Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 87 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`Kodak DCS200 and Kodak DCS200 User's Manual
`
`USP 6,895/149's Claim Language
`Dependent Claim 12:
`12. An interface device
`in accordance with claim 1
`wherein the file allocation table
`includes information on numbers
`of blocks occupied by the data
`file wherein the interface device
`
`is arranged for receiving block
`numbers or a block number
`
`range from the host when the
`host wants to read the data file,
`and wherein the interface device
`is arranged to start a data transfer
`to the host, when the block
`numbers or the block number
`range is received from the host.
`Dependent Claim 13:
`13. An interface device
`in accordance with claim 12
`wherein the processor is
`arranged for formatting the data
`acquired by the second
`connecting device into blocks
`having a predetermined size, the
`predetermined size being suited
`for the storage device.
`Dependent Claim 15:
`15. An interface device
`in accordance with claim 1
`wherein the storage device is a
`hard disk.
`
`Dependent Claim 16:
`6‘ An interface device
`in accordance with claim 1
`wherein the memory has a data
`buffer for permitting
`independence in terms of time of
`the data transmit/receive device
`attachable to the second
`
`connecting device from the host
`device attachable to the first
`connecting device.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 901/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 88 of21O
`
`Exhibit A57
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 902/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11
`
`Page 89 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,4’70,399’s Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`Independent Claim 1:
`1. An interface device for communication between
`
`See PAPO022852: ”Storage — 2MB
`internal”
`
`a host device, which comprises drivers for
`input/output devices customary in a host device and a
`multi-purpose interface, and
`
`a data transmit/receive device,
`
`the data transmit/receive device being arranged for
`providing analog data, comprising:
`
`61 PIOCESSOI}
`
`a memory;
`
`a first connecting device for interfacing the
`host device with the interface device via the multi-
`
`purpose interface of the host device; and
`
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious,
`that the DC25 camera includes a
`CPU.
`
`See I’AI’0()22854: Personal
`
`computer ”PC”
`
`See PAPO022854: ”Plug one end
`of the serial cable into the printer
`or a COM port on the back of
`your computer.”
`
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious,
`
`that a PC comprises drivers for
`input/output devices customary
`in a host device and a multi-
`
`purpose interface.
`
`See, e.g., PAPOO22844,
`PAPOO22849-50: ”Picture Card”
`
`See, e.g., PAPOO22836: ’’camera
`lens”
`
`The DC25 includes a CCD.
`
`The lens and CCD of DC25
`
`provide analog image data.
`
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious,
`that the DC25 camera includes a
`CPU.
`
`See PAPOO22852: ”Storage — 2MB
`internal”
`
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious
`that the DC25 camera includes an
`
`internal memory that is located
`on the camera.
`
`See PAPOO22854: ”camera’s serial
`1/
`
`port
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 903/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11
`
`Page 90 of21O
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`See PAPOO22849: ”Picture card
`slot”
`
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious,
`that the DC25 camera includes a
`
`second connecting device
`comprising a sampling circuit
`and an analog to digital
`converter. Inherent, or otherwise
`
`obvious, that this circuitry
`interfaces analog data provided
`by a data transmit receive device
`(including the CCD image
`sensor) with the interface device.
`
`See '399 claim 1, row G.
`
`See '399 Claim 1, row G.
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,4’70,399’s Claim Language
`
`a second connecting device for interfacing the
`interface device with the data transmit/receive device,
`
`the second connecting device including
`
`a sampling circuit for sampling the analog
`data provided by the data transmit/receive device and
`
`an analog-to-digital converter for converting
`data sampled by the sampling circuit into digital data,
`
`wherein the interface device is configured by
`the processor and the memory
`
`to include a first command interpreter and a
`second command interpreter,
`
`wherein the first command interpreter is
`configured in such a way that the command
`interpreter, when receiving an inquiry from the host
`device as to a type of a device attached to the multi-
`purpose interface of the host device
`
`sends a signal, regardless of the type of the
`data transmit/receive device attached to the second
`
`connecting device of the interface device, to the host
`device
`
`which signals to the host device that it is an
`input/output device customary in a host device
`
`whereupon the host device communicates
`with the interface device by means of the driver for
`the input/output device customary in a host device,
`and
`
`wherein the second command interpreter is
`configured to interpret a data request command from
`the host device to the type of input/output device
`signaled by the first command interpreter as a data
`transfer command for initiating a transfer of the
`digital data to the host device.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 904/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 91 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,4’70,399’s Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`Independent claim 11:
`l 1. An interface device for communication between
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row A.
