VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`Versata 2307
`Ford v. Versata
`IPR2017-00150
`
`- i -
`
`

`

`Table of Contents:
`Search Criteria:(cid:160)
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Business Description
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Financial Summary
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Officers
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Directors
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Industries
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Key Competitors
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Product Information
`Company Summary:(cid:160)VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Hoover's Company Profiles, 5/18/2016
`12:00:00 AM
`Litigation:(cid:160)Practice Area Trends & Analysis
`Litigation:(cid:160)Court Trends & Analysis
`Litigation:(cid:160)Law Firm Size Trends & Analysis
`Litigation:(cid:160)Docket and Opinion Trends & Analysis
`Litigation:(cid:160)Law Firm Representation Trends & Analysis
`Litigation:(cid:160)Presiding Judge Trends & Analysis
`Litigation:(cid:160)Attorney Representation Trends & Analysis
`Litigation:(cid:160)Legal Role Trends & Analysis
`Patent Assignments:(cid:160)Volume
`Granted Patents:(cid:160)Volume
`Granted Patents:(cid:160)Litigation
`Granted Patents:(cid:160)Litigation
`
`2
`3
`4
`5
`6
`7
`8
`9
`10
`
`13
`14
`15
`16
`17
`18
`19
`20
`21
`22
`23
`25
`
`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`1
`
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`2
`
`Search Criteria
`
`Company:(cid:160)
`VERSATA SOFTWARE INC
`Date Range:(cid:160)Last five years (05/2011 to 05/2016)
`
`Litigation Refinements
`Practice Area:
`Intellectual Property - Patents
`Intellectual Property: Generally
`Intellectual Property - Copyrights
`
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`3
`
`Company Summary:(cid:160) VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Business Description
`
`VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Business Description
`
`Copyright Hoover's Inc. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Austin, TX
`Distributed only in accordance with licensing agreement.
`
`Date: May(cid:160)18,(cid:160)2016
`
`Location:
`
`401 Congress Ave Ste 2600
`
`Austin, TX78701-3744
`
`United States
`
`Phone: 512-524-6149
`
`Fax: 512-874-8900
`
`Toll-free:
`
`Website: http://www.trilogy.com
`
`Ticker Information:
`
`Company Type: Private
`
`Stock Exchange: (cid:160) Ticker Symbol:
`
`Business Description:
`
`Trilogy helps your customers return again and again and again. The company's software helps
`large corporations manage comple x sales and purchasing channels that involve extensive
`product lines and high transaction volumes. Customers use its software to integrate and manage
`sales, distribution, and supplier channels, as well as for content management and data
`integration. In addition, the company provides professional services such as consulting and
`support. Customers have included(cid:160)General Motors, Ford,(cid:160)Goodyear, Nissan, and Penn Mutual
`Life. Founder and CEO Joe Liemandt is the controlling shareholder of the company.
`
`Trilogy has refocused its operations around two core market sectors -- automotive and
`telecommunications. The company has also expanded internationally, opening offices in China
`and India. In early 2009 the company attempted a hostile takeover of(cid:160)Autobytel(cid:160)but failed when
