Unlted States Patent [19]
`Rynderman et al.
`
`llllllllllllll|l|lllllillllllllllllllIllllllllllllllllllllllllllll||||||lll
`USO05563961A
`[11] Patent Number:
`5,563,961
`[45] Date of Patent:
`Oct. 8, 1996
`
`[54] VIDEO DATA COMPRESSION METHOD
`A
`
`To
`
`OPTIMIZE COMPRESSION RATE
`
`[75] Inventors: Michel Rynderman, San Jose; Jay
`Cuccarese, Boulder Creek, both of
`Calif.
`
`[73] Assignee: Radius Inc., Sunnyvale, Calif.
`
`[21] APPL N05 205,959
`[22] Film;
`Man 3’ 1994
`
`[51] Int. Cl.6 ..................................................... .. G06K 9/36
`[52] US. Cl. ........................ .. 382/239; 382/305; 348/419;
`358/430
`[58] Field of Search .............................. .. 382/56, 61, 239,
`382/305; 348/384, 419, 472, 390, 396;
`358/426, 261.2, 430
`
`[56]
`
`References Cited
`
`US‘ PATENT DOCUMENTS
`7/1983 Widergren et a1. ..................... .. 382/56
`4,394,774
`4,706,260 11/1987 Fedele et a1.
`348/419
`4,913,523
`4/1990 Simon 6t 81'
`343/396
`511361377
`8/1992 Johnston ct 31
`348/419
`22812215‘ 31' "
`"
`'
`’
`’
`348/396
`tal. .
`5,225, 05 7/1 93 o 11
`. 358/136
`5 227 378 7/1393 P31111631. ..... ..
`358/133
`5,231,484 7/1993 Gonzales et a1.
`5,253,078 10/1993 Balkanski et a1. ................. .11.. 358/426
`
`‘
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`VideoVisiori Studio v1.7 Upgrade Notes distributed by
`Rad1us Corporation (Mar. 1994).
`Becky Waring, “Targa 2000,” NewMedia, p. 30 (Mar. 1994).
`Primary Examiner—Leo Boudreau
`Assistant Examiner——David R. Anderson
`Attorney, Agent, or Firm—Limbach &,Limbach
`[57]
`ABSTRACT
`A method and system for processing and storing data in
`which the average time needed for storing the processed data
`in a storage device is automatically measured, and a pro
`cessing parameter is optimized in response to the measured
`avcraga Storage tinm In some embodiments, the invention
`compresses and stores video data, automatically measures
`the average time needed for storing the compressed video in
`a storage device, and optimizes the compression rate in
`responser'to the measured average storage time. The inven
`tion provides adaptive control of the bandwidth of processed
`data output to a storage device, to maintain transfer of the
`processed data to any desired storage device with optimal
`(for example, maximum attainable) bandwidth. In some
`embodiments, average throughput time for data transfers to
`and from a desired storage device is automatically measured,
`and an optimal compression rate is set in response to the
`measured time. The average throughput time for a video disk
`storage device can be measured by sending'a sequence of
`words of varied length to the storage device and measuring
`the time elapsed for each of the words to be wntten onto and
`.
`.
`read back fmm ‘1 ‘115k of the Storage dev‘ce'
`
`9 Claims, 1 Drawing Sheet
`
`M
`1
`18
`scs1 BUS
`(MAX
`BAND‘
`
`A
`
`,
`/
`16
`(NUBUS)
`
`17
`2
`> RAM =
`
`6
`8 \ 10a
`\l
`l
`
`CODEC
`WITH
`BUFFER
`
`_/_10b
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`1
`
`A
`
`VIDEO
`
`“5WD
`CONTROL
`
`PROcEssOR
`
`S
`9
`
`v
`
`7
`
`"
`
`CONTROL
`
`VIDEO
`SOURCE
`/
`12
`
`DISK
`
`DEVI
`
`sTOR/ggE
`(MAX
`BAB'?‘
`W'd ) H
`
`‘
`
`Veritas Techs. LLC
`Exhibit 1006
`Page 001
`
`

`
`US. Patent
`
`0a. 8, 1996
`
`5,563,961
`
`SYSTEM BUS
`
`l
`
`BUFFER / 4
`
`2/—
`
`CODEC
`
`¢_____
`CONTROL
`
`X%
`
`3 A; VIDEO
`SOURCE
`
`F|G_ 1
`(PRIOR ART)
`
`A
`q
`18
`SCSIBUS
`
`WW]
`
`A
`
`
`
`16’ (NUBUS)
`
`17
`2
`
`6
`8 \ 10a
`\
`\
`
`/
`
`\
`
`COOEC
`WITH
`
`’
`
`3
`
`BUFFER %f1ob
`// PROCEssOR<——>
`I W 9
`10
`CONTROL
`
`VIDEO
`
`7
`
`CONTROL
`
`VIDEO
`SOURCE
`/
`12
`
`FIG. 2
`
`Veritas Techs. LLC
`Exhibit 1006
`Page 002
`
`

`
`5,563,961
`
`1
`VIDEO DATA COMPRESSION METHOD
`AND SYSTEM WHICH MEASURES
`COMPRESSED DATA STORAGE TllVIE TO
`OPTllVIIZE COMPRESSION RATE
`
`FIELD OF THE INVENTION
`
`The invention relates to methods and systems for com
`pressing video signals, especially digital video data signals.