`
`a host device, which comprises a multi—
`purpose interface and a specific driver for this
`interface, and
`
`See PAPOO22854: Personal
`computer ”PC”
`See PAP0022854: ”Plug one end
`of the serial cable into the printer
`or a COM port on the back of
`your computer.”
`
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious,
`
`that a PC comprises drivers for
`the COM port.
`
`a data transmit/rcccivc dcvicc
`
`See '399 claim 1, row C.
`
`the data transmit/receive device being
`arranged for providing analog data, comprising:
`
`See ‘399 Claim 1, row C1.
`
`a processor;
`
`a memory;
`
`a first connecting device for interfacing the
`host device with the interface device via the multi-
`
`purpose interface of the host device; and
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row D.
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row E.
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row F.
`
`a second connecting device for interfacing
`the interface device with the data transmit/receive
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row G.
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row G1.
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row G2.
`
`device, the second connecting device including
`
`a sampling circuit for sampling the analog
`data provided by the data transmit/receive device
`and
`
`an analog-to-digital converter for converting
`data sampled by the sampling circuit into digital
`data,
`
`where the interface device is configured
`using the processor and the memory
`
`to include a first command interpreter and a
`second command interpreter,
`
`wherein the first command interpreter is
`configured in such a way that the interface device,
`when receiving an inquiry from the host device as to
`the type of a device attached at the multi-purpose
`interface of the host device
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 905/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 92 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,4’70,399’s Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`sends a signal, regardless of the type of the
`data transmit/receive device attached to the second
`
`connecting device of the interface device, to the host
`device,
`
`which signals to the host device that it is an
`input/output device customary in a host device,
`
`whereupon the host device communicates
`with the interface device by means of the specific
`driver for the multi-purpose interface, and
`
`wherein the second command interpreter is
`configured to interpret a data request command
`from the host device to the type of input/output
`device signaled by the first command interpreter as
`a data transfer command for initiating a transfer of
`the digital data to the host device.
`
`Independent Claim 14:
`14. A method of communication between
`
`a host device, which comprises drivers for
`input/output devices customary in a host device and a
`multi-purpose interface, and
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row A.
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row B1
`
`a data transmit/receive device
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row C.
`
`the data transmit/receive device being
`arranged for providing analog data, Via an interface
`device, comprising:
`
`interfacing of the host device with a first
`connecting device of the interface device via the
`multi—purp0Se interface of the host device;
`
`interfacing of the data transmit/receive device
`with a second connecting device of the interface
`device, the second connecting device including
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row C1.
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row F.
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row G.
`
`a sampling circuit for sampling the analog
`data provided by the data/transmit/receive device and
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row G1.
`
`an analog-to-digital converter for converting
`data sampled by the sampling circuit into digital data;
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row G2.
`
`inquiring by the host device at the interface
`device as to the type of device to which the multi-
`purpose interface of the host device is attached;
`
`regardless of the type of the data
`transmit/receive data attached to the second
`
`connecting device of the interface device, responding
`to the inquiry from the host device by the interface
`device
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 906/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 93 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,4’70,399’s Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`in such a way that it is an input/output device
`customary in a host device,
`
`whereupon the host device communicates
`with the interface device by means of the usual driver
`for the input/output device, and
`
`interpreting a data request command from the
`host device to the type of input/output device
`customary in the host device as a data transfer
`command for initiating a transfer of the digital data to
`the host device.
