WPKVGF UVCVGU RCVGPV CPF VTCFGOCTM QHHKEG
`
`aaaaaaaaaaa
`
`DGHQTG VJG RCVGPV VTKCN CPF CRRGCN DQCTF
`
`aaaaaaaaaaa
`
`MCYCUCMK TCKN ECT- KPE/-
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt-
`
`x/
`
`UEQVV DNCKT-
`
`Rcvgpv Qypgt
`
`aaaaaaaaaa
`
`Ecug KRT3128.11228
`
`Rcvgpv 7-811-713
`
`GZRGTV FGENCTCVKQP QH LCEM T/ NQPI
`
`EXHIBIT 2002
`
`

`

`K/
`
`KPVTQFWEVKQP
`
`2/
`
`3/
`
`K- Lcem Nqpi- jcxg dggp tgvckpgf d{ eqwpugn hqt Ueqvv Dnckt )jgtgkpchvgt •Dnckt–*/
`
`K uwdokv vjku fgenctcvkqp kp uwrrqtv qh Rcvgpv Qypgt”u Rtgnkokpct{ Tgurqpug vq
`
`Rgvkvkqp hqt Kpvgt Rctvgu Tgxkgy qh 7-811-713- Pq/ KRT 3128.11228/
`
`KK/
`
`SWCNKHKECVKQPU
`
`4/
`
`K jqnf c Dcejgnqt qh Uekgpeg fgitgg kp Ogvcnnwtikecn Gpikpggtkpi htqo vjg
`
`Wpkxgtukv{ qh Okuuqwtk/
`
`5/
`
`K ycu cp Qhhkegt kp vjg WU Cto{ Eqtru qh Gpikpggtu ykvj vyq {gctu cevkxg fwv{ cu
`
`Nkgwvgpcpv cpf hkxg {gctu tgugtxg fwv{ cu c Ecrvckp/
`
`6/
`
`K jcxg qxgt 46 {gctu qh gzrgtkgpeg kp xctkqwu gpikpggtkpi- ucngu- cpf kpvgtpcvkqpcn
`
`rqukvkqpu- kpenwfkpi cu Ejkgh Gpikpggt cpf Ugpkqt XR Kpvgtpcvkqpcn/
`
`7/
`
`K jcxg uwrgtxkugf c uvchh qh qxgt 51 rtqhguukqpcnu kp fgukip gpikpggtkpi- vguvkpi-
`
`hkgnf ugtxkeg gpikpggtkpi cpf ftchvkpi/
`
`8/
`
`K co c tgeqipk|gf gzrgtv kp vjg fgukip cpf gpikpggtkpi qh tqnnkpi uvqem kpenwfkpi
`
`nqeqoqvkxg- rcuugpigt cpf htgkijv xgjkengu )•tckn ectu–* cpf vjgkt eqorqpgpvu cpf qvjgt ctgcu qh
`
`gpikpggtkpi cpf ocvgtkcn uekgpeg/
`
`9/
`
`K jgcfgf vjg ucngu cpf ugtxkeg gpikpggtkpi hwpevkqpu hqt rtqrtkgvct{ tqnnkpi uvqem
`
`gswkrogpv/
`
`;/
`
`K ycu vjg vtcpurqtvcvkqp ucngu ocpcigt hqt c tcknyc{ gswkrogpv eqorcp{- cpf
`
`yqtmgf ykvj oclqt ogvtq cigpekgu cpf tqnnkpi uvqem dwknfgtu/
`
`21/
`
`K ycu c rtqitco ocpcigt hqt fgukipkpi cpf dwknfkpi vjg Ycujkpivqp F/E/ ogvtq
`
`ectu/
`
`22/
`
`K co vjg kpxgpvqt qh gkijv kuuwgf Wpkvgf Uvcvgu Rcvgpvu tgncvkpi vq xctkqwu tcknyc{
`
`tgncvgf gpikpggtkpi rtqfwevu- vjg fgukip cpf gpikpggtkpi qh tqnnkpi uvqem- vjgkt eqorqpgpvu cpf
`
`tgncvgf fgxkegu/
`
`23/
`
`24/
`
`25/
`
`K ycu c Ejkgh gpikpggt hqt tcknyc{ rtqrtkgvct{ htgkijv cpf rcuugpigt gswkrogpv/
`
`K jcxg ytkvvgp cpf rtgugpvgf rtqhguukqpcn vgejpkecn rcrgtu kp ugxgp eqwpvtkgu/
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv ;-4;6-387 gpvkvngf- •Ogvjqf cpf u{uvgo hqt
`
`fgvgevkqp cpf cpcn{uku qh tcknyc{ dqikg qrgtcvkqpcn rtqdngou/”
`
`

