morning 3:1,4
`
`motion 3:12 4:15
`6:23 7:8,9,15 8:11
`(7)
`
`much 9:8,10,12
`
`murphy 2:4,4
`3:1,3,3 4:17 5:13
`6:2 7:5,25 8:16
`9:13 (12)
`
`ohio 1:15,17
`10:10,10,5 (5)
`
`once 6:13
`
`one 5:17 6:15
`
`only 4:18
`
`order 7:18 8:2
`9:9
`
`other 4:21 5:6
`
`otherwise 10:10
`
`ingenio 3:18
`
`law 8:3
`
`my 7:18 10:10,10
`
`interest 3:25 5:23
`
`least 7:10
`
`named 6:4
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`posed 4:14
`
`reporting 1:16
`
`since 6:25
`
`position 3:15
`4:8,16 5:24 6:7 (5)
`
`request 3:12 4:15
`7:10 8:1 (4)
`
`precisely 4:24
`
`requested 3:11
`
`some 8:25 9:6
`
`something 7:18
`9:5
`
`owner's 4:8 8:11
`
`preclude 5:9,18
`
`reserve 7:10
`
`sort 5:6 7:14,23
`
`page 8:1
`
`prejudice 4:4
`
`respect 3:22
`
`sounds 8:25
`
`respond 6:7 8:11
`
`speak 6:12
`
`
`
`
`
`our 5:1
`
`out 4:22
`
`owner 1:8 2:6
`3:5,11,14 5:3
`6:6,21,25 7:14
`8:21 (11)
`
`pages 7:14,19 8:2
`
`party 3:25 5:25
`6:3 7:2 10:10 (5)
`
`patent 1:1,2,6,9,8
`2:6 3:5,10,11,14
`4:8,13 5:3,11,20
`6:6,6,20,20,25
`7:13,13,22
`8:10,12,19,21 9:7
`(28)
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`3
`
`polsinelli 3:3
`
`reporter 3:9
`
`signature 10:5
`
`testimony 10:10
`
`thank 3:10
`8:16,18,19
`9:8,10,11,13 (8)
`
`their 7:11
`
`them 9:2
`
`thereupon 9:16
`
`these 4:2
`
`think 6:16 8:2
`9:5
`
`those 5:17
`
`through 6:16
`
`time 4:6 10:10
`
`timing 7:14,23
`8:9
`
`presidential 3:20
`4:5
`
`pretty 8:3
`
`prior 3:21,24
`4:4,9 7:11 (5)
`
`response 8:22
`
`result 6:18
`
`reversed 3:19
`
`probably 8:1,10
`
`right 7:10,13
`
`products 1:4
`
`ruiz 1:4 3:25
`
`public 1:14
`10:10,5
`
`ruling 3:17
`
`speakerphone
`1:15 2:3,6
`
`specifically 4:22
`
`specified 10:10
`
`ss 10:10
`
`standing 4:11
`
`start 6:14
`
`today 9:9
`
`patents 4:3
`
`petition 3:23
`5:22 6:5
`
`petitioner 2:3 3:2
`4:11,13 6:21
`7:6,22 (7)
`
`petitioner's 5:24
`6:7 8:22
`
`petitions 3:24 4:5
`
`petravick 1:10
`8:13
`
`purposes 4:7
`
`qualified 10:10
`
`raise 9:1
`
`real 3:25 5:25 6:3
`7:2 (4)
`
`ryan 2:4 3:3
`
`same 6:17,18
`
`state 1:15
`10:10,10,5 (4)
`
`tracy 1:14
`10:10,5
`
`say 7:18
`
`states 1:1
`
`trademark 1:1
`
`scenarios 5:7
`
`statute 4:20
`
`transcript 10:10
`
`scope 5:8
`
`street 1:17
`
`treat 9:4
`
`realparty 5:22
`
`seal 10:10
`
`subject 5:14
`
`treated 5:16
`
`receive 8:10
`
`section 3:22
`
`substantial 8:3
`
`trevor 1:10
`
`recently 3:17
`
`see 5:1 7:3
`
`such 6:5
`
`trial 1:2
`
`place 10:10
`
`regard 5:3,9
`
`seems 5:3
`
`suppose 6:21
`
`trigger 6:14
`
`please 3:14 4:16
`
`regarding 3:12
`
`service 4:23
`
`sure 3:16 6:8 9:2
`
`triggering 6:13
`
`plus 8:5
`
`related 5:14
`
`services 1:16
`
`point 6:1 7:19
`
`relative 5:7 10:10
`
`set 1:18 10:10
`
`pointed 4:22
`
`reply 7:23 8:21
`9:6
`
`should 5:16 9:3
`
`taken 1:13,15
`10:10
`
`telephonic 1:13
`
`termed 5:22
`
`true 10:10
`
`tuesday 7:20
`
`two 8:9
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`Conference Call 9/21/2018
`
`4
`
`type 7:19
`
`will 9:9
`
`under 6:14
`
`underlying 6:11
`
`undersigned 1:14
`
`understand 4:14
`5:21 7:1
`
`united 1:1
`
`unring 6:12
`
`validity 4:2
`
`very 9:8,10,11
`
`via 1:15 2:3,6
`
`view 5:1
`
`voluntarily 3:21
`
`within 1:14
`10:10,5
`
`without 4:4
`
`witness 10:10
`
`would 4:19
`5:5,9,18 6:18
`7:3,15,18,23 8:1,9
`9:5,6 (13)
`
`y'all 6:22
`
`yeah 5:13
`
`yes 4:17 8:23
`
`your 3:1,15
`4:14,16,17 6:3
`7:5,25 8:17 9:13
`(10)
`
`vs 1:6 3:18
`
`315 4:7 6:15
`
`want 6:7 7:9 8:9
`
`1100 1:17
`
`we'll 8:14
`
`1468 1:16
`
`wednesday 7:20
`
`2018 10:5
`
`2022 10:12
`
`8275358 1:6
`
`9429659 1:9
`
`week 7:21
`
`weeks 8:9
`
`well 9:7
`
`went 6:16
`
`west 1:16
`
`what 3:19 5:12
`7:9,11,14,22 8:24
`(7)
`
`when 8:10
`
`whereof 10:10
`
`which 3:19
`4:19,24
`
`CADY REPORTING SERVICES, INC. 216-861-9270
`
`Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
`
`

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket