WPKVGF UVCVGU RCVGPV CPF VTCFGOCTM QHHKEG
`
`DGHQTG VJG RCVGPV VTKCN CPF CRRGCN DQCTF
`
`MCYCUCMK TCKN ECT- KPE/
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt
`
`x/
`
`UEQVV DNCKT
`
`Rcvgpv Qypgt
`
`KRT3128.12147
`
`Rcvgpv Pq/ 7-811-713
`
`GZ/ 3117. UWRRNGOGPVCN GZRGTV FGENCTCVKQP QH LCEM T/ NQPI
`
`
`
`DGHQTG VJG RCVGPV VTKCN CPF CRRGCN DQCTF
`
`MCYCUCMK TCKN ECT- KPE/
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt
`
`x/
`
`UEQVV DNCKT
`
`Rcvgpv Qypgt
`
`KRT3128.12147
`
`Rcvgpv Pq/ 7-811-713
`
`GZ/ 3117. UWRRNGOGPVCN GZRGTV FGENCTCVKQP QH LCEM T/ NQPI
`
`
`
`K- Lcem T/ Nqpi- jgtgd{ fgenctg vjg hqnnqykpi<
`
`K/
`
`DCEMITQWPF CPF SWCNKHKECVKQPU
`
`2/
`
`K co qxgt 32 {gctu qh cig cpf qvjgtykug eqorgvgpv vq ocmg vjku Fgenctcvkqp/ K
`
`ocmg vjku Fgenctcvkqp dcugf qp hcevu cpf ocvvgtu ykvjkp o{ qyp mpqyngfig cpf qp kphqtocvkqp
`
`rtqxkfgf vq og d{ qvjgtu/
`
`3/
`
`K jcxg dggp tgvckpgf cu cp gzrgtv kp vjku ocvvgt d{ Eqwpugn hqt Rcvgpv Qypgt Ueqvv
`
`Dnckt vq rtqxkfg o{ kpfgrgpfgpv qrkpkqpu qp egtvckp kuuwgu tgswguvgf d{ Eqwpugn hqt Rcvgpv
`
`Qypgt tgncvkpi vq vjg ceeqorcp{kpi rgvkvkqp hqt Kpvgt Rctvgu Tgxkgy qh W/U/ Rcvgpv Pq/
`
`7-811-713 )#vjg (713 Rcvgpv#*/ O{ eqorgpucvkqp kp vjku ocvvgt ku pqv dcugf qp vjg uwduvcpeg qh
`
`vjg qrkpkqpu tgpfgtgf jgtg/
`
`4/
`
`K jcxg rtgxkqwun{ uwooctk|gf kp o{ qtkikpcn fgenctcvkqp uwdokvvgf jgtgkp )Gz/
`
`3113* o{ gfwecvkqpcn dcemitqwpf- ectggt jkuvqt{- cpf qvjgt tgngxcpv swcnkhkecvkqpu/
`
`5/
`
`K jcxg dggp yqtmkpi cevkxgn{ kp vjg fgukip gpikpggtkpi kpfwuvt{ hqt oqtg vjcp 46
`
`{gctu/
`
`6/
`
`Cu rctv qh o{ yqtm kp eqppgevkqp ykvj vjku rtqeggfkpi- K jcxg tgxkgygf vjg
`
`hqnnqykpi ocvgtkcnu<
`
`" Rcvgpv 7-811-713 )vjg (713 Rcvgpv* kpenwfkpi vjg enckou vjgtgqh=
`
`" Rgvkvkqp hqt Kpvgt Rctvgu Tgxkgy qh W/U/ Rcvgpv Pq/ 7-811-713- Pq/ KRT3128.