`
`Dependent Claim 2:
`
`2. An interface device according to claim 1,
`wherein the drivers for input/output drivers
`customary in a host device comprise a hard disk
`driver, and the signal indicates to the host device that
`the host device is communicating with a hard disk.
`
`Dependent Claim 3:
`
`3. An interface device according to claim 1,
`wherein the memory means comprises a buffer to
`buffer data to be transferred between the data
`
`transmit/receive device and the host device.
`
`Dependent Claim 5:
`
`5. An interface device according to claim 1,
`wherein the processor is a digital signal processor.
`
`Dependent Claim 7:
`
`7. An interface device according to claim 2,
`which further comprises a root directory and virtual
`files which are present on the signaled hard disk drive
`and which can be accessed from the host device.
`
`Dependent Claim 15:
`
`15. A method according to claim 14, wherein
`the drivers for input/output devices customary in a
`host device comprise a driver for a storage device and
`in particular for a hard disk drive.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 907/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 94 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,895,449’s Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`Independent Claim 1:
`1. An interface device for communication between
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row A.
`
`a host device, which comprises drivers for
`input/output devices customary in a host device and a
`multi-purpose interface, and
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row B1.
`
`a data transmit/receive device comprising the
`following features:
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row C.
`
`a processor;
`
`a memory;
`
`a first connecting device for interfacing the
`host device with the interface device Via the multi-
`
`purpose interface of the host device; and
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row D.
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row E.
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row F.
`
`a second connecting device for interfacing the
`interface device with the data transmit/receive device,
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row G.
`
`wherein the interface device is configured by
`the processor and the memory
`
`in such a way that the interface device, when
`receiving an inquiry from the host device as to the
`type of a device attached to the multi-purpose
`interface of the host device,
`
`sends a signal, regardless of the type of the
`data transmit/receive device attached to the second
`
`connecting device of the interface device, to the host
`device
`
`which signals to the host device that it is a
`storage device customary in a host device,
`
`whereupon the host device communicates
`with the interface device by means of the driver for
`the storage device customary in a host device, and
`
`wherein the interface device is arranged for
`simulating a virtual file system to the host, the virtual
`file system including a directory structure.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 908/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 95 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,895/149's Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`Independent claim 17:
`17. An interface device for communication between
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row A.
`
`a host device, which comprises a multi—
`purpose interface and a specific driver for this
`interface,
`
`See ’399 claim 11, row B2.
`
`and a data transmit/receive device
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row C.
`
`comprising the following features:
`
`a processor;
`
`a memory;
`
`a first connecting device for interfacing the
`host device with the interface device via the multi-
`
`purpose interface of the host device; and
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row D.
`
`See '399 claim 1, row E.
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row F.
`
`a second connecting device for interfacing
`the interface device with the data transmit/receive
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row G.
`
`device,
`
`where the interface device is configured
`using the processor and the memory
`
`in such a way that the interface device, when
`receiving an inquiry from the host device as to the
`type of a device attached at the multi-purpose
`interface of the host device,
`
`sends a signal, regardless of the type of the
`data transmit/receive device attached to the second
`
`connecting device of the interface device, to the host
`device
`
`which signals to the host device that it is a
`storage device customary in a host device,
`
`whereupon the host device communicates
`with the interface device by means of the specific
`driver for the multi-purpose interface, and
`
`wherein the interface device is arranged for
`simulating a virtual file system to the host, the
`virtual file system including a file allocation table
`and a directory structure.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 909/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 96 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,895,449’s Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`Independent Claim 18:
`18. A method of communication between
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row A.
`
`a host device, which comprises drivers for
`input/output devices customary in a host device and a
`multi-purpose interface,
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row B1.
`
`and a data transmit/receive device via an
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row C.
`
`See ’399 claim 1, row F.
`
`See ‘399 claim 1, row G.
