Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`Curriculum
`Vitae
`
`Dr. Gareth Loy, DMA
`Stanford, 1980
`
`President, Gareth, Inc.
`POB 151185, San Rafael, CA 94915
`(415) 927-2916
`dgl@GarethInc.com
`http://www.GarethInc.com
`
`Synopsis
`
`Litigation Support
`20 years experience
`§
`§ Testified before the ITC
`§ Testified before a jury in Federal Court
`6 IPRs
`§
`2 Markman claim construction hearings
`§
`1 Markman tutorial
`§
`§ Deposed 12 times
`30 cases, 24 as Expert of Record
`§
`> 51 reports and declarations
`§
`Patent, copyright, trademark infringement,
`§
`inequitable conduct, trade secrets
`Software/source code discovery (C/C++,
`Java, ObjectiveC, Lisp, yacc, lex, etc.)
`Primary Technologies
`> 40 years experience
`§
`§ Generalist: computer science/ senior
`software engineer/software architect in
`academia and industry
`Specialist: digital media, networked media
`systems, digital signal processing (DSP)
`especially for music and audio
`
`§
`
`§
`
`§
`
`Published Author and Lecturer
`41 peer-reviewed publications in major
`§
`journals, internationally
`Frequent lecturer; keynote speaker at
`MCM2015, London
`§ Musimathics, two-volume reference on
`digital audio signal processing and music
`published by MIT Press
`Academic / Degrees
`§ Doctorate (DMA) from Stanford (1980)
`Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratory
`§
`(SAIL)
`Stanford Center for Computer Research in
`Music and Acoustics (CCRMA)
`§ Lecturer/Researcher UCSD (taught graduate
`courses in computer science and digital
`signal processing at UCSD for a decade)
`Employment
`§ Apple Computer (1979, worked for
`Jef Raskin who reported to Steve Jobs)
`Frox, Inc.
`§
`Sonic Solutions/Rovi
`§
`§ ATI/Chromatic Research
`Sony Corporation of America
`§
`
`§
`
`Page 1 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 1 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`§
`
`§
`
`§
`
`§ ValueClick v. Tacoda — behavioral
`profiling for advertising
`1st Technology v. Tiltware — black-box
`forensic analysis of Internet gambling
`application
`§ Visto v. Good — file synchronization across
`server, desktop, cellular network, and
`mobile handheld devices
`§ Visto v. RIM — file synchronization across
`server, desktop, cellular network, and
`mobile handheld devices
`Premiere International v. Apple — iTunes,
`iTunes Music Store (ITMS), stem to stern
`source code analysis
`§ Digeo v. Audible — audio content,
`encryption, audio downloading from the
`Internet, and device integration for handheld
`players
`Information Technology Innovation
`v. Motorola — Fortran 77 software program
`dating from 1986 for factory automation
`§ Audio MPEG v. Creative Labs — reviewed
`CL’s MPEG decoder source code for
`noninfringement
`
`Consulting Clients
`Buchla Assoc., Philips Semiconductor, Equator
`Technologies, Raza Microelectronics, Pixim,
`Inc., Cradle Technologies, Siemens
`Microsystems, Infineon Technologies, Zoran
`Corp., Dolby Laboratories, Malleable
`Technologies, C-Cube Microsystems, TriMedia
`Technologies, BOPS, Inc., SeaSound LLP,
`Palm, Inc.
`Source Code Discovery
`§ E-Watch v. Apple — digital watch functions
`§ Black Hills Media v. Samsung — networked
`mobile media players
`§ MobileMedia Ideas v. Apple — media
`codec, music recording, playlist, image
`compression and resolution conversion, GPS
`automobile navigation
`§ RMail v. Amazon — email authentication
`and dispatch
`§ Mirror Worlds v. Apple — OSX system,
`Spotlight, CoverFlow, Finder, and Time
`Machine, IOS system, iPod, iPhone, Apple
`TV, and xServe system and applications
`Expertise
`§ Digital Signal Processing (DSP), audio codecs, music technology, acoustics, digital recorders
`§ Home entertainment systems, set-top boxes
`§ Large Scale Software Architecture/Analysis in C, C++, Objective-C, Java, Swift, etc.