`
`12147 kpenwfkpi Gzjkdkvu=
`
`" Vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcp Vtckp Qrgtcvkqp Cuuqekcvkqp Ocic|kpg- Xqn/ 48- Kuuwg Pq/ 4
`
`)Octej 2- 2;;6* )Gz/ 2114- #LVQC Ocic|kpg#*=
`
`" Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 15.19648; )Gz/ 2116- #Pcokmcyc#*=
`
`2
`
`
`
`" Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 18.292;11 )Gz/ 2118- #Ok{clkoc#*=
`
`" Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 15.43368; )Gz/ 2122- #Ucucq#*=
`
`" Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 15.271;;2 )Gz/ 211;- #Ocgmcyc#*=
`
`" W/U/ Rcvgpv Pq/ 6-3;4-355 vq Mcyciwejk )Gz/ 2133- #Mcyciwejk#*=
`
`" Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 13.34;96 )Gz/ 2132- #Cocpq#*=
`
`" W/U/ Rcvgpv 6-259-393 vq Ugfkij|cfgj )Gz/ 2136- Ugfkij|cfgj*
`
`" W/U/ Rcvgpv 4-322-;15 vq Uejygpmngt )Gz/ 2137- Uejygpmngt*
`
`" Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 16.153964 )Gz/ 2139- [cocfc*
`
`" Vjg hkng jkuvqt{ qh vjg (713 rcvgpv rtqxkfgf kp Gzjkdkv 2123=
`
`" Vjg tggzcokpcvkqp hkng jkuvqt{ qh vjg (713 rcvgpv rtqxkfgf kp Gzjkdkv 2124= cpf
`
`" Fgekukqp Kpuvkvwvkpi Kpvgt Rctvgu Tgxkgy )Rcrgt 21* )#Fgekukqp#*/
`
`" C eqorngvg eqr{ qh vjg Rtqrqugf HTC twngu )Gz/ 3115*
`
`" Eqpuwogt Rtqfwev Uchgv{ Fkxkukqp Iwkfgnkpgu hqt Vgngxkukqp Tgegkxgt Uchgv{ )Gz/
`
`3116*
`
`KK/
`
`QXGTXKGY QH VJG 713 RCVGPV CPF VJG RTKQT CTV
`
`Vjg (713 Rcvgpv
`
`7/
`
`Vjg (713 Rcvgpv ku fktgevgf vq c xkfgq fkurnc{ oqpkvqt u{uvgo vjcv ku oqwpvgf cv
`
`hkzgf kpvgtxcnu cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi qh c uwdyc{ ect/ Ceeqtfkpi vq
`
`egtvckp godqfkogpvu- vjg xkfgq oqpkvqt u{uvgo kpenwfgu cp gpenquwtg hqt vjg xkfgq oqpkvqt vjcv
`
`ku fgukipgf vq dg oqwpvgf cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi kp uwej c ocppgt vjcv
`
`3
`
`
`
`vjg uetggp qh vjg xkfgq fkurnc{ oqpkvqt )qt cp gpenquwtg qt c vtcpurctgpv eqxgt wpkv hqt vjg xkfgq
`
`fkurnc{ oqpkvqt* ku uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwuj )qt uwduvcpvkcnn{ eqpvkiwqwu qt hnwuj* ykvj vjg cflcegpv
`
`uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ycnn cpf qtkgpvgf qdnkswgn{ fqypyctf vqyctfu vjg uwdyc{ ectu ugcvu/
`
`Ugg Gz/ 2112- r/ 23 cv 2<34.55- 2<74.78.3<28- 3<44.57/ Ceeqtfkpi vq qvjgt godqfkogpvu- vjg
`
`xkfgq fkurnc{ oqpkvqtu ctg gcej gpenqugf ykvjkp cp gpenquwtg yjkej oc{ dg ugewtgf vq c
`
`uvtwevwtcn ogodgt dgvyggp cp kppgt ycnn cpf cp qwvgt uvtwevwtcn ujgnn qh vjg uwdyc{ ect/ Ugg Gz/
`
`2112- r/ 23 cv 2<66.2<6;- 3<67.71/ Ceeqtfkpi vq uvknn qvjgt godqfkogpvu- vjgtg oc{ dg c dcem nkv
`
`rcpgn fkurqugf qp vjg cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ect/ Ugg Gz/ 2112- r/ 23 cv 2<62.65-
`
`3<3;.42 cpf 3<64.66/ Vjg u{uvgo cnuq eqortkugu c #xkfgq ukipcn uqwteg wpkv# eqppgevgf vq vjg
`
`oqpkvqtu/ Vjg #xkfgq ukipcn uqwteg wpkv# eqpukuvu qh rtg.tgeqtfgf ocvgtkcn hqt dtqcfecuvkpi qp
`
`vjg uetggpu uwej cu pgyu- cfxgtvkugogpvu- gve/ Kv ecp dg kp vjg hqto qh xkfgq fkum rnc{gtu- EF.