`

`26/
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv 7-533-265 gpvkvngf- •Vjtgg.rkgeg tcknyc{ vtwem
`
`htcog jcxkpi c ugngevkxgn{ tgoqxcdng dqnuvgt/–
`
`27/
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv 7-253-192 gpvkvngf- •Rgfguvcn tqemgt ugcv hqt
`
`rtqxkfkpi rcuukxg czng uvggtkpi vq c tkikf tcknyc{ vtwem/–
`
`28/
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv 6-618-511 gpvkvngf- •Uncemnguu ftcydct qt eqwrngt
`
`ykvj uykxgn oqwpvkpi/–
`
`29/
`
`2;/
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv 6-574-;75 gpvkvngf- •Tqemgt ugcv eqppgevkqp/–
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv 6-24;-272 gpvkvngf- •Cwvqocvke cevwcvqt hqt
`
`eqwrngt mpwemng.cuugodn{ qh c tcknyc{ rcuugpigt ect/–
`
`31/
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv 6-138-827 gpvkvngf- •Uvcdknk|gf uykpi.oqvkqp vtwem
`
`hqt tcknyc{ ectu/–
`
`32/
`
`K co cp kpxgpvqt qh W/U/ Rcvgpv 5-855-419 gpvkvngf- •Eqodkpgf egpvgt rncvg0egpvgt
`
`hknngt hqt tcknyc{ htgkijv ectu/–
`
`KKK/ OCVGTKCNU EQPUKFGTGF
`
`33/
`
`K jcxg tgxkgygf vjg hqnnqykpi<
`
`c/
`
`d/
`
`W/U/ Rcv/ Pq/ 7-811-713 )•vjg “713 rcvgpv–* kpenwfkpi vjg enckou vjgtgqh=
`
`Rgvkvkqp hqt Kpvgt Rctvgu Tgxkgy qh W/U/ Rcvgpv Pq/ 7-811-713- Pq/
`
`QRT3128.11228 kpenwfkpi Gzjkdkvu/
`
`e/
`
`Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcp Vtckp Qrgtcvkqp Cuuqekcvkqp Ocic|kpg- Xqn/ 48-
`
`kuuwg pq/ 4 )Octej 2- 2;;6* )Gz/ 2114- •LVQC Ocic|kpg–*=
`
`f/
`
`Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 15.19648; )Gz/ 2116-
`
`•Pcokmcyc–*=
`
`g/
`
`Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 18.292;11 )Gz/ 2118-
`
`•Ok{clkoc–*=
`
`h/
`
`Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 15.43368; )Gz/ 2122-
`
`•Ucucq–*=
`
`i/
`
`j/
`
`•Ocgmcyc–*=
`
`W/U/ Rcvgpv Pq/ 6-3;4-355 vq Mcyciwejk )Gz/ 2133- “Mcyciwejk–*=
`
`Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 15.271;;2 )Gz/ 211;-
`
`