`
`interface device comprising the following steps:
`
`interfacing of the host device with a first
`connecting device of the interface device via the
`multi-purpose interface of the host device;
`
`interfacing of the data transmit/receive device
`with a second connecting device of the interface
`device;
`
`inquiring by the host device at the interface
`device as to the type of device to which the multi-
`purpose interface of the host device is attached;
`
`regardless of the type of the data
`transmit/receive device attached to the second
`
`connecting device of the interface device, responding
`to the inquiry from the host device by the interface
`device
`
`in such a way that it is a storage device
`customary in a host device,
`
`whereupon the host device communicates
`with the interface device by means of the usual driver
`for the storage device, and
`
`wherein the interface device is arranged for
`simulating a virtual file system to the host, the virtual
`file system including a file allocation table and a
`directory structure.
`
`Dependent Claim 2:
`2. An interface device in accordance with
`
`claim 1, in which the directory structure has a
`configuration file for setting and controlling functions
`of the interface device or an executable or a batch file
`
`for conducting a routine stored in the memory or a
`data file used for transferring data from the data
`transmit/receive device to the host device or a help file
`for giving help on handling the interface device.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 910/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 97 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,895/149's Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`Dependent Claim 6:
`6. An interface device in accordance with
`
`claim 1 wherein, in response to a request from the
`host to read a boot sequence, the processor is
`arranged to send a virtual boot sequence to the host.
`
`Dependent Claim 7:
`7. An interface device in accordance with
`
`claim 6 wherein the virtual boot sequence includes a
`starting position and a length of a file allocation table,
`an indication of a type of the storage device or a
`number of sectors of the storage device.
`
`Dependent Claim 8:
`8. An interface device in accordance with
`
`claim 7 wherein, in response to a request from the
`host to display a directory of the storage device, a
`processor is arranged for transferring the file
`allocation table and the directory structure to the host.
`
`Dependent Claim 9:
`9. An interface device in accordance with
`claim 1 wherein the file allocation table and the
`
`directory structure is transferred to the host in
`response to a request from the host to read data from
`or store data to the storage device.
`
`Dependent Claim 12:
`12. An interface device in accordance with
`claim 1 wherein the file allocation table includes
`
`information on numbers of blocks occupied by the
`data file wherein the interface device is arranged for
`receiving block numbers or a block number range
`from the host when the host wants to read the data
`
`file, and wherein the interface device is arranged to
`start a data transfer to the host, when the block
`
`numbers or the block number range is received from
`the host.
`
`Dependent Claim 13:
`13. An interface device in accordance with
`
`claim 12 wherein the processor is arranged for
`formatting the data acquired by the second connecting
`device into blocks having a predetermined size, the
`predetermined size being suited for the storage
`device.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 911/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 98 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,895/149's Claim Language
`
`DC25 Camera and DC25
`Camera User's Guide
`
`Dependent Claim 15:
`15. An interface device in accordance with
`
`claim 1 wherein the storage device is a hard disk.
`
`Dependent Claim 16:
`6. An interface device in accordance with
`
`claim 1 wherein the memory has a data buffer for
`permitting independence in terms of time of the data
`transmit/receive device attachable to the second
`
`connecting device from the host device attachable to
`the first connecting device.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 912/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 99 of21O
`
`Exhibit A58
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 913/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 100 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,470,399’s Claim Language
`
`Kodak DCS1, DCS 3, DCS 5
`("DCS Cameras”) and DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual
`
`Independent Claim 1:
`1. An interface device for
`communication between
`
`See, eg: 2-3 of DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”KODAK Camera Back. The
`KODAK camera back is a sealed, one-piece unit. A single mounting screw attaches
`it to a specially modified Canon EOS—1 camera body that has had its film back
`removed.”
`
`a host device, which comprises
`drivers for input/output devices
`
`See, e.g., page 1-4 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Required SCSI Interface.
`ASPI (Advanced SCSI Programming Interface) V\/indows host adapter [.]”
`
`C“S‘°mar.V 1“ a 1105‘ dEViCe and a
`mu1ti‘purp°se interface’ and
`
`a data transmit/receive device,
`
`the data transrnit/receive device
`being arranged for providing
`analog data, comprising:
`
`a processor;
`
`a memory;
`
`See eg. page 4-13 of DCS1 DCS 3 DCS5 User's Manual: ”3/IACINTOSH: Attach
`one 25-pin connector to the SCSI port on the back of the Macintosh computer. [...]
