`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`_________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`_________________
`
`GOOGLE LLC,
`Petitioner,
`
`v.
`
`BLACKBERRY LTD.,
`Patent Owner.
`
`_________________
`
`Case IPR2017-00914
`Patent 8,713,466 B2
`_________________
`
`PETITIONER’S DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBITS
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Demonstratives of Petitioner Google LLC
`
`Inter Partes Reviews of
`U.S. Patent No. 8,402,384
`U.S. Patent No. 8,713,466
`
`IPR2017-00913
`IPR2017-00914
`
`Oral Hearing: May 30, 2018
`
`1
`
`

`

`IPR2017-00913 – Instituted Grounds
`
`• Claims 1, 4-7, and 10-13 as obvious over Cadiz;
`• Claims 2 and 3 as obvious over Cadiz and Ng;
`• Claim 8 as obvious over Cadiz and Matthews;
`and
`• Claim 9 as obvious over Cadiz and Smith.
`
`IPR2017-00913, Dec. (Paper 7) at 29
`
`2
`
`

`

`IPR2017-00914 – Instituted Grounds
`
`• Claims 1, 4, 6, 12-14, 17, 22, and 24 as obvious
`over Cadiz;
`• Claims 2, 3, 15, and 23 as obvious over Cadiz
`and Hawkins;
`• Claims 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 as obvious over
`Cadiz and Siedlikowski; and
`• Claims 5, 10, 11, 16, 20, 21, and 26 as obvious
`over Cadiz and Yamadera.
`
`IPR2017-00914, Dec. (Paper 7) at 24
`
`3
`
`

`

`IPR2017—00913 —Independent Claim 1
`
`1. A method for controlling an apparatus comprising a
`display, the method comprising:
`displaying a dynamic bar on the display;
`displaying dynamic preview infomiation in the dynamic
`bar, the dynamic preview information bein determined
`
`from information managed by3*
`expan!ing llle !ynan1ic bar to display an expanded
`
`updated to reflect the same or different Chan e to the
`
`eing 11p
`the dynamic preview information
`reflect a chan e to the information managed by th
`
`e
`
`0
`
`dynamic bar in response to a first input from an input
`device, displaying the expanded dynamic bar compris-
`mg:
`displaying additional dynamic preview information
`determined from the information managed by the
`
`H the additional dynamic preview
`
`1 orma ion eing ifferent from the dynamic pre-
`view information displayed in the dynamic bar, and
`the additional dynamic preview information being
`
`

`

`IPR2017—00914 —Independent Claim 1
`
`1. A method for displaying preview information,
`method comprising:
`displaying on a display dynamic preview information in a
`dynamic bar, the dynamic preview information being
`
`the
`
`up ate to reflect a Chan e to the information managed
`
`ar to display an expanded
`ynamlc
`expanding t e
`dynamic bar in response to a first input, displaying the
`expanded dynamic bar comprising:
`displaying additional dynamic preview information deter-
`
`dis la ed in the d namic bar'
`
`determined from infomlation managed by a!
`E the dynamic preview information
`e1ng
`by the“ and
`
`mined from the information managed by thit—
`m the additional dynamic preview ' orma ion
`
`erent from the dynamic preview information
`
`e1ng
`
`

`

`Claim Construction
`
`Can “additional dynamic preview information”
`include information that is not dynamic?
`
`Must the “selectable link” include dynamic
`preview information?
`
`The prosecution history does not support Patent
`Owner’s claim construction positions.
`
`6
`
`