`More speci?cally, the invention is a method and system for
`compressing video signals in which the average required
`time for storing the compressed video is measured, and in
`which the compression rate is optimized in response to the
`measured average storage time.
`
`BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
`
`2
`completely full or completely empty (to ensure that com
`pressed data are output from buffer 4 to the system bus at a
`preselected constant rate).
`Codec 2 and bu?cer 4 of FIG. 1 are typically implemented
`as a single piece of hardware (often a single integrated
`circuit). Compressed data are written to a storage device
`(connected along the system bus) from buffer 4 at a prese~
`lected ?xed rate, to provide a controlled output bandwidth to
`the system bus from the hardware in which buffer 4 is
`implemented.
`However, conventional video compression methods
`which implement adaptive rate control (including those of
`the type described with reference to FIG. 1), have serious
`limitations. One such limitation is that their output band
`width cannot be automatically and adaptively controlled to
`maintain transfers of compressed video data therefrom to
`any of a variety of compressed video data storage devices (or
`other devices) with an optimal (e.g., maximum attainable)
`bandwidth which depends, in general, on the particular data
`storage device receiving the compressed video data signals.
`
`SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
`
`In a class of embodiments, the invention is a method and
`system for processing and storing data in which the average
`time needed for storing the processed data in a data storage
`device is automatically measured, and a processing param
`eter is optimized in response to the measured average
`storage time. In preferred embodiments, the invention is a
`method and system for compressing and storing video data
`in which the average time needed for storing the compressed
`video in a storage device is automatically measured, and the
`compression rate is optimized in response to the measured
`average storage time. In these embodiments, the invention
`provides adaptive control of output bandwidth (to any
`speci?c data storage device employed to store the processed
`data generated by the invention) to maintain transfer of the
`processed data (e.g., compressed video) to any desired data
`storage device with optimal (e.g., maximum attainable)
`bandwidth.
`In a class of embodiments, the inventive system include
`a means for measuring the average throughput time for data
`transfers to and from the data storage device, and for
`selecting an optimal value of the compression rate in
`response to measured average throughput time. In preferred
`embodiments of the system, the data storage device is a disk
`storage device and the average throughput time is measured
`by sending a sequence of words of varied length to the disk
`storagefdevice and measuring the time elapsed for each of
`the words to be written onto a disk of the disk storage device
`and read back from the disk.
`
`BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
`
`FIG. I is a block diagram of a conventional circuit
`including a video compression/decompression circuit and a
`bu?er memory.
`FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a system which embodies the
`invention.
`
`DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE
`PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
`
`A preferred embodiment of the inventive system will be
`described with reference to FIG. 2. Circuit 6 of FIG. 2
`includes both codec circuit 8 (corresponding to codec 2 of
`FIG. 1), buifer memory 10 (corresponding to buffer 4 of
`
`Throughout the speci?cation (including in the claims) the
`terms “video data” and “video signa ” are used to denote any
`of the broad class of image signals indicative of pixels of an
`image, including analog image signals and digital image
`signals.
`Throughout the speci?cation (including in the claims) the
`expression “disk storage device” is used to denote any of the
`broad class of devices which store data on one or more
`magnetic, optical, magneto-optic, or other disks. The term
`“disk” is used to denote any of such disks.
`Throughout the speci?cation (including in the claims) the
`expressions “external storage device” and “storage device”
`are used interchangeably to denote a storage device which is
`a member of the broad class of storage devices capable of
`storing compressed (or otherwise processed) data, and
`which is separate from a compression circuit or other
`processing circuit (including any buffer memory associated
`therewith) employed to generate the compressed (or other
`wise processed) data to be stored therein. For example, disk
`storage device 14 (shown connected along bus 18 in FIG. 2)
`is an external storage device, capable of storing compressed
`video data generated in codec circuit 8 within circuit 6.
`Device 14 includes one or more magnetic, optical, magneto
`optic, or other disks (the term “disk" is used to denote any
`of such disks).
`Many methods and apparatus for compressing digital
`video data have been developed. An important class of
`conventional methods for digital video compression are
`compression methods which employ adaptive rate control to
`limit the output data rate (the rate at which compressed data
`are output) to a ?xed value. Examples of conventional
`digital video compression methods with adaptive rate con
`trol are described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,231,484, issued Jul. 27,
`1993 to Gonzalez, et al., U.S. Pat. No. 5,253,078, issued Oct.
`12, 1993 to Balkanski, et al., and U.S. Pat. No. 4,394,774
`issued Jul. 19, 1983 to Widergren, et al.
`FIG. 1 is a block diagram of a typical conventional system
`for implementing digital video compression with adaptive
`rate control. In FIG. 1, compression/decompression
`(“codec”) circuit 2 receives video data from video source 3,
`and can process the video data to generate compressed video
`data and then output the compressed video data to bu?rer
`memory 4. Buffer memory 4 has a ?xed capacity. The
`compressed video data are then output from bu?ier 4 over a
`system bus. A video disk storage device (not shown) is
`typically connected along the bus for storing the compressed
`video data. Codec circuit 2 monitors the amount of buffer 4’ s
`capacity ?lled with compressed video data (the value X%,
`indicated in FIG. 1), and adjusts the ?ow rate of compressed
`video pixels into buifer 4 such that buifer 4 is never
`
`25
`
`30
`
`35
`
`45
`
`55
`
`60
`
`65
`
`Veritas Techs. LLC
`Exhibit 1006
`Page 003
`
`

`
`5,563,961
`
`3
`FIG. 1). The FIG. 2 system also includes video source 12
`(which can be a video camera, for example), circuit 6
`(connected along system bus 16), disk storage device 14
`(connected along bus 18), and random access memory 17
`(RAM 17) connected both to bus 16 and bus 18. Disk storage
`device 14 includes one or more disks 14a for storing
`(compressed or uncompressed) video data.
`In operation, codec 8 compresses input video data from
`source 12, and sends the compressed video data to buffer
`memory 10. The compressed video data are output from
`bulfer memory 10 to system bus 16, and are then written into
`RAM 17. Data stored in RAM 17 are then read out onto bus
`18 (under control of processor 9), and transferred over bus
`18 to storage device 14.
`Bus 16 is typically the system bus (e.g., a NUBUS) of a
`host computer in which circuit 6 is installed. Bus 18 is
`typically a SCSI bus.
`Codec 8 compresses input video supplied to it from
`source 12 at a selected compression rate (a rate selected from
`a range of compression rates in response to a control signal
`from processor 9). The selected compression rate is the
`value Y%, where
`Y%=(number of input data bits received by codec
`8)/(number of compressed data bits generated by codec
`8 in response to the input data bits).
`Codec 8 can implement any of a variety of variable rate
`compression methods, such as a compression method which
`satis?es the JPEG (or MPEG) standard.
`Codec 8 typically includes circuitry for decompressing
`compressed video data which it may receive (in addition to
`circuitry for compressing uncompressed input video data
`which it may receive), but it need not include such decom
`pression circuitry in all embodiments of the invention.