`
`TQO rnc{gtu- cpf xkfgq vcrg rnc{gtu )Gz/ 2112 cv 3<26.53*/
`
`KKK/ WPFGTN[KPI HKPFKPIU
`
`Ngxgn qh Umknn qh c Rgtuqp Jcxkpi Qtfkpct{ Umknn Kp Vjg Ctv
`
`8/
`
`Dcugf qp o{ gfwecvkqp- vtckpkpi- cpf rtqhguukqpcn gzrgtkgpeg kp vjg hkgnf qh vjg
`
`enckogf kpxgpvkqp- K co hcoknkct ykvj vjg ngxgn cpf cdknkvkgu qh c rgtuqp qh qtfkpct{ umknn kp vjg
`
`ctv cv vjg vkog qh vjg enckogf kpxgpvkqp/ K fq pqv fkucitgg ykvj vjg swcnkhkecvkqpu tgekvgf d{
`
`Rgvkvkqpgtu gzrgtv vjcv c rgtuqp qh qtfkpct{ umknn kp vjg ctv qh vjg (713 Rcvgpv cv vjg vkog qh vjg
`
`enckogf kpxgpvkqp )RQUKVC* yqwnf jcxg dggp c rgtuqp jcxkpi vjg gswkxcngpv qh c dcejgnqtu
`
`fgitgg )g/i/- c dcejgnqtu kp Cgtqurceg- Kpfwuvtkcn qt Ogejcpkecn Gpikpggtkpi* qt c rtcevkecn
`
`gzrgtkgpeg gswkxcngpv vq vjgug fgitggu ykvj cv ngcuv vyq {gctu qh gzrgtkgpeg kp fgukip qh tckn ectu
`
`kp qtfgt vq dg ecrcdng qh wpfgtuvcpfkpi vjg (713 Rcvgpv cpf vjg rtkqt ctv tghgtgpegu fkuewuugf
`
`4
`
`
`
`jgtgkp/ Cffkvkqpcnn{- K oggv cv ngcuv vjgug okpkowo swcnkhkecvkqpu vq dg c rgtuqp jcxkpi qtfkpct{
`
`umknn kp vjg ctv cu qh vjg vkog qh vjg enckogf kpxgpvkqp qh vjg (713 Rcvgpv/
`
`Dcemitqwpf Kphqtocvkqp qp Uwdyc{ Ectu
`
`9/
`
`Uwdyc{ vwppgnu ctg oquv eqooqpn{ eqpuvtwevgf d{ vwppgn dqtkpi- yjkej etgcvgu
`
`c uwduvcpvkcnn{ ektewnct vwppgn d{ c nctig vwppgn dqtkpi ocejkpg vjcv jcu c dqtkpi jgcf cv vjg htqpv
`
`qh vjg ocejkpg cpf ewvu vjtqwij vjg itqwpf ykvj ocvgtkcn tgoqxgf dgkpi oqxgf vq vjg tgct cpf
`
`qwv qh vjg vwppgn qp uocnn tckn ectu vjcv qrgtcvg qp vtcem yjkej jcu dggp nckf hqt vjg dqtkpi
`
`ocejkpg/ Cu vjg dqtkpi rtqitguugu- vjg ocejkpg oqxgu hqtyctf qp pgy vtcem/ Kp vjku ecug- vjg
`
`uocnngt vjg fkcogvgt qh vjg vwppgn- vjg nguugt vjg equv cpf vkog kpxqnxgf/
`
`;/
`
`Ykvj vjg vwppgn fkcogvgt dgkpi mgrv cv c okpkowo hqt vtckp qrgtcvkqp- vjg etquu.
`
`ugevkqp qh vjg ectu owuv dg ectghwnn{ fgukipgf kp tgncvkqpujkr vq vjg vwppgn ycnnu/ Vq gpxkukqp
`
`vjku- qpg ecp ftcy c ekteng- vjgp ftcy c uswctg kpukfg vjg ekteng- ykvj vjg eqtpgtu lwuv vqwejkpi vjg
`
`kpukfg qh vjg ekteng/ Vjku tgrtgugpvu c dcuke #urceg gpxgnqrg/# Jqygxgt- vjg tgncvkqpujkr dgvyggp
`
`vwppgn ycnnu cpf ect uvtwevwtg tgswktgu cfgswcvg urceg dgvyggp vjgo hqt vjg ect vq dg cdng vq
`
`oqxg xgtvkecnn{ cpf ncvgtcnn{ qp kvu uwurgpukqp u{uvgo/ Uq pqy ewv vjg hqwt eqtpgtu qhh qh vjg
`
`uswctg vq rtqxkfg vjku engctcpeg- cpf {qw jcxg c tqwij fghkpkvkqp qh c urceg gpxgnqrg kp yjkej
`
`vjg ect owuv dg dwknv/ Vjg kpdqctf vyq eqtpgtu qh vjg vqr oc{ pqy dg eqppgevgf ykvj c ewtxgf
`
`ugevkqp yjkej uvc{u ykvjkp vjg engctcpeg cpf uqogyjcv fghkpgu vjg ujcrg qh vjg tqqh/
`
`21/
`
`Kp uwooct{- uwdyc{ ectu oc{ jcxg c tqwpfgf rqtvkqp cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg
`
`ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi vq ceeqooqfcvg vtcxgn vjtqwij uwdyc{ vwppgnu yjkej ctg dqtgf d{ c
`
`ocejkpg kp c tqwpf ujcrg cpf ocfg vq dg cu uocnn cu rquukdng vq tgfweg equvu/