`PC: Attach the 50-pin SCSI2 connector to the SCSI2 port on the back of the PC.”
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious, that Macintosh Computer and IBM PC or
`Compatible Computer comprise drivers for input/output devices customary in a
`personal computer.
`See, eg, page 2-3 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”[S]pecially modified
`Canon EOS—1 N camera body that has had its film back removed."
`See also, Appendix F ("Using an Infrared Camera”);
`See also, page 7-41 (”Separating the Camera from the KODAK Camera Back").
`See, e.g., page 1-6 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Electronic flash and
`accessories.”
`
`See, eg, page 1-6 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Extra lenses for the
`camera.”
`
`See also, page 3-2 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Obtain and mount a lens
`on the camera.”
`
`See also, pages A-6 to A-8: ”EOS—DCS 1 Lenses”, ”EOS—DCS 3 Lenses”, "EOS—DCS 5
`Lenses"
`
`See, eg, page 1-6 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Close—up accessories.”
`See, eg, page 1-6 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Other camera accessories.”
`See, eg, page 1-6 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: "Optional l’ClVlClA Hard
`Disk Card. The camera is designed to accept |’ClVlC|A hard disk cards that support
`the PCMCIA ”ATA" interface and operate in 8-bit mode. Refer to the read-me file
`on |.he supplied software driver diskette for information on specific cards known to
`work with the camera."
`
`See, eg, page 7-2 of DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual: "Just after you take a
`picture, the Canon EOS-1N camera transmits data such as the ISO, aperture, and
`shutter speed to the KODAK camera back. After the shutter closes, the camera back
`uses this information to process the image data.”
`See also, pages 7-18 to 7-20 (”l’ClVlClA Cards").
`See, eg, page 7-2 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”The KODAK camera back
`incorporates a charge coupled device (CCD) full—frame imager that collects light
`striking the imager. [. . .] When you take a picture, light passes through to the lens
`onto the imager; each pixel in the imager receives and stores a specified amount of
`light. These data — for one image — leave the imager chip in analog form, and are
`converter to digital form and stored with other data in dynamic random access
`memory (DRAM)/'
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious, that the DCS Cameras comprise a digital signal
`processor to process digital image data.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither expressly nor inherently disclosed, it would be
`obvious in light of numerous references including US. Patent No. 5,231,501 at 8:27-
`29: "The digital signal processing circuit 177 comprises a microcomputer"
`See, e.g., page 2-4 of DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Dynamic random access
`memorv”
`See, e.., Cha ter 7 ("Reference — Camera 7-1) of DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 914/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 101 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,470,399’s Claim Language
`
`Kodak DCS1, DCS 3, DCS 5
`("DCS Cameras”) and DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual
`
`a first connecting
`device for interfacing the host
`device with the interface device
`via the multi—purpose interface
`of the host device; and
`
`See, eg, page 2-5 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”A SCSI port to connect the
`camera to your computer for transferring images from the camera to your
`computer.”
`See, eg, page 4-13 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”3/Iaking the SCSI
`Connection”
`
`See, eg, page 4-16 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Attach the open end of
`the 25-pin terminator to the SCSI connector on the back of the camera.”
`See, eg, page 7-16 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”SCSI Connector (KODAK
`Camera Back). A 25-pin, female, subminiature D, SCSI connector appears on the
`KODAK Camera back: You connect the camera to your computer from this
`connector with one of the supplied SCSI cables. Once you connect it you can
`operate the camera and the computer simultaneously."
`See, eg, page 2-3 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”The KODAK ca111era back
`is a sealed, one—piece unit. A single mounting screw attaches it to a specially
`modified Canon EOS—1 N camera body that has had its film back removed."
`See, eg, page 2-4 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual.