`Buffer memory 10 includes portion 10b in which com
`pressed video data have been stored, and portion 10a which
`does not contain stored compressed video data. Processor 9,
`which is programmed with software (to be described) for
`implementing the method of the invention, communicates
`with codec 8. In particular, processor 9 sends one or more
`control signals to codec 8. Alternatively, Codec 8 includes a
`microprocessor which is programmed with software for
`implementing the method of the invention. It is contem
`plated that in some embodiments, processor 9 will be
`programmed with some of the software for implementing
`the invention, and that a processor within codec 8 will be
`programmed with the remaining software for implementing
`the invention (such as speci?c routines called at appropriate
`times by processor 9). In all variations of the FIG. 2 system,
`a processor (e.g., processor 9) functions as a control means
`(or several processors, including processor 9, function
`together as a control means) for measuring the average
`throughput time for data transfers to and from storage device
`14, selecting a desired compression rate in response to
`measured average throughput time, and generating a control
`signal which sets the compression rate applied by codec 8 to
`be the desired compression rate.
`Bus 18 has a maximum bandwidth “b” and a normal
`realizable bandwidth which is some fraction of “b.” Disk
`storage device 14 has a maximum bandwidth “d” and a
`normal realizable bandwidth which is some fraction of “d.”
`Under control of the programmed processor of the invention
`(e.g., processor 9), the system performs tests to determine
`automatically what the overall attainable bandwidth (bit
`rate) for data transfers to and from disk 14a (within storage
`device 14) is likely to be, and then sets the compression rate
`control of codec 8 to an optimal value which does not exceed
`this amount. In a class of preferred embodiments, the
`
`20
`
`25
`
`30
`
`35
`
`45
`
`55
`
`60
`
`65
`
`4
`optimal compression rate matches the overall attainable
`bandwidth for data transfers to and from disk 14a.
`The overall attainable bandwidth for data transfers to and
`from disk 14a is determined by (and can thus be determined
`by measuring) the average throughput time for writing data
`to disk 14a and reading the data back from disk 14a.
`Preferably, the average throughput time is measured by
`sending a sequence of words of varied length from processor
`9 to disk storage device 14 and measuring the time elapsed
`for each of the words to be written onto disk 14a and read
`back from disk 14a.
`In a class of preferred embodiments, the invention mea
`sures both the read and write average throughput times of an
`individual disk system (i.e., the portion of device 14
`employed to write data to and read data from disk 14a), and
`stores this measured data for subsequent processing (for
`example, to determine an optimal compression rate). The
`software for implementing the measurements preferably
`makes all measurements through the appropriate device
`driver (so as to include the “overhead” time of the device
`driver as well) but makes no direct SCSI or drive speci?c
`calls (so as to remain detached from any speci?c hardware
`or platform). It is contemplated that performance of the
`measurement operation may require substantial time (sev
`eral seconds, or even a minute), and so it may be desirable
`to design the inventive system so that the measurement
`operation is performed automatically, but only in response to
`an operator request (such as by operator selection of an icon
`displayed, as part of a “disk characterization” menu, on a
`display device connected along bus 16). '
`In other embodiments, the invention measures both the
`read and'write average throughput times of an individual
`disk system (i.e., the portion of device 14 employed to write
`data to and read data from disk 14a) during a recording
`operation, and processes the measured data (in a feedback
`control loop) to generate feedback signals for use for con
`trolling the recording operation. For example, the feedback
`control signals can vary the compression rate during record
`ing, to cause the compression rate to be optimal at all times
`during the recording operation. Such feedback control loop
`can also measure the percentage of buffer 10’s capacity
`which has been emptied out to storage device 14, and control
`this percentage to be within desired limits.
`In embodiments in which the invention measures average
`throughput time for writing data to one or more disks of a
`disk storage device and reading back the stored data, the
`measurement operation preferably begins by measuring the
`length of a data track on the disk storage device. This
`requires detemiining the number of sectors on a particular
`track. One way to measure the length of a data track, is for
`processor 9 to write a sequence of words of varying length
`to disk 14a, read the sequence of words of varying length
`from disk 14a, and note the time required for each read and
`write operation. In this case, processor 9 would be pro
`grammed to interpret the results of this operation by deter
`mining the maximum length Word that can be written onto
`a single concentric track of disk 14a, and identifying the
`average time required to write such maximum length word
`to a single track and read back such maximum length word
`from the single track. More speci?cally, processor 9 issues
`a sequence of “butter?y address” requests (min-max),
`measures the response times, and weeds out the times which
`represent head switches and cylinder crossings.