`
`22/
`
`Kv yqwnf dg engct vq qpg qh qtfkpct{ umknn kp vjg ctv vjcv vjg #lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn
`
`5
`
`
`
`cpf vjg egknkpi# kp c uwdyc{ ect ku pqv c ukping rqkpv- dwv cp ctgc dgvyggp vjg egknkpi cpf c ukfgycnn
`
`vjcv ku v{rkecnn{ ewtxgf/
`
`23/
`
`Dwugu cpf cdqxg.itqwpf vtckpu yqwnf pqv jcxg vjg ucog pggf vq dg tqwpfgf cv
`
`vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi- cu vjg{ fq pqv iq vjtqwij wpfgtitqwpf vwppgnu kp vjg
`
`ucog ocppgt cu uwdyc{ ectu/
`
`24/
`
`Uswctg lwpevwtgu cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg egknkpi cpf vjg ukfgycnn kp uwdyc{ ectu ctg
`
`cnuq cxqkfgf vq tgfweg hcvkiwg uvtguugu cpf hqtocvkqp qh hcvkiwg etcemu/
`
`25/
`
`Rtkqt vq vjg ewttgpv kpxgpvkqp- vjg rtqdngo ycu jqy vq cejkgxg c vgngxkukqp kp c
`
`uwdyc{ ect vjcv ycu uoqqvj cpf cguvjgvkecnn{ rngcukpi- ukoknct vq c vgngxkukqp kp c ycnn- dwv cnuq
`
`fktgevgf qdnkswgn{ fqypyctfu hqt gcug qh xkgykpi cpf nqecvgf cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf
`
`vjg egknkpi uq cu pqv vq vcmg wr ect urceg qt kplwtg rcuugpigtu/ Vjg rtqdngo- rqugf vq vjg kpxgpvqt
`
`cv vjg vkog qh vjg kpxgpvkqp- ycu rctvkewnctn{ ejcnngpikpi cu uwdyc{ ectu jcxg ejcnngpigu vjcv fq
`
`pqv gzkuv kp tgukfgpvkcn gpxktqpogpvu qt gxgp dwugu qt Covtcm vtckpu/
`
`26/
`
`C RQUKVC- kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog- yqwnf pqv jcxg dggp oqvkxcvgf vq oqwpv
`
`c oqpkvqt uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwuj ykvj cp cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh c uwdyc{ ect dgecwug qh
`
`jgkijvgpgf uchgv{ tgswktgogpvu- cp gzvtgog cxgtukqp vq cp{ rqvgpvkcn hktg jc|ctfu- cpf mpqyngfig
`
`vjcv c vgngxkukqp ujqwnf pgxgt dg rwv kp c dwknv.kp gpenquwtg/
`
`27/
`
`Pcokmcyc engctn{ vgcejgu c tqwpfgf dcem vgngxkukqp vjcv ku oqwpvgf qp vjg
`
`ukfgycnn cpf ku pqv uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwuj ykvj vjg cflcegpv ycnn cpf egknkpi rcpgnu/ Pcokmcyc
`
`fgrkevu cpf engctn{ uvcvgu vjg oqpkvqtu ctg fkurqugf QP c ycnn hceg/ Pcokmcyc vgcejgu oqpkvqtu
`
`vjcv ctg oqwpvgf QP VQR qh c ycnn hceg= vjg{ ctg cp crrtgekcdng fkuvcpeg htqo vjg ycnn- cpf vjg
`
`uetggp qh vjg oqpkvqt ku PQV uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf ykvj vjg cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg
`
`ect/ Pqvjkpi ykvjkp vjg vgcejkpiu qh Pcokmcyc vgcejgu qt uwiiguvu vjg cxckncdknkv{ qh urceg
`
`6
`
`
`
`dg{qpf vjg ycnn- ngv cnqpg vjg cxckncdknkv{ qh urceg dg{qpf vjg ycnn cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn
`
`cpf vjg egknkpi vq cnnqy hqt vjg uetggp qh vjg oqpkvqt vq dg uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf ykvj vjg cflcegpv
`
`ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ect/ Pqpg qh vjg ekvgf rtkqt ctv vgcejgu qt uwiiguv vjg cxckncdknkv{ qh
`