`See, eg., page 2-5 of DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual: "A PCMCIA—ATA Type III
`slot is designed to accept PCMCIA cards that support the ”ATA protocol and
`operate in 8-bit mode”
`See, eg, page 2-4 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”A charge coupled device
`(CCD) imager, with image data recorded as listed in the Specifications appendix.”
`See, eg., page 7-2 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”The KODAK camera back
`incorporates a charge coupled device (CCD) full—frame imager that collects light
`striking the imager: [. . .] When you take a picture, light passes through to the lens
`onto the imager; each pixel in the imager receives and stores a specified amount of
`light. These data — for one image — leave the imager chip in analog form, and are
`converted to digital form and stored with other data in dynamic random access
`memory (DRAIVI)/'
`
`To the extent that neither the DCS Cameras nor the DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's
`Manual anticipate or render obvious the "sampling circuit" limitation of the asserted
`claims of the '399 patent, the limitation would be obvious when combining the DCS
`Cameras and/or the DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual with the textbook by
`Kenneth Short, Microprocessors and Programmed Logic, Prentice—Hall, Inc., 1981,
`pp. 424-426 ("Microprocessor and Programnied Logic"): One skilled in the art
`would have been motivated to combine these references because the DCS Cameras
`and the DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual comprise or disclose using an A/D
`converter, and Microprocessors and Programmed Logic teaches using a sample and
`hold circuit with an A/D converter to minimize inaccuracies. Thus, one skilled in
`the art would have been motivated to combine the references to minimize the
`inaccuracies of the A/D measurement in the DCS Cameras and disclosed in the
`DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual. Further, the general similarity of technology of
`the references would have motivated one skilled in the art to combine the
`references:
`
`See, eg, page 7-2 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”These data — for one image
`— leave the imager chip in analog form, and are converter to digital form and stored
`with other data in dynamic random access memory (DRAM).”
`
`See "399 claim 1, rows D and E.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither described nor inherently disclosed, it would
`be obvious in light of the SCSI book:
`See '39‘) claim 1, row H.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither expressly nor inherently disclosed, it would be
`obvious in light of the SCSI book:
`
`a second connecting
`device for interfacing the
`interface device with the data
`transmit/receive device, the
`second connecting device
`including
`
`a sampling circuit for
`sampling the analog data
`provided by the data
`transmit/receive device and
`
`an analog—to—digital
`converter for converting data
`sampled by the sampling circuit
`into digital data,
`wherein the interface
`
`device is configured by the
`processor and the memory
`to include a first
`command interpreter and a
`second command interpreter,
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 915/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 102 of21O
`
`USP 6,470,399’s Claim Language
`
`wherein the first
`command interpreter is
`configured in such a way that
`the command interpreter, when
`receiving an inquiry from the
`host device as to a type of a
`device attached to the multi-
`
`purpose interface of the host
`device
`
`sends a signal,
`regardless of the type of the data
`transmit/receive device attached
`to the second connecting device
`of the interface device, to the
`host device
`
`which signals to the
`host device that it is an
`input/output device customary
`in a host device
`
`whereupon the host
`device communicates with the
`interface device by means of the
`driver for the input/output
`device customary in a host
`d evi ce, and
`
`wherein the second
`command interpreter is
`configured to interpret a data
`request command from the host
`device to the type of
`input/output device signaled by
`the first command interpreter as
`a data transfer command for
`initiating a transfer of the digital
`data to the host device.
`
`Independent claim 11:
`11. An interface device for
`communication between
`
`a host device, which
`cmnpri ses a mul ti -purpose interface
`and a specific driver for this
`interface, and
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`Kodak DCS1, DCS 3, DCS 5
`("DCS Cameras”) and DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual
`See ’399 claim 1, rows H and F.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither expressly nor inherently disclosed, it would be
`obvious in light of the SCSI book.
`
`See ’399 claim 1, rows H and F.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither expressly nor inherently disclosed, it would be
`obvious in light of the SCSI book‘
`
`See '399 claim 1, rows H and F.