`By holding the requests to a single track (e.g., a track on
`disk 14a) and issuing subsequent requests for a total track
`(beginning at index), processor 9 can readily calculate the
`average latency times. It is important to note that this
`
`Veritas Techs. LLC
`Exhibit 1006
`Page 004
`
`

`
`5,563,961
`
`5
`
`5
`measurement should be made at various places throughout
`the disk to get a complete picture, since transfer times will
`vary according to head position relative to the outer diameter
`of the disk. When processor 9 has determined the latency
`times and measured throughput times, it can accurately
`calculate the true throughput times (in a manner that will be
`apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art).
`In one embodiment in which codec 8 operates in response
`to control signals from processor 9 connected along system
`bus 16, processor 9 is the host processor of a Macintosh
`computer system (Macintosh is a trademark of Apple Com
`puter, Inc.), and processor 9 is programmed with the com
`mercially available software known as Macintosh Time
`Manager software and other software (identi?ed below as
`“compression rate control” software for convenience) nec
`essary for implementing the invention. During performance
`of the invention, the compression rate control software
`interfaces with the Macintosh Time Manager software to
`obtain the read time and write time values which the
`compression rate control software needs to determine an
`optimal compression rate and send a corresponding control
`signal to codec 8 (to cause codec 8 to operate at such optimal
`compression rate). By so employing the Macintosh Time
`Manager software (or software functionally equivalent
`thereto), the inventive system requires no special timing
`hardware.
`It is contemplated that in alternative embodiments of the
`invention, the storage device to receive compressed video
`data can be a storage device (e.g., a tape storage device)
`other than a disk storage device. In all such embodiments,
`the inventive method includes the steps of measuring aver
`age throughput time (or the equivalent step of measuring the
`normal realizable bandwidth) for transfers to and from the
`storage device, selecting a desired compression rate in
`response to the measured throughput time (or bandwidth),
`and setting the compression rate (for data to be stored in the
`storage device) at the desired compression rate.
`It is also contemplated that in other alternative embodi
`ments of the invention, the invention processes data (other
`than by compressing video data) in a processing means, and
`stores the processed data in a storage device. The storage
`device can, but need not, be a disk storage device. In these
`alternative embodiments, the storage device can be con
`nected as device 14 vof FIG. 2 is connected, and the pro
`cessing means can be connected as circuit 6 of FIG. 2 is
`connected. Examples of such processing include compres
`sion of audio (or other non-video) data, and encoding (other
`than by compression) of video or non-video data. In all these
`embodiments, the inventive method includes the steps of
`measuring average throughput time (or the equivalent step
`of measuring the normal realizable bandwidth) for data
`transfers to and from the storage device, selecting a desired
`processing rate in response to the measured throughput time
`(or bandwidth), and setting the processing rate (for data to
`be stored) at the desired processing rate. In preferred
`embodiments, the desired processing rate is such that the
`processed data are transferred to the storage device with a
`bandwidth matching the normal realizable bandwidth for
`transfers between the processing means and the storage
`device.
`Various other modi?cations and alterations in the method
`and system of the invention will be apparent to those skilled
`in the art. Although the invention has been described in
`connection with speci?c preferred embodiments, it should
`be understood that the invention as claimed should not be
`unduly limited to such speci?c embodiments.
`What is claimed is:
`1. A system for compressing and storing video data,
`including:
`
`6
`variable rate compression means for generating com
`pressed video data by compressing input video data at
`a ?rst compression rate selected from a range of
`compression rates in response to a control signal;
`a data storage device connected to the variable rate
`compression means, for storing the compressed video
`data; and
`control means, connected to the variable rate compression
`means and the data storage device, for measuring
`average throughput time for data transfer to and from
`the data storage device, selecting a desired compression
`rate in response to measured average throughput time,
`and generating the control signal so that said control
`signal sets the ?rst compression rate to be said desired
`compression rate, wherein the data storage device is a
`disk storage device, and wherein the control means
`includes a processor programmed with software for
`sending a sequence of data words of varied length to the
`disk storage device and measuring time elapsed for
`each of said data words to be written onto a disk of the
`disk storage device and read back from said disk.
`2. The system of claim 1, wherein the processor is
`programmed with software for identifying a maximum
`length data word that can be written onto a single concentric
`track of the disk, and identifying the average time required
`to write said maximum length data word to the single
`concentric track and read back said maximum length data
`word from the single concentric track.