`§ Networked digital media, streaming digital media, digital radio
`§ Mobile apps, cellular networks, iOS iPhone apps, iPad apps, Android apps, PDAs, data synchronization
`§ Enterprise email apps, Enterprise networked systems
`Factory automation software
`§
`§ Networked file systems, file backup/restore and archiving
`§ Media databases, iTunes Music Store
`§ MPEG, MP3 and MPEG Standards
`§ On-line gaming
`Internet commerce systems
`§
`§ Networked digital cameras, CCDs, digital video, DVDs, video codecs
`§ GPS navigation systems
`§ Music Technology
`§ Operating systems
`§ User interfaces
`§ Compilers/assemblers
`§ Real-time computing, parallel processing systems
`§ Digital watch systems
`
`Page 2 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 2 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`
`•
`
`Professional Summary
`•
`
`
`Dr. Loy has over 40 years of academic and engineering experience and 20 years experience as an expert
`witness in computer science, software development, network streaming media, embedded systems,
`enterprise software systems, digital signal processing for audio and music technology.
`He has sustained a long and successful career at the cutting edge of software development and system
`design using multiprocessor/multi-core architectures for signal processing and control. He has been
`Software Architect for multiple projects at various companies, and has consulted for a long list of
`technology companies. Through Gareth, Inc., Dr. Loy provides computer technology consulting, software
`engineering, and litigation support to high-technology companies, internationally.
`Dr. Loy has testified before the International Trade Commission, and before a jury in Federal Court, has
`testified at Markman claim construction hearings and Markman tutorials in Federal Court, been deposed
`over 10 times, and has authored more than 50 reports and declarations. Case types include patent, trademark
`infringement, copyright, trade secret misappropriation, and inequitable conduct. He has worked on complex
`international patent cases, and has provided expertise on such diverse areas as streaming media systems,
`handheld networked Personal Information Management (PIM) devices, enterprise email systems, software
`for factory automation, interactive databases, enterprise software for management of media libraries, MPEG
`audio compression, on-line gaming, composition systems, digital camera hardware and software, digital
`audio hardware and software technologies, compilers, file systems, operating systems, and more. (See the
`Summary of Testifying Experience below.)
`Dr. Loy’s doctorate is from Stanford, 1980, where he studied under Dr. John Chowning at the Stanford
`Artificial Intelligence Laboratory and the Center for Computer Research in Music and Acoustics.
`He has published widely in various juried journals, and has authored three books with the MIT Press,
`including Musimathcs, a two-volume text on the mathematics of music, and Music and Connectionism, a
`collection of articles on artificial neural networks and music research.
`He taught graduate and undergraduate courses in computer science and digital audio at UCSD for a decade,
`cofounded the Computer Audio Research Laboratory there, conducted computer systems research for
`digital audio, designed and built several networked digital media computer laboratories.
`
`
`§
`
`Education
`§
`
`Degree
`
`DMA digital signal processing (DSP), computer science (CS),
`computer systems for audio, real-time computing, and compiler
`technology. Thesis research:
`• Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (SAIL)
`• Center for Computer Research in Music and Acoustics
`(CCRMA)
`I wrote the compiler for the Systems Concepts Digital Synthesizer,
`and conducted foundational research in digital audio that led to
`hardware and software systems to compute digital audio in real time.
`B.A. Music — music technology, computer science, composition,
`and classical guitar
`
`Page 3 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`
`
`Year
`
`1980
`
`College or
`University
`Stanford University
`
`1975
`
`San Francisco State
`University
`
`PAGE 3 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`
`
` §
`
`
`Projects and Skills
` > 40 years experience as a C/C++/ObjectiveC/Java software engineer, software systems architect
`§ Early Apple employee (1979), worked for Jef Raskin, who reported directly to Steve Jobs
`§ Lecturer and researcher in computer science, digital signal processing for a decade at UCSD
`§ Architected numerous large-scale enterprise software and hardware systems
`§ Developed and debugged prototype multiprocessor systems, real-time systems, embedded systems, file
`systems
`§ Wrote assemblers, compilers, linkers/loaders
`§ Created hundreds of user-level applications on numerous platforms
`§ Built home entertainment systems, professional audio recording systems
`§ Designed, developed and implemented embedded systems for handheld applications
`§ Direction and management of research and software development projects
`§ Digital audio signal processing, systems software for custom computing platforms
`§ Parallel-processing systems software
`§ Operating systems: PC, UNIX, OSX Mac, iOS iPhone, Windows Developer Studio, LINUX,
`VxWorks, and WindRiver
`§ Computer programming language development with yacc and lex
`§ Real-time programming with VxWorks
`§ Systems programming, device drivers, file systems, systems administration
`§ Multiprocessor systems programming
`§ Multimedia computing
`§ Designed, debugged, and documented microprocessor Instruction Set Architecture for Philips
`§ Built automatic document generation systems that created finished documents directly from
`commented code source
`§ Designed software, hardware, and VLSI architectures
`
`
`
`
`Professional Experience
`From:
`1998
`To:
`Present
`Organization: Gareth, Inc., Corte Madera (Marin County), CA.
`Title:
`President
`Summary:
`Provide software and hardware engineering, and litigation support to high-technology
`companies, internationally.
`
`
`From:
`To:
`Organization:
`Title:
`Summary:
`
`2003
`2004
`Sony Corporation of America
`Software Architect, Super Audio CD Project
`§ Developed 48-track pro-audio recording system for authoring next-generation
`audio media, including SACD/DSD audio discs, DVD, and Blu-Ray discs.
`§ System included synchronous Internet transmission of digital audio, custom
`hardware interfacing, complex user interface design, real-time operating systems
`(VxWorks), code development in C++, interfacing to traditional recording
`devices.
`§
`Improved system design to meet project goals
`§ Met aggressive project deadlines.
`
`Page 4 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 4 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`§ Manager: Ethan Grossman (currently at Digidesign)
`
`
`1994
`From:
`1998
`To:
`Organization: Chromatic Research, Inc.
`Summary:
`Senior Information Engineer
`§ Wrote hardware architecture documentation for next-generation multi-media
`1997-1998:
`processor
`§ Wrote software API reference documentation for multi-media processor
`
`Senior Digital Audio Engineer
`§ Reverse-engineered popular FM synthesis chip, and reduced it to software
`simulation running on Mpact processor
`§ Reviewed extensive music synthesis patent law, advised on patent protection
`strategies and work-arounds to patented signal-processing technologies.
`§ Led wave-table synthesis project, hired & managed voicers, licensed sound
`libraries, specified the synthesis architecture, interfaced between marketing,
`engineering and voicers
`§ Represented Chromatic at the MMA’s IASIG 3DWG (3D audio industry group of
`the MIDI Manufacturer’s Association)
`§ Spearheaded the successful effort to open Microsoft’s 3D audio API to hardware
`acceleration
`§ Consulted on 3D audio subsystem design
`
`1994
`1994
`Sonic Solutions; Novato, CA
`Senior Digital Audio Engineer
`Specified, architected, and implemented track-based recording system for automatic
`dialog replacement (ADR) and Foley, involving user interface design, new core
`functionality for rapidly capturing and easily comparing multiple session takes.
`
`1988
`1993
`Frox, Inc., Milpitas, CA
`Digital Audio Systems Architect and Project Lead
`§ Member of VLSI design team that developed a custom stream-oriented move
`engine that linked an array of up to 16 Motorola 56000’s, operating
`synchronously at the instruction and sample level. Features included
`subsampling, 24x24 AES-EBU serial link I/O, and both asynchronous parameter
`update and synchronous data movement to/from a host computer
`§ Debugged brass-board and ASIC implementation of move-engine with architects.
`§ Designed and implemented the user interface, system model, and control system
`for a parallel-processing multiple-DSP audio subsystem
`§ Developed user interface for audio system based on proprietary Frox “wand”
`remote controller.