`

`Claim Construction
`
`Can “additional dynamic preview information”
`include information that is not dynamic?
`
`Must the “selectable link” include dynamic
`preview information?
`
`The prosecution history does not support Patent
`Owner’s claim construction positions.
`
`7
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — “Additional Dynamic Preview Information”
`
`IPR2017-00913
`
`IPR201 7-0091 4
`
`displaying
`determined from the infomiation managed by the
`software application. the additional dynamic preview
`information being different from the dynamic pre-
`view information displayed in the dynamic bar, and
`the additional dynamic preview infomiation being
`updated to reflect the same or different change to the
`information managed by the sofiware application;
`displaying a selectable link embedded in the additional
`dynamic preview information to invoke the software
`application; and
`activating the software application in response to a sec-
`ond input invoking the link.
`
`
`
`IPR2017—00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at Claim 1
`
`
`
`mined from the information managed by the software
`application, the additional dynamic preview information
`being different from the dynamic preview information
`displayed in the dynamic bar;
`the additional dynamic preview information comprising a
`selectable link which when activated, invokes the soft-
`ware application.
`
`IPR2017-009l4, ’466 Patent (Ex. 1001) at Claim 1
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — “Additional Dynamic Preview Information”
`
`° The specification does not recite the term “additional dynamic
`preview information.”
`
`° The specification describes “dynamic preview information.”
`
`Dynamic bar 304 of FIGS. 5 and 6 includes counts
`of new events 502 (e.g. new voice mail messages, email
`messages, SMS messages or contacts online with which to
`chat). As such, mobile stations status portion 306 need not
`display such—. Other events
`types may be counted and displayed such as available friends
`or groups for Push-to-Talk over Celluar (POC) calls etc. The
`need not be limited to a count.
`
`
`
`For example. the information may include some details of a
`recent event, which may be displayed temporarily for
`example. One such example is information about a missed
`call (e.g. “Missed call from NNN .
`.
`. ”) which may be
`temporarily displayed. Thereafter, cmmt or other preview
`information may be displayed.
`
`IPR2017—00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at 7:46—58
`
`
`
`IPR2017—009l3, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at FIG. 5
`IPR2017-00914, ’466 Patent (Ex. 1001) at FIG. 5
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — “Additional Dynamic Preview Information”
`
`° Patent Owner identifies only “50” in “50 unread” as dynamic.
`
`’ selectable link is “embedded” in the “additional
`
`dynamic preview information” because the link includes dynamic infonnation
`
`V :
`
`V
`
`.J-
`
`..
`I
`v;..
`
`r
`. 't
`.
`
`. v
`¥.r
`
`.,
`
`»
`
`-.
`..
`
`J
`
`'
`5 Q I! .Vglgg'M-‘a‘il,
`-J
`8 No new email messages,-
`E7 10W
`n 19 Contacts Online St’art tg‘Chat...
`V v
`
`

`

`Claim Construction
`
`Can “additional dynamic preview information”
`include information that is not dynamic?
`
`Must the “selectable link” include dynamic
`preview information?
`
`The prosecution history does not support Patent
`Owner’s claim construction positions.
`
`11
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — “Selectable Link”
`
`IPR2017-00913
`
`IPR201 7-0091 4
`
`displaying
`determined from the infomiation managed by the
`software application. the additional dynamic preview
`information being different from the dynamic pre-
`view information displayed in the dynamic bar, and
`the additional dynamic preview infomiation being
`updated to reflect the same or different change to the
`information managed by the software application;
`displaying
`
`
`
`application; and
`activating the software application in response to a sec-
`ond in ut invokin the link.
`
`IPR2017-00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at Claim 1
`
`mined from the information managed by the software
`application, the additional dynamic preview information
`being different from the dynamic preview information
`displayed in the dynamic bar;
`
`
`
`—which when activated, invokes the soft-
`ware application.
`
`IPR2017—00914, ’466 Patent (Ex. 1001) at Claim 1
`
`

`

`IPR2017-00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at 7:39-40
`
`
`
`Claim Construction — “Selectable Link”
`__A_.__.......
`
`
`
`150 Messages, 30 New
`From: Andrew
`| Subject: New 83
`From: Jack
`I Subject: Help me! jé
`
` From: Joan I Subject: RIM Party
`
`2.
`
`IPR2017—00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at FIG. 4
`
`IPR2017-00914, ’466 Patent (Ex. 1001) at FIG. 4
`
`