`urceg dg{qpf vjg ycnn cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi qh c uwdyc{ ect vq cnnqy hqt
`
`vjg uetggp qh vjg oqpkvqt vq dg uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf/
`
`28/
`
`Pcokmcyc ku oqwpvgf qp vqr qh c ycnn- uq Rgvkvkqpgtu uvcvgogpv Kv yqwnf jcxg
`
`dggp cp qdxkqwu fgukip ejqkeg hqt c RQUKVC kp 2;;8 vq ocmg vjg gpenquwtg cpf xkfgq fkurnc{
`
`oqpkvqt tgoqxcdng cu c wpkv dgecwug uwej c oqfkhkecvkqp yqwnf jcxg hceknkvcvgf hcuvgt cuugodn{
`
`qt fkucuugodn{ qh vjg fkurnc{ oqpkvqt hqt ockpvgpcpeg rwtrqugu cpf gcukgt jcpfnkpi qh vjg
`
`gswkrogpv d{ ockpvgpcpeg gornq{ggu/ ku kortqrgt cpf kpeqttgev/ Cffkpi cp cffkvkqpcn
`
`gpenquwtg vq c vgngxkukqp yqwnf ocmg cuugodn{ qt fkucuugodn{ hqt ockpvgpcpeg rwtrqugu oqtg
`
`fkhhkewnv/
`
`29/
`
`Ucucq vgcejgu vjg wug qh c hktg.tgukuvcpv hnqqt oqwpvgf ecdkpgv vq cfftguu hktg
`
`uchgv{- dwv vjg ecdkpgv yqwnf htwuvtcvg vjg rwtrqug qh Pcokmcyc dgkpi oqwpvgf cv vjg lwpevkqp
`
`qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi cpf dgkpi uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwuj/ Ucucq vgcejgu cyc{ htqo oqwpvkpi
`
`cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi kp c uwdyc{ gpxktqpogpv/ Ucucq vgcejgu c hnqqt
`
`oqwpvgf vgngxkukqp kp c ycnn ykvj c hnqqt uwrrqtvgf ecdkpgv vjcv oc{ dg ocfg qh hktg.tgukuvcpv
`
`ocvgtkcn/ Vq cnvgt Ucucq vq fq cyc{ ykvj vjg hktg.tgukuvcpv ecdkpgv yqwnf pqv dg ykvjkp vjg
`
`vgcejkpiu qh vjg tghgtgpegu- rctvkewnctn{ kp vjg jgkijvgpgf hktg cfxgtug gpxktqpogpv qh c uwdyc{
`
`ect/ Vjg Ucucq tghgtgpeg owuv dg eqpukfgtgf kp kvu gpvktgv{- kpenwfkpi vjg vgcejkpi vjcv vq cxqkf
`
`c hktg yjgp rncekpi c vgngxkukqp kp vjg ycnn- {qw ujqwnf kpenwfg vjg hnqqt uwrrqtvgf ecdkpgv ocfg
`
`qh hktg.tgukuvcpv ocvgtkcn/
`
`2;/
`
`Cocpq vgcejgu c oqpkvqt vjcv ku oqwpvgf qp vjg egknkpi cpf0qt vq vjg nwiicig
`
`7
`
`
`
`tcem/ Oqtg rctvkewnctn{- vjg kpxgpvkqp vgcejgu c u{uvgo qh kpuvcnngf uetggpu yjkej ctg gzvgtpcnn{
`
`oqwpvgf cv nqecvkqpu cyc{ htqo cp{ cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ect/ Vjwu- Cocpq
`
`cnuq fqgu pqv vgcej c u{uvgo yjgtgkp vjg uetggpu ctg uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf ykvj vjg ycnn
`
`cflcegpv uwthceg/ Cnuq- Cocpq fqgu pqv vgcej qt uwiiguv gcej oqpkvqt dgkpi oqwpvgf cv vjg
`
`lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf egknkpi- ykvj vjg uetggp qh vjg oqpkvqt uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf ykvj vjg
`
`cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ect/
`
`31/
`
`Ocgmcycu u{uvgo fqgu pqv fkuenqug vgngxkukqpu kpuvcnngf cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg
`
`ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi qh c uwdyc{ ect ykvj vjgkt uetggpu uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf ykvj vjg cflcegpv
`
`ycnn uwthceg cpf vjgkt uetggpu fktgevgf qdnkswgn{ fqypyctfu vq vjg uwdyc{ ectu ugcvu/ Ocgmcyc
`