`Implemented Lucasfilm THX processing, Dolby ProLogic, concert hall
`simulation and other forms of audio processing
`§ Wrote marketing documentation, white papers, delivered papers at conferences
`(AES and ICMA), and wrote support documentation
`§ The FroxSystem received the Industrial Design Excellence Award (IDEA)
`
`§
`
`Page 5 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`
`
`1994-1997:
`
`
`From:
`To:
`Organization:
`Title:
`Summary:
`
`
`From:
`To:
`Organization:
`Title:
`Summary:
`
`PAGE 5 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`Bronze Award for excellence in User Interface Design; Popular Science
`Magazine's Best of What's New Award for Audio and Video Products,
`AudioVideo Magazine's Grand Prix Award, CES/EIA Innovations '93 Award
`
`Title:
`
`Summary:
`
`
`1980
`From:
`1989
`To:
`Organization: University of California, San Diego, CA
`Concurrent appointments: Computer Audio Research Laboratory, Center for Music
`Experiment, UCSD Music Department
`Researcher, Lecturer, Administrator, with concurrent appointment as Director of
`Research at the Computer Audio Research Laboratory (CARL), part of the Center for
`Music Experiment (CME), an Organized Research Unit (ORU) of the University of
`California, San Diego (UCSD)
`§ Lecturer, 3-quarter graduate sequence in computer science, digital audio and
`computer music.
`§ Lecturer, undergraduate computer science, digital media, electronic music and
`computer aided music composition.
`§ Conducted original research in computer architectures and software for digital
`signal processing of music and musical performance
`§ Wrote numerous scholarly articles for various publications on original research
`topics
`§ Responsible for development and distribution of the CARL Software Distribution,
`a collection of research software developed at CARL for use at collaborating sites
`§ Supervised staff and research assistants, directed projects in digital interfaces for
`music instrument gesture capture, digital audio, signal processing
`§ Designed, specified, and installed computing laboratories and instructional
`facilities
`
`
`1979
`From:
`1980
`To:
`Organization: Apple Computer, Inc., Cupertino, CA
`Title:
`Technical writer
`§ Wrote user manuals for the original Apple II: Fortran, Basic, text editing
`Summary:
`§ Developed Apple's first self-documenting text editing paradigm
`§ Worked with Jef Raskin (my boss) on the very earliest research platforms that
`would eventually become the Macintosh computer. Raskin worked directly for
`Steve Jobs.
`
`1974
`1975
`San Francisco State University
`Lecturer
`§ While still a graduate student, I was appointed to be a Lecturer by the Music
`Department to replace faculty on sabbatical.
`I taught electronic music theory and practice.
`
`§
`
`
`
`Page 6 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`
`From:
`To:
`Organization:
`Title:
`Summary:
`
`
`
`PAGE 6 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`Summary of Testifying Experience
`
`§ 24 cases as Testifying Expert, Expert of Record
`§ 30 total cases to date
`§ Trial testimony
`o 2014: ITC: Black Hills Media LLC v. Samsung, et al.
`§ Two days of testimony under oath before the International Trade Commission
`§ Deposed 4.5 consecutive days
`o 1995: Industrial Indemnity v. Apple Computer
`§ Three days jury testimony in Federal Court
`§ Markman Claim Construction hearings
`o 2011: Gibson v. 745 LLC
`o 2011: MONKEYmedia Inc. v. Apple
`o 2011: MONKEYmedia Inc. v. Disney et al.
`§ Markman tutorials
`o 2004: Seer Systems v. Beatnick & Microsoft
`§ Depositions
`o 2016 Mobile Media Ideas v. Apple (re. design-arounds)
`o 2016 MasterObjects v. Google
`o 2014 IPR: Yamaha v. Black Hills Media
`o 2014 IPR: Yamaha v. Black Hills Media
`o 2013 ITC: Black Hills Media v. Samsung et al.