`

`k/
`
`Vjg vtcpuncvkqp qh Lcrcpgug Rwdnkecvkqp Pq/ 13.34;96 )Gz/ 2132-
`
`•Cocpq”*=
`
`l/
`
`m/
`
`Vjg hkng jkuvqt{ qh vjg “713 Rcvgpv rtqxkfgf kp Gz/ 2123= cpf
`
`Vjg tggzcokpcvkqp hkng jkuvqt{ qh vjg “713 Rcvgpv rtqxkfgf kp Gz/ 2124/
`
`34/
`
`K wpfgtuvcpf kv jcu dggp uvcvgf vjcv vjg hqnnqykpi tghgtgpegu ctg rtkqt ctv vq cnn qh
`
`vjg enckou qh vjg “713 Rcvgpv<
`
`c/
`
`LVQC Ocic|kpg=
`
`d/ Pcokmcyc=
`
`e/ Ok{clkoc=
`
`f/ Ucucq=
`
`g/ Mcyciwejk=
`
`h/ Ocgmcyc= cpf
`
`i/ Cocpq/
`
`35/
`
`Kp ocmkpi o{ eqpenwukqpu uvcvgf jgtgkp- yjkng tgxkgykpi vjg ocvgtkcnu nkuvgf kp
`
`rctcitcrju 33 cpf 34- K jcxg crrnkgf vjg encko eqpuvtwevkqp fghkpkvkqpu crrnkgf d{ Rgvkvkqpgt kp kvu
`
`Rgvkvkqp hqt Kpvgt Rctvgu Tgxkgy qh W/U/ Rcvgpv Pq/ 7-811-713- Pq/ KRT3128.11228/
`
`36/
`
`K wpfgtuvcpf vjcv c encko ku kpxcnkf hqt qdxkqwupguu kh vjg fkhhgtgpegu dgvyggp vjg
`
`uwdlgev ocvvgt uqwijv vq dg rcvgpvgf cpf vjg rtkqt ctv ctg uq kpuwduvcpvkcn vjcv vjg uwdlgev ocvvgt cu
`
`c yjqng yqwnf jcxg dggp qdxkqwu- cv vjg vkog vjg kpxgpvkqp ycu ocfg- vq c rgtuqp jcxkpi qtfkpct{
`
`umknn kp vjg ctv vq yjkej vjcv uwdlgev ocvvgt rgtvckpu/
`
`37/
`
`Vq vjg dguv qh o{ wpfgtuvcpfkpi- o{ qrkpkqpu tgictfkpi qdxkqwupguu qh vjg “713
`
`Rcvgpv hqnnqy vjg ngicn rtkpekrngu eqpvckpgf kp Itcjco x/ Lqjp Fggtg- 494 W/U/ 2 )2;77* cpf MUT
`
`Kpv”n Eq/ x/ Vgnghngz- Kpe/- 661 W/U/ 4;9 )3118*/
`
`KX/
`
`RGTUQP QH QTFKPCT[ UMKNN KP VJG CTV
`
`38/
`
`Igpgtcnn{- vjg “713 Rcvgpv ku kp vjg hkgnf qh kpvgtkqt fgukip qh tckn ectu cpf oqtg
`
`urgekhkecnn{ vjg hkgnf qh xkfgq fkurnc{ u{uvgou oqwpvgf kp cpf qrgtcvkpi kp ocuu vtcpukv uwdyc{
`
`ectu/
`
`

