Exhibit F.1
`
`Invalidity Claim Chart for U.S. Patent No. 8,749,507
`Based On U.S. Patent No. 6,590,568 (Astala ’568)
`
`Astala ’568 invalidates the ’507 patent under at least 35 U.S.C. §§ 102(a), (b) and (e).
`
`
`’507 Claim Language
`
`1.pre A method comprising:
`
`Exemplary Disclosure in Astala ’568
`Astala ’568 discloses a method. For example:
`
`1.a
`
`receiving contact data from
`an input device;
`
`Abstract (“A method of and apparatus for dragging and dropping items displayed on a touch screen.”).
`
`Claims 1 and 14, and the claims depending from each.
`
`To the extent this reference does not expressly disclose this limitation, it inherently discloses it.
`
`To the extent this limitation is not disclosed, this limitation is rendered obvious in light of this reference by
`itself, this reference combined with the other references charted for the ’507 patent, and this reference
`combined with any of the references identified in Section B.3 of these contentions.
`
`Astala ’568 discloses receiving contact data from an input device. For example:
`
`2:11-48 (e.g., “Another object of the present invention is to provide a touch screen technique for an electronic
`device in which the location and the time duration of an object, such as a finger or stylus or other pointed
`object, contacting or pressing a detection point on the touch screen, are detected. In addition, the pressure of
`the object on the touch screen may be detected as well as the velocity of the object as it is moved across the
`face of the touch screen.”)
`
`FIG. 3 and 6:23-32 (“FIG. 3 is a block diagram of a mobile terminal 20a that operates within the MDA system
`of FIG. 1. Terminals 20b and 20c may be similar in design. Terminal20a may include a touch screen 70 for
`providing a display, a keyboard 72, a browser 74, a driver 76, and hardware 78. The hardware 78 may include
`a memory for storing data, such as the Internet address of the global address server 36, and the software for
`operating the terminal20, such as the browser 74. Hardware 78 may include a touch screen controller for
`
`Immersion Ex. 2005 - p1
`Apple vs, Immersion
`IPR2017-01310
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`Chart Applying Astala to the ’507 Patent
`
`
`
`’507 Claim Language
`
`Exemplary Disclosure in Astala ’568
`controlling the input process for touch screen 70. As the terminal 20a is”)
`
`7:4-10 (“In order to retrieve information or to request services from the MDA server 28 or the Internet 26, the
`user might utilize the input touch screen 70. …”)
`
`9:16-20 (“The process begins at step 700. At step 702, a touch screen input is detected. That is, the touch of an
`object, such as a finger or pointed stylus, on the touch screen 70 is detected. This is illustrated in FIG. 6b by
`touch input 732 being disposed over the object file 1 of window 728.”)
`
`See also: FIGS. 6a-6d; 1:18-2:8 (“Background of the Invention”); 8:47-57; 8:58-9:65 (describing
`embodiments in the context of FIGS. 6a-6d); and claims 1 and 14 and the claims that depend from them.
`
`To the extent this reference does not expressly disclose this limitation, it inherently discloses it.
`
`To the extent this limitation is not disclosed, this limitation is rendered obvious in light of this reference by
`itself, this reference combined with the other references charted for the ’507 patent, and this reference
`combined with any of the references identified in Section B.3 of these contentions.
`
`Astala ’568 discloses determining an interaction with a displayed object on a screen based on the contact data.
`For example:
`
`Abstract (“A method of and apparatus for dragging and dropping items displayed on a touch screen.”)
`
`2:11-48 (e.g., “Thus, when a touch input is effected by pressing a selected first item displayed on the touch
`screen for a predetermined period of time and then dragging the object or finger along the face of the touch
`screen to a second item displayed on the touch screen while pressing the screen with a lighter pressure than
`the initial pressing on the selected first item and then pressing on the second item displayed on the touch
`screen for a third predetermined period of time may result in moving the selected item to the location of the
`second item, that is, dragging and dropping the selected first item on the second item.”)
`
`FIG. 3 and 6:23-32 (“FIG. 3 is a block diagram of a mobile terminal 20a that operates within the MDA system
`of FIG. 1. Terminals 20b and 20c may be similar in design. Terminal20a may include a touch screen 70 for
`
`1.b
`
`determining an interaction
`with a displayed object on
`a screen based on the
`contact data;
`
`
`
`Page 2 of 19
`
`Immersion Ex. 2005 - p2
`Apple vs, Immersion
`IPR2017-01310
`
`