`Autobytel's board of directors rejected its offer and recommended that shareholders(cid:160)reject
`Trilogy's offer.
`
`Trilogy acquired Versata(cid:160)in 2006(cid:160)for about $3 million. Trilogy(cid:160)then merged(cid:160)portions of(cid:160)the
`company(cid:160)(primarily its(cid:160)Trilogy Technology Group) into Versata as part of a broad reorganization
`that also included moving most technical positions offshore to its office in Bangalore, India.
`
`Versata has been active on the acquisition front in recent years, purchasing(cid:160)Artemis
`International,(cid:160)Nextance, and(cid:160)Gensym(cid:160)in 2006-2007. The(cid:160)Versata acquisitions continued(cid:160)(cid:160)in
`2008 with the(cid:160)purchases(cid:160)of NUVO Network Management,(cid:160)TenFold, Clear
`Technology,(cid:160)Evolutionary Technologies International, and(cid:160)Ecora Software, with(cid:160)Everest
`Software(cid:160)joining the fold in 2009.
`
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`10
`
`Company Summary:(cid:160) VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Hoover's Company Profiles, 5/18/2016 12:00:00 AM
`
`Copyright Hoover's Inc. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Austin, TX
`Distributed only in accordance with licensing agreement.
`
`Hoover's In-Depth Company Records
`
`Date: May(cid:160)18,(cid:160)2016
`
`Trilogy Enterprises, Inc.
`
`Overview
`
`Trilogy helps your customers return again and again and again. The company's software helps large corporations manage
`complex sales and purchasing channels that involve extensive product lines and high transaction volumes. Customers use its
`software to integrate and manage sales, distribution, and supplier channels, as well as for content management and data
`integration. In addition, the company provides professional services such as consulting and support. Customers have
`included(cid:160)General Motors, Ford,(cid:160)Goodyear, Nissan, and Penn Mutual Life. Founder and CEO Joe Liemandt is the controlling
`shareholder of the company.
`
`Trilogy has refocused its operations around two core market sectors -- automotive and telecommunications. The company has
`also expanded internationally, opening offices in China and India. In early 2009 the company attempted a hostile takeover
`of(cid:160)Autobytel(cid:160)but failed when Autobytel's board of directors rejected its offer and recommended that shareholders(cid:160)reject Trilogy's
`offer.
`
`Trilogy acquired Versata(cid:160)in 2006(cid:160)for about $3 million. Trilogy(cid:160)then merged(cid:160)portions of(cid:160)the company(cid:160)(primarily its(cid:160)Trilogy
`Technology Group) into Versata as part of a broad reorganization that also included moving most technical positions offshore to
`its office in Bangalore, India.
`
`Versata has been active on the acquisition front in recent years, purchasing(cid:160)Artemis International,(cid:160)Nextance, and(cid:160)Gensym(cid:160)in
`2006-2007. The(cid:160)Versata acquisitions continued(cid:160)(cid:160)in 2008 with the(cid:160)purchases(cid:160)of NUVO Network Management,(cid:160)TenFold, Clear
`Technology,(cid:160)Evolutionary Technologies International, and(cid:160)Ecora Software, with(cid:160)Everest Software(cid:160)joining the fold in 2009.
`
`Contact Information
`
`401 Congress Ave Ste 2600
`
`Austin, TX78701-3744
`
`United States
`
`Phone: 512-524-6149
`
`Fax: 512-874-8900
`
`Toll-free:
`
`Website: http://www.trilogy.com
`
`Key Numbers
`
`Fiscal Year End:
`
`