`

`
`.
`
`,
`.
`,
`l
`|
`,
`
`V:
`.1:
`..
`p was a;
`»,
`--
`i
`ifiii‘fim,‘
`.
`
`,'
`
`»
`
`'.I
`
`,
`
`.
`
`.s
`.~
`
`;
`.
`
`-
`..
`5'
`
`,
`--
`
`.
`""‘j
`
`:.,r..-=¢
`'.
`
`:-
`, an;
`-
`.xza
`t:-
`'
`.
`'
`
`IPR2017-00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at FIG. 6
`
`IPR2017-00914, ’466 Patent (Ex. 1001) at FIG. 6
`
`Claim Construction — “Selectable Link”
`
`Expansion pop-up 602 in the present embodiment does not
`preview a content ofthe new event but lists particular services
`604 associated with the dynamic bar 304 such as voice mail,
`email, SMS and chat including an iconic representation ofthe
`service 606 and preview information comprising a count 608
`as similarly displayed by bar 304 and a-to invoke the
`associated application user interface for the service.
`
`IPR2017-00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at 7:60-66
`
`
` D
`
`5 gall Voice Mail
`
`3 No new email messages,W
`z t 10 View SMS
`
`an 10 Contacts Oniine Start to Chat...
`
`i
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — “Selectable Link”
`
`° Based on Dr. Ligler’s testimony, “50 unread” Is not “additional
`dynamic preview information.”
`
`Q
`
`Which would be what?
`
`a
`
`okay.
`
`The—
`
`in the dynamic bar of claim 1 needs to be
`
`determined from information managed by_
`
`— and the displaying—
`
`_ in the expanded dynamic bar
`
`needs to be determined from the information
`
`managed by the— using ——
`
`the" software application, which to me means
`
`step about the dynamic bar.
`
`the same software application in the displaying
`
`G. Ligler
`
`Ligler Dep. Tr. (Ex. 1018) at 138:18-139z3
`
`

`

`Claim Construction
`
`Can “additional dynamic preview information”
`include information that is not dynamic?
`
`Must the “selectable link” include dynamic
`preview information?
`
`The prosecution history does not support Patent
`Owner’s claim construction positions.
`
`16
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — Prosecution History
`
`° Patent Owner’s statements related to Ogren:
`
`Claim 28 describes the expanded dynamic bar including additional dynamic
`
`preview information and “a selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`
`information to invoke the software application”. This is shown, for example, in FIGS. 4
`
`and 6 ofthe present application, and described in paragraphs [0046] and [0048]. A person
`
`skilled in the an would understand that a “selectable link” is a portion of the display,
`
`
`
`often text, that a user can select, for example by positioning a cursor over the link and
`
`actuating an input device, such as a mouse button or a clickable trackball switch. This
`
`selectable link is embedded in the additional dynamic preview information of the
`
`exmnded dynamicbar-—
`
`—_
`
`IPR2017-00913, ’384 Patent File History (Ex. 1004) at 114-16
`
`IPR2017-00914, ’384 Patent File History (Ex. 1005) at 114-16
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — Prosecution History
`
`° Patent Owner argued that Aaltonen is not prior art.
`
`° Patent Owner‘expressly disclaim[ed]” all prior arguments
`
`related to Ogren and Aaltonen
`
`We discussed "the dynamic Qreview information beim updated to reflect a chame to the information manfled bz the
`
`
`softwareIication" that Iicant submits that the above references do not disclose. We determined tha a further
`
`search will be considered
`
`IPR2017—00913, ’384 Patent File History (Ex. 1004) at 45, 63
`
`IPR2017—009l4, ’384 Patent File History (Ex. 1005) at 45, 63
`
`