`o 2012: MobileMedia Ideas v. Apple (re. infringement/validity)
`o 2011: Gibson Guitar v. 745 LLC
`o 2011: MONKEYmedia v. Apple
`o 2011: MONKEYmedia v. Disney
`o 2009: 1st Media. v. Electronic Arts, inequitable conduct
`o 2004: Seer Systems v. Beatnick & Microsoft
`o 1995: Industrial Indemnity v. Apple
`§ Case Profile:
`o Patent litigation: 27
`o
`Inequitable conduct: 1
`o Copyright: 1
`o Trade secret misappropriation: 1
`o Trademark infringement: 1
`
`
`
`
`
`Expert Engagements
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Law Firm:
`Case Name:
`
`Patent litigation
`Heim, Payne & Chorush
`MasterObjects, Inc., Plaintiff, v. Google, Inc., Defendant. Case No. 15-cv-1775-
`PJH
`U.S. 8,539,024 — “System and Method for Asynchronous Client Server
`Session Communication”
`Testifying expert for plaintiff regarding dispositive issues in claim
`construction. Declaration. Deposition.
`In progress.
`
`Patents at issue:
`
`Services:
`
`Disposition:
`
`Page 7 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 7 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`Date:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Law Firm:
`Case Name:
`Patents at issue:
`
`Services:
`Disposition:
`Date:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Law Firm:
`Case Name:
`
`Patent owner:
`Petitioner(s):
`Services:
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Law Firm:
`Case Name:
`
`Patent owner:
`Petitioner(s):
`Services:
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Law Firm:
`Case Name:
`
`Complainant:
`Respondents:
`Patents at issue:
`
`2015–2016
`
`Patent litigation
`DiNovo Price
`E-Watch, Inc. et al. v. Apple, Inc. et al. 2:13-cv-1061
`7,365,871, 7,643,168 — “Apparatus for capturing, converting and transmitting
`a visual image signal via a digital transmission system”
`Testifying expert for infringement, source code discovery for plaintiff.
`All work for client in this matter has been completed.
`2015
`
`United States Patent Office, inter partes review (IPR)
`Pepper Hamilton
`Samsung v. Black Hills Media, LLC IPR2014-00709 Patent 8,028,323
`Samsung v. Black Hills Media, LLC IPR2014-00711 Patent 8,230,099
`Samsung v. Black Hills Media, LLC IPR2014-00723 Patent 8,214,873
`Black Hills Media, LLC
`Samsung Electronics Company, Ltd.
`Testifying expert for validity, for patent owner Black Hills.
`Expert reports, deposition.
`All work for client has been completed.
`2014 – 2015
`Lana Gladstein, Reza Mollaaghababa, Thomas Engellenner, 617-204-5168.
`
`United States Patent Office, inter partes review (IPR)
`Pepper Hamilton
`Yamaha v. Black Hills Media, LLC IPR2013-00598 Patent 8,214,873 B2
`Yamaha v. Black Hills Media, LLC IPR2013-00597 Patent 8,230,099 B2
`Yamaha v. Black Hills Media, LLC IPR2014-00733 Patent 8,458,356 B2
`Yamaha v. Black Hills Media, LLC IPR2014-00766 Patent 8,214,873 B2
`Black Hills Media, LLC
`Yamaha Corporation of America
`Testifying expert for validity, for patent owner, Black Hills.
`Expert reports on validity, deposition.
`All work for client has been completed.
`2014 – 2015
`Lana Gladstein, Reza Mollaaghababa, Thomas Engellenner, 617-204-5168.
`
`Patent litigation before International Trade Commission (ITC)
`Mintz Levin
`Complainant Black Hills Media, LLC v. Samsung, et al. “In the Matter of
`certain digital media devices, including televisions, Blu-Ray disc players, home
`theater systems, tablets and mobile phones, components thereof and associated
`software.” Investigation No. 337-TA-882.
`Black Hills Media, LLC
`Samsung, LG, Panasonic, Toshiba, Sharp
`• 8,214,873 — Method, system, and computer-readable medium for
`
`Page 8 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 8 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`employing a first device to direct a networked audio device to render a
`playlist
`• 8,028,323 — Method and system for employing a first device to direct a
`networked audio device to obtain a media item
`• 8,230,099 — System and method for sharing playlists
`Testifying expert for infringement and validity, source code discovery, for
`complainant.