`vgcejgu oqpkvqtu kpuvcnngf qp vqr qh c ukfgycnn cpf pqv uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf/
`
`32/
`
`Ugfkij|cfgj cnuq vgcejgu fktgevn{ cyc{ htqo dgkpi oqfkhkgf vq dg fkurqugf
`
`ykvjkp vjg vtcpukvkqpcn ycnn rqtvkqp uwej vjcv vjg vtcpurctgpv eqxgt wpkvu eqxgtkpi tgurgevkxg qpgu
`
`qh vjg xkfgq fkurnc{ oqpkvqtu ctg uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwuj ykvj vjg cflcegpv uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg
`
`vtcpukvkqpcn ycnn rqtvkqp/ Ugfkij|cfgj vgcejgu c uykxgn oqwpvgf vgngxkukqp hqt gcu{ xkgykpi
`
`d{ ocp{ kpfkxkfwcnu/ Ugfkij|cfgj urgekhkecnn{ fkuetgfkvu vjg Fcjnuvtqo rcvgpv- yjkej yqwnf
`
`crrgct vq dg fgukipgf vq tguv qp c uwrrqtvkpi uwthceg uwej cu c vcdng qt eqwpvgt vqr cpf yqwnf
`
`cnuq crrgct vq dg qtkgpvgf hqt xkgykpi d{ qpg qt c uocnn pwodgt qh kpfkxkfwcnu/ Ugfkij|cfgj
`
`Gzjkdkv 2136- r/ 6/ Ugfkij|cfgj gzrtguun{ rtqxkfgu c uykxgn oqwpvgf vgngxkukqp ecp dg xkgygf
`
`d{ c itgcvgt pwodgt qh kpfkxkfwcn cpf fkuetgfkvu c uvcvkqpct{ oqwpvgf vgngxkukqp/ Ugfkij|cfgj
`
`owuv dg tglgevgf cu vgcejkpi cyc{ htqo eqodkpcvkqp ykvj Pcokmcyc cu uwiiguvgf/ Oqwpvkpi
`
`ykvjkp c vtcpukvkqpcn ycnn rqtvkqp yqwnf cnuq dg owej oqtg eqornkecvgf vjcp oqwpvkpi qp vqr qh
`
`vjg ycnn )cu kp Pcokmcyc* qt oqwpvgf qp c vtc{ )cu kp Ugfkij|cfgj*/
`
`33/
`
`Vjg rtkqt ctv yqwnf pqv vgcej qt uwiiguv vq c RQUKVC cp{ cxckncdknkv{ qh urceg cv
`
`8
`
`
`
`vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi- Ucucq ku fktgevgf vq c tgukfgpvkcn ycnn cpf ku kttgngxcpv
`
`vq vjg swguvkqp- cpf vjg tgockpkpi Cocpq cpf Ocgmcyc tghgtgpegu dqvj ujqy vjgtg ku pq urceg
`
`dgjkpf vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi/
`
`34/
`
`Dgecwug Uejygpmngt vgcejgu cyc{ htqo rcpgnu vjcv ctg pqv gpf.vq.gpf cpf
`
`rncekpi dcem.nkv rcpgnu pgzv vq vjg xkfgq uetggpu yqwnf tguwnv kp vjg fkxgtug ngxgnu qh nkijvkpi cu
`
`ycu urgekhkecnn{ fkuetgfkvgf d{ Uejygpmngt- c RQUKVC yqwnf pqv oqfkh{ Pcokmcyc vq
`
`kpeqtrqtcvg egtvckp hgcvwtgu qh Uejygpmngt kp cp ghhqtv vq cttkxg cv vjg enckogf kpxgpvkqp/
`
`35/
`
`Kv yqwnf dg tgswktgf vjcv vjg pwodgt qh ectf fkurnc{u yqwnf dg tgfwegf vq ocmg
`
`tqqo hqt vjg oqpkvqtu yjkej yqwnf rtqxkfg kortqrgt knnwokpcvkqp )cu vcwijv d{ Uejygpmngt
`
`gpf.vq gpf nkijvkpi rtqxkfgu rtqrgt knnwokpcvkqp* cpf okpkok|g vjg ghhgevkxg cfxgtvkukpi ctgc-
`
`ceeqtfkpin{ vjg tcvkqpcng hqt eqodkpkpi tghgtgpegu ncemu c tcvkqpcn wpfgtrkppkpi/ Vjg oqpkvqtu
`
`qh Pcokmcyc cnuq yqwnf pqv dg oczkok|gf d{ oqfkh{kpi Pcokmcyc ceeqtfkpi vq Uejygpmngt/
`
`36/
`
`C RQUKVC- kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog- tgcfkpi Uejygpmngt yqwnf pqv dg
`
`oqvkxcvgf vq rnceg dcem nkv rcpgnu pgzv vq vjg xkfgq uetggp- cu Uejygpmngt vgcejgu vjg pggf hqt
`
`nkijvkpi hkzvwtgu cttcpigf gpf.vq.gpf vq cxqkf fkxgtug ngxgnu qh nkijv kpvgpukv{ yjkej ngcfu vq
`
`rcuugpigt g{g fkueqohqtv/ C RQUKVC yqwnf pqv dg oqvkxcvgf vq rnceg nkijvkpi hkzvwtgu pgzv vq
`