`

`Company Summary: VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Hoover's Company Profiles, 5/18/2016 12:00:00 AM
`(Continued)
`
`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`11
`
`2016 Sales ($mil.): $70.1
`
`One Year Sales Growth:
`
`2016 Sales ($mil.):
`
`Sales ($mil.): 36
`
`One Year Employee Growth:
`
`Auditor ()
`
`Stock
`
`Company Type: Private
`
`Stock Exchange: (cid:160) Ticker Symbol:
`
`Rankings
`
`Officers
`
`Senior Vice President Products ,(cid:160)Latif Nathani
`
`Executive Vice President Global Sales ,(cid:160)Douglas (Doug) Gattuso
`
`Directors
`
`There is no Company Summary information for this section from the most current Hoovers Company Profile report.
`
`Product Information
`
`Production:
`
`There is no Company Summary information for this section from the most current Hoove rs Company Profile report.
`
`Operations:
`
`There is no Company Summary information for this section from the most current Hoovers Company Profile report.
`
`Selected Products
`
`Automotive prospecting and portal (CarBuy)
`
`Lead generation (Trilogy SmartLeads)
`
`Telecommunications sales prospecting (YourBillBuddy)
`
`

`

`Company Summary: VERSATA SOFTWARE INC - Hoover's Company Profiles, 5/18/2016 12:00:00 AM
`(Continued)
`
`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`12
`
`Key Competitors
`
`IBM Global Services
`Ariba
`Selectica
`A.T. Kearney
`Oracle
`Ernst & Young Global
`SAP
`
`Industry
`
`Computer Software
`
`E-commerce Software
`
`History
`
`As a Stanford University student in the late 1980s, budding entrepreneur Joe Liemandt studied software companies and worked as a computer
`consultant. At work, he noticed that shipments were often sloppily handled. In 1989 he dropped out of school, recruited four other students,
`and started Trilogy Development Group to create sales order software. Family friend and former GE CEO Jack Welch provided
`encouragement while Liemandt juggled credit cards to fund the startup.
`
`The company moved to Austin in 1992, recruited top software designer David Franke, and soon inked a deal with Hewlett-Packard, followed by
`deals with Silicon Graphics and Boeing. In 1993 the company formed pcOrder.com to develop artificial intelligence-based sales order software
`(for helping customers make decisions) for online computer sellers. By 1994 more than half of the biggest computer makers in the country
`were using Trilogy's Sales Builder program.
`
`Trilogy introduced a slew of products in 1998, including Channel Chain software (personalized catalogs) and Web-based procurement software
`Buying Chain. That year the company changed its name from Trilogy Development Group to Trilogy Software. In 1999 Trilogy took
`pcOrder.com public, but retained significant majority control over the company's voting power. The company that year also formed
`carOrder.com and applianceOrder.com (both companies ceased operations within a year).
`
`It by then had also developed a reputation for its on-campus recruitment program, Trilogy University. Trilogy University introduced potential
`employees to the company through a rigorous three-month tutorial; many new hires began the intensive schooling with no set position and were
`challenged through the months to discover their best fit with the company.
`
`Trilogy in 2000 shortened its name from Trilogy Software to Trilogy. As the market for technology spending began to ease, the company pulled
`back its online efforts. Late in 2000 Trilogy bought back the public shares of pcOrder.com.
`
`The company in 2001 announced it would cut about 340 jobs (about 30% of its workforce), and restructure operations around automotive,
`telecommunications, and other specific vertical market niches.
`
`In an effort to save costs, Trilogy moved its software department and the acclaimed Trilogy University program to Bangalore, India in May
`2004. Trilogy entered the market for software for automotive engineering and sales when it acquired Michigan-based VulcanWorks in June
`2004.
`
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`13
`
`Litigation:(cid:160) Practice Area Trends & Analysis
`
`Uses West’s KeySearch topics to analyze litigation activity by practice area. (Practice area of an opinion is based on the topics
`that occur most often in the opinion text and West headnotes.) Analyzes litigation events by overall share of a particular practice
`area, and by number per year per practice area within the date range.
`
`Practice Area Distribution
`
`Practice Area Trend
`
`(cid:160) (cid:160) Practice Area
`Intellectual Property - Patents >
`Federal NOS: Property Rights:
`Patent (830)
`Intellectual Property: Generally
`> Infringement
`Intellectual Property - Patents >
`Infringement
`Intellectual Property - Patents >
`Actions and Proceedings
`Intellectual Property -