`Two days testimony at ITC hearing in February 2014; 4.5 days of deposition;
`expert reports on infringement and validity; witness statements on infringement
`and validity, product testing, wireshark internet packet analysis; source code
`analysis.
`All work for client has been completed.
`2013 – 2014
`James Conley (858) 314-1500, Howard Wisnia (858) 314-1500, Joe Hameline
`(617) 348-1651.
`
`Patent litigation
`Desmarais LLP
`MobileMedia Ideas LLC v. HTC Corp. and HTC America, Inc., Case 2:10-cv-
`00112-DF (2:2010cv00112), Eastern District of Texas. Judge Folsom.
`Testifying expert for plaintiff for infringement and validity.
`• 5,490,170 — Coding apparatus for digital signal
`Settled
`2011 – 2013
`Jonas McDavit, Desmerais LLP 212-351-3425; Laurie Stempler, Desmerais
`LLP, 212-351-3423
`
`Services:
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Law Firm:
`Case Name:
`
`Services:
`Patents at issue:
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Patents at issue:
`
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Proskauer Rose
`Case Name:
`MobileMedia Ideas LLC v. Apple Inc., Case 1:10-cv-00258-SLR-MPT
`(1:2010cv00258), Wilmington Delaware, Judge Robinson.
`• 5,490,170 — Coding apparatus for digital signal
`• 6,393,430 — Method and system for automatically recording music data
`files by using the hard drive of a personal computer as an intermediate
`storage medium
`• 6,446,080 — Method for creating, modifying, and playing a custom
`playlist, saved as a virtual CD, to be played by a digital audio/visual
`actuator device
`• 7,349,012 — Imaging apparatus with higher and lower resolution
`converters and a compression unit to compress decreased resolution image
`data
`• 6,725,155 — Method and apparatus for information processing, and
`medium for information processing
`o GPS routing and navigation systems
`Testifying expert for infringement, validity, design-arounds, source code
`discovery, for plaintiff. Source code review, reports on infringement and validity
`(1/13/2012), depositions on infringement and validity (4/13/2012). Report on
`design-arounds and deposition on design-arounds (4/14/16) re. the ‘155 patent.
`
`Services:
`
`Page 9 of 22
`
`Printed: 6/24/2016 Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 9 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Continuing.
`2011 – 2012
`Current contacts: Safraz Ishmael, 617.526.9712. For work performed in 2012: Alan
`Federbush, 212.969.3211, John Stellabotte, 212.969.3413
`
`Patents at issue:
`
`Services:
`
`Patent at issue:
`
`Services:
`
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Proskauer Rose
`Case Name:
`MobileMedia Ideas LLC v. Research In Motion Limited and Research In Motion
`Corporation, No. 3:11-cv-02353-N (3:2011cv02353), Northern District of Texas,
`Judge Godbey.
`• 6,446,080 — Method for creating, modifying, and playing a custom
`playlist, saved as a virtual CD, to be played by a digital audio/visual
`actuator device
`• 7,349,012 — Imaging apparatus with higher and lower resolution
`converters and a compression unit to compress decreased resolution image
`data
`• Digital camera resolution conversion and compression system
`Testifying expert for plaintiff for infringement and validity, source code
`discovery.
`Concluded
`2011 – 2013
`Alan Federbush, 212.969.3211, John Kitchura, (617) 526-9676
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Harness & Dickey
`Case Name:
`Gibson Guitar Corp. v. 745 LLC; Case No. 3:11-cv-00058, before Hon. Sharp,
`Magistrate Judge Brown, Middle District of Tennessee, Nashville
`• 5,990,405 — System and method for generating and controlling a simulated
`musical concert experience
`Testifying expert for defendant, for infringement and validity. Reports,
`declarations, deposition, Markman claim construction hearing.