`

`Claim Construction — Prosecution History
`
`° Patent Owner’s statements related to Wagner:
`
`Cla'm 28 redtes ‘display‘ng a selectable link embedded "n the additions! dynamic
`
`preview 'nformation to invoke the software mplication'. This is shown. for example, in FIGS. 4
`
`and 6 of the present application. and described in paagaphs [0046] and [0048]. A person skiled
`
`in the art would understand that a "selectable I‘nk" is a portion of the display, often text, which a
`
`user can select. for example by position'ng a cursor over the link and actuat'ng an 'nput device,
`
`such as a mouse button or a dickable trackball switch. This selectable link is embedded in the
`
`additiona dynamic preview iiformation of the expanded dynamic bar.—
`
`
`
`This is not found it Wagner. Nowhere in Wagner. and nowhere in the particular passage
`
`cited,
`
`is there any teaching or suggestion of a selectable link embedded in any additional
`
`dynamic preview information that is displayed in an expanded dynamic bar. FIG. 4 of-
`
`— I
`
`PR2017-00913, ’384 Patent File History (Ex. 1004) at 39
`
`IPR2017-009l4, ’384 Patent File History (Ex. 1005) at 39
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
` Claims 10, 11, 20, and 21 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
`
`20
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
` Claims 10, 11, 20, and 21 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
`
`21
`
`

`

`Person-Centric Interface “Software A lication” Limitations
`
`1
`
`° Patent Owner’s argument:
`
`For example, because Figure 8B provides Gavin’s availability
`
`With respect to five different communications channels, his overall availability as
`
`communication channels 840.5
`
`reflected in the sidebar of Figure 8A, which accomlts for Gavin’s availability via
`
`all connmulications channels, must be provided by some other means, e.g., an
`
`application that aggregates Gavin’s availability with respect to the five individual
`
`

`

`1. A method for controlling an apparatus comprising a
`display, the method comprising:
`displaying a dynamic bar on the display;
`displayin d namic
`review information in the d namic
`bar.
`
`.
`
`the dynamic preview information being updated to
`reflect a change to the information managed by the soft-
`ware application;
`expanding the dynamic bar to display an expanded
`dynamic bar in response to a first input from an input
`device, displaying the expanded dynamic bar compris-
`1n :
`
`Person-Centric Interface
`
`“Software A. lication” Limitations
`
`
`
`, the additional dynamic preview
`information being different from the dynamic pre-
`view information displayed in the dynamic bar, and
`the additional dynamic preview information being
`updated to reflect the same or different change to the
`information managed by the software application;
`displaying a selectable link embedded in the additional
`dynamic preview information to invoke the software
`application; and
`activating the software application in response to a sec-
`ond input invoking the link.
`
`IPR2017-00913, ’384 Patent (Ex. 1001) at Claim 1
`
`

`

`Person-Centric Interface
`
`“Software A lication” Limitations
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 2
`
`IPR2017—00914, Cadiz (Ex. 1006) at FIG. 2
`
`

`

`“Software A. .lication” Limitations
`
`Person-Centric Interface
`
`° PO’s argument is inconsistent with Cadiz’s
`disclosure.
`
`In addition, again as discussed above, in one embodi-
`ment, this person centric interface provides a communica-
`tions status 485 via any of a number of communications
`channels for each of the displayed entities. Further,
`in
`another embodiment, a “best available” communications
`
`or “richest” communications with the contact.
`
`channel for communicating with a particular contact can be
`automatically selected based on a determination of which
`channel is most likely to be successfully used for commu-
`nicating With the contact, or on which will provide the best
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at 11[0171]
`
`IPR2017-00914, Cadiz (Ex. 1006) at 11[0171]
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
` Claims 10, 11, 20, and 21 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
`
`26
`
`

`

`Person-Centric Interface
`“Selectable Link”
`• Based on its construction, Patent Owner argues that Cadiz’s
`action buttons do not disclose the following limitations because
`they do not include dynamic information:
`
`− “a selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913); and
`− “additional dynamic preview information comprising a selectable
`link” (IPR2017-00914).
`
`IPR2017-00913, Resp. (Paper 17) at 30-34
`IPR2017-00914, Resp. (Paper 17) at 32-36
`
`• Patent Owner’s argument fails because:
`
`− Patent Owner’s construction is wrong;
`− The action buttons may include dynamic information; and
`− Patent Owner ignores Petitioner’s obviousness argument.
`
`27
`
`

`

`“Selectable Link”
`
`Person-Centric Interface
`
`° Cadiz does not restrict the location of the action buttons.
`
`This person window includes further infor-
`mation about the person or entity, as well as—
`for initiating communication via any of a number of con-
`ventional communications channels, i.e. email, voice mail,
`instant messaging (1M), cell phone, telephone, mail, etc.
`
`
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at {[[0183]
`
`IPR2017—00914, Cadiz (Ex. 1006) at {[[0183]
`
`° Dr. Olsen explained that the action buttons could be a variety of
`different things.
`
`Olsen Dep. Tr. (Ex. 2009) at 112:10-21
`
`THE WITNESS: Reading that passage,
`
`a person of ordinary skill would have
`
`understood that—
`
`— —— what
`it?
`
`it he called
`
`17
`
`15
`
`A- —_
`
`16_—
`
`It could be all of the above.
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
` Claims 10, 11, 20, and 21 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
`
`29
`
`

`

`“Activatin” / “Invokes”
`
`Email-Centric Interface
`
`° The email window provides a subset of email functionalities.
`
`° Functionalities are achieved in two alternative ways.
`
`Further, clicking on, or hovering a pointing device
`over the email item serves to bring up an email pop-up
`window including the contents of the email inbox folder
`being tracked/watched in accordance with the email ticket
`instructions. As described in further detail below, the user
`may interact with any message in this window in the same
`manner as if the messages with being accessed or viewed
`
`within the users’email application.
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at 1[[0072]
`
`IPR2017-009l4, Cadiz (Ex. 1006) at 11[0072]
`
`

`

`Email-Centric Interface
`
`“Activatin” / “Invokes”
`
`333:,9'33!-sxfiw'iwfi‘uzsfi’s3}:
`
`: -ug- om; emanate nan“.
`Bu: and ComIenen all Ir m: ‘I
`Dave and;
`mm:$236k ‘.
`- Amq 09,933.31“?
`' Mun status
`'
`- mm. aunts
`at: Neda Player mm
`‘IMDop Gupta
`3" Q Ron Smith [PREMI... FIE: Sided-ow wdolo Elli-JIM"
`W MJM I’IIR’
`Iluthnl l-nltlel Vm hunt
`#573 Paul Smell ENETI mm :wytsfiun
`_ a E-ic Elam:
`Siam-cums: ROFOII
`‘ Adam Billsdh arm-net
`Flierflv am it Weathel skew
`
`aun 4122:2001 a: 03
`"In 4/] WEIIJI 8:16
`We! If'lHflllm 'lll'h
`Wed 4/1 EIZCOI 336 PM.
`Wed 421 E2101 3'32 PM;
`Wed VIE/2120! 33 PM 1':
`
`IPR2017—00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 10
`
`IPR2017—009l4, Cadiz (Ex. 1006) at FIG. 10
`
`

`

`Email-Centric Interface “Activatin_” / “Invokes”
`
`° Whether a particular implementation is preferred or better is
`irrelevant.
`
`Obviousness “does not require that a particular combination must be the
`preferred, or the most desirable, combination described in the prior art in
`order to provide motivation for the current invention.”
`
`In reFulton, 391 F.3d 1195, 1200 (Fed. Cir. 2004)
`
`(
`
`I
`
`(CC
`
`[T]he question is Whether there is something in the prior art as a Whole to
`suggest the desirability, and thus the obviousness, of making the
`combination,’ not Whether there is something in the prior art as a Whole to
`suggest that the combination is the most desirable combination available.”
`
`In re Fulton, 391 F.3d 1195, 1200 (Fed. Cir. 2004) (internal citation omitted)
`
`

`

`“Activatin” / “Invokes”
`
`Email-Centric Interface
`
`° Dr. Ligler testified that it was known that there can be multiple
`invocations of the same application.
`
`I appreciate that.
`
`In the object—oriented paradigm, .
`
`and that's a very technical term --_
`
`
`
`not having been executed before, it's a new
`
`instantiation.
`
`That new instantiation,
`
`Objection to form.
`
`THE: WITNESS: -
`
`Ligler Dep. Tr. (Ex. 1018) at 90:1-24
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
` Claims 10, 11, 20, and 21 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
`
`34
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`• Cadiz renders obvious claim 4 of the ’384
`patent, which states that “the apparatus
`comprises a cellular telephone.”
`
`• Patent Owner argues that the Petition relies on
`FIGS. 6B, 8A-C, and 10, but that Cadiz does not
`disclose that the interfaces in these figures
`“could have and would have been implemented
`in exactly the same way on a cellular
`telephone.” (IPR2017-00913, Paper 17 at 38-
`39.)
`
`35
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`• The Petition and Dr. Olsen also rely on FIGS. 1-
`3, 4A, and 5, which illustrate the concepts
`shown in FIGS. 6B, 8A-C, and 10.
`
`• Cadiz explains that its concepts can be
`implemented on a cellular telephone.
`
`• FIGS. 6B, 8A-C, and 10 are merely exemplary
`screen images of working examples.
`
`IPR2017-00913, Reply (Paper 20) at 17-23
`
`36
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`
`
`____________________..______:_.I1
`
`‘—
`
`
`
`ut are not limited to, personal computers, server computers,
`hand-held, laptop or mobile computer or communications
`devices such as_ Pocket PC’s and PDA’s,
`multiprocessor systems, microprocessor-based systems, set
`top boxes, programmable consumer electronics, network
`PCs, minicomputers, mainframe computers, distributed
`computing environments that
`include any of the above
`systems or devices, and the like.
`
`VOLATILE
`
`NON-
`VOLATILE
`
`[0050] With reference to FIG. 1, an exemplary system for
`implementing the invention includes a com utin device,
`such as computing device 100.fi
`
`__ b
`
`IPR2017—00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at “[00491—[0050]
`
`IPR2017-009l3, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 1
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`tem and process of the present
`
`In particular, the sys-
`invention will
`first be
`
`described with resiect to FIG.2.—
`
`[0079] Exemplary ticket 210 types include, for example,
`—as
`described in further detail below in Section 5.0, -
`- calendar or scheduling tickets, file system or file
`
`[0090] As noted above, each ticket 210 includes instruc-
`tions as to which viewer is to be used for displaying the
`communications contact or information represented by the
`ticket.
`
`
`
`240
`
`i Ii
`
`u]
`INFORMATION SOURCE(S)
`
`230
`
`SERVICE(S)
`
`200
`
`III9 220
`i V'EWER(S’
`
`ITEMS
`
`250 V
`
`CONTAINER(S)
`
`270
`
`DISPLAY DEVICE
`
`another viewer is designed to interact with a
`database to provide a summary of particular information
`from the database in the thumbnail.
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at “@0571, [0079], [0090]
`
`IPR2017—00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 2
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`32°
`TICKET
`
`MANAGER
`MODULE
`
`31o
`
`USER INTERFACE
`MODULE
`
`‘-I
`
`IIIIIIIIIII
`
`pointing devices, voice activated controls, or any other
`conventional method for interacting With electronic devices
`such as computers, PDA’s,_ personal organizers,
`
`330
`lNFOilNfigTION i0
`
`COMMUNICATION
`MODULE
`
`‘----
`
`[0104] The—is capable of per-
`forming several functions using any of a number of con-
`ventional input devices, such as, for example, keyboards,
`
`]
`
`250
`CONTAINER(S)
`
`260
`{32%;
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 3
`
`IPR2017-00913,C d'
`
`a 12 (Ex
`
`.1005
`
`t
`
`)3 WI
`
`0100 , 0104
`
`1
`
`[
`
`

`

`
`
`series of actions that illustrates an exemplary method for
`implementing the present invention.
`
`In a computing environment, there are many pos-
`[0176]
`sibilities for arrangement and placement of the peripheral
`awareness display described herein. Such possibilities
`include, for example, a display along one edge, or on any
`other part of a display or monitor,
`including the entire
`monitor, a Windows sidebar, a portion of a second monitor,
`a display of a conventional Pocket PC docked near a user’s
`computer, a display of a handheld device such as, for
`example, a PDA, a- a handheld or palmtop
`computer, or similar device, or even via a physical icon, such
`as, for example, a doll that turns it head to one side when a
`person or entity which it represents is either available or
`unavailable for communication.
`
`USER
`A PROFILE :3
`415 "n --"
`
`430
`.--.\n --..-,
`:STORETICKETIN p-
`I USER PROFILE
`,
`'--------------
`:mmnner:
`'
`UNK. FILE
`L-
`
`LQQNgCLEIQJ
`
`440
`
`450
`
`fi...'.....
`I DRAG AND I__
`: DROP TICKET:
`470
`X .._________.
`.................
`(AGGRESETZENSST) I"
`__________.______I
`1
`: MANAGE CONTAINERS l"
`I
`(MOVE. LINK. ETC.)
`.
`L--.....- ..----.--
`475/
`I
`
`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`RETRIEVE TICKET(S)
`FROM USER PROFILE
`
`SPECIFY INFORMATION OF
`INTER-EST AUTOMATICALLY
`OR VIA USER INTERFACE
`
`SELECT 0R CREATE
`TICKET(S),
`INCLUDE POINTER To
`APPROPRIATEVIEWER
`
`RETRIEVE INFORMATION AND
`CONTACT DATA FROM
`INFORMATION SOURCE(S)
`VIA SERVICE(S)
`
`UPDATE AND DISPLAY
`"EMS m CONTNNERS
`V"
`PERIPHERAL AWARENESS
`INTERFACE
`
`TICKET J
`I
`“:---::-:_
`I.
`‘S‘IbRE7
`:
`«nu COPY/EDIT I
`
`L-.T.IC.\K.ET.-J
`
`425
`
`445
`455
`,.....Z.
`J TIMED I
`I TICKETS I
`I........
`run...
`"’I ALERTS
`g.--___-"
`
`455
`
`I [430
`
`AGE
`"E DISPLAY:
`..... -.
`\‘5"
`
`—I
`I """""" J__
`'
`I
`l
`PROVIDE
`,..-----......fl
`I
`IPROV'DE COWS Ié-H' PERSON CENTRIC INTERFACE Imp: HISTORY!
`LCEEES’SICEEJ
`I
`FOR CONTACT ITEMS
`;
`:PA‘ITERNSI:
`b-------------.........
`I AVERAGES '
`485/
`bun-{793‘
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at 1I1I[0164], [0176]
`
`FIG. 4A
`
`IPR2017—009l3, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 4A
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`,"""""
`mm:
`I
`I
`2:3:
`
`.‘
`
`in accordance with the preceding
`In particular,
`[0191]
`discussion, FIG. 5 illustrates an—for
`interacting with a system and method according to the
`~
`.
`.
`o
`present 1nvent10n 15 1mplemented on a—
`using conventional techniques.
`
`IPR2017—00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at 11[0191] .v'|x .
`
`réfifflTAWTeiTTGfi-k_
`HISTORY
`
`PERSON
`
`58° reanmmrc'm n
`1 AVAILABILITY
`575 '2
`---
`---.
`555
`.
`(sec
`ENHANCED
`E NESTED '
`u TOOLTIPS l" TOOLTIPS
`c......"J
`I
`
`565
`
`.
`
`ASENSITIVE M_EN.U E1-
`
`540
`
`imam"
`WERE?"
`
`IPR2017—00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 5
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`6.0 Working Example
`
`interface as described herein.
`
`0196] As illustrated by the—
`according to
`the present invention is embodied in a system and process
`that automatically provides peripheral awareness of infor-
`mation of interest to a user via the peripheral awareness
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at 1H0196]
`
`

`

`Claim 4 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`[0199] Further, as illustrated by the image of FIG. 6C, a
`container/sidebar 600 having items 605 (i.e., ticket thumb-
`nails may cover the entire display.
`
`User interaction with tickets on such handheld devices is
`
`similar to that described above for tickets displayed on other
`conventional devices.
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at 111] [0199], [0095]
`
`accordance with the present invention, the container 250 is
`implemented in one embodiment as a persistent “sidebar”
`for displaying items 200 along either a portion of the display
`device 260, or the entire display device.
`
`In
`
`In still another embodiment,
`a conventional “auto-hide” function is associated with one
`
`or more containers 250, such that a particular container is
`not visible until a user moves a pointing device near one
`edge of a display device 260.
`
`IPR2017-00913, Cadiz (Ex. 1005) at FIG. 6C
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
` Claims 10, 11, 20, and 21 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
`
`44
`
`

`

`Claim 9 (IPR2017-00913)
`
`• The combination of Cadiz and Smith renders obvious
`claim 9 of the ’384 patent, which states that “the
`dynamic preview information comprises an identity of
`a calling party.”
`
`• Patent Owner argues that the combination makes no
`sense “because the person items already identify a party
`(or contact).” (IPR2017-00913, Paper 17 at 48.)
`
`45
`
`

`

`Claim 9 (11311201700913)
`
`° The sidebar in Figure 8A does not identify a calling party.
`
`
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
` Claims 10, 11, 20, and 21 of the ’466 patent (IPR2017-00914)
`
`47
`
`

`

`Claims 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 (IPR2017—00914)
`
`
`
`7. The method of claim 1, further comprising:
`displaying, in the expanded dynamic bar,—
`_; and
`upon receipt of a configuration input, changing the con-
`figuration option.
`8. The method of claim 7, wherein the interface element
`identifies a wireless networking function, and wherein chang-
`ing the configuration option comprises turning the wireless
`networking function on or off.
`9. The method of claim 7, fiirther comprising updating the
`displayed interface element to reflect the changed configura-
`tion option.
`
`IPR2017-00914, ’466 Patent (Ex. 1001) at Claims 7-9
`
`

`

`Claims 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 (IPR2017—00914)
`
`° Whether a particular implementation is preferred or better is
`irrelevant. (See Fulton, 391 F.3d at 1200)
`
`° Siedlikowski describes changing contact notification settings.
`
`Quick Settings
`
`In one embodiment, quick access is provided to certain
`critical settings Via a—- from the
`taskbar. For example, as indicated in the quick settings menu
`
`1411, the E
`
`IPR2017-009l4, Siedlikowski (Ex. 1008) at 6:66-7:9
`
`

`

`The Challenged Claims Are Obvious
`
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses the “software
`application” limitations.
` Cadiz’s person-centric interface discloses or renders obvious “a
`selectable link embedded in the additional dynamic preview
`information” (IPR2017-00913) / “additional dynamic preview
`information comprising a selectable link” (IPR2017-00914).
` Cadiz’s email-centric interface discloses a selectable link that
`“activat[es]” (IPR2017-00913) / “invokes” (IPR2017-00914) the
`software application.
` Claim 4 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 9 of the ’384 patent (IPR2017-00913)
` Claim 7-9, 18, 19, and 25 of the ’466 pat