`Copyrights > Federal NOS:
`Property Rights: Copyrights
`(820)
`Intellectual Property - Patents >
`Claims
`Intellectual Property: Generally
`> Trade Secrets
`Intellectual Property -
`Copyrights > Actions and
`Proceedings
`Intellectual Property: Generally
`> Actions and Proceedings
`Other Practice Areas
`
`Occurrences
`27
`
`%
`29.0%
`
`11
`
`11.8%
`
`9
`
`6
`
`5
`
`5
`
`4
`
`3
`
`3
`
`9.7%
`
`6.5%
`
`5.4%
`
`5.4%
`
`4.3%
`
`3.2%
`
`3.2%
`
`20
`
`21.5%
`
`View Report Online
`
`*Data for partial year only
`
`(cid:160)
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`14
`
`Litigation:(cid:160) Court Trends & Analysis
`
`Displays the state and federal courts in which the company has litigated within the date range. Analyzes litigation events by
`overall share litigated in a jurisdiction.
`
`Courts Distribution
`
`Courts Trend
`
`(cid:160) (cid:160) Courts
`U.S. District Courts > Texas -
`Federal Courts
`U.S. District Courts > California
`- Federal Courts
`U.S. Courts of Appeal > United
`States Court of Appeals,
`Federal Circuit
`U.S. District Courts > Delaware
`- Federal Courts
`U.S. District Courts > Michigan -
`Federal Courts
`Misc. Federal Courts > United
`States Patent Trial and Appeal
`Board
`U.S. District Courts > New
`Jersey - Federal Courts
`U.S. Courts of Appeal > United
`States Court of Appeals, Ninth
`Circuit
`
`Occurrences
`20
`
`%
`33.9%
`
`13
`
`22.0%
`
`9
`
`9
`
`3
`
`2
`
`2
`
`1
`
`15.3%
`
`15.3%
`
`5.1%
`
`3.4%
`
`3.4%
`
`1.7%
`
`View Report Online
`
`*Data for partial year only
`
`(cid:160)
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`15
`
`Litigation:(cid:160) Law Firm Size Trends & Analysis
`
`Displays the sizes of law firms that have represented the companies included in this report within the date range.(Size is based
`on number of attorneys within the entire firm, not on individual office or location.) Analyzes law firm representation by overall
`share of events per size of firm, and by number of litigation events per year per size of firm.
`
`Law Firm Size Distribution
`
`Law Firm Size Trend
`
`(cid:160) (cid:160)
`
`Law Firm Size
`16 to 40
`
`101 to 250
`
`2 to 15
`
`41 to 100
`
`501-750
`
`Solo
`
`751+
`
`251-500
`
`Occurrences
`21
`
`16
`
`14
`
`11
`
`4
`
`3
`
`2
`
`1
`
`%
`29.2%
`
`22.2%
`
`19.4%
`
`15.3%
`
`5.6%
`
`4.2%
`
`2.8%
`
`1.4%
`
`View Report Online
`
`*Data for partial year only
`
`(cid:160)
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`16
`
`Litigation:(cid:160) Docket and Opinion Trends & Analysis
`
`Tracks a company’s litigation by number of filed cases (dockets) and number of decided cases (opinions) within the date range.
`
`Docket and Opinion Trend
`
`(cid:160) (cid:160)
`
`Docket and Opinion Breakdown
`Cases Filed (Dockets)
`
`Cases Decided (Opinions)
`
`*Data for partial year only
`
`Occurrences
`32
`
`27
`
`View Report Online
`
`(cid:160)
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`17
`
`Litigation:(cid:160) Law Firm Representation Trends & Analysis
`
`Displays law firms that have represent companies in litigation included in this report within the date range. Analyzes law firm
`representation by overall share of events, and by number of events per year per firm.
`
`Law Firm Representation Distribution
`
`Law Firm Representation Trend
`
`(cid:160) (cid:160)
`
`Law Firm Representation
`AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS,
`ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI &
`MENSING P.C.
`MCKOOL SMITH
`
`MCGINNIS LOCHRIDGE
`
`VALOREM LAW GROUP
`LLP
`ROSENTHAL, MONHAIT &
`GODDESS, P.A.
`MORRIS, NICHOLS,
`ARSHT & TUNNELL LLP
`DORSEY & WHITNEY
`LLP
`YOUNG & ASSOCIATES,
`PLLC
`GIBBONS P.C.
`Other Law Firms
`
`Profile Occurrences %
`21
`28.0%
`
`14
`
`7
`
`6
`
`5
`
`4
`
`3
`
`3
`
`2
`
`10
`
`18.7%
`
`9.3%
`
`8.0%
`
`6.7%
`
`5.3%
`
`4.0%
`
`4.0%
`
`2.7%
`
`13.3%
`
`View Report Online
`
`*Data for partial year only
`
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`18
`
`Litigation:(cid:160) Presiding Judge Trends & Analysis
`
`Shows judges who have participated in legal events in this report within the date range. Analyzes litigation by a judge’s share of
`events, and by number of events per year per judge.
`
`Presiding Judges Distribution
`
`Presiding Judges Trend
`
`(cid:160) (cid:160) Presiding Judges
`BRYSON, HON.
`WILLIAM CURTIS
`SPARKS, HON. SAM
`
`ILLSTON, HON. SUSAN
`
`ROBINSON, HON. SUE
`LEWIS
`STARK, HON. LEONARD
`PHILLIP
`GREWAL, HON. PAUL
`SINGH
`LEITMAN, HON.
`MATTHEW FREDERICK
`ENGLAND, HON.
`MORRISON C. JR.
`LOURIE, HON. ALAN
`DAVID
`Other Judges
`
`Profile Occurrences Percent
`7
`12.3%
`
`7
`
`5
`
`5
`
`4
`
`3
`
`3
`
`2
`
`2
`
`12.3%
`
`8.8%
`
`8.8%
`
`7.0%
`
`5.3%
`
`5.3%
`
`3.5%
`
`3.5%
`
`19
`
`33.3%
`
`View Report Online
`
`*Data for partial year only
`
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`