`Settled on terms favorable to my client
`2011 – 2012
`Kara Fussner, Rudolph Telsher, Harness & Dickey: (314) 446-7664
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation, ITC
`Law Firm:
`Jones Day
`Case Name:
`International Trade Commission (ITC) Ogma v. Activision et al. “On certain
`motion-sensitive sound effects devices and image display devices and components
`and products containing same”, Investigation No. 337-TA-773; ALJ Gildea;
`• 6,150,947 — Programmable motion-sensitive sound effects device
`Testifying expert: non-infringement/invalidity for respondent Kyocera. Prior art
`research.
`Settled.
`2011
`Jose Patiño, Jones Day, now at Foley, 858.847.6700
`(Blaney Harper, Jones Day: 202.879.3939)
`
`Patent at issue:
`Services:
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Page 10 of 22
`Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 10 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`
`
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Flachsbart & Greenspoon
`Case Name:
`RMail Ltd. v. Amazon.com, Inc. et al., E. Dist. Texas, 2:10-cv-00258-TJW
`Patent at issue:
`• 6,571,334 — Apparatus and method for authenticating the dispatch and
`contents of documents
`• 6,182,219 — Apparatus and method for authenticating the dispatch and
`contents of documents
`Testifying expert, software discovery, infringement analysis for plaintiff.
`Settled
`8/5/2011
`Robert Greenspoon, Flachsbart & Greenspoon 312-551-9500
`
`Services:
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Irell & Minella, LLP
`Case Name:
`International Trade Commission (ITC): Microsoft Corporation v. Tivo Inc.,
`“Certain Set-Top Boxes and Hardware and Software Components Thereof”,
`Investigation No. 337-TA-761 (ITC), No. 2:11-cv-00134 (W.D. Wash.) ALJ:
`Gildea.
`Microsoft Corporation
`Tivo Inc.
`• 5,585,838 — Program time guide
`• 5,731,844 — Television scheduling system for displaying a grid
`representing scheduled layout and selecting a programming parameter for
`display or recording
`• 6,028,604 — User friendly remote system interface providing previews of
`applications
`• 5,758,258 — Selective delivery of programming for interactive televideo
`system
`Testifying expert for respondent. Report written.
`Settled
`3/28/2011
`Eric Carsten, Chris Vanderlaan, Irell & Minella, (310) 203-7031
`
`Services:
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Graves Dougherty Hearon & Moody
`Case Name:
`MONKEYmedia Inc. v. Apple, Inc. Case No. 1:2010cv00319, Texas Western
`District, Austin, Judge Sam Sparks, patents at issue: Seamless Contraction
`Seamless contraction patents:
`• US 6,177,938 — Computer user interface with non-salience deemphasis
`• US 6,219,052 — Computer user interface with non-salience deemphasis
`• US 6,335,730 — Computer user interface with non-salience deemphasis
`Seamless expansion patents
`• US 6,393,158 — Method and storage device for expanding and contracting
`continuous play media
`• US 7,467,218 — Method and storage device for expanding and contracting
`
`Complainant:
`Respondent:
`Patents at issue:
`
`Patents at issue:
`
`Page 11 of 22
`Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 11 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`Services:
`
`continuous play media
`• US 7,890,648 — Audiovisual presentation with interactive seamless
`branching and/or telescopic advertising
`Testifying expert for plaintiff: infringement, claim construction. Markman claim
`construction hearing.
`Concluded
`2010
`Steve Smit, Graves Dougherty Hearon & Moody: 512-480-5600
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Graves Dougherty Hearon & Moody
`Case Name:
`MONKEYmedia Inc. v. Disney, Inc. et al. Case No. 1:10-cv-00533-SS, Texas
`Western District, Austin, Judge Sam Sparks
`Seamless Contraction:
`• 6,335,730 — Computer user interface with non-salience deemphasis
`Seamless Expansion:
`• US 6,393,158 — Method and storage device for expanding and contracting
`continuous play media
`• US 7,467,218 — Method and storage device for expanding and contracting
`continuous play media
`• US 7,890,648 — Audiovisual presentation with interactive seamless
`branching and/or telescopic advertising
`Consulting expert for plaintiff: infringement analysis. Testifying expert for
`plaintiff: infringement, claim construction.