`c oqpkvqt yjkej ku oqwpvgf ykvjkp vjg vtcpukvkqpcn ycnn rqtvkqp hqt hktg uchgv{ tgcuqpu- cu nkijvkpi
`
`hkzvwtgu kp enqug rtqzkokv{ vq c oqpkvqt yqwnf eqpvtkdwvg oqtg jgcv vq c oqpkvqt vjcv tgswktgu
`
`xgpvkncvkqp cpf tgswktgu vjcv jgcv dwknf.wr dg cxqkfgf/
`
`37/
`
`Vjg HTC yqwnf pqv tgswktg cp kpvgtkqt hkvvkpi kh kv yqwnf rqug c hktg jc|ctf/
`
`38/
`
`C RQUKVC- kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog- yqwnf pqv jcxg dggp oqvkxcvgf vq
`
`oqwpv c oqpkvqt uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwuj ykvj cp cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh c uwdyc{ ect
`
`dgecwug qh jgkijvgpgf uchgv{ tgswktgogpvu- cp gzvtgog cxgtukqp vq cp{ rqvgpvkcn hktg jc|ctfu cpf
`
`9
`
`
`
`mpqyngfig c vgngxkukqp ujqwnf pgxgt dg rwv kp c dwknv.kp gpenquwtg cpf vjg xgpvkncvkqp unqvu
`
`ujqwnf pgxgt dg dnqemgf/
`
`39/
`
`C RQUKVC- kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog- yqwnf pqv jcxg dggp oqvkxcvgf vq
`
`oqwpv c oqpkvqt uwduvcpvkcnn{ eqpvkiwqwu ykvj cp gzvgtkqt uwthceg qh uckf vtcpukvkqpcn ugiogpv qh
`
`c uwdyc{ ect dgecwug qh jgkijvgpgf uchgv{ tgswktgogpvu- cp gzvtgog cxgtukqp vq cp{ rqvgpvkcn
`
`hktg jc|ctfu- cpf mpqyngfig c vgngxkukqp ujqwnf pgxgt dg rwv kp c dwknv.kp gpenquwtg cpf vjg
`
`xgpvkncvkqp unqvu ujqwnf pgxgt dg dnqemgf/
`
`3;/
`
`C RQUKVC- kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog yqwnf pqv gzrgev c ecxkv{ cv vjg lwpevkqp
`
`qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi )qt vjg vtcpukvkqpcn ugiogpv* uwhhkekgpv vq tgvckp c fkurnc{ oqpkvqt
`
`uwej vjcv kv yqwnf dg uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwuj ykvj vjg cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg/ Kh yg ctg vq ceegrv vjcv
`
`c ecxkv{ yqwnf dg gzrgevgf cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi kp vjg vkog rgtkqf qh
`
`2;;6.2;;8- vjgtg yqwnf dg pq gzrgevcvkqp vjcv kv yqwnf dg cxckncdng cu kv eqwnf dg hknngf ykvj
`
`vjgtocn kpuwncvkqp- uqwpf fgcfgpkpi ocvgtkcn- yktkpi cpf ecdng cpf cp cttc{ qh uvtwevwtcn
`
`ogodgtu/
`
`41/
`
`Vjg uvcvgogpvu ocfg d{ Nqygnn Ocnq kp Gz/ 2126 ¸ 52 vjcv qpg qh qtfkpct{ umknn
`
`kp vjg ctv tgcfkpi vjku fkuenquwtg qh Pcokmcyc cpf xkgykpi kvu hkiwtg hqt vjg uwdyc{ godqfkogpv
`
`yqwnf wpfgtuvcpf vjcv vgngxkukqpu 23 ctg rncegf cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf vjg egknkpi-
`
`ykvj cv ngcuv uqog rqtvkqpu qh vjg vgngxkukqpu gzvgpfkpi kpvq vjg urceg dgvyggp vjg kppgt cpf qwvgt
`
`ycnnu qh vjg tcknect ctg fkukpigpwqwu/
`
`42/
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt qhhgtu dtqcf uvcvgogpvu- uwej cu Pcokmcyc fkuenqugu vjg enckogf
`
`XUUW- yjkej yqwnf jcxg vq dg eqppgevgf vq vjg vgngxkukqpu 23 hqt vjg u{uvgo vq hwpevkqp cu
`
`kpvgpfgf/ Vjku ku wpvtwg= vjg XUUW eqwnf- hqt gzcorng- dg eqppgevgf vq vjg vgngxkukqp vjtqwij
`
`c rtgxkqwun{ kpuvcnngf vtcem- vwppgn qt eqpvtqn u{uvgo cpf yqwnf pqv dg c ugnh.eqpvckpgf yktkpi.