`

`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`23
`
`Granted Patents:(cid:160) Litigation
`
`Shows a summary of patent litigation within the date range. The heat map shows number of patent cases and overall growth
`rate of patent cases broken down by state and court jurisdiction during the selected date range. Coverage begins in 2003.
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MAINTAINING AND CONFIGURING
`SYSTEMS
`
`THE HECKER LAW GROUP, PLC
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`MASTER DATA MAINTENANCE TOOL FOR SINGLE SOURCE DATA
`
`Unknown
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MAINTAINING AND CONFIGURING
`SYSTEMS
`
`Unknown
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`Case
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`713/100,
`US
`713/001,
`Class:
`710/008, 700/019
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Patent Number:
`
`6405308
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Patent Number:
`
`6678695
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`US
`Class: 707/102
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Patent Number:
`
`5825651
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`US
`Class:
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`RULE BASED CONFIGURATION ENGINE FOR A DATABASE
`
`Unknown
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MAINTAINING AND CONFIGURING
`SYSTEMS
`
`Unknown
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`PRODUCT CONFIGURATION USING CONFIGURATION PATTERNS
`
`Unknown
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent Number:
`
`6836766
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`US
`703/019,
`Class:
`706/001, 706/046
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Patent Number:
`
`6675294
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`713/100,
`US
`700/019,
`Class:
`713/001, 710/008
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Patent Number:
`
`7188335
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`US
`717/122,
`Class:
`717/104, 717/121
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`

`

`Granted Patents: Litigation (Continued)
`
`(C) Thomson Reuters | VERSATA SOFTWARE INC Company Report
`
`24
`
`CONFIGURATION MODEL CONSISTENCY CHECKING USING FLEXIBLE
`RULE SPACE SUBSETS
`
`Unknown
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`CONFIGURATION REPRESENTATION AND MODELING USING
`CONFIGURATION SPACES
`
`Unknown
`
`SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,LANCE
`LEE,AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING
`P.C.,SANDERS, O'HANLON & MOTLEY, PLLC,LANCE LEE,AHMAD,
`ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS, ALAVI & MENSING P.C.
`
`SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP,BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.
`
`METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MAINTAINING AND CONFIGURING
`SYSTEMS
`
`Unknown
`
`BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.,DYKEMA GOSSETT PLLC
`
`YOUNG & ASSOCIATES, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,YOUNG & ASSOCIATES,
`PLLC
`
`METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR MAINTAINING AND CONFIGURING
`SYSTEMS
`
`Unknown
`
`BROOKS KUSHMAN P.C.,DYKEMA GOSSETT PLLC
`
`YOUNG & ASSOCIATES, PLLC,Unknown,Unknown,YOUNG & ASSOCIATES,
`PLLC
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Patent:
`
`Patent
`Firm:
`Plaintiff
`Firm:
`Defendant
`Firm:
`
`Case
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`US
`706/047,
`Class:
`706/046, 706/045
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Patent Number:
`
`7200582
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Patent Number:
`
`7953779
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Tex. 4:15-CV-00316
`
`TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC,TRILOGY INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA
`SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,TRILOGY
`INC
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 05/07/2015
`US
`Class:
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`Defendant:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Patent Number:
`
`6405308
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Mich. 2:15-CV-10628
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 02/19/2015
`US
`Class:
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Defendant:
`
`VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE
`INC,TRILOGY INC,TRILOGY INC
`
`Patent Number:
`
`5825651
`
`Court/Dkt:
`
`E.D.Mich. 2:15-CV-10628
`
`(cid:160) C
`
`ase
`Filed: 02/19/2015
`US
`Class:
`
`Plaintiff:
`
`FORD MOTOR CO,FORD MOTOR CO
`
`Defendant:
`
`VERSATA SOFTWARE INC,VERSATA SOFTWARE
`INC,TRILOGY INC,TRILOGY INC
`
`View Report Online
`
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`(cid:160)
`