`Concluded
`2010
`Steve Smit, Graves Dougherty Hearon & Moody: 512-480-5600
`
`Disposition:
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Stroock & Stroock & Lavan
`Case Name:
`Mirror Worlds, LLC v. Apple Computer, Inc. Case No. 6:2008cv00088, Texas
`Eastern District Court, Tyler, Judge Leonard Davis
`• 6,006,227 — Document stream operating system
`• 6,638,313 B1 — Document stream operating system
`• 6,725,427 B2 — Document stream operating system with document
`organizing and display facilities
`• 6,768,999 B2 — Enterprise, stream-based, information management system
`Consulting expert for plaintiff (expert of record: Dr. John Levy): infringement
`analysis. Source code discovery. Analysis of Apple Computer OSX operating
`system source code and applications software source code for products including
`Spotlight, CoverFlow, Finder, and Time Machine in Tiger and Leopard releases,
`IOS operating system and applications software source code for iPod, iPhone,
`Apple TV, and xServe. This was a very large-scale discovery project, requiring
`analysis of approximately 1.5 billion lines (not bytes, lines) of disclosed source
`code.
`On 10/1/2010 a jury in EDT found Apple willfully infringed, and set a $625 million
`dollar judgment. Judge Davis subsequently reversed the judgment while upholding
`the validity of the patents.
`
`Patents at issue:
`
`Services:
`
`Patents at issue:
`
`Services:
`
`Disposition:
`
`Page 12 of 22
`Printed: 6/24/2016
`
`PAGE 12 OF 22
`
`I.M.L. SLU'S EXHIBIT 1009
`
`

`
`Dr. Gareth Loy – Curriculum Vitae
`
`2009 – 2010
`Kenneth Stein, Stroock & Stroock: 212-806-5491
`
`Patents at issue:
`
`Services:
`
`Disposition:
`
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Patent litigation
`Law Firm:
`Robins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi LLP
`Case Name:
`St. Clair Intellectual Property Consultants v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., et al.,
`Case No. 1:04-cv-1436-JJF-LPS (or 1:2004cv01436), United States District Court
`for the District of Delaware, Judge: Joseph J. Farnan
`• 5,138,459 — Electronic still video camera with direct personal computer
`(PC) compatible digital format output
`• 6,094,219 — Electronic still video camera with direct personal computer
`(PC) compatible digital format output
`• 6,323,899 B1 — Process for use in electronic camera
`Consulting expert for plaintiff (expert of record: Tom Gafford): infringement
`analysis of digital camera technology. Reviewed thousands of digital camera
`technical drawings, schematics, block diagrams, parts lists, service manuals,
`engineering product specifications, technical manuals, industry standards, and user
`guides for specific analog and digital technologies such as CCDs, SDRAM, video
`DSPs, microprocessors, embedded software APIs, and other camera technologies at
`issue, wrote reports.
`All work for client completed in 2009. (Note: Samsung settled before my work on
`this case began.)
`2009
`Robins Kaplan: Seth Northrop: 612.349.8500; Brock Spect: 612.349.8500
`
`Date:
`Contact:
`
`Expert Engagement:
`Type of Matter:
`Inequitable conduct
`Law Firm:
`Flachsbart & Greenspoon, LLC
`1st Media. v. doPi Karaoke, Electronic Arts, Inc., Harmonix Music Systems, Inc.,
`Case Name:
`Microsoft Corporation, Viacom, Inc. and Sony Computer Entertainment America,
`Inc., Case No. 2:07-cv-1589-JCM-RJJ, United States District Court, District of
`Nevada, Judge: Kent J. Dawson, reassigned to Judge James C. Mahan.
`US 5,464,946 — Karaoke information entertainment system
`Testifying expert for 1st Media re. Inequitable Conduct. Evaluate materiality of
`pertinent prior art for plaintiff’s patent, rendering expert opinion, deposition,
`declarations, briefs.
`The Court of Appeals reversed the District Court, finding for 1st Media.
`2009 – 2012
`William W. Flach