`

`39/
`
`Kp vjg 2;;6.2;;8 vkoghtcog- c rgtuqp qh qtfkpct{ umknn kp vjg ctv kp vjg hkgnf qh vjg
`
`“713 Rcvgpv yqwnf jcxg )2* c Dcejgnqt”u Fgitgg kp Gpikpggtkpi- cpf )3* cv ngcuv 3.4 {gctu qh
`
`Gpikpggtkpi gzrgtkgpeg ykvj tckn gswkrogpv cpf0qt vjg fgukip qh tckn gswkrogpv/
`
`3;/
`
`Kp hqtokpi vjg qrkpkqpu vjcv K gzrtguu jgtgkp- K jcxg cfqrvgf vjg rgturgevkxg qh c
`
`rgtuqp qh qtfkpct{ umknn kp vjg ctv- cu fguetkdgf cdqxg/
`
`X/
`
`QRKPKQPU
`
`C/ UVCVG QH VJG CTV
`
`41/
`
`Kp vjg gctn{ 2;;1u- kv ycu pqv mpqyp vq hnwuj oqwpv vgngxkukqp uetggpu kp vjg ycnnu
`
`qt egknkpiu qh c tckn ect/ Vjg gzcorng rtqxkfgf kp Crrgpfkz E qh vjg Fgen/ qh Nqygnn Ocnq kp hcev
`
`eqphktou vjku rqkpv/ Vjg vgngxkukqp uetggp jcu c rtqvtwfkpi uykxgn oqwpv/
`
`42/
`
`Vjg Rcvgpv Dqctf qh Crrgcnu- fwtkpi vjg gz rctvg tggzcokpcvkqp qh vjg ykvjkp
`
`rcvgpv- eqpenwfgf vjcv c uetggp nqecvgf cv c oqpkvqt qp vqr qh vjg uwthceg qh vjg ect yqwnf pqv dg
`
`uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf cickpuv vjg ect uwthceg/ K citgg ykvj vjku rqukvkqp/
`
`43/
`
`Kv ycu cnuq pqv ygnn mpqyp- rtkqt vq vjg “713 rcvgpv- vq rtqxkfg c rnwtcnkv{ qh xkfgq
`
`fkurnc{ oqpkvqtu gcej jcxkpi c xkfgq uetggp‡ gcej qh uckf oqpkvqt dgkpi oqwpvgf cv vjg lwpevkqp
`
`qh vjg ukfgycnn cpf egknkpi- ykvj vjg uetggp qh vjg oqpkvqt uwduvcpvkcnn{ hnwujgf ykvj vjg cflcegpv
`
`ycnn uwthceg uvtwevwtg qh vjg ect- cpf fktgevgf qdnkswgn{ fqypyctfn{ vqyctf vjg ect ugcvu/
`
`44/
`
`Gzrgtv Ocnq uvcvgu vjg #pqto# )kp vjg hktuv ugpvgpeg qh rctcitcrj 42 qh jku
`
`Fgenctcvkqp* qt vtgpf™cu gzgornkhkgf d{ vjg HTC twng.ocmkpi fkuewuugf kp rctcitcrj 42™ycu
`
`vq jcxg #kpvgtkqt hkvvkpiu# tgeguugf qt hnwuj.oqwpvgf/ Vjg gzcorngu ikxgp kp rctcitcrju 38.41 )cpf
`
`ogpvkqpgf cdqxg* ctg gzcorngu qh uwej #kpvgtkqt hkvvkpiu-# cpf- jgpeg- qpg umknngf kp vjg ctv yqwnf
`
`jcxg uwtgn{ mpqyp vq kpuvcnn uwej hkvvkpiu kp c tgeguugf qt hnwuj.oqwpvgf ocppgt/ Jqygxgt- vjg
`
`uetggp qh c vgngxkukqp qt xkfgq oqpkvqt ku pqv c #hkvvkpi/# Uvknn hwtvjgt- rtkqt vq vjg (713 rcvgpv- kv
`
`yqwnf pqv jcxg dggp qdxkqwu vq hnwuj.oqwpv kv cv vjg lwpevkqp qh vjg egknkpi cpf c ukfgycnn qh c tckn
`
`ect/ Vjku ku hwtvjgt gxkfgpegf d{ Gzrgtv Ocnq”u qyp uvcvgogpvu cpf rjqvqu ujqykpi Covtcm
`
`wvknk|gf c rtqvtwfkpi uykxgn oqwpvgf oqpkvqt- yjkej ku pqv hnwuj oqwpvgf )qt uwduvcpvkcnn{
`
`hnwujgf* cpf ku qp c nqygt ukfgycnn- yjkej yqwnf dg c v{rkecn g{g ngxgn/
`
`45/
`
`Rtkqt vq 2;;8- qpg umknngf kp vjg ctv yqwnf jcxg dggp cyctg qh kpuvcnnkpi #kpvgtkqt
`
`hkvvkpiu# )yjkej yqwnf pqv kpenwfg VXu qt xkfgq uetggpu* kp c tckn ect kp c #tgeguugf qt hnwuj.
`
`oqwpvgf# ocppgt- dwv vjg kpuvcnncvkqp qh c xkfgq uetggp kp vjku ocppgt™gurgekcnn{ cv vjg lwpevkqp
`
`

`

`of the ceiling and a sidewall of a rail car—would Q have been obvious, as inaccurately concluded
`
`in paragraph 34 in the Expert Malo Declaration without citation to any supporting evidence.
`
`35.
`
`Figure 1 of Miyajama depicts a gap between the display 01 and the sidewall.
`
`Arrows have been added to show the gap. Miyajarna discloses in [0017] “the structure is such that
`
`cooling air 03 passes by the baeklight UIP, in order to limit the temperature-rise of the backlight
`
`DIP .... . .cooling air 03 flows between the vehicle carriage 03 and the bael-alight.”
`
`36.
`
`One skilled in the art can reasonably conclude that Miyajirna illustrates external
`
`mounting of the curved (or 2 piece) displays way from the carriage wall.
`
`VI.
`
`COMPENSATION
`
`37'.
`
`Although I am compensated for the time I work on this litigation, this
`
`compensation is not dependent on the outcome of this proceeding.
`
`I hereby declare that all statements made herein of my own knowledge are true and that all
`
`statements made on information and belief are believed to be true; and further that these statements
`
`were made with knowledge that willful false statements and the like so made are punishable by
`
`fine or imprisonment, or both, under Section 1001 of Title I3 of the United States Code.
`
`Dated: February 2, 201 T
`
`Jack R. Long
`
`