`3. The system of claim 2, wherein the processor is
`programmed with software for issuing a sequence of but
`ter?y address requests for data transfers to the disk storage
`device, measures response times for implementing the but
`ter?y address requests, and identi?es ones of the response
`times which represent head switches and cylinder crossings.
`4. The system of claim 2, wherein the processor is
`programmed with software for identifying a second maxi
`mum length data word that can be written onto a second
`concentric track of the disk, and identifying the average time
`required to write such second maximum length data word to
`the second concentric track and read back such second
`maximum length data word from the second concentric
`track.
`5. A method for compressing and storing video data,
`including the steps of:
`(a) generating compressed video data by compressing
`input video data at a ?rst compression rate selected
`from a range of compression rates in response to a
`control signal;
`(b) storing the compressed video data in a data storage
`device; and
`(0) before step (a), measuring average throughput time for
`data transfer to and from the data storage device,
`selecting a desired compression rate in response to
`measured average throughput time, and generating the
`control signal so that said control signal sets the ?rst
`compression rate to be said desired compression rate,
`wherein the data storage device is a disk storage device
`including a disk, and wherein step (0) includes the steps
`of:
`sending a sequence of data words of varied length to the
`disk storage device; and
`measuring time elapsed for each of said data words to
`be written onto the disk and read back from said disk.
`6. A method for compressing and storing video data,
`including the steps of:
`(a) generating compressed video data by compressing
`input video data at a ?rst compression rate selected
`
`25
`
`30
`
`35
`
`45
`
`55
`
`65
`
`Veritas Techs. LLC
`Exhibit 1006
`Page 005
`
`

`
`5,563,961
`
`7
`from a range of compression rates in response to a
`control signal;
`(b) storing the compressed video data in a data storage
`device; and
`(0) before step (a), measuring average throughput time for
`data transfer to and from the data storage device,
`selecting a desired compression rate in response to
`measured average throughput time, and generating the
`control signal so that said control signal sets the ?rst
`compression rate to be said desired compression rate,
`wherein the data storage device is a disk storage device
`including a disk, and wherein step (c) includes the steps
`of:
`(d) identifying a maximum length data word that can be
`written onto a single concentric track of the disk; and
`(e) identifying average time required to write said maxi~
`mum length data word to the single concentric track
`and read back said maximum length data word from the
`single concentric track.
`7. The method of claim 6, wherein step ((1) includes the
`steps of:
`issuing a sequence of butter?y address requests for data
`transfers to the disk storage device;
`measuring response times for implementing the butter?y
`address requests; and
`determining ones of the response times which represent
`head switches and cylinder crossings.
`8. A method for processing and storing data, including the
`steps of:
`(a) generating processed data by processing input data at
`a ?rst processing rate selected from a range of process
`ing rates in response to a control signal;
`(b) storing the processed data in a data storage device; and
`(c) before step (a), measuring average throughput time for
`data transfer to and from the data storage device,
`
`20
`
`25
`
`30
`
`35
`
`8
`selecting a desired processing rate in response to mea~
`sured average throughput time, and generating the
`control signal so that said control signal sets the ?rst
`processing rate to be said desired processing rate,
`wherein the data storage device is a disk storage device
`including a disk, and wherein step (c) includes the steps
`of:
`sending a sequence of data words of varied length to the
`disk storage device; and
`measuring time elapsed for each of said data words to
`be written onto the disk and read back from said disk.
`9. A method for processing and storing data, including the
`steps of:
`(a) generating processed data by processing input data at
`a ?rst processing rate selected from a range of process
`ing rates in response to a control signal;
`(b) storing the processed data in a data storage device; and
`(c) before step (a), measuring average throughput time for
`data transfer to and from the data storage device,
`selecting a desired processing rate in response to mea
`sured average throughput time, and generating the
`control signal so that said control signal sets the ?rst
`processing rate to be said desired processing rate,
`wherein the data storage device is a disk storage device
`including a disk, and wherein step (c) includes the steps
`of:
`(d) identifying a maximum length data word that can be
`written onto a single concentric track of the disk; and
`(e) identifying average time required to write said maxi
`mum length data word to the single concentric track
`and read back said maximum length data word from the
`single concentric track.
`
`Veritas Techs. LLC
`Exhibit 1006
`Page 006