`
`This limitation is inherently disclosed, or otherwise obvious, because the SCSI
`protocol will identify an interface device as an input/output device customary in a
`host device.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither expressly nor inherently disclosed, it would be
`obvious in light of the SCSI book‘
`See ’399 claim 1, rows H and F.
`
`This limitation is inherently disclosed because the SCSI protocol will identify an
`interface device as an input/output device customary in a host device and the
`personal computer would communicate with the interface device by means of a
`driver that corresponds to the input / output device.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither expressly nor inherently disclosed, it would be
`obvious in light of the SCSI book.
`See '399 claim 1, rows H and F.
`
`To the extent this limitation is neither expressly nor inherently disclosed, it would be
`obvious in light of the SCSI book.
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row A4
`
`SEE, E'..g., pages ll-2 to 1-4 Of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Macintosh
`Computer — Hardware and Software" and ”ll3l\/I PC or Compatible Computer —
`Hardware and Software"
`
`See, eg, page 1-4 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Required SCSI Interface.
`ASPI (Advanced SCSI Programming Interface) Windows host adapter [.]”
`See, eg, page 4—l3 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: "MACINTOSH: Attach
`one 25-pin connector to the SCSI port on the back of the Macintosh computer. [...]
`PC: Attach the 50-pin SCSI2 connector to the SCSIZ port on the back of the PC.”
`
`Inherent, or otherwise obvious, that a Macintosh Computer and an IBM PC or
`Compatible Computer comprise a specific driver for a multi—purpose interface, such
`as a SCSI interface.
`
`HUAWEI EX. 1002 - 916/2201
`
`

`

`Case 1:07-mc-00493-RMC Document 414-5
`
`Filed 01/20/11 Page 103 of21O
`
`PRIOR ART CLAIM CHART
`
`USP 6,470,399’s Claim Language
`
`a data tran smit/receive
`
`Kodak DCS1, DCS 3, DCS 5
`("DCS Cameras”) and DCS1, DCS3, DCS5 User's Manual
`See ’399 Claim 1, row C.
`
`the data transmit/receive
`device being arranged for providing
`analog data, comprising:
`3 IJIOCCSSOI’;
`3. l116lI10l"y;
`
`a first connecting device
`for interfacing the host device with
`the interface device via the multi-
`purpose interface of the host device;
`and
`
`a second connecting
`device for interfacing the interface
`device with the data
`transmit/receive device, the second
`connecting device including
`a sampling circuit for
`sampling the analog data provided
`by the data transmit/receive device
`and
`
`an analog—to—digital
`converter for converting data
`sampled by the sampling circuit into
`digital data,
`where the interface
`device is configured using the
`processor and the memory
`to include a first
`coiiiuiaiid interpreter and a second
`command interpreter,
`wherein the first
`coinman d interpreter is contigured
`in such a way that the interface
`device, when receiving an inquiry
`from the host device as to the type
`of a device attached at the multi-
`purpose interface of the host device
`sends a signal, regardless
`ofthe type ofthe data
`traiisiiiit/receive device attached to
`the second connecting device of the
`interface device, to the host device,
`which signals to the host
`device that it is an input/output
`device customary in a host device,
`whereupon the host
`device coiniiiuiiicates with the
`interface device by means of the
`specific driver for the iiiulti-purpose
`interface, and
`
`Sec '399 Claim 1, row Cl.
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row D.
`See '39‘) Claim 1, row E.
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row F4
`
`See '399 Claim 1, row G.
`
`See '39‘) Claim 1, row G1.
`
`See '399 Claim 1, row G2.
`
`See '399 Claim 1, row H,
`
`See "399 Claim 1, row H1.
`
`See '399 Claim 1, row I.
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row I.
`
`See ’399 Claim 1, row K1.
`
`See, eg, pages 1-2 to 1-4 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: ”Macinlosli
`Computer — Hardware and Software" and ”IBM PC or Compatible Computer —
`Hardware and Software"
`
`See, eg, page 1-4 of DCS1, DCS 3, DCS5 User's Manual: