`
`1.
`
`I graduated from the Missouri School of Mines and Metallurgy (now Missouri University of
`
`Science and Technology) in 1962 with a degree in petroleum engineering and have worked in
`
`the oil and gas industry since. After holding positions with Shell Oil, Juniper Petroleum,
`
`Prospect Petroleum (which I founded in 1982) and working as a consultant,
`
`I opened the
`
`Headington Oil Company’s Denver office in 1991.
`
`2.
`
`In the fall of 2001, I was the Manager of Headington Oil’s Rocky Mountain Division. At
`
`that time, I was responsible for an oil well in the Bakken formation in Richland County,
`
`Montana, identified as Dynnson llX-S, among others. The well was drilled as a dual-lateral,
`
`horizontal well, but was not producing enough oil to be economically viable.
`
`3.
`
`I decided that I wanted to fracture the sidetrack lateral
`
`to improve production.
`
`I first
`
`approached Halliburton and Schlumberger, which were two of the leading oil field service
`
`companies at that time. Both companies told me that it would not be possible.
`
`I was aware
`
`that both companies had unsuccessfully tried to fracture long horizontal wells in the North
`
`Sea.
`
`4.
`
`I had heard of Packers Plus from a Calgary company that drilled the Dynnson llX-S well,
`
`Ensign Well Services.
`
`I contacted Packers Plus in August or September 2001 and spoke with
`
`Dan Themig about fracturing the well.
`
`In early September, Packers Plus provided me with a
`
`completion proposal for the work.
`
`5.
`
`I reviewed the September proposal and decided to pursue the project.
`
`It provided for
`
`mechanical diversion and fracturing far down the horizontal section of the well.
`
`I had not
`
`previously seen a fracturing system having multiple sliding sleeves moved open with drop
`
`balls, nor had I seen packers being used for fracturing in the open hole.
`
`1 of 3
`1 of 3
`
`Ex. 2103
`Ex. 2103
`IPR2017-01232
`IPR2017-01232
`
`
`
`6.
`
`The September proposal was
`
`stamped “Confidential — Not
`
`to be disclosed outside
`
`Headington” when I received it. There was a mutual agreement and understanding between
`
`Headington Oil and Packers Plus that the proposal and all information concerning the project
`
`were to be kept confidential.
`
`I viewed the work as experimental and saw that Packers Plus
`
`was trying something new.
`
`Under these circumstances, it was customary in the industry that the work would be kept
`
`confidential. As a new technology that could result
`
`in increased production,
`
`it was
`
`understood in the industry as a secret and not
`
`to be shared.
`
`I have worked on new
`
`technologies with other companies with the same expectation and practice of maintaining
`
`confidentiality.
`
`It was very important to Headington Oil that our competitors not learn of any technological
`
`advantages that we had to improve production. This was especially so in Richland County in
`
`the fall of 2001. At that time, most of the wells that had been drilled in the area were not
`
`good producers and much of the land in the area had not been leased for oil production.
`
`I
`
`saw that Packers Plus technology may offer a competitive advantage and as an opportunity to
`
`exploit a largely untapped resource.
`
`In early October 2001, Packers Plus attempted to install
`
`the equipment shown in the
`
`September proposal in the Dynnson llX-S sidetrack. The assembly, however, got stuck in
`
`the well and had to be removed. Packers Plus then provided a revised proposal later in
`
`October also labelled “Confidential — Not to be disclosed outside Headington”.
`
`10.
`
`In late October, the equipment in the October proposal was successfully installed and the
`
`lower two stages of the well were fractured.
`
`I considered the job to be successful.
`
`Production increased from about 40 to 370 barrels per day.
`
`2 of 3
`2 of 3
`
`Ex. 2103
`Ex. 2103
`IPR2017-01232
`IPR2017-O1232
`
`
`
`11. I was responsible for the overall operation on behalf of Headington Oil. Packers Plus had a
`
`representative on site, Ray Hoffman, who directed the fracturing operation using Packers
`
`Plus’ equipment. There was also a rig crew who ran the tools into the well on Mr. Hoffman’s
`
`instructions, and a “frac” company that pumped the fluid down the well used to fracture the
`
`formation. The members of the rig crew were not given details of the operation.
`
`I
`
`specifically told the persons on site from the frac company that the work was to be kept
`
`confidential.
`
`12. Following the operation I continued to consider and maintain the proposals, information and
`
`details of the job as confidential.
`
`I am not aware of anyone disclosing such information after
`
`the work was completed or at any time.
`
`Signed at Denver, Colorado, this
`
`'7
`«if
`
`
`/6 day of April, 2015
`
`pal.A
`" Lav
`/ ,
`tau/2’6” 4
`
`Alfred R. Powell
`
`3 of 3
`3 of 3
`
`Ex. 2103
`Ex. 2103
`IPR2017-01232
`IPR2017-O1232
`
`