`
`;
`
`
`
`ecdnkpi u{uvgo/
`
`43/
`
`Vjg u{uvgo fguetkdgf d{ Rgvkvkqpgtu gzrgtv kp Gzjkdkv 2126 cv r/ 214 ku qpg vjcv
`
`ku pqv ugnh.eqpvckpgf/
`
`44/
`
`C RQUKVC- kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog- yqwnf jcxg pq mpqyngfig qh c
`
`uvtwevwtcn ogodgt fkurqugf dgvyggp cp kppgt ycnn cpf cp qwvgt uvtwevwtcn ujgnn hqt ugewtkpi vjg
`
`gpenquwtg/ Kv yqwnf pqv jcxg dggp qdxkqwu hqt c RQUKVC kp 2;;8 vq jcxg c xkfgq fkurnc{ oqpkvqt
`
`gpenqugf ykvjkp cp gpenquwtg uwej vjcv vjg gpenquwtg ku ugewtgf vq c uvtwevwtcn ogodgt fkurqugf
`
`dgvyggp cp kppgt ycnn cpf cp qwvgt uvtwevwtcn ujgnn qh vjg uwdyc{ ect/
`
`45/
`
`C RQUKVC- kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog- yqwnf pqv dg oqvkxcvgf vq rtqxkfg
`
`vtcpurctgpv eqxgt wpkvu eqxgtkpi tgurgevkxg qpgu qh vjg xkfgq fkurnc{ oqpkvqtu vq dg uwduvcpvkcnn{
`
`hnwuj ykvj vjg cflcegpv uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg vtcpukvkqpcn ycnn rqtvkqp- cu vjg{ yqwnf gzrgev
`
`vjcv c vtcpurctgpv eqxgt wpkv yqwnf hwtvjgt rtgxgpv xgpvkncvkqp qh vjg fkurnc{ oqpkvqt- ecwug jgcv
`
`dwknf.wr cpf etgcvg c hktg jc|ctf/
`
`46/
`
`Ugfkij|cfgj vgcejgu c ujgnn vjcv ku pqv vtcpurctgpv- ykvj c vtcpurctgpv ykpfqy
`
`vjcv ku eqxgtgf d{ c pqp.vtcpurctgpv unkfkpi ycnn yjgp pqv kp wug/ Ugg Gz/ 2136- r/ 6- 3<32.4;/
`
`Ugfkij|cfgj rtqxkfgu- c unkfkpi ycnn qp vjg ujgnn ecp dg ugngevkxgn{ oqxgf kpvq c rqukvkqp
`
`qxgtn{kpi cpf vjgtghqtg dnqemkpi vjg vtcpurctgpv ykpfqy rtkoctkn{ hqt cguvjgvke tgcuqpu/ Ugg
`
`Gz/ 2136- r/ 6- 3<46.49/ Uvknn hwtvjgt- vjg vtcpurctgpv ykpfqy qh Ugfkij|cfgj ku uwduvcpvkcnn{
`
`rgtrgpfkewnct vq vjg cflcegpv uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ycnn/ Ugfkij|cfgj cnuq vgcejgu fktgevn{
`
`cyc{ htqo dgkpi oqfkhkgf vq dg dgkpi oqwpvgf cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf egknkpi cpf
`
`hwtvjgt dgkpi eqxgtgf ykvj c vtcpurctgpv eqxgt wpkv- ykvj vjg vtcpurctgpv eqxgt wpkv hnwujgf ykvj
`
`vjg cflcegpv ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ect/
`
`47/
`
`[cocfc fqgu pqv vgcej c vtcpurctgpv eqxgt wpkv vjcv eqxgtu vjg xkfgq fkurnc{
`
`21
`
`
`
`monitors. The screen that is a part of and inside the actual video display does not support such a
`
`teaching. Still further, the screen of Yamadais not substantially flush with the adjacent surface
`
`structure or directed obliquely downward. Yamada teaches a monitor (without a transparent
`
`cover) that is directed obliquely upward.
`
`37.
`
`The combination of Namikawa in view of Sasao, Amano and Yamado or
`
`Sedighzadeh does not teach or suggest, infer alia, “a plurality of transparent cover units that
`
`cover respective ones of the video display monitors....the monitors being disposed within the
`
`transitional wall portion such that the transparent cover units covering respective ones of the
`
`video display monitors are substantially flush with the adjacent surface structure of the
`
`transitional wall portion” as in claim 8. An enclosure enclosing the monitor and disposed within
`
`the transitional wall portion would not make the television moreaesthetically pleasing.
`
`38.
`
`| declare that all statements made herein of my knowledge are true, and that all
`
`statements made on information and belief are believed to be true, and that these statements were
`
`made with the knowledge that willful false statements and the like so made are punishable by
`
`fine or imprisonment, or both, under Section 1001 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
`
`Date. // “70-26 7
`
` Jack R. Long
`
`11
`
`
Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.
After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.
Accept $ Charge
Still Working On It
This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.
Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.
A few More Minutes ... Still Working
It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.
Thank you for your continued patience.
This document could not be displayed.
We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
Set your membership
status to view this document.
With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll
get a whole lot more, including:
- Up-to-date information for this case.
- Email alerts whenever there is an update.
- Full text search for other cases.
- Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.
One Moment Please
The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.
Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.
Your document is on its way!
If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.
Sealed Document
We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.
If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.
Access Government Site
